I cried the moment I saw her perform this song live at HP Pavillion in San Jose in 2009 because it was the most beautiful song I have ever heard in a concert hall in my life.
while other singers practically swallow the mic look at the distance she's holding it, you can tell those are power vocals, if you've ever used a mic you know that. Amazing!!
@@kezoorfilipe1847 im pretty sure the Memphis and Trisha Lee are live too..kook at hownher throat and neck are.moving..like she's putting in effort..and the other one I KNOW is live is at all the way 1999 concert..check that one out and tell me if you agree..
@@leif1075 sorry but i have to disagree.Memphis,The one with Trisha Lee,All The Way Special and Paris 1999 are all lipped.Listen Carefuly and you will notice that they sound the same!
One of the few proper live performances for this song. Most of the audio is taken (for the lipped ones) from Celine in Memphis. As my fave song even of other singers, I love this...so authentic.
Are youbsure..Inthink Memphis is love because there is a 96 performance that sounds similar to Memphis so how could Memphis be lipped..and Memphis and 99 rationality sounds live too..and WHYBWHY can't sje sing it LIVE IN SAME KEYMMWhy doesnshebjave to drop tone so much..this doesn't sound hard to sing for her I don't think..
@@p.m.6064 isn't live In Memphis live..and couldn't she sing this at the right key if she sings other songs that are higher and as hard like All By myself?
i'm listening to both versions. definitely sounds lower to me. celine's first note in the studio version is an E, and in this performance it's an E-flat.
Buy Bionic I am pretty positive that this song is one of her hardest to sing, right up there with Fade Away and Breakaway. The reason for these three being the hardest is because they are consistently high and never really get low except for at the beginning. That constant highness is harder than a single big note like in All By Myself since the rest of the song is doable under normal conditions. I think Breakaway is probably her hardest, and I've seen other people say the same. I've never sang that song without giving up before I get to the end because it's just so tiresome.
+razrv3lc I agree with your reasoning although I feel like Breakaway is probably lower in the list (on par with Le blues du businessman maybe) with constant high notes that nevertheless seem to be still in her comfort zone. I feel like I Surrender is harder and more tiring to sing.
No way. Did you even watch her performance in Live in Memphis and her performance for the King and Queen of Brunei?? They're all live and in the original key. Performing in an award show is different that' s why you become more careful cause it will make or break you especially she is a hot artist during this time in the 90's she has always been a careful artist back then. But yes she performed this Live a lot of times in her falling into you tour LIVe in the original key mind you.
This was actually Junos 1995 or 1996 in Hamilton Ontario as I was there and saw her backstage as she was talking to Shania Twain with Rene by her side.
We have a reason..it's called proof lol. But I still love her no matter what. I'm glad she saved her voice..yea sometimes it's sad and I wish she would sing live, but she does it for a reason. If she didn't work on saving her voice throughout the years, she would sound ratchet now. She still sounds amazing to this day because of it, unlike a few others..lol!
As Irene Laca (mother's maiden name) and Irene Spitzer (sugar daddy's last name) as well and although there are others out there who may want to claim and steal my identity, demeanor, I am the only one, a biologist, pharmacologist, and mathematician with very starkly different views from the mainstream. At age 49, I am searching for a spouse to love and share the rest of my life.
Ferdinand Kertz 내 댓글 읽을 수 있으면 읽어봐요.번역 돌리면 나오겠죠.세계최고의 가수는 캐나다에 셀린 디온,한국에는 이선희. Best of the world in Canada~Celline Dion,in Korea~Sunhee Lee. Best councert,Celine Dion. i'll be waiting for councert in Korea(south). i'd love to meet her,Celind Dion.Please get here,South Korea,Dion
@Yangedd1 @Markus Link obviously it's live duh! Are you guys tone deaf? Try checking other vids of this song like in Memphis and Tokyo and its also live as well as her earlier concerts. She's obviously a great performer still active and maintained her voice compare to her counterparts, that's why people kept on accusing her for lipping.
This song is ridiculously hard. The stamina needed to do it in the original key would be more than most people have. She probably had to do it more than a handful of times to get it right in the studio.
No way. Did you even watch her performance in Live in Memphis and her performance for the King and Queen of Brunei?? They're all live and in the original key. Performing in an award show is different that' s why you become more careful cause it will make or break you especially she is a hot artist during this time in the 90's she has always been a careful artist back then. But yes she performed this Live a lot of times in her falling into you tour LIVe in the original key mind you.
That's all everyone ever cares about. Lipping, lipping, lipping. HEY GUESS WHAT WITHOUT LIPPING THERE WOULD BE NO VOICE. Its as if some of you want her to loose her voice. Dont have a heart attack just because she lips its not a BIG deal. Celine has some of the MOST GREEDY fans I have ever seen. She gives up half her life to her fans and all you can do is debate for hours on whether or not she is lipping. Either way she took time out of HER life to sing and or record the song. She sang it. What more do you want. You say " we like the flaws so she shouldn't lip" then you say " omg she cracked she can't sing anymore". Please get over yourselves and just ENJOY THE MUSIC. She's already proved she can sing. Enjoy the music or be gone.
You don't know how much I like you right now. Even though this is not lipped, yes, there are people on here that post nothing but "Lipped", "Not Lipped". Some call themselves her biggest fans and yet will post "Lipped" on her videos. It's like they are trying to call her out. Who cares? They all lip...it's voice saving techniques. We heard how 200 shows a year for 5 years in Las Vegas killed her voice the first time...Taking Chances tour she sounded bad, but she was able to regain her voice and is now in Las Vegas singing better than ever, not to mention the awesome album "Loved Me Back To Life!" She's almost 46 years old and still sounds just as good, or better, as she did in this performance 16 years ago. She KNOWS what she is doing. If you really love Celine, enjoy her music and let her do what she is doing to keep her voice decent so we can continue to enjoy her music for another 20 years!
Think she is cheating.. lol.. she is soo good on so many levels.. did you all see what happen towards the end??? She couldnt do the vocalise all the way as she was out if breath. But look at what she did with it!! Gosh she is good; she must be cheating☺
Shivers down spine every time, I was lucky enough to see her in Vegas 2015 and she is simply the best live
I made my bigest dream come true In 2019 in Vegas too. I'm so thankfull for that! I did it the second time seeing her here in Columbus, Ohio. ❤🙏
Celine Dion is one of the few singers that can sing live and sound amazing
Her improvisation of the ending and holding that note, incredible!
I remember this performance. It was the highlight of the show.
I was there, it was amazing!! Love Celine
Lucky You! Was it in Hamilton?
this is by far my favorite celine dion song! amazing!
The one and only Celine Dion
the long note of the last part is definitely hard to maintain over and over again and celine made a wise choice👍🏼
I will see her perform live one day! She is just amazing!
I hope I will too someday...
I love how she ends the song here!!
I'd like to note the violinist, Taro Hakase, from Japan, did the recording of the violin on this music! Thanks to him as well.
Love this piece. The violin intro alone gets me hooked every time!
I cried the moment I saw her perform this song live at HP Pavillion in San Jose in 2009 because it was the most beautiful song I have ever heard in a concert hall in my life.
you can see how humble she is. even after that big note, she still gave Taro the spotlight. true class
Splendid...The Violinist..am weak.
while other singers practically swallow the mic look at the distance she's holding it, you can tell those are power vocals, if you've ever used a mic you know that. Amazing!!
She is literally the Mount Rushmore of vocalists 💯💯🌹🌹...and there's PLENTY of examples everywhere😎😎😎😎😎❤❤❤❤❤
I like that !
@@manolo1918🎉🎉❤
perfect and beautiful !!!!
There will never be no one like her . Wow
no it is not lipped, She's singing on direct 100% live. :D celine is amazing!!!!
Isnt the performance with Trisha Lee also live? And the live in memphis one too i think ?
@@leif1075 no! Same Pre-recorded track from 1996-2009.
This one and Rosie O'donnel are the only live performances of this song!
@@kezoorfilipe1847 im pretty sure the Memphis and Trisha Lee are live too..kook at hownher throat and neck are.moving..like she's putting in effort..and the other one I KNOW is live is at all the way 1999 concert..check that one out and tell me if you agree..
@@leif1075 sorry but i have to disagree.Memphis,The one with Trisha Lee,All The Way Special and Paris 1999 are all lipped.Listen Carefuly and you will notice that they sound the same!
@@leif1075 the whole thing was lipped on FIY and LTAL tour. Notice she dropped the song from the fully live Brunei 1997 show.
She is unbelievable.
Stunning!
Celine at her peak!
These were the years that she didn't need to lipsync as her vocals were still at its best.
so, so, good. and so cute at the end with her little head to the side gesture. she's a gracious woman.
a rock version with prominent drumming and guitars, perfect
I’ve always loved this song! She was ALIVE!!
Wat een geweldige zangeres, maar ook een geweldig mens. ❤️
That come back at the end though during the whoooas
I love this song, i give this to the real owner of my heart!!!
Celine is perfect in this show
5:11 Rene's so proud of her!
She is amazing, and this song is amazing
Amazing !!!! Bravo !!!! My Ideal Celine Dion
The beeeeeeest!!!!!!!!
Graet Song Amazing Voice... Still loving it CD X EVER 🇨🇷✌️🥰🤩😻
The best ❤
i love how she was struggeling a bit in the end... shows she is only human :-)
Este cea mai tare cîntăreață din lume si cea mai iubita romania
Wow⭐⭐❤ I LOVE Celine
priceless music.
My idol Singer me celine dion 😊and vaforite song ☺️love u celine 😘😚☺️😊
L.I.V.E
This is the queen beautiful celine 😍 ❤️ 💕 💖 💗
Hermosa canción, una gran cantante, espero que algún día visite Chile!
Taro and Celine! and it's live❤❤❤
すごいー。。。唄になのか、バイオリンになのか涙がじわ～っと出る
The finish, WoW!
One of the few proper live performances for this song. Most of the audio is taken (for the lipped ones) from Celine in Memphis. As my fave song even of other singers, I love this...so authentic.
That’s why she dropped it a semi tone. The original is so hard to sing. I can understand why she always lip synches this song.
Are youbsure..Inthink Memphis is love because there is a 96 performance that sounds similar to Memphis so how could Memphis be lipped..and Memphis and 99 rationality sounds live too..and WHYBWHY can't sje sing it LIVE IN SAME KEYMMWhy doesnshebjave to drop tone so much..this doesn't sound hard to sing for her I don't think..
@@p.m.6064 isn't live In Memphis live..and couldn't she sing this at the right key if she sings other songs that are higher and as hard like All By myself?
one and only.
Briliant!
i'm listening to both versions. definitely sounds lower to me. celine's first note in the studio version is an E, and in this performance it's an E-flat.
This one was sung in a lower key but it’s 100% live !
This and Rosie are the only live performances
Buy Bionic I am pretty positive that this song is one of her hardest to sing, right up there with Fade Away and Breakaway. The reason for these three being the hardest is because they are consistently high and never really get low except for at the beginning. That constant highness is harder than a single big note like in All By Myself since the rest of the song is doable under normal conditions. I think Breakaway is probably her hardest, and I've seen other people say the same. I've never sang that song without giving up before I get to the end because it's just so tiresome.
+razrv3lc I agree with your reasoning although I feel like Breakaway is probably lower in the list (on par with Le blues du businessman maybe) with constant high notes that nevertheless seem to be still in her comfort zone. I feel like I Surrender is harder and more tiring to sing.
+shado474 I Surrender is more consistent to sing and vocally affordable than TLYM
No way. Did you even watch her performance in Live in Memphis and her performance for the King and Queen of Brunei?? They're all live and in the original key. Performing in an award show is different that'
s why you become more careful cause it will make or break you especially she is a hot artist during this time in the 90's she has always been a careful artist back then. But yes she performed this Live a lot of times in her falling into you tour LIVe in the original key mind you.
I think it would be pretty difficult to sync the violin sound perfectly with the violinist's wild movements as well as her voice
The greatest of the greatest.
one of kind.
violinist went ham!
Come to south Africa Celine dion plz i will offer you a place to stay u will not pay a cent because u are my hero in music.
Perfection
Wonderfull Song.I love it.... :)
Te amo Celin Dion ❤
Céline linda musica amo to love more taro rakse um violinista consagrado juntos e lindo de mais amo todas essas musicas internacional românticas
THIS VERSION IS 100% LIVE, PEOPLE!!!
priceless celine rene love.
i love you Celine
I saw this TV program in the suburbs of Toronto in 1997.
Please sing like this with breakaway, coulda woulda shoulda, and one heart T-T
live in memohis, he one for the king and queen of malaysia and brunie there are a lot
her rehearsal at las vegas
nobody can do same as the same perfect you does.
Amor da minha vida 😍❤️
Incrível como ela canta bem! 😍
とにかく最高ですね。
This was actually Junos 1995 or 1996 in Hamilton Ontario as I was there and saw her backstage as she was talking to Shania Twain with Rene by her side.
It was 1997
Her voice sounds a bit tired here.. she lowered the notes a bit.. which is fine better than lipping
We have a reason..it's called proof lol. But I still love her no matter what. I'm glad she saved her voice..yea sometimes it's sad and I wish she would sing live, but she does it for a reason. If she didn't work on saving her voice throughout the years, she would sound ratchet now. She still sounds amazing to this day because of it, unlike a few others..lol!
❤️
shes not lipping it.
January 2021 and forever
As Irene Laca (mother's maiden name) and Irene Spitzer (sugar daddy's last name) as well and although there are others out there who may want to claim and steal my identity, demeanor, I am the only one, a biologist, pharmacologist, and mathematician with very starkly different views from the mainstream. At age 49, I am searching for a spouse to love and share the rest of my life.
perfect and beautiful with Taro Hakase...The best Song in the World...
Ferdinand Kertz 내 댓글 읽을 수 있으면 읽어봐요.번역 돌리면 나오겠죠.세계최고의 가수는 캐나다에 셀린 디온,한국에는 이선희.
Best of the world in Canada~Celline Dion,in Korea~Sunhee Lee.
Best councert,Celine Dion.
i'll be waiting for councert in Korea(south).
i'd love to meet her,Celind Dion.Please get here,South Korea,Dion
최고의 가수^^
she is not lip singing. If she is give her the award for best lip singer of all time.
She was not!
Leyenda...pfff...los 80´s y 90´s no hubieran sido los mismos.
@Yangedd1 @Markus Link obviously it's live duh! Are you guys tone deaf? Try checking other vids of this song like in Memphis and Tokyo and its also live as well as her earlier concerts. She's obviously a great performer still active and maintained her voice compare to her counterparts, that's why people kept on accusing her for lipping.
2018😍
is it just me?!? it seems that celine is singing hear in lower key but still amazing 😄😄😄
*sorry for my english
I think she is. This is the first version I found without playback. Maybe she can't really perform this song live in the original key.
oh I see thanks~ ^.^
This song is ridiculously hard. The stamina needed to do it in the original key would be more than most people have. She probably had to do it more than a handful of times to get it right in the studio.
I think it is one of her toughest song ever, and I dont think people realize that this is one of her toughest.
No way. Did you even watch her performance in Live in Memphis and her performance for the King and Queen of Brunei?? They're all live and in the original key. Performing in an award show is different that'
s why you become more careful cause it will make or break you especially she is a hot artist during this time in the 90's she has always been a careful artist back then. But yes she performed this Live a lot of times in her falling into you tour LIVe in the original key mind you.
저 일본 바이올리니스트..ㅋㅋ.바이올린 연주가 신나긴 첨이네.허허~ㅋㅋ.노래도 좋고..역시..국내가수는 이선희를 제일로 꼽고,해외가수는 셀린 디온을 꼽는다.여기..나 말고 한글 쓰는 사람 안 나타나나? 나 한국사람이다.
Yes it was in Hamilton
celine rene love.
Join to CelineDionGreece in facebook!
😘😍😍
To how many keys did they lower this?
Vince Broma half step down.
1 guy disliking this video may be fucking jealous with our love, damn it. So angry
Join "Celine Dion World's best Diva" in facebook
That's all everyone ever cares about. Lipping, lipping, lipping. HEY GUESS WHAT WITHOUT LIPPING THERE WOULD BE NO VOICE. Its as if some of you want her to loose her voice. Dont have a heart attack just because she lips its not a BIG deal. Celine has some of the MOST GREEDY fans I have ever seen. She gives up half her life to her fans and all you can do is debate for hours on whether or not she is lipping. Either way she took time out of HER life to sing and or record the song. She sang it. What more do you want. You say " we like the flaws so she shouldn't lip" then you say " omg she cracked she can't sing anymore". Please get over yourselves and just ENJOY THE MUSIC. She's already proved she can sing. Enjoy the music or be gone.
You don't know how much I like you right now. Even though this is not lipped, yes, there are people on here that post nothing but "Lipped", "Not Lipped". Some call themselves her biggest fans and yet will post "Lipped" on her videos. It's like they are trying to call her out. Who cares? They all lip...it's voice saving techniques. We heard how 200 shows a year for 5 years in Las Vegas killed her voice the first time...Taking Chances tour she sounded bad, but she was able to regain her voice and is now in Las Vegas singing better than ever, not to mention the awesome album "Loved Me Back To Life!" She's almost 46 years old and still sounds just as good, or better, as she did in this performance 16 years ago. She KNOWS what she is doing. If you really love Celine, enjoy her music and let her do what she is doing to keep her voice decent so we can continue to enjoy her music for another 20 years!
you do know that is not lipped right?
Yesssss, my thoughts exactly. YES.
I loved your words, totaly AGREEEEED!!! O/\o
Couldn't agree more!!!
It's not lip sycing I heard that she stopped singing on last chorus
this is not lipped listen @4:46
This is one of the few versions LIVE.
no... they were just playing a lower key
ohh okay no sorry i see now what you were saying:)
The violin sounds a little weird in some parts..
Think she is cheating.. lol.. she is soo good on so many levels.. did you all see what happen towards the end??? She couldnt do the vocalise all the way as she was out if breath. But look at what she did with it!! Gosh she is good; she must be cheating☺
Gary……
the song started on the wrong note and the man playing the violin
is the fault
I think she was trying to tell the violinist to get into key haha
He's a worldclass violinist. He would know if he was off-key. She often does signals to the audio engineers, though, and that might be what you saw.
At last, a live version. I'm not going to praise her. She has lipped this song enough.