The very ending is still interesting to me. Karenin is still living life on the stage, but a more peaceful one where he and the children are unburdened. He never fully escapes the limelight, but he finds peace in it cause Anna is not around... a very bittersweet ending.
@@monicad99 The pretense was part of Anna, not Karenin. Karenin always lived the life he wanted, he was just part of the norm and there's nothing wrong with that
If you slow down moments before you can actually see she was beheaded but the film director wanted it to make it look like a theater play so it cuts to her like that
Add to that list he could be her dad with how older he was from her and you'll see why their relationship is repulsive. He should have thought twice before marrying a child this is what happens
In the book, he had a pretty paternalistic attitude towards her, it wasn't exactly what I'd call love. He was much older than her and emotionally removed. She may have been rash and a tad emotionally immature, but she needed to LIVE and Karenin couldn't give her that. The deeply sexist, paternalistic system that didn't recognize women's feelings or emotional needs was the problem at the root.
I still wonder why they didn't show any reaction shot or epilogue for Vronsky. Seems like a glaring decision not to. But I don't quite understand why yet.
@@nicoleperaltaanduray7243 he gives up his daughter to Karenin during Anna’s funeral and then enlists to fight in Serbia, which is for all intents and purposes, a death sentence. he left his daughter to karenin because he knew he was going off to his death. none of this ended happily, for either of the three parties.
So, Karenin takes care of Anna's child with Bronski, I never new this until this movie, in truth I have never read the book, a to-do in my reading list, but I've saw many adaptations and I always wonder what happen with their dougther
If I remember correctly, in the book he was tender to the child because of her innocence on the whole stuff, and raised her as his own, along with his and Anna's son.
@@drariet9190 I found that very amiable of him, to raise his wife's child that she had after cheating on him, a lot of people would resent their partners' child born of adultery.
@@drariet9190 i remember anya's dad participated in battle where i assumed he dies and now that anya's parents are gone and idk what happened to his paternal grandma or maternal relatives but i guess this is a good way to show that anya has a good life after her parents abandoned her
@@user-vp9ko6bv2p wtf how can you say that! He did nothing wrong as well you love who you love! You can’t control who you fall in love with and Anna didn’t marry out of love so of course she is going to be with a man she loves
@@user-vp9ko6bv2p huh ? She was forced to marry and had no human rights yet she is wrong for going after who she loves ? You can’t force someone to be with you and then except loyalty
dude Karenin should have just divorced her wtf. the girl went mad because he stopped her from seeing her own son while the whole world crashed upon her, im sad for her.
@@hottea9826 Karenin offered her a divorce once with no strings attached, but she threw it back in his face. The reason she went mad is because society shunned her in addition to her paranoia over the possibility of Vronsky leaving her or cheating on her.
Книга очень интересная, даже после просмотра фильма . У меня пялятся собрания сочинений. Но этот фильм помог передать тонкую суть и красоту в тех персонажах, что играли довольно мастерски актеры. Ошибки или сложности выбора, паттерны поведения, важность полезности для миру , стоицизм, вера в себя и понимание , что живёшь не зря, и любовь и понимание в отношениях❤. Может что то ещё важное, что имеет смысл. Достойно, даже великолепно получилось,хотя определенно жанр театральной постановки не каждому привычен. Разнообразие эмоций потрясает.
Don’t get me wrong. I enjoy this film for what it is but the scene with the little kids dancing in the grass is kind of awkward. It reminds me of the ending credits of LHOTP when there was a sad episode like May We Make Them Proud or Sylvia and then suddenly we’d see Laura dancing in the fields with upbeat music immediately pulling us out of the somber mood. “What are those kids dancing around for? Don’t they know what just happened?”
In the book, Karenin even attends the funeral, so Seryozha probably knows. By like the end of the novel, when Stiva talks to Karenina and after talks to Seryozha he refuses to remember anything about his mother. He is resentful or distraught with Anna for leaving him and Karenin. At last, Seryozha in book accepts Karenin as a better guardian and a parent than Anna, but lives and accepts societal standards and expectations forced upon him as Karenin's son. As for Annie, she is still too young to understand. The real question is, Why would they care about Anna, at all? Hell, she is a grown ass woman, and even when Karenin offered her divorce she didn't take it before and if she loved Seryozha that much, why didn't she do neither? Either stay with Karenin or take a divorce. Heck, if my mother did that to me at a very young age like 8 yrs old, I'll respond the same way like Seryozha. If that happened, I wouldn't give a thing about her, even if she's my momma. Once trust is broken, it's broken forever. It is not said Karenin is an abuser. He is manipulative, yes, but his intentions are justifiable. Do you think one can live in a society like that without living according to its ethics? Karenin is the most well aware person about it. Levin, ofc, is not from high society, is free from all that.
He didn't left her, she was too paranoid and had borderline personality disorder which made her have episodes seeing scenes where he was cheating on him etc. She couldn't take it anymore and killed herself then
Sy baru selesai bc novelnya, yg sy tangkap vronski tdk selingkuh, dia muak dg kecemburuan anna & kecemburuan anna lbh krn dia ketakutan cinta vronski makin berkurang kepadanya krn keributan yg selalu terjadi diantara mrk, ending nya kl sy tdk salah tangkap si vronski jd sukarelawan di perang Serbia krn patah hatinya setelah anna bunuh diri di rel kereta
In the book, Vronsky was in such severe grief his family feared for his life. When Karenin came to Anna's funeral he gave him his daughter (Karenin had cared for the newborn Annie throughout Anna's illness and come to love her). Then Serbia fought for independence against the Ottoman Empire, and the Russian public had an idea to help fellow Slavs. Vronsky donated money for a squadron and volunteered himself, wishing to be killed in battle.
You're thinking the fast man to have died in The Avengers. You guys make a new movie with a new hero to the Fast Man, like Spider-Man. [١٦/٨ ٦:٠٣ ص] محمد: If he thinks it's a good idea. [١٦/٨ ٦:٠٤ ص] محمد: Add likes [١٦/٨ ٦:٠٥ ص] محمد: Talk about it. [١٦/٨ ٦:٠٦ ص] محمد: Because Marvel Studio can see it
The fact that Karenin decided to take care of Anna and Vronsky's daughter...
Goes to show he is a bigger man than most husbands would be.
The very ending is still interesting to me. Karenin is still living life on the stage, but a more peaceful one where he and the children are unburdened. He never fully escapes the limelight, but he finds peace in it cause Anna is not around... a very bittersweet ending.
the stage means he is still living a life of pretense and double standards.
@@monicad99What do you mean?
@@monicad99What do you mean??
@@monicad99 The pretense was part of Anna, not Karenin. Karenin always lived the life he wanted, he was just part of the norm and there's nothing wrong with that
She is in remarkably good shape for someone who died by train
If you slow down moments before you can actually see she was beheaded but the film director wanted it to make it look like a theater play so it cuts to her like that
😆
My dad was killed by a train and years later we could still find pieces of his truck by the tracks
Trains were slower then. 😆
My thoughts exactly! 🚂
What I find so profound about this movie is that it is both sad and uplifting at the same time.
The sound at impact when the train hit was rough. I was stunned to see her so well preserved.
You can’t build happiness over other people pain and humiliation when you try it usually doesn’t end well.
If only she understood her husband's love for her,love can't always be shown...he loved her he worked hard for her but she never realised it
he didn’t really love her
@@watermelon520b he did but not all are able to express their feelings by sexual tension or physically
Add to that list he could be her dad with how older he was from her and you'll see why their relationship is repulsive. He should have thought twice before marrying a child this is what happens
@@phoenixangel5073 Yeah, Karinin is pretty awful in the book.
In the book, he had a pretty paternalistic attitude towards her, it wasn't exactly what I'd call love. He was much older than her and emotionally removed. She may have been rash and a tad emotionally immature, but she needed to LIVE and Karenin couldn't give her that. The deeply sexist, paternalistic system that didn't recognize women's feelings or emotional needs was the problem at the root.
It's been a year since i've read the book. I need to re revisit this piece again.
What is the book called? Written by whom? I will find the book myself.
@@wjkwjk3484 ANNA KARENINA by LEO TOLSTOY.
Anna Karenina - Leo Tolstoy
I still wonder why they didn't show any reaction shot or epilogue for Vronsky. Seems like a glaring decision not to. But I don't quite understand why yet.
Because he really didn't matter.
@@calypsosgarden203 she killed herself over him. Plus there’s an epilogue of him in the book…. Why not include it
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim why does it says?
@@nicoleperaltaanduray7243 he gives up his daughter to Karenin during Anna’s funeral and then enlists to fight in Serbia, which is for all intents and purposes, a death sentence. he left his daughter to karenin because he knew he was going off to his death. none of this ended happily, for either of the three parties.
@@PutinsMommyNeverHuggedHim i love that he really did love her 💔
I've never seen the movie or read the book but really like the soundtrack here. Really sets the scene.
So, Karenin takes care of Anna's child with Bronski, I never new this until this movie, in truth I have never read the book, a to-do in my reading list, but I've saw many adaptations and I always wonder what happen with their dougther
If I remember correctly, in the book he was tender to the child because of her innocence on the whole stuff, and raised her as his own, along with his and Anna's son.
@@drariet9190 I found that very amiable of him, to raise his wife's child that she had after cheating on him, a lot of people would resent their partners' child born of adultery.
@@drariet9190 i remember anya's dad participated in battle where i assumed he dies and now that anya's parents are gone and idk what happened to his paternal grandma or maternal relatives but i guess this is a good way to show that anya has a good life after her parents abandoned her
@@cyrilmarasigan7108 why say dad and not Vronsky lol
@@plantsbyhailey8326 sorry i forgot his name but yeah his name i think is vronsky
Such a sad story and movie. 😞
Fr like I hope the people she affected had a good life except the dude she cheated with
@@user-vp9ko6bv2p wtf how can you say that! He did nothing wrong as well you love who you love! You can’t control who you fall in love with and Anna didn’t marry out of love so of course she is going to be with a man she loves
@@roselamoure r u blind so something?
@@user-vp9ko6bv2p huh ? She was forced to marry and had no human rights yet she is wrong for going after who she loves ? You can’t force someone to be with you and then except loyalty
@@mebeb6399 spoken like a true cheater
Although Anna is the main character
I think each family already find peace..
Мне очень понравилась эта версия "Анны Карениной".Запала в душу, никогда не забуду.
This is the best version
Tolstoy at the end of his life run away from his wife and died at the age of 95.
and...?
dude Karenin should have just divorced her wtf. the girl went mad because he stopped her from seeing her own son while the whole world crashed upon her, im sad for her.
you shouldn't be
@@Not_Always dont tell me what to do
@@hottea9826 Karenin offered her a divorce once with no strings attached, but she threw it back in his face.
The reason she went mad is because society shunned her in addition to her paranoia over the possibility of Vronsky leaving her or cheating on her.
@@miyukun6183 damn maybe i should read the book
He did though and she didn’t take it, her cheating and taking her own life was on her and her choices
Maturity is realizing that Karenin is the best character in this work, and the one who suffered the most
Любимый роман, прекрасный фильм ❤ Я удивлен и мне очень приятно, что так много иностранцев знают русскую литературу 🇷🇺
Хороший фильм
I started getting into Russian literature and poetry because of Lana Del Rey, she’s an amazing artist. Much love from Miami
Книга очень интересная, даже после просмотра фильма . У меня пялятся собрания сочинений. Но этот фильм помог передать тонкую суть и красоту в тех персонажах, что играли довольно мастерски актеры. Ошибки или сложности выбора, паттерны поведения, важность полезности для миру , стоицизм, вера в себя и понимание , что живёшь не зря, и любовь и понимание в отношениях❤. Может что то ещё важное, что имеет смысл. Достойно, даже великолепно получилось,хотя определенно жанр театральной постановки не каждому привычен. Разнообразие эмоций потрясает.
In 1917, all of them and their descendants are either dead, imprisoned or had left Soviet Russia for good.
🙄🙄
@@Not_Always no, the OPs comment is historically correct. I am not sure why you thought the OP was over reacting.
A great movie
Never go into the tall grass
LMBAO!
I didn’t know she was in this movie
This movie was something.😕😕
What happened to vronsky?
He went to the war with Serbia
@@maria77746He went to war with Turkey, not Serbia.
@@LiuXiangchengHe went to war with Turkey in Serbia
This whole title was a spoiler for me 😢😢😢
The story is centuries old I'm afraid :D
@@Bjjbhcoa86 I know;)
What happen to count vronkey after her death??
He went a bit insane and went to war with Serbia
Don’t get me wrong. I enjoy this film for what it is but the scene with the little kids dancing in the grass is kind of awkward. It reminds me of the ending credits of LHOTP when there was a sad episode like May We Make Them Proud or Sylvia and then suddenly we’d see Laura dancing in the fields with upbeat music immediately pulling us out of the somber mood. “What are those kids dancing around for? Don’t they know what just happened?”
In the book, Karenin even attends the funeral, so Seryozha probably knows. By like the end of the novel, when Stiva talks to Karenina and after talks to Seryozha he refuses to remember anything about his mother. He is resentful or distraught with Anna for leaving him and Karenin. At last, Seryozha in book accepts Karenin as a better guardian and a parent than Anna, but lives and accepts societal standards and expectations forced upon him as Karenin's son. As for Annie, she is still too young to understand. The real question is, Why would they care about Anna, at all? Hell, she is a grown ass woman, and even when Karenin offered her divorce she didn't take it before and if she loved Seryozha that much, why didn't she do neither? Either stay with Karenin or take a divorce. Heck, if my mother did that to me at a very young age like 8 yrs old, I'll respond the same way like Seryozha. If that happened, I wouldn't give a thing about her, even if she's my momma. Once trust is broken, it's broken forever.
It is not said Karenin is an abuser. He is manipulative, yes, but his intentions are justifiable. Do you think one can live in a society like that without living according to its ethics? Karenin is the most well aware person about it. Levin, ofc, is not from high society, is free from all that.
What did he realize?
That love has no reason
So he left her that she killer herself?
She died because she became an outcast in society
He didn't left her, she was too paranoid and had borderline personality disorder which made her have episodes seeing scenes where he was cheating on him etc. She couldn't take it anymore and killed herself then
😢😢😢😢😢😢
Ok but what about Vronsky?
He went to war
@ДмитрийФёдоровичКарамазов What were his feelings after Anna's death?
@@missbateman3250 He fell into depression.
@@missbateman3250 He suffered from depression.
Apa yg terjadi dgn vronsky slanjutnya?apa benar dia berselingkuh??atau itu hanya kecemburuan anna yg sedang kondisi tak stabil??
Sy baru selesai bc novelnya, yg sy tangkap vronski tdk selingkuh, dia muak dg kecemburuan anna & kecemburuan anna lbh krn dia ketakutan cinta vronski makin berkurang kepadanya krn keributan yg selalu terjadi diantara mrk, ending nya kl sy tdk salah tangkap si vronski jd sukarelawan di perang Serbia krn patah hatinya setelah anna bunuh diri di rel kereta
Name of movie?!
anna karenina
What about alexi?? Dd he die too ??
In the book, Vronsky was in such severe grief his family feared for his life. When Karenin came to Anna's funeral he gave him his daughter (Karenin had cared for the newborn Annie throughout Anna's illness and come to love her). Then Serbia fought for independence against the Ottoman Empire, and the Russian public had an idea to help fellow Slavs. Vronsky donated money for a squadron and volunteered himself, wishing to be killed in battle.
Stay out of the long grass
He should have left her alone
You're thinking the fast man to have died in The Avengers. You guys make a new movie with a new hero to the Fast Man, like Spider-Man.
[١٦/٨ ٦:٠٣ ص] محمد: If he thinks it's a good idea.
[١٦/٨ ٦:٠٤ ص] محمد: Add likes
[١٦/٨ ٦:٠٥ ص] محمد: Talk about it.
[١٦/٨ ٦:٠٦ ص] محمد: Because Marvel Studio can see it