Congrats Prof. Manabe! Your talk had lots of important messages for Japanese scientific research in future. I strongly hope Japanese government receive your advice seriously.
Princeton has an amazing awesome Nobel prize party in 2021. 5 Princeton scholars and graduates won the prizes in the four fields. Wow the No.1 university in the world. Go Princeton~~~~ I love Princeton.
Being a Japanese native who discarded the nationality in order to be naturalized as U. S. citizen myself, I found the Japanese reporter's question was offensive. Generally people in Japan don't like a person who thinks differently and questions a lot, they expect you to "behave not to disturb the harmony" and be considerate of others, as Prof. Manabe says. I have a theory that being a small island and experience the most natural disasters so often (earthquake, tsunami, typhoon and hurricane, volcano eruption, you name it) throughout its history, Japan may cultivated the culture where an individual not to act differently, not to stray from herd in order to survive? When a massive natural disaster hit, acting different means death and somehow Japanese people remember that in their DNA? Anyway, congratulations and thank you to Prof. Manabe, I'm happy that his long time work was recognized at the age of 90.
I'm Chinese and the situation in China is quite similiar to the one in Japan. So my hypothesis is the influence of Confucianism creates our obedience to authority, to the majority at an early age.
i would`ve answer to that question: (why do you care ?)そもそもどっちか選べなきゃいけないのは可笑しい。It just amuse me how the media in Japan says "Japanese with American Citizenship Won the Physics Nobel price", by their definition he is not longet Japanese but because He won a Nobel price, the media sudenly fills their chest with patriotism and out of no where "a Japanese won the Nobel price"is in every article with his name written in 漢字when other people who has discarded the Japanese Citizenship don`t get the same treatment...
50:40 The reason why Dr. Manabe had to choose American citizenship over his native country is because Japan does not allow double citizenship by law. Otherwise, he still is a Japanese scientist as well as American. It actually took Dr. Manabe 17 years of residency in the US to eventually decide to apply for the American citizenship.
Congrats on your Nobel Prize in physics. Your reseach and efforts on climate change gave a lot of insight into the future generations in Atmospheric Sciences.
Congratulations Dr. Manabe, you are an inspiration in many dimensions. This Nobel prize is well deserved and has a lot of spiritual lessons too. Though you say you are not an advocate of harmony, it seems to be the driving force behind your work, even your change of nationality from Japanese to the American has a lot in it in terms of love for harmony. Great choice "Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences"
Let us welcome and congratulate Benjamin List and David W.C. MacMillan for jointly getting the Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2021 for the development of asymmetric organocatalysis." #nobleprizeinchemistry2021 #nobleprize #aminulcheminnovation #chemistry #nobleprize2021
Yeah it’s disgrace. Japanese media are celebrating his achievements in the US as if it belonged to them. The same thing happened to Nambu who had a tremendous career in the US. Another example was Nakamura at UCSB who invented blue LEDs. His work wasnt properly evaluated in Japan. Celebrating their accomplishments is fine I guess but they should see where credits are due. Manabe’s research has been supported mostly by US throughout his career, and he chose to become an American. It’s his personal choice. That question gave me a sense of mugging his achievement. Japanese PM also gave a speech that he’s proud of Dr. Manabe’s achievement as a Japanese(wtf). Dead wrong.
@@0720emyu Not really. At a Prof Manabe level, he would appreciate the reporter of Kyoto News, which is liberal media in Japan. That sounded rude but that question was necessary to ask Prof. Manabe and the Japanese goverment. What the Japanese goverment has been doing is not allow the Japanese citizens to have dual citizenships and enjoy freedom in the fields.
I’m pretty sure the Japanese media wanted to report him as a Japanese citizen but they can’t so I guess they are “curious” about his decision to choose the us over Japan. He told us to be curious so what’s wrong with this question tho?
It's much easier to hear with the link below, no breaking-ups: ua-cam.com/video/Y_cdtWVr5M0/v-deo.html It's the same press conference. Part of the first comment from Dr. Manabe was cut. Other than that, it pretty much covers the whole thing.
In most Asian regions including India, Rule of Thumb is that the more you're educated, the better you're at speaking and writing in English. In Japan, it used to be completely opposite. Even today, high level scholars are not expected to make a speech in English. They've never had a single prime minister with decent fluency in English since the beginning of democratic governance. Never in history.
That’s because most other Asian countries have learn science and technology from the West where English is the way to communicate. Japanese is very good at their own, they don’t need English to get good education. They build their science and technology in Japanese.
it is so frustrating trying to listen to this which would be so interesting. there are constant dropouts of audio! Can't Princeton do better than this?
Is it an American advantage to be able to do whatever you want and not worry about what others think? Isn't it time to start caring a little about other people's feelings?
I think Japanese people are more aggressive than you think. It's considered as good thing that caring someone and bothering someone. It makes unusual person hard to live. Sorry if I offended you, but as a Japanese, I think America is better country at that point. And that's why many people leave Japan.
EXPANDING UNIVERSE.MENTIONED IN HOLY QUR'AN 1500 YEARS AGO ALMIGHTY ALLAH THE ORIGINATOR TO THE UNIVERSE AND CREATOR OF THE MANKIND Who can claim 1350 years ago that the universe is expending? والسماء بنينها بايد و انا لموسعون o " And the heaven We built it with power, and indeed, We are the expander " (And We it is Who make the vast extent, thereof ) (Qur'an, 51:47) Until 1931, physicist Albert Einstein believed that the universe was static. An urban legend attributes this change of perspective to when American astronomer Edwin Hubble showed Einstein his observations of redshift in the light emitted by far away nebulae - today known as galaxies. After Hubble discovered that the universe was expanding, Einstein called the cosmological constant his "greatest blunder." At around the same time, larger telescopes were being built that were able to accurately measure the spectra, or the intensity of light as a function of wavelength, of faint objects. Almighty Allah is the Creator of the whole universe.He says: Should He not know what He created? And He is the Subtile, the Aware. The knowledge of scientists is very limited and insufficient to understand the universe! ! Recently NASA launched JWST. This telescope will see the beginning of the universe and how it evolved. Today the scientists accepted that they know very little about the universe. DR.MOHAMMAD LAEEQUE NADVI Ph.D. (Arabic Lit.) M.A. Arabic Lit. Director Amena Institute of Islamic Studies & Analysis A Global & Universal Research Institute Donate to promote this Institute SBI A/C30029616117 Kolkata,Park Circus Branch nadvilaeeque@gmail.com Thanks
Congrats Prof. Manabe! Your talk had lots of important messages for Japanese scientific research in future. I strongly hope Japanese government receive your advice seriously.
Manabe-san is 90years old and his mother language is Japanese. Not only study but also he gave speech in English. It’s amazing.
He was around during WWII and the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings.
@Rainbow's Room yeah decades bruh
That’s kinda racist.
Princeton has an amazing awesome Nobel prize party in 2021.
5 Princeton scholars and graduates
won the prizes in the four fields.
Wow the No.1 university in the world.
Go Princeton~~~~
I love Princeton.
Congratulations for the Nobel Prize Physics
CONGRATULATIONS DR. MANABE AND PRINCETON UNIVERSITY FROM PERU
Being a Japanese native who discarded the nationality in order to be naturalized as U. S. citizen myself, I found the Japanese reporter's question was offensive. Generally people in Japan don't like a person who thinks differently and questions a lot, they expect you to "behave not to disturb the harmony" and be considerate of others, as Prof. Manabe says. I have a theory that being a small island and experience the most natural disasters so often (earthquake, tsunami, typhoon and hurricane, volcano eruption, you name it) throughout its history, Japan may cultivated the culture where an individual not to act differently, not to stray from herd in order to survive? When a massive natural disaster hit, acting different means death and somehow Japanese people remember that in their DNA? Anyway, congratulations and thank you to Prof. Manabe, I'm happy that his long time work was recognized at the age of 90.
I'm Chinese and the situation in China is quite similiar to the one in Japan. So my hypothesis is the influence of Confucianism creates our obedience to authority, to the majority at an early age.
i would`ve answer to that question: (why do you care ?)そもそもどっちか選べなきゃいけないのは可笑しい。It just amuse me how the media in Japan says "Japanese with American Citizenship Won the Physics Nobel price", by their definition he is not longet Japanese but because He won a Nobel price, the media sudenly fills their chest with patriotism and out of no where "a Japanese won the Nobel price"is in every article with his name written in 漢字when other people who has discarded the Japanese Citizenship don`t get the same treatment...
Thank you for sharing, Princeton U. I really
enjoy it. Congratulations, Dr. Manabe·
50:40 The reason why Dr. Manabe had to choose American citizenship over his native country is because Japan does not allow double citizenship by law. Otherwise, he still is a Japanese scientist as well as American. It actually took Dr. Manabe 17 years of residency in the US to eventually decide to apply for the American citizenship.
Congratulation Dr. Manabe and their family! A question about his wife is really interesting and touching👍
Congrats on your Nobel Prize in physics. Your reseach and efforts on climate change gave a lot of insight into the future generations in Atmospheric Sciences.
As a former of Princeton, I am totally happy to see Nobel committee recognise and honour Dr.Manabe's work.
Congratulations Dr.Manabe.
But he received his prize for developing the worst climate model. It has the largest error rate of all climate models.
Congratulations Dr. Manabe, you are an inspiration in many dimensions. This Nobel prize is well deserved and has a lot of spiritual lessons too. Though you say you are not an advocate of harmony, it seems to be the driving force behind your work, even your change of nationality from Japanese to the American has a lot in it in terms of love for harmony. Great choice "Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences"
Manabe received this prize for creating the worst climate model. It has the largest errors of all models.
Why is the sound so bad? Great opportunity to teach climate science, which we are in dire need of, blown by unbearable sound.
His climate model is a joke. It runs too hot ... ua-cam.com/video/98zl8SlObLE/v-deo.html
Let us welcome and congratulate Benjamin List and David W.C. MacMillan for jointly getting the Nobel Prize in Chemistry 2021 for the development of asymmetric organocatalysis." #nobleprizeinchemistry2021 #nobleprize #aminulcheminnovation #chemistry #nobleprize2021
Congratulations Dr Manabe,
That question about nationality from the Japanese reporter is so rude.
You mean 50:40? Yeah, that’s very rude.
Yeah it’s disgrace. Japanese media are celebrating his achievements in the US as if it belonged to them. The same thing happened to Nambu who had a tremendous career in the US. Another example was Nakamura at UCSB who invented blue LEDs. His work wasnt properly evaluated in Japan. Celebrating their accomplishments is fine I guess but they should see where credits are due. Manabe’s research has been supported mostly by US throughout his career, and he chose to become an American. It’s his personal choice. That question gave me a sense of mugging his achievement.
Japanese PM also gave a speech that he’s proud of Dr. Manabe’s achievement as a Japanese(wtf). Dead wrong.
The way of asking sounds so. Not just the question itself.
@@0720emyu
Not really. At a Prof Manabe level,
he would appreciate the reporter of Kyoto News, which is liberal media in Japan. That sounded rude but that question was necessary to ask Prof. Manabe and the Japanese goverment.
What the Japanese goverment has been doing is not allow the Japanese citizens to have dual citizenships and enjoy freedom in the fields.
I’m pretty sure the Japanese media wanted to report him as a Japanese citizen but they can’t so I guess they are “curious” about his decision to choose the us over Japan. He told us to be curious so what’s wrong with this question tho?
It's much easier to hear with the link below, no breaking-ups:
ua-cam.com/video/Y_cdtWVr5M0/v-deo.html
It's the same press conference. Part of the first comment from Dr. Manabe was cut. Other than that, it pretty much covers the whole thing.
In most Asian regions including India, Rule of Thumb is that the more you're educated, the better you're at speaking and writing in English. In Japan, it used to be completely opposite. Even today, high level scholars are not expected to make a speech in English. They've never had a single prime minister with decent fluency in English since the beginning of democratic governance. Never in history.
That’s because most other Asian countries have learn science and technology from the West where English is the way to communicate. Japanese is very good at their own, they don’t need English to get good education. They build their science and technology in Japanese.
The U-turn Theory: How Indian Ideas are stolen by the West and Covered up | Rajiv Malhotra
ua-cam.com/video/tR6QGe-a8gM/v-deo.html
it is so frustrating trying to listen to this which would be so interesting. there are constant dropouts of audio! Can't Princeton do better than this?
If there were a Nobel Prize in Audio, your university wouldn't win it.
I want this video re-uploaded as sounds are skipped
The sound kills me unbearable, anyways really ground breaking achievement
Congratulations
GREAT, CONGURTULATIONS
His climate model runs too hot ... ua-cam.com/video/98zl8SlObLE/v-deo.html
Prof. Manabe's English cracks me up (**)!
Is it an American advantage to be able to do whatever you want and not worry about what others think?
Isn't it time to start caring a little about other people's feelings?
I think Japanese people are more aggressive than you think. It's considered as good thing that caring someone and bothering someone. It makes unusual person hard to live. Sorry if I offended you, but as a Japanese, I think America is better country at that point. And that's why many people leave Japan.
EXPANDING UNIVERSE.MENTIONED
IN HOLY QUR'AN 1500 YEARS AGO
ALMIGHTY ALLAH THE ORIGINATOR TO THE UNIVERSE AND CREATOR OF THE MANKIND
Who can claim 1350 years ago that the universe is expending?
والسماء بنينها بايد و انا لموسعون o
" And the heaven We built it with power, and indeed, We are the expander "
(And We it is Who make the vast extent, thereof )
(Qur'an, 51:47)
Until 1931, physicist Albert Einstein believed that the universe was static. An urban legend attributes this change of perspective to when American astronomer Edwin Hubble showed Einstein his observations of redshift in the light emitted by far away nebulae - today known as galaxies.
After Hubble discovered that the universe was expanding, Einstein called the cosmological constant his "greatest blunder."
At around the same time, larger telescopes were being built that were able to accurately measure the spectra, or the intensity of light as a function of wavelength, of faint objects.
Almighty Allah is the Creator of the whole universe.He says:
Should He not know what He created? And He is the Subtile, the Aware.
The knowledge of scientists is very limited and insufficient to understand the universe! ! Recently NASA launched JWST. This telescope will see the beginning of the universe and how it evolved. Today the scientists accepted that they know very little about the universe.
DR.MOHAMMAD LAEEQUE NADVI
Ph.D. (Arabic Lit.) M.A. Arabic Lit.
Director
Amena Institute of Islamic Studies
& Analysis
A Global & Universal Research Institute
Donate to promote this Institute
SBI A/C30029616117
Kolkata,Park Circus Branch
nadvilaeeque@gmail.com
Thanks
🤷♀️🏝🏝🤷♀️
Completely wrong.
Agree. His climate model runs too hot ... ua-cam.com/video/98zl8SlObLE/v-deo.html
50:42 この部分日本のマスコミはほとんど報道しないww
Japanese brain is most intelligent brain...
So he’s been in the us for decades, and his English is this?
He was focusing on research, not public speaking.
@@el.t2567 researching with a team using English for decades. That should tell ya something right there. You just don’t get it do you?
Also he is 90 years old. Most people at this age speak worse than that in their native language.