@@surgezoom7079 what's the issue here? that illegals are illegal? DACA are victims, but victims of their parents crimes, I would support DACA if their parents are punished accordingly.
@nomooon What is illegal, son? What about the time the Hoover and other racist a-holes went against the Constitution and ILLEGALLY deported Americans of Mexican origin? You guys move the goal post when it's convenient to "Whites."
I self deported in May 2012 to Mexico, one week before DACA was announced. You can imagine how I felt thinking I missed a great opportunity to stay in the US. Almost 11 years later and living in Canada, I do not regret it at all. I’m free, I’m welcomed, I’m a citizen of this great country and now I can visit the US whenever I want.
Because Canada have a merit base immigration system or point base immigration system so it's easy for you to find out when you will achieve your permanent resident unlike here in US we don't have that kind of immigration system. That's what US immigration system must have!
@@ILovePortugal-l9r I blame the political right wing that has used immigration as a wedge issue, along with guns, abortion and gay rights. It's disgusting and, in the end, America loses. Real smart.😔
Brought here at 3 years old. Impoverished up bringing in the ghettos of socal. Grew up chasing dreams, payed my way thru college as we do not qualify for federal assistance. Today im 27, registered broker on the new york stock exhcange and working for the most elite financial institution on wallstreet. I have to be honest, im beginning to share the sentiment with this fellow dreamer. Go on, deport me. I dont care anymore. If congress wont allow me to contribite my skills and talents to this great society, another country will. Plain and simple. No doubt id be leaving with a heavy heart as we truly love this country, but ive had it. Enough being a bargaining chip.
These are the kind of people Americans actually should be trying to encourage to stay here. Not the criminals and other undesirables that come and take.
@@ILovePortugal-l9ryour personal experience or opinion doesn’t group everyone in. no one in this country will do certain things for free. Have some empathy for your fellow human we are 1 species made by god and this is his earth not by the man made laws from England immigrants who invaded Native American land by force.
A lot of my colleagues in IT have choose to immigrate to Canada. Not only IT, but people from medical fields like doctors and nurses are choosing to abandon this country. Brain drain is for real.
I’m in Canada, they’re not taking in people in the daca system. In fact, they don’t bring in many Latinos at all. They announced a big plan to bring in over 500k from India from 2023-2024… So stop lying
People on temporary visas like H-1B yes coz the wait times for a green card especially for Indians, Chinese, Filipinos and Mexicans can be daunting. You're tied to your employer and can lose your chance to get PR if you fail to find a substitute sponsor if the company closes or you get laid off.
Who understands this country? These ppl are young educated professionals whom contribute and yet congress doesn’t do anything for them. I wish them the best of luck, I’m sorry this country can’t do more for them.
their parents came here illegally and for free fair for immigrants that paid a lot of money to get here and got here the legal way that's like a parent stealing someone's house yet the children are allowed to stay in that house
@@izzymalik9173 we can’t change the past. Why are they paying for their parents mistakes. What is the difference between these ppl and all the asylum seekers that are currently coming in? Many of these Ukrainian and Venezuelans are still using resources, taking away from Americans.We are loosing professionals to other countries & that’s what I have issues with. These ppl know the language, are paying taxes,are educated, giving back to their communities, what else do we want?
@@lizz3104 At the same time, those who were brought here as children of non-immigrant visa holders have no DACA - they are excluded from DACA (via the requirement that the applicant had no legal status on 6/15/2012). And once they age out of their non-immigrant dependent visa (at age 21), they have to self-deport (unless they qualify for a visa by themselves). So, it is exactly the other way around: We reward children of illegal immigrants (with DACA) and we punish children of non-immigrant visa holders for the fact that their parent's obeyed our immigration laws.
@@rolandrahn8343 that’s not fair either! If these ppl were raised here and are law obeying ppl they should stay. But these ppl had no choice, I wonder if they can reapply to come into this country once they leave?
Wish me luck guys im moving to spain. Ive been in the US my whole life. Ive had DACA for pver 10 years now. DACA is closer to be taken away than us having somehting permanent. Im happy for all my fellow DACA recipients who were able to kove on.
Absolutely Disgusting! 🤮 The United States should have done something about this a long time ago. I don't blame these doctors, nurses, firefighters, etc. for leaving to an even better country! 😤
@@surgezoom7079 It will happen specially if Local Americans participate and volunteer to deport this criminal illegal immigrants to show their patriotic duty in this country.
MIguel seeking refuge in Canada when so many Canadian come to the U.S illegally burdening the northen states that border Canada. All of the ppl self deporting have something in common, they know the english language.
@@peni1641 And why would they come to the Northern states to live "illegally" considering once they are here they won't be able to find work, won't be able to be eligible for any kind of government benefits, and won't be able to earn any money or even do anything at all when they don't have legal status? Unless you are talking about the ones that somehow have legal status, in which case they wouldn't be illegal. Unless you're also referring to snowbirds? But snowbirds don't come to the northern states, they go to the southern states, that's the whole point. Kinda wondering because I am actually one of the "Canadians" you're talking about staying illegally in Washington State right now, and my life has been kinda uphended by the fact that There is Nothing I Can Do Here. (I can find work in California since I'm Chinese, but not here). I just recently found someone to marry which would have finally given me immigration status, but I can't imagine why you think there's all these Canadians living here if they don't even have status.
It’s ok “the American dream” is dead. The day is coming, that day will humble all these greedy politicians and racists citizens. I’m a citizen and leaving soon! Screw this mess I’m out.
The price of coming illegally to any country is living under a cloud of uncertainty. Not having access to services for legal citizens can also be denied you or cost money. Leaving for a place where you can live your life is a better option. Those educated in the US have good chances overseas if they are accepted there. It is not the end of the world. It's a new beginning. You can always return to the USA under a working visa or a student visa. Being young allows you to have options outside of DACA. Embrace it and fulfill your dreams.
But, in California they have a good life and jobs. The majority work in government agencies, they love to disqualify citizens recipients asking for medical, unemployment benefits..etc.
@@nicolesaylor4027 No they did not have a choice to come here. but who every brought them here regardless if its was their parents or another adult, they should be held accountable for bringing them here illegal. I feel sorry for the children who was brought here of no fault of their own.
@@teedee643 I'm in my own country and so are my family. I do not know my ancestors. eveybody that came here illegal is trying to come up with an excuse is to why they broke the law. I was born here and so was my family
As long as you are a DACA recipient you can work and study. Don't despair. The government must find a solution . It would be impossible to deport 700,000 DACA recipients. It's not good for the economy or the immigrants. That would be a lose lose proposition. DACA recipients work and contribute to the economy. They pay social security and taxes as anyone else. For all practical purposes they are already american.
Exactly, I just left a message for JPL above:Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
You must’ve lived a very privileged life. Must be a Boomer. You clearly have no idea the psychological toll this kind of precarity takes on a human being. Not knowing if you’ll be evicted in a month, or deported in a year… not having agency in your own life. Doing everything right and still getting fucked. Here’s what you don’t get. This country isn’t worth the fight. The American dream is leaving America. Canada will give you permanent residency status in as little as 15 months as a skilled worker. It’s a fair, objective, points-based system. You do what they expect of you, learn their languages, get the degrees they want, turn in your assault rifles, and you’re welcomed as a full citizen with equal rights. Why in god’s name would you stay in this shithole country as a second class citizen, where a ride in an ambulance can bankrupt you? I hate it here so much.
@Sean70712 you need to give praise to Obama for signing an executive act that was not passed by the legislative act of the house, and senate. Be humble alien.
Well nothing would be given to you, without an education you’re not getting pay over $15-$20ish / hour… getting rid of young educated men/women sounds like a freaking awesome idea doesn’t SMFHA!
I hear alot of "we don't mind immigrants but if they come here legally" I hope you understand that it takes alot of money and is time consuming, it's not given to you by a snap of your fingers. Also hear "immigrants are cared for better then our Americans" not true! Immigrants are basically on there own with little to no help. Everything is "US citizens" you qualify. Learn that the American dream is alot of sacrifice
Yet in Mexico, it is illegal to work if you are not Mexican, its simply not possible. But Mexicans (and others) coming here want every opportunity. Sickening how our borders are not secure, and very enlightening to learn how other countries protect their borders/jobs/way of life from foreignors, both legal and illegal. U.S. taxpayers deserve better on all fronts.
Its not easy let me just break the law .There are a lot of immigrants around the globe who do it legally and wait for their turn. Don't normalise crime.
@warriorclan26 don't twist my words, I know the process, just stating It's lengthy and expensive process. Not given to you as people think it it given.
Huge disappointment to know some people are getting green cards without proving their deserved to be here.. some people deserved to be eligible for green cards.saddest part is the trump wanted to DACa to end and give the chance those who already participate in the program to change their status🥴
@@thomasperkins7318 melania trump is a citizen.. she became a card green holder after married mr . Trump ( usa citizen) by the way sponsor by him. Meaning she didn’t use any free resources from the gov.
Tps recipient with european citizenship here 👋🏼 I’ve been waiting on my fiance for the past 2 years I’ve followed every single one of their steps and they denied me twice without any reason, but let el tren the aragua gang into the country it’s legitimately insane, I’m moving to Ireland later this year to live with her and be legal citizens wish me luck 🍀🇮🇪🇪🇺
Self deportation is not a bad thing. In 2023, the world is a different place than their parents' generation. Other countries have better systems that the US and aren't as underdeveloped as American media makes them out to be. One of my best friends self deported. Ten years later, she bought two houses in her home country and paid off her car. Can American millennials living in the US even afford such luxuries? The best part is...her education was funded by American taxpayers and didn't receive a single dime from her. Now she's paying taxes in another country and living it up.
He should have stated that he was immigrating to Canada. Also, the journey to being a permanent residence in Canada is not a walk in the park...it has its own challenges.
Exactly, he will not realize this until he gets there. I left a message for JPL above:Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
It does, but he is more likely to be welcome in Canada as an educated and hardworking person, while the U.S is busy trying to kick him out for simply wanting to work and contribute.
Exactly, I just left a comment above to JPLLBravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
They didn't either. They were brought here as young children by their parents. They didn't choose anything. And if you had actually watched the video, you would know that many of them are educated professionals, they're doctors and lawyers and social workers. They pay taxes, they make our country better. It's completely absurd to suggest that we should send doctors and lawyers that were educated here to Canada just because our government can't process reality.
How does moving to Canada count as "self-deportation"? Self-deportation in these cases should refer to going back to Mexico.. if they're going to Canada, it technically counts as immigrating there.. lol Also, it's such a pity if they've been deceived into going to Canada, I understand if Mexico isn't a good country, but it's just sad all around tbh
*deportation* dē″pôr-tā′shən noun 1. The act or an instance of deporting. 2. Expulsion of an undesirable alien from a country. 3. A carrying away; *a removing from one country to another* , or to a distant place; transportation; specifically, forcible transportation, especially to a penal colony.
Been there, I was once a TPS holder...I was born in El Salvador and I had to renew the TPS card every 18months, I'm now a US citizen as of last June 2022 🙏🙏🙏 but it took a long, long time ...I couldn't go to college because it wasn't "valid" at the time to go to the school I wanted to go
Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
IT Field Service Tech here. Grew up in here, pay taxes, I help 1000s of clients every year. I cannot believe that Biden is helping other people to come in the US like nothing. This is almost an insult to us. My family voted democratic thinking he was going to help us. Now I see all these people causing problems every where. They don't know the culture, care less about America, but somehow they gave them documents. This is not acceptable. Even my grandfather was born here yet I don't have a path for citizenship. We need help. We are Americans, I love this country, and I would fight without doubts if we ever went to war. We need help!
1:40 He spend $10k on DACA. This requires a more thorough explanation. The current fee is $495. So, in order to spend around $10k, he must have paid that fee 20 times. DACA exists since 2012, it has to be renewed every 2 years. So, how did he manage to spend $10k on DACA?
@@godtalks7588 Normally, you won't need a lawyer to file for DACA. So, yes, IF he had the need for a lawyer, then it would be believable - but that that would be an unusual case.
@rolandrahn8343 In layman's terms its like when you go to court and sure you can represent yourself but the odds that you something correct are very slim and thus you need a lawyer
Sad that Congress cant work together to do something. Even some US Citizens married to DACA recpients/ undocumented person are unable to fix their spouses status and end up being separated or must exile to remain together.
@@laurymakesaway6695 The permanent solution for immigration reform in USA is to follow Canadian style Merit Base Immigration System or Point Base Immigration System.
@@carlag.9914 Never!!!! 🤨Canada is heading towards being a 3rd world. Most Real Canadians are kind people. The people I see now...... Let me stop🤦🏿♀️ Trudeau is ruining that country.
Breaks down in the car crying, and claims he has no regrets. I blame his parents no one else. Good luck young man America gave you the skills now put them to use in the global economy. Make 7 figures and America will welcome you back with open arms, who care about immigration status at that point.
This makes no sense. We are recruiting nurses, engineers, and doctors from Southeast Asian countries, a good number from the Philippines. Yet we can't keep college educated dreamers already contributing to the U.S? This will be a major brain drain.
@QEE QEE HA!! My family originated from California far before the West became part of the United States. So I can show you the door out if you like. The Lugos owned massive amounts of land, which is now known as San Berbardino County, and were auto naturalized right after the Treaty of Guadaluoe Hidalgo was signed. Under that treaty, February 2, 1848, ended the war between the United States and Mexico. By its terms, Mexico ceded 55 percent of its territory, including the present-day states California, Nevada, Utah, New Mexico, most of Arizona and Colorado, and parts of Oklahoma, Kansas, and Wyoming. These states have less than 200 years of having been taken over. How about we make it right and get the U.S. to return thies stolen territories, then we'll keep our dreamers.
Because those Filipino people have Merit they came here in US with Merit and they came in this country legally. That's why you're jealous to them because they successfully become US Permanent resident and US citizen. They are not stealing American jobs they are in a job where it's less among American people.
Daca is a big business for the U.S government, yes renewing four to five times 10 grand for every person, seventy thousand plus people billions of dollars 💵 gotta love uncle Sam🤑🤑🤑🤑
I blame Obama for the mess. A deal to deport recent illegals and allow them to stay. Going to Canada is not a solution. This issue will blow up in the years to come. Moral of the story is not to come here illegally
As a DACA member I Have fixed and serviced hundreds of life support ventilators. I arrived as a 4 year old. Now my time is up so I should go back to a place a never remember...
Very sad ..this country is stupid cause this kids are the future of this country and they all profecionals ..some doctors, some lawyers, and some super inteligents in technology.. I can't believe 😢 this country don't see this potential.. Very SAD ...
Me too. I just left a message for JPL above: Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
@@bikal1645 I assume most of them know nothing about their native country. Their parents came to America when they were just a kid so they have no ties to their native country.
Xi Jinping will invite them to live in Hong Kong. Then, they will strengthen the Hong Kong economy and indirectly strengthen the Chinese economy, making the Chinese Communist Party stronger. Remember, Hong Kong is a former British colony, so they speak English there.
Daca student who have been here for years should be give choice before any other immigrants to become US citizens or not. If not then they should apply for green cards or leave our country. But they deserve the choice above the invaders coming in illegally. Also the doca program should not be extended to include any others who are here illegally
I think they should be legalized once they have a college degree and shown satisfactory work history and payment of income taxes. It's dumb and bad for our society to let these professionals leave and instead let thousands of uneducated non English speaking people in who will be nothing but a burden to us all.
@@ILovePortugal-l9r only the ones that have finished college and are working should be given citizenship because they are paying taxes and are not a drain on US citizens. Those that are not productive citizens and are just draining our country of resources from taxpayers should be deported
Forcing them to leave the country seems like a brillant idea , isn’t ??? SMFHA why do you need young educated adults in this country? No need for that… right? smh -- in what world…….
The American dream has been over for all Americans too.
Lol most people on this thread is self untitled and negative you couldn't see something good if it fell on your lap
You're doing the "All Lives Matter" thing. 😮💨 Purposefully trying to ignore the issue.
@@surgezoom7079 what issue? That blacks do the most crime because their hood culture is trash.
@@surgezoom7079 what's the issue here? that illegals are illegal? DACA are victims, but victims of their parents crimes, I would support DACA if their parents are punished accordingly.
@nomooon What is illegal, son? What about the time the Hoover and other racist a-holes went against the Constitution and ILLEGALLY deported Americans of Mexican origin? You guys move the goal post when it's convenient to "Whites."
As an American, I may self deport. This country is very sick.
Do so and never come back. You are the sick one
It's almost like the U.S was not designed for ppl to live in but for corporation to do business in.
Facts
(@y2kelly66) Hurry, and get out before the door hits you in your ass.
👋
I self deported in May 2012 to Mexico, one week before DACA was announced. You can imagine how I felt thinking I missed a great opportunity to stay in the US. Almost 11 years later and living in Canada, I do not regret it at all. I’m free, I’m welcomed, I’m a citizen of this great country and now I can visit the US whenever I want.
Because Canada have a merit base immigration system or point base immigration system so it's easy for you to find out when you will achieve your permanent resident unlike here in US we don't have that kind of immigration system. That's what US immigration system must have!
Sad but, I'm happy you made it out and became successful
Illegal immigrant
@@vinny6242 your mom?
Least she has a passport
Key word - stability and peace of mind
@@ILovePortugal-l9r who? The parents or the kids?
Poor kid. Our politicians don't care about anyone but their wallets whether it be left or right.
what Drew you to that conclusion😂😂😂🤦
It’s literally just racist republicans in office that make it difficult for qualified and hard working individuals to become citizens in the u.s.
More on the Right than the Left.
@@ILovePortugal-l9r
I blame the political right wing that has used immigration as a wedge issue, along with guns, abortion and gay rights. It's disgusting and, in the end, America loses. Real smart.😔
The rare time Canada has been mentioned in the US media..,bravo!
Exactly, things are taking a very weird and unusual turn... lol
Canada is more welcoming. They're going to crush America economically.
645,000 applicants x $500.00 every 2 years . Its just profit for the u.s more than anything . that's only 1 small portion
Its actually more than 800,000
@@ILovePortugal-l9r your similar to the trash and junk I throw out
@@ILovePortugal-l9r what do you mean poor?
@@marksweeney5237 how are they draining resources? Provide facts not just your feelings.
@@ILovePortugal-l9r poor ocean croser .
Brought here at 3 years old. Impoverished up bringing in the ghettos of socal. Grew up chasing dreams, payed my way thru college as we do not qualify for federal assistance. Today im 27, registered broker on the new york stock exhcange and working for the most elite financial institution on wallstreet. I have to be honest, im beginning to share the sentiment with this fellow dreamer. Go on, deport me. I dont care anymore. If congress wont allow me to contribite my skills and talents to this great society, another country will. Plain and simple.
No doubt id be leaving with a heavy heart as we truly love this country, but ive had it. Enough being a bargaining chip.
These are the kind of people Americans actually should be trying to encourage to stay here. Not the criminals and other undesirables that come and take.
@@marksweeney5237 you
@@marksweeney5237 How are they at fault? They were brought as kids who don’t remember anything from their origin country, stupid…
I agree.
It is so hilarious!!! Hispanics will never help a non Hispanic if money is not involved.
@@ILovePortugal-l9ryour personal experience or opinion doesn’t group everyone in. no one in this country will do certain things for free. Have some empathy for your fellow human we are 1 species made by god and this is his earth not by the man made laws from England immigrants who invaded Native American land by force.
A lot of my colleagues in IT have choose to immigrate to Canada. Not only IT, but people from medical fields like doctors and nurses are choosing to abandon this country.
Brain drain is for real.
That’s a lie .
I’m in Canada, they’re not taking in people in the daca system. In fact, they don’t bring in many Latinos at all. They announced a big plan to bring in over 500k from India from 2023-2024…
So stop lying
Nope there are lot of legal immigrants who are handling all the STEM jobs brilliantly.
People on temporary visas like H-1B yes coz the wait times for a green card especially for Indians, Chinese, Filipinos and Mexicans can be daunting. You're tied to your employer and can lose your chance to get PR if you fail to find a substitute sponsor if the company closes or you get laid off.
@@asyongmatipid2 that's the crazy thing, we make it so hard for the legal immigrants, but expedite for illegals who should be jailed and deported!
Why not go back to Colombia?
Who understands this country? These ppl are young educated professionals whom contribute and yet congress doesn’t do anything for them. I wish them the best of luck, I’m sorry this country can’t do more for them.
their parents came here illegally and for free fair for immigrants that paid a lot of money to get here and got here the legal way that's like a parent stealing someone's house yet the children are allowed to stay in that house
@@izzymalik9173 we can’t change the past. Why are they paying for their parents mistakes. What is the difference between these ppl and all the asylum seekers that are currently coming in? Many of these Ukrainian and Venezuelans are still using resources, taking away from Americans.We are loosing professionals to other countries & that’s what I have issues with. These ppl know the language, are paying taxes,are educated, giving back to their communities, what else do we want?
@@lizz3104
At the same time, those who were brought here as children of non-immigrant visa holders have no DACA - they are excluded from DACA (via the requirement that the applicant had no legal status on 6/15/2012).
And once they age out of their non-immigrant dependent visa (at age 21), they have to self-deport (unless they qualify for a visa by themselves).
So, it is exactly the other way around:
We reward children of illegal immigrants (with DACA) and we punish children of non-immigrant visa holders for the fact that their parent's obeyed our immigration laws.
The old, "ask what your country can do for you" Just like JFK intended. There are millions of people waiting to come here the correct and legal way
@@rolandrahn8343 that’s not fair either! If these ppl were raised here and are law obeying ppl they should stay. But these ppl had no choice, I wonder if they can reapply to come into this country once they leave?
We're political pawns for both parties! I'm sick and tired of it!
You don't know much about American politics, do you? Better luck in Canada or wherever you self deport to.
@@ILovePortugal-l9r go kick rocks
The American dream has left out American born citizens, too.
Facts.
Not really they just lazy
That's true there's no arguing that. Things are not what they were in the 90's. But all we ask for is a chance to try.
The American Dream can be anywhere In America not just in the states
Wish me luck guys im moving to spain.
Ive been in the US my whole life. Ive had DACA for pver 10 years now. DACA is closer to be taken away than us having somehting permanent. Im happy for all my fellow DACA recipients who were able to kove on.
Wish them well!
I was born in Washington DC and the American dream has left me out as well.
Are you saying that because you were born there you are not considered a US citizen?
I find that hard to believe.
He should be mad at his parents.
and mad at Obama.
So dumb they are still temporary legal in Canada!
Thank you, the manner in which they said I am moving to Canada is delusional, as if you can immigrate permanently within a snap of a finger.
Cancel that 💩
American dream is over rated. We all get a mortgage and get overworked in our jobs and just play the hamster wheel.
Absolutely Disgusting! 🤮 The United States should have done something about this a long time ago. I don't blame these doctors, nurses, firefighters, etc. for leaving to an even better country! 😤
Their parents should be blame for making their child (ren) as an illegal immigrants like them.
@2557carla Who cares? You waste time playing the blame game all you want. These guys need to be US Citizens ASAP.
@@surgezoom7079 No they deserve to be deported not awarded!
@2557carla Too bad, sweetie. That's never gonna happen. They pay a lot of money to the government, they're not gonna mess that up.
@@surgezoom7079 It will happen specially if Local Americans participate and volunteer to deport this criminal illegal immigrants to show their patriotic duty in this country.
0:47 Lol if LBJ is his favorite President he deserves deportation 🤣
That's not nice 😂😂
No fooling. LBJ opened up this country to the 3rd world and created the welfare state
That girl is probably still illegal, just in another country.
MIguel seeking refuge in Canada when so many Canadian come to the U.S illegally burdening the northen states that border Canada. All of the ppl self deporting have something in common, they know the english language.
So Canadians come to US illegally? Where is the source for that?
😂 damn coconut , please grab a book won’t hurt
@@louish2037 ppl living in the Northern U.S states that border Canada.
@@peni1641 And why would they come to the Northern states to live "illegally" considering once they are here they won't be able to find work, won't be able to be eligible for any kind of government benefits, and won't be able to earn any money or even do anything at all when they don't have legal status?
Unless you are talking about the ones that somehow have legal status, in which case they wouldn't be illegal.
Unless you're also referring to snowbirds? But snowbirds don't come to the northern states, they go to the southern states, that's the whole point.
Kinda wondering because I am actually one of the "Canadians" you're talking about staying illegally in Washington State right now, and my life has been kinda uphended by the fact that There is Nothing I Can Do Here. (I can find work in California since I'm Chinese, but not here). I just recently found someone to marry which would have finally given me immigration status, but I can't imagine why you think there's all these Canadians living here if they don't even have status.
@@louish2037 Right back at you why did you come to the U.S illegally?
BYE
It’s ok “the American dream” is dead. The day is coming, that day will humble all these greedy politicians and racists citizens. I’m a citizen and leaving soon! Screw this mess I’m out.
Great news. Self deportation!!!!
The price of coming illegally to any country is living under a cloud of uncertainty. Not having access to services for legal citizens can also be denied you or cost money. Leaving for a place where you can live your life is a better option. Those educated in the US have good chances overseas if they are accepted there. It is not the end of the world. It's a new beginning. You can always return to the USA under a working visa or a student visa. Being young allows you to have options outside of DACA. Embrace it and fulfill your dreams.
But, in California they have a good life and jobs. The majority work in government agencies, they love to disqualify citizens recipients asking for medical, unemployment benefits..etc.
But they didn't have a choice to come here at all.
@@nicolesaylor4027 No they did not have a choice to come here. but who every brought them here regardless if its was their parents or another adult, they should be held accountable for bringing them here illegal. I feel sorry for the children who was brought here of no fault of their own.
@@johnniebeavers4003 so what do you say to your Euro ancestors who came here illegally? Should you self deport also?
@@teedee643 I'm in my own country and so are my family. I do not know my ancestors. eveybody that came here illegal is trying to come up with an excuse is to why they broke the law. I was born here and so was my family
Make the DACA people legal after EVERY other illegal is repatriated
As long as you are a DACA recipient you can work and study. Don't despair. The government must find a solution . It would be impossible to deport 700,000 DACA recipients. It's not good for the economy or the immigrants. That would be a lose lose proposition. DACA recipients work and contribute to the economy. They pay social security and taxes as anyone else. For all practical purposes they are already american.
Exactly, I just left a message for JPL above:Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
DACA is good but their parents are criminals, and criminals need to be punished accordingly to make this whole thing fair.
You must’ve lived a very privileged life. Must be a Boomer. You clearly have no idea the psychological toll this kind of precarity takes on a human being. Not knowing if you’ll be evicted in a month, or deported in a year… not having agency in your own life. Doing everything right and still getting fucked. Here’s what you don’t get. This country isn’t worth the fight. The American dream is leaving America.
Canada will give you permanent residency status in as little as 15 months as a skilled worker. It’s a fair, objective, points-based system. You do what they expect of you, learn their languages, get the degrees they want, turn in your assault rifles, and you’re welcomed as a full citizen with equal rights. Why in god’s name would you stay in this shithole country as a second class citizen, where a ride in an ambulance can bankrupt you? I hate it here so much.
This made me cry. As a black American, I know how discrimination and lack of opportunities affect others, so I hate seeing people not get a chance.
Go to New York and he,p all those illegal aliens if you want to cry and be sad about it!
KEEP CRYING',WHAT ELSE IS NEW WITH SELF LOATHING WEAKLINGS SUCH AS YOUR SELF.
They don’t like u smarty
@Sean70712 you need to give praise to Obama for signing an executive act that was not passed by the legislative act of the house, and senate. Be humble alien.
@@Sean70712 I don’t like them either pedro.
It's plenty of Americans who don't have the dream.
Well nothing would be given to you, without an education you’re not getting pay over $15-$20ish / hour… getting rid of young educated men/women sounds like a freaking awesome idea doesn’t SMFHA!
instead of going home and building you flee to yet another country
My parents paid a lot of money and work their ass off to come here legally if anyone comes here illegally they need to be deported.
Illegal immigration isnt a crime its a civil infraction like speeding. I geuss we should deport everyone that gets a speeding ticket as well.
Where did they come from?
I hear alot of "we don't mind immigrants but if they come here legally" I hope you understand that it takes alot of money and is time consuming, it's not given to you by a snap of your fingers. Also hear "immigrants are cared for better then our Americans" not true! Immigrants are basically on there own with little to no help. Everything is "US citizens" you qualify. Learn that the American dream is alot of sacrifice
Yet in Mexico, it is illegal to work if you are not Mexican, its simply not possible. But Mexicans (and others) coming here want every opportunity. Sickening how our borders are not secure, and very enlightening to learn how other countries protect their borders/jobs/way of life from foreignors, both legal and illegal. U.S. taxpayers deserve better on all fronts.
Its not easy let me just break the law .There are a lot of immigrants around the globe who do it legally and wait for their turn. Don't normalise crime.
@warriorclan26 don't twist my words, I know the process, just stating It's lengthy and expensive process. Not given to you as people think it it given.
He was college grad so couldn't he got an OPT visa? or H-1b?
Huge disappointment to know some people are getting green cards without proving their deserved to be here.. some people deserved to be eligible for green cards.saddest part is the trump wanted to DACa to end and give the chance those who already participate in the program to change their status🥴
Tahts what pissed me off
Like Melania Trump.
@@thomasperkins7318 melania trump is a citizen.. she became a card green holder after married mr . Trump ( usa citizen) by the way sponsor by him. Meaning she didn’t use any free resources from the gov.
Tps recipient with european citizenship here 👋🏼 I’ve been waiting on my fiance for the past 2 years I’ve followed every single one of their steps and they denied me twice without any reason, but let el tren the aragua gang into the country it’s legitimately insane, I’m moving to Ireland later this year to live with her and be legal citizens wish me luck 🍀🇮🇪🇪🇺
Yeah, he needs to go back if LBJ is his guy just because he was a Texan.
Self deportation is not a bad thing. In 2023, the world is a different place than their parents' generation. Other countries have better systems that the US and aren't as underdeveloped as American media makes them out to be. One of my best friends self deported. Ten years later, she bought two houses in her home country and paid off her car. Can American millennials living in the US even afford such luxuries? The best part is...her education was funded by American taxpayers and didn't receive a single dime from her. Now she's paying taxes in another country and living it up.
Nice, it’s good they go somewhere else. They’re not from here.
He should have stated that he was immigrating to Canada. Also, the journey to being a permanent residence in Canada is not a walk in the park...it has its own challenges.
Exactly, he will not realize this until he gets there. I left a message for JPL above:Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
It does, but he is more likely to be welcome in Canada as an educated and hardworking person, while the U.S is busy trying to kick him out for simply wanting to work and contribute.
True. But at least there is a defined path to citizenship. That's not the case here because it's a useful political issue for Republicans.
Don’t give up keep working hard!!
Dreamers never quit !!
2 year to renew Daca it’s like Two steps to get closer to your goals!! Never quit!!!
Exactly, I just left a comment above to JPLLBravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
@@francetogo794and weathered the storm? 😅😅😅😅. Daca recipients were handed everything nothing earned. 😅😅😅
with that hair cut your should never be let back in 😂😂😂
It's always America's fault. This country didn't ask them to come here via illegal means.
Don't be so mean
America is a Continent
You are trying to say United States right?
Are you that dense up there ? They were brought here as kids by their families; they didn’t choose to set up roots here.
They didn't either. They were brought here as young children by their parents. They didn't choose anything. And if you had actually watched the video, you would know that many of them are educated professionals, they're doctors and lawyers and social workers. They pay taxes, they make our country better. It's completely absurd to suggest that we should send doctors and lawyers that were educated here to Canada just because our government can't process reality.
@Bipolar Ferret don't worry the border jumpers will get whatever they want and then thumb their noses at people trying to come in legally
They can go back home then. They have a choice to do so. They are adults. They don't have to stay here and the U.S. doesn't need to give anything.
Go home thanks
How does moving to Canada count as "self-deportation"? Self-deportation in these cases should refer to going back to Mexico.. if they're going to Canada, it technically counts as immigrating there.. lol
Also, it's such a pity if they've been deceived into going to Canada, I understand if Mexico isn't a good country, but it's just sad all around tbh
he is from colombia dude why go to mexico racists much ??
@Mariza Gamboa he failed his geography class
They ain’t stupid they ain’t going to a third world country they prefer the white countries
@@rogeliogutierrez225 yeah
*deportation*
dē″pôr-tā′shən
noun
1. The act or an instance of deporting.
2. Expulsion of an undesirable alien from a country.
3. A carrying away; *a removing from one country to another* , or to a distant place; transportation; specifically, forcible transportation, especially to a penal colony.
Sad. And an ugly situation to be in.
I'm a U.S. citizen(native American) and i want to leave this country! 😅
Good,leave
Definitely support you 💯 Miguel it's not worth it to stay in America illegal to difficult men
Feel bad for him
Dade- why?
我本身是澎湖人居住台灣。做水電工兼做菜市塲(常常被警察抄或開紅單)而且有值照。我家裡也做生意。
本人有房子又有車，也人說要送我房子或車子(3台)了。
台灣人需要民主，台灣人可以做美國人，不願意作共產黨的犧牲品或奴隸。
本身是作營造和建築的我可以幫忙美國人的房子建築防遇美國的龍卷風或者是颱風。
我願意在臺灣防守，弟弟到(美國拿到綠卡)平安做生活，弟弟的家庭到美國平安生活了，我願意學英文加入美國戰塲一生。
Been there, I was once a TPS holder...I was born in El Salvador and I had to renew the TPS card every 18months, I'm now a US citizen as of last June 2022 🙏🙏🙏 but it took a long, long time ...I couldn't go to college because it wasn't "valid" at the time to go to the school I wanted to go
Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
@@francetogo794Jackie here, thank you for the acknowledgement, it was a long road, but so well worth every struggle 🙂🙏👏
Now you can go to college 🙂
@@y2kelly66 yes, now I just need to find the time lol 😂 but yes, it's never too late 🙏
Cerote
Get married
We're losing as a country!!!
Dreamers sounds right. You gotta be asleep to believe it.
IT Field Service Tech here. Grew up in here, pay taxes, I help 1000s of clients every year. I cannot believe that Biden is helping other people to come in the US like nothing. This is almost an insult to us. My family voted democratic thinking he was going to help us. Now I see all these people causing problems every where. They don't know the culture, care less about America, but somehow they gave them documents. This is not acceptable. Even my grandfather was born here yet I don't have a path for citizenship. We need help. We are Americans, I love this country, and I would fight without doubts if we ever went to war. We need help!
Time to go julio
United States better wake up!
Yes We want Merit Base Immigration System!
1:40
He spend $10k on DACA.
This requires a more thorough explanation.
The current fee is $495.
So, in order to spend around $10k, he must have paid that fee 20 times.
DACA exists since 2012, it has to be renewed every 2 years.
So, how did he manage to spend $10k on DACA?
If it involved paying a Lawyer to help with the filing process, i belive him
@@godtalks7588
Normally, you won't need a lawyer to file for DACA.
So, yes, IF he had the need for a lawyer, then it would be believable - but that that would be an unusual case.
Paying a lawyer it’s not included with the DACA fees
@@JoseOrtiz-fc7mj
I fail to see why he would have needed a lawyer in the first place.
@rolandrahn8343 In layman's terms its like when you go to court and sure you can represent yourself but the odds that you something correct are very slim and thus you need a lawyer
Sad that Congress cant work together to do something. Even some US Citizens married to DACA recpients/ undocumented person are unable to fix their spouses status and end up being separated or must exile to remain together.
They need to go home.
@@laurymakesaway6695 The permanent solution for immigration reform in USA is to follow Canadian style Merit Base Immigration System or Point Base Immigration System.
Cartel DACA
@@carlag.9914 Never!!!! 🤨Canada is heading towards being a 3rd world. Most Real Canadians are kind people. The people I see now...... Let me stop🤦🏿♀️ Trudeau is ruining that country.
@@laurymakesaway6695 Really? I don't think so migrating in Canada is hard because of Merit Base Immigration system.
Breaks down in the car crying, and claims he has no regrets. I blame his parents no one else. Good luck young man America gave you the skills now put them to use in the global economy. Make 7 figures and America will welcome you back with open arms, who care about immigration status at that point.
Sadly truth. If you can invest $800,000 in the US, you can qualify for a visa. The rich play by a different set of rules.
Trump try making a deal with Congess Democrats. But the Democrat refuses to make the deal happen.
He can dream in his country 😂😂
No, he can’t. Stupid idiot
10 thousand dollars ? It cost 495 plus shipping. If you can’t fill out the paperwork yourself then you should move to Canada 😂
This makes no sense. We are recruiting nurses, engineers, and doctors from Southeast Asian countries, a good number from the Philippines. Yet we can't keep college educated dreamers already contributing to the U.S? This will be a major brain drain.
WHO IS WE + RECRUITING, OPEN BORDER'S, GET OUT , WE DON'T WANT YOU AS WELL.
@QEE QEE HA!! My family originated from California far before the West became part of the United States. So I can show you the door out if you like.
The Lugos owned massive amounts of land, which is now known as San Berbardino County, and were auto naturalized right after the Treaty of Guadaluoe Hidalgo was signed.
Under that treaty, February 2, 1848, ended the war between the United States and Mexico. By its terms, Mexico ceded 55 percent of its territory, including the present-day states California, Nevada, Utah, New Mexico, most of Arizona and Colorado, and parts of Oklahoma, Kansas, and Wyoming.
These states have less than 200 years of having been taken over. How about we make it right and get the U.S. to return thies stolen territories, then we'll keep our dreamers.
Because those Filipino people have Merit they came here in US with Merit and they came in this country legally. That's why you're jealous to them because they successfully become US Permanent resident and US citizen.
They are not stealing American jobs they are in a job where it's less among American people.
@@apllu17 that would eally be Spain, Those states u named were only Mexico for less than 30 years.
correcting my typo really not eally
These folks displaced me from finding a rental.
Work go home and sleep. Repeat. AKA The American Dream.
Daca is a big business for the U.S government, yes renewing four to five times 10 grand for every person, seventy thousand plus people billions of dollars 💵 gotta love uncle Sam🤑🤑🤑🤑
I really hope the program does not get taken away.
They closed daca two weeks before I could get it, I don’t even have a work permit💔
I blame Obama for the mess. A deal to deport recent illegals and allow them to stay. Going to Canada is not a solution. This issue will blow up in the years to come. Moral of the story is not to come here illegally
PELEAR POR MIS SUEÑOS ES MI SUEÑO
¿Sueños? Para mí son pesadillas
U dont need it just come on over there are no imagration law's
Good
As a DACA member I Have fixed and serviced hundreds of life support ventilators. I arrived as a 4 year old. Now my time is up so I should go back to a place a never remember...
I love America 🇺🇸
Very sad ..this country is stupid cause this kids are the future of this country and they all profecionals ..some doctors, some lawyers, and some super inteligents in technology.. I can't believe 😢 this country don't see this potential..
Very SAD ...
goodbye Miguel !! whoever wants to go can go ✌️
USA keeps on getting bad here
Good start....
Huh… I should leave .
One to Canada buddy we’ll treat you like a human :)
I understand him 1000% but I honestly prefer to keep dreaming in a country like this than moving back to the country I came from
Maybe, watch it again boss. He is not moving to the country where he was born. --moving to Canada.
Me too. I just left a message for JPL above: Bravo to you Sir or Madam, you are brave to have weathered the American storm. America is a great country and has many opportunities. It just may take a long time to live your dream as in any other country. Virginia, USA
@@bikal1645 I assume most of them know nothing about their native country. Their parents came to America when they were just a kid so they have no ties to their native country.
Xi Jinping will invite them to live in Hong Kong. Then, they will strengthen the Hong Kong economy and indirectly strengthen the Chinese economy, making the Chinese Communist Party stronger. Remember, Hong Kong is a former British colony, so they speak English there.
The American dream is really a nightmare.
It is not that expensive!
AMFs
Daca student who have been here for years should be give choice before any other immigrants to become US citizens or not. If not then they should apply for green cards or leave our country. But they deserve the choice above the invaders coming in illegally. Also the doca program should not be extended to include any others who are here illegally
I think they should be legalized once they have a college degree and shown satisfactory work history and payment of income taxes. It's dumb and bad for our society to let these professionals leave and instead let thousands of uneducated non English speaking people in who will be nothing but a burden to us all.
@@ILovePortugal-l9r 😂 you’re a joke
@@V.E.R.O. BIDENS BILLION DOLLARS TO UKRAINE, DACA , AFGHANISTAN, MEXICAN ILLEGALS
Nope there are a lot of legal immigrants who are still waiting to get their green cards ,The DACA recipients has to be at the bottom of the list.
@@ILovePortugal-l9r only the ones that have finished college and are working should be given citizenship because they are paying taxes and are not a drain on US citizens. Those that are not productive citizens and are just draining our country of resources from taxpayers should be deported
Good
He's need to married a American citizen to gain legal status.
I thought they were going back to Mexico
chia c
Blame Biden!!!!!!!!!!!!!
She is a zotz zotz zotz anteater lol
Now you know why the caged bird sings..🙏😔
Forcing them to leave the country seems like a brillant idea , isn’t ??? SMFHA why do you need young educated adults in this country? No need for that… right?
smh -- in what world…….
Bro find you a wife and she petitions for you