United fans still think Rashford is a world class player…he’s the most inconsistent player in the league both within a game and across seasons. IQ of a toddler.
Longstaff should be in A based on comparisons of what is in B, he has played over 100 PL matches, one of the core members of Newcastle getting CL, and overall is so underrated and under appreciated by everyone other than Newcastle fans (even some actually don’t appreciate him). Nobody in the b-list has done more than what longstaff has done and he should be in A
Foden has been playing a very important role for us this season however he Is okay a more b silva role this season you will see the best of him. In th prem last season he had better mind per gc than saka and he only played half the minutes of saka
It’s partly because not as many people care about City and don’t pay attention. Obviously very successful side but the amount of support amongst generations above school age won’t be at the levels of other big clubs
as good as he is attacking wise he is as bad in defense,ranking him as his natural position RB he is an A at best,but B for me,if we were ranking him as a cm he would be S
@@LocalNoob_2 Saying Trent can't defend is not true. You can't win every trophy available to you with a right back who can't defend. His defensive awareness can be poor but it isn't as bad as people make it out to be. Saying he is B tier when he is one of the most successful players ever 24 doesnt make sense.
I dont think any player for Newcastle was stunted quite as much under Steve Bruce as Sean Longstaff was. (Except for maybe Joelinton). Longstaff was smashing it under Benitez and linked to Man Utd. The difference with him out of the side in this Eddie Howe setup is remarkable. We simply couldnt win games without him last season. Should easily be in A tier
i think for S-tier to have meaning it has to be one of the least populated categories. speaking as an arsenal fan, based on achievements and availability i feel like you could reduce the S tier to foden and trent, MAYBE saka.
Harsh on Bueno, you were full of praise for him in the games he did play and he is only out of the team thanks to ait nouri who is an excellent leftcback, should not place under skipp
Facts. In 8 seasons he has scored 77 goals. Take out a 2 month period last season in which he scored 11 goals, he was shocking. Rashford is the most overrated player in the league
La Cobham is the Best simple name another PL side with as many Academy players in the top 5 Leagues and has had as many academy players play for the first team
Could be Cobham, could be the catchment area, seems like south London is a hotbed of talent. Probably both. Don't think anyone would disagree, it's a shame almost all of them will need to leave to get a game.
@@rajivroy5047 unlike a lot of fans, I haven't just been following him since he signed for Liverpool, I knew about him from RB Salzburg through to RB Leipzig, he is a special talent.
Reece James has not done enough to be in the tier with Bukayo and Trent, especially in the league. He had one really good season and hasn't matched the same heights since
not really on him as he came back to find the team ridiculously low on on confidence,reece is a special talent and has the skillset to become the best right back of all time forget the the passing,shooting and defensive skills you must watch how he takes on defenders so effortlessly like a winger as his body structure also helps just bully the opposition honestly we've never seen anyone with such a complete skillset at that position..its a pity he's always injured
People rate James on what he could be instead of what he is. He's an injury prone player who can't string gametime together for the life of him. Saying hes world class is ridiculous, you need to be a weekly starter to be world class and not only do it every 5 months when your fit for a game or two
How is Dunk A, a literal club legend and maybe their best ever academy player if not player period. And James in S, bro can't put two games together without his knee breaking
@@edwardchamberlain8476 league one, championship promotion and staying in the side to Europe through thick and thin. Reece James won a few trophies injured Saka won one Rashford is more inconsistent than shit porridge
It depends on how you look at the video. I think Lewis Dunk is our most important player, a club legend and is certainly in S tier if the task is to rank him as an academy graduate based on his career and contribution. But if the task is to rank him as a player (and this is what I think Joe is doing), I can understand why he’d be in A and not S. I guess he’s not ‘elite.’
why is rice not on there over ben johnson, he came through west hams academy aswell as chlesea, but he he was at west ham from the age of like 14 hahaha
I don’t get why people use team trophies to celebrate an individual player, it prevents about 14 players from getting in the top tiers, using individual awards would make way more sense
They don’t necessarily have to revive it but I would enjoy seeing more content specific to those leagues maybe. I think the divided channels were just losing viewers
Spot on, and below Dunk a player that I appreciate but can’t be 1 category above Ramsey. And to have Rashford 2 categories above too. 🤪 Let’s face it this is based on watching highlights and a couple of games per season… can’t have watched all the players extensively.
Why is everything about trophies? Trophy logic doesn't make sense to me because trophies don't or should not determine a player ability. Example: Harry Kane (the best striker in the world for the last 5 five years consistently, maybe more) pretty much has no trophy therefore "has not reached his potential", compared to Nacho from Real Madrid who has won every single trophy possible although he is never been first choice, according to trophy logic, "he is an expectational player, S-tier stuff" due to trophies won. I must also add that trophies are essentially won by clubs and not players and it's not always the best clubs with the best players that win trophies (Man Utd always win some sort of trophy almost ever season but...). But more on the video, Ramsey, Mitchell and Longstaff and not same tier as Skipp and Johnson. Put some respect on these guys
Can tell you work with sky, putting trent top because he was Once really productive when he was able to get away with not doing a massive part of his job as a full back.
Putting James and Foden in the same tier as Saka and Trent is embarrassing. You can’t rely on potential forever and James and Foden just haven’t lived up to the hype
Are you high? Foden hasn't lived up to potential. His numbers alone prove you wrong. He puts up similar numbers to Saka despite being injured and limited game time. Watch him play before you spout nonsense. Also I'm not trying to be mean, but your take is so Ludacris that I couldn't help myself.
What a horrendous take. I can agree on James but your take on foden is hilariously bad. He’s literally on the level of Saka and consistently puts up the same numbers as Saka. Just because he didn’t start as much last season doesn’t mean he hasn’t lived up to the hype. You’re just saying that because he plays for city
@@nadirabdelnour756 a year or two ago and I would agree with you. But Saka has consistently been improving and Foden has stagnated. He’s still good, don’t get me wrong, but at one point he was considered to be the best young English talent and for now at least Bellingham, Rice, and Saka have passed him.
rashford been in multiple TOTS,won trophies for his boyhood club,had over 40 G/A last season,and is generally good in every season how tf is that not an S? Foden aswell? one of the most talented players in the league,if not the most talented,won a treble and multiple pl titles with his boyhood club.,..you are speaking nonsense buddy
Your opinion is based on recent form. All 3 are elite level players. You could make a case for James due to his injuries but he is still world class nonetheless
When you say "career" what do u mean? Foden has won more and been playing at the highest level for longer than saka. And actually you could say the same about rashford. I think he's basing it more on their talent anyway.
@@niallmcgirr7697 agreed, but still played an important role in winning a lot. Which I would argue is at least similar to being the main man at a team that have achieved much much less. That's my opinion anyway.
I don't think trophies make you a better player. Reece James hasn't done much with injuries. Rashford deserves his place. And saka is way better than Trent. Kelvin Philips won the treble does he deserve to be known as one of the greatest cdm's in history?
He's redefined a position, he has won everything there is to win at club level, he's the club vice-captain, his passing is elite and he has a crazy amount of assists, how can he not be S?
Balon D'or shouts for Saka? WTF are we doing. Has 1 exceptional season and he gets Balon D'or shouts. Rabid behavior here, might as well say Michu could've won a Balon D'or
This backdrop, this camera quality, the outfit - Joe looking good! Keep up this format!
Pretending Ben Johnson and Oliver Skipp are anywhere near Longstaffs level is crazy 😂
Skipp is better mate
Outstanding comedy
Reece James and Rashford should be in the tier A, not S. Not enough consistency (form/game time)
United fans still think Rashford is a world class player…he’s the most inconsistent player in the league both within a game and across seasons. IQ of a toddler.
We are talking about a champions league winner are you serious
Rashfords has scored 100 goals for united I reckon he's an S
Reece won us multiple trophies while playing a pivotal part don’t mention him in the same bracket as rashford
Hi Football Fans 👋 One Player That Is Too good for you club is on our channel NOW🚨 Check it out👍🏻
Longstaff should be in A based on comparisons of what is in B, he has played over 100 PL matches, one of the core members of Newcastle getting CL, and overall is so underrated and under appreciated by everyone other than Newcastle fans (even some actually don’t appreciate him). Nobody in the b-list has done more than what longstaff has done and he should be in A
Him and Ramsey in that tier with those others is strange
Hahahahaha
Joe is so safe with his opinions. Every decent player going into S tier is a cop out. Should be reserved for Saka and Trent only.
No Foden in S tier? Are you mad?
Doing Ramsey dirty with the other inclusions in the B tier. He’s head and shoulders above the rest of them
Foden has started 10/12 games this season… and got six G+A from those ten.
He starts most games, are people not paying attention?
The take that Foden doesn’t ever start is really a hangover from last year and has always been used to downplay the level of talent he has
Foden has been playing a very important role for us this season however he Is okay a more b silva role this season you will see the best of him. In th prem last season he had better mind per gc than saka and he only played half the minutes of saka
He also started last season until he got injured, people just dont watch
Yea he's starting a lot of games now, but that's because alot of City's stars are either out of the club or injured.
It’s partly because not as many people care about City and don’t pay attention. Obviously very successful side but the amount of support amongst generations above school age won’t be at the levels of other big clubs
Never thought I’d get to say I’ve scored against a player mentioned in a football daily video, but now I can. Cheers Ellery.
Finally a good Trent Alexander-Arnold take
as good as he is attacking wise he is as bad in defense,ranking him as his natural position RB he is an A at best,but B for me,if we were ranking him as a cm he would be S
Nope bad take.
@@LocalNoob_2Saying Trent is a B is delusional 💀💀
@@sethbrand9009 saying he is a S rated right back when he can't do 50% of his job is crazy aswell buddy
@@LocalNoob_2 Saying Trent can't defend is not true. You can't win every trophy available to you with a right back who can't defend. His defensive awareness can be poor but it isn't as bad as people make it out to be. Saying he is B tier when he is one of the most successful players ever 24 doesnt make sense.
Longstaff should definitely have been in A!!!!
I dont think any player for Newcastle was stunted quite as much under Steve Bruce as Sean Longstaff was. (Except for maybe Joelinton). Longstaff was smashing it under Benitez and linked to Man Utd. The difference with him out of the side in this Eddie Howe setup is remarkable. We simply couldnt win games without him last season. Should easily be in A tier
I agree with you he should be in the b tier with possibly Ramsey, but never the A tier, they're the proven world class talents.
i think for S-tier to have meaning it has to be one of the least populated categories. speaking as an arsenal fan, based on achievements and availability i feel like you could reduce the S tier to foden and trent, MAYBE saka.
They really put the daily into football daily
The disrespect to Longstaff in this is outrageous. What man got do get some respect
Would love to see rankings with similar themes for the bigger european clubs as well, especially now that EFD isnt with us anymore!
Harsh on Bueno, you were full of praise for him in the games he did play and he is only out of the team thanks to ait nouri who is an excellent leftcback, should not place under skipp
Rashford in S tier is an absolute joke
Hilarious
No it’s not you prisoner of the moment he’s literally won player of the year for United achieved more individually than most of these players
@@aze4964inconsistent though😂
@@aze4964 that says more about United than rashford in fairness
Facts. In 8 seasons he has scored 77 goals. Take out a 2 month period last season in which he scored 11 goals, he was shocking. Rashford is the most overrated player in the league
La Cobham is the Best simple name another PL side with as many Academy players in the top 5 Leagues and has had as many academy players play for the first team
Could be Cobham, could be the catchment area, seems like south London is a hotbed of talent. Probably both. Don't think anyone would disagree, it's a shame almost all of them will need to leave to get a game.
The odds of all our youth being in the first team is small for many reasons but we do give more minutes than to youth than most Prem sides
@@jrb614 that’s a myth. Chelsea give them loads of opportunities. Its just they produce so much talent you can’t give them all a go
Hi Football Fans 👋 One Player That Is Too good for you club is on our channel NOW🚨 Check it out👍🏻
TAA is the guy. Once our defence is fixed he's ballon d'or man.
Fantastic player
I believe Szoboszlai is future Ballon D'Or.
True Gary.. Szobo is the next big thing..
@@rajivroy5047 unlike a lot of fans, I haven't just been following him since he signed for Liverpool, I knew about him from RB Salzburg through to RB Leipzig, he is a special talent.
Hi Football Fans 👋 One Player That Is Too good for you club is on our channel NOW🚨 Check it out👍🏻
Hugo Bueno being in D Tier has got to be some kind of joke
Good stuff Joe great content!!!
Best video in a visual sense in ages
Man Utd fan discounting the community shield? I'd never thought I'd see the day
Weird considering that's the most of anything Man United have ever won lol.
Respect for bigging up TAA. I’m an Iron but he’s been amazing. He could be an amazing #8 imo - he sprays a pass like Silva in his prime.
Which silva?
*kidding lol*
Gr8 vid as allways.
Reece James, Gallagher and Levi Colwell for Chelsea
Joe channelling his inner Professor Green with this backdrop hahaha
Bueno is miles better than Johnson but Johnson's two tiers ahead 🤔
Come off it, put James and Rashford down into A where they belong
I KNOW
Reece James has not done enough to be in the tier with Bukayo and Trent, especially in the league. He had one really good season and hasn't matched the same heights since
not really on him as he came back to find the team ridiculously low on on confidence,reece is a special talent and has the skillset to become the best right back of all time forget the the passing,shooting and defensive skills you must watch how he takes on defenders so effortlessly like a winger as his body structure also helps just bully the opposition honestly we've never seen anyone with such a complete skillset at that position..its a pity he's always injured
What has Saka achieved for arsenal. It’s just recency bias. If this was 2021 you wouldn’t say that. If Reece doesn’t belong then saka doesn’t
The audacity to say Reece hasn’t done enough than say Saka has. What has he won? Brush your gums
@@nowan2121 what has who won? James or saka?
@@olajideolabode5652 Saka. I’m an arsenal fan and even i can admit reece is 100% in that top category
Thought this was supposed to be graduates this year i.e United Mainoo or Hannibal
Rate each clubs academy next
Unpopular opinion: if city and Liverpool weren’t at eachothers throats from 18-22, madrid would not have won all those ucls.
They only won 1 during that period?
Rashford and James are A tier. Especially Rashford.
People rate James on what he could be instead of what he is. He's an injury prone player who can't string gametime together for the life of him. Saying hes world class is ridiculous, you need to be a weekly starter to be world class and not only do it every 5 months when your fit for a game or two
No branthwait for Everton?
How is Dunk A, a literal club legend and maybe their best ever academy player if not player period.
And James in S, bro can't put two games together without his knee breaking
And what has Dunk won?
You can't even compare them
@@edwardchamberlain8476 league one, championship promotion and staying in the side to Europe through thick and thin.
Reece James won a few trophies injured
Saka won one
Rashford is more inconsistent than shit porridge
It depends on how you look at the video. I think Lewis Dunk is our most important player, a club legend and is certainly in S tier if the task is to rank him as an academy graduate based on his career and contribution. But if the task is to rank him as a player (and this is what I think Joe is doing), I can understand why he’d be in A and not S. I guess he’s not ‘elite.’
@skaoxyz Dunk's underrated, I would say he's elite, not world class but elite for sure.
Reece James constantly living on previous seasons. Bloke has missed over 80 games of football in 4 seasons.
divine mubama for West ham, he scored 2 goals in our road to the final
Ramsey has to be in the A class
Skipp might not be the guy - but our academy is getting really strong!
😂😂
😂😂
Comparing skipp to longstaff is offensive to Sean
Haven’t watched yet, but only S tiers r Saka and Trent maybe Foden or Rashford but I don’t think so
Rashford and Reece James in S, what is going on?!
why is rice not on there over ben johnson, he came through west hams academy aswell as chlesea, but he he was at west ham from the age of like 14 hahaha
Very interesting
I don’t get why people use team trophies to celebrate an individual player, it prevents about 14 players from getting in the top tiers, using individual awards would make way more sense
Skipp over Kane as our graduate is mental
Didn't know Kane is a current player 😅
Ball knowledge
where is this tier list?
You should revive Euro Football daily. Some subscribers want to see more videos on La Liga, Bundesliga and Serie A.
They don’t necessarily have to revive it but I would enjoy seeing more content specific to those leagues maybe. I think the divided channels were just losing viewers
@@sethbrand9009 I hope they pay a little more attention on other Leagues
Trent and Saka should be the only ones at tier S
Lewis Dunk desrved the S tier
2:29 "I'm not disrespecting Aston Villa..." - but you kinda are, Joe. You kinda are.
Jacob Ramsey big move? That is disrespecting Villa. He'll get Champions League at Villa if we keep building.
Ramsey b?
Jacob Ramsey in the same tier as Skipp and Johnson is laughable Joe mate come on
Yeah that’s laughable🤣 Ramsey is unbelievably good, better than Grealish was at the same age. He has all the tools to go right to the top
Spot on, and below Dunk a player that I appreciate but can’t be 1 category above Ramsey. And to have Rashford 2 categories above too. 🤪
Let’s face it this is based on watching highlights and a couple of games per season… can’t have watched all the players extensively.
foden never injured??? if were talking never injured thats saka if anything
Rashford is just like lingard. Lingard is a starboy until we know he's 30 years.
Putting Ramsey, Mitchell and longstaff in the same tier as Ben Johnson and Skipp is silly
Can You guys compare the Incomparable? His name is MG11. he is our best academy graduate no matter his current position. Rashford is not our best
Why in the world have you gone for Ben Johnson over Declan Rice?
Because its grads that currently play for their club......
@@adawongsitonmyface The title says "RANKING EACH CLUBS BEST ACADEMY GRADUATE"
Rice was at Chelsea for longer than West Ham I think
No. Chelsea from 2006-2013, West Ham from 2013-2023. See: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declan_Rice@@Zzzzzzzz390
Just changed these segments to JNTR "Joe Needs To Rank"
1. CHELSEA
2. CRYSTAL PALACE
3. MAN CITY
4. ARSENAL
we all live in the world of Ryan Yates
Only S Tiers should be Saka and Foden
James in tier A is a joke, chelseas formation covers his lack to defend where trent gets ripped apart.
Surely Brennan Johnson instead of Ryan Yates
Hmmmmmmmm... I mean Rashford is probably between S and A and might move a couple of the Ds to C but anyway...
Let me get this straight. You won't count Saka's community shield wins but you count Reese James' supercup? That's poor from you Joe.
Dunk💥💥💥💥
Cmon man James is not in the same category as Saka he never plays!!!!
If he doesn't put TAA at the very top level then its shambolic
s tier is for saka taa and foden,
A tier dunk Rashford James
rashford isnt half as good as united fans claim he is, james is permanently injured
Still insane to me that Harry Kane isn’t on this list
Is he in the premier league currently?
He plays in Germany 😂
Rashford should be A & Bueno should be C
Why is everything about trophies? Trophy logic doesn't make sense to me because trophies don't or should not determine a player ability. Example: Harry Kane (the best striker in the world for the last 5 five years consistently, maybe more) pretty much has no trophy therefore "has not reached his potential", compared to Nacho from Real Madrid who has won every single trophy possible although he is never been first choice, according to trophy logic, "he is an expectational player, S-tier stuff" due to trophies won. I must also add that trophies are essentially won by clubs and not players and it's not always the best clubs with the best players that win trophies (Man Utd always win some sort of trophy almost ever season but...).
But more on the video, Ramsey, Mitchell and Longstaff and not same tier as Skipp and Johnson. Put some respect on these guys
Can tell you work with sky, putting trent top because he was Once really productive when he was able to get away with not doing a massive part of his job as a full back.
James should be nowhere near the s tier availability is a huge factor
Rashford is maybe an A. But i think he is just b+
Putting James and Foden in the same tier as Saka and Trent is embarrassing. You can’t rely on potential forever and James and Foden just haven’t lived up to the hype
Are you high?
Foden hasn't lived up to potential.
His numbers alone prove you wrong. He puts up similar numbers to Saka despite being injured and limited game time.
Watch him play before you spout nonsense.
Also I'm not trying to be mean, but your take is so Ludacris that I couldn't help myself.
What a horrendous take. I can agree on James but your take on foden is hilariously bad. He’s literally on the level of Saka and consistently puts up the same numbers as Saka. Just because he didn’t start as much last season doesn’t mean he hasn’t lived up to the hype. You’re just saying that because he plays for city
@@nadirabdelnour756 a year or two ago and I would agree with you. But Saka has consistently been improving and Foden has stagnated. He’s still good, don’t get me wrong, but at one point he was considered to be the best young English talent and for now at least Bellingham, Rice, and Saka have passed him.
Why you act like Saka is better than Foden?😅
@@xixo4798 I can’t tell if you are joking or not, nobody thinks Foden is better than Saka lol it’s not 2020 anymore
10:12 😅
Saka is 100% gonna win the balon dor in his carreer
😅 That's so disrespectful to Saka, Rashford and Reece James is not even in the same League.
Ramsey in the same tier as skipp longstaff and Ben Johnson is a disgrace
Rashford, James and Foden should be in A tier based on their careers so far
rashford been in multiple TOTS,won trophies for his boyhood club,had over 40 G/A last season,and is generally good in every season how tf is that not an S? Foden aswell? one of the most talented players in the league,if not the most talented,won a treble and multiple pl titles with his boyhood club.,..you are speaking nonsense buddy
Your opinion is based on recent form. All 3 are elite level players. You could make a case for James due to his injuries but he is still world class nonetheless
When you say "career" what do u mean? Foden has won more and been playing at the highest level for longer than saka. And actually you could say the same about rashford.
I think he's basing it more on their talent anyway.
hardly playing, spent most his career on the bench lol @@digit432
@@niallmcgirr7697 agreed, but still played an important role in winning a lot. Which I would argue is at least similar to being the main man at a team that have achieved much much less. That's my opinion anyway.
Saka, FA cup winner, league bottler, euro bottler, world class bottler
Saka Ballon dor..... if he wasn't English he'd be a very good player that's all
Oh cmon
I don't think trophies make you a better player. Reece James hasn't done much with injuries. Rashford deserves his place. And saka is way better than Trent. Kelvin Philips won the treble does he deserve to be known as one of the greatest cdm's in history?
Rj not on the level of saka? Rj has had better wingers in his pockets than him
Rashford 🙈
James and Rashford down. Dunk and Longstaff up. Bueno placement is a joke. Come on Joe.
J.Ramsey in B tier is a joke 😂
Trent anywhere higher than tier 3 is an absolute joke
He's redefined a position, he has won everything there is to win at club level, he's the club vice-captain, his passing is elite and he has a crazy amount of assists, how can he not be S?
Foden, James and Rashford dont belong with Saka and Trent.
Reece James in S is laughable 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Poor judgement Saka is something different from this lot
Balon D'or shouts for Saka? WTF are we doing. Has 1 exceptional season and he gets Balon D'or shouts. Rabid behavior here, might as well say Michu could've won a Balon D'or
Jacob ramsey B, is this a joke
Wtf is James doing in s, barely plays and when he does he's average at best 😂😂😂 (also Purple patch ford)
Reece James in S tier is a joke
lol how so?