Future Seeds of Tibet | TCV Summer Camp Students | EP 09-19
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- Future Seeds of Tibet | TCV Summer Camp Students | EP 09
Initiative of Stories of Tibetans | Interview 186
"Future Seeds of Tibet" is an initiative by Stories of Tibetans that aims to delve deeper into the lives of the upcoming Tibetan generation. The goal is to develop a more effective educational system that caters to their needs. As part of this initiative, we had the opportunity to interview several students from the US, Canada, and Switzerland who participated in the TCV Summer School program.
Our special thanks to the staffs of TCV Upper and the Summer School Students
Interview and Edit by Kunsang Tenzing
#Tibet #Tibetan #SudaySchool #TCV #TIbetanChildrensVillage #TCVupper #TCVlive #UpperTCV #School #Tibetanrefugee #Refugee #Dhamrahsala #tibetanculture #Kids #Child #Insights
None of these older generation that are commenting can understand the struggle of growing up Tibetan in a different country. It’s so hard! Maybe not as physically hard as growing up as a Tibetan in India. Tibetans overseas definitely experience a sense of privilege even they aren’t aware of, but they also experience a sense of not fully being accepted by neither the western world nor the Tibetan world.
@@user-xq2ij4ze3j To strengthen the bond between the new generations and the Tibetan community, and to ease the challenges faced by young Tibetans in the West, it is crucial to preserve and effectively pass on the Tibetan language to these children. While this is undeniably challenging, it is essential for the survival of Tibetan identity. I feel deep empathy and solidarity with these children, who are innocent and caught in a situation where the responsibility lies with their parents and our broader community.
Unlike Tibetans in Tibet, who lack the freedom of choice we have in the West, we must prioritize the preservation of our language and recognize the urgency of this issue. We cannot afford to be disheartened by our failures; instead, we need to address them with renewed focus. The preservation of Tibetan language requires time, effort, and sacrifice. Everyone can contribute-learning Tibetan is valuable regardless of age. Let’s commit to this vital cause and make a difference.
Agreed 💯
Hmmm but they r Tibetan
I don't know. The Tibetan diaspora is criticizing the CCP for trying to erase the Tibetan language and culture. If the young generations can't speak Tibetan as their first tongue, then we have failed. They're making us look like hypocrites. I can't accept any excuses.
You mean ར་མ་ལུག 😂
My daughter is one of the kids in TCV summer camp. She did all her interview in English, but the amount of she knows and willing to learn about Tibet is proud moment for me. I didn’t failed as a parent. We have an option to send kids to summer camp in U.S to do different activities or go on a vacation. But we choose to sent our daughter to TCV summer camp, we feel that important. So that mean my daughter doesn’t have summer break while rest her friends are enjoying their vacation.
I understand your situation and thank you for being responsible by sending your child here. I appreciate it.
in case any of the Tibetans abroad or any of the kids in this video wishes to improve their Tibetan speaking, here is the link to a video series i started with the sole reason to educate the language. ua-cam.com/video/_Y8d0cvwIuw/v-deo.htmlsi=puY6g9oPcFuXPqvu
I understand the lack of exposure to the language and will surely be upload ing more soon. I have been in the mountains for some time now and wasn't able to continue the series. but i will surely upload more soon.
Pls at the end Kids get benefit from learning rich tibetan culture and value ... So its for own wholesome future
I appreciate your decision making. And also appreciate to those Tibetan children who understand the reason and value of sacrificing vacation. 🎉
Obviously, u have failed a parent. Do you speak to your kids in Tibetan at all? Don't you feel like a hypocrite when you accuse China of erasing our language? I can understand if you don't use your regional dialects anymore, but the Lhasa dialect should be preserved at all costs.
Let's give these kids and their parents a pat on the back for taking on this Tibetan summer camp. It's a big deal.
Some folks are saying we should be all sunshine and rainbows, but let's be real. We've lost our homeland, our people, and our way of life. It hurts.
The criticism might sting, but it shows we care. It's a sign that we're still fighting. If we want to get back what's ours, we need to be tough. We need to learn, work hard, and stand up for ourselves. Let's show the world what we're made of. 🎉🎉🎉
@@premkijhalak5368 unfortunately shame never works as an effective tool of encouragement. I know that shame is prevalent as an encouragement tool in Tibetan society but all it does is create resentment.
These kids are brilliant. Trust me guys it’s not easy to hold on to your language and culture when you are in an alien environment. But these little ones are trying their level best. I’m sure they will learn more as they grow up.
I was born in Bhutan and raised here… all of my friends right from childhood to adolescence are Bhutanese but I can write and speak Tibetan so fluently coz growing up my parents main concern was “she can learn English and Bhutanese language in school but she may lose touch with her own ethnicity “ so they made sure we speak only Tibetan at our home and my dad tutored me regarding Tibetan and my fav book was Gangjong ❤ so my main point is you should be proud to call yourself Tibetan the moment you have curiosity to learn sth about our own country… I am proud of you all💗
Sweet young people! I appreciate their attempts to communicate in Tibetan, their sense of identity and desire to connect. This is how it starts and if we encourage them and laude their efforts, they will flourish and continue to build on it further.
U dont need to appreciate,its a shame that that tibetans cant speak tibetans
There.speaking.tibetan.are.very.jokeing
@@user-cx1ol3lh2ithat’s their parents faults
@@user-cx1ol3lh2ishame has never inspired someone to learn something new. We need these Tibetan youngsters and shaming is the worst strategy to convince them that it is worth learning. Kindness over shame might be more effective.
@@HalfDumb These arent toddlers,their parents weren’t kind enough to speak tibetan in their home and do u think still think kindness can change these kids of lost identity?
First of all, we tried our best even though if we are not talking in Tibetan there’s no point in shaming us for it. Shaming others will not benefit you or us. Just because we weren’t speaking in Tibetan doesn’t mean we aren’t Tibetan. Also our parents tried hard for us to learn fluently and understand Tibetan so if anything it’s not their fault. They are trying hard for us to learn Tibetan and more about our culture that’s the reason why they sent us to TCV summer camp.Us Tibetans who live abroad we do try though to speak Tibetan , but we also have to speak English everywhere, we have to speak it in school, getting around, basically every single day English is spoken most of the time . I’m not saying that learning Tibetan is unnecessary. Adding negative comments won’t do anything with your life or ours especially saying that we are failures and our parents are failures. Judging won’t help anyone. Instead of being negative be positive, support the future Tibetan community instead of trying to bring it down.
Sorry, but I will not accept your excuse. Work harder.
@@nepalirecapsagree with you.
Dear, མཛེས་སྐྱིད please try harder 😊
Hope to see you doing better in upcoming 3 years.
@@premkijhalak5368 well.. that said, I hope they are still Tibetan Buddhists. I don't know, but sometimes I think Buddhism was a mistake. Other times, I think Tibet is lost if we abandon our faith.
ཧཧ, nga zuma tha excuse la mei facts re 😂
As a an Indian and from its ut of Ladakh, i know how to speak tibetan and read n write ofcourse. Its really important to know once own root language and culture.
Proud of you brother ❤
Good job to all these young kids for taking initiative in participating this summer camp👍👍👍 never late to learn, you are still young… you can do it🙌 you all are under 18, good luck to you all🍀 in Europe we Tibetans start learning European languages after 30… so you all can do 👍 it’s never late to learn … keep the spirit 👍
Applause to all great parents who have sent their children for wholesome learning. Good nature and exposure help the development of individual, family and society. Each one of us has our responsibility that we can't deny, law of karma is there and above all WE SHOULD ALWAYS REMEMBER HIS HOLINESS THE DALAILAMA'S GRATEFULNESS AND BLESSINGS.
Proud of each words they spoke. Great parents n children. ❤ nice video👍🙏
Appreciate the parents of those three kids who spoke in Tibetan. Even when they were from Swiss, their parents have taught them well and made them to speak only Tibetan at home their first language being either French or German. They were also sent to private tuition to learn Tibetan. That’s one way to preserve our Tibetan culture even when you move abroad..and don’t even bring the topic of feeling excluded in their school.. we all face racism wherever we go. It’s really important to make them learn their own mother tongue. And one can do such by making a rule to speak only Tibetan at home. A small act, that’s all it takes.
In Swiss countries as a Tibetan, isn’t the main language spoken with most parents from birth Tibetan? Obviously, that’s why the Swiss kids were able to speak Tibetan. But in a first world country in America where 90% of the population speaks English wouldn’t our parents have to adapt to? And as everyone knows the only way to learn a language is to speak it. So it is not a choice it is a need. Unlike you guys in the comment section who have probably been living in India for sometime as a refugee
@@ZeykiNak
Even if the 90% of population in US speaks English that doesn’t mean that you should abondon their mother tongue at home. In an English-speaking environment the kids will naturally become more fluent in English through school, institutions, friends and the media too! But if you don’t initiate such practice of letting them speak Tibetan at home then it could easily be lost in just one generation, which is what the Chinese Communist Party want. They are planning to erase the Tibetan language and culture completely and have even changed the name of our country Tibet to Xizang. Hence it is crucial to teach them Tibetan at a young age no matter if you have moved to the “first world country” or the last.
And I’m not pin-pointing over them having to speak perfect Tibetan, even if it was broken that’s still one step ahead. But the kids here from US barely spoke in Tibetan.. I know some of the kids here from Swiss and they generally speaks fluent French but still manage to keep Tibetan as a part of their lives, even if it’s not perfect. It’s all about the effort of their parents in preserving our Tibetan culture through such practices while allowing them to adapt to the French language dominant environment. I’m not saying that it’s an easy thing to do. And I may have forgotten to mention in my previous comment to also appreciate all the parents for sending their kids to the summer camp to get closer to their culture.
Finally let me ask you this;
Does a Tibetan settling in US makes you a less of refugee to look down on those living in India??
Even if you have managed to get the citizenship that doesn’t erase your roots and the struggles we as a Tibetan community shared as a refugee.
@@andy_k5153 No one is saying we don’t practice the language at home or try to learn. We were saying it is harder to learn Tibetan fluently in a place where the main language you speak is not Tibetan. As for other places like Tibet and India you are surrounded by people who are Tibetan and speak it constantly. In places like the US no one speaks Tibetan and is much harder to learn. So do not try to compare your speaking with ours or try to judge us when you truly don’t know how difficult it is to learn in a foreign country.
@@AnjaliSonn You probably didn’t read the comment did you? Anyways yes, I understand that it’s not easy as it is in Tibet or India. And I’m not forcing anyone to learn or speak Tibetan, nor am I comparing but merely using the kids from Swiss as an example. And that parents can apply such practices as well to preserve the Tibetan language. That’s all. Peace out.✌️
@@andy_k5153 Using them as a example for us is comparing😭
kudos to swiss children for speaking tibetan very well
Appreciated their efforts to speak in Tibetan language ❤
Bravo!!! Feel proud to where you root from.
Their give answer amanzing whether they speak tibetan or not. Thanks for TCV for take responsibility.❤
in case any of the Tibetans abroad or any of the kids in this video wishes to improve their Tibetan speaking, here is the link to a video series i started with the sole reason to educate the language. ua-cam.com/video/_Y8d0cvwIuw/v-deo.htmlsi=puY6g9oPcFuXPqvu
I understand the lack of exposure to the language and will surely be upload ing more soon. I have been in the mountains for some time now and wasn't able to continue the series. but i will surely upload more soon.
Hello everyone, Thank you so much for the video. I think the purpose of making this video is to encourage our youngsters to take more interest in our language and culture. I am proud of my kids speaking good Tibetan but it has never been easy to let them speak because I have to shout each and every moment they are together to speak in Tibetan. So, I can understand that it’s very difficult for parents abroad…! I respect very much other parents and their kids for their choice of speaking the language of their own residential country. There’s nothing wrong in it. It’s their right! No one has the right to point out on them!
I sincerely salute them for taking very keen interest in our language and our valuable culture that they decided to participate in the TCV Summer Camp program. They will learn Tibetan in no time! The will is already there, so the way will follow naturally!!! Don’t you worry!
My message to the people who always complain about language and stuff, is that please don’t discourage the ones who come forward to do something meaningful during their vacation time, instead of enjoying and hanging around somewhere you dream of spending your 6 weeks’ vacation! Don’t you realise how much they sacrified so much? Please respect them and STOP being rude. You will receive nothing in return! So what is the use of blaming??? Hope you will think twice before writing your comments in the future! BOD GYAL LO!!!
I appreciate your efforts in preserving our language, and you are a role model for other parents. But please understand those who are criticizing the new generation. Even I, as a pro-CCP, criticize them for not doing much to preserve our languages. We just can't make ourselves look like hypocrites now, do we? We can all understand if they can't speak their regional dialects, but we can't accept if they can't use the Lhasa "choe-kye" language.
To strengthen the bond between the new generations and the Tibetan community, and to ease the challenges faced by young Tibetans in the West, it is crucial to preserve and effectively pass on the Tibetan language to these children. While this is undeniably challenging, it is essential for the survival of Tibetan identity. I feel deep empathy and solidarity with these children, who are innocent and caught in a situation where the responsibility lies with their parents and our broader community.
Unlike Tibetans in Tibet, who lack the freedom of choice we have in the West, we must prioritize the preservation of our language and recognize the urgency of this issue. We cannot afford to be disheartened by our failures; instead, we need to address them with renewed focus. The preservation of Tibetan language requires time, effort, and sacrifice. Everyone can contribute-learning Tibetan is valuable regardless of age. Let’s commit to this vital cause and make a difference.
People who are born or raised in foreign countries and who Speaks Tibetan so well, I have deep respect to their parents and more over the organization which never fails to provide Tibetan classes and teaches them its unique culture
well done all of you….. u r doing great…. 👍🏻 well done to parent too… for sending their child to embrace own cultures. Small baby step is all we need for greater tmw.
They are very cute
Also spoke very well👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
@@tibetanhopeDakgoboy even puppies are cute! What’s there to applaud for?
@@premkijhalak5368What does this even mean.
@@kiyoyachii you know what I mean, if you don’t, then ignore it. 😎
Appreciate these kids trying their best . Much love . Keep trying
Please before commenting think twice,will it help them or hurt them? I think we Tibetan should be more inclusive and more open minded in order to motivate these dedicated youngsters. I highly appreciate their parents as well them for choosing to learn Tibetan culture and languages.
@@heytenzin3077 hahahahaha hurt?
Being a Tibetan if you could not speak Tibetan.I think your parents have all the answers. བློ་ཕམ་རེད་ད།
You're right. Past tense 😂 but they're learning and that's what matters right? We're supposed to give them a pat on their backs for having chosen to come all the way to india instead of choosing other options where they'd rather learn something else. They got their priorities right. So chillllll
So proud of u guys and u guys r so lucky to have this chance . Thank u TCv for organising such an opportunity
Chinese kids, Spanish kids, Indian kids, south East Asian kids etc who grew up in the US can speak fluently in their native language, I know this bc I went to school when them. We don’t have enough influences around us.
some of them speak really good tibetan that's great. its all because their parents taught well and kept connected them with their language and culture.
They are doing really good 👍🏻
I went to TCV Camp and it was a good experience for me.
Suisse kids n parents ❤Bravo🎉
Very nice one
@StoriesOfTibetans I think you should turn off the comment section. These kids are too young to be exposed to such hate and negativity from random internet strangers. They might process it differently and as they gave you the interview as minors, it’s your responsibility to keep them away from the negativity of the internet and it does not affect them adversely.
Very good point.
Good idea. It's sort of like the CCP way, isn't it?
Not really! They’re just protecting us from GROWN adults shaming children who have many years to learn to Tibetan and are shaming them for not speaking Tibetan! Assuming that they know nothing just because they spoke English for 10-15 minutes!
Not really! More likely trying to protect us from adults attacking us for not speaking Tibetan for 10-15 minutes!
@@nepalirecaps you lack CRITICAL THINKING, u need to learn that first. There is a difference between protecting a minor from negativity and blocking free media from general public.
Appreciated 👏👏👏
👏👏👏
👍🏻👍🏻❤️❤️
It’s little disturbing and heartbreaking to see us loosing our identity as year passes.
It’s very important for parents to make it compulsory for their kids to speak in Tibetan at home. I have my cousin, born in New York, speaks fluent Tibetan coz they speak in Tibetan at home. I think making it compulsory for the kids to speak in Tibetan at home is one good option.
Also if we consider ourselves as Tibetan, we should know Tibetan.
🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰👍👍👍👍👍
Sad, our tibetan future seeds need more TIBETAN LANGUAGE class.
One thing i noticed is that kids born in Europe generally speak better Tibetan than the ones in the States and Canada. I think the main reason behind this is most of the parents in Europe cant speak German, french, dutch etc.. While in the states most of the parents can speak in english, they dont put the extra effort to teach them Tibetan as they are quite comfortable communicating with them. You can also see that kids whose parents are directly from Tibet usually speak better Tibetan than the ones whose parents are from India. No ill intentions, just something that i noticed.
It’s largely depends where these kids live or if their Parents communicate primarily by speaking only Tibetan at home!
Speaking about Tibetan Parents from India or directly from Tibetan doesn’t really make kids speak better or smarter, I assume it has to with Parents upbringing/ education and place or sometime SONAM/karma!
😂 only my assumptions
Tibetan seeds who can’t speak Tibetan and it’s not their fault, Their parents should atleast speak Tibetan at home 😢😢
Cute boy from swiss
Where is this sommercamp?
All Swiss kids speaks Tibetan then the kids from USA
The haters are idiots, how shameful do you have to be to put the pressure of being "the future seeds of Tibet" on the shoulders of literal kids who in fact do not live in Tibet but in AMERICA. They speak English well because they go to AN AMERICAN SCHOOL where they SPEAK ENGLISH. Do you not understand they go to high school where these kids are given assignments that could take hours to finish and afterschool club activities that take over their afternoon? Yet you expect them to magically be fluent in Tibet right away! Not to mention the PARENTS HAVE JOBS!!!! In America, immigrants struggle as they don't have high-paying jobs meaning most of them work OVERTIME and sometimes multiple jobs as well! People who call these children and parents "disgraces" have way too much time on their hands to criticize and hate. I even know some of these students and they all WORK HARD to learn the Tibetan language and its culture, Learning a language cannot be done easily especially not with all these students and their parent's busy schedules. So instead of being an absolute douchebag and a nuisance, EITHER SUPPORT THEM OR DON'T SPEAK.
They like guilt tripping as well, as if that’s help in anyway. I have a feeling they don’t actually care about wanting to teach them Tibet but instead just want to hate on teenagers on the internet. I’m not even surprised though, almost all older Tibet generations are like this, it’s sad.
Tldr: don't go to America
its not even a america only problem I'm sure all immigrants can relate in a way.
First speaking Tibetan
Ain't no way brutha
ཇོ་རིན་པོ་བོད་སྐད་ཞིག་མ་ཤེས་ན་བོད་པ་རེད་ལབ་ན་ཁེ་མཚར་འདྲ་བོ་འདུག ཕྲུ་གུ་འདི་ཚོའི་ཕ་མ་དེ་ཚོས་ཕྲུག་གུ་བདག་པོ་ཡག་པོ་རྒྱབ་ཐུབ་མི་འདུག འགན་ཡག་པོ་ཁུལ་མི་འདུག ཐབས་སྐྱོ་བོ་རེད་ཡ། 😢😖😖😖😖
Rip བོད་སྐད།
@@tenzinchowang9448 😢😔😢
This kids are our tibetan feature lol😂😌
what's there to laugh? also you spelled future wrong
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
@@AnjaliSonn Don't take these comments to heart. They don't represent all of the Tibetan population and why waste time on someone who can't spell future correctly?
Write in tibetan🤡
The Tibetan language I don’t understand even though I’m trying hard to understand what they are saying 🥲 I would request please put English subtitles 🙏🏾
I don't know if you are a Tibetan or not, but I would appreciate if you can at least listen to or sing Tibetan songs.
ལྷན་རྒྱས་ཡོངས་ལ་འབོད་སྐུལ་ཞུ་རྒྱུ། བུ་ཕྲུག་འདི་གའི་བོད་སྐད་ལ་འབད་པ་ཙམ་གྱིས་དགའ་བསུ་ཞུ་མ་ཐུབ་ན་དམའ་འབེབ་མ་བྱེད་རོགས།
Okay now the future of Tibetan Culture seems promising, in this case its not the kids fault but the parents failed miserably.
In the process of making money, we trade our culture. 😰😢
Oh lord, these kids will ruin our culture
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
You are ruining our culture because your goal is to make these kids unhappy
དཀོན་མཆོག་མཁྱེན་ད་ཚར་བཞག་ གགགགག
ཕོ་སྡུག་མོ་ད་ཚར་འདུག་བ་དེ་ཚོ་ལ་ལྟོས་དང་།
These kids can’t speak and understand own language ( Tibetan ). I don’t know why not try to speak Tibetan to own kids from the beginning then it won’t be struggle for them now. Their parents failed as a parent
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
I can’t see the any Tibetan monk or nun in Nepal monastery and India monastery
don't worry. we have Tibetan monks in Nepal. My village has not only preserved many variations of our Ngari dialect but also the Lhasa dialect. We have a Nyingma rinpoche family from Ngari teaching us, and we still retain strong bonds with the Tibetans in Purang.
འོ་་ཡ་་ད་ཚར་འདུག་་་
བླ་མ་མཁྱེན་ནོ། ད་ཡིན་་ན་་བོད་པ་ཚང་ཚར་སོང་་་་་་དཔལ་ལྡན་ལྷ་མོས་སྐྱོབས།
Thompson Eric Jones Timothy Walker Timothy
I would feel as failed parents if i were their parents,they dont know where they belong,the childrens of lost identity 😢
Atleast they are trying their best. We should encourage and motivate them.
@@tenzinkunsang608 they are tibetans not africans and they must know tibetan language! Its saddening to see these childrens have lost their identity ! Their parents didnt encourage them to speak tibetans and who are you to encourage them?
@@user-cx1ol3lh2iFirst of all you are a horrible person for being racist. And second of all you don’t understand how difficult it is to learn Tibetan language in a country that mainly speaks English. For me my dad is white and my mom is Tibetan so what we speak in my house is English because my father doesn’t understand Tibetan. You have to think before you write a reason on why we might not know Tibetan and not just come up with a conclusion that we are lazy kids who don’t care about where we came from and who we are. We were there for a reason to get closer to our culture and learn our language.If you are just gonna put negative comments and not support the younger generation trying to connect to their culture then YOU are not a true Tibetan.
Yea at least parents and kids try their best to understand history of Tibet n accept as Tibetan. Gd to begin n never late to learn
ཕྱོ་ལོག་་ལ་གཞུག་མཁན་་ཕ་མ་ཚོ་
Appreciate those kids but I blame the parents for them not speaking Tibetan. Language is a must for every Tibetan and shouldn’t be compromise and it start from home
ད་ལྟ་འགྱུར་བཞིན་པའི་བོད་དང་མ་འོངས་བོད་པའི་མི་རིགས་རྩ་མེད་འགྱུར་བའི་སྔོན་བརྡ་རེད། ཨ་ཁ་ཁ་འཆི་བཞིན་པའི་བོད་པའི་མི་རབས། མ་འོངས་ ཨ་རི་བོད་པ་ཡུལ་རོབ་བོད་པ་རྒྱ་གར་བོད་པ་རྒྱ་ནག་བོད་པ་ཞེས་པའི་མིང་ཚིག་སྐམ་པོ་ཙམ་གྱི་མིང་ཅན་པ་རེད།
སེམས་པ་སྐྱོ་བོ་རེད། ཕྲུ་གུ་ཚོ་ལ་ཁག་མེད་ སྤྱི་ཚོགས་དང་ཕ་མའི་ནོར་འཁྲུལ་ཆེན་པོ་ག་ཚོད་ཤོར་གྱི་ཡོད་མེད་གཟིགས་དང་། བོད་ལ་སྐད་ཡིག་རིག་གཞུང་རྒྱུན་འཛིན་བྱེད་པའི་རང་དབང་མིན་འདུག་ཟེར་སྡུག་སྐད་ག་ཚོད་རྒྱབ་ཀྱི་ཡོད་དམ། ང་ཚོ་རང་དབང་ལུང་པའི་ནང་ཡོད་པའི་བོད་མི་ཚོས་འགན་འཁྱེར་གྱི་འདུག་གམ། ཕྱི་རྒྱལ་ལ་ཡོད་པའི་ཕ་མ་དང་སྤྱི་ཚོགས་ཀྱི་འཁུར་མ་བླངས་ན་ བོད་ཆགས་འཇིག་ཉག་ཕྲ་བའི་དུས་ཀྱི་ཞབས་འདྲེན་ངོ་མ་དེ་རེད་
ཕྲུ་གུ་ཚོ་མུད་མཐུད་ཤུགས་རྒྱོབ།
Its a shame that tibetans cant speak tibetan😢 the childrens of lost identity
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
@@AnjaliSonn do you think parents of chime lhamo from canada and that minesota guy who speaks fluent tibetan are dumb or what?? They gave special focus on preserving tibetan language and culture by working hard on it! Kudos and Respect for those parents who deliberately speak tibetan in their household and emphasis on preserving our roots! I have tons of my friends who live in west and whose childrens have kept their tibetan culture and language intact. It all begins with your priorities
@@user-cx1ol3lh2i I don’t know who those people are but the three kids who were talking in Tibetan were from Swiss. In Swiss countries as a Tibetan, isn’t the main language spoken with most parents from birth Tibetan? Obviously, that’s why the Swiss kids were able to speak Tibetan. But in a first world country in America where 90% of the population speaks English wouldn’t our parents have to adapt to? And as everyone knows the only way to learn a language is to speak it. So it is not a choice it is a need. Unlike you guys in the comment section who have probably been living in India for sometime as a refugee
don't say freedom
Future Seeds of Tibet 😅😅😅 That sounds offensive.In English Language objectifying a person especially Kids is considered not Nice..U can just say Future of Tibet.🇺🇸
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
its very sad these kids from foreign countries cannot speak tibetan language clear and probably its lost they identity no matter where you from ,you ORGINAL from tibet DNA. they are proud of speaking English its all there parents fault and careless. its very shameful as a tibetan can't speak tibetan langauges. if you make a mistake on other foreign languages its will ok and no need shame because you all are refugee on tibetan name. if you can't speak tibetan language as a tibetan thats you lost everything.
It’s very sad that a GROWN person is saying this about minors. There’s no point in shaming others if it’s not benefiting me or you. Nobody said we are proud of not speaking Tibetan, and shaming our parents won’t do you any good. We still have many years to go we are all still under 18 most of the people are 10-15 we still have lots to learn about our culture. So we haven’t lost everything yet. Also our parents are trying to teach us, that’s the reason why we were sent to TCV summer camp .
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
Why all the Tibetan media promoting such a shameful student who can’t speak even a single sentence of Tibetan language
Instead they should promoting more who speak fluent Tibetan language
བོད་པའི་གཞོན་སྐྱེས་དེ་ཚོ་འཚར་ལོངས་འབྱུང་ས་དེ་ཕྱི་རྒྱལ་ལུང་པ་ལ་རེད་འདུག ད་ཆ་རྒྱ་གར་ལ་སླེབས་ནས་རང་གི་རིགས་གཞུང་དང་སྐད་ཡིག་ལ་དོ་སྣང་བྱེད་ཀྱི་ཡོད་པ་་མི་མཐོང་ངམ།
This is freak behavior
😂 good idea! But media showing the facts
:( they try their best! calling them shameful will just make them have a hatred of tibet which will be bad for the future of their children who are TIBETAN.
It’s shame that these kids can’t speak proper Tibetan language, let alone reading and writing in Tibetan. Their parents should be ashamed of themselves, kids are definitely not at fault cos I have seen so many Tibetan diaspora’s parents talking to their children in English ( broken 😞) , as if speaking in English makes them feel superior. I am working here in corporate company in New York and whenever I see Tibetan so called parents talking to their kids in English, I feel like mocking them and make them realise the importance of speaking to them in Tibetan at least. I Would never speak to my kid in English and nor do I entertain when they talk to me in English .. if we Tibetans don’t preserve our own language n culture , then it’s no brainer that our culture n language will extinct in no time ( we don’t need CCP to destroy our heritage and language) . Always try to communicate to ur kids in Tibetan at home atleast . If you see any kids laughing or feeling weird at our own language n prayers , blame urself as a parents ( not the kids ) . Hope this knocks some vestige of sensitivity among those half baked parents who thinks speaking in English looks sassy 💁.
Future.seed.of.tibetan.inside.tibet.inside.this.are.i.dont.no
First.teach.them.language.of.pure.tibetan
😢😢😢Tibetan seeds who can’t speak Tibetan well
future seeds not very bright..😇😆😁
I don’t understand how you think it’s so easy to learn tibetan from a foreign country. Our parents sent us there to learn and connect to our culture. You go straight to conclusion and think we don’t care about being Tibetan and our culture in general. Tibetan is not one of the languages you talk in America and is difficult to learn when all you talk in is English in America. My dad is white and my mom is Tibetan and we have to talk in English due to my father. But I still do try to connect to my culture and if all you think is negative then you are a reason why younger generation kids are like this. Instead of trying to help or motivate you bring them down and talk negatively to the younger generation kids from foreign countries who are trying to learn. You give them no motivation to try because all you think of them is as failures with comments like these. We were all there for a reason and for these hate comments is just sad when the kids here are there to learn. You should be ashamed and embarrassed for yourself for calling your self a proud Tibetan when you have no hope for the future kids and only spread hate towards them.
@@AnjaliSonny u spamming same ans 😂😂🤣
@@AnjaliSonn it is easy to learn Tibetan if there is willingness or enthusiasm within..If your mom spoke just Tibetan with you at home from a young age..you would be able to converse if not write in Tibetan..but the problem is everyone feels superior just talking in English and look down upon those who speak in Tibetan..its not your fault..I assume you are one of the students here in the video..all the blame goes to your Amala..
@@kamikaze7846 Yes but it’s hard to learn Tibetan with a American dad who doesn’t understand Tibetan. And growing up with mainly Americans and people who only speak English makes it even harder
@@Clipsfun90 cause everything there saying is the same😭
Great video