Why They Were Disqualified from the Big Rock Blue Marlin Tournament

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 105

  • @mosesmike4117
    @mosesmike4117 Рік тому +5

    to clarify the first boat to bring in a 500 pound or better marlin wins the bonus money of over 700 thousand dollars. since no boat won the bonus it rolls over to next year and the first boat to bring in a marlin over 500 pounds wins over 1.5 million dollars.

  • @bobbynewton9247
    @bobbynewton9247 Рік тому +3

    Thanks for the update Dieter sounds like alot going on!! God Bless my friend

  • @DB-zp9un
    @DB-zp9un Рік тому +17

    I personally think the review was basically to get the crowd dispersed. If they would have announced that night the DQ they probably would have had a riot.. There was a HUGE crowd there.

    • @jdbyrd84
      @jdbyrd84 Рік тому

      I ABSOLUTELY agree...they would have a mess to deal with.

    • @Zupstruck
      @Zupstruck 6 місяців тому

      I was there and the crowd was mad

  • @jeffreyneely9283
    @jeffreyneely9283 Рік тому +5

    Wow that's gotta hurt ,that kind of money is no joke..thanks for your video Dieter . Enjoyed watching..

  • @DrSlipstream
    @DrSlipstream Рік тому +7

    Something to note on the "rich people" thing: the Sensation team sold shares on the team, about 35 of them. Anyone competing with the crew had to buy a share, each worth about $102k if that fish hadn't been disqualified. I know several of the guys fishing on that team were just regular blue-collar dudes that stood to win life-changing money from that fish.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +5

      ….and there are guys in single engine outboards that enter a single division for $2500.
      But, when much of the fleet is comprised of million dollar boats, some $10 million plus, and Michael Jordan flies in on his private jet to fish, its really honestly a rich man’s game.

    • @eddiemadden318
      @eddiemadden318 Рік тому +1

      3 mill ain't life changing no more

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +2

      @@eddiemadden318 for one person it may be, but split amongst 20 people, not so much.

    • @douggiedevil
      @douggiedevil Рік тому +2

      @eddiemadden318 if you can’t say 100k US (a share) at any age south of 50 changed your life you either blew it away or you had enough to begin with, 100k down on a mortgage early on would take 10 years of almost any mortgage,

    • @eddiemadden318
      @eddiemadden318 Рік тому

      @@douggiedevil that's not life changing.

  • @a.p.5429
    @a.p.5429 Рік тому +2

    Thanks for the complete info.

  • @InbredJed82060
    @InbredJed82060 Рік тому +6

    Youre bringing interest and knowledge to alot of people like myself who would have never heard of things like this. Really neat story

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +1

      Thanks for taking the time to watch, comment and offer some feedback!

  • @darkskater107
    @darkskater107 Рік тому +3

    Yep went to lawsuit. Was announced earlier. I don't think it will hold up. Rules are pretty well written. Pretty much all saltwater tournaments don't allow you to weigh a fish that has been bitten by a shark. Lots of king mackerel tournaments have had winning fish that a 1/3rd of it is missing but they don't count.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +1

      I hate it for the crew, but that stuff happens. Pretty sure this fish was dead before the shark got to it….

    • @mattengle7385
      @mattengle7385 Рік тому

      The one thing that sensation has them on is the tournament is not an IGFA sanctioned tourtament so there rules should not apply cause it not written into big rock’s rules!

  • @dmalloy96
    @dmalloy96 Рік тому +1

    That’s a crazy story thanks for sharing it

  • @mikebrown9418
    @mikebrown9418 Рік тому +1

    Just found your TikTok bud love your content

  • @scottgautier1373
    @scottgautier1373 Рік тому

    $793,500 bonus for the FIRST marlin 500 pounds or over to be weighed in at the tournament. Sensation had the first one to be weighed in, that's why they were eligible for it. If another boat had landed one that was 500 or above, and weighed it in before the Sensation, they would have won the bonus money. Just wanted to clarify that.

  • @eddelapena367
    @eddelapena367 Рік тому +4

    With the amount of money trying to win. There should be officials on each boat. With a video recorder while fish is on!! Just my perspective. Sounds like a rules needs to be updated or redone.

    • @striperjunkie
      @striperjunkie Рік тому

      their on the boat as well as they forced them to have go pros covering the entire boat and also they have to turn in their GPS cards each day they fish. amazing that they go to great lengths to make people be held accountable but dont want themselves to be held to the same standard.

  • @johnhoard2802
    @johnhoard2802 Рік тому +1

    Every participant on every boat understood and agrees with the rules.

    • @patrickseay1544
      @patrickseay1544 Рік тому

      Then why are they going to court?

    • @whistleemupfishing9573
      @whistleemupfishing9573 Рік тому

      ​@@patrickseay1544 because rich white people do not think rules apply to them.....thats the only reason

  • @chrisclary5595
    @chrisclary5595 Рік тому +2

    I wished the biologist would have identified the shark bite because that shark would have a bounty on it. So sad for the crew.

  • @evilgibson
    @evilgibson Рік тому +1

    I have caught the largest bluefin tuna!
    Just a little damaged. Wheres my money?

  • @ray1068
    @ray1068 Рік тому +3

    Hey Dieter, you mentioned if that people that join your UA-cam channel have some gifts coming their way. I have been subscribed for a little while but have not received anything. Just checking if I maybe have something coming. Thank you for putting out such an interesting channel. Hope to hear from you.

    • @InbredJed82060
      @InbredJed82060 Рік тому +2

      Joining the channel is $9.99 per month. He is sending those people something.
      He has 90k subscribers. If he sent something to each subscriber, that would cost him over $1 Million

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +1

      It's for channel members, which is different from subscribers. If you click the "JOIN" button you can learn more.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      That would be correct sir....

    • @ray1068
      @ray1068 Рік тому +2

      Sorry for my confusion. I do think you have a very good channel.

    • @yoshisaidit7250
      @yoshisaidit7250 Рік тому

      @@ray1068 He gives out a Demon Dragon painted by himself. Glitter and all.

  • @jonathanfeltman4362
    @jonathanfeltman4362 Рік тому

    I don't know if it's true or not but I heard that damaged fish had been excepted before and the rules have not been equally applied

  • @davidwoolsey2135
    @davidwoolsey2135 Рік тому +4

    This is pretty silly when an "act of God" makes the fish easier to boat, but the rules don't allow for that. Sure, they don't want competitors doing something like shooting a fish to make it easier to boat, but that's a deliberate, man made event, with a set objective. Unless they can show how the folks in the boat caused the shark to strike the fish, or how they caused the fish to get a tail wrap and expire..., this should be a court victory for the boat, not the Association. (imho)

  • @papilloncycles3463
    @papilloncycles3463 Рік тому +1

    Well I hope they could keep the meat from that guy or get a mount made? Do you know how that works when a fish is held over for inspection, is the fish still able to be kept and divided among the party?

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      These guys don't eat these fish....they end up in a dumpster or at hog farm.

    • @papilloncycles3463
      @papilloncycles3463 Рік тому

      @@DieterMelhorn Wow! I would think that a billfish steak would be really prized like a swordfish!

    • @eastcoastlocal8536
      @eastcoastlocal8536 Рік тому +1

      You can't eat marlin. The mercury content is too high. The marlin goes to I believe UNC(or to the Duke research center in Beaufort)right beside the DMF in Morehead City for research.

    • @papilloncycles3463
      @papilloncycles3463 Рік тому +1

      @@eastcoastlocal8536 Ok makes sense I guess a fish that big, top predator accumulates a lot of that in its life.

    • @a180combatbowsergamepro6
      @a180combatbowsergamepro6 6 місяців тому

      How the heck does it have mercury in it​@@eastcoastlocal8536

  • @fishinwiththegriffins7304
    @fishinwiththegriffins7304 Рік тому +2

    No sound on the video

  • @KickenChickenNetwork
    @KickenChickenNetwork Рік тому +2

    Good morning from KY

  • @davidwills8803
    @davidwills8803 Рік тому +1

    One would think with that much on the line. They would have someone on board video tapping the the catch the whole time.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      Every catch has video of it. This one did too……

  • @DB-zp9un
    @DB-zp9un Рік тому +2

    You said the 750k for the over 500# and winning. Has nothing to do with winning or losing, just the first fish over 500#.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +2

      I'm telling ya, Capt. McCoy is gonna kill every shark he brings to the side of the boat from now on....LOL!!

    • @DB-zp9un
      @DB-zp9un Рік тому

      @@DieterMelhorn Gotta pay the taxman

  • @Zaaxun
    @Zaaxun Рік тому +2

    Man I'd be on suicide watch if I lost that much money over a couple shark nibbles.
    What a collosal bummer.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      Well, if it makes you feel any better, they never really “had” $3 million….LOL!

  • @securityofficer9483
    @securityofficer9483 Рік тому +5

    What a dumb rule. How you supposed to stop a shark from biting your fish 😂😂😂

    • @striperjunkie
      @striperjunkie Рік тому

      no whats even crazier is that they even said that if the fish is damaged beyond control AFTER you catch it then its still a legal fish to weigh in. so in other works cut the fish in half and yes you can weigh that fish but a fish bite not a chance. this rule makes people move away from supporting tournaments like this and they keep trying to make it harder every year. the big rock had a lot of people mad when they cut the live feed. little did they know that the local news was live streaming and they left theirs up so everyone could watch what happens.

    • @mrcommonsense9074
      @mrcommonsense9074 Рік тому

      Wow that is a stupid rule Any idea why this rule would be in place ? Even a little bit ?

    • @striperjunkie
      @striperjunkie Рік тому

      @@mrcommonsense9074 the IGFA has that rule and its wide open to opinion on what is allowed and what is not allowed. the problem is they want to judge it on a case by case basis. in other words if we dont like what we see then not allowed. but if we like what we see then allowed.

  • @allenpoborac9924
    @allenpoborac9924 Рік тому +4

    That's the TAXMAN!

  • @connor.....
    @connor..... Рік тому +1

    This call really sucks for the crew of the sensation, they had no control over the sharks or any other marine animals. Congrats to the crew of the sushi tho. (Little side note, the new Big Rock tournament record it 914lbs. Caught by the crew of the Top Dog in 2019)

    • @ennisking6764
      @ennisking6764 Рік тому +1

      You don't understand the rule obviously! A fish is considered an easier catch if it's reeled in injured or dead. Rule makes everyone earn their fight/catch. It has to be absolute w/ no waivering.

    • @TheMcLeanster
      @TheMcLeanster Рік тому +1

      @@ennisking6764 so exactly what did connor(original post) say that was inaccurate to the point where you formed the opinion that he "doesn't understand the rules, obviously"?

    • @connor.....
      @connor..... Рік тому

      @@ennisking6764 Im aware that its a rule dude. Chill out. All i said was that the call/rule sucks for the crew of the sensation.

  • @sanitymaintenance1585
    @sanitymaintenance1585 Рік тому +1

    Any person that gets a fish back from a shark and you get 80% of it ??? That's Sweet !!! To me that should count !!! Has anyone gaffed a fish wile 3 to 5 sharks were after it and hitting it ??? We had one year thing got so bad that we gaffed the shark ( Gaffing a shark is hard ) so we could gaff the fish ... Cheers from Murrell's Inlet SC

  • @cindybriggs2604
    @cindybriggs2604 Рік тому +2

    My neighbor was on the boat tjat ultimately won. He was on the sushi

  • @Randymcsendy
    @Randymcsendy Рік тому +1

    The way it was written sensation lost BUT this rule needs to be changed. Shark populations are now unchecked with the commercial fishing for them being shut down. This will only get more common. Also there are a lot of normal folks fishing in this. It’s also a matter of pride. First the folks want a NC boat to win then they want their port. There’s definitely some competition within competition between the Wilmington morehead city and hatteras fleets.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому +1

      I think the rule is somewhat silly, though I I understand the intent.
      If you think the rule is important, then any fish brought to the side of the boat dead (drowned) should be DQ’d…..

  • @ChristopherEuliss-pm8mf
    @ChristopherEuliss-pm8mf 6 місяців тому

    One more thing: the Big Rock is not a IGFA sanctioned tournament!... they have their own rules, and a lot which is not IGFA. 🤷‍♂️.
    It's turned into a spectacle for publicity & sponsors like the superbowl. They need to get together and establish their rules and apply em! If it's not in their rules submitted to all anglers in writing, then it shouldn't be effective!

  • @eddiemadden318
    @eddiemadden318 Рік тому

    Could you buy fishing licenses online in 2010?

  • @rolandvance6663
    @rolandvance6663 Рік тому +2

    So what about all that money ?

    • @eastcoastlocal8536
      @eastcoastlocal8536 Рік тому +2

      A boat won 1st place. The Fabulous Fisherman category will roll over to next year's tournament.

  • @ropedb
    @ropedb Рік тому

    Common sense is whats needed and we aint got any of that left in this world.

  • @spencerfallin1682
    @spencerfallin1682 Рік тому +2

    While this guy means well and is trying to make content. There are several facts in this video that are incorrect. Not enough research was done before making this and posting it. The rule in question does focus on mutilation but has nothing to do with altering the weight of a fish. And the standard has to be set for all shark bites. All though this fish maybe didn’t die from its injuries. It has to be judged fairly because of tournaments goin forward. More research needs to be done

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      I think the fish was dead way before the shark got to it. 6+ hours to reel in a fish that size, on that tackle, usually means it’s dead.
      There is video somewhere of that fish being leadered and brought aboard….that would tell a lot about that what really happened…😉

  • @americanfreedom1016
    @americanfreedom1016 Рік тому +1

    Can't stop sharks and other bigger fish from biting the marlin....so there fish is disqualified for something they have no control over...who cares if a shark took a bite of the marlin it's about how much the marlins weighs so losing a piece of marlin only makes the marlin weigh less...but should still count

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      The intent of the rule is to prevent people from just reeling a dead fish that is not capable of fighting.
      With that said, I think they should do away with the rule….

  • @keithdennis5085
    @keithdennis5085 Рік тому +1

    'Hope you had a wonderful Father's Day! Interesting story; sounds like the kind of luck I would have, if I were that calibur of a high roller.

  • @ChristopherEuliss-pm8mf
    @ChristopherEuliss-pm8mf 6 місяців тому

    Let's hope it doesn't happen again! 6hrs is a long haul to be disqualified. And the across the board fishing gives anglers a reason not to target 1 big fish. There's so many options to catch & release smaller fish and target other species. 🤔... when a dolphin can net a boat 400,000 plus dollars.. it kinda gives boats other options to make money I guess. But the angler has no control over shark bites.. it's sad😪....

  • @badkarma2202
    @badkarma2202 Рік тому

    They should still get the money. Any angler knows when a hooked fish is on the line sharks come for free food. They should not have been DQ!

  • @waterdad711
    @waterdad711 Рік тому +1

    I would sue!
    This tournament has lost all credibility.
    They are as bad as the Walleye cheaters. Killbigrock

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      It’s Apple as an oranges compared to the walleye tournament….

    • @waterdad711
      @waterdad711 Рік тому

      @@DieterMelhorn to me this is way worse. This is a dishonest tournament committee and director! Not dishonest fishermen. This is the Bud Light of tournaments now. #bigrockbudlight

  • @Impozalla
    @Impozalla Рік тому +1

    Unfortunately the Marlin was killed by the shark before the fishermen were able to get their hand on it. They cannot claim the work of nature as theirs. There was no evidence that the fishermen hooked the fish to begin with. They couldn't provide video evidence of the catch. Experts have concluded that the fisherman most likely lied to have caught the fish. But what is more importantly is that the fishermen agree to the terms and conditions of the rule prior to entering this fishing tournament. So it is pretty pathetic for them to now contest the rules. No...

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      “…no evidence that fishermen hooked the fish to begin with….”…..where did you hear this?

    • @gunnarstumpe7189
      @gunnarstumpe7189 Рік тому +1

      Just curious where you get that information from? I live there, was there and haven't heard that at all.

    • @DieterMelhorn
      @DieterMelhorn  Рік тому

      @@gunnarstumpe7189 I'm curious about that too.....

  • @nickallen9583
    @nickallen9583 Рік тому +2

    I was 14 fishing out of Organ inlet we hooked up with a blue marlin at the point I was in the chair my dad handed me the rod for 14 I thought I was reeling in a VW my dad held the rod my brother held the fighting chair to keep it from turning after about an hour he sounded because he got tail wrapped end result he drowned crancking my heart out dead weight streight up for another 1 hr and half finally the leader then the shark NOTHING YOU CAN DO out of your control I'm now 67 my opinion and you know what they say about opinions those guys busted their asses to get that fish to the boat in the boat and back to the dock THEY GOT SCREWED oh yeah my fish weighed 350 big for 14 years old .