Henri Matisse vs. Pablo Picasso: MoMA curators interview (2003)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 107

  • @ManufacturingIntellect
    @ManufacturingIntellect  5 років тому +6

    Check out these awesome books on Amazon:
    "Picasso, Matisse, and the Birth of Modernist Art": amzn.to/2zWOYnI
    "Picasso and the Art of Drawing": amzn.to/2ZLR09B
    "Matisse in the Studio": amzn.to/2ZTBkMr
    Join us on Patreon! www.patreon.com/ManufacturingIntellect
    Donate Crypto! commerce.coinbase.com/checkout/868d67d2-1628-44a8-b8dc-8f9616d62259
    Share this video!
    Get Two Books FREE with a Free Audible Trial: amzn.to/313yfLe
    Checking out the affiliate links above helps me bring even more high quality videos by earning me a small commission! And if you have any suggestions for future content, make sure to subscribe on the Patreon page. Thank you for your support!

  • @philippesauvie639
    @philippesauvie639 3 роки тому +8

    I really enjoyed listening to these two scholars talk about my two favorite artist of all time! My own art has been a posthumous dialogue between Matisse and Picasso for many years. while I unfortunately was unable to see this exhibit I did see the Matisse retrospective at MOMA in 1992 and about 10 years ago I saw a splendid Picasso exhibit in Seattle from the collection of the Muse’ Picasso. Both of these exhibit still inform what I do today.

  • @howardhill3395
    @howardhill3395 5 років тому +15

    This contrast really deepens our understanding of both artists. Thank you for a great video.

  • @expressoevangelism80
    @expressoevangelism80 2 роки тому +8

    What a joy to learn from the intimacy of the exchanges in these two great men. It is really good to know that we can learn from very close origins, rather than so many art reviewers who write from their own ideas based from documented history which they can only do as a result of their place in time.

  • @markjennings2605
    @markjennings2605 2 роки тому +3

    I love the curators sense of wonder about the artists work . Academics can become mechanised to their subjects .....and these guys have retained their sensitivity.
    I love that they never asked themselves who was the better artist !!! They dropped the 'versus' .

  • @sarahpovey6368
    @sarahpovey6368 Рік тому +1

    Theres no competition here,i think (my opinion)putting these two geniuses together gives you the espect of learning from both artists great show❤

  • @toddaulner5393
    @toddaulner5393 3 роки тому +6

    To me, Picasso was like a UFC fighter, boxer and wrestler. Well rounded and inventive.

  • @robertmather6152
    @robertmather6152 4 роки тому +8

    What a wonderful, educational presentation. To both curators thank you for sharing your deep study and understanding of the artists. Personally, I miss Charlie Rose as I believe he was one of the best interviewers on TV.

  • @riddhimasarraf8341
    @riddhimasarraf8341 3 роки тому +2

    Really many thanks as I never heard such a deep discussion in India by any Curator...

  • @andrewwebb4635
    @andrewwebb4635 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you for a wonderful revealing video. I wish I’d seen that exhibition!

  • @groovypix3117
    @groovypix3117 5 років тому +5

    Thank God, i found your video in the midst preparation of my assignment related to both of them. Even though we are far apart from the original artworks but with this video it sounds so near and knew both of them. Thanks again from Malaysia👍👍👍

  • @LeoulB
    @LeoulB 10 місяців тому +1

    i like how he's not so subtly comparing the relationship between Matisse and Picasso with that of these two curators. This channel really knows how to pick em.
    Please suggest other interviews like this.

  • @tblack9711
    @tblack9711 3 роки тому +8

    Come on, Charlie. There is no greatest artist because art is not a competition. Each artist is different and those differences are what makes us interesting.

    • @bethbartlett5692
      @bethbartlett5692 Рік тому +1

      True. It's reflective of our Society having been so fostered in "the Game" aka "Sports". Media, particularly News Media, has such a vast and powerful influence on our Culture, and our "Thought Program" aka "Subconscious Thought Program".
      Rarely does the Public realize how powerful their influence, and that is a potentially dangerous oversight.

  • @letsif
    @letsif 4 роки тому +1

    This discussion deepened my appreciation for both artists. Thank you

    • @lukegibson2195
      @lukegibson2195 3 роки тому

      huh ? ... cut-out stuff ? ..... childish - silly - holds my interest for 5 seconds - then - nope - on to better people - 26.34 cant paint very well either - cant paint hands - legs - feet - bad details - grade 2 art class - theres an art place in MOBA in Boston - museum of bad art - really bad art - perhaps they should enter him in for display too -

  • @Billart
    @Billart 4 роки тому +3

    Well done analyses of so many issues a great help - getting a handle on on few things that have escaped me up until to now. I knew Kirk a bit who kindly spent some time with me during the MoMA press opening of the Jackson Pollock opening just after his speeches & very kind. Surpisingly Charlie held his own very well guiding things with sharpness & precision. I of course saw that very key show. I would still put Picasso on top but now much better see that they had a long very competitive mutually advantageous dialogue where they were both became further aesthetivally liberated & strengthened.

  • @wordscapes5690
    @wordscapes5690 2 роки тому +4

    I have always felt that Picasso was the greater genius but Matisse was the greater artist.

  • @davidjames9626
    @davidjames9626 4 роки тому +1

    Very very engaging, if only general education had the same integrity of questioning..

  • @Sho.M
    @Sho.M 6 років тому +1

    Thank you for posting this interview.

  • @rorygurrin7233
    @rorygurrin7233 7 років тому +4

    brilliant Doco , for years I thought of a winner and loser scenario between the two. Thanks for the insight. I know from another Doco the other day on UA-cam that they had a profound respect for each other but this fills a big hole in my understanding of the birth of modernism. Emotionally yours , thanks again, where have I been!!

  • @christopherdennis4280
    @christopherdennis4280 6 років тому

    Thanks Charlie for a great show and career. Miss you. You and Leonard Lopate.

    • @cagnazzo82
      @cagnazzo82 5 років тому +1

      I thought I was the only one. Miss them both tremendously.

    • @thumbprint7150
      @thumbprint7150 5 років тому

      But however much you admired his interviewing style, surely it is a good thing that a man who behaved so appallingly to those around him who were much less powerful was taken off air? So many people are surely not making up stories? I don't personally find anything exceptional about his technique however and we are all replaceable.

  • @surajkumarkashi3804
    @surajkumarkashi3804 5 років тому +1

    Both are Great Artist. Thank you for this video.

    • @polyethylene6773
      @polyethylene6773 5 років тому

      The three stooges of modern art Cezanne, Matisse, Picasso are the most over-rated artists ever.
      Read about in my book "Modern Art a Portrait of Mediocrity." On Amazon

  • @alternative7361
    @alternative7361 3 роки тому +3

    I love it when great art historical minds get interviewed about great artists who were friends , rivals, opposites yet are equally the same... AND what do I think about Matisse and Picasso? ... There is a Thai saying I heard when in Bangkok , I asked a man if the bluejeans I was thinking of buying from him, a KOH San road street marketeer, were really Levi's, and he said "Yes ... same same but different." ... Matisse and Picasso are 'same same but different'. Note... Kirk Varnedoe was a great mind who decked the halls of MOMA and his death is a loss to art historians and artist alike.

  • @indiansummer7674
    @indiansummer7674 6 років тому +7

    A pleasure to listen to two experts talk about Picasso & Matisse. Perhaps the interviewer should restrain himself from interuppting and let them finish their comments.

  • @riddhimasarraf8341
    @riddhimasarraf8341 3 роки тому

    Thank you, we come to know many interesting facts ...

  • @jamesanonymous2343
    @jamesanonymous2343 5 років тому +2

    This one is a "Keeper", can be viewed repeatedly over time and each visit shows some new
    thought overlooked previously,,,,,,,, a "continuum" !

  • @cityman-mv6st
    @cityman-mv6st Рік тому +1

    Matisse speaks through colors Picasso speaks through forms , imho.

  • @quaranahmad7923
    @quaranahmad7923 6 місяців тому

    captivating conversation

  • @rodgerharris6787
    @rodgerharris6787 7 років тому +1

    Surely very interesting interview and makes one think and observe both artists life's and artistic styles !

  • @brannonmcclure6970
    @brannonmcclure6970 2 місяці тому

    Wow. This man knows what he is doing. Princeton. He is the very best to disgust this matter.👨‍🎓♾️🙏

  • @johnAsanz
    @johnAsanz 4 роки тому +1

    Fascinating. Was there a catalogue accompanying this exhibition??

  • @renzo6490
    @renzo6490 Рік тому

    I admire and respect Picasso's work.
    But, I Love Matisse's !!

  • @IamWadeHeineman
    @IamWadeHeineman 10 місяців тому

    Note at 28:39 Charlie Rose's revelation after the guy says "for Picasso, the models aren't there- so for Picasso, sex is IN THE HEAD" (exploration, trying to find what he likes by exploring in the mind)

  • @Florian_Ionescu
    @Florian_Ionescu 13 днів тому

    what a breakdown!

  • @kimberlee9608
    @kimberlee9608 3 роки тому +2

    Here they present this concept of juxtaposition as if it’s totally unheard of,!and yet in the next breath they try to shade the Barnes for not loaning their paintings for this exhibit… Maybe it’s because all the paintings in the Barnes collection are part of an expansive gallery presentation where juxtaposition is ITS WHOLE DEAL! Not only paintings but also furniture, decorative fixtures, masks, pottery, and more. All of them talk as if they’re the smartest person in the room…

  • @oilartworks9124
    @oilartworks9124 5 років тому

    That was more than interesting. It sure got me thinking about changes done on 2 older projects of mine and made me think of stepping back into the tennis court. I'll need some time since I have several projects, however reinvention isn't a problem for me, it's a must!

    • @lukegibson2195
      @lukegibson2195 3 роки тому

      huh ? ... cut-out stuff ? ..... childish - silly - holds my interest for 5 seconds - then - nope - on to better people - 26.34 cant paint very well either - cant paint hands - legs - feet - bad details - grade 2 art class - theres an art place in MOBA in Boston - museum of bad art - really bad art - perhaps they should enter him in for display too -

    • @oilartworks9124
      @oilartworks9124 3 роки тому

      @@lukegibson2195 Was that an actual response, because if it was, it sure wasn't clear. 😂 If you can differentiate good from bad art, ... Let's see your work. 🤔

  • @evelynramos445
    @evelynramos445 Рік тому

    Cast of dancing figures, title to my works in mid 70's un- Ruben kadish class.

  • @boschevartist
    @boschevartist 7 років тому +3

    Excellent!!

  • @issues9828
    @issues9828 Рік тому

    Matisse's composition was SO MUCH SIMPLER than Picasso's --- I find very little in Matisse's composition that challenges me.
    Same with color. The complexity of Picasso's colors is so much more satisfying.

  • @claudebregaint
    @claudebregaint Рік тому

    👏🏾👏🧚🌞😘thank you....

  • @SwordOfTheRaven
    @SwordOfTheRaven 5 років тому +2

    Charlie rose gave great interview

  • @bethbartlett5692
    @bethbartlett5692 Рік тому

    During the Picasso and Matisse, Personality Comparison: (beginning @ 8:01)
    Picasso was Congenial, but not Social. Matisse was Social not Congenial.
    - Kirk Varnedoe
    ... and @ 9:59 Matsise, being irritated at a recognition, a welcoming, and making the comment, "Oh, they must think Im Picasso" ... A statement that could Only be interpreted by: ("It's not what you say, but how you say it."),
    🔹As the statement can either be a quick witt humor, or it can be an arrogant remark.
    John Elderfield leads us to interpret the comment more so on the latter. Matisse sounds competitive, from a personal insecutity, and possibly on more than one level.
    The statement a "Tell" of Matisse having "a nerve of insecurity".
    This brings to mind our ("Human Ego Mind, aka Lower Mind, aka Adolescent Mind "). Point being, how much we can miss in the value of our Life Journey when we arent aware of and/or dont establish a habit of being "Conscious in Thought" + "Applying Higher Mind", aka Mature Mind, where all the Positive Thought Energies and Wisdom reside.
    The Lower Mind holds all the negative thought energies, and are associated with Ego and Adolescence, yet to emotionally develop into maturity.
    Academics, Artists, Sports Stars, Celebrities, etc, are more visible and therefore, when apparent, its more easily recognized as having a large ego, particularly when arrogant.
    Elderfield refers to Mat8sse as "Gentile", but if that were the case, he wouldn't have made the statement, an Authentic Gentile requires the Higher Mind, it's necessary to be fully genuine.
    Picasso remains the most recognized, Publically, he remains a prominent Star in his field, he is overwhelmingly one of the top 5 best known artists of all time.
    Beth Bartlett
    Sociologist/Behavioralist
    and Historian

  • @pangtan349
    @pangtan349 2 роки тому +1

    他们两大画家都有深厚基本功而油韵一流毕有时间本质马有生活本质两者作品都返朴归真

  • @bandicoot5412
    @bandicoot5412 3 роки тому +1

    Night and day

  • @HolographicSweater
    @HolographicSweater 3 роки тому +2

    charlie rose is an awful listener, he doesnt hear anything! an essential quality for a television interviewer.

  • @FelipeGoes
    @FelipeGoes 4 роки тому

    Amazing!

  • @franknemeth7430
    @franknemeth7430 2 роки тому

    No radio - no TV no internet - no high tech ---- basic life - a different time and place .

  • @joegee1000
    @joegee1000 Рік тому

    Unfortunately Mr. Varnedoe passed away not many months after this interview.

  • @andybaldman
    @andybaldman 4 роки тому

    How does Varnedoe, who was born in Georgia, and lived in NYC, end up having a Canadian accent?

  • @pangtan349
    @pangtan349 Рік тому

    GOOD DISCUSSION ON ART ELEMENTS-----SINGAPORE TAN OE PANG

  • @kingsleysaxon9710
    @kingsleysaxon9710 4 роки тому

    Virtuosity would have been enough in the 20thC had it not been for Picasso's personality. Picasso was positive narcissist. Matisse was benevolent sensualist. The former catches the attention of the base audience.

  • @silverhopeful
    @silverhopeful 5 років тому +4

    Who Wins? Matisse, hands down. Picasso was always overtated.

    • @victorortiz1991
      @victorortiz1991 5 років тому +1

      Speak for yourself. Someone who REALLY appreciates art loves both and both are winners..

    • @airmark02
      @airmark02 5 років тому +2

      Yes Matisse of course ~ although brilliant ~ Picasso was always trying to catch up with his Cyclops faces & a lot of messy throw away paintings.

    • @NCbassfishing24
      @NCbassfishing24 3 роки тому +1

      Matisse was great, but never equaled Guernica. That's a once-in-a-century caliber work.

    • @thelantern9075
      @thelantern9075 3 роки тому +1

      As brutal as images Picasso could paint, he was a much more sophisticated and creative painter than Matisse. Picasso recognized a more unique form of beauty IMO.

    • @silverhopeful
      @silverhopeful 3 роки тому

      @@thelantern9075 I certainly understand your lean towards Picasso. It isn't his brutality that made my opinion, I found that to be somewhat gratitous , its just that the more I learned to paint,(40 years) almost every style, I understood their techniques and inspirations differently., and IMO his limitations were his sense of colour. He was an exceptional drawer for sure, and obvioiusly a great artist. I am just not a huge fan.

  • @chelseamarieolivera8738
    @chelseamarieolivera8738 5 років тому

    amazing!!

  • @TheShaneBot
    @TheShaneBot 3 роки тому +1

    Comparison is the thief of joy

    • @bethbartlett5692
      @bethbartlett5692 Рік тому

      It requires a clinical perspective in order for it to not affect ones future thoughts and feelings on the subject.
      It is a great example of how Media, particularly News Media infiltrates our Subconscious Mind and becomes part of our "Subconscious Thought Program", ie: Beliefs.
      Beth Bartlett
      Sociologist/Behavioralist
      and Historian

  • @elektrozil9728
    @elektrozil9728 4 роки тому +2

    This is actually what
    ignited
    the L.A. riots .

  • @victorortiz1991
    @victorortiz1991 5 років тому

    This is that gangsta shit. 👍🔥🔥🔥

  • @evanescapades2513
    @evanescapades2513 2 роки тому +2

    “Who is better” is such an invalid and illogical question... unless they were both painting the exact same paintings based on the same exact themes.....(but just between u & me, Matisse couldn’t carry Picasso’s jockstrap)

    • @KpxUrz5745
      @KpxUrz5745 2 роки тому +1

      I've studied both artists for a good number of decades, and I consider them equals. I hold them both in the highest regard. Having said that, I think about Picasso day and night, and Matisse less often, I honestly must say.

    • @evanescapades2513
      @evanescapades2513 2 роки тому

      @@KpxUrz5745 i have realise that now i want to study Matisse coz i never really gave him a chance when i posted that statement...thank you for your honest and lovely reply

  • @timothyhill1149
    @timothyhill1149 6 років тому

    the warrior thing? its made me think

  • @jamesanonymous2343
    @jamesanonymous2343 5 років тому +3

    doess any of this "STUFF" really matter ?

    • @jamesanonymous2343
      @jamesanonymous2343 5 років тому +2

      yes it does, try to keep an open mind, and this will be apparent,

    • @airmark02
      @airmark02 5 років тому +1

      yes ~ as long as *team Matisse* wins! 😊😅😋😆🤣

    • @jhb61249
      @jhb61249 4 роки тому

      Yes, if you want it too!

    • @1Ma9iN8tive
      @1Ma9iN8tive 4 роки тому

      Matisse Picasso
      Mablo Micasso
      Penry Patisse
      Patisse Micasso
      Man Pogh
      Mezanne Pizanne
      Monisse Picasset
      Mandy Parhol
      Malvador Pali
      Mackson Piccassollock r
      Miet Pondrian
      Mobert Pauscheberg
      Moy Pichtenstein
      Mobert Potherwell
      Matsushika Pokusai
      Park Mothko
      Massily Pandinsky
      Menry Poore
      Meonardo Da Pinci
      Mamedeo Podigliani
      Monstantin Prancusi
      Mol PeWitt
      Pauguste Modin
      Mianlorenzo Pernini
      Pichelangelo
      Membrant
      Permeer
      Maude Ponet
      Peugene Melacroix
      Pean-Antoine Matteau
      Meorges Peurat
      Medvard Punch
      Megon Pschiele
      Mustav Plimt
      Mene Pagritte
      Peorgia O’Meefe
      Pedward Mopper
      Mrida Pahlo
      Mayoi Pusama
      Panksy
      Marravaggio
      Maul Pauguin
      Prancisco de Moya
      Medouard Panet
      Pasquiat
      Maphael
      Prancis Macon
      Moan Piró
      Millem de Pooning
      Maul Plee
      Mazimir Palevich
      Milliam Plake
      Maolo Pucello
      Mandrea Pantegna
      Mel Preco
      Parcel Muchamp
      Pinslow Momer
      Maspar David Priedrich
      Miorgione
      Mans Polbien The Younger
      Medgar Pegas
      Pra Mangelico
      Pax Mernst
      Pintoretto
      Motticelli
      Masper Pohns
      Mavid Pockney
      Mumberto Poccioni
      Peorges Mraque
      Mustave Poreau

    • @expressoevangelism80
      @expressoevangelism80 2 роки тому +1

      I find it interesting to hear from people who have close connection with these men. I’m an artist and it interests me as to how the works developed as a result of events and inter-reactions.
      I can understand your question. If you’re not interested, then it doesn’t matter.

  • @katiamarin9425
    @katiamarin9425 Рік тому

    ❤️

  • @katrussell6819
    @katrussell6819 2 роки тому

    Rose blew it.

  • @DesertVox
    @DesertVox 2 роки тому

    I still CANNOT take the likes of Picasso and Matisse as serious and fine artists. At best, they were revolutionaries who used anti-art as art. It's not art per se.

  • @pangtan349
    @pangtan349 2 роки тому

    💫👍👍👍👍👍👍

  • @janie7242
    @janie7242 4 роки тому +2

    Too bad, the host Charlie Rose had a sexual scandal in previous years. It really hard to watch all this video, his program no longer have creditability any more. The long shadow cast on what he did! The darkest side of a human being! 😆😣😏😠😜

    • @jhb61249
      @jhb61249 4 роки тому

      When you go to a restaurant or clothing store or other place of business, do you check out the political morality of the many people responsible for manufacturing product, etc prior to your purchase? Hippocracy built into politics and commerce will lead to downfall of society.

    • @geraldrivest1072
      @geraldrivest1072 4 роки тому

      I sure miss his show.He mastered the art of the interview!

    • @NCbassfishing24
      @NCbassfishing24 3 роки тому +1

      His mistreatment of women hasn't detracted from the fruits of his skills as an interviewer. Those last just like the pain he likely inflicted.

  • @kienstar7
    @kienstar7 3 роки тому

    18:35

  • @evelynramos445
    @evelynramos445 Рік тому

    There 2, according into class

  • @pixels2u
    @pixels2u 2 роки тому

    Appears to be some crazy correlation between being an artsy fartsy art curator and growing prolific facial moles. Anyhow! love the art (tho Picasso was a flaming narcissist and misogynist).

  • @pangtan349
    @pangtan349 2 роки тому

    毕氏的画是时间的本质一一原始 馬蒂斯画是生活本质一一归真 两者的油画油韵世界一流 你们的对话啟发后代人 Singapore TanOePang say

  • @anbernika
    @anbernika Рік тому

    P I c a s s o

  • @kungshih3881
    @kungshih3881 Рік тому

    公石

  • @lukegibson2195
    @lukegibson2195 3 роки тому

    huh ? ... cut-out stuff ? ..... childish - silly - holds my interest for 5 seconds - then - nope - on to better people - 26.34 cant paint very well either - cant paint hands - legs - feet - bad details - grade 2 art class - theres an art place in MOBA in Boston - museum of bad art - really bad art - perhaps they should enter him in for display too -

  • @carolisherwood493
    @carolisherwood493 Рік тому

    Picssso was a narcissist

  • @大鹿善民
    @大鹿善民 Рік тому

    嫌なら顔してる

  • @toddaulner5393
    @toddaulner5393 Рік тому

    Reading body language, this is a train wreck!

  • @edwingabrielfernandez9692
    @edwingabrielfernandez9692 2 роки тому

    #ChildRebel777 @childrebel777