Lawyer ANGRY at Full COURT | 'Aap Sab Sabar Karein' | Shocking Scenes From Supreme Court
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лют 2025
- A full court bench headed by Chief Justice Qazi Faez Isa is hearing the review petitions [clubbed together] against the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act, 2023 - a legislation introduced by the former coalition government.
This is the first time in country's history that the hearing in a case is being live telecast.
In this way, the new chief justice will hear one of the most important cases currently pending with the Supreme Court on his very first working day.
Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa is presiding over the full court on the first court day. The 15-member full court headed by Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa also comprised Justice Sardar Tariq Masood, Justice Ijazul Ahsan, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah, Justice Muneeb Akhtar, Justice Yahya Afridi, Justice Aminuddin Khan, Justice Mazahir Ali Akbar Naqvi, Justice Jamal Khan Mandukhel, Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar, Justice Ayesha Malik, Justice Athar Minallah, Justice Hasan Azhar Rizvi, Justice Shahid Waheed and Justice Musarrat Hilali.
Earlier, the Supreme Court approved the petitions to constitute a full court on appeals against the SC Practice and Procedure Act in the Supreme Court.
The federal government requested the apex court to reject petitions against the Supreme Court Practice and Procedure Act. The federal government, taking a stand, requested that the petitions against the Act of the Parliament were inadmissible, so theses should be dismissed.
The federal government submitted its written response in the case through the attorney general, in which the federal government requested to reject petitions against the Act.
According to government reply, Parliament was empowered to legislate under Article 191 of the Constitution and Article 191 did not prevent Parliament from making laws.
It was stated in the reply that the independence of the judiciary was not affected by the said Act and no power had been withdrawn from the Supreme Court under the Act. It further said that petitions against the Parliament Act were inadmissible even on merit.
As the hearing started, Khawaja Tariq Rahim started presenting arguments. Justice Ayesha Malik remarked that the right to appeal had been given in Section 5 of the Act in question.
“If we decide the case on the full court and declare the law correct, how the appeal would be made against it?, she asked.
The Chief Justice remarked that 57,000 cases of the people were awaiting justice.
Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhel remarked that Khawaja Rahim should read Article 191. Kh Rahim said the power to regulate the court belongs to the Supreme Court under the Federal Legislative List Schedule.
The Chief Justice said that the Supreme Court had its own authority to regulate its powers. “Are you saying that 1989 rules are in conflict with the Constitution?, The CJP asked to the counsel.
Khawaja Rahim said the rules of 1980 were framed by the full court and those rules were correct. The chief justice remarked that he should not talk about the future and limit his arguments to the present.
The CJP said if the legislation was enacted in the future, he could challenge it again. Justice Muneeb Akhtar questioned that allowing the thee-member committee to have the power of clause 3 of Article 184, was a judicial power or an administrative one.
Justice Muneeb raised the question that if there was administrative authority, had the parliament abolished judicial authority?
It should be remembered that the eight-member bench of the Supreme Court had stopped implementation of the Practice and Procedure Act on April 13.
The Supreme Court Practice and Procedure Act deals with distribution of powers of the Chief Justice in cases of public interest. According to the Act, the decision to take suo motu notice will be taken by the chief justice and a committee consisting of two senior judges.
The Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act, 2023 has curbed the chief justice’s powers to take suo motu in individual capacity and vested the same to a three-member committee comprising the chief justice and the next two most senior judges.
Moreover, the legislation also says that the three-member committee would also responsible for constituting benches to handle cases with the majority vote being the mode of making a decision in case there is a disagreement.
Last month, Justice Mansoor Ali Shah suggested that the chief justice should halt proceedings of cases instituted under Article 184(3) of the Constitution, until a final decision on the fate of the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act, 2023.
His remarks were part of the two-page note he issued during the hearing of a petition filed by the PTI chairman challenging the amendments in the NAB laws.
#supremecourt #qazifaezisa #fullcourt
Qazi sahib great
bunch of jokers
Essa sb very good
گیم فکس ھے یہ سب ڈرامہ ھے
Qazi Faiz EssaSahib ZindaBaad 👍
A VERY GOOD
COLLECTIVE
GATHERING OF
THE HONOURABLE
JUDGES.
------------- ---- --- --
BUT HOW A LEARNED
ADVOCATE---
CAN SPEAK BEFORE
THE --- 15--'
DIGNIFIED JUDGES. ????
Essa sb v good
If. The judges are not silent they are bhonkey and hungry
Too many cooks (crooks) spoil the broth
Wakeelon ko sahi thoka hai..faiz esa..love u
We stand with Imran Khan
may Allahs curse be with you
Itna mulk ki awam k sath sachay hoty to itne case pending na hoty
THE NATION
WILL APPRECIATE
IMPARTIAL JUSTICE..
Very sad. Cjp is not allowing sir Imtiaz to argue
Sir Imtiaz 😂😂😂😂 He has no Legal answer.
Lawer is absolutely right chief justice has already made up his mind he is acting as a teacher
Lawyer
Chief justice is making mockery of justice he is not allowing advocate to argue the case
Because Lawyer is Bulshiting
Now, people will stop watching "Dramas" as this new drama which is being played in the supreme court is much more fascinating..
KIA YE PAKISTANI SUPREME COURT HEY KARVAIE `URDU MAIN HONI CHAHIE
Wakeel ko to bolny nai dy rahy ye 15 judge. Ek rukta to dosra shuro ho jata.
Wakeel sb koyi daleel bi dyn khiali plao na pkaen Wakeel sb KY pas argument Hai hi nayi hr juj keh raa hai ayen ki shiq btaen wo Wakeel ko a nyi ryi. Hr bat me politic ko na ly Aya karen
The one judge doesn’t want to allow the justice system work properly as he is constantly provoking.
A new drama create only for nawaz sharifs jst look the judges to protect shariff
Looks big geo darama 😂😂😂😂
❤
😂😂 worst judicttiory system they didn't even translate the laws in their own national language in 75 years 😂
اردو ہماری قومی زبان ھے لیکن غلامی کی وجہ سے جیف جسٹس تک کو بھی انگلش بولنا پڑھتی ہے- افسوس صد افسوس۔ پھر کہتے ھیں ہم آزاد ھیں
Impressed with justice Muneeb Akhtar observations .
Hounoable Judges khud he sb discussion kr rahay hain ye sb Becharay Wakeel ko bonay ka moqa he nhe de rahay... Honourable Chief Jucetice sahib kehtay hain keh unhon ke Constituiton of Pakistan ka halaf uthaya hai.... Aray bhai Wakeel Sahib bhe yahi keh rahay hain keh Constituition allow nhe karta Parliment ko keh wo Supreme Court k internal matters main interfere kray .... than how parliment can do this without constituition amendment .....
Why on earth judges are in so much hurry and keep interupting.
In any civilised conversation, you listen and then speak. Really disappointed the manner in which this whole proceeding is taking place.
Faisla to aaj hi suna dia gia hay 😂simple law is Superior than Constitution 😂😢
It is very clear that faiz esa is inclined on one side
Like the previous was...If they are human it would be
ur aami jaan fuda side
pehla muqaddma hai jo judge aapas main lar rahay hain
اللہ پاک جو جو میرے اس ملک کے ساتھ غداری کر رہا ہے عوام کو بیوقوف بنا رہا ہے یا اللہ اس کی نسلوں کو تباہ کر امین
Ameen inshallah
Essa sb ki any se achy faisly hon ghien
inshallah
اُردو 😢ہماری قومی زبان 😢ہماری بربادی ادھر سے شروع ہوتی ہے 😢 پلیز اردو میں
That is right. Unfortunately these judges be they from any party are in heavy complex of proving that English language and culture is much superior than Pakistani national language and culture. It is shame.
Are they talking about Nawaz Sharif. What kind of Youthiapa u people have? Its case of Parliament n Supreme Court Legal authority.
ایک وکیل نے پندرہ ججوں کو گھما کر رکھ دیا
We need Justices like Justice Muneeb Akhtar, Ijaz Ul Ahsan& Aisha Malik❤❤❤
Why u forgot Bandyal,,, Saqib Nasoor. ASIF KHOTA,,, ETC. IMRANDOO Lawyers. 😂
یہ سارے باتیں اردو میں ہونی چاہیے
اے پاکستان کی عوام اس فل کورٹ سیشن کو دیکھیں 15 جج ایک طرف تابڑ توڑ سوال کریں اور اکیلا وکیل کس طرح اس کا صحیح جواب دے سکتا ھے انہوں نے طے کیا ہوا تھا کہ وکیل کو بولنے نہیں دیا جائے گا اور وہی ہوا وکیل بے چارہ ھے اور بے چارہ ہی رھے گا کیونکہ یہ سب کے سب 15 فل کورٹ کے جج اس کو بولنے نہیں دیں گے
kyun wo wakeel teri baji ka yar hai
Juj sb ny bohat acha faisla kiya kio KY awam ko bi pta chly KY hr ghndh KY pichy kis ka hath Hai. Political soch sy bahir nikl KY daikhyn gy to ye judgment bohat achi lgy gi
Supreme court is Super Pawer.
Beshumaaaaaar judge aur mulk my phir b aain ni
عیسیٰ فائز نواز شریف کے لیے راستہ ہموار کر رہا ہے ۔ اللّہ پاک پاکستان کے عوام کی حفاظت فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین عمران خان زندہ باد
Right ✅️
Issue shouldn’t be power of CJ but appeal rights after one appeal is already used.
پاکستان میں جنگل کا قانون ہے اور اللہ تعالیٰ پاکستان کے عوام کی حفاظت فرمائے آمین یارب العالمین عمران خان زندہ باد
Loota"C +" Sirpanch....?
I have a great respect for new CJ of Pakistan but is it not a violation of the Constitution of Pakistan which clearly says that Urdu Language is the National language of Pakistan which must be used in all institutions of Pakistan including the Judiciary of Pakistan? Unfortunately, most high officials of all institutions of Pakistan are not only liberal and in heavy complex for Western language and culture but also love to see their family members especially their kids to use Western language as their mother language. The only difference between the slavery of pre partition and post partition is that we were physical slaves before and now we are mental slaves of our eternal masters.
" کہڑیاں قصائیاں وچ بھڈ مردار" کوئی فائیدہ نہیں بلکہ انصاف پہلے سے بھی زیادہ مہنگا ہوگیا😮😮😮😮
Chiaf sahib ka matlab hy jo wo keh rahy hn wo he ap bhe bolyn mind bana howa hy Nawaz sharif ko jo saza hoi hy us ko review karna hybus simple parlemant jo qanoon banayi hy ya jo ayin mn likha hy us ki interpretation supreme court karti hy or us qanoon ko dekhti hy ky is ky pechay neyat kiya hy
100% agree
aap ki pan da fuda
Justice Qazi faiz isa ki right side wale judge ka kia name hai
عمران خان عمران خان عمران خان بس عمران خان 💪
This can beat our dramas and daily talk shows and some extent morning shows. A clear threat to entertainment industry.
Full bench is created and yet judges expect that case should be resolved in very next minute. 80% of time is consumed by Judges. This is absurd.
Why are they all yupping English for
Headlines Mistake in Urdu " Mujay bol to do". Correct: "Mujay Bolney to denh". 😳😳😱😱
Our country language is urdu but unfortunately here is English. Pakistani logo ko tu nahi pta yh bol kiya rhy hin i think uk ya usa main rahny walo ko smjya ja ra ha
Pakistani logo ko pata be neh chalna chahey k yhaan kia ho reha hey?? Un ko auqaat hey be neh.
@@tughral😂😂😂
Qazi sab lower ko bolnain dain ap insaaf k liy aya hain iss mulk pr reham krain
Teri Baji k mammon par reham karen
Lawyers ki to achi khaasi rolty hen court me. Achy khaasy bandy k paseeny choot jaen.
What a joke thus judiciary is. This is the reason why we hav a failed state
Are these judges Pakistani
If so why they are speaking English?
Pakistani star plus aa gya achi acting krty hain sary actors lakin director sb ny jo hokam dena ha faisly wohi hon gy
Ijaz ul ahsan aor munib judge nahi karinday hain
Justice munib r ijazul ehsan ko is bench main lena b nhn chaye tha
Insan ki defination bhi khabi discus karen ?
Ye sari exercise Nawaz k liye ho rahi hay baqi awam jain bard main
Unfortunately Chief Justice didn't allow the poor lawyer to argue and establish his point of view
Feel sorry for the lawyer. He tried his best.
Public k lye Kya ha to wo language use krein Jo aam aadmi ko bhe smjh aai
Its in both Urdu and English
@@MREHMAN7865 20 percent urdu bro
@@MREHMAN7865 jb unko uski English khud ko n aati to urdu boltay
Faiz Issa zyada urdu he bol raha hay
Koi Article ho to English men bata kar urdu b translate karta hay
Muneeb Akhtar or Ijaz Ahsan sirf English bol rahey hain
Kya faida is transmission ka jo zuban boli ja rhi hai almost wo Pakistan ki gareeb awan ko smji ati he nai
Quality of selection of the lords by their quality of education is poor... aaj akhri umeed thi wo b hill gaee. Pakistan he yaha esa chalta he Muaaf karna bhai
urdu please
اردوُ کیوں نہیں بولتے یہ جج کیا اس ملک کی قومی زبان انگریزی ہے؟؟؟
Supreme Court's Justices were displaying mannerism of fish market vendors they were posing questions without affording courtesy to lawyers to reply . I suspect village panchayat behaves better while settling disputes.
This is literally a distorted monopoly of judges! They are all attacking the lawyer from different directions and not having the patience to listen to him.
What a show off of power possession! Justice Faiz Isa just revealed everyone his low threshold for being easily irritated. I think this drama should immediately be stopped and judges should concentrate on provision of justice only!
Pakistani dant no englash speek urdu we live in pakistan
The lawyer isn't providing clear and cogent arguments
this lawyer is Hamkhor Bubdiyali Lawyer
یہ جو لوگ بیٹھے ہیں کیا ہیں اور کون ہیں اور کیا کر رہے ہیں اگر کسی کو معلوم ہو تو بتایے کہ الله ﷻ کا قانو ن کہں کھو گیا ہے یہ کس قانون کی بات کر رہے ہیں اور یہ کس کی زبان بول رہے ہیں شکلوں سے کیسے لگ رہے ہیں کس قوم اور امت سے متعلق ہیں کوی تو بتلاو
Angrez k andon urdu bolo.
اردو میں بات کرین
Can I see the ain what is that is it cake for you
Whenever the lawyer makes strong arguments the CJP interrupts and trying to twist and then again asks him to start arguments 😅 bara pistoli hai
Angrezo k aullad kaha sa aa gai Allah pak en ko es dunia ma dekhaye jesy enhone insaf dia awam ko zalim ghulam jaj kharedy hoaeye buzdel jernelo K ghulam jaj
Aisay hi nahi Pakistan tabah ho gaya.
Salon tum USA mai rehty ho urdu mai baji paish kro tanky hr pakistani apki baatein samj saky😈
یہ انگریزی ملک ہے
جسٹس صاحب اردو میں بات کیا کریں
Media show off.. Not letting advocates to speak and then arguing why you're not speaking 😂. Love this advocate Siddiqui 😅
Khosa is self egoistic person.
اردو میں کیوں بات نہیں کرتے