No it doesn't... UN charter article 51: "Nothing in the present Charter shall impair the inherent right of collective or individual self-defense if an armed attack occurs against a member of the United Nations, until the Security Council has taken the measures necessary to maintain international peace and security. Measures taken by members in exercise of this right of self-defense shall be immediately reported to the Security Council and shall not in any way affect the authority and responsibility of the Security Council under the present Charter to take at any time such action as it deems necessary in order to maintain or restore international peace and security."
@@Urair222 I mean the UN are one of the main souces of disinformation about this conflict, does that surprisee you that the main UN troll Francesca Albanese would blatantly misrepresent what the article actually says
@@dimasaryotejo4227 That doesn't include the Palestinian territories. Only the ones that were a part of Israel in the 1947 plan. And also, by stating that law, you just accepted that Israel is a colonial state.
@@jeremyvogt102 Israel has been occupying Palestinian land for over 75 years That is a fact What part of that exactly would you describe as misinformed or wrong?
Nice try Hasbara, BUT Israhell moved the rave on the 3rd day to GAZA. You were openly invading and thney have the right to get you off their lawn. Here's hoping tomorrow shows the entire world why inbreeding should be illegal.@@ARH-FHD23
Yes. Norman Finkelstein likened it to all wardens leaving the prison complex and giving the jailed the keys to their cells but the wardens man the compound walls and with their weapons control what goes in and goes out and can shoot anyone in their cell from the compound wall and can intrude and kill whenever they want. Sure, the.prisonerd provide for their own needs and choose their leaders but are the prisoners free? I don't think so. It is more like Apartheid South Africa bantustans but worse.
Exactly 💯 it's not a self defence when you are occupying a land illegally and then the people retaliate as a result of the occupation. Thank you Francesca for stating it as it is.
Israel is not occupying a land illegally, Israel is a sovereign state and is recognized as such world wide. This chic from the un wouldn't know if her pants were on fire and the un is a farce and should have been dissolved years ago.
@@EverLastingUnity-xo5wm bunch of bull cr@p. How about DNA test to verify it? Those settlers are Eastern European rejects. Got no business in Palestine.
She should first listen to herself. If Hamas does not control a territory but operates from within a territory then Israel has the right to go after it.
Her word soup is typical of what we have come to expect from anyone trying to justify violence against Israel then wants to complain about their retaliation. If Hamas is a ‘non group’, how then does she explain all the foreign aid that’s been poured into Gaza; money that Hamas has misappropriated to its own cause? Hamas is the governing body of Gaza. They attacked Israel, therefore, they are a legitimate target.
H@mas this word soup that. We all know what the root cause is. Izzy is the root cause of every issue in the Middle East and dare I say at a global level. The utter contempt they have for the rule of law on a national and international level should be a cause of concern for every citizen of the world.
Oh and why is it that your heroes, the so called “freedom fighters” of Hamas hide behind women and children? They train in uniform so why won’t they face their enemy in battle wearing their uniform? Instead they fight in civilian clothing? I’ll tell you why…………….cuz they’re a bunch of f?!$&@% cowards just like you😎👍
@@zitrone2250your a disingenuous Zionist who’s not trying to understand. Your question makes no sense, because that’s your point is to pick at nonsense. The fact that their water, fule and movement is restricted is evidence of occupation. It’s been deemed so by UN, and every human rights group
@@zitrone2250 ah, you are not listening.. the self defence reason can be erected if a state is under attack by another state, because palestine is not a state, gaza is not an autonomous entity, israel cannot claim the right of self defence. However, an occupied territory have the right to defend themselves from occupier. Therefore, palestine or gaza has the right to defend themselves. The 2 conditions are different, one is self defense of one independent state towards a military aggression of other independent state, the other is self defense of occupied territory towards their occupier. Is it clear enough for you?
@@mha9578 Then you forgot History since palastines are oquping parts of israel that Israel and before that Egypt has pulled out of not the other way around and its not the first time they have done that its the reason the other arabik states in the region dont want there refugees sine they had them in the past and the palastinians played the same game there
You guys need to stop using such dumb analogies. So long as these backwards people think it's "their land" this will never end. People like you giving them false hope is why all this violence is happening
Lol there are literally over 200 kidnapped Israelis by hamas on october 7 , 2cnd of all Israel is threted, and israel went out of gaza in 2005 but why should the truth or the reality bother you, or this stupid stupid woman , i would like to see her telling us another country cant protect it self after only one attack that killed over 1500 children an woman by terrorists in a single day
Ask yourself a question - how can Hamas be the governing authority in Gaza and claim to be occupied by a foreign power at the same time? Seems to me like a propaganda masterpiece and she is spreading it. Same as claiming Israel is blockading Gaza when it does not control all of its borders.
You're the only Albanese I'd follow Francesca. I wouldn't follow the Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese anywhere. Absolutely disgusted by his government's cowardice on the matter.
She said exactly what I have been saying! How is Israel under threat from a country that Israel has occupied 😂 it’s so delusional! That’s like saying “the squatters forced the home owners out of their own homes and then the owners fought back for their home and then the squatters played the victims saying the owners are terrorists because they want their home back. So the squatters deserved to self defend themselves against the home owners” it’s so crazy and frustrating to hear when someone says things like “Israel is defending themselves” ummmm from what exactly?!
@davidmr2121 dude shut up! Whole of Palestine and (Israel) was stolen from the Palestinians! My grandparents are older than “Israel” they quite literally become squatters on my grandparents lands in 1948! They literally kicked my grandfather of his property and squatted in his home! Take this from someone who has grandparents who has had Jewish people spit on them and kick them out off their own home with guns pointed at them! Take this from a person who has also had her uncle kidnapped at the age of 18 from their home and up until now we don’t know if he’s dead or alive. My grandmother died heartbroken not knowing anything about her son. So shut up and don’t even try to go there with me about October 6! You don’t know nothing except for what your bias news is wanting to show you. You talk about October 6 as if this all started then! But how about we go way back to 1948! Israel has murdered millions of Christian and Muslim Palestinians. You tell me what this has done to Palestinians?! Why does the world think that a dead Jew is more important than a dead Palestinian?! Sorry to break it to you but YOU white people are NOT the only ones that can be victims! i know you white folks are so used to having white supremacy power and privileges but we will not allow this anymore all thanks social media the world has finally woken up to the truth. What Palestine is enduring right now is 1000000 times worse than what Hitler did to the Jews! And you’d think the Jews would be against genocide on Palestinians because of what they experienced, some are actually speaking against Israel and some (like yourself) are just being plain ignorant and stupid and evil with no heart who actually supports the killing of a Palestinian child! Sick and disgusting.
@@notowar8918 Your comment is totally irrelevant... "occupation" was not mentioned. In any case, Israel stopped occupying Gaza 19 years ago. Please refer to a dictionary.
Exactly! More people should be saying this. This is all within Israel's borders. This is a problem of their own creation. And it has been going on for decades. If you look at it another way, it's been going on for a century.
What a joke … this stupid woman must be blissfully unaware that Hamas are the elected government of the Palestinian territory of Gaza. Hamas have recently posted videos stating they intend to repeat the 7th October massacres over and over again. Hamas own charter calls for genocide of the Jews all over the world not just Israel. This UN woman is delusional or straight up retarded. Hamas call for the destruction of Israel openly. Is she deaf 🤷♂️
You must be very lazy and very stupid. Gaza was never occupied…Gaza was and still is a hornets nest trying to destroy Israel. And now all Palestinian Nazis (Hams or whatever their name may be) will be sent where they belong…
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@thedunyadoneya2628 oh by the way, since I both watch the Arab and west media, there are so called expert Palestinians testifying on matter they do not know. I’m sorry if you do not know that. Ignorance will kill you. 🤣😂🤭
@@thedunyadoneya2628 I will repeat what I have typed. I’m not a native speaker but my understanding is better than yours. My logic is logical than yours. My listening skill is far better than yours. 😅😂😇 Don’t worry brother/sister, you will be shamed by the evidences of this war because Idf is near to uncover the tunnels where Hamas are hiding. That’s why they want ceasefire and your terrorist allies are destructing Idf. But God be with them. Your lies will be exposed. 😂🤡☺️🤭
🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇵🇸🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸 Black South Africans fought an armed struggle against its Apartheid Government- the ANC was an "armed group" Mandela and the other leaders of the resistance were arrested and tried for treason for Terrorism, yes Mandela was a terrorist and spent 27yrs in jail for wanting a single state for all people equal before the Law.. nobody would dare say to us South Africans that the Apartheid Government had the right to defend its self whilst it was an oppressor of human rights, its one crime is to occupy it is another thing to commit crimes against humanity while you occupy, so no there is no right to self defense. Occupation and oppression expressed in a single word is RAPE.
@@GertMyburgh-g4o And? When you are a slave all you care about is being free when youre sick all you care about it being healthy at least we now have a society that can protest that can VOTE or have you forgotten that voting was reserved for Whites only ? Every country has its problems at least we no longer have to worry about every white person being a racist and every black person being an animal in Africa.. that is a great achievement today we are proud to speak Afrikaans and Zulu and our other national languages side by side as equals..
She called Gaza "an occupied territory" when in fact Hamas has been in charge for over two decades. They are a proxy for Iran and guess what, they decided to launch an attack from the strip into Israel to hit random people. To inflict maximum damage and now you want a ceasefire. Neither side here can claim the high moral authority because they are just playing proxy war games.
t's like if someone raped her without an italian ID she would say that he shouldn't be punished, because only Italian citizens can be punished in Italia.
@alanhat5252 Eat your hat, Alan. Admittedly gratuitous, but bullying, c'mon. Now, you come across as a school marm, just to give you a little of your own back. Keep wagging that finger of yours!
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@Sheikh_White_ 😂🤣😂 enlighten me sheikh why i need to be killed or disown when I leave Islam. The last time I heard Dr. Shaib, your brave debater and president of Muslim blah blah blah was talking about free will. So should human in Islam must not exercise his free will given by God to him?
I’m so glad all the Arab nations in the Middle East are so compassionate towards the Palestinians. It just makes me so happy they’re accepting all refugees with open arms. never mind that’s not the case at all.
So Arabs must take in the Palestinians? So you want the Arabs to complete the Ethnic Cleansing and Genocide of the Palestinians on behalf of israel? Because clearly that is israel's intent. They want to clear all of Gaza and the West Bank of Palestinians.
Palestine was their land. The Jewish refugees decided they wanted it all. The took houses, land, dug up ancient olive groves all with the help of the US. Took over 70% of the country and still wanted more. Now they are aiming for 100% of Palestine.
@micahellowitz9722 when Osama Bin Laden went into the Twin Towers..the USA did not run to Saudi Arabia, where Bin Laden was from, and destroy Saudi Arabia with 2000 bombs and kill 27,000 people. They waited, found him in Afghanistan and killed him years after 911. THAT'S a CIVILIZED RESPONSE
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@iBored123yeah i accept the fact hamas is terrorist,islam is the worst religion in rhis world,all muslim are the bad guy ,bla bla bla bla bla bla bla😂😂😂
@@erikthered1719 use your brain,you claim hamas doesn't care about gaza,some of you saying free gaza from hamas,so why not israel care about gazans ,why airstrike hospital,camp refugee, church and school and over 10000 gazan died
@@LikadeesIsrael. Since the 1948 Nakba, since Britain handed over the partitioned land to a newly formed state in which the majority of the people who lived there were deprived of the right to vote, since historic Palestine was annexed.
@@zaidal-hindawi1784the fact that someone commented to you claiming she is lying.. what benefit is there to lying about your land being stolen 😂😂unless you were coming back years later to secretly claim it like Hitler claimed Germany. Supporters of Israel just never make any sense like their whole argument is everything she said was a lie because she paused for 3 seconds 😂 she is most likely bi lingual too and I bet money the person who tagged you.l can barely speak one 😂☝️
She is correct , but Israel , the US , the EU doesn’t care about her explanation . Basically the rules are what the occupiers say it is. That’s the sad part
It's like if someone raped her without an italian ID she would say that he shouldn't be punished, because only Italian citizens can be punished in Italia.
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@iBored123So, because Hamas say they represent Palestinians they are in fact the Palestinian representation? Don't you know the West Bank is also part of Palestine and is ruled by the Palestinian Authority (different from Hamas)? Gaza is not a state, it's a territory and under International Law, a STATE has to attack another so the latter can claim self-defence. Anyway, those technicalities are not what really matters in her argument. What's relevant is the fact that Israel has been occupying Gaza since 2007 by doing a blockade that has kept the territory in inhumane conditions. Hamas attacks are a response to that occupation and under International Law, Israel cannot claim self-defence in that case. It makes all sense. Let me give you an example: In the XIXth century, Spain was the colonizer of the now Latin American countries. The indigenous people of those territories attacked Spain to become independent. If the UN existed by that time, could have Spain claimed self-defence?
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@iBored123 And many don't even recognize Palestine as a state and it is being forcefully occupied by Israel. So she's not wrong. These are essentially the same role the French resistance played in world war 2, with similar brutality from Israel's part might I add.
This is what is called an asymmetric conflict: one side is expected to conduct in accordance with all international laws and procedures, and another side can perform whatever crimes against humanity in accordance with it’s own rules… It’s like to play cards with a bunch of cardsharpers.
I don't even know which side you're referring to. Because idiocy is rampant around here and people actually think Hamas is "in accordance" with international laws by mutilating kids, raping innocent women and baking toddlers. It's strange.
Are you being funny? She unironically stated you don't have the right of self defense if you are attacked by anything other than another state. That statement alone completely nukes any credibility she has to speak on the subject given she made such a dumb statement given there is no ruling, statute or treaty that specifies that an act of self defense only applies if committed by another state.
Palestine is freeing us: From propaganda From ignorance From blind consumerism From conformity From cowardice From the facade of safety From shame From individualism From fear Freedom for Palestine
Except it’s the law she posted it on her X account for the people having trouble. It also dated back to the 2000s Israel knows it that’s why it’s so important everyone acknowledge their right to defend themselves because the government knows the laws.
@@Stavroforoi_Kata_Islam OK bro and the journalist that got shot in the head(they said not us then ok😊 it's us) , also the little Palestinian that got killed for no reason before the 7 October and others before thats ok for you? Like you accept the atrocious stuff from one side ig
@@Stavroforoi_Kata_Islam which constant attacks? Every year Isreal bombs Gaza... plus there was no Hamas prior to 06 n this occupation n oppression has been going on for way longer than 17 years
@@AshrafAnam Israel left Palestine in 2005. Back to the real question: Where is the demand for Hamas to surrender and return the hostages? Answer that instead of making up another "question"?
When are you going to understand that Israel don't care about the hostages. The proof is there that they killed their own people at the festival. This is from their own investigations. If they really cared about about their people they would have used their top of the world military intelligence & do ground work to get to the hostages without flattening a whole population. Their actions are so clear but you are so blind.
A colonizer can't claim to defend himself from people of a land he's illegaly stealing lands from. If anything, Palestinians have the legal right to defend themsleves against the military attack being conducted against their population
@@rbcreations2They are extremely dangerous Jihadists, actually. You're clearly misinformed about what that group represents. They are a terror to their own people as well. A death cult.
And what gives them the legal right? If you follow this lady's line of argument Gaza is not a legal entity, not a state. Hamas is a militant group, not a national army. Gaza is 'occupied' territory (occupied by whom?). Technically, if you follow this lady's argument, Hamas is a gang of thugs fighting for control over turf and wanting to expand that turf. So, with no legal status any and all acts of violence, physical or otherwise, are criminal acts, making Hamas a crime syndicate with the crime boss tucked away safely and lavishly in Doha Qatar. And a very well funded one at that, because the UN has a commission supplying aid and funds just for them.
@@barakasher45 yet their situation is much much better than gaza citizens even when being under military law. This just proves these people can't govern themselves, the moment israel pulls out of the west bank there would be a rain of rockets in tell aviv. Oh and there's no big wall there(unlike gaza) and it cant even be built due to the geography so the moment a terror organization rises to power(a thing that happened in literally EVERY muslim country) that would be much much worse than the hamas attacks
@maxamedm3040 What is it with you commenters with your BLIND LOVE of the word "apartheid". Whatever the Israeli situation has in common with 1980s South Africa, that word does not signicantly apply to how Arab citizens are "treated" in Israel.
Brought this upon themselves by being diplomatic when offering peace solutions on several different occasions, only to be met with hostile rejections in the form of attacks. 🤷🏿♂️
@@Mmmmmmm232they never. It was always Israel bombing and settling on somebody's home and claiming to be peaceful. Israel is already in no position to speak 🤡your lies doesn't work anymore
@lukeleney5917 Where to begin, First and foremost, Israel didn't take land from Palestinians. Secondly, please establish when they did take land from Palestinians that wasn't diplomatically acquired as a result of Palestines actions. Thirdly, Israel offered peace negotiations on several occasions, and we're met with hostile rejections via attacks. The first attack immediately after Israel's statehood was ratified; Amazingly Israel still sought out diplomacy vs war. It was not until 1967 did Israel start to remove a persistent threat from the West Bank after 20 years of persistent attacks by the PLO, so please regale us with your extensive knowledge of how Israel supposedly "stole land" from Palestinians.
An armed group in an occupied territory is a liberation movement. For example, the ANC is apartheid South Africa. They were labelled terrorists but in fact they were a liberation movement.
Even if this woman was right it means every police force and military called out to defend and fight a domestic terror attack would be unjustified. Ridiculous.
@@eggggg3577Their has never not been Jews in Palestine and Palestine has never been a country, it’s always been someone else’s land. Yet since 1948 they could have a nation if only they would negotiate a settlement in good faith. Oct7th was a terror attack of the most gruesome kind.
Times of Israel: Former Israeli Prime Minister Yair Lapid says "If the international media is objective and shows both sides, it serves Hamas," Lapid said on Sunday. "My argument is that the media cannot just claim to bring both sides of the story. If you do that, you are only bringing one - Hamas's side," No coverage so no war crimes
Only when media manipulation, stops to be the only source of information, disseminated by the occupiers, to coverup the reality of the violations committed by them, their supporters and suppliers, for more than 75 years, is when the real suffering of the Palestinians, has come to light, for it can no longer be denied, because the eyes of millions of humans was kept blindfolded by the murderous forces of immorality but now, those are no longer victims of misinformation for the genocide is been committed in front of their faces.
The right of self defence should be invoked whenever a State is threatened whether from another state or even its citizens. A state must always protect its citizens even if a threat is from within.
So the zionist IDF protected their citizens by shooting at them from an appatchi helicopter so their bodies were burned? and Palestinians are not citizens of the zionist movements of Israel until Zionism keeps lying to the world, your comical propaganda is failing the good Jewish people out there? 2 equal states its the only way for Israel to live in peace anything less than that, Israel will never live in peace, you can kill as many innocent babies, but you can not kill an ideology wake up and smell the coffee mate?
1) apartheid Israel does not consider Palestinian in the occupied territories citizens 2) “from within” would require Israel to annex Gaza, West Bank and Gollan and they won’t as that would mean citizenship for people in those occupied territories Now ask me why Israel do not want to give them citizenship ?
@@cristalp00 Israel can be apartheid in one part “West Bank for example and a belligerent occupier “Israel Supreme Court definition” in another like Gaza And before you say they are not occupying Gaza. They control land borders, sea shores and air space. The y also control who and what goes in and out of Gaza. That is occupation with out the hassle and dangers of boot on the ground PS Insults are the arguments employed by those who are in the wrong
@@DerrickCNdu yea. Go look up international law and explain to me how Israel are breaking any of them…does Hamas have to follow international too or do you only apply the law when you want to apply it?
Civilian that come knowingly to land that is not theirs, house that are not theirs. Frankly, the status of occupying settlers is less than standard civilian.
So you saying that killing innocent civilians is OK. That it is fine that Israel killed the people at the festival (their own investigations proof it) then use that to justify the genocide they are doing now. Everything they claimed happened to justify their attacks couldn't be backed up with proof/facts. Bombing of hospitals, letting prem babies die for what... Their own actions. Their actions are clear but you are blind.
Haha, have you ever asked yourself why other countries don't have Iron dome? How come Iran doesn't attack neighboring countries? How come Spain doesn't bomb Portugal? I wonder why Israel has to protect itself from Palestine? Jeez, what did they do? 😂
@@nickgoldring1446 I think the Israeli gov lies, obfuscates and fabricates evidence. I think most civilians are on board with this, since it facilitates the mass killing of Palestinians, and this is not just post Oct 7th, it has happened for a century. I think they way Israelis are behaving, it's monstrous. They were victims of the Holocaust themselves, after only 3 years they went on to do the Nakba, and are doing a New Nakba right now as we write. Now tell me what YOU really think, Sport.
@@bananenbrot-pt7moIsrael killing 12800 civilians(5800 of which are children)is just propaganda? yeah sure,then the Holocaust too was just propaganda by that logic🤡
The Palestinians have had a state brokered for them twice - once under Arafat of the PLO. And Abbas of Hamas. Both vetoed the idea because they did not want to lose the power and money involved. No sympathy for them.😊
Lady, you are very educated but am surprised that you still not aware that Israel left Gaza since 2005, which occupation are you talking about??!! Actually, if you say that Israel is still occupying Gaza, that even gives Israel much authority to enter and clean up the mess... What should Israel do when they are attacked by the same group you are talking about?? What do you suggest to Israel as a nation, they should fold their arms?? You speak comfortably because you are living in peace, ... Which country are you from? Probably very far from a terrorist organization, and you have never experienced any kind of terrorism so keep quiet and let the country that is feeling the pain to deal with it...
@@xillaTVis literally israels land. the jews were there before islam was even there. israel agreed to a 2 state solution, and the palestinians refused. they then elected hamas and declared war on israel. you don't get to complain about being oppressed when you get smacked by the people you tried to genocide.
Now that there is the before and after the genocide on Gaza in every aspect of life. the genocide on Gaza revealed the truth about everything and everyone even the truth about the people I considered my role models and heroes before the genocide on Gaza. As a human beings I can’t have genocide enablers as role models… Francesca Albanese is my new role model along with Naledi Pandor. My utmost respect and admiration for both of them🫡🫡you are my superwoman. Keep standing up for humanity!
Oh look, you're the 20,000,000,000th person to say "Free Palestine." I guess Israel just has to give up the war Hamas started and let themselves be genocided because you said so
I found this out weeks ago, its in the UN charter, you can't claim self defence from territory that you occupy.
No it doesn't... UN charter article 51: "Nothing in the present Charter shall impair the inherent right of collective or individual self-defense if an armed attack occurs against a member of the United Nations, until the Security Council has taken the measures necessary to maintain international peace and security. Measures taken by members in exercise of this right of self-defense shall be immediately reported to the Security Council and shall not in any way affect the authority and responsibility of the Security Council under the present Charter to take at any time such action as it deems necessary in order to maintain or restore international peace and security."
@@BamBamGT1Apparently you know more about international law than the UN themselves.
@@Urair222 I mean the UN are one of the main souces of disinformation about this conflict, does that surprisee you that the main UN troll Francesca Albanese would blatantly misrepresent what the article actually says
Utis posidetis juris learn it bto that is the international law for land you call as occupy land.
@@dimasaryotejo4227 That doesn't include the Palestinian territories. Only the ones that were a part of Israel in the 1947 plan.
And also, by stating that law, you just accepted that Israel is a colonial state.
That should be in mainstream media.. it is not controversial.. it is a fact..
You know facts are misinformation. Come on, what century are you from?
@@jeremyvogt102 Israel has been occupying Palestinian land for over 75 years
That is a fact
What part of that exactly would you describe as misinformed or wrong?
@@Violett8 I’m with you brother. Miscommunication
Facts are fake news. If you don't like a fact, it's not true.
@@jeremyvogt102 Sorry Bro, my bad 🙏
Palestine has every right to resist Israel occupation
and Palestine is a country is it?
Was Israel occupying Gaza when Hamas attacked it on Oct 7th?😎
Nice try Hasbara, BUT Israhell moved the rave on the 3rd day to GAZA. You were openly invading and thney have the right to get you off their lawn. Here's hoping tomorrow shows the entire world why inbreeding should be illegal.@@ARH-FHD23
Yes. Norman Finkelstein likened it to all wardens leaving the prison complex and giving the jailed the keys to their cells but the wardens man the compound walls and with their weapons control what goes in and goes out and can shoot anyone in their cell from the compound wall and can intrude and kill whenever they want. Sure, the.prisonerd provide for their own needs and choose their leaders but are the prisoners free? I don't think so. It is more like Apartheid South Africa bantustans but worse.
@@ARH-FHD23 no, Israel withdrew it's military and civilians from Gaza in 2005.
Exactly 💯 it's not a self defence when you are occupying a land illegally and then the people retaliate as a result of the occupation. Thank you Francesca for stating it as it is.
Israel is not occupying a land illegally, Israel is a sovereign state and is recognized as such world wide. This chic from the un wouldn't know if her pants were on fire and the un is a farce and should have been dissolved years ago.
@davidmr2121 yes she is and gullible people are believing her.
hahaahahahah illegally. study history better plz
Where do you live and how is it illegal?
Says who
Read it slowly, "occupied". It is an occupation by Israel. Israel is a colonizer
@@schotty616 truth
Lies
No,,, Israel is the previous owner like 1000 Bce... Arabs are Arabs, Palestine was renamed from Judaea... So Palestinians never existed just Arabs.
@@EverLastingUnity-xo5wm bunch of bull cr@p. How about DNA test to verify it? Those settlers are Eastern European rejects. Got no business in Palestine.
@@brandonking995 what part do you consider to be lies? How about you come up with more than one word on the issue.
WELL SPOKEN AND ABSOLUTELY CORRECT
She should first listen to herself. If Hamas does not control a territory but operates from within a territory then Israel has the right to go after it.
@@israelnwanne8401 nah.
Out of all the languages, she decided to speak facts ✨
Unfortunately that’s the only language Israel chooses not to understand.
@mattdiamand3374really what's the actual fact? tell me
Her word soup is typical of what we have come to expect from anyone trying to justify violence against Israel then wants to complain about their retaliation. If Hamas is a ‘non group’, how then does she explain all the foreign aid that’s been poured into Gaza; money that Hamas has misappropriated to its own cause? Hamas is the governing body of Gaza. They attacked Israel, therefore, they are a legitimate target.
@@kimhaslam664 fighting against occupation isn't considered a crime. Get it genius?
H@mas this word soup that. We all know what the root cause is. Izzy is the root cause of every issue in the Middle East and dare I say at a global level. The utter contempt they have for the rule of law on a national and international level should be a cause of concern for every citizen of the world.
Israel :"I locked up a bear and poked it repeatedly with a stick. I was so shocked when it growled at me and tried to bite me"
Except 50% of the ‘bears’ are children!
Oh and why is it that your heroes, the so called “freedom fighters” of Hamas hide behind women and children? They train in uniform so why won’t they face their enemy in battle wearing their uniform? Instead they fight in civilian clothing? I’ll tell you why…………….cuz they’re a bunch of f?!$&@% cowards just like you😎👍
Wait for the bear to come out of cage then see what will happen
If only this simplified statement was true….
@@harietahubanova9846precisely - what an "analogy" by a super intelligent antisemite......
She has explained the issue with clarity.
if Gaza or Palastina is no country that self defence can be declared again how can it be ocupied at the same time explain that logic to me
@@zitrone2250your a disingenuous Zionist who’s not trying to understand. Your question makes no sense, because that’s your point is to pick at nonsense. The fact that their water, fule and movement is restricted is evidence of occupation. It’s been deemed so by UN, and every human rights group
@@zitrone2250 ah, you are not listening.. the self defence reason can be erected if a state is under attack by another state, because palestine is not a state, gaza is not an autonomous entity, israel cannot claim the right of self defence.
However, an occupied territory have the right to defend themselves from occupier. Therefore, palestine or gaza has the right to defend themselves.
The 2 conditions are different, one is self defense of one independent state towards a military aggression of other independent state, the other is self defense of occupied territory towards their occupier.
Is it clear enough for you?
@@mha9578 Then you forgot History since palastines are oquping parts of israel that Israel and before that Egypt has pulled out of not the other way around and its not the first time they have done that its the reason the other arabik states in the region dont want there refugees sine they had them in the past and the palastinians played the same game there
@@mha9578They might be different & yes she has a point. But to say Israel DOESN'T have the right to defend itself is ludicrous!
UN resolution 37/43, dated 3dec.1982, gives the right of self-defense, BY ALL MEANS, only to the occupied nations, and not to the occupier.
But Palestine isn't a nation.
@@MrAbuYazYes that is an issue, exactly why Isr has worked so hard to prevent it from ever happening.
@@mischevious nope,pals don't want it bc then they'd b subjectvto intl law.
They wait for Israel to be destroyed.
@@MrAbuYaz There's a difference between a nation and a country.
@@mischevious silly goose, they don't want a state, they want to eliminate,a state. Biggest con in history.
Exactly. It's like saying a kidnapper has a right to self defense against the person they've kidnapped.
Funny you should mention kidnapping, considering Hamas kidnapped a 9-month old baby
It has ALWAYS been the Arabs who attacked. If they're in prison now it's their own doing
Spot on! ❤
You guys need to stop using such dumb analogies. So long as these backwards people think it's "their land" this will never end. People like you giving them false hope is why all this violence is happening
Lol there are literally over 200 kidnapped Israelis by hamas on october 7 , 2cnd of all Israel is threted, and israel went out of gaza in 2005 but why should the truth or the reality bother you, or this stupid stupid woman , i would like to see her telling us another country cant protect it self after only one attack that killed over 1500 children an woman by terrorists in a single day
She is courageous and absolutely right.
She paid attention in her classes ❤
Did her research, she is 💯 correct.
YOU BET,, AFTER 25 YEARS WORKING FOR THE "RIGHTS" OF PALESTINES, OR BETTER CALLED FALASTINES.
SHE IS A GREAT LAWYER,,!!!
VERY PRECIOUS.
@@stellaeliza5317 But how exactly are they occupying?
Ask yourself a question - how can Hamas be the governing authority in Gaza and claim to be occupied by a foreign power at the same time? Seems to me like a propaganda masterpiece and she is spreading it. Same as claiming Israel is blockading Gaza when it does not control all of its borders.
@@NathanBee3 Military control and a complete blockade is "occupation."
@@NathanBee3They are building their illegal settlements in the West Bank.There are IDF soldiers IN the West Bank.What do you think occupation mean?
Absolutely correct. 💯
Evil succeeds when good men do nothing
You must be very successful 😂
@@EverLastingUnity-xo5wm what you want him to do become a terrorist lover and protest free phonystine
Yes , we need to stop the vicious arabs
Luv ❤️ Your Comment.
Evil just succeeds
You're the only Albanese I'd follow Francesca. I wouldn't follow the Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese anywhere.
Absolutely disgusted by his government's cowardice on the matter.
It DOES make a Difference, Please Share NEVER Stop Sharing
I bet that no western media will show this clip in their coverage ❤ free palestine
Ok i' ll take that bet.
@@casimerbrylski1900they'll never as they dont we doomed on Tvs everyday 😂😂
Western Media is all you watch, living in your mind
I'm Australia and this was in our national channel ABC before this she was a prominent ABC program called Q & A
@@sashmendis8432oh really ? Show us please ?
Can we please share this as much as possible. This needs to go viral to help the mentally challenged people who support Israel understand the reality
Mentally challenged, disingenuous, or just plain evil.
so you are Muslim and are a Sharia Muslim?
@davidmr2121 yes she most certainly is.
@davidmr2121 do you denounce white supremacy?
@@sarvolfe6435 do you denounce white supremacy
She said exactly what I have been saying! How is Israel under threat from a country that Israel has occupied 😂 it’s so delusional! That’s like saying “the squatters forced the home owners out of their own homes and then the owners fought back for their home and then the squatters played the victims saying the owners are terrorists because they want their home back. So the squatters deserved to self defend themselves against the home owners” it’s so crazy and frustrating to hear when someone says things like “Israel is defending themselves” ummmm from what exactly?!
You understand that we forcibly removed our civilians and our army in 2005?
@mrabuyaz, siege = occupation.
@@MrAbuYazthen why is your army & your bombs still there?
They never left did they?
@@alanhat5252 2005-2023 idiot
@davidmr2121 dude shut up! Whole of Palestine and (Israel) was stolen from the Palestinians! My grandparents are older than “Israel” they quite literally become squatters on my grandparents lands in 1948! They literally kicked my grandfather of his property and squatted in his home! Take this from someone who has grandparents who has had Jewish people spit on them and kick them out off their own home with guns pointed at them! Take this from a person who has also had her uncle kidnapped at the age of 18 from their home and up until now we don’t know if he’s dead or alive. My grandmother died heartbroken not knowing anything about her son. So shut up and don’t even try to go there with me about October 6! You don’t know nothing except for what your bias news is wanting to show you. You talk about October 6 as if this all started then! But how about we go way back to 1948! Israel has murdered millions of Christian and Muslim Palestinians. You tell me what this has done to Palestinians?! Why does the world think that a dead Jew is more important than a dead Palestinian?! Sorry to break it to you but YOU white people are NOT the only ones that can be victims! i know you white folks are so used to having white supremacy power and privileges but we will not allow this anymore all thanks social media the world has finally woken up to the truth. What Palestine is enduring right now is 1000000 times worse than what Hitler did to the Jews! And you’d think the Jews would be against genocide on Palestinians because of what they experienced, some are actually speaking against Israel and some (like yourself) are just being plain ignorant and stupid and evil with no heart who actually supports the killing of a Palestinian child! Sick and disgusting.
Respect to this lady for clarifying what is 'self defence'. Which main stream media intentionally reported wrongful for decates.
Nonsense. So if someone attacked you physically and you fought back, then that is not self-defence according to you!
@@davidbroadfoot1864this is in the case of states not individuals. Completely different
@@rerandhaskele205 so, what types of entities are states allowed to defend themselves against?
@@davidbroadfoot1864 Pursue of ignorance. Can't deny occupation and international law. Occupier vs occupied.
@@notowar8918 Your comment is totally irrelevant... "occupation" was not mentioned. In any case, Israel stopped occupying Gaza 19 years ago. Please refer to a dictionary.
this girl is speaking only truth. may Allah bless her and protect her and guide her on a right path .
Is she a girl or a woman?
Woman*, not girl
@@TrueEnglishMan01or girly woman
Exactly! More people should be saying this. This is all within Israel's borders. This is a problem of their own creation. And it has been going on for decades. If you look at it another way, it's been going on for a century.
Actually almost 14 centuries,sine Arabs invaded and murdered natives in Palestine.
@@MrAbuYaz
Are you one of thise right wing, neo con born again Christians?
@@MrAbuYaz Oh, really? Which incident are you talking about?
@DAbibliophile arabcolonizers,and supremacists invaded the world.
What, you didn't know?
@@DAbibliophile Reread his comment. The answer to your question is in there, even the implied point in time.
Exactly! It's an occupied territory. It's like claiming being attacked by their own citizens!
No. F no. Those animals are not israeli citizens.
She speaks Facts
What a joke … this stupid woman must be blissfully unaware that Hamas are the elected government of the Palestinian territory of Gaza. Hamas have recently posted videos stating they intend to repeat the 7th October massacres over and over again. Hamas own charter calls for genocide of the Jews all over the world not just Israel. This UN woman is delusional or straight up retarded. Hamas call for the destruction of Israel openly. Is she deaf 🤷♂️
Thank you maam for clarifying for these criminals
Not occupied since 2005
You must be very lazy and very stupid. Gaza was never occupied…Gaza was and still is a hornets nest trying to destroy Israel. And now all Palestinian Nazis (Hams or whatever their name may be) will be sent where they belong…
@@CoolTaxiDriveri recommend you start reading up
@@geennaam4576 Same for you
They didn't clarify Hamas wdym
"The flame of resistance will never be extinguished as long as the desire for justice burns in our hearts." Leila Khaled
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@iBored123it might sound like a contradiction because your english is so poor. "Expert palestinians"😂😂😂
@@thedunyadoneya2628 oh by the way, since I both watch the Arab and west media, there are so called expert Palestinians testifying on matter they do not know. I’m sorry if you do not know that. Ignorance will kill you. 🤣😂🤭
@@thedunyadoneya2628 oh my, somebody deleted my comment. 🤡😂🤣 What is this? Hahaha.
@@thedunyadoneya2628 I will repeat what I have typed. I’m not a native speaker but my understanding is better than yours. My logic is logical than yours. My listening skill is far better than yours. 😅😂😇 Don’t worry brother/sister, you will be shamed by the evidences of this war because Idf is near to uncover the tunnels where Hamas are hiding. That’s why they want ceasefire and your terrorist allies are destructing Idf. But God be with them. Your lies will be exposed. 😂🤡☺️🤭
1st time UN.Reporter has talk truth
Palestinian have rights for their own land
Should be returned to Palestinian.
Yes, you are 100% correct!
🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇿🇦🇿🇦🇿🇦🇵🇸🇿🇦🇵🇸🇵🇸
Black South Africans fought an armed struggle against its Apartheid Government- the ANC was an "armed group"
Mandela and the other leaders of the resistance were arrested and tried for treason for Terrorism, yes Mandela was a terrorist and spent 27yrs in jail for wanting a single state for all people equal before the Law.. nobody would dare say to us South Africans that the Apartheid Government had the right to defend its self whilst it was an oppressor of human rights, its one crime is to occupy it is another thing to commit crimes against humanity while you occupy, so no there is no right to self defense. Occupation and oppression expressed in a single word is RAPE.
But look what's happening in south Africa no power no water and so much more politicians have done nothing for the people voetsek anc eff
@@GertMyburgh-g4o And? When you are a slave all you care about is being free when youre sick all you care about it being healthy at least we now have a society that can protest that can VOTE or have you forgotten that voting was reserved for Whites only ? Every country has its problems at least we no longer have to worry about every white person being a racist and every black person being an animal in Africa.. that is a great achievement today we are proud to speak Afrikaans and Zulu and our other national languages side by side as equals..
Mandela was a terrorist
👏 well said
She called Gaza "an occupied territory" when in fact Hamas has been in charge for over two decades. They are a proxy for Iran and guess what, they decided to launch an attack from the strip into Israel to hit random people. To inflict maximum damage and now you want a ceasefire. Neither side here can claim the high moral authority because they are just playing proxy war games.
t's like if someone raped her without an italian ID she would say that he shouldn't be punished, because only Italian citizens can be punished in Italia.
Thank you Fransesca Albanese 🙏 for saying what the crowd around can't say.
You must be mesmerized by the chic scarf she wears.
@@nickgoldring1446
I'm actually mesmerised by what she says and stands for.
I'll leave the other observations for you.
Enjoy 😉
@@hasslefreehass9380
Mesmerized in any case.
@@nickgoldring1446you come across as a child bullying in the school playground.
@alanhat5252
Eat your hat, Alan.
Admittedly gratuitous, but bullying, c'mon.
Now, you come across as a school marm, just to give you a little of your own back.
Keep wagging that finger of yours!
this lady knows the law she should be UN secretary general
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
Yep another air head!
@@iBored123cope
@@Sheikh_White_ 😂🤣😂 enlighten me sheikh why i need to be killed or disown when I leave Islam. The last time I heard Dr. Shaib, your brave debater and president of Muslim blah blah blah was talking about free will. So should human in Islam must not exercise his free will given by God to him?
@@Sheikh_White_ I need your answer. Cope. 🤡
Clear and patently true, against Israeli lies, misrepresentation and obfuscation.
Believes
Thank you lady for talking sense 🙏
francesca albanese
The truth is spoken..
International law that is all! however USA seems to be oblivious
USA is not oblivious....the USA is just greedy and sees to see benefit out of everything and everyone they "help"
Do you even know what international law is?
Sad that you’re ignorant of so much . UN is a corrupt organization being a Muslim you probably understand what that means
u.s has other imterests, sadly.
I’m so glad all the Arab nations in the Middle East are so compassionate towards the Palestinians. It just makes me so happy they’re accepting all refugees with open arms. never mind that’s not the case at all.
Right?? Because they wont.. and know what will happen if they do..
Exactly
You idiot, that's what Israel wants so they can take all the land and not allow those people to return.
They are all hypocrites
So Arabs must take in the Palestinians?
So you want the Arabs to complete the Ethnic Cleansing and Genocide of the Palestinians on behalf of israel?
Because clearly that is israel's intent. They want to clear all of Gaza and the West Bank of Palestinians.
She should go and teach those who are
supporting Netanyahu.
Stop using the word teach. You guys are all uneducated and don't know what teaching or education is.
About what??
She has no clue
This was posted on X & people still commented she didn’t know anything
@zuleimahernandez8037 They will continue to live in LA LA land until the lord of lords return.
@@erikthered1719 Do you know Hertzl. Go and study him. The father of zionism.
You are talking facts lady. Thank you❤❤❤
She has spoken the truth.
Truth has many faces, she has spoken which gives your thoughts a cushion.
@r_vis_nghani9981 are you dumb or on crack?
@@r_vis_nghani9981 an Occupying force can not act in self defence, it's not even debatable, its absurd to claim otherwise.
Yes they can, that’s absurd logic
Who is occupying Gaza? Whose government runs Gaza?
The right of self-defense only applies when you defend yourself on your own land.!
Palestine was their land. The Jewish refugees decided they wanted it all. The took houses, land, dug up ancient olive groves all with the help of the US. Took over 70% of the country and still wanted more.
Now they are aiming for 100% of Palestine.
hahahahahha, you are hilarious
@micahellowitz9722 when Osama Bin Laden went into the Twin Towers..the USA did not run to Saudi Arabia, where Bin Laden was from, and destroy Saudi Arabia with 2000 bombs and kill 27,000 people. They waited, found him in Afghanistan and killed him years after 911. THAT'S a CIVILIZED RESPONSE
Hamas and plo are squatters with evil intent
Israel is in their own land.
I like her direct, no-bullshit tone. These are facts, not opinions.
Actually there’s a lot of mental, logical and moral gymnastics she’s performing, and she’s definitely not accurately describing international law.
@@tamirch1wow i bet you're an expert on that practices 👍
In your opinion?
Her credentials speak for themselves.
The interpretation of words is always opinion, as it is a subjective experience
@@EvelynSmith-yo8eh she has indeed credentials working for an anti-Israel organisation for many years. Her bias is irrefutable.
It's ridiculous we have to mention the obvious! She has said it nicely, without ridiculing. Kudos!
Respect true honest people
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@iBored123 you are bot paid by israel, I saw your exact reply everywhere. Nice try
@@iBored123Bot??
@@Martinschniderr 🤖 me or you? Your you are just blinded by your pride that’s why you can’t accept the facts. 😂😁🤭
@@iBored123yeah i accept the fact hamas is terrorist,islam is the worst religion in rhis world,all muslim are the bad guy ,bla bla bla bla bla bla bla😂😂😂
Agreed with her 💯..
@user-jv3xg7mb2yenglish is not her first language. Thats all.
@user-jv3xg7mb2yautism vs god chosen people,which one better
Because you’re a Hamas fighter?
@@erikthered1719 use your brain,you claim hamas doesn't care about gaza,some of you saying free gaza from hamas,so why not israel care about gazans ,why airstrike hospital,camp refugee, church and school and over 10000 gazan died
@@erikthered1719you know you lost the argument when you start calling people Hamas 😂 go suck on Nuttyahoos nutz already 😂
Свободу Палестине
From who?
@@Likadees
From the Zionists occupation
@@Likadeesfrom Israel who r occupying since 1947
@@LikadeesIsrael.
Since the 1948 Nakba, since Britain handed over the partitioned land to a newly formed state in which the majority of the people who lived there were deprived of the right to vote, since historic Palestine was annexed.
@@Pyromantic_KingBritain, an illegal occupier, could not give away land which did not belong to it.
Exactly 💯 but they don't get it
Mrs Francesca Albanese, peace be upon you
This Italian lady said it perfectly!
No, she is stupid
Could she stop the UmmmEmmmm....it's hard selling a lie
@@diannepotoczny9571 She is Italian. This is a typical way of how Italians speak. She is not lying. You are just in denial.
@@zaidal-hindawi1784the fact that someone commented to you claiming she is lying.. what benefit is there to lying about your land being stolen 😂😂unless you were coming back years later to secretly claim it like Hitler claimed Germany. Supporters of Israel just never make any sense like their whole argument is everything she said was a lie because she paused for 3 seconds 😂 she is most likely bi lingual too and I bet money the person who tagged you.l can barely speak one 😂☝️
Again don't forget thats how isis began,..... Enforcing sharia law... I hope it will still be the truth to you under international law.
Salute to this lady.
Calling israeI an evil is an insult to the word of Evil 👹👿
She is correct , but Israel , the US , the EU doesn’t care about her explanation .
Basically the rules are what the occupiers say it is.
That’s the sad part
It's like if someone raped her without an italian ID she would say that he shouldn't be punished, because only Italian citizens can be punished in Italia.
Euro has be neutral. Look at the UN votes.. only 12 countries in the world was for Israel’s bullshit
They believe her and many others. Admitting the truth publicly will make them look weak and embarrass.
Well educated and genuine
How here all basis is wrong
Yes,,, isn't she... She for the stupidity class of people
Finally! Someone speaking the human language!❤
Saya setuju pendapat anda. Agree
The human language with an Italian accent, which is even better ;)
If ignorance is the human language
Yes, it's designed for people like you... Thats you way of thinking
lies ?nice language u understand? Israel left Gaza in 2006 it’s occupied by Hamas.
Finally Italians can be proud of their country!
@@7truthseeker7 Italians are and have been proud of who they are throughout their glorious history
Italians have been second to no one forever and Mis Albanese proves it once again
Great lady
Well said.
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@iBored123ok bot
@@Ali-no1hf 🤡 clown
@@iBored123So, because Hamas say they represent Palestinians they are in fact the Palestinian representation? Don't you know the West Bank is also part of Palestine and is ruled by the Palestinian Authority (different from Hamas)? Gaza is not a state, it's a territory and under International Law, a STATE has to attack another so the latter can claim self-defence. Anyway, those technicalities are not what really matters in her argument. What's relevant is the fact that Israel has been occupying Gaza since 2007 by doing a blockade that has kept the territory in inhumane conditions. Hamas attacks are a response to that occupation and under International Law, Israel cannot claim self-defence in that case. It makes all sense. Let me give you an example: In the XIXth century, Spain was the colonizer of the now Latin American countries. The indigenous people of those territories attacked Spain to become independent. If the UN existed by that time, could have Spain claimed self-defence?
Alhamdulillah. Slow but steady, Palestine won the International Publics. Palestine Suffering is not in VAIN!!!
Malaka Palestine won nothing, arab nations still treat palestinians as animals
Yes it is 😂😂
But no actual help
The gift would present it self. For those who have patience within themself.
@@TheAlchemist1089 and Israel not helping with the public unrest that's happening in Every states of America, London and so on and so forth.
Wow!! Very impressive explanation by the UN Rapporteur. Congratulations!!!
🎉❤❤❤🎉
She is so correct...!
No, she is not.
Wars have consequences, islamona.z.i
No
Wait what? Who is this? He is contradicting her definition. 😂😂😂 I am ashamed of this so called experts when they themselves do not know what they are talking. Didn’t she know that Hamas claimed that they represent Palestinians??? Have she watched Hamas and so called experts Palestinians. Al Jazeera, please hire a more knowledgeable speaker for your Paid truth please. The last time I saw your engineer in fact check who actually draw the building, 😴🤣 😅 I can not believe that he is engineer of the Shifa hospital because his drawing is not a work of engineer. 😢 A kinder garden can draw the diagram he presented.😂😂😂😂
@@vadimshulman1199this isnt war. This is a genocide of Palestinians, im the largest concentration camp, by the zionists colonizers
@@iBored123
And many don't even recognize Palestine as a state and it is being forcefully occupied by Israel. So she's not wrong.
These are essentially the same role the French resistance played in world war 2, with similar brutality from Israel's part might I add.
This is what is called an asymmetric conflict: one side is expected to conduct in accordance with all international laws and procedures, and another side can perform whatever crimes against humanity in accordance with it’s own rules… It’s like to play cards with a bunch of cardsharpers.
So basically the US in every war they’ve been in since Vietnam
@@a.n.n8282GOT HIM
This woman needs to be fired!!!She is working for the terrorists ,apologizing for the terrorist acts of hamas!!!
I don't even know which side you're referring to. Because idiocy is rampant around here and people actually think Hamas is "in accordance" with international laws by mutilating kids, raping innocent women and baking toddlers.
It's strange.
@@lisatarr3078😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Finally, someone who understands international law!
Lololololololol😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Lol! HAHA!
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂.. she is dumb as fckk 😂😂😂.. she literally says there is no state of Palestine 😂😂😂.. since it's ISRAELs internal matter, no one can intervene 😂😂
Are you being funny? She unironically stated you don't have the right of self defense if you are attacked by anything other than another state.
That statement alone completely nukes any credibility she has to speak on the subject given she made such a dumb statement given there is no ruling, statute or treaty that specifies that an act of self defense only applies if committed by another state.
Palestine is freeing us:
From propaganda
From ignorance
From blind consumerism
From conformity
From cowardice
From the facade of safety
From shame
From individualism
From fear
Freedom for Palestine
Respect. The UN has many of humanity's finest.
And many more of our worst.
Like the child trafficers and groomers in Africa , right? Lol when someone still believes a word this organization says, well...
She described it the way it should in the first place
How tragic that the logic expressed by this woman is so beyond both the intelligence and honesty of our government (u.s.).
Oh, I think our government understands it perfectly. They just think that the backing of the almighty USA washes every crime away.
Agree
EEUU nunca ha Sido honesto, pero si ha sabido hacer terrorismo por todo el mundo .
Except it’s the law she posted it on her X account for the people having trouble. It also dated back to the 2000s Israel knows it that’s why it’s so important everyone acknowledge their right to defend themselves because the government knows the laws.
& by government I mean Netanyahu etc
She’s a hero to Palestinian people. She speaks up for the truth.
It's sad on both sides but you can't lob rockets and expect no retaliation this is insanity
Question: who are you referring to? Because every year Isreal bombs Gaza... in case you didn't already know
you can't expect occupation and oppression to be met with silence either.
@@ambulancekun3142 You can't expect threats of massacre and constant attacks to be met with anything less than pacification and occupation.
@@Stavroforoi_Kata_Islam OK bro and the journalist that got shot in the head(they said not us then ok😊 it's us) , also the little Palestinian that got killed for no reason before the 7 October and others before thats ok for you? Like you accept the atrocious stuff from one side ig
@@Stavroforoi_Kata_Islam which constant attacks? Every year Isreal bombs Gaza... plus there was no Hamas prior to 06 n this occupation n oppression has been going on for way longer than 17 years
Where is the demand for Hamas to surrender and return the hostages?
Where is the demand for Israel to surrender and leave Palestine?
Stupid boy
@@AshrafAnam Israel left Palestine in 2005. Back to the real question: Where is the demand for Hamas to surrender and return the hostages? Answer that instead of making up another "question"?
@AshrafAnam only a pro palestnian wants war but cry when it happens
When are you going to understand that Israel don't care about the hostages. The proof is there that they killed their own people at the festival. This is from their own investigations. If they really cared about about their people they would have used their top of the world military intelligence & do ground work to get to the hostages without flattening a whole population. Their actions are so clear but you are so blind.
If they claim "we have the right to defend ourselves" why it took them 6 hours to come to the Kibbutz, to protect their people on October 7?
It makes sense, and whoever enforces the law should be held accountable
We don’t have an enforcement body for international law.
A colonizer can't claim to defend himself from people of a land he's illegaly stealing lands from.
If anything, Palestinians have the legal right to defend themsleves against the military attack being conducted against their population
If they had the weaponry or military to do this. That is why Hamas was developed. They are extremely mad Palestinians.
😂
Jewish people have been there for at least 2300 years when Arabs were still in Arabia. Read a book?
@@rbcreations2They are extremely dangerous Jihadists, actually. You're clearly misinformed about what that group represents. They are a terror to their own people as well. A death cult.
And what gives them the legal right? If you follow this lady's line of argument Gaza is not a legal entity, not a state. Hamas is a militant group, not a national army.
Gaza is 'occupied' territory (occupied by whom?). Technically, if you follow this lady's argument, Hamas is a gang of thugs fighting for control over turf and wanting to expand that turf.
So, with no legal status any and all acts of violence, physical or otherwise, are criminal acts, making Hamas a crime syndicate with the crime boss tucked away safely and lavishly in Doha Qatar.
And a very well funded one at that, because the UN has a commission supplying aid and funds just for them.
Finally,....someone with the correct wording!
The Meaning of Words and the Word of Truth of a Woman of Honor
Absolutely the Palestinians have right to opposed the occupation.. The Apartheid state.
They have not been occupied since 2005. You have Palestinians fleeing the country because of hamas. One is either a part of hamas…or you have nothing.
@@CoolTaxiDriverLook West Bank. there so no Hamas there still many Palestinians kids got killed by Israel.
@@CoolTaxiDriverpleeeeessss
@@barakasher45 yet their situation is much much better than gaza citizens even when being under military law. This just proves these people can't govern themselves, the moment israel pulls out of the west bank there would be a rain of rockets in tell aviv. Oh and there's no big wall there(unlike gaza) and it cant even be built due to the geography so the moment a terror organization rises to power(a thing that happened in literally EVERY muslim country) that would be much much worse than the hamas attacks
@maxamedm3040
What is it with you commenters with your BLIND LOVE of the word "apartheid".
Whatever the Israeli situation has in common with 1980s South Africa, that word does not signicantly apply to how
Arab citizens are "treated" in Israel.
Israel is so wrong about this. They also brought this upon themselves.
Brought what? Last time I checked Hamas brought this upon themselves and Gaza
Brought this upon themselves by being diplomatic when offering peace solutions on several different occasions, only to be met with hostile rejections in the form of attacks. 🤷🏿♂️
@@Mmmmmmm232they never. It was always Israel bombing and settling on somebody's home and claiming to be peaceful. Israel is already in no position to speak 🤡your lies doesn't work anymore
@@ThePowerOfTheDwhat peace occasion? Israel and peace after stealing somebody's Home WOW 😳
@lukeleney5917
Where to begin,
First and foremost, Israel didn't take land from Palestinians.
Secondly, please establish when they did take land from Palestinians that wasn't diplomatically acquired as a result of Palestines actions.
Thirdly, Israel offered peace negotiations on several occasions, and we're met with hostile rejections via attacks. The first attack immediately after Israel's statehood was ratified; Amazingly Israel still sought out diplomacy vs war.
It was not until 1967 did Israel start to remove a persistent threat from the West Bank after 20 years of persistent attacks by the PLO, so please regale us with your extensive knowledge of how Israel supposedly "stole land" from Palestinians.
Well said. Facts matter….
An armed group in an occupied territory is a liberation movement. For example, the ANC is apartheid South Africa. They were labelled terrorists but in fact they were a liberation movement.
Even if this woman was right it means every police force and military called out to defend and fight a domestic terror attack would be unjustified. Ridiculous.
Every police force and military that has kept occupied other people's land by force, not a domestic terror attack.
She’s referring to international law under the Geneva convention. Which does not apply to local police forces 🤦🏽♂️
@@eggggg3577Their has never not been Jews in Palestine and Palestine has never been a country, it’s always been someone else’s land. Yet since 1948 they could have a nation if only they would negotiate a settlement in good faith. Oct7th was a terror attack of the most gruesome kind.
Article 42 of the convention says otherwise, though...@@farishabib9177
You need to learn to listen to what she is saying. She is talking about international UN law which Israel agreed to abide by and is breaking!
Times of Israel: Former Israeli Prime Minister Yair Lapid says "If the international media is objective and shows both sides, it serves Hamas," Lapid said on Sunday. "My argument is that the media cannot just claim to bring both sides of the story. If you do that, you are only bringing one - Hamas's side,"
No coverage so no war crimes
Who is this lady? We need to hear more from her, and even more, from more like her🇵🇸👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Francesca Albanese, relator of the UN 🇺🇳 she‘s italian
Only when media manipulation, stops to be the only source of information, disseminated by the occupiers, to coverup the reality of the violations committed by them, their supporters and suppliers, for more than 75 years, is when the real suffering of the Palestinians, has come to light, for it can no longer be denied, because the eyes of millions of humans was kept blindfolded by the murderous forces of immorality but now, those are no longer victims of misinformation for the genocide is been committed in front of their faces.
Salute to you sister. A brave soul.
The right of self defence should be invoked whenever a State is threatened whether from another state or even its citizens. A state must always protect its citizens even if a threat is from within.
So the zionist IDF protected their citizens by shooting at them from an appatchi helicopter so their bodies were burned? and Palestinians are not citizens of the zionist movements of Israel until Zionism keeps lying to the world, your comical propaganda is failing the good Jewish people out there? 2 equal states its the only way for Israel to live in peace anything less than that, Israel will never live in peace, you can kill as many innocent babies, but you can not kill an ideology wake up and smell the coffee mate?
True
1) apartheid Israel does not consider Palestinian in the occupied territories citizens
2) “from within” would require Israel to annex Gaza, West Bank and Gollan and they won’t as that would mean citizenship for people in those occupied territories
Now ask me why Israel do not want to give them citizenship ?
@@hatemallebdiAs Israel didn’t rule Gaza since 2005, Israel can’t act there as an apartheid state. Just use your brain if you have one…😉
@@cristalp00 Israel can be apartheid in one part “West Bank for example and a belligerent occupier “Israel Supreme Court definition” in another like Gaza
And before you say they are not occupying Gaza. They control land borders, sea shores and air space. The y also control who and what goes in and out of Gaza. That is occupation with out the hassle and dangers of boot on the ground
PS Insults are the arguments employed by those who are in the wrong
What an absolutely insane take…
I like how you didn’t offer up any rebuttal to her point. You’re the one who is denying the reality of the apartheid state Israel clearly is.
It's international law. Not a take
@@DerrickCNdu yea. Go look up international law and explain to me how Israel are breaking any of them…does Hamas have to follow international too or do you only apply the law when you want to apply it?
@johnkroeger9352 if a country doesn't exist it doesn't have to follow any rules, didn't you know that?
@owenmyhra8723 That is not CLEAR at all, and you know it.
Where would we be without such courageous women
wonderful lady speaking the truth.
Thank you for providing the accurate definition. These liars think the truth is to be transformed for their hateful purposes.
Not occupied since 2005
Bulshit definition…you are the hateful liar 🤥
If israel didn't have the iron dome, they'd have civilian casualties too and she wouldn't have said a word
Civilian that come knowingly to land that is not theirs, house that are not theirs.
Frankly, the status of occupying settlers is less than standard civilian.
So you saying that killing innocent civilians is OK. That it is fine that Israel killed the people at the festival (their own investigations proof it) then use that to justify the genocide they are doing now. Everything they claimed happened to justify their attacks couldn't be backed up with proof/facts. Bombing of hospitals, letting prem babies die for what... Their own actions. Their actions are clear but you are blind.
Haha, have you ever asked yourself why other countries don't have Iron dome? How come Iran doesn't attack neighboring countries? How come Spain doesn't bomb Portugal? I wonder why Israel has to protect itself from Palestine? Jeez, what did they do? 😂
@@ahmadashraf9448by your logic then Pakistan needs to be given back to India since they displaced Hindus that live there before giving it to Arabs.
How DO YOU KNOW she wouldn't 🤔🤔🤔
What I've known & been saying all along. What it really is. It is PLAIN to see!
I'm thankful she said this. I bet the Israelis are calling her an antisemite.
@eralylii
Well yeah and what do you REALLY think, Champ?
@@nickgoldring1446 I think the Israeli gov lies, obfuscates and fabricates evidence. I think most civilians are on board with this, since it facilitates the mass killing of Palestinians, and this is not just post Oct 7th, it has happened for a century. I think they way Israelis are behaving, it's monstrous. They were victims of the Holocaust themselves, after only 3 years they went on to do the Nakba, and are doing a New Nakba right now as we write.
Now tell me what YOU really think, Sport.
It’s crazy how so many people can be so misinformed. Crazy
It's crazy to listen and believe what Qatar's main propaganda channel says!
@@bananenbrot-pt7moisn't Qatar the home of hamas leaders?
@@morchard85 Yes I believe.
@@bananenbrot-pt7moIsrael killing 12800 civilians(5800 of which are children)is just propaganda? yeah sure,then the Holocaust too was just propaganda by that logic🤡
The Palestinians have had a state brokered for them twice - once under Arafat of the PLO. And Abbas of Hamas. Both vetoed the idea because they did not want to lose the power and money involved. No sympathy for them.😊
Who is this well spoken woman? 🤝🏽
Francesca Albanese, look her up
the situation is literally the same thing with what happened between early usa(in 19th century) and indians
Well well well said beloved sister ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ 🇵🇸❤🇵🇸❤🇵🇸❤🇵🇸❤
Lady, you are very educated but am surprised that you still not aware that Israel left Gaza since 2005, which occupation are you talking about??!!
Actually, if you say that Israel is still occupying Gaza, that even gives Israel much authority to enter and clean up the mess...
What should Israel do when they are attacked by the same group you are talking about??
What do you suggest to Israel as a nation, they should fold their arms??
You speak comfortably because you are living in peace, ...
Which country are you from? Probably very far from a terrorist organization, and you have never experienced any kind of terrorism so keep quiet and let the country that is feeling the pain to deal with it...
This courageous lady says you don't have a right to self defence if a terror group attacks you.
She's not courageous and not a lady just another western simple idiot. Hamas watches these useless idiots in the west and loughing their heads off.
No u don’t have a “right to self defense” in a land you are occupying. Idk how that went over ur head sheesh.
@@xillaTV 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 what would Israel do without permission from fools like you?
@@xillaTVis literally israels land. the jews were there before islam was even there. israel agreed to a 2 state solution, and the palestinians refused. they then elected hamas and declared war on israel. you don't get to complain about being oppressed when you get smacked by the people you tried to genocide.
@DCmac Stop spreading nonsense propaganda..You really are brainwashed to believe that..
Now that there is the before and after the genocide on Gaza in every aspect of life. the genocide on Gaza revealed the truth about everything and everyone even the truth about the people I considered my role models and heroes before the genocide on Gaza. As a human beings I can’t have genocide enablers as role models… Francesca Albanese is my new role model along with Naledi Pandor. My utmost respect and admiration for both of them🫡🫡you are my superwoman. Keep standing up for humanity!
Alhamdulillah sister, my Allah subhanwatala guide you to his religion Islam.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ❤
Yes king
Free Palestine from Hamas
Nuke Palestine !
Oh look, you're the 20,000,000,000th person to say "Free Palestine." I guess Israel just has to give up the war Hamas started and let themselves be genocided because you said so