She is a liar and is absolutely clueless. I feel sorry for Malcolm Roberts having to talk to her as it would be almost impossible to get a valid answer from her.
With aid of the Chair, the arrogant and dismissive look on her face when saying, "No I dont" says it all. She is contemptuous at being questioned at all, just give us power and money and shut up. We are so stupid.
@derekmottley3656 I am both. Been watching most of the questioning that goes on and am over their entitled attitudes but it occurred to me today that some look like they cannot groom themselves. Greasy hair on some , do not look like they have combed it in ages. Big mops of hair. Others might as well declare to the world their gender confusion. Seriously, did the pride movement take up barracks in the ACT? No wonder the woke movement has taken legal hold on AU.
It’s unreal yet the aboriginal community don’t build any houses they wait for white mans houses and complain about their homes they have aboriginal housing how rasist is that, I don’t see a white Australians housing… that would be racist. Imagine how many houses could of been built with all that wasted money
All questions must be placed in a context. That is what Sen. Roberts was establishing. The constant dismissal and down-playing of context by these others is bad behaviour. Truly they are trying to cover-up the financial waste that our government is conducting, while keeping the poor in poverty.
Mate easy to see. Sit out front of one of those places that are meant to help abos. People who work there have 200k cars People who need help have no shoes...
Thank you Senator Roberts for continuing to expose the stupidity and incompetence of this government. Their thought processes seemed to be focused on themselves and keeping the status quo while the indigenous peoples keep suffering.
They’re unbelievable thank you for trying to get through to them Senator Robert’s. We need more senators like you that’s actually got a backbone to stand up. 😢❤
@@Antechynus I wouldn't say that but there are certain people in parliament that aren't doing stuff in the best interest of our country or our people, little less our futures in a true and honest sense
Just about every facebook group brainfart, nanny state, fringe minority benefiting, revenue wasting, freedom limiting, impossible to implement policy idea and legislation gets its start with panels like this. Feelings and wokeness have no place in government. Therefore, ladies out.
This minister being asked the question is part of the problem. Keep that money flowing to fill the pockets of elites from the people. She is the problem. Give the people the audit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
She is still bitter and twisted because the Voice referendum was defeated and she didn't receive more power and glory from the Voice!! The chairwoman is a Labor stooge 😢
We are pissed off the gap has gotten wider my mum has some Aboriginal blood and my step dad is Aboriginal and he said closing the gap is a scam for people to abuse the system. They are not helping they are just getting rich.
The great thing is your mum, stepdad and you are fully aware of this and many many many more are becoming aware of it. The Dark is coming into the Light about this corrupt industry. 🤗
I don't know about Sen.Roberts but my blood pressure was peaking at this display of bs from prominent Voice activist Mccarthy & that useless Chair. My sympathies,Sen.Roberts.
All aboriginal agencies and funding must cease and the 50+ billion dollars per year spent on all Australians in health, education and infostructure, all mining royalties should be shared equally among all Australians and native title abolished.
lol we have all been asleep at the wheel and that brick wall is closer than we think. The lucky country has slowly silently been taken over bit by bit from within by our very own thinking there doing a great job/service for there country. My grandparents fought for this land. The only Gap is between their ear's and watching this makes me sick this con has been going on way to long with No accountability for everyone to see.I really believe we are in for serious changes ahead with No Opt-Out option if we don't take a stand. Look into National Strike Australia. Buckle-up the shit show has not ended. I only replied because it made me laugh lol!!! You would've loved talking with this couple in their late 30's Sat night on the V/line journey home.
You are never gonna close any gap because of the elephant in the room people are not allowed to acknowledge: most meaningful gaps are based on preferences and biological differences, which are substantial, and not discrimination.
Every dollar spent across the government should be audited regardless of where it’s going. You can gauge its effectiveness and whether there is a better approach or cost savings that can be used in other areas. Only people who are doing the wrong thing push back against audits
Exactly. It’s about $40000 per person - children, teenagers, work age, elderly , males and female. Let them have autonomous control. Take the money from the myriad ‘organisations and agencies’ where-in there is the corruption.
This woman has gotten soo much money for decades and the gap still isn't closing yet getting wider by making her richer so we can get the blame for not closing the gap. What is she doing.
He is 100% correct. If we close the 'gap' this billion dollar industry will disappear. There are people with vested interests to keep that gap wide open. It's the same as the DV industry. There's no benefit to ending it for these people who financially benefit from it.
We know the problem. The gap won't be closed while authorities work to keep it wide and keep it funded. Senator Price knows the truth. She is a champion of the aboriginal people, the real ones.
Audits are not the answer. In Moree NSW, the aboriginal villages housing was repeatedly vandalised by the inhabitants, then repeatedly repaired and refurbished by taxpayers' funds. In Bowen, housing was not distributed fairly within the ATSI community. Choice houses going to elders and their relatives, rather than families on waiting lists.
The aboriginal industry, like health, education etc in this country is not made to actually help people on the ground. It only keeps others in a style of life we can only dream of. . . . Except we strive for morals, ethics and an actual want to help people.
So she's asking the questions & refusing to answer any. We're so special (& over-funded) that we can't be asked ANY pertinent questions that may put said ongoing funding at risk)! 🤯
Why is it the only thing that can preserve aboriginal culture and heritage is huge amounts of money and land ! There are way to many bodies be it private and public that do not want to close the gap because they obviously see it as a cash cow which they want to milk forever !
The biggest problem I see in the political theatre today is the lack of respect shown across political lines, the elected officials in that room represents thousands/millions of Australian people, voters feel that senator should speak for them, and when they no longer feel that way a new senator is elected. When these senators ask questions they should be responded to, not as a personal point of view but as the words of the Australian people, questions that need to be answered not dismissed. Truth and effectiveness need not hide.
Up until 1973, Australia was an explicitly Anglo Celtic endeavour. Antipodean browns weren't considered Australian until 1948. We don't need their "Dancers and Artists"
@@muzzer0181 More sensible times. Pre Australians should have been left alone. Now identity politics needs to go further with tax spending only going to the group you identify with.
100% right, people don’t want words and empty promises; it won’t change while the elites are filling their pockets. After working in this area for 10 years it has only gotten worse.
So in the spirit of closing gaps, can I stop working and get as much money as a CEO? No reason to discriminate against me, as a laziness-afflicted person. After all, all gaps are due to discrimination, right? There are no other factors to consider whatsoever.
At 1.45 when interupted by the chair i think most of us new what the question was. To keep throwing money that comes from tax payers, at closing the gap, without any minor or significant result is insanity! Call for an audit!
Ordinary everyday Australians care about Aboriginal communitys, and with Billions of Dollars being spent We still see No Advancement of Aboriginal Progress, It would seem that the Women running the expenditure of that money are Incapable of doing the Right things. And, The Female Chair Isnt Helping.
She is a disgrace
Bubi Bear and Square Bear both miss her, but Hair Bear isn't listening.
@@GazGuitarz Hair Bear calls herself first nation but clearly has a fair bit of non indigenous ancestry that she fails to acknowledge at all.
Totally NOT.
@@lynhill8443 Says you, putting a word in capitals doesn't make it more important but it does reveal you as a screaming lefty.
Not about politics at all. About what is right.
What an arrogant minister
Vulgar piece of work.
She is a liar and is absolutely clueless. I feel sorry for Malcolm Roberts having to talk to her as it would be almost impossible to get a valid answer from her.
What do you expect ??? They own most of Australia now !!!!
On the take with jobs for the girls
This womans dismissive, disinterested & uncooperative attitude is disgusting.
Not the first time.
She’d still be dragging her fly blown arse around in the dirt digging grubs out of the ground for lunch if it wasn’t for the white man!! 😡
Typical really, she's only there to milk the system and protect her authority to continue to milk the system.
With aid of the Chair, the arrogant and dismissive look on her face when saying, "No I dont" says it all. She is contemptuous at being questioned at all, just give us power and money and shut up. We are so stupid.
Who's the shaggy headed horror ? Do the treat the parliament as their own personal ugly contest , abo history is a load of BS
I am embarrassed by the appearance of these women who represent our government.
They represent Satan
You should be angered, not embarrassed.
@derekmottley3656 I am both. Been watching most of the questioning that goes on and am over their entitled attitudes but it occurred to me today that some look like they cannot groom themselves. Greasy hair on some , do not look like they have combed it in ages. Big mops of hair. Others might as well declare to the world their gender confusion. Seriously, did the pride movement take up barracks in the ACT? No wonder the woke movement has taken legal hold on AU.
It's free money.
She smirks when says, I'll take that on noticed
I'm embarrassed 95% of the Population still acquiesces to it all
What a scam..... thanks senator Roberts
The Biggest scam!
The government does not want the public to know how much money is spent on this aboriginal culture in Australia
Too much.
Homeless are everywhere
Centerlink is full of foreigners
over 40 billion a year
Sounds like they have for too many agencies happening which are not so effective yet drain the coffers just keeping them in jobs.
Thats what you believe. Be heaps more i reckon @muzzer0181
It’s unreal yet the aboriginal community don’t build any houses they wait for white mans houses and complain about their homes they have aboriginal housing how rasist is that, I don’t see a white Australians housing… that would be racist. Imagine how many houses could of been built with all that wasted money
Another Labor Minister who is a waste of space
has she has enough carbon credits
They all are, everyone of those jobs can be replaced or removed... everyone of those positions... YOU ARE PAYING THEM... STOP PAYING TAX...
@@bryceanderson1772 how? any idea? or just words into the wind
These chairs don't want the truth exposed.
All questions must be placed in a context. That is what Sen. Roberts was establishing.
The constant dismissal and down-playing of context by these others is bad behaviour. Truly they are trying to cover-up the financial waste that our government is conducting, while keeping the poor in poverty.
Eysenck and Jensen examined race and IQ in the early twentieth century. Their line of research sheds light upon the problems of the Australoid race.
The Chair was merely being herself, a prat(t).
No wonder Labor and the "aboriginal industry" do not want an audit of aboriginal funding and use of these funds.
Mate easy to see.
Sit out front of one of those places that are meant to help abos.
People who work there have 200k cars
People who need help have no shoes...
They need to buy “no more gaps” apparently it’s a good product and should fix their issues.
Bring on an audit.
Keep plugging away, Malcolm!!!
It's a disgrace that's she can't comprehend this
She is a leech. She understands how to live off taxing whites.
Thank you Senator Roberts for continuing to expose the stupidity and incompetence of this government. Their thought processes seemed to be focused on themselves and keeping the status quo while the indigenous peoples keep suffering.
It's by design. They have sold out to evil.
The hide and audacity of this chair person.She is a disgrace.
Closing the gap is a business model.
Another reason to vote One Nation.
Pauline's love of Israel is a reason to withhold that vote, until we get an explicitly pro White party
@muzzer0181 A pro white party ,you may aswell have vote yes for the voice.
Closing the gap is impossible with current technology due to genetic differences between the races.
They should be treated equally by law.
Pauline is a business, registered with abn and "trading" in the lumber sector
@@kinchegayowie6167 And ?
She DOESN'T WANT an Audit!! Thats OBVIOUS.
She is part of the industry… not part of the people…. Aboriginal lives will never change if people like her continue to support the industry
She was front and centre when Albo was pushing the Voice she was on the take as well and part of the problem
Greed greed greed greed greed greed greed🤢
Amazing how we never see full bloods in the voice or any of these discussions
The aboriginal woman is trying to maintain the victim mindset
Is she really an abo...REALLY
According to Wayne Glew the “Aboriginal” people WERE NOT the FIRST people to settle in Australia. Interesting..
Mixed breed.. For. Sure..
I call them white Aborigines cuz that's what they are
@@itslife761ua-cam.com/video/lN2mvdCjXH8/v-deo.htmlsi=UKvW5BWv2ONILTKa this is what they looked like when white man turned up
Auditing is required and not being done
Albo wont do it, he is part and parcel of the scam. Need him gone before any action can happen.
They’re unbelievable thank you for trying to get through to them Senator Robert’s. We need more senators like you that’s actually got a backbone to stand up. 😢❤
I find my tax dollars being wasted is patronising, wasteful, and fraudulent.
Maternal in this case.
Can I list the entire aboriginal community as dependants on my tax return?
Net Zero is the biggest fraud in history.
A large amount of money is also wasted on Aboriginal affairs.
Toxic victimhood
Investigate this woman
I bet she lives in a million dollar mansion!
@@alanharrison573
Absolutely 💯 %
That woman is part of the problem, not the solution
Women on policy recommendations is a disaster for Australia.
@@Antechynus I wouldn't say that but there are certain people in parliament that aren't doing stuff in the best interest of our country or our people, little less our futures in a true and honest sense
Just about every facebook group brainfart, nanny state, fringe minority benefiting, revenue wasting, freedom limiting, impossible to implement policy idea and legislation gets its start with panels like this. Feelings and wokeness have no place in government. Therefore, ladies out.
@user-qo5kt2ux5o tried to reply but yt and its pissweak safe space language police doesn't even allow the polite discussion of ideas.
She can’t come out and just say it!!
“ It’s a rort”.
Keep going Malcolm 💪
She has her and her buddies snout buried deep in the trough at the taxpayer's expense.
She's an extremely divissive person - she needs to be sacked ✌🏼
She is a bureaucratic thief.
$490 Billion or half a Trillion dollars for 2% of the population.
Sack the lot
Having lived in aboriginal regions, I believe the closing the gap is pointless and useless. Just another wasted taxpayer money grab
how it can be useless if some people get real use of it? At least salaries, but business profits from budget money are much sweeter!
This minister being asked the question is part of the problem. Keep that money flowing to fill the pockets of elites from the people.
She is the problem.
Give the people the audit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Exactly she's in business of maintaining the gap for profit.
She is the problem.
And is happy to be on the payroll.
race grifters abound .bring on the audits she has a cheek calling sen roberts patronising ,way out of her depth
The Aboriginal industry grows richer and richer yet don’t care enough about their own disadvantaged people and communities.
Grifters get very angry when their grift is exposed, especially Govt grifters.
She is still bitter and twisted because the Voice referendum was defeated and she didn't receive more power and glory from the Voice!!
The chairwoman is a Labor stooge 😢
Malcolm Roberts you legend! Keep hammering these labour losers & exposing the aboriginal industry. It's disgusting!
Well done Sen Roberts for calling out the grift that is the aboriginal grievance industry.
If these people have nothing to hide and are proud of their performance then they would welcome the Audit .
all of these tax payer funded bodies.
She is a waste of our money, just like closing the gap.
Are these women Smart enough to govern if they can't follow his excellent questions🤔
Obfuscation.
They don't want to answer...
that is the reason for = the GAP !
Horribly incompetent and out of depth.... 90% of women in government.
Nobody may question these people. Her open disdain is a huge part of the problem.
The money has gone to the hair salon girls by the looks
Curly red haired abbo ....
😂😂😂😂
Pemulwuy would be impressed !
We are pissed off the gap has gotten wider my mum has some Aboriginal blood and my step dad is Aboriginal and he said closing the gap is a scam for people to abuse the system. They are not helping they are just getting rich.
Been going on since 80s.
The great thing is your mum, stepdad and you are fully aware of this and many many many more are becoming aware of it. The Dark is coming into the Light about this corrupt industry. 🤗
Sadly nothing will change for another 20 years.
Not if we keep voting for the Magor partys shooters fishers and hunter's party and one nation are the only way out
I'm not going to answer because you're correct and your question is patronising.
Free money hunters
AUDIT Land Councils NOW!!!!
$540 million spent on the voice failure……..
I don't know about Sen.Roberts but my blood pressure was peaking at this display of bs from prominent Voice activist Mccarthy & that useless Chair. My sympathies,Sen.Roberts.
All aboriginal agencies and funding must cease and the 50+ billion dollars per year spent on all Australians in health, education and infostructure, all mining royalties should be shared equally among all Australians and native title abolished.
lol we have all been asleep at the wheel and that brick wall is closer than we think. The lucky country has slowly silently been taken over bit by bit from within by our very own thinking there doing a great job/service for there country. My grandparents fought for this land. The only Gap is between their ear's and watching this makes me sick this con has been going on way to long with No accountability for everyone to see.I really believe we are in for serious changes ahead with No Opt-Out option if we don't take a stand. Look into National Strike Australia.
Buckle-up the shit show has not ended.
I only replied because it made me laugh lol!!! You would've loved talking with this couple in their late 30's Sat night on the V/line journey home.
She likes it just the way it is!
I work in far north remote Australia and you are SPOT ON, thousands of people taking money form themselves and not the end user
I've seen millions wasted on freeloaders sucking it up .
Room full of woke senators
You are never gonna close any gap because of the elephant in the room people are not allowed to acknowledge: most meaningful gaps are based on preferences and biological differences, which are substantial, and not discrimination.
garbage = it is their action`s and behavior that is a problem !
She is a big lady but I wouldn't call her an elephant.
The grievance industry is HUGE business and none of the grifters involved in it ever want to see it end. Perpetual failure is its MO.
Could the chair just shut up.
Every dollar spent across the government should be audited regardless of where it’s going. You can gauge its effectiveness and whether there is a better approach or cost savings that can be used in other areas. Only people who are doing the wrong thing push back against audits
Before she self identified as a traditional Aboriginal, she used to be a public servant
called Barbara.
A white public servant called Barbara.
Curly red hair .... hmmmmm
McCarthy & the rest of them all working together to stop Senator Roberts asking relevant questions. AUDIT needed ASAP
You're outstanding, Senator. We appreciate you. It says a lot about their characters when they can't give you the same respect you give to them.❤
They are trying to block him questioning these ministers at every opportunity so they can avoid answering . We want these questions answered.
if they gave that money directly to the people who need it the gap would be closed
Exactly. It’s about $40000 per person - children, teenagers, work age, elderly , males and female. Let them have autonomous control. Take the money from the myriad ‘organisations and agencies’ where-in there is the corruption.
The bottle shop would be very viable.
@@derekmottley3656 Choice. Gap closed.
This woman has gotten soo much money for decades and the gap still isn't closing yet getting wider by making her richer so we can get the blame for not closing the gap. What is she doing.
Why does the chair keep interjecting? Let the man speak!!
Because she is a Leftest.
Disrupt the flow!
The same problem in Canada, billions of dollars being spent. With little to non result.
Good one. They get prickly when ratios of inclusion are pointed out.
He is 100% correct. If we close the 'gap' this billion dollar industry will disappear. There are people with vested interests to keep that gap wide open. It's the same as the DV industry. There's no benefit to ending it for these people who financially benefit from it.
The gap she references it's pointing out his questions are valid and respectful
We know the problem. The gap won't be closed while authorities work to keep it wide and keep it funded. Senator Price knows the truth. She is a champion of the aboriginal people, the real ones.
The massive black hole gets deeper and deeper. This is outrageous. The whole Bureaucracy needs Shutting Down.
All of this funding is creating so much division, and it's all done by governments and NGOs and activists.
Money laundering.
Audits are not the answer. In Moree NSW, the aboriginal villages housing was repeatedly vandalised by the inhabitants, then repeatedly repaired and refurbished by taxpayers' funds. In Bowen, housing was not distributed fairly within the ATSI community. Choice houses going to elders and their relatives, rather than families on waiting lists.
Good on you Malcolm !!!!!
The aboriginal industry, like health, education etc in this country is not made to actually help people on the ground. It only keeps others in a style of life we can only dream of. . . . Except we strive for morals, ethics and an actual want to help people.
It's a business opportunity.
@@briananderson7285 Absolutely agree.
Helps those that get gifted top non jobs that pay high 6 figures.
Closing the gap, what gap? Aboriginals have more support and rights than most white Australians.
More rights than all white Australians. Australia is a very racist country against whites.
So she's asking the questions & refusing to answer any.
We're so special (& over-funded) that we can't be asked ANY pertinent questions that may put said ongoing funding at risk)! 🤯
How much are we paying these muppets? Senator Robert’s is the only one earning his pay check
The 'gap' will never be closed, no matter how many billions are used? wasted on a race of people who don't want to help themselves.
I feel very sorry for Malcolm Roberts having to ask this person questions. She is so obnoxious.
She was an ABC news reader in Darwin when I came to Australia 27 years ago, but in those days she was called Barbara and had a posh ABC accent.
Vote ONE NATION . Australia 🇦🇺 needs a senate full of Senate Roberts
Aboriginals need to realise and accept that this is no longer aboriginal land , this is Australia , this country belongs to everyone!!🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺
Why is it the only thing that can preserve aboriginal culture and heritage is huge amounts of money and land ! There are way to many bodies be it private and public that do not want to close the gap because they obviously see it as a cash cow which they want to milk forever !
Bingo.......
She is a thief and liar
Spot on there are many people that won’t have a job if Aboriginal person receive the support they need.
Criminal, where are the billions and billions going for these comunities. Why are there no Audits on this, what are they hiding...
Why? Kos they won’t do an audit and accountability.
Good on you Senator...we have to TRY to keep everyone ac ountable!
Red and Black , colours of evil
Thank you
The biggest problem I see in the political theatre today is the lack of respect shown across political lines, the elected officials in that room represents thousands/millions of Australian people, voters feel that senator should speak for them, and when they no longer feel that way a new senator is elected. When these senators ask questions they should be responded to, not as a personal point of view but as the words of the Australian people, questions that need to be answered not dismissed. Truth and effectiveness need not hide.
Native Anglo Australians need a voice, how about some bodies and charities to represent them.
Up until 1973, Australia was an explicitly Anglo Celtic endeavour.
Antipodean browns weren't considered Australian until 1948.
We don't need their "Dancers and Artists"
@@muzzer0181 No one was considered Australian until 1948 they were British subjects.
@@muzzer0181 More sensible times. Pre Australians should have been left alone. Now identity politics needs to go further with tax spending only going to the group you identify with.
100% right, people don’t want words and empty promises; it won’t change while the elites are filling their pockets. After working in this area for 10 years it has only gotten worse.
Productive people, singing, dancing, painting etc ...
So in the spirit of closing gaps, can I stop working and get as much money as a CEO? No reason to discriminate against me, as a laziness-afflicted person. After all, all gaps are due to discrimination, right? There are no other factors to consider whatsoever.
To many woke and disgruntled to get anything exciting today for Australia today😅
Yes, Aboriginals have a lot of representation in gov't without the Voice, wasting billions taxpayer money
At 1.45 when interupted by the chair i think most of us new what the question was. To keep throwing money that comes from tax payers, at closing the gap, without any minor or significant result is insanity! Call for an audit!
Ordinary everyday Australians care about Aboriginal communitys, and with Billions of Dollars being spent We still see No Advancement of Aboriginal Progress, It would seem that the Women running the expenditure of that money are Incapable of doing the Right things. And, The Female Chair Isnt Helping.
What is the matter with the chairwoman? OMG! What a harridan