Nate Tice's Rookie WR Check-in: MHJ, Malik Nabers, Ladd McConkey, Xavier Lagetter & Rome Odunze

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 52

  • @kinggame9940
    @kinggame9940 20 днів тому +32

    BTJ is the best of the lot

  • @devinpayton7475
    @devinpayton7475 9 днів тому +11

    Brian thomas is one of 4 rookies to have 1100 yards and 10 tds as a rookie. The other 3 are randy Moss, jamaar chase and OBJ

    • @Black4Cook
      @Black4Cook 7 днів тому +1

      and nobody talks about it unless you watch a jaguars game

  • @Colton2418
    @Colton2418 9 днів тому +6

    Nabers and Thomas have both been top 10 Wideouts as rookies

  • @MattyzBeatz
    @MattyzBeatz 14 днів тому +20

    BTJ is the best by a mile

  • @jags9046
    @jags9046 8 днів тому +5

    BTJ is the next superstar WR in the NFL and was the best wr of the draft class by far.

  • @reyhaze5044
    @reyhaze5044 23 дні тому +10

    Underselling how good Nabers and BTJ have been for rookies

  • @brianradant2885
    @brianradant2885 24 дні тому +12

    Nabers and Thomas look like high end WR1s. Ladd gonna be real good too. Marv might prove it’s just been the scheme but he’s looked underwhelming. People were way too high on Worthy because he ran fast. Overall, lived up to expectations.

  • @KentaeJames
    @KentaeJames 16 днів тому +13

    Dang, Brian Thomas Jr must not be on your radar if you think he hasn't been the best.. Gimme nabors in 2nd..

    • @jaybirdmyers
      @jaybirdmyers 15 днів тому +3

      I'll take 1k and 9 tds on a team with no offense.

    • @a6i396
      @a6i396 15 днів тому +5

      btj is the best rookie

    • @Black4Cook
      @Black4Cook 7 днів тому +1

      @@jaybirdmyers 1.1k yards and 10TDs

  • @brichb87
    @brichb87 17 днів тому +11

    Disappointing? 2 guys are already in the top 5-10 dynasty wr assets, it’s just not MHJ

  • @austinsbostons7040
    @austinsbostons7040 15 днів тому +8

    Btj is the truth

  • @keithbenjamin9156
    @keithbenjamin9156 13 годин тому

    Brian thomas was a instant elite playmaker for the Jags..Hes the best Rookie wideout

  • @googlechicken
    @googlechicken 4 дні тому

    Jalen McMillian came on late and has looked very good, Coker has been a nice surprise and and I’m pretty confident Ricky Pearsall is going to be very productive in the future.

  • @captainactiv
    @captainactiv 23 дні тому +3

    MHJ has Kyler who's game is best when the play breaks down, Nabers hasn't had a QB yet, BTJ has one of the worst offenses in the NFL and a lil bad luck with his QB injured, Ladd is in a run heavy scheme, Legette was a lil behind in development and their passing has mostly been a joke in general tho looking better lately, Coleman has always had separation issues and Josh is too good of a rushed. This class has tons of talent and it's usually the third year for most WRs. That said, I expect these guys to all take massive steps forward next year.

    • @captainactiv
      @captainactiv 23 дні тому

      Forgot about Rome but it seems like Caleb does most of the time too lol. He'll get it together as well I believe.

    • @ernestogastelum9123
      @ernestogastelum9123 8 днів тому +1

      @@captainactiv Rome wasnt going to get that many receptions because they actually have a #1 receiver with DJ Moore and Keenan Allen

  • @MattyzBeatz
    @MattyzBeatz 14 днів тому +5

    This dude is delusional 😂😂😂

    • @dman9416
      @dman9416 14 днів тому

      As if disappointing

  • @dukegdb
    @dukegdb 12 годин тому

    Yall tripping this draft class is deeper then the 2019 AJ, Terry DK class The 2020 JJets Ceedee, Tee Higgins Aiyuk 2021 Jamarr, Amon ra, Waddle Collins Devonta draft. If you going off numbers. None of them classes have 4 1,000 yard WRs each class went 3/4 deep at best. 2024 have BTJ Nabers Ladd,MHJ Worthy Brock Bowers also McMillian and Vele last 4 weeks of the season McMillians closed out with 8 TD in limited games also Rome played well also
    That’s 9 WRs deep

  • @kingave9721
    @kingave9721 9 днів тому +1

    I see why this only has 3,000 views. lol a receiver out here breaking records but he’s not the best 😮

  • @user-hy1od6by1w
    @user-hy1od6by1w 24 дні тому +16

    Every expert claimed Harrison was some football God 😂

    • @jason5265
      @jason5265 24 дні тому +1

      Right! What happened?

    • @KevinWM2
      @KevinWM2 24 дні тому +7

      Nabers would have been the man with a capable QB. The first part of the season proved that when Danny Dimes was somewhat effective.

    • @FrankLaghezza
      @FrankLaghezza 24 дні тому +2

      Thanks for explaining Harrison being misused- looks like a pure X wideout
      Marvin has so much talent - he’s so much more than that!
      Even if Arizona won’t hire you - can you drop them a message- lol😂
      great show

    • @SheeshLeLL
      @SheeshLeLL 24 дні тому +1

      Watch some Harrison film his still amazing and if you genuinely watch his college film and don’t think he was that good you are smoked

    • @GGG600-n4l
      @GGG600-n4l 22 дні тому

      To bad he not in college still lol😂😂😂

  • @pacificbeatz5440
    @pacificbeatz5440 24 дні тому +1

    It’s like Travis Hunter. He’s good but wherever he goes he can’t make the QB throw to him.

  • @jason5265
    @jason5265 24 дні тому +2

    Why isn’t MHJ better? Is it Kyler or the offense or is he just not as great as everyone said?

    • @KevinWM2
      @KevinWM2 24 дні тому

      @@jason5265 Kyler's non-quality passes and there often aren't many of them a game. That being said, I still think at this stage of their careers Nabers is way ahead of the curve.

    • @jarvaewray453
      @jarvaewray453 15 днів тому

      He’s in a horrible position he’s not used for anything besides vertical routes

  • @newlifeeveryday1821
    @newlifeeveryday1821 23 дні тому +1

    Rome Odunze only has 3 drops this year. Do your homework.

    • @broq9194
      @broq9194 15 днів тому

      You're talking about the balling hitting you directly in your hands easy catch drops. Odunze was drafted because he was "supposed" to be a ball magnet and catch everything his way, including difficult and contested catches, AND HE HAS NOT DONE THAT. Most difficult catches he drops and makes hardly any contested catches at all. His catch percentage is lowest on his team and lowest out of all the receivers drafted in the first round, close to 50% which means an average throw to Odunze is a 50/50 ball, even lower than Xavier Worthy who is a true deep threat being thrown many low percentage balls. That's pathetic, especially for a guy who was drafted to be a ball magnet. His overall play and production is either matched or exceeded by every receiver drafted in the first round. Odunze might will tighten up and be really productive but so far he's been quite underwhelming and not worth a top 10 pick, not even close. So I don't know why you and the media keep swinging from the guy's nuts. BTJ and Nabors have been the only two receivers worth high-mid first round grades so far. People are just trying to justify their pre-draft opinion of Odunze, because so many people were so high on him. I wasn't, because he's not explosive enough, doesn't have any elite qualities, and has a skill set that far too many lower drafted receivers can match. Bears should have traded down and took BTJ and a top O-lineman instead of Odunze at #9.

  • @chasec7729
    @chasec7729 11 днів тому

    When has Kyler supported a WR1?

  • @dblorenzo1528
    @dblorenzo1528 22 дні тому +1

    Nabers has missed 2 games n has the worst qb room ever. And is on pace for 100 rec 1000 yds

  • @585_Mar
    @585_Mar 4 дні тому

    Leek clear 🥱🥱🥱

  • @BigJase1021
    @BigJase1021 13 днів тому +2

    I think just chill its been a damn good class give these guys a few years and it will most likely be 1 of if not the best WR class.

  • @jags9046
    @jags9046 8 днів тому +1

    Ladd The best on tape?? What football are you watching lmao. Just look at receiving yard stats for the league. Btj is 4th bro

  • @OwenMeenie-d8u
    @OwenMeenie-d8u 24 дні тому

    Malika Nabers, huh? Is that Maliks mother, perhaps?

  • @Cartier_FRITZ
    @Cartier_FRITZ 23 дні тому +4

    Ladd is not better than Malik 😂😂

    • @MattyzBeatz
      @MattyzBeatz 14 днів тому +5

      Malik is also not better than BTJ 😂😂😂😂

    • @ZoddGuts
      @ZoddGuts 10 днів тому +1

      Ladd is consistent. Has more total yards and TD's than Nabers despite having less Recs. Ladd also has a higher average per yards.

    • @ernestogastelum9123
      @ernestogastelum9123 8 днів тому

      tbh if Ladd had the same targets as Malik, then Ladd wouldve had more receptions. the first 5 weeks we hardly passed the ball since we relied more on runnin the ball

    • @ButtBongoFiesta
      @ButtBongoFiesta 8 днів тому

      @@ZoddGuts Ladd is consistent..Hmm why is that?

    • @Black4Cook
      @Black4Cook 7 днів тому +1

      @@ernestogastelum9123 yes but ladd plays in a run heavy offense. Jaguars and Giants are a bad run team which makes it harder to shine because teams wont stack the box against them.