Simon Jordan doesn't think Steven Gerrard has the ability to be a manager in the Premier League 👎
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 жов 2022
- Aston Villa sacked Steven Gerrard last week. talkSPORT's Jim White, Simon Jordan and Graeme Souness discuss!
Want content first & fastest? ✅ SUBSCRIBE here: / talksport
Enjoyed this video? 😍
Check out some of our BEST stuff!
⚽ INCREDIBLE CALL🔥 You have to hear this 𝙚𝙥𝙞𝙘 call from a very, VERY frustrated Manchester United fan - • INCREDIBLE CALL🔥 You h...
⚽ SIMON JORDAN vs KELL BROOK😱 Simon Jordan tells Kell Brook that Amir Khan will beat him! - • SIMON JORDAN V KELL BR...
⚽️ SIMON JORDAN vs DEREK CHISORA ROUND 2🔥 Derek Chisora calls Simon Jordan a "TELEPHONE TOUGH GUY!" - • JORDAN vs CHISORA ROUN...
⚽ JAKE PAUL vs EDDIE HEARN💪 Jake Paul says boxers are easier to fight than MMA fighters! - • JAKE PAUL vs EDDIE HEA...
⚽ AMAZING😂 Jason Cundy pranked by Darren Farley with fake Steven Gerrard interview - • AMAZING! Jason Cundy p...
⚽ "BE QUIET & NOT SAY A BAD WORD ABOUT HIM!"😳 Mourinho gives his honest opinion on his former players
👂Listen to talkSPORT LIVE: talkSPORT.com/Live
🖥️Personal website: /talksport.com/
📲Twitter: / talksport
📷Instagram: talksport?...
👤Facebook: / talksport
📱 Tik Tok: / talksport
🔴Download the talkSPORT app: talksport.com/apps/
🗣️ Want to have your say on LIVE radio and maybe even make it on our official UA-cam channel? Call the show on 08717 22 33 44 (13p/min) or text 80189 (50p + charges).
🔎Want to see if you feature on our channel? Check out our Best talkSPORT callers playlist: • The BEST talkSPORT Cal...
#stevengerrard
#avfc
#astonvillafc
#talkSPORT
#PremierLeague
#ChampionsLeague
#FACUP - Спорт
He needs to do what Kompany is doing with Burnley basically
he was trash with anderlecht, a belgian will tell you that.
@@steve13191 hence why I said what he’s flung with Burnley 😂
Doing*
@@steve13191 he seems to be doing ok at Burnley a club out the limelight
@@MrJeffHead yeah but he’s completely changed the way they play and he’s having success
Finally someone talking facts about the Gerrard situation 😂
It was so obvious
He's managed 2 yrs max . Seriously...how can anyone get a fair deal after 2 yrs ffs
What do you mean 'finally'?
Agree, little fairy needs to find a Sunday club to manage, ideally a girls team
He's no ability to manage
Simon Jordan is 100% correct.
Gerard’s formation he used at Villa was literally the entire cause of his downfall, that and his continued picking of out of form players as well as continually playing players out of positions.
Gerrard only has himself to blame. Trying to compete in the premier league without a midfield ceases to amaze me for someone who dominated the midfield in the premier league for seasons.
Baffling.
man had john mcginn as his captain lmao
Sounds like a England manager
@@marknewton7212
Don’t 😂 I’ve so got visions of it after Southgate.
Don’t you dare 😂😂
@@GingahBish23 😂😂😂
@@GM_FtblA As a Villa fan that was so frustrating. Dude was only in the starting eleven because he was captain. Was the worst player on the pitch every game this season. He's forgotten how to pass the ball lol
Ancelotti said it well. "I was sacked from every job". Now he's the most successful manager in the game. You move on, that's life.
Gerrard ain’t a Carlo standard manager
Carlo was a great player too, so it's very similar.
@@tomwilson6359 it's very early to say that. You learn from failure and mistakes.
@@ashhy2576 come on pal he won’t have anywhere near the career Carlo will in the managerial world red tinted glasses or what 😂😂
@@tomwilson6359 Right now, he's not. But Carlo wasn't Carlo when he first began.
As a Villa fan I loved the buzz that he brought when he first arrived but it just didn’t work out. He just wasn’t ready for a prem team. Wish Stevie all the best in the future!
Many were hoodwinked by the same razzmatazz of having one of the best ever England players as the club manager. The dream of him being able to transfer some of his magic as a world class player over to being a world class manager. But, it was all a smoke and mirrors illusion.
Many clubs have fallen for this, including the likes of Middlesbrough, Chelsea, Man utd and so on. These guys need to earn the right to take these jobs. I don't think you should write Gerrard off as a manager, he just needs to learn from this.
@@davidal180 Did you watch many of Villa's games under Gerrard? Man was clueless. Played players out of position, in-game management tactics were even worse. Gerrard had more than enough time ... to expose his lack of managerial nous at this level. Anyway, Stevie G is ancient history now (as well as a clear mistake) for Aston Villa. Onward and upward with Unai Emery. UTV!
Wish all Gerrard's friends in the media would have the same honesty
I doubt Jordan has any friend.
Simon is bang on again!
He's Luck Lucky
Always thought he should have stayed at Rangers for a couple more seasons. He was on a good thing.
Not so much a good thing just still learning his job and should have stayed put, won a title when Ceptic where in transition
@@thumpertoon76 Celtic were not in transition at all he destroyed them by a Record Breaking 25 points then they attacked their own manager and players and now he lives in their heads forever 😂😂😂👍
@@thomaswilson4418 of course they were in transition, new manager, new players all take time to settle that's TRANSITION PAL, 12 first team players had left during the summer that's some upheaval for any club and I follow the bears chum
@@thumpertoon76 Omg No They Were Not 😁 Lennon was the manager and they only started the transition after the season ended. No New players or manager for Celtic When Stevie Smashed them that season chum 😂😂👍
@@thomaswilson4418 why do you think those players left the summer after Rangers won the league, they weren't good enough that's still a team in transition from the old guard to the new guard, Ceptic had a torrid season with manager upheaval, Rangers are still a good few years behind Ceptic especially at present, Gerrard should have stayed at Rangers and proved himself over at least 5 seasons before thinking he was good enough to enter the Premiership, he jumped to early thinking he was good enough with only one title to his name a title he won against a very poor Ceptic
Facts are facts especially from an outsider looking in....
Apart from spitting at kids I’m astounded Carragher still gets to speak crap on so many platforms. Thanks Simon for finally telling the truth about Stevie G who won 1 trophy in 3 years in a 2 horse race.
To be fair it was a 1 horse race until steven made it a 2 horse race.
Meanwhile SP MS has won nothing and never will because he's just a little UA-cam user who likes trying to diminsh the achievements of real winners. Quite pathetic.
@@FreshAlchemy What have you won then pal that others haven't to put you in a position to dismiss other people's views?
@@brandurhansen2099 it's not a 6 horse race in england any more 3 or 4 have fell
Yes weres his spitting partner eliaf diouf both liverpool players is spit the dog a liverpool fan
Souness makes me laugh "The new guys done nothing with them"
Except.
Change the formation so players can play in positions that suit them and the balance of the team.
Press from the front rather than centrally.
Go for width of forward players over either lumping it forward centrally or using the wingbacks to cross it in.
And switching from defensive tactics to more offensive ones
And score 4 and concede 0
This is the dumb narrative going around. Fact is, players have to adapt to new formations and the tactics that any given manager decides. That's football. Half the players in the Premier League don't get to play in their prefered position, players are moved around all the time to suit the needs of the team. No formation will make defenders unable to defend or forwards unable to put their chances away. What Villa fans are unable to grasp is that their players downed tools for the last 6 months and weren't even trying, which is a direct slap in the face to the fans and the club. Of course it is easier to blame Gerrard for everthing than to accept that their team is full of mentality midgets who can only play for a small club like Villa because no-one else wants them....I wonder why! If I was a Villa fan I'd be more annoyed at the players than the manager at this point. Gerrard has a lot to learn as a football manager but what those players have done for the last half a year is unacceptable. They deserve to get relegated.
@@FreshAlchemy hardly a dumb narrative is it?! What Gerrard was doing wasn’t working. It was painfully obvious to everyone it wasn’t working except for perhaps Gerrard himself. If he, like you, thinks the players have downed tools as much as 6 months ago he could have cleared them out and bought in the summer. He didn’t. Go and watch the 6 Villa games before Sunday. Actually don’t. Wouldn’t wish that upon my worst enemy! Persisted with a terrible system that was easy to play against and continued to pick players woefully out of form.
You play a system that doesn’t suit if the other team has better players. He played the same shitty formation and tactics against Southampton, 10 man Leeds, Notts Forest and Fulham. I really wanted Gerrard to do well, was sceptical when he came in but liked what he was doing initially. But he very quickly got found out and didn’t adapt when that happened. No choice but to get rid.
Finally An English man ain't supporting Gerrard..Well Done Simon..Ur right.
bitter aren"t you
@@lynnwrigley4244 for what😂🤌🏻..Ur the one who is butthurt lol.
Like you’d go against anyone of your own ethnicity.
@@MrJevman I would if wrong.
Actually he’s well wrong , he done great at rangers and will prove you and the 🔔 end Jordan wrong
As a Liverpool fan I never saw Stevie getting near us any time soon and now it's been set back immensely
I would say it's been set back conclusively which is probably a blessing in disguise.
same here.. as a fan i know hes a trainee manager and like these ex pro all really should start in the lower leages or stay up in scotland
People confusing Gerrard the player and Gerrard the manager. As a manager he hasn't earned his stripes. The assumption that he will be a good manager is at this time fanciful. If he's serious about being a manager then he needs to invest time and learn the job and not assume because he was a good player he knows what he's doing. Being a manager and being a player are two separate things. Completely different skill sets.
He's already demonstrated a lack of humility and man-management skills with the Mings captaincy debacle. His reputation as a player can't makeup for the absence of those qualities. It already looks like his players had 'downed tools' and since his exit, they've picked them back up again!
Was he not a good manager at Rangers?
@@Micker375 English Premier League, different ball game, Rangers and Celtic more or less play the equivalent to teams in English League 1 each week, whilst being equivalent to mid table Championship teams themselves. I think Liverpool recently proved that point, and they are not having a good season by their standards.
Gerrard should maybe have looked at managing a mediocre championship or league 1 side to get the experience, certainly not a big city EPL team like Villa. Not his fault though, entirely the fault of those who appointed him.
It’s not fanciful. He’s obviously got some talent, and he’s young for a manager but it’s up to him to learn from his mistakes and come back better.
@@Micker375 no he wasn't, won one league title in three seasons in a weak league, lost to the same team twice in his last season in two cup competitions, failed in europe
Juande Ramos’s second season at Spurs was a real disaster, they were nearly relegation material until Harry Redknapp took over.
Yet he then immediately went on to manage Real Madrid for the remainder of the season, and his record was absolutely outstanding, unbeaten I think.
It just shows how things can be very different if and when the stars align for you.
I looked up Ramos at Real Madrid, out of interest, and they lost their last 5 league games in a row. But your general point is still valid. Who knows for gerrard.
Finally some sense! And surprise surprise it’s Jordan. It seems too many pundits and fans have taken this extremely personally instead of analysing his tenure, those who do take the time will realise the football he’s been getting Villa playing has been pretty bad well into last season. He was given plenty of time to change it and 2 transfer windows so there’s no excuses really.
Agree totally. Many fans and pundits seem unable to communicate or debate over a certain subject without allowing their emotions to take control thus usually ending in personal ad-hominem attacks.
It’s almost like if you criticise anyone or anything these days you instantly hate said thing.
Villa were in a worse position than when Gerrard took over. simple.
@@sammyharvard835
That’s fair enough, it’s not how you start though it’s how you finish and it fell apart for Stevie.
It was obvious when he took the job it was too big, we don't need SJ to tell us what was so obvious.
Couldn’t manage in Scotland either to be fair won 1 trophy out of 9! absolutely shocking. He ran when he couldn’t walk.
It’s funny to see Jamie defending Gerard but saying that United players defended Ole 😂
thats what mates do.
they find it hard to be objective
They did.. remember El sakico.. they never rolled over for Ole
Silly comparison.
He didn’t defend him. He just didn’t slate him. Which he wouldn’t do, because it’s his longtime friend and teammate…
Gerrard's got limited interpersonal skills. Type of bloke you can share a changing room with for 10 years and know absolutely nothing about him. I don't think many players would develop such a relationship with him that they would want to run through brick walls for him.
He needs to learn humility first and foremost.
You wouldn't know about that if ya haven't shared a dressing room with him.
@@pleasantville4529 sure mike tyson said that learn humility before humility finds you. We are all humbled in life including him
@@darrenrobertson1673 Being humble is not something that I would consider to be one of Gerrards qualities.
@@pleasantville4529 one of the best players of his generation, spoken about in high regard, remained loyal to Liverpool amongst etc etc yet he lacks humility? Lessers players have made louder noises
Spot on, Gerrard has a hell of a lot to learn before he can be considered for another Premier League job. He'll be in the sky sports studio this time next year.
Shame he has all the personality and charisma of a wet flannel
I hope not, he has as much charisma as a gas chamber and the last thing we need is another scouse accent on TV
But he's a piss poor pundit tbh, so I cant see him as a regular on Sky, or even Talk Sport!
@@anthonylong6403 I agree. He has no charisma and a very depressing voice. I'm not talking about his accent, just the monotonous tone in which he speaks.
Lampard was sacked from his dream club ( Chelsea) went away for a year, came back as Everton manager in PL.
Murinho was sacked from EVERY club he’s been at, still gets top jobs
Mourinho has trophies in the bank
@@jonathanniblock7799
Rusty old ones maybe…. 🤣😂
@@johnnyhock Won his last trophy not even 5 months ago. Try again
Souness suggesting that Danks did nothing with the team….. 🙄
Other than change the formations and drop the players who aren’t performing.
You should wait until more than one game before you start talking about such things.
And we all saw the Villa players were not even trying for the last 6 months, they down tools, that has nothing to do with formations.
@@FreshAlchemy Changing a formation in one game is still changing something though
Carnt take Simon Jordan seriously now after hearing darren farley impression of him🤣🤣
Simon Jordan would be a seriously awesome PM.
Love how Souness manages to turn it into a rant about foreign managers 🤣
I knew I could rely on Simon to say it how it is, we're getting hammered because the media have created a narrative to protect their friendship with Gerrard. His man management is poor, he doesn't coach and relies on others, couldn't get it right with team set up or in game decisions and never analysed games properly in interviews. He was out of his depth so why should we have risked our league status while he learns to manage, no one else would at their club
Gerrard fell for the hype that everyone gave him. Hes the Ronda Rousey of football.
🤔❔⚠️
But Ronda was a dominant champion for years until she was coached by a moron who told he to stand up with a kick-boxer and she lost?.. if she kept to her Jiu Jitsu she probably would be regarded as the best mma champion ever.. so your comparison is just dogshit pal..
@@SnotzalotzDominant against no Mark's. Name me one decent fighter she beat other than Meisha Tate?
I agree with Simon. I think he would be a good manager for a low level club because he’s a legend of the game and would inspire the players. He doesn’t seem to have the high-level tactical brain and man management for being a top manager though.
He's hasn't even had one full season in the league.. so many experts on here that haven't a clue what they're talking about
2 early to judge football you be be fantastic in the job then year later be run down
@@MrJeffHead to generalise a whole section which happens to also be the majority on the basis they're ex pros is ignorant mate...you could generalise and say that no young English manger will succeed in the top flight as it has become a global league and i don't think it would be harsh on England as a country to say that.. it's the best league in Europe right now
@@MrJeffHead the vast majority of premier league managers were ex pros and the two current best managers were ex pros in pep n Klopp.. pep was world class also so i fail to see your point mate i really do
@@MrJeffHead and right now Steven Gerrard might not be cut out for the although it's not like he was rock bottom destined to go down by the way some people are going on... maybe it was too early but i have no doubts he will be a top coach in years to come
Good players don't always make good managers, the reason why villa won on Sunday because the shackles were taken off them, we had players actually playing wide on roles they have played in, the players bought into the system of playing and they had smiles on their faces. Gerrard might be a good manager but he isn't a coach, but on Sunday we had a coach who knew how to get the best out of the players he has and wasn't afraid to drop the captain either.
Plus he dropped mcginn and ramsey who IMO cant play in the same 11. Luiz with Kamara/Dendoncker is so much more solid and doesnt leave gaping holes in the middle of the pitch
Yes ,Look at Patrick Viera, ✅✅
he did MLS then came to Europe slowly moving up,Now he is fighting for top 10 with Palace,
Last year FA Cup Semis, is beating did the double on City, Arsenal, drew big games, infact he didnt lose that many games
Victories have many fathers. Defeats will always be an orphan.
It’s called stepping stones and things take time perhaps Villa job came a bit sooner or it wasn’t the right match but he ain’t finished as a manager yet he has much more to offer the game I believe, best of luck for the future and remember Frank Lampard came back at Everton so why not Gerrard ?
8:30 - Souness needs to do some research we played completely different
GS always has contempt for Villa. There's no way he watched the actual match, unless somebody pays him to.
Piss poor pundit. The formation and tactics were completely different, both attacking and defensively
ive played about 2 games of football in my life. stick me in a sheepskin coat on the sideline at ibrox and I reckon I could guide rangers to the top 2 .
Thing is with Gerrard is that he talks a good game.
Completely agree with Simon Jordan quote 'you have to seperate the player from the manager'. Some incredible players have of course become hugely successful managers example being Zidane but its no guarantee. Gerrard and Lampard had tge same hype because of the name brand not the skills or managerial experience. I'm glad its starting to kind of work at Everton for Lampard but I think Gerrard needs to swallow his pride and maybe take an assistant role with a top manager like Arteta did.
There is a difference, Zidane took over at real Madrid where he already had world class players in place, I think me and you could have won trophies with that team, where as Gerrard took over a failing Aston villa team
@@littlemissy2883 Zidane got lucky based of his name but he made it work, they weren't guaranteed to win the amount of champions leagues they got in a row. He kept Real Madrid where they were supposed to be and some would argue improved on it. Gerrard had a very good squad of players and could not take them forward at all. Think he needs to be an assistant to a good manager similar to what Arteta did
@@garypipe1770 you want to listen to greame souness what he says about when he played for Liverpool, he said it wasn't the managements tactics that won them the trophies but it was down to the players, and I tend to think that's how the real Madrid players were like
Simon Jordan and mikah Richards need to get together as the clueless panel match made in heaven
Ridiculous. Many managers don't work out at certain clubs. Learn from their mistakes. And go on to success.
To be fair to Gerrard it’s not his fault that he got the job offers that he got and of course he’s going to take the opportunity but Villa was too big of a jump for him. The real test would have been could he compete with a Celtic that’s firing like they are now. He should have stayed on another year perhaps
Simon = Top LAD Proper Clobber. Darren Bent suggesting the other day that the FA could look to hire Gerrard as the next England manager. It wouldn't surprise me if that did actually happen as they've celebrated and rewarded mediocrity for years. Gerrard should be kept as far away as possible from the England setup in the future
Bent is oways Bent.
English team is great responsibility. Just look at pressing on the actual Coach.⚠️
No.
Gerrard should be appointed England manager immediately, also whilst managing Liverpool simultaneously!
Sammy Beck = Top LAD Proper Clobber 💯 Facts 💪😉👍
As Liverpool fan, I want to see Gerrard go abroad than joining down a level in Championship.
@@lfcspectre4335 Can't see him wanting to manage in the championship in all honesty. LFC Spectre =Top LAD Proper Clobber
Great Comment Sir.
Soupness is morphing into an older version of Yosser Hughes.
@MR MISTER I coulda been a footballer...... but i had a paper round
🤣🤣😂
The managerial circuit in England is a de facto 'old boys' club. These former players with a name from their playing days just walk into these coaching jobs while the 'you know who" keeps getting overlooked.
No, I don't know who, and stop talking absolute rubbish.
I'd say in response to Simon's comment on SG being there a year is ample time; You have to be able to make relationships work with people who you don't get on with that well after a spell of time, personality clashes call it what you want the manager has to be so consistent in his words and actions because he needs to motivate the players every day. Such a difficult job with the money around today at the top end, which brings with it the hyperbole coming form media outlets, fans, punditry, basically everywhere. Three or four bad games now and you can loose your job. If you ask me too much hype and judgement. I feel for Gerrard, very very tough job and yes, probably not enough experience yet for a prem club but he will be back and whatever happened at Villa, I think he is a fair and honest man and has what it takes to bounce back stronger.
To early to say that to be honest but i think he did come to the premier league to soon. I would expect him to do well in a lower league and then see how it goes
Just because one is a good footballer doesn’t automatically make them good managers. Most successful managers in England weren’t really known as players, Brian Clough, Bill Shankley, Alex Furgeson, to name a few. There was the odd one like Kenny Dalglish, Kevin Keegan, who did well, but I really can’t think of many more.
Cloughie was a top striker and england international.
@@happyapple4269 Clough got 2 England caps and played 3 games in the first division - the rest of his career was in the second division. He scored one goal at a high level, but was prolific in the second division. A good player, not a top player.
@@happyapple4269 Maybe I should have said outstanding players, I meant no disrespect to any players skills and achievements.
Alan Shearer is a prime example of the point I was making, and to be honest I had never heard of Brian Clough until he started his management career, as he wasn’t really in the national news as a player, he wasn’t a household name like Bobby Moore, Nobby Styles, or Bobby Charlton.
The trouble with Gerrard waiting for a big club is which big club will want him now ? He is a bigger risk now than what he was for Villa
Henry flopped at Monaco now he’s at Belgium
Yh the new guy came in (interim coach) and did nothing with them (changed formation, played ppl in their strongest positions, dropped the captain) and we played our best football this season. Gerrard was too stubborn to change from a narrow formation and it hindered him as a manager. Also almost definitely lost the dressing room a good while ago
Everyone should have been able to see villa was a risky move, the expectations were higher than the ability of the club and regardless of Gerrard’s managerial ability he would never have been given the time to get there. Most people predicted that this would set back his career if it went downhill too. Though the biggest thing is I think we’ve seen that Gerrard as a coach/manager isn’t good enough yet and was somewhat reliant on his back room staff, which in and of itself it’s terrible but once they leave he’s not got that support structure in place
He should look at what Vincent kompany is doing,he won championships with city as captain but didn't think a job in the lower divisions was beneath him if you pardon the pun.
His next job is at the mighty pub team at his local
he couldnt even manage a piss up in a brewery. totally useless
Steven Gerrard's pull was good at Villa, but he was an awful manager/coach. I think he'd make a better Sporting Director than head coach. He should probably look at the likes of van der Sar at Ajax and move in that direction.
Why would you have any reason to think that?
What part of being a bad manager makes you think he'll be a good director?
Agree with Simon. Wasn’t ready for it. Should have stayed at rangers for another 1-2 seasons.
We all said, why villa?
The move was back closer to his family but He was too young and inexperienced to take that challenge on with billionaire owners expecting instant success. The villa fans and owners have treated a young manager like dirt and hung him out to dry. Shame on them. They hung Paul lambert and dean smith out to dry.
A championship club should jump at the chance to take him, he would be brilliant at that level.
( comment from a huge rangers fan)
Poor Jamie, couldn’t say “premier league winner” when listing Slippy’s credentials
'direction of travel', 'narrative', 'consequenced', 'gravitas'.
I don't always agree with Simon but he's absolutely nailed this.
When villa fans thought Gerrard was a better appointment than Eddie Howe! You could pick anyone off the street to win something with rangers or Celtic!
Simon Jordan also was thinking suit was to big for Ten Hag
Simon Jordan is right here. Gerrard isn't ready for high-level management, talk about him being fast-tracked as manager of Liverpool or England is nothing but mere former player privilege. With Villa thrashing Brentford 4 nil straight after Gerrard left is telling. Either he made the dressing room toxic or he is seriously wanting in terms of both people management and tactical aptitude.
Gerrard is still a young manager and saying he doesn't have ability of being in Premier League long term is mad by Simon knowledge. Gerrard needs go abroad and learn his trade then come back 5/10 years time with vase of experience under his belt in management.
LFC Spectre = Top LAD Proper Clobber. Gerrard's no longer at the wheel
Graeme does a column with the daily mail Incase you didn’t know. He’s only mentioned it 54378 times since he joined talksport
And here you are, spreading the good word.
And Simon used to be a club owner. Only mentions it every other topic.
🤣
Lol
And to think he was, this time last year, in the frame for the Newcastle job. Same with Emery (who turned them down). I wonder what both think of the job Eddie Howe has done. Simon talks of not judging a manager on what he does in the first three months. Tell that to Howe.
Gerrard never seemed to be the sort who would do the hard yards in learning management and coaching. It seemed to be all about his reputation and standing as an elite player.
I'm amazed that most football fans still don't realise that there is no correlation between the players ability and their ability as a manager? And vice versa...
EG Mourinho wasn't a good player but he's been a world class manager etc
It's easy for someone who spends time on his butt to make a grandiose comments like this. Gerrard is a young manager and he is more likely to fail and learn. But to say he's not good enough to manage in the EPL is just outlandish.
Souness talking absolute crap again, trying to defend Slippy !
The new bloke’s done nothing?? What ! He managed to turn the team around within 72 hours, put out a team that was hungry for a win ,and played with energy!
winning the spl is the equivalent of league 1 (I'd argue that league is more competitive) in England should try his luck there
Im not sure any scottish club would get promoted to the premiership. They be bottom to middling in championship.
@@mabozza85 exactly 💯 accurate it's like comparing the northern Irish league to serie a 😆
@@beerguy177 well said👌
Personally think Gerrard needs to be someone's assistant for a while, maybe even in the Championship & build up his knowledge & experience at coaching as he's far too reliant on his staff to do the majority of the work for him due to his lack of experience, however I think he will take an easy option & go abroad to an easy league, maybe the MLS.
League 1 or 2 is good 4 him
@Michael Davis You seem to be unaware of the varying standard levels within football. The Premier League is the top level. Not being able to immediately succeed at the highest level of football does not mean you're "not that good". Grow a brain.
Gerrard's ego would never allow him to drop down to those levels (in his mindset).
@Michael Davis you can be an electrician if you're colour blind & the colours used in modern electrics were partly chosen to avoid confusion for those that have issues with colour... Just so you know
@@FreshAlchemy Is that you Stevie G?
Rangers fans said Mick Beale was the brains behind Gerrard’s success as a manager and it’s been proved.
Gerrard the player played on instinct due to his immense talent. It's difficult to translate that into coaching which requires a more cerebral feel for the game. The best former players as managers are the thinking players (Pep) or the limited ability players that consequently could coach limited players to greater heights (Mourinho, Klopp). Also, all of these coaches have great charisma in their own ways. I loved Stevie as a player but he didn't strike me as charismatic.
Too early to judge. He might be a really good manager one day but he needs a lot more experience and should probably spend some years managing lower down first
I have never understood why ex premier league footballers seem to skip the lower levels and get to manage the big clubs almost straight away. Surely there are good managers in the lower leagues who deserve a chance?
not just ex prem player's, happens all the time abroad as well
Spot on
English culture or should I say premier league culture towards management is very odd. Especially when managers fail. Conte had a disastrous time at Atalanta and left the job after 3 months. Just over a year later he was the Juventus coach. Luis Enrique had an underwhelming time at Roma. 3 years after he left Roma he was coaching Barcelona to a treble. If they were premier league based, none of them would be getting those opportunities at such big clubs.
With managers it takes time. Not everyone Pep or Fergie. To have a long successful career in management means you will have to contend with many moments of failure. The key now for Gerrard is does he analyse what went wrong at Villa, look at the things he did wrong and try to improve on those things at his next job. And if he does show improvements, he should get another shot.
This coming from Simon who did wonders at Palace
stevie thought he could skip the learning part and it never worked look at kompany with Burnley doing it the hard way he needs to humble himself and start from the bottom villa should never have given him the job his mate purslow has ruined his managerial career now 😕
I think perhaps an assistant manager role with a good manager experienced manager so he can learn the ropes. Similar to what Arteta did
And you "need" to "humble" YOURSELF and stop telling people who are infinitely more successful than you what they "need" to do. We can always rely on the UA-cam comment section for all the armchair experts to crawl out from under their rocks.
@@FreshAlchemy Simon Jordan is a lot more successful than you and me but that doesn't stop you crawling from under your rock as an armchair expert to slate Simon, yet you have an issue with other people doing the same to Gerrard. Strange.
@@FreshAlchemy Weird your name is free speech and you're having a go at people in the comment section for having an opinion.
Souness somehow finding a way to involve foreigners in this lmao
How Villa played against Fulham and Brentford should tell you everything about the division between Manager and Players. It would seem they weren't willing to play for him.
He will admit he probably jumped too soon from Rangers but Villa may have also done the same to Gerrard. I'd have backed him to bounce back but managers do not get that time anymore. He will be back no doubt about it .. the way he fronted at the end you have to admire that. I just wonder why more managers don't go abroad and get out of their comfort zone.
I like the route that vincent kompany took
Man management is a different skill Roy Keane is an example Graeme Souness another you need to be able to read certain characteristics in the men you manage and have natural leadership
frank lampard failed at Derby failed at Chelsea and is failing at Everton but he's in a job
Irony that Souness is there....he was a Liverpool legend, captain, dominant midfielder but didn't have what it takes to manage Liverpool either
its not easy from being a great player to become a manager. just look at Rooney, Roy Keane, Phil Neville, Del Piero. Lampard has been doing well but it is an exception so far. Perhaps he should become an assistant manager like Mikel Arteta under a great coach and gain experience
Simon telling it how it is.
When?
@@FreshAlchemy During this video, in fact on nearly every segment he's involved in on talksport he's bang on the money
He should have stayed in Glasgow but instead he got fooled by the success he had with Rangers thinking he'd get same results in the premier league. I'm sure teams in the championship, league one & teams back in Scotland will be lining up for his services. But I'd recommend he not rush and reflect to what went wrong and where to improve.
The perceived media narrative was that he "turned around Rangers". In three years he won one trophy out of a possible ten in a pub league. He is too dour and miserable to motivate players. Have you ever seen him smile? Have you ever seen respond with any semblance of personality?
Simon Jordan wow. He's impressed me a lot. Only englishmen I've seen who says it how it is. In Boxing and football. Respect to him. Souness is completely political and is careful with his wording to protect his relationships etc
You're delusional. Simon is one of the worst hypocrites around, holding other people to standards which he constantly falls short of. He's been defending Everton on here for the last decade because he's mates with Bill Kenwright. You are only so "impressed" because you're not looking at all the facts about Simon Jordan, you're choosing instead to adopt a blinkered and myopic view of him. And if you think he is the only Englishman in the world who tells it like it is (what a ridiculous statement), then you simply need to look around more.
@@FreshAlchemy Everyone defends their mates on national radio or tv. Carragher defended Gerrard because it's his mate. Believe it or not Simon isn't the only person to have defended someone he gets on with personally on a radio station or on tv
Err, of course you are going to carefully word criticism of any friend. You think you want to sensationally slag off your mate in front of millions, then go "well, it's only business, next time I Might be nicer? Don't work like that.
Simons right. If rangers and Celtic played in the prem, they’d finish 14,15th.
No doubt , no real rangers or celtic fan would disagree as we don't have the class of player that the big boys do , if we did maybe it would be different but we will never ever know 🇬🇧 same old argument
Gerrard will get another big job because he’s CAPTAIN FANTASTIC… Lampard got sacked and Everton gave him another chance because he’s FRANK LAMPS…
Captain fantastic doesn't make Manager magic tho, won one title in a very poor league...
Lampard got sacked by Chelsea there's no shame in that they've also sacked 6 of the best managers in world football. Lampard was 5 points of top spot when they sacked him and was unbeaten in 6 UCL games they went on one bad run and was sacked. In only one transfer window and little money to spend he's already transformed Evertons defense who conceded 66 last season only Burnley were worse. Ok the dramatically need to strengthen up top but defence wise there up there at the top there biggest loss was a 2-0 loss at Spurs there other losses being 2-1 or 1-0 as opposed to last year's embarrassing performances shipping 5 at home to Watford 5 at Spurs, Arsenal. The results might not be showing yet but the improvement already is clear to see Lampard is heading in the right direction.
@@thumpertoon76 Yh but he’s relatively new in the business mate and easy league or whatever you wanna say he’s still won a tittle early in he’s career
@@Mansa-kunda here mate Steve Bruce could win a league title up there and he's lost more games than he's won 🤣🤣 just look at Lennons managerial success South of the border zero success, tells you everything, only successful manager to leave Scotland is Fergie in the last 30 years...
Changing tone aren't we Jordan? Same you said he was going to make it more than Frank Lampard.
McLaren, AVB, Neville, Shearer, Ince, Ranieri, Lennon, Robson. Lots of managers on the merry go round
Neither do many other managers in the division
With Stevie Geee he just blames everyone around him. His tactics are- kick the opposition.
It's a shame Gerrard Failed but I wish him well
Liverpool fans need to forget him for about 10 years!!
Great players don’t necessarily make great managers. “Stevie G” is just another example of it. Him and Lampard are prime examples of this fact.
I don't like suey as an Evertonian but he is so so right
Like many on here I think he needs to manage a established championship side that have a little chance of relegation or promotion and then try and get them up to the Premier League. That’s the only way to repair his reputation now.
Simon Jordan spot on again 👏
A championship club will give him a shot prob a Reading/Stoke Sunderland level club at some point.
Great players don’t always make great managers, Zidane is a rare breed. I think Lampard, Xavi, Xabi Alonso all have potential to get there someday but I feel with Stevie G he needs a bit more experience and credibility.
Your comment is senseless. Do you think the other managers you mentioned don't need to gain more experience? There's no difference. And I think you do not understand what credibility is. At the end of the day, Gerrard has won more as a manager than all the other names you mentioned. Lampard hasn't won anything and only narrowly avoided relegation last season. Develop some basic intelligence before speaking.
@@FreshAlchemy But Gerrard does need some more experience in management
All managing jobs are risky. You don't get to the next level without taking risks.
I hear he is more of a manager than coach. Villa needed coaching.
He is media hungry, and plays the cool guy. He should drop the fake persona and develop some humility.
He doesnt have that in him
Simon is a breath of fresh air.