Multan's Hindu Legacy & Secrets of The Partition | Satya Samvad Ep.1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- Multan's Hindu Legacy & Secrets of The Partition | Deepak Srinivasan & Dr.Mrittunjoy Guha Majumdar Satya Samvad Ep.1
In the first dialogue under the Satya Samvad initiative by Dr. Mrittunjoy Guha Majumdar, he discusses about the nuances of Pakistani Hindus in Punjab, before and after 1947, the roles of Nehruvian Congress and Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh during Partition, the realities of Gilgit Baltistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir.
Satya or truth is the bulwark of the Bharatiya civilizational ethos. To look closely at truth is to look at its assertion, its negation, its nuances and even its paradoxes.
Satya Samvad is a platform for exploring the truth in various points of civilizational and humanitarian interest, both ontological as well as epistemological. Our aim is to look at the nuances and even paradoxes of truth, even as we work towards a sustainable and Dharmic tomorrow.
The partition of India and Pakistan stands as a monumental paradox in the annals of history, encapsulating layers of ontological and epistemological truths, yet mired in unresolved tensions and consequences. Ostensibly, the partition sought to resolve religious and cultural schisms, aiming to establish sovereign states reflective of different premises - one an Islamic Republic while the other being a secular state. However, beneath this veneer of nationhood lay deep-seated fractures in communal identities and historical grievances. The partition, ostensibly a solution, revealed itself as a profound paradox: an exercise intended to foster stability and peace, but which unleashed unprecedented violence and displacement. The very act of demarcating borders along religious lines underscored the limits of human understanding and the frailty of political solutions in addressing complex social realities. Moreover, the partition's aftermath has yielded a tapestry of narratives, each imbued with its own truth-of migration, loss, and identity upheaval. These truths, often conflicting and contested, underscore the ontological complexity of historical events and the subjective nature of memory and interpretation. The India-Pakistan partition thus remains a poignant reminder of the inherent contradictions within political exercises, and the enduring quest for reconciliation amidst the tumult of human experience.
Snakes in the Ganga - www.snakesinthe...
Varna Jati Caste - www.varnajatica...
The Battle For IIT's - www.battleforii...
Power of future Machines - www.poweroffutu...
10 heads of Ravana - www.tenheadsofr...
To support Infinity Foundation’s projects including the continuation of such episodes and the research we do:
इनफिनिटी फ़ौंडेशन की परियोजनाओं को अनुदान देने के लिए व इस प्रकार के एपिसोड और हमारे द्वारा किये जाने वाले शोध को जारी रखने के लिए: infinityfoundat...
To Subscribe to Rajiv Malhotra Official:
राजीव मल्होत्रा ऑफिसियल की सदस्यता लेने के लिए: / @rajivmalhotraofficial
Join Rajiv's discussion (राजीव की चर्चा से जुडें): groups.google....
Listen to the Kurukshetra podcast! Available on:
iTunes: podcasts.apple...
Google Podcasts: www.google.com...
Anchor: anchor.fm/kuru...
Spotify: open.spotify.c...
What really is encouraging is the emergence of young Bharatiya s , discussing the itihas, the values, the sanskriti philosophy of our forefathers/ mother through the Sanatan lense. Please keep this good work going.🙏
Pl keep up the enlightenment
Absolutely true.... I just feel hopeful when I see these youth taking charge of Bharath 🇮🇳🇮🇳🙌🙌💐💐🙏🙏
Well done 👌👌👍👍👏👏 Keep it going.... 💐💐🙏🙏
its not "emergence". Infinity foundation has mentored and groomed these people !!
Dr Mazumdar is a very intelligent, knowledgeable, and brave scholar, and was ably supported by Sri Deepak Srinivasan. The topic is one on which very little was known, till the analysis presented today. The partition of Bengal has somewhat been at least politically redeemed through the formation of Bangladesh, but the severance of West Punhab ftom Bharat (in the gruesome manner described in thus conversation) remains a non healing sore, probably worsening over time. It's only revelations from platfotms such as Satya Samvad that will first make us aware, and then lead us to recovery. My respects to both. Chalapati Rao
keep this initiative alive
thank you
Namaskar and thank you! 🙏💐
Mool sthaan multan ❤ land of bhakt prahlaad and Malhotra clan of Punjabi khatris 🎉 sun temple and suryavanshi kshatriya
I love listening to Deepakji. Always very insightful. A literary giant in making.
जय श्री राम
Very interesting conversation.. Dr.Mrittyunjoy Guha Mazumdar and Sri Deepak Srinivasan are scholars and they came here fully prepared. Each sentence or second was very informative. Please accept my compliments.
---- ------
Just a thought.
The interviewer should speak less .........and allow the interviewee have more time..
Even though the interviewer does know the answers, he should ask the questions in such a way so as to make the answers come from the mouth of the interviewee.
----- ----- -----
SATYA-SAMVAD is an appropriate name.
Kudos to the person who did this " naamakaranam".
Namaskar, thank you for your view. Satya Samvad is an initiative by myself under the aegis of Infinity Foundation. This was not quite an interview but an interaction, and therefore the significant points by myself. Thanks. 🙂🙏
Indeed, the interactive element of the episode is what kept me engaged throughout, with an expectation of something complementary and additive from each turnover. If at all, you might change ends next time, to give us a different experience of the interaction.
love your work
Good effort friends….all out support for this scholarly work.
you gyus are doing a great job, more power to you.
Very important insights.
❤
Sindhava lavanam is the original salt used in Indian cuisine and used to come from a mountain in Sindh. Also, it's potassium chloride instead of Sodium chloride, which is better for human health,BP, water retention etc.
The reference to the indian sub continent as south Asia is objectionable and shows thw coolie mentality
same eduaction should be available in hindi also, hindi population needs more awareness of our civilisation compare to other population outside country
Can Tajikistan 1:24:07 ? be a model
First start ghar whapsi in a missionary mode
Keep discussing history futile.There is huge influx of UP Muslims..in the East Panjab..population has increased from 1.5 % to 4% .as per recent Panjabi News Channels..were discussing impact on High caste Hindus..all are vulnerable ..why forget the worst Partition is in the 1947 the horror of kind.StrangePolitical system prevailing,and Soft corner of Majority Sikh,Hindu who suffered worst.Waff property more than 70000 ,in the state of small Panjab.Emergence Mazar,Ghettos at all important ant location and around border Distt,other towns.,Halal shops,conflict of refined are being overlooked.Forget history ..consequences of onslaught of missionary .the future is alarming.
Pakistan ke sabhi hinduon ko Bharat mein bula lena chahiye aur saman sankhya mein musalmanon ko Pakistan bhej dena chahiye Issey Bharat mein bahut shanti ho jayegi Jai hindu rashtra Bharat
saath mai musla bhi "hindu" bol kay ghuss jayega...because they are hating their oppressive lives in parkistan
Discussing about history is no use, India met huge loss due to partition. No proper population exchange. As Ambedkar wishes, hindus in Pakistan still persecuted. So our government take back hindus from pak, and equal number of Muslims should sent Pakistan,
History as a stream is not final but ever flowing and evolving.
Our Present and near Future will become history for the following generations.
It should be discussed do that it doesn’t repeat again
Great initiative Mrittunjoy 👍🏼
Very interesting, thank you
I have read twitter threads of Deepak Srinivasan and they are very well researched! Thank you for bringing him to the IF channel.
Multan is always a Hindu (Different Sect) now the Elite Muslims named the Area as Seraikistan.
The partition was unfortunate but having happened, wish MKG, Nehru and rest of Congress did a complete exchange of Muslims and brought UCC then itself 🙏
Interesting samvaad
All in all very good discussion
No comparison between Mrityunjay ji who can take a masterclass sleeping and Deepak who is still a budding technocrat good with numbers. Great interaction!
🙏🙏👍
❤❤❤
A very insightful and informative discussion with many unknown facts or purposefully hidden history on partition. Thank you Sir.
Moderator needs to add pauses and emphasis on certain syllables. Helps to avoid talking in a fast monotone. Very long compound sentences/paragraphs tend to put audience into a trance or sleep. At the very least the point of the long sentence gets lost on the audience.
Please keep it "Short and Sweet".
Compare above two paragraphs to see the difference. 🤔😁
Pre. Islamic heirtage of old multan surya temple and. Prahaladpuri
अंग्रेजी के दास तो बन ही गए हैं हम।
Why INC never bothered to bring back Hindus before partition. RSS made a better job. INC with it's closeness to the british should have planned along with the british to bring back Hindus. 😢
Because they didn't wanted to come...they choose that nation......even some hindus went to Pakistan from India...mandal was thier first law minister i think
Token coverage by India today