@Lyrictheac In Victorian England, it was expected that men would show no emotion and that women would do all that on their behalf. So not only is this more accurate than the Rathbone tellings, it is also a masterful depiction of Victorian ideals. As such, I'd say ACD would have approved of this as a way to explain his world to late 20th, early 21st century people with no direct experience of Victorianisms even if he'd have rejected it as a drama for Victorians.
@Songsmirth The plan's useless without final instructions. Without the governess, there's no spy in the camp to send information. She's not terribly bright, but it would seem that she's trying to goad her enemies into a frontal assault that might see them killed. Garcia's duelling pistols indicate he's a confident shot and he'd have the advantage of a building that offers protection of sorts. With no time to think of options, I can understand her taking that kind of a gamble.
I wonder what kind of drug that they might've given to the poor woman that she forgotten who she is? I've seen a couple of times how the Victorian era drugged people that make the person forget who they are and their identity but not kill the person.
You could say that but on a very real scale evil has no diminsions or no levels evil is the same in small doses and large in passing thoughts and planned ones no I believe that once evil subdues the soul the outcome is the same though and though
Thank you very much for uploading! :-) I enjoyed every episode but this one. I must say I never read the books. But is it only me, or was the director trying to put some "artistic elements" into it? If so.... It didn't work for me. It just distracted me from the storyline.
I must say that the so called Spanish actors have the worst Spanish accents I cant even understand them. Their Spanish is pretty terrible. But I still love the episode!
that little look jeremy gives at 1:32 is awesome. jeremy always cheers me up so much. thank you anish79!!!!!
"You'll rise high in your profession... except your are so old, that you won't be around much longer anyway"
They made good movies year's ago I wish they would make them now days.
@Lyrictheac In Victorian England, it was expected that men would show no emotion and that women would do all that on their behalf. So not only is this more accurate than the Rathbone tellings, it is also a masterful depiction of Victorian ideals. As such, I'd say ACD would have approved of this as a way to explain his world to late 20th, early 21st century people with no direct experience of Victorianisms even if he'd have rejected it as a drama for Victorians.
great episode keep them coming please
Arrgh poor woman in the book they "just" twisted her arm to get info :|
Miss Burnet (Durando) handled the little bit part admirably.. quite in line with the book.
@Songsmirth The plan's useless without final instructions. Without the governess, there's no spy in the camp to send information. She's not terribly bright, but it would seem that she's trying to goad her enemies into a frontal assault that might see them killed. Garcia's duelling pistols indicate he's a confident shot and he'd have the advantage of a building that offers protection of sorts. With no time to think of options, I can understand her taking that kind of a gamble.
I wonder what kind of drug that they might've given to the poor woman that she forgotten who she is? I've seen a couple of times how the Victorian era drugged people that make the person forget who they are and their identity but not kill the person.
@notAbba Perhaps. But at least it's more accurate than the videos with Basil Rathbone. :P
i AGREE He has too many manners
You could say that but on a very real scale evil has no diminsions or no levels evil is the same in small doses and large in passing thoughts and planned ones no I believe that once evil subdues the soul the outcome is the same though and though
i wonder if you anish has 79 has study in scarlet complete
Thank you very much for uploading! :-) I enjoyed every episode but this one. I must say I never read the books. But is it only me, or was the director trying to put some "artistic elements" into it? If so.... It didn't work for me. It just distracted me from the storyline.
I Agree. That theme music every time the governess appears in a window...So clunky and distracting. This and other bits...did not work.
Isn't Jeremy posing just a little too much? This isn't a ballet.
@2206411411 Indeed!
I must say that the so called Spanish actors have the worst Spanish accents I cant even understand them. Their Spanish is pretty terrible. But I still love the episode!
I think I could act better than that woman.
Very trashy directing aimed at emotion; this is hardly like ACD would have approved.