this is how it should be done so they all get to feel like more then backing dancers also it would take a some of the pressure off Nicole to perform so hard with her voice.
Well Jessice and Melody were singing. I'm assuming it's because the backing was so quiet so they needed to have people actually singing to not make it look awkward
Well…The energy they put is awesome, but the space in which they performed here is horrible and sad. This song needs the video we all know. Choreographies on the the cars and on the construction platform are more catchy.
Nicole is insanly good live. I love how she reenacts every verse of the song, making it sound much more emotive than the studio version. Rolling in and out of volume, using vocal fry, sustaining those long notes, Gosh what a blessing!
@@thiagothi1582 coz DC3 are first singers and secondary dancers . Individually,Beyonce, Kelly or Michelle can outsing better than 5 of the PCDs combined.
OMG, I can hear them all singing. This is like a dream. Dancing while singing or vice versa is hard but they sounded good. Love my girls. And the camera, it did not focus only on Nicole, yasssss!
they are good singing live i don't understand what they use an instrumental in others performances... i love pcd they are soooooooooooo amazing (specially kimberly with her leg) AMAZING!!!!!!!! =)
Nijia Johnson hopefully the tour will be different though I’m not sure whose going to take over Melody’s parts, I’m guessing they’ll be shared between Nicole and Carmit
Jerome Hinayon she was hired as a vocalist and had to learn to dance with the other girls... she was told that it would soon be her time to sing more and then it never happened.
I wish they would get along and do a massive comeback tour and album like it was supose to happen in 2020, look at this, they are having massive choreography and singing 100% live with absolutely no backtrack. I know they did use backtrack in most of the performances but not on this anyways even with backtrack is insane
Melody helping Nicole out on the chorus when Nicole is out of breath like usual , why can’t melody be in the middle when she sings more of the chorus than Nicole
Franco Firpo She IS oversinging. I just can’t stand her. Why bein in a group if you won’t let anybody else shine....oh I know why....cuz she’s a flop as a solo artist
@@Kiddblu9 It's ridiculous that you're commenting like she's the one making the decisions when it's obvious that there's a music execs that is calling all the shots.
Why did they manage them like that? It’s horrible how they only let Nicole sing all the versus. I love Nicole and know that she’s extremely talented but a group should be a group. PCD’s entire career was basically Nicole ft PCD.
Seriously. They only had 6 members... kpop groups can have 6+ and all members sing and have a role in the group. They would have lasted much longer and have had a bigger impact if they were a more balanced group. Despite how many hits they had, people didn't take them seriously because it was Nicole and her backup dancers essentially. All members are talented and have a distinctive aura to them. A shame. Hopefully their upcoming comeback is distributed more fairly but it's unfortunate Melody won't be there.
T K Stop the KPOP shit. That industry is nowhere near one in the US or UK. These are true artists and dancers doing their craft, not long-term trainees finally being a KPOP star with expiration date.
Nicole still looks like this today. And the voice hasn't changed. Well, occasionally she sounds old and struggling now, but the tone is the same. Maybe because she already had that "mature" look and voice so nothing much has changed as she aged.
a real star and a performer no one can beat this pcd and.nicole of course until now 2022 they are my favorite and nicole is forever love#1singer nicolesherzinger❤️👑🍷👍👏💯✅
@iloveashleyroberts01 DON'T COME AT MELODY LIKE THAT LOL! jk THAT WAS KINDA FUNNY. I AM THE ULTIMATE MELODY FAN, BUT THAT SHIT WAS FUNNY. Leave her alone y'all know she be making faces when she dances. That means she's into it. She was probably extra excited that all of their mics were on.
Finally they sing live 1st ive heard. N Nicole cldnt handle all the vocals by herself. U can see Melody do the chorus with her...no credit given. I love pcd bt the other can sing wld b nice 2 them do it
Not in this performance with all of the singing live. Pay attention usually she uses her pre recorded background vocals 2 do chorus etc. This time there arent none n she couldn't do both thts y melody is singing them with her. In this particular performance
So all the dolls are actually singing background live...but who noticed that they turned melody mic all the way the fuck down? She usually have a louder vocal than everyone
LOVED The Pussycat Dolls. I hear they're coming back together? They made some great pop music!!!! They were the original Little Mix! 😍😍 Thanks UA-cam for only just showing up in my news feed! Nearly a decade after it was released!!! 😑👀🙄😑😑😂😂
@RedleaderDemauriea no, actually, the song still has the back-up singers. Maybe they let the others sing because they realized their true potential. :D and that's how it's supposed to be . ISupportAshleyRoberts
Aside from her beautiful incredibly rich tone and powerful voice Melody definitely down played herself when it came to her dancing , I watched very closely and her lines are crisp , she’s note versatile than she gave herself credit for
can someone make a mix of this performance with melody's mic turned up? xD would love to know if they'd sound better or worse if you could hear the rest of the group
the only performance wherw you hear all the dolls do live background vocals... wow this passed me by
INDEED!! This is the live show that I watch it again and again.
MusicBlue22 Watch them perform ‘When I Grow Up’ on So You Think You Can Dance, you can hear all of them on there as well.
this is how it should be done so they all get to feel like more then backing dancers also it would take a some of the pressure off Nicole to perform so hard with her voice.
and this is why its amazing!
@Lionel really cuz I hear them all
camera's not focusing on Nicole either!!!! mics on!!!! LOVE IT
this is in my recomendations after 11 years, wtf youtube
LMFAO SAME!!!
Because of the reunion people started watching their older videos. That's why youtube is recommending it
me too!!!!
najaspears same!
The same I’m like ummmmmmmm wtf
OMGGGG They were so good doing all the dancing and singing at the same time! THAT SHIT IS HARD!!! They are so epic! i miss them!!!
IN HEELS AND IN TIGHT ASS CLOTHES
I wouldnt be able to breathe! they had really Great training!!!
They are back
This is one if their best performances because we get to hear them all sing and have a good time
Well Jessice and Melody were singing. I'm assuming it's because the backing was so quiet so they needed to have people actually singing to not make it look awkward
@@Solo-vh9fm Melody NOT being out of key with those backing vocals for once, and Jessica being heard....!
The energy you get from LIVE vocals, including background ones, is irreplaceable - shame they didn't do this more!
Well…The energy they put is awesome, but the space in which they performed here is horrible and sad. This song needs the video we all know. Choreographies on the the cars and on the construction platform are more catchy.
IT IS WAY BETTER to hear them all singing!
The energy and vibes here are so legit because everyone sings in this show...
Nicole is insanly good live. I love how she reenacts every verse of the song, making it sound much more emotive than the studio version. Rolling in and out of volume, using vocal fry, sustaining those long notes, Gosh what a blessing!
of all PCD performances this is my ultimate favorite! live vocals from all the members no fireworks and just them.
Yasss finally hear the real voice of kimberly,ashley,jessica and melody😍😍😍😍😂😂😂😂
This performance seems so genuine they all look so happy
They were so happy to be actually singing!
this is SO rare. Finally a group that is SMOKIN and they can ACTUALLY ALL sing. Damn!
tatsurider destiny child!!!
@@ANDEZ the dind't dance like pcd
@@thiagothi1582 coz DC3 are first singers and secondary dancers . Individually,Beyonce, Kelly or Michelle can outsing better than 5 of the PCDs combined.
Thiago Thi true they did it better
Andez and Beyoncé, Kelly & Michelle Weren’t out of breath unlike them
After many years .. finally i can hear all of them singing.. very shocked 💋😣🤣
To hear all of them singing is my dream!
#sharedvocals
Melody Carries The Chorus
Akii Martice I don’t blame her for quitting the group. They fucked her over so bad
Melody is not a good singer and its ok for PCD to kick her off
aiko banagan She left not kicked out. Pcd can stay on that group where they can all stay irrelevant and let nicole shine
aiko banagan LIES google her
DIY Construction Melody is a GREAT singer
The best live performance ever of PCD !!
OMG, I can hear them all singing. This is like a dream. Dancing while singing or vice versa is hard but they sounded good. Love my girls. And the camera, it did not focus only on Nicole, yasssss!
The first time that you can hear all the girls
They really turned Jess into Carmit
Exactly
Now that the original Red Hair girl is back, it's quite weird to watch the two of them. Hahaha
lol I really thought that Carmit when looking at the thumbnail
I thought jess was the one who left because of that
it's only the hair… when carmit was in the group they really gave her bad outfits and hairstyles, though.
there wont be any other group like PCD no matter what the problems they have, wes must appreciate them ❤
I have never seen this before ...I love it
Recomended 14 years later 😂 🔥🔥🔥
Jess singin when i grow up live yesss even hear ash & kim x
First time i dont hear just only nicole vocals live
juan enrique that’s because it’s a small crowd
Bet Nicole chewed out the sound guy for leaving the other girls mics on. Lmao. I’m glad to hear them all. #SharedVocals ❤️
they are good singing live
i don't understand what they use an instrumental in others performances...
i love pcd they are soooooooooooo amazing (specially kimberly with her leg)
AMAZING!!!!!!!! =)
Melody deserves some spotlight
This is such a random performance. Where even are they?
In someone's living room Hahaha
Wow, they look the same! I saw the date on this, 11 years ago!!!
If this isn't how the reunion performances are with all the girls singing it I'll be pissed!
Go watch the x factor performance
Nijia Johnson hopefully the tour will be different
Nijia Johnson hopefully the tour will be different though I’m not sure whose going to take over Melody’s parts, I’m guessing they’ll be shared between Nicole and Carmit
Even the new song is only nicole singing
kween I hope we hear them on the backgrounds and carmit gets a solo
i miss Ashley and her dancing so much!
That leg extension is very everything
When it comes to group always fascinating to see them sing together
Omg i love this performance you can hear all the girls
Missing this era so bad. I'm glad they're back. ❤️
me to too. In my opinion this was their best era: The hair, the wardrobe, make up and music
And now they're gone again
@@korikewl0151 Sad. Still happy they did a comeback. It was majestic!
I miss this group. Good times! 💖
melody is wearing something that looks like what they used wear when they first came out.
Wow, think this is the best When I grow Up performance!
Jesus...the editing lmao STAY STILL!
I KNOW I LOVE THEM ALL SINGING!
All their mics were on cause you can hear Ashley singing the “oohh” in the final part
we want more of nicole and the pcd we dont want the other group and singer only this#1❤️❤️❤️👑👑👑
2019... ❤️🔥
Love it! You can hear them all!
Wow this was great! They all did the thang! Danity Kane is shook
Was Melody being punished?! Why does it look like they just pulled her up on stage and was like “you’re in the group now... sing and dance!”
That's actually how she was managed. She was asked to dance in the bg.
Jerome Hinayon she was hired as a vocalist and had to learn to dance with the other girls... she was told that it would soon be her time to sing more and then it never happened.
@@BrizzzoStizzzo Yes, she was hired as a vocalist but was treated as a bg dancer for nicole. She said that in an interview awhile back.
I think he's talking about her outfit
C⁴Cosplay yes I was lol
They WERKED the limited space they had! wow!
Performance was great but why did they put them in a corner like this? Really cringy. Like performing in someone’s living room.
Lucy Preece it was a talk show and the set up was suppose to look like a house
I would love them to perform in my living room lol
To force them to sing. Literally backing them into a corner where they have no choice but to go fully live.
I wish they would get along and do a massive comeback tour and album like it was supose to happen in 2020, look at this, they are having massive choreography and singing 100% live with absolutely no backtrack. I know they did use backtrack in most of the performances but not on this anyways even with backtrack is insane
Todas estão tão lindas, mas a Nicole.... 😍😍😍 Perfeita!
Melody helping Nicole out on the chorus when Nicole is out of breath like usual , why can’t melody be in the middle when she sings more of the chorus than Nicole
Nicole is not out of breath, she's just harmonizing with the other girls, otherwise it would be too much and she would be oversinging the song.
Franco Firpo nicole cant sing and dance.
Franco Firpo She IS oversinging. I just can’t stand her. Why bein in a group if you won’t let anybody else shine....oh I know why....cuz she’s a flop as a solo artist
Because she's *The Vocalist* of the group. I wish that the other girls sang more but let's not get it twisted.
@@Kiddblu9 It's ridiculous that you're commenting like she's the one making the decisions when it's obvious that there's a music execs that is calling all the shots.
Why did they manage them like that? It’s horrible how they only let Nicole sing all the versus. I love Nicole and know that she’s extremely talented but a group should be a group. PCD’s entire career was basically Nicole ft PCD.
Seriously. They only had 6 members... kpop groups can have 6+ and all members sing and have a role in the group. They would have lasted much longer and have had a bigger impact if they were a more balanced group. Despite how many hits they had, people didn't take them seriously because it was Nicole and her backup dancers essentially. All members are talented and have a distinctive aura to them. A shame. Hopefully their upcoming comeback is distributed more fairly but it's unfortunate Melody won't be there.
That was the set up fromthe start to get nicole out there
T K Stop the KPOP shit. That industry is nowhere near one in the US or UK. These are true artists and dancers doing their craft, not long-term trainees finally being a KPOP star with expiration date.
Tai Phan you’re saying kpop artists/groups aren’t “real” artists? That’s just ridiculous!
@@ianphan2806 ok lol
That break down was fire 🔥
pcdddss.... when is the comeback? 2019 dec still watching and waiting
Nicole still looks like this today. And the voice hasn't changed. Well, occasionally she sounds old and struggling now, but the tone is the same. Maybe because she already had that "mature" look and voice so nothing much has changed as she aged.
I love how Kimberly is always smiling
woah that was beyond great
wow! the other girls are singing too! i had never seen it!
yay,they are ALL singing
amazing performance
i miss so much pcd!!!
2:57 I'm Kimberly always flexible!
a real star and a performer no one can beat this pcd and.nicole of course until now 2022 they are my favorite and nicole is forever love#1singer nicolesherzinger❤️👑🍷👍👏💯✅
@iloveashleyroberts01 DON'T COME AT MELODY LIKE THAT LOL! jk THAT WAS KINDA FUNNY. I AM THE ULTIMATE MELODY FAN, BUT THAT SHIT WAS FUNNY. Leave her alone y'all know she be making faces when she dances. That means she's into it. She was probably extra excited that all of their mics were on.
You can hear them all in this one!
these girls are so talent,
WE CAN HERE JESSICA!!!!!!
jessica and melody
Isso sim foi um ao vivo
Love it. #KimberlyWyatt rules.
Finally they sing live 1st ive heard. N Nicole cldnt handle all the vocals by herself. U can see Melody do the chorus with her...no credit given. I love pcd bt the other can sing wld b nice 2 them do it
Not in this performance with all of the singing live. Pay attention usually she uses her pre recorded background vocals 2 do chorus etc. This time there arent none n she couldn't do both thts y melody is singing them with her. In this particular performance
literally no one is doing it like them these days
So all the dolls are actually singing background live...but who noticed that they turned melody mic all the way the fuck down? She usually have a louder vocal than everyone
Jessica Sutta
aunque le pongan el peor vestuario a Melody, ella no para de brillar, es fenomenal.
Exacto... ello lo disfruta, se lo vive y lo goza, claro siempre y cuando su MiC este ON
Thanks 👍👌
Melody The Best
Melody out here jumping from Lead to Background vocals the whole performance 😂 basically could’ve done this herself 🤣
Wow I didnt even notice that red haired girl was missing wow
Omg they are hot and back then even now... can’t wait for reunited :-) ❤️❤️❤️
This one, so you think you can dance and this morning are all completely live like this of you are looking for more
que afortunadossss las tuvieron ahi nomas * - *
Pretty dancers and choreography very good exercices for the health of the body and mind #soiroyale 💓💓💓
Ojalá todos sus conciertos fueran así
Ashley is my fav😌
Look at all the mics being on!
LOL .
PAUSE WHERE KIMBERLY DO THE LEG LIFT, THEN LOOK AT MELODY. XDD
Angelo Ladimo 😂😂😂
LOVED The Pussycat Dolls. I hear they're coming back together? They made some great pop music!!!! They were the original Little Mix! 😍😍
Thanks UA-cam for only just showing up in my news feed! Nearly a decade after it was released!!! 😑👀🙄😑😑😂😂
@RedleaderDemauriea no, actually, the song still has the back-up singers. Maybe they let the others sing because they realized their true potential. :D
and that's how it's supposed to be .
ISupportAshleyRoberts
melody mustve lost her outfit cuz she usually doesnt wear that
Aside from her beautiful incredibly rich tone and powerful voice Melody definitely down played herself when it came to her dancing , I watched very closely and her lines are crisp , she’s note versatile than she gave herself credit for
❤
I barely heard Jessica's voice in the first part of the chorus.
The chorus is just Nicole and Melody.
@@iampause I think he mean the "when i grow up" line
Why they cut the video like that? 🤣 Change of perspective every second damn
can someone make a mix of this performance with melody's mic turned up? xD would love to know if they'd sound better or worse if you could hear the rest of the group
@mohamed061996 She is just singing like that in beep, she is making her voice like that.
when they live singing, then I click like
Waw her voice
Melody, Kim, Jess and Ashley had to sing and dance here and they should have had more vocals