Origins of the Ukraine War & What Comes Next | Serhii Plokhy

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 31 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 43

  • @Catechumen_01
    @Catechumen_01 Рік тому +7

    That intro is too long

  • @yttean98
    @yttean98 Рік тому +1

    Whether his book is an accurate account of the events before and after the Russian and Ukraine war, at least his job at the university would be safe.

  • @athanasiusmcvay4449
    @athanasiusmcvay4449 Рік тому +4

    He is one of the world's leading Ukrainian historians. He did not "escape" anywhere but worked in Soviet Ukraine and was invited to work in the west as part of an academic exchange in the 1990s. rather than "escape" he has kept constant contact and visits to Ukraine and promotes the knowledge of Ukraine and its history and culture on the world stage, especially to the enormous English-speaking audience.

    • @galanis38
      @galanis38 Рік тому +2

      He is also biased and inaccurate in many of his analyses (as bias tends to do even with historians.)

    • @DARKSTAR-mn8ee
      @DARKSTAR-mn8ee Рік тому +1

      No to Naziukropnato. Glory Freedom and Victory for the DPR and LPR Russian federation and allied forces 🤗❤️🇷🇺👍.

  • @kennygrande9478
    @kennygrande9478 Рік тому +1

    I love Hidden Forces!!!!!! #1 place to get your news.

  • @maxentropy7596
    @maxentropy7596 Рік тому +3

    What part of Ukraine does this person come from ??

  • @magefixler885
    @magefixler885 Рік тому +2

    This gentleman is a cheerleader, it’s impossible for him to be objective. No I’m not Russian & my opinion is neither side is worth the powder & shot it would take to blow them both to hell.

  • @daveforgot127
    @daveforgot127 Рік тому +1

    You're trying to milk your audience, stop it

  • @olgaltey3278
    @olgaltey3278 2 місяці тому

    I had better opinion about professor
    After he called Ukraine democracy, my positive opinion died

  • @jannaZX
    @jannaZX 4 місяці тому

    " Defeat for Russia " , yeah, naw, that hasn't aged very well.

  • @daveforgot127
    @daveforgot127 Рік тому

    Why do you think we are so stupid? Why do you think we're so stupid

  • @nbach2202
    @nbach2202 Рік тому

    Sergey Ploxoy only in name on only in nature too ?

  • @daveforgot127
    @daveforgot127 Рік тому

    I'm a genius and i'm not stupid enough to pay your fees

  • @maxentropy7596
    @maxentropy7596 Рік тому +13

    This author is crazy… he escapes the ‘war zone’ and lives happily in the West, with now a protected job at Harvard. What do you think he is going to say.
    I find his thoughts offensive. What person in their right mind would facilitate a war with a super power??
    Safely opining from a comfy job in the West, he thinks it is normal to loose the several generations of a countries’ peoples.
    The Ukraine has been sold (lands) and it’s peoples have sold out to the West.
    Responsible leadership would have found a way for Ukraine to function as a buffer state to the super power.
    This guy is going to be seen on the wrong side of history, a term his handlers love to use.

    • @liquidus
      @liquidus Рік тому +12

      I've read your comment 2 times and I couldn't put together a clear picture of what you wanted to express

    • @allydea
      @allydea Рік тому +2

      ​​@@liquidus Point is: it's easy to be absolutist and patriotic when it's not your skin in the game.

    • @liquidus
      @liquidus Рік тому

      @BlueBottle Makes sense. And if one has a skin in the game, what changes then?

    • @allydea
      @allydea Рік тому +1

      @@liquidus what changes is that one becomes more pragmatic and willing to compromise when said skin is in the game.
      Btw, while I don't agree with some of the interpretations given by the author, I don't find him as extreme and unreasonable as the OP suggested.

    • @liquidus
      @liquidus Рік тому

      @@allydea true

  • @joelferguson8714
    @joelferguson8714 Рік тому +2

    Putin is a Godsend to the world.

  • @daveforgot127
    @daveforgot127 Рік тому

    Read me a feed rip off

  • @LaughterMan85
    @LaughterMan85 Рік тому

    Harvard, pffft