Katie Herzog on Gender Dysphoria | We The Internet TV
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 бер 2020
- Katie Herzog explains Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria and its effect on the gay and lesbian community. Check out the full video here: • We The Internet TV Liv...
Producer & Head Writer: Lou Perez
Executive Producers: Rob Pfaltzgraff & Nick Reid
Creative Producer: Lana Link
Associate Producer: Jordan Best
Marketing Director: Allison Ryan - Комедії
ITS A TREND AND A MENTAL ISSUE. Help the people. not the illness.
That suit, all i could think of was alternate timeline Joker where he's the TV personality.
There are children in elementary and middle school who are self proclaimed transgender and gay/lesbian. Its becoming very normalized especially in our youth and this will have a huge consequence on their mind when they grow up.
I met a woman who had a daughter that was around 10. She came home one day crying because she was confused about her gender and sexuality. Apparently the public school she was going to in Atlanta was pushing this crap on her. Thankfully the woman pulled her daughter from the school right away and got her counseling. Now she is homeschooling. That got my blood boiling.
It's already happening. You just don't hear about it because it's goes against the agenda. There is a girl in the UK who is suing. Best wishes
Insanity in the nineties happened mainly in males one in 4500
I am friends with someone who is trans, and he brings up the "I knew as a child" thing all the time. I've always countered with that it's not about who knew as a child who made the choice to transition as an adult, it's about how many kids who say they are trans change their mind before they turn 18. That's why I don't support making any permanent changes to a child's body. Once you're an adult and you want to do something, go ahead, your body belongs to you. But children need protecting. They should become adults with their body intact.
Children's bodies belong to adults is pretty twisted as a rule. Also, you're not a very good friend to this trans person.
@@vinnym5607 guardianship and ownership are not the same thing.
Children shouldn't be forced to have permanent changes made to their bodies that they explicitly don't want, that's why preventing unwanted puberty is so important. I mean, it's healthier to just let kids have the right puberty, but at the very least stopping them from blocking the wrong puberty, causing permanent disfigurations of which only some can somewhat be addressed via expensive and otherwise unnecessary surgeries down the line, is just straight up abuse.
@@ephemeraldisle so at what age can they start going into tanning beds? Get a body full of tattoos and pierce every place they can? What age can a girl get breast implants? If all her friends have breasts but she doesn't yet, is it abusive to tell her no, that she has to wait until she's an adult to get them done?
@@LizRealGirlBeauty I don't understand your point or line of questioning, your stated stance was people should reach adulthood with their bodies intact, right? If that's the case, you certainly would be agreeing with me that it's wrong to permanently disfigure girls by forcing them to go through a testosterone driven puberty.
I get the sense this is somewhat an exhausting topic for her to speak about, even keeping it as much a fact based conversation as she could. Like walking on eggshells. It's not attacking people because of not agreeing or seeing their perspective. Of coarse it can be, but when one is sure to be respectful towards others in general, we need to be able to speak to one another. Especially about such nuanced topics.
Who ever disputed that gender dysphoria was real? The problem is the definition being turned on its head. Gender dyspohoria is not "being born in the wrong body" - it is the psychiatric/psychological disorder of believing that to be true. As one clinical psychologist observed in the UK, how is it that the entire premise has been inverted and instead of treating the underlying psychological disorder, you alter the body to accomodate it? Now, imagine you were to treat an anorexic the same way, by affirming their 'fatness' instead of prescribing the correct and possibly life-saving course of action, all for the sake of fearing offense. The degree to which individuals, and indeed society, are capable of deluding themselves never ceases to amaze.
Transsexuality femininity in males and masculinity in females secondary sex characteristics lm trans
Wow, a two minute video generated this much drama...
We hope everyone watches the entire show.
@@WeTheInternetTV And.... where exactly is the "entire" show located? I wouldn't mind.
@@corruptparagon
check the link in the description
@@sunnyday4055 Where have I heard that line before?
To all the kids today who think this PC crowd isn't a fad, and that she is wrong about what we will think in 30 years, maybe listen to those of us old enough to remember 30 years ago. PC became a thing in the late 80s and 90s. And yes, we do look back on it and ask "what the F*** happened?"
.....and it wasn't even remotely as insane as your version.
@1:14 "There are no butches left to date" --- absolutely profound comment for anyone who is a lesbian.
This will not end well for anyone. I predict there will be a surge of regret due to people realizing that they had no idea what they were doing. Thing is - the push is on "believe" rather then hard science. Because feelings. This will be considered hate speech or transphobia by some.
It's already happening. Unfortunately once you've done this, especially at a young age, there's no going back. Best wishes
Doctors making money. Making terms up like gender identity. Doctors $$$$$$$$ no morals
There needs to be stricter requirements to medically transition. One of them should be socially transitioning for a set amount of time, to make sure that’s how they want to live.
Years of counselling and gender ldentity is rubbish male female not feeling
just wanna say welcome to Portland, hopefully all this political drama leaves and portland can be wierd and positive again
How about a digital viewing of "Five Reasons for HateSpeech"? Online Movie night?
Hmmm. That could be interesting.
@@WeTheInternetTV Please, I'd love this :')
I want to write a dissertation now on how gender dysphoria is killing off the modern lesbian lol.
The war between lesbians and the woke left is actually fascinating, I'm 100% for team Navratilova. When you base an ideology on identity and make victim-hood a commodity, then throw in a heavy dose of science denial to separate your movement from reality, it inevitably collapses. And in this case, it collapses in spectacular fashion.
Do it. Fight the worthy cause.
If you have a penis and are a woman and with someone who has a penis and is also a woman are you lesbian or homosexual?
@@DeconvertedMan Don't those two essentially mean the same thing? An attraction towards someone of the same sex? :/
Lolz I made a joke and it got removed immediately.
No one has to ask you which political ideology you offended to make your comment disappear.
Get used to it. It's getting worse.
I thought this channel of all channels would've been more pro free speech. It was a slightly offensive joke but not bad at all. Definitely not something that I would've thought would get deleted. Oh well.
Sometimes... Jokes get deleted by accident by the poster
@@peacheskong2245 _"Jokes get deleted by accident by the poster"_
You're cute. There are a whole pile of things you absolutely cannot post on UA-cam or the algorithms will auto-delete them.
And it is 100% political bias, else every single one of them wouldn't fall solidly on one political ideology.
For instance, try making a post that outlines FBI statistics on violent crime and the 'background' of the people who commit them (even this may be enough to get me purged).
Or here's an easy one, try posting the name of the CIA "whistleblower" who went to congress about the Ukraine phone-call. No content, just the guy's name, your post will immediately be deleted even though his name is public knowledge.
KEY WORD- A D U L T S
MEN & WOMEN. No knockoff wannabes
So is that really Nicholas Cage in the red suit?
The one and only.
Merci beaucoup katie !
I'm not sure if anyone wants to have a conversation about this (I hope you do) but I'm mtf trans and I didn't have "dysphoria" my whole life as explained in the video. The reason I transitioned was that it was essentially the only mental trick that allowed me to have any semblance of a life. I was in a complete pit. No motivation, no will to do anything. I was essentially letting myself slowly die because I just couldn't give a shit about my body. I know it's "wrong" biologically and that it is essentially a mental disorder that I want this but the simple fact is it turned my life around. I'm happy like I've never been before, I now have huge reserves of will power that I could only have dremt of before. I don't have the space here to go into why I have this disorder, but basically it comes down to the fact I was emotionally abused by parents and this is the pattern it created in me. I wish I was happy like this with my biological gender, I really do. This just works and I would rather deal with the health risks and stigma than be that useless sad blob of a person I was. Before anyone asks, yes I tried other things. I didn't want to be trans, I always thought they were stupid and hurting themselves due to a disorder as well so believe me, I tried a lot of shit before this. It's just..... the only thing that worked. If anyone actually reads this and wants to ask me anything I'd be happy to answer. Thanks for your time.
We're happy it worked for you.
@@WeTheInternetTV Thank you! Love the show, hope it gains more traction. Different and open opinions are going to be increasingly important as we head into the future.
Thank you for sharing honestly about your reasons and feelings. I'd be lying if I said this whole trans "movement"? (For lack of a better word) hasn't had me wondering and hypothesizing what it is that people are feeling that is leading so many to such drastic measures. Well regardless, nobody deserves to feel such a way that they hate themselves like that and I truly wish the best for everyone and I try to treat everyone as I would like in return. But you did at least partially enforce my personal theory that much, not all of "alternative lifestyles" (as we used to say) are often part to do with people suffering abuse of a certain nature especially and before they reach maturity. I believe it probably confuses the forming mind to the nature of attraction and things. But I never ever hear any people much less professionals even suggest such connection. Tho it seems to be the elephant in the room often. Idk what would be the answer regardless. But I believe that it is completely unacceptable how many young people are being subjected to who knows what when they are too little to protect themselves or even know to. It takes a village to raise a child and we have lost this in reality and are failing our future generations more and more. Just my thoughts. Take care.
If your trans you a masculinised woman. See masculinity is feeling Male female biological reality.
Kids are being indoctrinated and it's just wrong, absolutely wrong. If my son or daughter told me they wanted to be a girl or boy respectively, my response would be, if you still want this when you're 21 then fine, but whilst you're my responsibility it's not happening. I would pull them out of indoctrination classes in school, and they can say they hate me all they want. At the end of the day, when they become adults, they'll see I was doing the right thing.
@@jhnh78 I don't care, I'd do whatever I could to protect my child, even if that meant going to jail ... The authorities can go and take a long jump off a short pier ...
Very true.
Onya Katie.
Adults do have access to medical care. She means access to other people's services and money for free.
Taking care of each other is virtuous.
@@Quizoidno it’s not virtuous it doesn’t teach personal responsibility
welp guess this was the moment youtube decided to stop recommending this channel to people
The RATOPOLIS EFFECT is REAL!
We're going backwards.
So you’re saying we’ve transitioned from simple mental illness to full blown psychosis? Makes sense. Celebrate! YEA!!
We're evolving but just backwards
LOL
"adults should have access to medical care" - then they should pay for it or there should be charities that pay for it and people who believe in this as a cause should donate to those charities.
Don't think those charities will have enough money? Then spend your own time promoting those charities and help them raise funds.
Don't think you have a right to tax people for your medical needs. You don't.
Exactly. *Adults* who still feel gender dysphoria should be able to pursue transitions or whatever suits them. But children should not, because of the very real possibility (and, as she reports, 80% likelihood) that they'll grow out of it.
I, too, have heard anecdotal stories of people who transitioned too young, grew out of it, regretted it, and finally transition back (or try to afford to). That's a lot of trauma for them to go through.
Transition is impossible cannot change primary sex characteristics
Sounds like Katy's parents would've fucked it all up
"80% are growing out of this" does anyone have a source to this statement?
Yes. Thers is a video on youtube re this
I will look for it and send it to you
WHERE THE HELL ARE YOU GUYS??
2 Yrs and nothing?!?
Is this channel Kaput?
What da phuk is going on , if anything???
The fact that most of these people share the same diagnosis as me speaks a lot.
@Bruce Jenner Is Not A Woman autism.
I am diagnosed with high-functioning autism.
@Bruce Jenner Is Not A Woman I love how you never read my full comment and assume I was referring to my *DIAGNOSIS* as an illness.
But thank you for the opportunity to know what my mental disorder is
@Bruce Jenner Is Not A Woman how about say that next time?
I think the issues people might have with talking about the percentage of youg people who might feel gender dysphoria and grow out of might be that they think it trivialize transgenderism, and could be used as a excuse to right off real trans-people as ‘trans-trenders’.
Trendsgender
I don’t believe in real transgender. Two genders, that’s your lot in life, deal with it. Everybody has problems the grass is not greener on the other side of the fence.
Lorric Logging It’s about scientific facts, not what you believe.
Will Higgins look in your pants for science. There are two genders expressed in many ways, but boys are boys, girls are girls and nature asks you not to screw it up
@@HubertofLiege I think gender refers to the expression, whereas sex refers to the anatomy. So they say. But nature screws up sex, as you put it, in cases of hermaphroditism, 0.05% of the time. May not sound like much but that's alot of people
First
Sure you don’t want to transition into second? You can do that now, you know. You just have to say “I identify as second” and they’ll let you in the locker rooms and toilets of the seconds.
@@WouterCloetens Oh don't worry, I have surgery next week so I don't only identify as second but I'll be a second.
@@mr.mayonnaise2095 So you’re getting one added? Transition by addition?
@@WouterCloetens si
Please stop indulging mentally unwell people in their own delusions, have you seen their suicide rates? These people need real help like medication and therapy, they are very obviously dealing with a type of Body dysmorphic disorder, I wouldn’t be surprised if people had anorexia also have the disorder, that being said you wouldn’t encourage an anorexic person to just keep being anorexic, they need help, not encouragement to further mutilate themselves.
[CITATION NEEDED]
For an "equal opportunity" laughs place you guys sure do have conservative views.
Since when is being correct about everything "conservative"?
@@WeTheInternetTV So you're not biased just 'correct about everything?'
Correct.
@@WeTheInternetTV Wouln't you call that being bias? If I heard a liberal say "I'm always correct" I would be suspect!
Man-girl called Butch
Blue-girl called Smurf
Holland-girl called Dutch
This-girl called TERF
Transsexuality femininity in males and masculinity in females hormones feeling secondary sex characteristic
I'm hurt just listening to that crap my ears are bleeding
Unsubscribing because of this video how gross