“It is actually a war of annihilation of the entire Gaza Strip ” In a sobering interview, historian
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 гру 2024
- “It is actually a war of annihilation of the entire Gaza Strip.” In a sobering interview, historian Omer Bartov tells me about his recent visit to Israel, his reaction to the IDF saying they only target military targets, and why his view on the question of genocide has now changed.
*It's astonishing that Christiane Amanpour does not yet know what is happening in Gaza.*
Hear no evil see no evil.....CNN
@Jean, She knows. She doesn't care. None of the zi o minions do.
She knows but she is a very hypocritical CNN typical naught off
She knows but the ones who pay her have her on a leash.
@ 100% agree. I don’t understand people like her. She fled Iran system and you think she will report atrocities taking place against other people let’s say compassion or sympathy. This woman proven nothing but loyal for the money and power.
When did CNN released this interview exactly….9 p.m.central in the U.S. on the 24th December…effectively burying it.
🎯
Senior people in CNN are working for the IDF
1000 percent
And without even giving us any idea of when the interview was conducted or when Prof. Bartov "was in Israel for the second time"! Other videos on YT show him calling Israel's campaign in Gaza a genocide 4 or 5 months ago. DOes that mean they sat on the interview the whole time? Was it done live 4-5 months ago? Many unanswered questions.
@@RobinHerzig 💩
It's not a "war" as she calls it. WAR against an illegally occupied people is illegal, it's a GENOCIDE, the direct continuation of the Nakba of 1948.
The Nakba was self-inflicted, in 1947 November the Arabs could’ve chosen to create a state under United Nations GA 181 however, the Arabs refused and chose to start a civil war. In 1937 the peel commission offered a state for the Arabs, the Jews agreed the Arabs was rejected it. While the Arabs only occupied 3 1/2% of the land of the mandate for Palestine, the Jews occupied roughly 9% of the land. Since the 1880s Jerusalem., Safed, Acre, have been populated primarily by Jews. In 2000 the Clinton parameters would’ve given the Arabs a state, they refused.
@@johndunne7900That’s false, but even if true it’s irrelevant.
There is no illegal occupation.
@@neilltavernier4586 Everyone in the world except one tiny country in the Levant disagrees with you.
@@neilltavernier4586 I know you'll delete this reply, so I've put it in two locations. Yes, there is. DECADES of international criminality. The ICJ concluded that Israel should put an end to its illegal occupation of the Palestinian territories, desist from creating new settlements, and evacuate those already established. It further concluded that where Palestinians have lost land and property, that Israel should pay reparations. By the way, why has Israel made it illegal for Israelis to share the results of their DNA tests? Could it be that their DNA proves they have no genetic ties to the Middle East, and are truly nothing but terrorist invaders?
It's what 19 year olds on campuses across the U.S have been trying to tell you. It's what the entire World has been screaming for more than a year. It's what we can all see on our phones every day. But let's get some more analysis on what's going on because eh we kinda aren't sure yet.
It is you who “kinda aren’t sure yet”, dear Chris Frantnazis…. The real world, not your antisemitic crowd, perfectly knows what is going on…
It is you who “kinda aren’t sure yet”, dear Chris Frantnazis…. The real world, not your antisemitic crowd, perfectly knows what is going on…
Thank you. I’m still wondering, after 14 months of genocide and 77 years of ethnic cleansing by Israel, Christiane still acts befuddled when an expert declares this.
😂😂😂😂😂
What do you mean by 77 years of ethnic cleansing ?
She is #manufacturingConsent
That is her job.
It's what she is paid to do.
@@haydenharris3059how else do you describe being under constant threat from your jailers.
@@haydenharris3059 antisemitism
Killing, or prohibiting all of the people reporting on the people being killed is a self-report.
Nazis also did not allowed press into auschwitz and they created propaganda films to fool people
Christiane please can you do MORE??? Those children in Gaza need HELP
Thank you for honouring Hind Rajab in your profile picture. That little girl’s story is still haunting me.
p.stinians have brought it upon themselves
@JDshao Please make Hind your profile photo too. She is the Anne Frank of Gaza
Yes, Christian’s, please, we do not care about Jewish children hostages in Gaza, we do not care about raped and murdered Jewish women, we do not care about murdered old women and men…. Just talk about lack of water delivered to Hamas Gaza from Israel.
Yes, please, Christiane, we do not care about Jewish children hostages in Gaza, we do not care about raped and murdered Jewish women by Hamas innocent civilians… we care about why not enough clean water is delivered from Jewish state to Hamas.
She is weak and sold out... for shame... could have used her reputation for good, but in fact her true colours are on display, and they are bad
Her true colours are are white and blue always will be.. Decent people should not be on her pro israhell propaganda show
Omer Bartov is one of the best communicators on the Zio nist devastation throughout this geno side
The presenter feel at ease to describe what happened on 7th xxx but has never called what has gone on since same despite the mass destruction & killing!
Speaking truth to power
It has always been a genocide since 1948.
have brought it upon themselves
@@davidwilson448 By being illegally occupied, displaced or murdered since 1948? Quit lying.
@@afterkwiss how can occupy your own home?
@@afterkwiss rubb|e-stinians have brought it upon themselves
But its’s not their home is it….and numerous UN resolutions prove it!
That was a pretty abrupt end to this upload. "Israel cannot..." what?
Ooops Prof Bartov probably just dropped some devastating knowledge on CNN that was too much for them to handle + impossible to dispute
Do we need to mention Oct 7th in every interview? The Palestinians have been experiencing Oct 7th for 80 years.
Are you really surprised of what he said?!
This is not a war. It’s the General’s Plan. The retired general said the quiet part out loud. It’s the expulsion of a people to steal its land, otherwise known by a word starting with a letter following two letters after E. and also three letters after.
The premise that you’re calling it a war is absurd.
A wsr is between 2 standing armies, this doesn't qualify
She's act like nothing happened?
Yes whole West .And they know it is genocide they know long time .West show No morality and depravation
Amanapour is married to an American Jew😂
Finally, a little decent honest reporting from CNN design his propaganda machine!
A population kept in bondage resisting against their subjugation is not called a war in international. It is called armed RESISTANCE for decades now. Mrs Amanpour, you rightly say that "we can't verify independently". Let that be your bottom line.
A population that has chosen war each time they've had the option of peace cannot be said to be resisting, when you break out of prison, you don't go on a killing spree. Only in Palestine does this happen, nowhere else in the world.
A population who’s majority are children didn’t choose anything…..stop this tiresome idiotic arguments allready…and even if they choose whateve,should majority face anihilation for acts of minority?Most israelis apparently think yes,that’s why most of the world see them as inhumane monsters!
Can we finally move on from the deliberations now its getting a bit tedious. I suppose we should all have expected there would necessarily be a bit of a delayed response due to however far away in terms of relative distance between Earth to whichever nebulous star or far flung planet or unknown galaxy outer space Christiane and her associates must be broadcasting from.
"They" wrote the " Protocols " Look it up. Be prepared to be attacked as an "Anti-Semitic Conspiracy Theorist" for so much as keywording it.
is this a waver in the selective myopia? its a christmas miracle!
Every now and then the light breaks through the cracks
Interesting point to cut off the video
"Looks like Germany at the end of the war."
Try Poland.
Mind-bogglingly one-sided and deceptive. Is this what journalism has come to?
Did we fight WW2 until they couldn't offer "real" resistance or until they surrendered?
Joined Dec 26, 2024= paid mossad bot
Are hostages already free?
No , there are still many Palestinian hostages being hold in Israeli terror dungeons. At least 10.000 of them. But thanks for showing your concerns ❤
@ You are welcome, but can you name exactly persons who you allege are illegally hold as “hostages” in as you say in “Israeli terror dungeons” ? Also, please name those “terror dungeons” where convicted terrorists get university education, medical care that Arabs don’t have in their countries, high quality religiously clean food , etc. Otherwise…. you are a filthy antisemite…
Why such a bad efit from a professional channel ? Video terminates suddenly ay 14:59 .
His idea is that Israel has to make it a fair fight?
Joined Dec 26, 2024= paid mossad bot
I have rarely heard so much garbage in one "interview" in my life.
Is there a war? Where are the active Palestinian combatants? And if yes given the pictures presented, when will the total defeat occur?
Oh this woman is steel working???
Nice, it just took you 14+ months.
what's the most unfortunate is , this bullshit rederick, herts the palistins more than helps
Algo
????????????????Hostages????????????????????????? How many times did he mention the Hostages??????????
Israel has killed them all
How many hostages are in Isreali prissons? How many hostages has been killed by the IDF?
DOES Nantanyahu care about hostages?
Nothing good will come out of this..
The terrorist attack was completely over on 10/7. They could have spent a couple weeks or months negotiating for hostages before starting their annihilation campaign. Unfortunately, revenge and annexation were just too important to wait 🙄.
Satanyahu doesn't care about hostages. If hostages released he has to stop the war but he doesn't want to finish the war.
Maybe ask Nethanyu, who does not give a hoot about hostages. He coukd have had them out in the first week, but he chose to use them as a reason to exterminate a population.
Fake news,enough of this rubbish.
Fake news come from zionists.Enough of this rubbish
I find Omer Bartov speaking more from his own interpretation rather than the facts. For instance, he doesn't seem to understand why the IDF moved Gazans around to the south to Rafah and later out of Rafah. The IDF of course is methodically destroying the large network of tunnels and so the repeated movement of civilians to different parts makes sense and the IDF did explain this. Likewise, he doesn't understand that the many buildings which are bombed are precisely because of the tunnels built under all those buildings and that's the only way to destroy those tunnels where Hamas fighters are hiding. There is a good report on these actions by a UK military man in the following link - well worth watching.
ua-cam.com/video/GGMadJ2pviY/v-deo.html
The # of births in Gaza exceeds the # of deaths (even using their #'s), so this is the worst genocide ever!
Joined Dec 26, 2024= paid mossad bot
What boule sheeet. If this were the case it would have been all over in 40 minutes on 8 October
Germans also could finish it in 3 months. So it's not genocide what happened there. Right Einstein ? 😂
Raz seagal has said months ago