Eu nunca imaginei que um documentário tão bom, mostrando a dura realidade de alguns seres humanos, pudesse trazer uma visibilidade negativa pra eles. Passaram 30 anos e não mudou muita coisa, a educação básica não foi ofertada a eles pelo governo, oferecer cursos para pessoas que não são alfabetizadas é uma maldade sem medida!!! Chocada com o depoimento desse senhor que deixou subentendido sua insatisfação pelo documentário.
Esse documentário representou 90% das favelas no Brasil na década de 80.. Mas o documentário é real sim. Os moradores acham que foi ruim...gente....foi ótimo esse documentário. Veja a senhora mais idosa. Ela sim fala tudo. Parabéns..
Não tem como dizer que o documentário mostrando mulheres e crianças pegando lixo pra comer levou visibilidade negativa pras pessoas da ilha. O que levou visibilidade negativa pras pessoas da ilha é o poder público, o estado irresponsável, e os bilionários que lucram cada vez mais bilhões e jogam fora comida pra aumentar o preço pra lucrarem mais. 1 ou 2 moradores que moram lá que culpam o documentário por algum tipo de piora que tenha havido na região só confirmam o poder ideológico que tem a burguesia.
justo, camarada! O doc é uma crítica e uma denúncia, se o poder público nada faz quanto às críticas e denúncias, o diretor do doc nada pode fazer, não é função dele e ele não tem poder sobre isso. Infelizmente a cegueira ideológica deixa turvo o entendimento de quem são os inimigos do povo pra quem nasce nessa ideologia nefasta que é a ideologia dominante. Tão imersos que as pessoas ficam que culpam quem faz algo pra denunciar as situações calamitosas que o capitalismo nos imbui.
As pessoas que estão dando essa entrevista, são muito sábias em suas palavras. Pessoas seguras no que falam. Alguns seres "humanos" estão sempre querendo crescer em cima dos menos favorecidos. Triste !!
Acho que o documentário foi muito bom para nos mostrar a realidade de tantas pessoas, mas foi péssimo porque mesmo sabendo a realidade naquele local, ninguém fez nada a respeito
Hello! im here to say that its translated using the youtube's automatic subtitles, So, the translation is not going to be 100% accurate i'm sorry 'bout that, thirty years after the launch of the short film island of flowers recognized in Brazil and in the international some things have changed in the main lease of production to the island great of sailors in Porto Alegre( a city in Brazil :) ) but the community still lives with dilemmas such as social inequality in the the same territory the work of the new bridge of the guaíba and the dismay of public power beyond report on the consequences that the short film occasioned for us not changed nothing because for us it was just a son a short that cost us a lot to Low benefit nothing up for a job staff of the islands of the big island had to give the address of other family members who live in a Porto Alegre to be able to get a job because in time so it appeared that when it is the time of the beast those people who was kind of a contract was to run after that truck but didn't know what they were Doing at that moment when as the vegetables truck the guys came out everybody saw here started running together that bunch of people don't even know well thinking it was just that came in only the ones who were filmed is that was subscribed is well that the union that didn't exist that people sought and took the food here but it wasn't that dispute with the animals there is not community at that time was a chick community admits had not and didn't had nothing at that time had no lusa had no water at that time had no light no had water had nothing saying so nothing is just the truck has the way for that actually something that there many people the water had no light to that there was actually a battle of the own residents put us put something that at the time that came this is a challenge but had no piped water as if you say the kite you were carrying but not sold from the city hall bring there only that there 3rd gave some negative visibility visibility because we're judgments several things like that were evolving but it's are so very creative things in the truth right it would take a lot more right to be able to give people's better living conditions because the government doesn't give the ball first place because it doesn't matter doesn't interest people who don't vote a small-quantity option has no no power is they are forgotten abandoned to incentivize abandoned chosen that's the most correct word choice of the same the total abandonment because you see well marquesan is not even realizing Porto Alegre and we of the islands we're facing the Porto Alegre portalegre of coast but i always say you know why you're out there screaming if you is on the island of pintada sees harbor Porto Alegre so right sees him facing him but they're on their backs there the story of bridge of the guaíba they made a survey might and will not affect for that people take away from inventing the purchase assisted that it was not accepted that Project the project was to make an undertaking in the sound area of the island so people could morals move from here to there but it was in 2014 it's a beautiful project also they often serve as bushing cannon to open new areas of real estate speculation to the extent that many poor lands there after more or less consecrated were bought in exchange for bananas to put millionaire mansions so that part is another that power public does not see it right the destruction of the park through people speculation who have such a great taste of wanting invest in a mansion inside a park and it was a feeble mental lawn taking from the law the native plants what changed was the following people have more awareness staff have always worked with recycling be true we had shed of recycling that the staff who stay in the our own house and earn your livelihood working with garbage that staff don't consume is that selective garbage most of the staff they live on recycling because they are people who have no study know there the city hall of Porto Alegre sometimes so we took several courses and the people who wanted to take advantage is truth bring several courses only that so it's the courses the person had to study the bump test with two extremes very sad right people who are there for not had no choice of people who are there having all the options will decide there does not preserve destroy in its great majority clear that there are exceptions talking and I talk a lot and we started the nazareth owner on these things right including she said she said she was going to had a lot of poverty today the island don't have that level of poverty that had previously been not today we have teachers within the Island we have social assistance within the island a dense we have people who are doing college within the island with all the Difficulties we have children who do not miss 8th grade that the college has have class in the night not all much of the community does not nothing of me and i was in that movie only don't appear will appear the families my that there was used a dump that was there where is the video nowadays the bid there was a dump make a note or márcio lara deploy the uncle and then it's not do that he doesn't talk if they didn't talk spoke to the island don't know whatever it is has flowers but it was implied that would be there but it's he doesn't see clear really want there we get a lot is not yet like us wanted it understood it's not hot that's lighter than the delay on the hot island A there's not going to be any more hot stuff that need to just write to me no in all 74 91 venice and suddenly a lot thing that's going to come into the island in a model right but i hope my children my grandchildren i see [Music]
Cadê a melhora? Ele nem ao menos citou essa ilha Já se passaram 11 meses e o Brasil não avançou, pelo contrário, retrocedeu Temos que parar de ficar idolatrando presidentes,ele estão lá para servir o povo e não para serem servidos
Eu nunca imaginei que um documentário tão bom, mostrando a dura realidade de alguns seres humanos, pudesse trazer uma visibilidade negativa pra eles. Passaram 30 anos e não mudou muita coisa, a educação básica não foi ofertada a eles pelo governo, oferecer cursos para pessoas que não são alfabetizadas é uma maldade sem medida!!! Chocada com o depoimento desse senhor que deixou subentendido sua insatisfação pelo documentário.
Tive a mesma impressão !
Esse documentário representou 90% das favelas no Brasil na década de 80.. Mas o documentário é real sim. Os moradores acham que foi ruim...gente....foi ótimo esse documentário. Veja a senhora mais idosa. Ela sim fala tudo. Parabéns..
Vdd
Não tem como dizer que o documentário mostrando mulheres e crianças pegando lixo pra comer levou visibilidade negativa pras pessoas da ilha. O que levou visibilidade negativa pras pessoas da ilha é o poder público, o estado irresponsável, e os bilionários que lucram cada vez mais bilhões e jogam fora comida pra aumentar o preço pra lucrarem mais. 1 ou 2 moradores que moram lá que culpam o documentário por algum tipo de piora que tenha havido na região só confirmam o poder ideológico que tem a burguesia.
Desse jeito...muito boa a tua colocação !!
justo, camarada! O doc é uma crítica e uma denúncia, se o poder público nada faz quanto às críticas e denúncias, o diretor do doc nada pode fazer, não é função dele e ele não tem poder sobre isso. Infelizmente a cegueira ideológica deixa turvo o entendimento de quem são os inimigos do povo pra quem nasce nessa ideologia nefasta que é a ideologia dominante. Tão imersos que as pessoas ficam que culpam quem faz algo pra denunciar as situações calamitosas que o capitalismo nos imbui.
ótima reportagem, simplesmente incrivel
As pessoas que estão dando essa entrevista, são muito sábias em suas palavras. Pessoas seguras no que falam.
Alguns seres "humanos" estão sempre querendo crescer em cima dos menos favorecidos. Triste !!
Que triste ouvir isso. Pessoas se sentem excluídas ainda hoje. Foda mesmo.
Vc tá aqui por que o professor mandou.
Vdd kkk
Tem gente que gosta de aprender por aprender...
Sim
Não
Parabens pelo trabalho Vinicius!! Importantissimo
Triste. Mais triste ainda é que foi toda inundada e hoje está submersa.
Fake News ein! A Ilha das Flores, em Porto Alegre, já foi atingida por alagamentos, mas não está submersa!
@@porumtrizbea que bom!! Cai na mentira
Acho que o documentário foi muito bom para nos mostrar a realidade de tantas pessoas, mas foi péssimo porque mesmo sabendo a realidade naquele local, ninguém fez nada a respeito
can anyone add english subtitles pls? very interested in this subject
Hello!
im here to say that its translated using the youtube's automatic subtitles, So, the translation is not going to be 100% accurate
i'm sorry 'bout that,
thirty years after the launch of the
short film island of flowers
recognized in Brazil and in the
international some things have changed in the
main lease of production to the island
great of sailors in Porto Alegre( a city in Brazil :) )
but the community still lives with
dilemmas such as social inequality in the
the same territory the work of the new bridge of the
guaíba and the dismay of public power beyond
report on the consequences that the
short film occasioned for us not
changed nothing because for us it was just a
son a short that cost us a lot to
Low
benefit nothing up for a job
staff of the islands of the big island
had to give the address of other
family members who live in a Porto Alegre
to be able to get a job because in
time so it appeared that when it is
the time of the beast
those people who was kind of a
contract was to run after that
truck but didn't know what they were
Doing
at that moment when as the
vegetables truck
the guys came out everybody saw here
started running together
that bunch of people don't even know well
thinking it was just that came in only the ones who
were filmed is that was subscribed is
well that the union that didn't exist that
people sought and took the
food here but it wasn't that
dispute with the animals there is not
community at that time was a
chick community admits had not and didn't
had nothing
at that time had no lusa had no
water at that time had no light no
had water had nothing saying
so nothing is just the truck has the way
for that actually something that there
many people the water had no light to
that there was actually a battle of the
own residents put us put
something that at the time that came this is a
challenge but had no piped water as
if you say the kite you were carrying but not
sold from the city hall bring there only that there
3rd gave some negative visibility
visibility because we're judgments
several things like that were evolving but
it's are so very creative things in the
truth right
it would take a lot more right to be able to give
people's better living conditions
because the government doesn't give the ball
first place because it doesn't matter
doesn't interest people who don't vote a
small-quantity option has no
no power is they are forgotten
abandoned to incentivize abandoned
chosen that's the most correct word
choice of the same
the total abandonment because you see well
marquesan is not even realizing
Porto Alegre and we of the islands
we're facing the Porto Alegre
portalegre of coast but i always say
you know why you're out there screaming if you
is on the island of pintada sees harbor
Porto Alegre so right
sees him facing him but
they're on their backs there the story of
bridge of the guaíba they made a
survey might and will not affect for
that people take away from inventing the purchase
assisted that it was not accepted that
Project
the project was to make an undertaking in the
sound area of the island so people
could morals move from here to there
but it was in 2014 it's a beautiful project
also they often serve as bushing
cannon to open new areas of
real estate speculation to the extent that
many poor lands there after
more or less consecrated were
bought in exchange for bananas to put
millionaire mansions
so that part is another that power
public does not see it right the destruction of the
park through people speculation
who have such a great taste of wanting
invest in a mansion inside a park
and it was a feeble mental lawn taking from the
law the native plants what changed was the
following people have more awareness
staff have always worked with recycling
be true we had shed of
recycling that the staff who stay in the
our own house and earn your livelihood
working with garbage that staff don't
consume is that selective garbage
most of the staff
they live on recycling because they are
people who have no study know there the
city hall of Porto Alegre sometimes
so we took several courses and the
people who wanted to take advantage is
truth bring several courses only that
so it's
the courses the person had to study the
bump test with two extremes very
sad right people who are there for not
had no choice of people who are
there having all the options will decide there
does not preserve destroy in its great
majority clear that there are exceptions
talking and I talk a lot and
we started the nazareth owner on these
things right
including she said she said she was going to
had a lot of poverty
today the island don't have that level of
poverty that had previously been
not today we have teachers within the
Island
we have social assistance within the
island a dense
we have people who are doing
college within the island with all the
Difficulties
we have children who do not miss 8th
grade that the college has have class in the
night not all much of the community does not
nothing of me and i was in that movie only
don't appear will appear the families
my that there was used a dump that
was there where is the video nowadays the bid
there was a dump make a note or márcio
lara deploy the uncle and then it's not
do that he doesn't talk if they didn't talk
spoke to the island don't know whatever it is
has flowers but it was implied that
would be there but it's he doesn't see clear
really want there we get
a lot is not yet like us
wanted it understood it's not hot that's
lighter than the delay on the hot island
A
there's not going to be any more hot stuff that
need to just write to me no
in all 74 91 venice and suddenly a lot
thing that's going to come into the island in a
model right
but i hope my children my grandchildren
i see
[Music]
Quem veio assistir esse vídeo pq a professora pediu ?
Vc aqui praga kkkkkk
Pediram agora no Home Office
Alguém pode me ajudar? Preciso fazer uma resenha com 2 páginas kkkkk
Manda ai Monteiro
Ah ta.... Nao era nao... Ate parece que ....
Onde acho o resumo desse video
Deixa de ser preguiçoso e v esse trem todo
É
Toma no cu de vcs
o doc não tem nem 20 minutos, irmão, pqp
😂😂😂😂 esse é pobre de espírito 😂
Agora nós temos um Presidente de verdade.... essa história há de mudar, de ser reescrita para melhor!!!
Cadê a melhora? Ele nem ao menos citou essa ilha
Já se passaram 11 meses e o Brasil não avançou, pelo contrário, retrocedeu
Temos que parar de ficar idolatrando presidentes,ele estão lá para servir o povo e não para serem servidos
😅😅😅😅😅 luladrao???? Pwp