Can You Choose The RIGHT Option... || Moral Dilemma || The Trolly Problem ||
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- Curious here. This video is about the The Trolly Problem and the Moral Dilemma that
comes with it while talking the decision...
Hope you guys like it and if you don't feel free to comment your thoughts and suggestions.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.
.
.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
CONTACT INFORMATION :
--- Instagram link = / _mukund_pawar
--- Business Query = somethingcalledcurious@gmail.com
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.
.
.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Links for Stuff :
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mic : amzn.to/49zSP9u
48 Laws Of Power : amzn.to/431FZ14
Power Of Subconscious Mind : amzn.to/3uS321V
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Links above are affiliated.
If you buy from these links that supports our channel :)
.
.
.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tags:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Tags:
#curious
#hindi
#moraldilemma
#morality
#gooodandevil
#thetrollyproblem
#choice
#decision
#philosophyoflife
#mysterious
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.
.
.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Topics :
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What is Moral Dilemma
What is Morality
The Trolly Problem
The Trolly Problem Explained
The Trolly problem Explained in Hindi
The Effects of Circumstances
Subjective Nature of Morality
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.
.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credit for background music:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music by Myuu
Promoted by Music Fellows | bit.ly/MF_official
Video Link: • Evil thoughts 🖤 a DARK...
CC BY 4.0 | www.youtube.co...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
&
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fernweh by Myuu | / myuu
Promoted by Music Fellows | bit.ly/MF_official
Video Link: • MOONLIGHT 🎹 Dark Piano...
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License
www.youtube.co...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
&
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Music used : " HALLOWEEN LOVE " composed and produced by "Vivek Abhishek"
Music link : • [ No Copyright ] HALLO...
SUBSCRIBE us on UA-cam: bit.ly/3qumnPH
Follow on Facebook : bit.ly/33RWRtP
Follow on Instagram : bit.ly/2ImU2JV
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
&
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits:
Music: Shell Ghost by Soundridemusic
Link to Video: • Cinematic Tension Trai...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
&
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sound Effect from Pixbay
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
&
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sound Effect from Pixbay
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
FAIR-USE COPYRIGHT DISCLAIMER:Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
Dude casually left me feeling the most guilty person ever 💀😭
Using Instagram comment language
@@dipanshukumar5504 oh- didn't know insta had a specific language for comment section 😋
There is nothing right or wrong here, according to me, because you thought that you are bound by morality which is bound by this society, think if the same morality comes into play when you eat a dish made of chicken, ok let's assume that you are a vegetarian, what will happen if there is life in the vegetables, will you eat them, if you don't eat them then you will die.
Thare is all about our thoughts of emotion We do not want to kill anyone because we feel the pain of seeing them suffer, but we do not feel the same when we kill ants or mosquitoes. Am I right
@@blue_skycloud bro is so unemployment to wrote 2 paragraph
@@dipanshukumar5504 indeed
I did not save those 5 people even once. Maybe because replacing someone's fate with someone else's is not not what i came in this world for.
What if their fate was actually to get saved by you
You never know
@@strikkler But saving someone by shifting it to other person's death is not what i could do. There's def no literal definition of right or wrong in this situation. This is entirely my perspective of the situation. What if that one person is a very genius one who is significant while the rest 5 are common workers. So we did not know really what is right or wrong.
@@alizarizvi6580so you are saying if one person is genius than he must be saved , common people doesn't matter 😂what kind of logic is this.I'm not questioning your choices but the reason you gave seems illogical.
@@lakshmi1973 Come on bro that's the example of situation not my reason. But you probably seem like the person who threw that fat man on rail to save other workers and now you are commenting if i chose to do nothing instead of throwing that person whether that's genius or no.
Wow what a brilliant mind
You know
Okay now answer my question
If your father was the only worker there and on the other track no one was there.. and you have a chance to save your father and in exchange no one will be dead
But you will not do anything and see him dying, although it is his fate
Am I right?
BHAI SAALO BAAD UA-cam PR IS TYPE KA CONTENT DEKHA. JUST AMAZING!!!
Movies dekhna 2014 se chorr diye uske baad se hum yhi dekh rhe life mea vo sacrifice kro jo tumhe bhut pleasure deta but reality mea vo materialistic hota thays all mene chicken khana chorr diya my fav dish from 7years thisis called sacrifice ghar pr 2 baar bn hi jata hafte mea but i don't eat even though isee others eating thisis sacrifice try on you with your conditions accordingly !
What are the results ? @@bobbuilder3414
My honest choices:-
1. Save 5 for saving 1
2. Sacrifice 5 for my own greed
3. Sacrifice 5 for my love towards father.
4 . Sacrifice 5 because I will feel more guilty to push 1 man, and i think the 5 people for whom I did the unthinkable will blame me instead of being
grateful .
What I learned from this video?
=>No matter how much we try to convince ourselves that, all human lives are equal in our own mind we know they’re NOT.
Me lovernhi khichta
We are sem vro
I totally agree with you I choose same we are like minded people
Same here
I did the samee
Never judge someone actions without knowing their circumstances 😢
1.
Sacrifice 5 Peoples
2.
Sacrifice 5 Peoples
3.
Sacrifice 5 Peoples
Last One
Sacrifice 5 Peoples
I Think My Choice Different From Others.
Thank You Sir ❤
His words was making me feel guilty but yes.... I think we are same, we 👽🗿
Same like me
uss fr
Same *
Same
You are my favorite UA-camr but I don't want you become big UA-cam because i don't want everyone know this type of information
Mai bhi yahi chahta hu
Bro has the same opinion as me
Ye ideolpgy mera har jagha hea jhan kuch rare chiz milta mujhe either its info music cloth ideas sab ko chupana.chahte but ye glt hea specially in case of knowledge bec tum jitna knowledge ko chupaoge dusron se kal whi dusra log uss knowledge ki kni se tummo nuksan phunchaega directly or indirectly karma works bec you have chance to let him aware about that but u missed ao things you put will came back to you in same ways but its a paradox if u share some info if the person misused on you then it harm you karma here also works 😂 i am also little philosopher from 2011 i am curious my age same as years no. 🙂 @digitalAbhishek_
@Robiiin_chan__here morality work as a perception for me he doing great job where as the top commenter its bad its all about perception our choice is youtuber our perception is which direction we tilt the UA-cam is positive or little negative (as he also aware others )😂
Okay if you don't want him to be a big youtuber so jab Tum kuch bada Insaan ban Jana tab kuchh big money donate kar dena inko🤟
nothing is equal....you just opened my eyes....I've been matured since started watched your vdos❤
R.I.P english
He just used Shortform , you understand what he meant, that's what matters@@SakshiSingh-fu2bi
My reaction during whole video :- Eat 5 star do nothing 💀
I saved 5 life's anyway by doing nothing, first that unknown guy , second my boss , third my dad , fourth again worker infront of me and last my own from jail
I also did same mate
Cause , I don't have right to take someone life
"Chun na hi hoga... Tabhi ise dilema kehte hai"
Video ka starting part dekh lo sir
@@Imflexo SARCASM 🙂
Bhai maa ki Kasam isko dekhte vakt mai 5 star hi kha raha rha😂
I made the choice every time i saved that 1 person don't know why and didn't feel guilty
No matter what kind of decision I chose the circumstances will always go against the morality
That's the deal...
Morality is a construct of the weak-minded. Circumstances bend to the will of the strong. It is not the decision that shapes the circumstances, but the strength and cunning of the one who makes it.
@@Ayush.Mishra50 i see you didn't suffers from anything in your life
@@ALONE_dm Suffering is a concept for those who allow themselves to be constrained by it. True strength is born from transcending suffering, not being defined by it. The weak remain prisoners of their pain, while the strong reshape their reality. Do not mistake my perspective for lack of experience; rather, it is a testament to my mastery over it.
@@Ayush.Mishra50 when life throws You down then We value every single help and kindness from others who really wanted to help , we don't deny it . But I guess you are not mature enough to understand it .
By the way I am not trying to argue so yeah , everyone has different perspective :)
my honest choice
1)save 5 and sacrifice one
2)save 5 and sacrifice boss
3)sacrifice 5 people and save father
4)sacrifice 5 people and not push 1 people cause guilt won't let me
1. 5 personal sacrifice
2. 5 person sacrifice
3. 5 person sacrifice
4. 5 person sacrifice
Same
In the first 3 cases i did not pull the liver because, i agree that me not pulling the liver would kill 5 person but me pulling the liver would kill 1 person and i would be his killer. Doesn't matter how many people die but i will never be the reason of someone's death
Edit:- My choice is absolute you can't change my mind, I would still not do it
You still had the power to save 5 ppl..it was in your control because you were there !nYou could've saved rhem for your presence was capable of saving 5 people by just sacrificing a mere human body..It's non existent infronr of those 5 people !
I agree with him , in all time I don't pull the liver ,just I don't want to be the killer
Who knows who provides more value by just having a look a the number of people
Let's assume ,5 logo ki jaga agar 10 loge hote ta bhi kya Aisa karte 1 kelia sabke marne kelia chhod dete🥺🥺
@@demandunboxing7327 ha agar credit mil raha fir bachaunga
You literally changed my perspective 😳🤯
Why I didn't find this channel more early this Channel is perfect👍
Welcome aboard!
If you are the only one to write the script then you are a very good writer and i love the topic and how you explained it , it was very good
I am the only person who does everything 😊
Then you sure are a writer 👍
@@somethingcalledcurious bhai law 7 use kar eahe ho kya (😂💀)
@@AlBal-qq3fm Nahi sachme me hi karata hoo... Team hoti to bahut jaldi video ate.
@@somethingcalledcurious bhai bas majak kar raha hu *pata hai tumhi banate ho*
Logic informative video and thank 🌺🌺
Good I'm a cold blooded in it. I wont hesitate to make decision if things are in my way or profit but if not, well its your fate.
If you are emotional then you will pull the liver, your guilt will eat you up , but being practical in this if you pull the liver you will NOT be considered a hero but someone even your siblings might do a police case on you for intentionally pulling the liver and murdering the other person....
And most of us here just to feel good, for being called a good person and praise will say I would pull the liver, but in this world NOBODY means NOBODY will help you if you lose your job and when you really need help... rarely some people have those true friends who would come at anytime even when they are busy....
Any choice u made in life they had there own consequences 😊
Good Saying...
Certainly, every choice has consequences. But for those with the intellect and determination to control outcomes, the consequences can be molded to serve their ultimate objectives.
Your words directly touch my heart ❤
Very well explained.... 🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤ It's 48 Law Of " 48 Law's Of Power " ❤❤ Keep It up Bro....
I saved the 5 people 1st, 2nd, and 4th time. because my morality doesn't allow me to watch 5 people dying, when I had a chance to save them. And for the 3rd one, I am definitely guilty and I know, I can't justify that, But I would not use my morals against the one who taught me Spelling, Meaning and Importance of Moral.
Appreciated
you should then have surely choosed to pull the lever in 3rd one since you shouldn't let his morals fail
@@filtergaming9184 I would definately choose his teaching at any point, except when it is against his life.. For me, He is more important to me than My morals.
OMG what a unique content 🤩
Thank you @UA-cam for recommending such a mind-blowing video ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐🇳🇵
Morality binds you and wisdom frees you when a you make a decision always understand your situation then take a decision
We call it dharmsankat
Omg 😂😂 har waqt dil upr niche ho rha tha 😂😂
For the first time in life, someone made me realize that i've been pretending it all. I didnt want to choose those 5 strangers above my father but then those 5 strangers are again someone's family. And when the last option was to choose to save those 5 strangers and push the man, i couldnt do it. Every life values and every choice has its own reason
Bro!! You left me speechless😮..
I choose to pull the lever in first three cases and at last didnt pushed that man on the track..
Idk why i did this..
Nice video. Good narration.
Literally this video is mind blowing man 👏
Next level explanation of a moral dilemma... great 👍
Bro Trust me, your storytelling is amazing. Keep Growing like this and All the best on your future endeavors ! You earned a Subscribe
Tum bahut hee majedaar ho bhai
Recommendation mey thumahari video mili afsoos ho raha hai. Ye channel aur pahle milna chahiye tha.
I got lost in your video bro..absolutely amazing work❤
As soon as I saw "Moral dilemma", I clicked on video. And I already know it'll be an amazing video....📈
Long time no see...
@@somethingcalledcurious well I was just waiting for dark psychological videos like about nihilism or maybe another video about philosophy of monster anime.....
@Scarydono I'm also not sure, but I think yes
Nice work buddy. Keep it up. Make more deep videos about Human Psychology (including dark), Philosophy, realation between human with society, and reality (including dark).
Bhai sabse acha psychologist to hi hai
Tune zindagi aur is zindagi ko jeene wao yani insaan ki mansikta batati hai , ki kese koi insaan sahi ya galat ni majboor hota hai
Aur har insaan ke zindagi mein ek esa daur ya fir bas ek pal zaroor ata hai jahan wo har choice ya option mai galat hi hota hai aur har galat option ke piche ek alag perspective chupa hota hai
Honestly speaking , in first case as everyone i will sacrifice one persons life
But in second , i thought for a few seconds and decided to sacrifice those 5 people
Third one was simple , sacrifice 5 people
Last one was very tricky , imagining that scenario gave me goosebumps killing one person with my hands for those 5 people
That was very hard but still i will let those 5 people die
I agree i am not moral, but still thats what i would do if that happened in real life
Brother You Are Not Alone I Am Also Just Like You
Masterpiece ✨
Finally after some years I really found a good video! Thanks to Algorithm ❤
bro I didn't choose these choices but i made my own and that allow in all situations that you gave in but the main thing is i understand something meaningful ❤
Bro, that was a mind-blowing presentation! I have earlier tried the trolley problem and it was very simple and easy every level but for the first time when you explained the situation so deeply it disturbed my inner peace! But it was a great realisation that how deep the trolley problem is and what moral dilemma really is...👍
This is insane...! Your voice the environment you create from your video is too much insane..❤
I chose those 5 people in my every choice, first one because Those five people were destined to die Not the one that was on the other track where the train was not coming And next choices you know why I chose those five people
Such a great video! The video quality considering the channel size is fabulous.Just keep the grind on,I see you reaching new heights in a year or so.
Thank you so much!
I really appreciate that you used real hindi and not so called Genz hindi.
The starting and the ending of this video are amazing ❤
You're right
Dude! What kind of storytelling is this? I was more hooked on this video than on a movie
4:00
condition 1.
un 5 aadmi ne voice cancellation wale headphones pahne
or dusre track ek aadmi jisne wo headphones nahi pahna to me koshish karuga ki second track wale aadmi ko pata chle ki train aa ri hai or wo aadmi bakiyo ko bacha sake
condition 2.
agar train us liver point se pahle hi aage nikal chuki ho to me sab ko as it is rahne duga
condition 3.
me 5 ko bachane ke liye 1 ki jaan leke ko tyaar hu
condition 4.
kuch nahi karuga
1st save 5 people
2nd save 5 people
3rd save 5 people ik its hard yes i would stillsave those 5 people
4th I'll be sacrificing my life, and if i cant then I'll do nothing as per choice. But reality is i would freeze at my place if that situation comes.
What i learned:- we make choices on the basis of circumsramces so gyan nai dena agle baar se kisi ko.
Whatever choice we make cannot be perfectly fine.
Another bangar from my favourite youtuber and creater ❤❤
You are becoming pro at editing videos 😊
Thank you so much :)
1 . I sacrifice 5 people because if i change the liver , I think the train was speeding so the train would turn over and killed hundreds of people.
If you are present there and you have a chance to save 5 people then it's not there fate, you are present there to save them. I don't care if it's my family or anyone I'll just see the numbers.
so bro you will really kill your father for 5 unknown people's , i mean think literally will you ?
I am at 8:57 and my choices are
1. Sacrifice 1 for 5 ( being guilty for life )
2. Sacrifice 1 for 5 ( being guilty for life )
3. Sacrifice Dad because he is my Life .
4. Sacrifice Myself and Save 6 Lifes ..
Another level bro ❤❤❤
Every time I have to make a decision, my heart begins to beat more quickly.😰
Last me :Apna Apna dekh lo mera ho gya😂
Best UA-cam Channel
My honest choices, I didn't choose to do anything and left them on their own. Because before pulling the lever I had the choice whether to get involved or not, and I chose not get involved in something which has been already decided by nature and fate.
1. The antagonist didn't pull the liver. It was fate
2. The antagonist did pull the liver cause if inspite of fate ,the antagonist would be a greedy person.
3. The antagonist choose the father.
4 the antagonist didn't push the man.
i choose " do nothing" each time
On the 1st one I thought whichever side will be beneficial in future I'll save : )
honest choices:-
1. Sacrifice 5
2. Sacrifice 5
3. Sacrifice 5
4. Sacrifice 5
This is my fav. channel.
Meanwhile me -: Eat 5 star, do nothing 😂😂😂
My father is already dead so imagining him in front of me and getting killed by train was hard but i still pulled the lever.
You are strong man, Brother...
@@somethingcalledcurious thanks brother
@@somethingcalledcurious
Him Sacrificing his dad for strangers....
was strong?
Or Him imagining his dad... was strong?
Bro think instead of your father you stand their place then what will you do ? you pull the lever ? Because you also stand there?
I don't wanna make you question again but just think it was anybody who is very close to your heart would you do the same?
Your content gives goosebump
Damn the story telling skill
The Best Answer Of Everything Is - "It Depends"
You're underrated keep underrated ❤👍
Vo 5 ,,,,, jinhe univers bula rha h♾️
The video was quite interesting....kept me hooked till the end.... keep up the good work...👌
So if this is the test of morality...then in the last case...I don't know how the train stops by killing one person...but if I have to sacrifice anyone and I am there then I will sacrifice my own life....I know there were only two options...either they all die..or only 1 dies and 5 are saved...but this is also a test of morality....🤧🤧
Your videos are really legend i am waiting next video i watch your every videos more than 3 times
its not just the dilemma.. he also wants us to think deeply by those compliments.. i wouldn't have minded doing anything in any particular case of this problem.. but for sure reality hits different.. a person's true nature is revealed under presssure.. and this particular problem exploits that fact by crossing over the bridge between morality and individaul choices.. CHOICES!!
7:25 yuuichi jump scare
Masterpiece
Faith and destiny on top, I'll always get what I deserve. So I didn't pull the liver even once. But at last I chose that 1 person with me, I could save him, so why not. It's not in my power to take life but sure I can save someone's right in front of me. no liver condition or anything.
3rd one was the toughest... I'd try to save both..
It was distributing at the end....
In the first example, I could not make any choice, in the second time I chose my boss because I felt that those 5 workers would be needed more by their families. But for the third time, I left all five of them to die because I could not bear the emotional pain. If anything happened to my parents, that too because of me.
You're right ,but that 5 worker also have family like you have. And they also work for money for there family. ❤❤
@@Sanju-ib6xb Agree
Ah ! Last question got me . I sure natively standing there and seeing train go. Reason:-
1. I am not controlling the train.
2. Cant i jump instead of kicking him?
3.Condition of first 3 questions and last questions are different since it last question depends upon pratical basis
I will choose my own profit every time😊😊 I don't care who will die who wil alive
1 I will not do anything because here I have no profit die 1 or all 5
2 I will save my boss
3 save boss
4 save dad
5 no profit I will not do anything 😃😃😃
I cried on third option but in fourth option I would rather jump in front of the train than pushing someone else.. cause it was just a choice anyways
before conclusion you quoted the ITACHI UCHIA .... WE ALWAYS TEND TO LOOK INTO THE RESULT THAT ONE PERSON HAD MADE BUT WE NEVER KNOW WHAT CHOICES HE HAD!!
Choice given rise to shades of grey it's not always black or white
I liked this video. However, i sense now that why vedas and Upanishads are so great. Because they always ask one question:- for whom? And subsequently from whom. For whom the action is being carried out and by whom the action is being carried out. It's simple, if the doer is "I" (which i called as personal self) then definitely the consequences are bound to be bad (bad not in moral sense but bad in a way where a choice made by different center (other than "I") would be better all the time.)
I didn't choose to save 5 people in any circumstances bcoz that's how is their destiny is...death is inevitable, those 5 people would die anyways in any other incidents, so i would choose to stay silent.
I choose 5 persons in all examples because death is their destiny.if you pull lever then it's your choice.
Life is all about choices
🎉 some time choices not or not wrong they depend on “point of view “
I think you said this in your video 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊
This is one of the best video on UA-cam
this video helped in find my solution of my problem
I always thinked to save all of them
but but the third one is really think me of pull the lever for my father but then i remembered my fathers words "there's always a way, hamesha har situation se bahar niklne ka koi na koi rasta to zarur hota hai, ill search to find a way to save my father and all 5 of them :)."
My perspective remained same during whole video i never pulled lever in any situation and i don't push the person in front of train My reaction was like remain calm and do nothing 😶
My heart cried but I choose 5 people in all the options. Now I feel shitty about myself. After 2 min I just had a thought why I am the most used person. Why people only uses me as their benefit. It's difficult to live with a good heart in today's world. 😢
Wow same choices and you got my name too 😂😂
I alway thought that arjun in Mahabharata was moral , but after watching this video i understood that we hindus were just justifying what he did 😨
Bro your videos are amazing it gives me too much information
I can't pull the leaver I just can't pull the leaver why why I am not pulling the leaver 😣😣
Bhai aap muje kadhi had tak muj jese lagte hoo muje be ese speaking krna pasand hai but I like to teach myself and on that topic which is not easy to think about it ❤❤