Simple test where you can see what is the different between standard open loop stepper motor, stepper motor with integrated driver and closed loop hybrid stepper motor.
To achieve high RPM with stepper motor you need to increase supply voltage. 24v is only for moderate speeds. For really high speeds you would need 48v or even more.
This was just comparison 3 different stepper motors with the same power voltage. With higher power voltage will be more stable but you can´t put "48v or even more" for the motor and driver which can handle just 40V. (standard nema 23 have nominal voltage just 3 volts per coil. Stepper motors aren´t the standard DC motors - more voltage you put in more speed you get out!
@@denislukcik9843 For maximum speed you should run driver at maximum voltage it can handle. It reduces stepper motor resonance so it stalls at higher RPM. I got 2000 RPM under load on open-loop NEMA23 with 48V supply, but only 1200 RPM on 24V supply. And acceleration can be set higher too.
@@TheNamelessOne12357 the point of this video was to show that the closed loop motors have at least double speed rpm without missing the steps with the same voltage. Everything depend on how good quality is your driver.
Un millón de gracias por presentar esta prueba.
NICE!!! Thanks man, I'll press on my order for that 2HSS57 and 57J1880EC-1000
süper bir test düzeneği elinize sağlık
To achieve high RPM with stepper motor you need to increase supply voltage. 24v is only for moderate speeds. For really high speeds you would need 48v or even more.
This was just comparison 3 different stepper motors with the same power voltage. With higher power voltage will be more stable but you can´t put "48v or even more" for the motor and driver which can handle just 40V. (standard nema 23 have nominal voltage just 3 volts per coil. Stepper motors aren´t the standard DC motors - more voltage you put in more speed you get out!
@@denislukcik9843 For maximum speed you should run driver at maximum voltage it can handle. It reduces stepper motor resonance so it stalls at higher RPM. I got 2000 RPM under load on open-loop NEMA23 with 48V supply, but only 1200 RPM on 24V supply. And acceleration can be set higher too.
@@TheNamelessOne12357 the point of this video was to show that the closed loop motors have at least double speed rpm without missing the steps with the same voltage. Everything depend on how good quality is your driver.
thank you very much friend..its very nice test...
Nice test!! i like the ball screw guiding the wire!
What is the diameter of the rod where the wire is beeing rolled??
Thanks for making this video!
Diameter of the rod shaft is 8mm
This video is pure Gold !!
Did you get x(t) ? speed, and accelerations involved ?
In the process ?
TKS
Спасибо за видео! Просто и понятно!
Wow, that's a heavy load to accelerate
how many kilos lifted on the test?
3,1kg
@@denislukcik9843 Thanks!
@@lucianomorico your welcome