Its like asking someone if is there something bigger than infinity No of course not because because infinity is literally limitless thus there is nothing bigger than it, because it is by definition the BIGGEST. In other words, to put it simply, allah is so powerfull he literally cannot become weak.
these r 'impossibilities' by definition- like a square circle, or a banana onion- its not a thing- as in, its not some thing that even exists conceptually
@@neko7981 I think such questions come up when debating with others, since christians believe that jesus (god) died, so they will say so your god can't die and come back. There is a difference between, god could and god doesn't do it. For example if we say can god lie, if god truly wanted to he could lie, but we believe he doesn't lie because this would contradict with his attributes
we live in 4 dimensions, xyz +4th dimension which is time and Allah created those dimensions so you can't compare Allah to any of them, you can't say after or before Allah because it's time comparing and Allah isn't related to time, same goes for size. Allah created the dimensions we understand today so it isn't logical to compare a created to his creations. And btw I strongly disagree with "Sheikh" is answering this way, this isn't how Dawah is done and this isn't the proper way of dealing with people asking this kind of questions. As a young child I used to have a lot of similar questions and all the answers I was getting were like this one here, "don't ask stupid questions", "Those questions are coming from the devil" etc.. Which btw lead to me to almost becoming an atheist later on and if Allah didn't guide me to find the answers for my questions I wouldn't be a Muslim today. Being rude with people and accusing them of being stupid is something that our prophet Muhammad pbuh that would never do or like anyone doing it.
Dumb questions get harsh replies! Use common sense! Its like asking can Allah exist and NOT exist at the same time? Can Allah make a square circle? Stupid questions with no reality!
@muhammadsalafiahlulhadith a guy literally peed in the mosque, and our prophet Pbuh didn't allow sahabis to be rude to the guy because he may be "not knowing" what he was doing! This guy isn't a child, but he may be ignorant, or he may really be suffering to find an answer to the question (which even the shaykh here didn't really have a satisfying answer to that tbh, for us Muslims we believe that Allah is the biggest but do you think that answer would make sense for someone who doesn't know Allah?). Regardless of what happened, I don't think he did something worse than peeing in a mosque, and the prophet teached us that even such a thing is not an excuse to act rude to people. imo the message of that was that you should think of all possibilities, maybe he is ignorant, maybe he is a guy about to turn to islam but one of his atheist friends told him to ask this question, maybe this was the question that would make him accept Islam and you being rude to him cuased him to run away from Islam. They threw stones at our prophet, and when Jibreel asked him to take his revenge, he refused. Do you think our prophet would be ok with asking a guy who is politely asking a question (even if it was silly) if he was stupid? Is this the way we were taught of doing dawah?
@muhammadsalafiahlulhadith tbh just thinking of the possibility that this guy having this last question to enter Islam and this response causing him to turn back is upsetting. Ignore the guy, people who are watching this. What would they think? tbh if I was watching this as a non-Muslim thinking this sheikh is representing Islam, I would have cold feet. Our prophet teached us how to deal with this kind of people and this isn't the way to do it and he never been rude to anyone.
And btw it's in the Quran as well. (3:159) It was thanks to Allah's mercy that you were gentle to them. Had you been rough, hard-hearted, they would surely have scattered away from you. So pardon them, and pray for their forgiveness.
The Answer is yes the Arsh of Allah is bigger than his Actual size which is carried by the 8 Angels. This not a stupid question at all!! Allah's House is bigger than himself is another example.
U KHABEES JAAHIL! DID U JUST SAY THE ARSH IS BIGGER THAN ALLAH? ALLAHU AKBAR MEANS ALLAH IS THE GREATEST! NOTHING IS GREATER THAN ALLAH! NOT EVEN THE ARSH!
*_It is FARD/obligatory upon The True Muslim to affirm the Asma/Names & Sifat/Attributes of Allah, without committing:1️⃣Tahreef:To attach figurative & metaphorical meanings to the attributes of Allah, while denying the apparent meaning of the attribute2️⃣Ta'teel:Leaving & vacating🔥Negation/Denial of His Attributes & denial of His Self & Being. Denial of the real meaning proved by the Quran & Sunnah🔥Tahreef includes Tateel but Ta'teel does not include Tahreef🔥There are 2 types of Tateel:❌️1)Absolute Tateel: Which the Jahamiyyah committed:Denying all attributes of Allah❌️2)Partial Tateel:Which the Ash’ariyya & maturidiyya commit:Denying all attributes of Allah by Tahreef & affirming only 7 (Ashariyah) & 8 (Maturidiyah) attributes of Allah3️⃣Takyeef:To have faith that the Attributes of Allah are such & such or to put questions as to the state of His Attributes. The term "beghair Takyeef' means that the AhlusSunnah deny having knowledge of Allah's condition as Allah alone knows the state of His Self & His Attributes4️⃣Tamtheel: To have faith that the Attributes of Allah are like the Attributes of His creatures5️⃣Tafweed: To have faith that it’s not the apparent meaning which is meant but only Allah alone knows the meanings of the attributes6️⃣Tajseem:To have faith that Allah has a body. (We as AhlusSunnah neither affirm nor negate the attribute of body, since nothing has come in Quran & Sunnah concerning it & Aqeeda is a matter purely based on Revelation/Wahi as mentioned by Shaykh IbnUthaymeen RAHIMAHULLAH & Shaykhul Islam IbnTaymiyyah RAHIMAHULLAH✅So we do NOT affirm that He has a body while affirming his attributes). The Salaf understood the meanings of the passages of the Quran & the Sunnah & proved these meanings in the favour of Allah. However they would submit the knowledge of the reality (how of the attribute) To Allah. Imam Malik RAHIMAHULLAH was asked about the state of Istawa (Rising Above) of Allah on the Throne, he said Istawa is known but ‘how’ He ascended is unknown. The code of conduct of the AhlusSunnah wal Jamah is as the clear Quran’s verse:“There is nothing like Him.”-Quran (112:4)✔️The correct Aqeeda therefore, is NOT that the Attributes are completely denied as is the way of the Mutazila🔥(A Deviant sect), NOR is it to try to prove them completely as is the way of the Mumathila🔥(Another deviant sect✏Rather the true Aqeeda is to make an affirmation of the Attributes without similitudes/likeness✅SALAFIYYAH✅️_* *Breaking down DEVIANT AQEEDAH OF SUFI/deobandis/asharis/matureedis🛐❌1️⃣They claim to follow imam AbuHanifa infact they follow him only in fiqhi issues, so they can fight with us that fold hands below navel or dont do Raful-Yadayen2️⃣The aqeedah of sufi/ashari/maturidi/deobandi is of sufi🔥WAllahu Alam from where they got this Shirk belief🔥Their aqeedah is of Mohammad bin Mohammad matrudi🔥If you know that matrudi is the fiqh who are wrong in the tawheed asma-wa-siffat of Allah.. They don't believe in every names of Allah, holding on only 7-8🔥They were wrong before & they're still wrong❌3️⃣Whilst in performing deeds they follow Sufi's 4 sub categories qadiri→chishti→naqshabandi→suharwardi👎🏻They're undercover Sufi🛐❌4️⃣SUFI/ASHARI/MATUREEDI/Deobandi claim that they follow 4 imams, but they follow imam matrudi in aqeedah & in fiqh they follow imam AbuHanifa, they leave 3 Imams as if they never existed!*_ *_WHERE IS ALLAH⁉️ImamAbuHanifah☝🏻AbuMutiAlBalkhi reported:I asked Imam AbuHanifah about a person who says:I do NOT know whether my Rab (Allah) is above the heavens or on earth⁉️AbuHanifah said:A person who makes such a statement becomes an apostate because Allah, the Exalted says:The Merciful has ascended above THE ARSH & THE ARSH OF ALLAH IS ABOVE HIS HEAVENS🔥I ALSO ASKED ABUHANIFAH🔥What if such a person admits, Allah is above His Arsh BUT EXCLAIMS:I do not know whether His Arsh is above the heavens or on earth‼️AbuHanifah responded🗣If he denies that the Arsh is above the heavens, he is an apostate‼️If the person apostatizes by saying that he did not know where is the ARSH of Allah, then by right a person who denies the Loftiness of Allah altogether is definitely worse than an apostate🔥ImamMalik🔥Abdullah binNafi reported:MalikBinAnas said:ALLAH IS ABOVE THE HEAVENS BUT HIS KNOWLEDGE encompasses everything. NOTHING ESCAPES HIS KNOWLEDGE🔥ImamShafi said:THE CREED which I hold is the same creed the MUSLIMS BEFORE me were holding, namely, the Testimony of Faith:There is no god worthy of being worshipped except Allah, that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah & that Allah is ABOVE HIS ARSH, above the heavens. He descends to the lowest heaven whenever He wishes📚ImamBinKhuzaimah a SHAFI himself said:Whoever DOES NOT BELIEVE that Allah is above His ARSH☝🏻Above His 7 HEAVENS & THAT HE IS SEPARATE from His creatures, is a KAFIR🔥Such person must be ordered to repent & disavow his belief or else he must be beheaded and thrown on a garbage dump so that neither Ahlul-Qiblah nor Ahludth-dthimmah be annoyed by the foul odour of his carcass🔥AbuBakr MuhammadatTamimi, a Shafi'ite imam of Naisabur said:"I do not pray behind a person who denies the attributes of Allah & does not recognise that Allah is above His Arsh🔥ImamAhmad🔥He was asked: Is Allah above His Arsh, above the 7th heaven, separate from His creatures, & is His knowledge & power encompassing everything everywhere⁉️He replied:'Certainly, He is above His Arsh & NOTHING escapes His knowledge. All of the above show that the entire Muslim ummah, in the past & present, is in unison regarding the belief in the Loftiness & SUPREMACY OF ALLAH THE EXALTED_*
@ Do you even know what is the Arsh & the Kursi? You think Allah sits on a pea sized throne? Allah stands & walks so where he walks in the air? Use your brain before you reply. Mind your Language first when you know nothing about Islam stop accusing alright!
@ On that day the Jahanum will say oh ALLAH are there any more disbelievers bz it will still have alot of space. But, their will be no humans & jinns left to put so ALLAH will place his foot inside the Jahanum & it will say I am full I am full search it up if you dont know. This clearly tells the size of Jahanum is larger than ALLAH’s footsize. So ALLAH can create things bigger than his actual size like ALLAH has his House so this makes no sense that the House of ALLAH is smaller than his size. But, ALLAH has complete control, power & authority over all his creations. But, people like you who know nothing just know how to abuse. Soon you will regret your actions Inshallah
@@ARCHANGEL_600WINGS dont use ur personal limited capacity of thinking to describe what is unseen and unknown. 'big' is a comparison that doesnt apply to Allah, as Allah is beyond comprehension. size is a factor that doesnt apply to him cause he cannot be limited to space time- all of which r his creations
I love it when syeikh ask him "are you stupid?" 😂😂😂
The guy who came up with this terrible question needs medical attention.
Allah ability is not something a human can understand, so dont think of asking question related to his ability
Its like asking someone if is there something bigger than infinity
No of course not because because infinity is literally limitless thus there is nothing bigger than it, because it is by definition the BIGGEST. In other words, to put it simply, allah is so powerfull he literally cannot become weak.
Bro just wanted to be on TV😭😭😆😆
the right spelling is "create" great video alhamdulillah
Yikes have to be careful when answering as well. Calling impossibility is a thin line when talking about allah swt.
these r 'impossibilities' by definition- like a square circle, or a banana onion- its not a thing- as in, its not some thing that even exists conceptually
@@neko7981 I think such questions come up when debating with others, since christians believe that jesus (god) died, so they will say so your god can't die and come back.
There is a difference between, god could and god doesn't do it.
For example if we say can god lie, if god truly wanted to he could lie, but we believe he doesn't lie because this would contradict with his attributes
@@KurdiliSo you are saying that Allah SWT can die? May Allah SWT save us from people like you
@@leun6768 I never said that….
@@Kurdili your point actually makes sense but not everyone is as clever as you and hence youll get people being hostile to you.
we live in 4 dimensions, xyz +4th dimension which is time and Allah created those dimensions so you can't compare Allah to any of them, you can't say after or before Allah because it's time comparing and Allah isn't related to time, same goes for size.
Allah created the dimensions we understand today so it isn't logical to compare a created to his creations.
And btw I strongly disagree with "Sheikh" is answering this way, this isn't how Dawah is done and this isn't the proper way of dealing with people asking this kind of questions.
As a young child I used to have a lot of similar questions and all the answers I was getting were like this one here, "don't ask stupid questions", "Those questions are coming from the devil" etc.. Which btw lead to me to almost becoming an atheist later on and if Allah didn't guide me to find the answers for my questions I wouldn't be a Muslim today.
Being rude with people and accusing them of being stupid is something that our prophet Muhammad pbuh that would never do or like anyone doing it.
Dumb questions get harsh replies! Use common sense! Its like asking can Allah exist and NOT exist at the same time? Can Allah make a square circle? Stupid questions with no reality!
THE SHAYKH WAS TALKING TO A GROWN MAN ASKING A STUPID QUESTION! NOT A CHILD😂
@muhammadsalafiahlulhadith a guy literally peed in the mosque, and our prophet Pbuh didn't allow sahabis to be rude to the guy because he may be "not knowing" what he was doing! This guy isn't a child, but he may be ignorant, or he may really be suffering to find an answer to the question (which even the shaykh here didn't really have a satisfying answer to that tbh, for us Muslims we believe that Allah is the biggest but do you think that answer would make sense for someone who doesn't know Allah?). Regardless of what happened, I don't think he did something worse than peeing in a mosque, and the prophet teached us that even such a thing is not an excuse to act rude to people. imo the message of that was that you should think of all possibilities, maybe he is ignorant, maybe he is a guy about to turn to islam but one of his atheist friends told him to ask this question, maybe this was the question that would make him accept Islam and you being rude to him cuased him to run away from Islam. They threw stones at our prophet, and when Jibreel asked him to take his revenge, he refused. Do you think our prophet would be ok with asking a guy who is politely asking a question (even if it was silly) if he was stupid? Is this the way we were taught of doing dawah?
@muhammadsalafiahlulhadith tbh just thinking of the possibility that this guy having this last question to enter Islam and this response causing him to turn back is upsetting. Ignore the guy, people who are watching this. What would they think? tbh if I was watching this as a non-Muslim thinking this sheikh is representing Islam, I would have cold feet. Our prophet teached us how to deal with this kind of people and this isn't the way to do it and he never been rude to anyone.
And btw it's in the Quran as well.
(3:159) It was thanks to Allah's mercy that you were gentle to them. Had you been rough, hard-hearted, they would surely have scattered away from you. So pardon them, and pray for their forgiveness.
I shook my head at this Clowns question. Indeed, that was a stupid question.
Satan can ask this type of question
The Answer is yes the Arsh of Allah is bigger than his Actual size which is carried by the 8 Angels. This not a stupid question at all!! Allah's House is bigger than himself is another example.
U KHABEES JAAHIL! DID U JUST SAY THE ARSH IS BIGGER THAN ALLAH?
ALLAHU AKBAR MEANS ALLAH IS THE GREATEST! NOTHING IS GREATER THAN ALLAH! NOT EVEN THE ARSH!
*_It is FARD/obligatory upon The True Muslim to affirm the Asma/Names & Sifat/Attributes of Allah, without committing:1️⃣Tahreef:To attach figurative & metaphorical meanings to the attributes of Allah, while denying the apparent meaning of the attribute2️⃣Ta'teel:Leaving & vacating🔥Negation/Denial of His Attributes & denial of His Self & Being. Denial of the real meaning proved by the Quran & Sunnah🔥Tahreef includes Tateel but Ta'teel does not include Tahreef🔥There are 2 types of Tateel:❌️1)Absolute Tateel: Which the Jahamiyyah committed:Denying all attributes of Allah❌️2)Partial Tateel:Which the Ash’ariyya & maturidiyya commit:Denying all attributes of Allah by Tahreef & affirming only 7 (Ashariyah) & 8 (Maturidiyah) attributes of Allah3️⃣Takyeef:To have faith that the Attributes of Allah are such & such or to put questions as to the state of His Attributes. The term "beghair Takyeef' means that the AhlusSunnah deny having knowledge of Allah's condition as Allah alone knows the state of His Self & His Attributes4️⃣Tamtheel: To have faith that the Attributes of Allah are like the Attributes of His creatures5️⃣Tafweed: To have faith that it’s not the apparent meaning which is meant but only Allah alone knows the meanings of the attributes6️⃣Tajseem:To have faith that Allah has a body. (We as AhlusSunnah neither affirm nor negate the attribute of body, since nothing has come in Quran & Sunnah concerning it & Aqeeda is a matter purely based on Revelation/Wahi as mentioned by Shaykh IbnUthaymeen RAHIMAHULLAH & Shaykhul Islam IbnTaymiyyah RAHIMAHULLAH✅So we do NOT affirm that He has a body while affirming his attributes). The Salaf understood the meanings of the passages of the Quran & the Sunnah & proved these meanings in the favour of Allah. However they would submit the knowledge of the reality (how of the attribute) To Allah. Imam Malik RAHIMAHULLAH was asked about the state of Istawa (Rising Above) of Allah on the Throne, he said Istawa is known but ‘how’ He ascended is unknown. The code of conduct of the AhlusSunnah wal Jamah is as the clear Quran’s verse:“There is nothing like Him.”-Quran (112:4)✔️The correct Aqeeda therefore, is NOT that the Attributes are completely denied as is the way of the Mutazila🔥(A Deviant sect), NOR is it to try to prove them completely as is the way of the Mumathila🔥(Another deviant sect✏Rather the true Aqeeda is to make an affirmation of the Attributes without similitudes/likeness✅SALAFIYYAH✅️_*
*Breaking down DEVIANT AQEEDAH OF SUFI/deobandis/asharis/matureedis🛐❌1️⃣They claim to follow imam AbuHanifa infact they follow him only in fiqhi issues, so they can fight with us that fold hands below navel or dont do Raful-Yadayen2️⃣The aqeedah of sufi/ashari/maturidi/deobandi is of sufi🔥WAllahu Alam from where they got this Shirk belief🔥Their aqeedah is of Mohammad bin Mohammad matrudi🔥If you know that matrudi is the fiqh who are wrong in the tawheed asma-wa-siffat of Allah.. They don't believe in every names of Allah, holding on only 7-8🔥They were wrong before & they're still wrong❌3️⃣Whilst in performing deeds they follow Sufi's 4 sub categories qadiri→chishti→naqshabandi→suharwardi👎🏻They're undercover Sufi🛐❌4️⃣SUFI/ASHARI/MATUREEDI/Deobandi claim that they follow 4 imams, but they follow imam matrudi in aqeedah & in fiqh they follow imam AbuHanifa, they leave 3 Imams as if they never existed!*_
*_WHERE IS ALLAH⁉️ImamAbuHanifah☝🏻AbuMutiAlBalkhi reported:I asked Imam AbuHanifah about a person who says:I do NOT know whether my Rab (Allah) is above the heavens or on earth⁉️AbuHanifah said:A person who makes such a statement becomes an apostate because Allah, the Exalted says:The Merciful has ascended above THE ARSH & THE ARSH OF ALLAH IS ABOVE HIS HEAVENS🔥I ALSO ASKED ABUHANIFAH🔥What if such a person admits, Allah is above His Arsh BUT EXCLAIMS:I do not know whether His Arsh is above the heavens or on earth‼️AbuHanifah responded🗣If he denies that the Arsh is above the heavens, he is an apostate‼️If the person apostatizes by saying that he did not know where is the ARSH of Allah, then by right a person who denies the Loftiness of Allah altogether is definitely worse than an apostate🔥ImamMalik🔥Abdullah binNafi reported:MalikBinAnas said:ALLAH IS ABOVE THE HEAVENS BUT HIS KNOWLEDGE encompasses everything. NOTHING ESCAPES HIS KNOWLEDGE🔥ImamShafi said:THE CREED which I hold is the same creed the MUSLIMS BEFORE me were holding, namely, the Testimony of Faith:There is no god worthy of being worshipped except Allah, that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah & that Allah is ABOVE HIS ARSH, above the heavens. He descends to the lowest heaven whenever He wishes📚ImamBinKhuzaimah a SHAFI himself said:Whoever DOES NOT BELIEVE that Allah is above His ARSH☝🏻Above His 7 HEAVENS & THAT HE IS SEPARATE from His creatures, is a KAFIR🔥Such person must be ordered to repent & disavow his belief or else he must be beheaded and thrown on a garbage dump so that neither Ahlul-Qiblah nor Ahludth-dthimmah be annoyed by the foul odour of his carcass🔥AbuBakr MuhammadatTamimi, a Shafi'ite imam of Naisabur said:"I do not pray behind a person who denies the attributes of Allah & does not recognise that Allah is above His Arsh🔥ImamAhmad🔥He was asked: Is Allah above His Arsh, above the 7th heaven, separate from His creatures, & is His knowledge & power encompassing everything everywhere⁉️He replied:'Certainly, He is above His Arsh & NOTHING escapes His knowledge. All of the above show that the entire Muslim ummah, in the past & present, is in unison regarding the belief in the Loftiness & SUPREMACY OF ALLAH THE EXALTED_*
@ Do you even know what is the Arsh & the Kursi? You think Allah sits on a pea sized throne? Allah stands & walks so where he walks in the air? Use your brain before you reply. Mind your Language first when you know nothing about Islam stop accusing alright!
@ On that day the Jahanum will say oh ALLAH are there any more disbelievers bz it will still have alot of space. But, their will be no humans & jinns left to put so ALLAH will place his foot inside the Jahanum & it will say I am full I am full search it up if you dont know. This clearly tells the size of Jahanum is larger than ALLAH’s footsize. So ALLAH can create things bigger than his actual size like ALLAH has his House so this makes no sense that the House of ALLAH is smaller than his size. But, ALLAH has complete control, power & authority over all his creations. But, people like you who know nothing just know how to abuse. Soon you will regret your actions Inshallah
@@ARCHANGEL_600WINGS dont use ur personal limited capacity of thinking to describe what is unseen and unknown. 'big' is a comparison that doesnt apply to Allah, as Allah is beyond comprehension. size is a factor that doesnt apply to him cause he cannot be limited to space time- all of which r his creations