@@texastaurus9271same! This was last September tho. Maybe I'm biased as they're my favorite and I've seen a lot of shows but that was the best fucking show I've ever ever seen.
Why this didn't make the final cut of With Teeth I don't know, it's such a good nine inch nails track dark, moody, energetic full of suspense and excellent synths. Trent you are a genius
Yurp. bugs me to think he must have so many other tracks never finished that we might never hear. The Fragile deviations was alright but too much today NIN influence i felt if that makes sense. Cleaned it up too much, added stuff they didnt add anything (end of starfuckers) o.0
I love so much how many of the lyrics in this song call back to and reference the other songs on With Teeth. It's like a summation of all the concepts on the album. "maze of monochrome" = All The Love In The World "How can I go home?" = Home "Try to stand in line" = The Hand That Feeds "Staring at the sun" = Sunspots Then there are some that more loosely reference lyrics and ideas, such as these: "I'm fading out of sight" = Beside You In Time "Try to obey" = Getting Smaller There are other that are more of a stretch, but you get the idea. Brilliance!
Honestly this feels more like a song that mixes both The Fragile and With Teeth together. This and Deep is what I imagine NIN sounding like if Trent released an album in 2001 or 2002
"The sky is not the same Shade of blue Every single thing I believe isn't true Missing in the maze of monochrome How did I get here? How can I go home? The echoes in my eyes Of all they used to see Burning down the world The ashes and debris And all that's left of me Non-Entity Try to stand in line Try to obey The ghost of what I was Keeps getting in the way Staring at the sun Blinded by the light Now I'm afraid, I'm fading out of sight The echoes in my eyes Of all they used to see Burning down the world The ashes and debris And all that's left of you And all that's left of me All have washed away Non-Entity Source: Musixmatch"
I remember watching Trent play this song live to benefit Hurricane Katrina and I was in actual tears by the end. It felt so personal and was one of the best live performances I've ever seen in my life.
Like Head Down. Mosh pit material - as I was doing just that at the time 19-21. Now at 43 The Beautiful Nightmare (Head Down) is what’s circling me head constantly. Those to Trent made versions are literally diametrically opposite Both have a place
Mr. Reznor's music can be easily categorized into phases of my life and those tracks that aren't filed yet are simply awaiting their turn. So glad he's still at it 30+ yrs later
I think it's the arrangement. It's a good tune at its core, but the arrangement is kinda meh. Solo piano Trent version is by far the best version of this song.
This song is so amazing, dark, moody, eerie, just overall so perfect. Trent Reznor is a phenomenal artist! I would give this song a billion thumbs up if I could.
Four years is not that long; it hardly would’ve made a difference. songs don’t exactly dull over time so much as your mind does when you listen to them
with the 20 year anniversary of with teeth in a little over a year (yes you read that right), i beg for a deluxe deviations with home+RWIBv2+not so pretty now+this on vinyl with robs original bleedthrough artwork. make it so, trent.
how have i not come across this song its one of the best I've ever heard and the lyrics are genius. i swear whatever the higher power is made me come across this right now for how i relate to it.
CaseyA Wheeldon Of his vast catalog the only song i cant stand is "Everything" off of Hesitation. just doesn't do it for me and it feels like he put minimal interest in it
I like that song! I think Trent's a genius of course, but there are some songs I just don't like that much by him. Love Is Not Enough for example, is great instrumentally but the lyrics are awful, they're not really saying anything he hasn't said before and they're doing it in a very boring way. Kinda I Want To has obnoxious stereo panning and cringeworthy lyrics. But I don't dislike any of those songs, I can only really come up with one song like that; In Two from HM. I hate the first half of this song, it starts with a great atmospheric build up then Trent's delivery is really awkward and the instrumentation is tripping on its own wires. After that an awful vocoder effect with trent just saying "nononnonono", it's almost comical, and the chorus has this fumbling confused falsetto harmony, it just sounds bad. After the second chorus there's a great typical NIN quiet bridge section which is fantastic, and then the transition into WISH here is excellent. Not a complete catastrophy, and not worth skipping but I don't like the main part of that song at all!
This may be one of the best songs ever made in the history of the world. What a brooding, raw song, every aspect is perfect the eeriness of the piano, the guitar giving it a bit of that hopeful feel, I hear this song and I hear perseverance of the human will in spite of nearly having lost all hope.
"The ghost of what I was keeps getting in the way"....Amazing lyrics that I relate to more than I care to admit. Trent has an uncanny gift....And it's been too long since I listened. Still sounds amazing~of course...
Rolling into hell on chariots of fire the first few records and rolling out the next few with “I got nothing.” It’s the nature of addiction and demons. 🤘🗿🤘
That is when you can say "NIN is never bad" When Trent is on tour...always an amazing show...here's hoping he can find the time to step away from his Oscar winning stuff and tour with NIN again one more time with some amazing new music...
wow is this a beautiful song with the piano in there. And again im in the same place emotionally as nails has captured in their music. I want this song played at my funeral.
I read all these comments on all ][\][ ][ ][/][ (sorry had to) vids and someone has to mention when they started listening to him. aren't we all just really fucking lucky that we know his music regardless if it was a day or 25 years ago that we found it? Trent will still win that pissing contest.
Man Do NIN know how to make music or what. F*cking awsome. best band to ever fill the air waves. Love this track. love "home" i just listen to this track all day long while staring at the sun!
Just realised basicallynonentity could be female and if someone is in such a dark place that certain music literally does save their lives,who are you to question that.I've listened to nin for 20yrs and have had depression for most of those."Oh nin are so depressing".Sick of hearing that.I'm hardly going to listen to something that will tip me over the edge!His lyrics are powerful,thought provoking and very perceptive.Something a lot of ppl can relate to.Don't know what music you listen to but even if i thought it was shit,i would not disrespect you for how it makes you feel.If you have feelings.
I wish.. I wish i could feel something. I haven't felt anything in what feels like a lifetime. I want it to end. I hate waking up in the morning, and all i have to look forward to is what? Nothing. Shit covered NOTHING.
i didnt know i had this song on my ipod until i heard it the other day for the first time. it floored me. i usually turn up the bass in my car when this plays.it feels like my mirrors are about to shatter at any moment.
i love all the versions to this song... Its not so much the instruments im interested in, its the lyrics... I mean the instruments halfway make nine inch nails what it is.... but id say the lyrics in this song are totally amazing. Then again so is every nine inch nails song..
i really like the drums on this one. reminds me the best drums are scottish and japanese. his voice is great too. its like with the literature we were mostly all of us reading during the time when the clubs were open....read enough of an author or listen enough to a particular band or person and discover if they have long lasting and genuine talent or not. well i think he does. they do. stephen king clive barker and anne rice at the time.... he's so cool because he's an engineer and Doom is him.
incredible song..........................pure talent love his work with Saul Williams and EL P. would also be great to hear a collab with UK act AllFlaws.
Voidless conception of all of your perceptions are inane to my self. The most important person on earth is myself because I’m the one conceiving the awareness of what my reality is. 99% are nicht to me. The consciousness is fueled by the soul and the mechanics of your body but the soul travels after the body breaks down and it’s haunting the help out of me with, sadness, beauty, love, want, euphoria and hope. There for I I’m not the most important person in my reality because I have a counterpart that sees much and understands much better than I. Love
Find the Bridge School Version, idk, as good as this is that version is the definite one. Plus you get to see pre-steroids with teeth ear Trent play it live looking super healthy.
I would indeed of been interesting for Reznor to record these ideally 'difficult to find' unreleased tracks for us devoted fans to find. Heavily influencial bands such as Radiohead, The Red Hot Chili Peppers and Incubus have quite a few album outtakes and B-Sides to share.
so far 2 versions of this track and i like them both but this oner really takes the cake floats my boat rocks the house etc sounds like you slowed it down an increment or two though
@the1andonlyDarkAngel yeah for example i dint take Survivalism at first listen to the studio version when Year Zero first came out, but then i checked out the live version of it and i was blown away!!! its so fuckin amazing and powerful
On the album? I think Jerome was only the live drummer..i heard Dave Grohl drummed for reznor on the With Teeth album BUT im only a newbie fan to NIN so i could be wrong. Only wish id gotten in to Trent's music years ago coz..well he's lyrics..music..its all unique, original and amazing. LOVE IT!
Been a fan for a while but theres always more NIN songs to discover!
5 years later. . .
Its a dark cornucopia
3 years ago saw them in concert and trent busted out a sax. i was like okay new song?? lol
@@texastaurus9271same! This was last September tho. Maybe I'm biased as they're my favorite and I've seen a lot of shows but that was the best fucking show I've ever ever seen.
Why this didn't make the final cut of With Teeth I don't know, it's such a good nine inch nails track dark, moody, energetic full of suspense and excellent synths. Trent you are a genius
Christian Kirschenmann and not so pretty now
Christian Kirschenmann and now im nothing
Now I'm Nothing would've made a great opening to PHM.
Yurp. bugs me to think he must have so many other tracks never finished that we might never hear. The Fragile deviations was alright but too much today NIN influence i felt if that makes sense. Cleaned it up too much, added stuff they didnt add anything (end of starfuckers) o.0
@@shaitet I think Now I'm Nothing was just an opener for Terrible Lie in-general, wasn't it?
the ghost of what I was
keeps getting in the way...
real talk
the best lyric in the song
Thefirstoneofmykind i think you mean best lyric period
I love so much how many of the lyrics in this song call back to and reference the other songs on With Teeth. It's like a summation of all the concepts on the album.
"maze of monochrome" = All The Love In The World
"How can I go home?" = Home
"Try to stand in line" = The Hand That Feeds
"Staring at the sun" = Sunspots
Then there are some that more loosely reference lyrics and ideas, such as these:
"I'm fading out of sight" = Beside You In Time
"Try to obey" = Getting Smaller
There are other that are more of a stretch, but you get the idea. Brilliance!
Ghosts find my way
Crazy!!!! Thay makes sense
Honestly this feels more like a song that mixes both The Fragile and With Teeth together. This and Deep is what I imagine NIN sounding like if Trent released an album in 2001 or 2002
Reminds me of 04 Ghosts I in the beginning
@@corntastrophyStill was released January 2002...quieter versions of tracks from previous albums
"The sky is not the same
Shade of blue
Every single thing
I believe isn't true
Missing in the maze of monochrome
How did I get here?
How can I go home?
The echoes in my eyes
Of all they used to see
Burning down the world
The ashes and debris
And all that's left of me
Non-Entity
Try to stand in line
Try to obey
The ghost of what I was
Keeps getting in the way
Staring at the sun
Blinded by the light
Now I'm afraid, I'm fading out of sight
The echoes in my eyes
Of all they used to see
Burning down the world
The ashes and debris
And all that's left of you
And all that's left of me
All have washed away
Non-Entity
Source: Musixmatch"
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
I remember watching Trent play this song live to benefit Hurricane Katrina and I was in actual tears by the end. It felt so personal and was one of the best live performances I've ever seen in my life.
A boom box and a grand piano. Absolutely legendary performance.
Get over it
This is such an incredible song...
Rebeca A. I add it to the with Teeth album. It fits perfectly
One of the best NIN songs ever. Those awesome drums, the guitar during the chorus... All EPIC!
i just realized i saw NIN peform this song live, 6 fucking years ago. and i still remember it so clearly...
Valathe yup
Another lost track that seems to have found me at the perfect time. ⚡👽⚡
I’ve been with NIN since 1988. I still find new shit that slipped through the other awesomeness of trent & co’s productions.
Like Head Down. Mosh pit material - as I was doing just that at the time 19-21. Now at 43 The Beautiful Nightmare (Head Down) is what’s circling me head constantly. Those to Trent made versions are literally diametrically opposite
Both have a place
I'm a year late, but goddamn a
I i feel it.
Cheers from Poland.
I have the same but year later
Mr. Reznor's music can be easily categorized into phases of my life and those tracks that aren't filed yet are simply awaiting their turn.
So glad he's still at it 30+ yrs later
This would have arguably been the best track on With Teeth. God knows what possessed Trent to think it wasn't worth putting it on there at the time.
I think it's the arrangement. It's a good tune at its core, but the arrangement is kinda meh. Solo piano Trent version is by far the best version of this song.
This song is so amazing, dark, moody, eerie, just overall so perfect. Trent Reznor is a phenomenal artist! I would give this song a billion thumbs up if I could.
Beautiful song. I don't doubt Trent's decision making, but I think this would have been just fine on the With Teeth album.
DAMELKEYON I agree. There are quite a few similar sounding songs on the With Teeth album. It would've fit so perfectly on there.
But it makes it special those few times you hear it separately
Replace Love Is Not Enough with it! I think the real reason is he just didn't have it recorded and/or properly mixed in time
Considering he let "everything" slide onto Hesitation Marks, its straight blasphemy this was left off With Teeth
Very good idea, seems like it would've been flawless.
I love Trent's vocal performance in this song
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
My favorite NIN “outtake/b-side” by far. I keep coming back to this, so thanks for the share.
Those drums!!
piggybank16 His Voice!!
This song!!
Dave Grohl on the drums according to NIN wiki, good stuff
A comment!!
Dave Grohl recorded all drums on this album :)
I like this as a song that didn't make the album cut just so it could maintain its luster as a gem all these years later.
Four years is not that long; it hardly would’ve made a difference. songs don’t exactly dull over time so much as your mind does when you listen to them
with the 20 year anniversary of with teeth in a little over a year (yes you read that right), i beg for a deluxe deviations with home+RWIBv2+not so pretty now+this on vinyl with robs original bleedthrough artwork. make it so, trent.
I loved this song live, I'm glad they finally did a studio version.
how have i not come across this song its one of the best I've ever heard and the lyrics are genius. i swear whatever the higher power is made me come across this right now for how i relate to it.
There's still to this day, not one song that i don't like. Truly a god of the Industrial world.
CaseyA Wheeldon
Of his vast catalog the only song i cant stand is "Everything" off of Hesitation.
just doesn't do it for me and it feels like he put minimal interest in it
then you clearly didn't pay attention to it. It's as depressing as the rest of Hesitation Marks.
I like that song! I think Trent's a genius of course, but there are some songs I just don't like that much by him. Love Is Not Enough for example, is great instrumentally but the lyrics are awful, they're not really saying anything he hasn't said before and they're doing it in a very boring way. Kinda I Want To has obnoxious stereo panning and cringeworthy lyrics. But I don't dislike any of those songs, I can only really come up with one song like that; In Two from HM. I hate the first half of this song, it starts with a great atmospheric build up then Trent's delivery is really awkward and the instrumentation is tripping on its own wires. After that an awful vocoder effect with trent just saying "nononnonono", it's almost comical, and the chorus has this fumbling confused falsetto harmony, it just sounds bad. After the second chorus there's a great typical NIN quiet bridge section which is fantastic, and then the transition into WISH here is excellent. Not a complete catastrophy, and not worth skipping but I don't like the main part of that song at all!
god of the rock world in general.
@@surroundgatari I like LINE and In two.😭
This may be one of the best songs ever made in the history of the world.
What a brooding, raw song, every aspect is perfect the eeriness of the piano, the guitar giving it a bit of that hopeful feel, I hear this song and I hear perseverance of the human will in spite of nearly having lost all hope.
perseverance of the human will??? nothing to do with that at all, dont disgrace this song with such nonsense!
made it sound gay!
@@THEFLESHGOD We don't need people like you in Nin's music videos.
elninjalaranja I'm the only one of my kind, there is no people lile me, we don't need people like you on earth
Well said
Amazing song! I have a feeling Trent left this song out because the vibe it was trying to give off was already achieved in love is not enough.
He should have left love is not enough off instead 😂
This should've been at least a bonus track on a special edition of With Teeth, it's a pretty good song
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
"Once Upon A Time In HOLLYWOOD" and "The Downward Spiral" are forever connected.
"The ghost of what I was keeps getting in the way"....Amazing lyrics that I relate to more than
I care to admit. Trent has an uncanny gift....And it's been too long since I listened.
Still sounds amazing~of course...
The vocal track is amazing, he really slayed the vocals on this , the ending is sick as well
This feels relevant in 2020->2021
Am I the only one who doesn't say "this song" fits the covid era?
Rolling into hell on chariots of fire the first few records and rolling out the next few with “I got nothing.” It’s the nature of addiction and demons.
🤘🗿🤘
This and the live version are perfection
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
That is when you can say "NIN is never bad" When Trent is on tour...always an amazing show...here's hoping he can find the time to step away from his Oscar winning stuff and tour with NIN again one more time with some amazing new music...
ninの曲の中でも、最高の曲のひとつ！！！
Too bad this track isn't readily available on Spotify...
I heard this song for the first time when I scored the Beside you in time DVD at the time of it's release I'm a little more fond of the live version
wow is this a beautiful song with the piano in there. And again im in the same place emotionally as nails has captured in their music. I want this song played at my funeral.
I read all these comments on all ][\][ ][ ][/][ (sorry had to) vids and someone has to mention when they started listening to him. aren't we all just really fucking lucky that we know his music regardless if it was a day or 25 years ago that we found it? Trent will still win that pissing contest.
+gigbuttisbad I also always read the comments of every vid. Such a good time. I agree, there's always a few
gigbuttisbad I'm 50 and I've been listening to NIN since I was 2
My piss will always win
Beautiful ....
Thumbs up for finding your way back in the awesomest way ever...
And many thanks for your service.
Sometimes I wake up to this song without even thinking about it the day before and I just think to myself... how?
Man Do NIN know how to make music or what. F*cking awsome. best band to ever fill the air waves. Love this track. love "home" i just listen to this track all day long while staring at the sun!
beautiful
Just realised basicallynonentity could be female and if someone is in such a dark place that certain music literally does save their lives,who are you to question that.I've listened to nin for 20yrs and have had depression for most of those."Oh nin are so depressing".Sick of hearing that.I'm hardly going to listen to something that will tip me over the edge!His lyrics are powerful,thought provoking and very perceptive.Something a lot of ppl can relate to.Don't know what music you listen to but even if i thought it was shit,i would not disrespect you for how it makes you feel.If you have feelings.
catherine walton Trent saved my life -- quite literally as well
edgy
amazing top 10 for me.
best lyrics ever
Where have I been?!..just hearing this in 2021
ああ、何回聴いても、凄まじく、この曲いい！！！
Love the live version
Look you are not royalty you are a discarded hobo
Holy shit this is EPIC
20 years I've been listening to him. How am I now learning this song exists.
I wish..
I wish i could feel something.
I haven't felt anything in what feels like a lifetime.
I want it to end.
I hate waking up in the morning, and all i have to look forward to is what?
Nothing. Shit covered NOTHING.
Another melancholic great one..
great song and it cant be that old can it TR? we both grew up in the same scene. him up in Phoenix and me in Tucson. Machines of Loving Grace!
i didnt know i had this song on my ipod until i heard it the other day for the first time. it floored me.
i usually turn up the bass in my car when this plays.it feels like my mirrors are about to shatter at any moment.
Stupid amazing 👏!
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
If this doesn’t make you want a mini moog, nothing will.
i love all the versions to this song... Its not so much the instruments im interested in, its the lyrics... I mean the instruments halfway make nine inch nails what it is.... but id say the lyrics in this song are totally amazing. Then again so is every nine inch nails song..
i really like the drums on this one. reminds me the best drums are scottish and japanese. his voice is great too. its like with the literature we were mostly all of us reading during the time when the clubs were open....read enough of an author or listen enough to a particular band or person and discover if they have long lasting and genuine talent or not. well i think he does. they do. stephen king clive barker and anne rice at the time.... he's so cool because he's an engineer and Doom is him.
I'm enchanted with this dark little number.
There needs to be an official studio release.
incredible song..........................pure talent
love his work with Saul Williams and EL P.
would also be great to hear a collab with UK act AllFlaws.
Man, NIN always uses the best raw snare tones with the perfect amount of ringing in it!
This is NIN's Soul to Squeeze (one of RHCP's best songs that was also B side)
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
Another awesome tune i love singing too.
CHRIS BROESKY Me too. I love singing this song.
Voidless conception of all of your perceptions are inane to my self. The most important person on earth is myself because I’m the one conceiving the awareness of what my reality is. 99% are nicht to me. The consciousness is fueled by the soul and the mechanics of your body but the soul travels after the body breaks down and it’s haunting the help out of me with, sadness, beauty, love, want, euphoria and hope. There for I I’m not the most important person in my reality because I have a counterpart that sees much and understands much better than I. Love
fantastic drums
that bassline... trent voice.. piano..
ROCK'ON!!!
song just sent a chill up my spine thanks for the upload never heard this song
This song is relative to Right Where It Belongs!
NIN you keep bringing me back to the "right side" of things.
thanks for uploading this b/c i couldnt figure out how to open the file once i downloaded it from the site.
Love this song so much
Fantastic song, I've always loved this.
Pure bliss.
Wicked!!
I enjoy this one and Home so much more than any song on With Teeth LOL
Definitely a favorite from the with teeth sessions! This and Sunspots and hand that feeds🤔😀
I'm gonna take my horse to the old town road, I'm gonna, riiiiide til I can't no more
Find the Bridge School Version, idk, as good as this is that version is the definite one.
Plus you get to see pre-steroids with teeth ear Trent play it live looking super healthy.
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
One of the best tracks from the with teeth era. Should have made the album 💯
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
This should have been trk 2
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
wow I ADORE that intro TRENT! fucking smashing man
Wow so good
Tried to stand in line
Tried to obey
The ghost of who I was keeps getting in the way.
I would indeed of been interesting for Reznor to record these ideally 'difficult to find' unreleased tracks for us devoted fans to find. Heavily influencial bands such as Radiohead, The Red Hot Chili Peppers and Incubus have quite a few album outtakes and B-Sides to share.
so far 2 versions of this track and i like them both but this oner really takes the cake floats my boat rocks the house etc sounds like you slowed it down an increment or two though
I like to play this version in my car...loudly...
@the1andonlyDarkAngel yeah for example i dint take Survivalism at first listen to the studio version when Year Zero first came out, but then i checked out the live version of it and i was blown away!!! its so fuckin amazing and powerful
I dont think I've hear anything of trents that I haven't liked. fucking awesome!!
@Xiatter very cool ..i agree my friend
The echos in my eyes
Of all they used to see
Burning down the world
The ashes and debris
And all that's left of me
Non-entity
On the album? I think Jerome was only the live drummer..i heard Dave Grohl drummed for reznor on the With Teeth album BUT im only a newbie fan to NIN so i could be wrong. Only wish id gotten in to Trent's music years ago coz..well he's lyrics..music..its all unique, original and amazing. LOVE IT!
@NIN99Koala
Thank you sir!
How is this not on Spotify?
ua-cam.com/video/EJg9B8Cx5fo/v-deo.html
awesome
Trent´s a genius...
listening to nin music always gives me this "goddamn..." feeling................kind of like the feeling of seeing something of pure beauty
or sex
Best reply ever.
Where can I buy this song?
I was able to download it. :-)
Yeah, because this and "Not so pretty now" are b-sides from With Teeth
so fucking amazing