You gained a sub I heard if you say a really good youtubers name 3 times in the comments you will get a pin Nostalgia Egg Nostalgia Egg Nostalgia Egg Did it work?
Considering how he played a role in some of my all-time favorite episodes, It's hard not to acknowledge him. The controversies aside I still think he was the best Mario recolor that wasn't SMG4 or SMG3.
Actually it was Peach. Lakitu being the second. Mario the third. And Toad being the fourth. Yet sadly most of them were flanderized and/or forgotten. Some became worse. Others are literally non-existent. That's the sad reality.
My reasons for rating the characters the way I did: SMG4 - Although he became a little bland during 2017 - 2019, I'd still consider him my personal favorite character in the entire series based off of his 2011 - 2016 appearances alone. Mario - Not all of his jokes land, But most of them do, And I enjoy how flexible his character can be depending on what episode he's in. SMG4 wouldn't be what is today without him. Luigi - He's one of the few classic era characters that actually got better in later years, Debut Luigi was basically an anti-hero that got treated unfairly while current Luigi is much more likable and not as much of a punching bag. Princess Peach - She was already unlikable during the classic era, Got slightly better in the randomness era, And became absolutely insufferable from 2019 onwards, She's by far the worst of the characters that still appear often. Yoshi - In hindsight, He's really unlikable and only has a handful of good appearances during 2015, 2016, and 2017, He's garbage in everything else before that, And after that. Toad - A bit of a controversial take, But while Toad during 2011 - 2013 is one of the series' best characters, None of his appearances since have really lived up to that standard, He's incredibly hit or miss and often fails to leave a lasting impression. He's the only one that receives the "Go now and never return" meme since he used to be fantastic. Toadsworth - I didn't like his debut, But all of his subsequent appearances have been pretty good. Toadette - In 2015 and 2016 she was ok, After that she became a less annoying version of Peach. Wario - I feel like he's often underutilized in the main episodes, But when he does have a solid role he knocks it out of the park. Waluigi - The Waluigi Arc alone was enough to bring him up to excellent status, But his appearances in the Wacky Wario Bros. series is also worth noting. Steve - Probably the only classic era character that has remained consistently fantastic since his debut Bowser - Part of me does miss his role in the classic era as the main villain, But his humor in the later episodes is some of best. Bowser Jr. - His debut was awful, Everything after that is forgettable. SMG3 - Current SMG3 is pretty unremarkable, But his roles in the 2011 - 2018 episodes are absolutely fantastic, Of all the recurring villains in SMG4 he is by far the most iconic and memorable one. Meggy Spletzer (Inking) - Probably the most influential character (That isn't Mario) in the entire series, She struck me as being an updated version of the X and Starman3 character type, Just with more depth than those two had. Even during my classic purist phase I still found her to be the best of the modern cast, I truly do miss the personality she brought to the series. Meggy Spletzer (Human) - While she's not quite as good as her inkling counterpart, I still think that Human Meggy has had a handful of fantastic appearances with Meggy's Destiny being at the top of that list, The only reason I'm ranking her lower is because she's not nearly as consistent and has had numerous bad appearances such as her roles in Boys VS Girls and DO NOT ENTER, But those aren't enough to completely ruin the great qualities that she still has. She has her moments from time to time. Tari - She was really good in the Waluigi Arc and has remained consistently decent since with her only real dud being 2019's The Big Bad Bully Saiko - I used to despise her character at first, But I now consider her to be the most consistent of the current main cast. She got much better once they dropped the "psycho" aspect of her character, Only Enzo could pull that one off. Melony - She was really bad prior to WOTFI 2021, I can't stand cutesy comedy in SMG4 and Melony was the embodiment of that. Her role in the Revelations arc was solid but I don't think it's enough for me to finalize my thoughts, I need to see more of her still. Desti - While her death was handled incredibly well, I think she works more as a plot motive than as an actual character, I respect her as Meggy's rival, But her personality was pretty bland up until her last few appearances. Ben - He was bad in his debut, And he never got better. I'm glad that he vanished after 2016. Axol - He was good in the Anime Arc, But I didn't care for any of his appearances after that, I also didn't have investment in his relationship with Melony since again, I can't stand cutesy comedy in SMG4. Between the two I think Desti was more effective overall. Chain Chomp - Since he's barely a character during the classic era, I have to base my opinion of him off of everything that proceeded it, Which is mostly just the "WTF is a Sonic?" joke that got stale after the second time it was used. If a character's gimmick is saying a single joke over and over, Then chances are that I dislike them. Chris - I consider him and Swag to be slightly overrated and I think they peaked in their respective series, But they're still really entertaining despite that. Swagmaster696969 - Everything I said for Chris applies to Swag as well. EpicYoshiFan - While he did play a role in some truly great episodes, I find that EpicYoshiFan is the least memorable out of the main Mario recolors, He doesn't hinder the experience by any means, But he doesn't offer anything either, Definitely the weakest link among the original main cast. Crazy Toilet Dude - The concept of an old man being obsessed with toilets is funny enough on its own, But his role in some of the classic episodes is typically very memorable. There's a reason why he's still talked about while Bot, John Gayhem, and Silent Guy have been forgotten. Princess Daisy - She was weird during the classic era, And has been perfectly ok since. Donkey Kong - I don't have anything to say about him other than that he's a fun antagonist in the Wacky Wario Bros. and Mario VS Donkey videos. Dr. Eggman - While he peaked in the Sonic The Derphog series, I do find most of Eggman's appearances to be really solid. Enzo - Pre-Birthday Freakout he was essentially a less prevalent version of Luigi, Post-Birthday Freakout he's my second favorite villain in the entire series, His whole motive for becoming a psycho murderer is some of the funniest writing. Starman3 - Controversies aside, He's one of the Top 10 (Possible Top 5) best characters in the entire series, And his presence, Although forced, Added a fantastic dynamic to the cast that elevated the later 2012 and early to mid 2013 episodes higher than what came before. That said, It is because of him that we never got to see characters like MCG, RM, MM54321, EpicYoshiFan, GD, and ADD in future episodes, And it's also because of his removal that we lost a lot of that original charm that was featured in most of those older episodes, But the downsides aren't enough to disregard the legacy of his character as a whole. Jacob Ware (Starman3 IRL) - If you want to know why Starman3 was axed from the series permanently despite his overall importance, Just look up Starman3 or Jacob Ware on UA-cam and prepare to feel disgusted. The Police - I always wondered why these guys vanished from the series, They were pretty good. FM - This is another controversial take, But while FM is a good character as a whole, He started becoming flanderized from 2013 onwards, He went from being the combat fighter of the original group to a bland semi-comic relief who also happens to be a police officer, He can still have his moments such as in the 10 Year Anniversary Special, But the rest of his later roles are forgettable. Fishy Boopkins - He was fine prior to the anime obsession, After that he became really hit or miss. Francis - My dislike for Francis has nothing to do with the events of The Anime Arc, In actuality it has to do with his jokes being really unfunny, I usually despise anime jokes in SMG4 and his character was the embodiment of that. Frankie - He's practically a less important and more comedic version of Luigi and Pre-Birthday Freakout Enzo, But he's consistently entertaining. Freddy Fazbear - I don't care for the series he stars in, And I don't find most of his jokes funny. Ganondorf - I'm only basing this ranking off of his debut appearance, I absolutely despised that text-to-speech voice he had. Admiral Greg - Solid comic relief in the G N' R series, I remember dying of laughter at his "box of hotdogs" line Hal Monitor - I don't get why so many people dislike him, He's not great by any means, But he's far from the worst character Isabelle - She had an interesting role in that one Shroomy episode, But that's about it. Jeeves - The definition of a meh tier character Jub Jub - He's Boopkins' brother, That's about it. Kaizo - I did sort of like how expressive he was during the miniature Saiko arc, But after that concluded he's been a filler character that has zero season to exist at this point. Karen - Probably the most pointless recent cast edition just behind Depresso, But she has some alright moments. King Pipe - It doesn't help that he's the main antagonist of one of my all time least favorite SMG4 episodes, But the fact that he's just a bland rehash of villains from the classic era makes him even more terrible. Kirby - He's consistently good in all of the videos he's been in, With the overall peak being 2016's Kirby Phones Home 1/2
Lakitu - While he hasn't been relevant since 2014 at the latest, Lakitu is the most unlikable of the original main cast, His whole character is based around him complaining about Mario and then torturing him for his own amusement, I'd normally be against retconning preestablished characters but in the case of Lakitu I'm glad that he never gets acknowledged and has been relegated to a background asset. His presence is not missed. MarioMario54321 - He was good for playing the role of the famous SM64 machinimist that SMG4 was aspiring to be, But is otherwise about as forgettable as EpicYoshiFan, He rarely showed up alongside the rest of the group and when he did, He didn't offer much. Sergeant Mark - Everything I said for Admiral Greg applies to Sergeant Mark as well MCGustavo - He's not quite on the same level as X and FM, But he's better than EpicYoshiFan, MM54321, and the other recolors I didn't name. The only reason why I didn't rate him higher is because he's pretty flat as a character and can only work within group settings. Metal Mario - His only role in the series was that he yelled at SMG4 and crew for stealing his rock collection, But that was decently entertaining I guess. Santa Claus - I really liked his portrayals in the 2011 and 2015 Christmas episodes, Which is why I approved him. Notch - In hindsight, I don't know why I included him in this video over GD, ADD, Bot, Silent Guy, Old Man, ect. His only trait was being a creep that the characters would freak out over. Professor E. Gadd - He was already a decent minor character during the classic era, But he became quite good from 2016 onwards. Rob - I don't understand why he still exists in the series, His whole character is revolved around him saying and doing stuff related to corn. He's not particularly funny and his presence bores me. The Rock Wizard - While his role in the series has substantially decreased over the last few years, His appearances during the classic and randomness eras were always great. Rosalina - Between the three princess characters, I think Rosalina is by far the best and I wouldn't mind seeing her return in the future. I don't understand why she disappeared Ruffman8890 - He showcased some potential during his debut appearance, But later became another stock Mario recolor that only excelled in episodes that were group centric. Shrek (In a Soup) - By far my least favorite joke in the entire series Shroomy - I don't like him quite as much as everyone else does, But I do find his backstory to be interesting at the very least. He has the potential to be great but he doesn't get used as much as he probably should. Slenderman - I'm honestly surprised that Slenderman was never forgotten about, Not that I'm complaining cause he's one of my favorite side characters. It also helps that he stars in my all time favorite episode 2012's My Best Friend Slenderman SLG4 - He's a good antagonist, But his time was cut off short before he could really become something on the level of Enzo, I'd love to see him brought back even though the chances of that happening are next to impossible. SMG0 - People pointed out that I forgot Niles in this video so I'll say my thoughts on both him and SMG0 here, They are both good arc centric characters that managed to turn one of the blandest villains in SMG4 into one of the most defining. SMG1 and SMG2 - Prior to the Genesis Arc they were annoying, Post Genesis Arc they're just alright SMG1 (SuperMegaGangsta1) - Good antagonist for the S.M.G Club episode, I remember liking the twist of finding out that the SMG1 abbreviation stands for SuperMegaGangsta Enter X - For being the first non-Bowser related antagonist in the series, X does a solid job. His gimmick is quite interesting. Bob - This is yet another controversial take, But I thought Bob was absolutely terrible up until late-2017, His "noticed me" joke was the only thing that defined him early on and it got annoying real fast, It wasn't until The Rapper Bob Arc where he started to become more than tolerable. Belle - She had the potential to be a recurring rival for Tari, But they've done absolutely nothing of note with her since The UA-cam Arc ended. Sonic The Hedgehog - The most underrated character in the series, I loved his role in Sonic The Derphog and I feel like he still has a ton of potential. Dr. Pootis - One of the only post-2013 comic reliefs that I liked, Even though his whole character is based on using Heavy sound clips. Heavy - Him and Dr. Pootis have the same gimmick, But they're both really entertaining. Stu and Pid - Probably some of my favorite one-time characters in SMG4, It's a crime that they didn't get brought back while Pete The Skeleton did, Their humor was so much funnier in comparison. Susan Wojcicki - About as unlikable as the actual UA-cam CEO, I understand that is supposed to be the point of her character, But it doesn't make her any less insufferable. Teletubbies - On the lesser scale of classic comic reliefs, But they're still relatively solid. Toast Guy - I don't find his jokes quite as bad as some of the other one-trick-ponies, But he's still never been all that funny. Villager - Not as great as Enzo, But still a solid minor antagonist. Weegee - I never understood the appeal of him, His jokes got old quickly for me. No idea why SMG4 decided that he was funny enough to have multiple episodes center around his existence. Weegee Doll - He's a decent antagonist in the Luigi Labyrinth and Luigi Uprising episodes, But is forgettable outside of that. Whimpu - While I understand that the point of his character is to be a pathetic loser, I still don't find him enjoyable in the slightest. X - Like I said for FM, X during the 2011 - 2013 episodes is a really good character, But he's progressively gotten more and more flanderized as time has gone on. Without watching those videos you would have forgotten that he was more than just the WOTFI host, He went from being a straightman type that had a knack for hunting zombies to a less interesting version of SMG4. He also has decent appearances from time to time, But he's still nowhere near what he used to be. Chica - While I can understand people liking other one-trick-pony characters like Chain Chomp and Toast Guy, I have no clue what the appeal is for Chica, The "pizza" line is the most played out gag in the entire series, It wasn't funny the first time, And it became completely unbearable after the first one hundred. Out of all the terrible characters I put in this lineup, Chica is by far the worst. Sans - He was fine in the Undertale episode, But is mostly unfunny outside of that. Ztar - Bad stars is a solid duology, And that's about it. 2/2
@Nostalgia Egg I 100% agree with you on Sonics case. He's one of the only modern characters (despite him being introduced to the series in 2011), that has barely any appearances, if at all. He did have a major role in the Sonic Movie recreations. I bet we'll see another one in 2024.
@@JasonSmith-dg1xf My favorite SMG4 episode of all time is My Best Friend Slenderman from 2012, I absolutely adore classic SMG4. But I don't consider Who Let The Chomp Out? apart of the classic era, It's from the randomness era.
@@TheColdfrontCommander Despite that videos' high view count I think Freddy's spaghettria was the more influential of the two since that one was literally everywhere, But both of them did play a part in making SMG4 what it is today, Though in fairness I think Who Let The Chomp Out? is a much better video than Freddy's spaghettria.
@@David_28050 Meggy: Inkling version is one of the best and most influential SMG4 characters, Human version has had some fantastic moments, But is very inconsistent. Tari: Her debut in the Waluigi Arc was really good, Everything after that has been consistently decent. Saiko: She was pretty bad at first, But started improving after The Rapper Bob Arc
Yeah the dude tricked me into believing that he’s changed….. and I believed it for over a year. Plus he literally blamed my mother over my personal problems what a piece of shit.
I haven't watched SMG4 for a couple of years now so I may be out of the loop, but during the time I was an active viewer I can guarantee you 90% of arguments in the comments of a video were related to 2:48 somehow. You could've sworn Meggy was a political figure with how radically divided opinions on her were.
The koopalings and bowser would definitely fight with jr and bowser jr is able to get luigi and melony to join them by staging a coup de etat in both weegeepie and melonyvideotime :D
I liked some of the jokes surrounding melony but looking back I didn’t like the direction of 2021’s arc took her in as it felt like anime. I don’t really like anime and I don’t think that’s a direction the channel should head.
Chris and Swagmaster getting approved. I agree, best underated characters, i honestly think they are better thannthe core cast old and new. (Just opinion, they are all good)
Personally, I started watching smg4 towards the end of 2014, and there are characters I don't really miss... Apart from Bowser, who had a pleasant personality and was pretty funny, other characters ended up being forgettable over time, always having the same running gags Peach is just a character who's angry all the time about anything, just that it's fun to see her get bashed And Toad... he's just a terrible person... all his faults are scattered throughout the smg4 gang (no bravery being Tari, egoism being Bob, laziness being Melony and addiction to a food is Mario) but unlike those characters, he has no qualities and is not lovable by the other characters. On the other hand, I hope to see an evolution in Tari's character, who hasn't had much importance since Waluigi arc, and more scenes with Melony, as she hasn't been around much since Revelations, especially as I like her a lot... cause my favorite smg4 videos are often when almost all the smg4 gang interact with each other and have fun or adventures/dramas, it's not the best video of 2023 I think but I loved for example the episode "The very safe & legal smg4 show" As for Axol, he was one of my favorite characters because he may not have been the funniest or the most remarkable, but he's the nicest guy for me and greatly influenced the other characters (especially Melony and Meggy). I find modern characters more enjoyable after WOTFI 2021
3:23 I don't really like melony. All she did until the SMG0 arc was act cute and sleep Kevin focused so much on making a watermelon frickable that he forgot to make her actually something decent
tbh your spittin facts melony was really just a funny little side character but when they made her like a "main character" her funny really just disappeared which really just made her character feel you know empty
Funny thing is that's the exact reason why he didn't get improved, Because he was only great during the classic era 2011 - 2013 and has been a hit or miss character since.
Melony being "cute and innocent" isn't enough to say that she's a good character, I don't necessarily think those sorts of characters work with SMG4. But that's just me, She got better later on which is why I didn't outright disprove her.
The reason why knuckles made sans illegal is because of how the undertale community used to be (or it could just be that sans doesn’t have much of a role in the series)
Time for a random comment SML VS SMG4 Still good contact: smg4 Many controversies: SML Favorite characters: Tie Worst characters of all time: SML Toxic Fandom: tie Best characters of all time: tie Serious stories: smg4 (because it has many serious storylines) Amazing old videos: smg4 (and still like old Sml as well) Really funny Contant: Smg4 The creator: smg4 Annoying characters: sml Free points: Sml Who got sued by Nintendo in reality: sml Most tragic downfall: sml Still makes Mario videos: smg4 Villains: Smg4 (kinda) Likable characters: smg4 (not the most likable characters but kinda likable then Mario, JR and Joseph except Brooklyn guy) Who won: SMG4 EDIT April 16: I think I should remake this comment
I'd say that SML's fandom during its peak was ten times worse than what the SMG4 fanbase became, The SML fandom has mostly died following Logan's switch to using the puppets. But prior to that it was infuriatingly terrible.
@@NostalgiaEgg I’m a SML fan as well, I like both of these channels the most problems are SML I don’t even see Sml for some reason I don’t know why but I think both of there fandom are toxic the smg4 Community is really split other side is who people who still like smg4, still love meggy, and love every video on the other side is that people don’t like smg4, thinks that Meggy or Kevin ruined SMG4, Despise human Meggy so much, don’t like new videos that has new characters, and people think that smg4 is greedy even though there kinda no proof of that and SML…nah I think u already know other side people love Jeffy and attack people that don’t like jeffy and the other side people hate jeffy don’t like the new videos and slowly not liking SML…and dubdude Literally yelled at people saying the word “SML” and make Livestreams 24/7. Both of the fandom are toxic. THAT A FACT!
@@Vinsalazar19 I'm not disagreeing that both of the fanbases are toxic, I'm just saying that the SML fandom during 2017 - 2019 was on another level of terrible. Back in those days there was major drama and serious allegations every other week, It got so terrible to the point where it completely collapsed on itself and decayed in relevance due to how unstable it was. Admittedly I've only been in the SMG4 fandom since 2019, But nothing I've seen comes close to the Dean VS GCD, FlameyCat, Davidplex, and especially the Shawn Mays drama. Everyone involved is still feeling the effects of that mess to this day. It was that crazy.
I feel like sml was enjoyable when I was little. I feel like id cringe looking at him now. Smg4 rn is just mid and nothing more. I watched this man cause I want to laugh and not cry. Like as soon as they started pulling this Persona 4 shit with Meggy they instantly lost me. Like I look back at his retarded series (don't hate me thats what they were called back in the day. People didn't take offence to the word retarded. Grow up people!) they had some actually funny stuff. I go back to those videos and said to myself "Man I miss the good ole UA-cam days." Those days we're the best. The days where everyone wasn't offended about every little thing. I genuinely feel the change in writing direction is due to how the way modern society is. Or at least American Society. Nowadays you can't say retarded and not get hate.
My opinion: Still good content: SML. Many controversies: SML. Favorite characters: Tied. Worst characters 9f all time: SMG4. Toxic fandom: SMG4. Best characters of all time: SMG4. Serious stories: SML because it's not stupid unlike SMG4. Amazing old videos: vkth. Really funny content: SML. The creator: SMG4. Annoying characters: SMG4. Free points: SML. Who got sued: SML. Most tragic downfall: SMG4. Still makes Mario videos: This is unfair. Villains: Ifk. Likable characters: Idk. Who won: SML.
Quality Meme Ranks (best to worst): Platinum Diamond Gold Silver Bronze Marble Stone Whatever paperclips are made from Wood Fabric Plastic Paper Trash Human waste Urinium (not Uranium)
honorable mentions/other characters (My opinion, I am starting to rewatch the old episodes) Also I find all the mario recolors to be very funny and awesome but starman3 has drama Old man pokemon sprite: Probably wasn't all that good but it was approved Old mario (smg4 mario from before 2014 or before the modern videos) Approved excellent multiple times John ham (too offensive today to say the part before ham): Approved Bots: Very simple characters but still approved (the part where the whole battlefield attacks them is hilarious) more coming soon
You gained a sub
I heard if you say a really good youtubers name 3 times in the comments you will get a pin
Nostalgia Egg
Nostalgia Egg
Nostalgia Egg
Did it work?
Indeed it did
200 iq
Man it actually worked
glazer
@@certainfriends no I’m not (I made a new channel btw)
You had the balls to put starman in there. Approved.
Considering how he played a role in some of my all-time favorite episodes, It's hard not to acknowledge him.
The controversies aside I still think he was the best Mario recolor that wasn't SMG4 or SMG3.
@@NostalgiaEgg Well…. this was before I knew about SMG4.
WTF happened with starman?
@@TheBerryVids420 I don't know the whole thing, but apparently he was grooming smg4.
@@Randowave Jesus Christ...
Chris & Swagmaster6969696969 being deemed excellent brings a smile to my face!
Hands down best characters alongside bob
I like how knuckles made it illegal to use the CEO of UA-cam, like he doesn't know what's about to happen to him.
UA-cam: YOU KNOW WHAT HAPPENS NOW!!
Why was the first thing to pop into my head Dave from day shift at Freddy going you what
Oh hey remember me?
@@Mapple318 no
@@SonicEXEProductions not you
This meme will never get old
It hasn't died because knuckles keeps approving the meme
It will die when someone removes him from office
Just got old.
It's because it's a excellent meme approved
I once sew someone who said the same thing, 5 months later it died
How unfortunate. Lakitu was amongst the first SMG4 characters to ever be onscreen.
Actually it was Peach.
Lakitu being the second.
Mario the third.
And Toad being the fourth.
Yet sadly most of them were flanderized and/or forgotten.
Some became worse.
Others are literally non-existent.
That's the sad reality.
Great video. Its rare to see someone looking into these characters for themselves instead of just shitting on the OC’s. Meme Approved.
5:21
Knuckles just Approved Eggman as It's is your enemy
Eggman has personality
He approved it better than Sonic.
Me: sees Inkling Meggy get a better approval than Human Meggy
Also me: And that's why I believe in Inkling Meggy supremacy
Should’ve either given them the same approval or ranked only one version since they’re the same character
MEGGY IS MEGGY
@@astraljava8500
Agreed, but I still prefer Inkling Meggy
Oh god I thought you were gonna say animae meggy was better it ruined the franchise
O ye
3:27 is so true, due to melony’ design being like an anime girl yet is good makes her not good or bad
My reasons for rating the characters the way I did:
SMG4 - Although he became a little bland during 2017 - 2019, I'd still consider him my personal favorite character in the entire series based off of his 2011 - 2016 appearances alone.
Mario - Not all of his jokes land, But most of them do, And I enjoy how flexible his character can be depending on what episode he's in. SMG4 wouldn't be what is today without him.
Luigi - He's one of the few classic era characters that actually got better in later years, Debut Luigi was basically an anti-hero that got treated unfairly while current Luigi is much more likable and not as much of a punching bag.
Princess Peach - She was already unlikable during the classic era, Got slightly better in the randomness era, And became absolutely insufferable from 2019 onwards, She's by far the worst of the characters that still appear often.
Yoshi - In hindsight, He's really unlikable and only has a handful of good appearances during 2015, 2016, and 2017, He's garbage in everything else before that, And after that.
Toad - A bit of a controversial take, But while Toad during 2011 - 2013 is one of the series' best characters, None of his appearances since have really lived up to that standard, He's incredibly hit or miss and often fails to leave a lasting impression. He's the only one that receives the "Go now and never return" meme since he used to be fantastic.
Toadsworth - I didn't like his debut, But all of his subsequent appearances have been pretty good.
Toadette - In 2015 and 2016 she was ok, After that she became a less annoying version of Peach.
Wario - I feel like he's often underutilized in the main episodes, But when he does have a solid role he knocks it out of the park.
Waluigi - The Waluigi Arc alone was enough to bring him up to excellent status, But his appearances in the Wacky Wario Bros. series is also worth noting.
Steve - Probably the only classic era character that has remained consistently fantastic since his debut
Bowser - Part of me does miss his role in the classic era as the main villain, But his humor in the later episodes is some of best.
Bowser Jr. - His debut was awful, Everything after that is forgettable.
SMG3 - Current SMG3 is pretty unremarkable, But his roles in the 2011 - 2018 episodes are absolutely fantastic, Of all the recurring villains in SMG4 he is by far the most iconic and memorable one.
Meggy Spletzer (Inking) - Probably the most influential character (That isn't Mario) in the entire series, She struck me as being an updated version of the X and Starman3 character type, Just with more depth than those two had. Even during my classic purist phase I still found her to be the best of the modern cast, I truly do miss the personality she brought to the series.
Meggy Spletzer (Human) - While she's not quite as good as her inkling counterpart, I still think that Human Meggy has had a handful of fantastic appearances with Meggy's Destiny being at the top of that list, The only reason I'm ranking her lower is because she's not nearly as consistent and has had numerous bad appearances such as her roles in Boys VS Girls and DO NOT ENTER, But those aren't enough to completely ruin the great qualities that she still has. She has her moments from time to time.
Tari - She was really good in the Waluigi Arc and has remained consistently decent since with her only real dud being 2019's The Big Bad Bully
Saiko - I used to despise her character at first, But I now consider her to be the most consistent of the current main cast. She got much better once they dropped the "psycho" aspect of her character, Only Enzo could pull that one off.
Melony - She was really bad prior to WOTFI 2021, I can't stand cutesy comedy in SMG4 and Melony was the embodiment of that. Her role in the Revelations arc was solid but I don't think it's enough for me to finalize my thoughts, I need to see more of her still.
Desti - While her death was handled incredibly well, I think she works more as a plot motive than as an actual character, I respect her as Meggy's rival, But her personality was pretty bland up until her last few appearances.
Ben - He was bad in his debut, And he never got better. I'm glad that he vanished after 2016.
Axol - He was good in the Anime Arc, But I didn't care for any of his appearances after that, I also didn't have investment in his relationship with Melony since again, I can't stand cutesy comedy in SMG4. Between the two I think Desti was more effective overall.
Chain Chomp - Since he's barely a character during the classic era, I have to base my opinion of him off of everything that proceeded it, Which is mostly just the "WTF is a Sonic?" joke that got stale after the second time it was used. If a character's gimmick is saying a single joke over and over, Then chances are that I dislike them.
Chris - I consider him and Swag to be slightly overrated and I think they peaked in their respective series, But they're still really entertaining despite that.
Swagmaster696969 - Everything I said for Chris applies to Swag as well.
EpicYoshiFan - While he did play a role in some truly great episodes, I find that EpicYoshiFan is the least memorable out of the main Mario recolors, He doesn't hinder the experience by any means, But he doesn't offer anything either, Definitely the weakest link among the original main cast.
Crazy Toilet Dude - The concept of an old man being obsessed with toilets is funny enough on its own, But his role in some of the classic episodes is typically very memorable. There's a reason why he's still talked about while Bot, John Gayhem, and Silent Guy have been forgotten.
Princess Daisy - She was weird during the classic era, And has been perfectly ok since.
Donkey Kong - I don't have anything to say about him other than that he's a fun antagonist in the Wacky Wario Bros. and Mario VS Donkey videos.
Dr. Eggman - While he peaked in the Sonic The Derphog series, I do find most of Eggman's appearances to be really solid.
Enzo - Pre-Birthday Freakout he was essentially a less prevalent version of Luigi, Post-Birthday Freakout he's my second favorite villain in the entire series, His whole motive for becoming a psycho murderer is some of the funniest writing.
Starman3 - Controversies aside, He's one of the Top 10 (Possible Top 5) best characters in the entire series, And his presence, Although forced, Added a fantastic dynamic to the cast that elevated the later 2012 and early to mid 2013 episodes higher than what came before. That said, It is because of him that we never got to see characters like MCG, RM, MM54321, EpicYoshiFan, GD, and ADD in future episodes, And it's also because of his removal that we lost a lot of that original charm that was featured in most of those older episodes, But the downsides aren't enough to disregard the legacy of his character as a whole.
Jacob Ware (Starman3 IRL) - If you want to know why Starman3 was axed from the series permanently despite his overall importance, Just look up Starman3 or Jacob Ware on UA-cam and prepare to feel disgusted.
The Police - I always wondered why these guys vanished from the series, They were pretty good.
FM - This is another controversial take, But while FM is a good character as a whole, He started becoming flanderized from 2013 onwards, He went from being the combat fighter of the original group to a bland semi-comic relief who also happens to be a police officer, He can still have his moments such as in the 10 Year Anniversary Special, But the rest of his later roles are forgettable.
Fishy Boopkins - He was fine prior to the anime obsession, After that he became really hit or miss.
Francis - My dislike for Francis has nothing to do with the events of The Anime Arc, In actuality it has to do with his jokes being really unfunny, I usually despise anime jokes in SMG4 and his character was the embodiment of that.
Frankie - He's practically a less important and more comedic version of Luigi and Pre-Birthday Freakout Enzo, But he's consistently entertaining.
Freddy Fazbear - I don't care for the series he stars in, And I don't find most of his jokes funny.
Ganondorf - I'm only basing this ranking off of his debut appearance, I absolutely despised that text-to-speech voice he had.
Admiral Greg - Solid comic relief in the G N' R series, I remember dying of laughter at his "box of hotdogs" line
Hal Monitor - I don't get why so many people dislike him, He's not great by any means, But he's far from the worst character
Isabelle - She had an interesting role in that one Shroomy episode, But that's about it.
Jeeves - The definition of a meh tier character
Jub Jub - He's Boopkins' brother, That's about it.
Kaizo - I did sort of like how expressive he was during the miniature Saiko arc, But after that concluded he's been a filler character that has zero season to exist at this point.
Karen - Probably the most pointless recent cast edition just behind Depresso, But she has some alright moments.
King Pipe - It doesn't help that he's the main antagonist of one of my all time least favorite SMG4 episodes, But the fact that he's just a bland rehash of villains from the classic era makes him even more terrible.
Kirby - He's consistently good in all of the videos he's been in, With the overall peak being 2016's Kirby Phones Home
1/2
Lakitu - While he hasn't been relevant since 2014 at the latest, Lakitu is the most unlikable of the original main cast, His whole character is based around him complaining about Mario and then torturing him for his own amusement, I'd normally be against retconning preestablished characters but in the case of Lakitu I'm glad that he never gets acknowledged and has been relegated to a background asset. His presence is not missed.
MarioMario54321 - He was good for playing the role of the famous SM64 machinimist that SMG4 was aspiring to be, But is otherwise about as forgettable as EpicYoshiFan, He rarely showed up alongside the rest of the group and when he did, He didn't offer much.
Sergeant Mark - Everything I said for Admiral Greg applies to Sergeant Mark as well
MCGustavo - He's not quite on the same level as X and FM, But he's better than EpicYoshiFan, MM54321, and the other recolors I didn't name. The only reason why I didn't rate him higher is because he's pretty flat as a character and can only work within group settings.
Metal Mario - His only role in the series was that he yelled at SMG4 and crew for stealing his rock collection, But that was decently entertaining I guess.
Santa Claus - I really liked his portrayals in the 2011 and 2015 Christmas episodes, Which is why I approved him.
Notch - In hindsight, I don't know why I included him in this video over GD, ADD, Bot, Silent Guy, Old Man, ect. His only trait was being a creep that the characters would freak out over.
Professor E. Gadd - He was already a decent minor character during the classic era, But he became quite good from 2016 onwards.
Rob - I don't understand why he still exists in the series, His whole character is revolved around him saying and doing stuff related to corn. He's not particularly funny and his presence bores me.
The Rock Wizard - While his role in the series has substantially decreased over the last few years, His appearances during the classic and randomness eras were always great.
Rosalina - Between the three princess characters, I think Rosalina is by far the best and I wouldn't mind seeing her return in the future. I don't understand why she disappeared
Ruffman8890 - He showcased some potential during his debut appearance, But later became another stock Mario recolor that only excelled in episodes that were group centric.
Shrek (In a Soup) - By far my least favorite joke in the entire series
Shroomy - I don't like him quite as much as everyone else does, But I do find his backstory to be interesting at the very least. He has the potential to be great but he doesn't get used as much as he probably should.
Slenderman - I'm honestly surprised that Slenderman was never forgotten about, Not that I'm complaining cause he's one of my favorite side characters. It also helps that he stars in my all time favorite episode 2012's My Best Friend Slenderman
SLG4 - He's a good antagonist, But his time was cut off short before he could really become something on the level of Enzo, I'd love to see him brought back even though the chances of that happening are next to impossible.
SMG0 - People pointed out that I forgot Niles in this video so I'll say my thoughts on both him and SMG0 here, They are both good arc centric characters that managed to turn one of the blandest villains in SMG4 into one of the most defining.
SMG1 and SMG2 - Prior to the Genesis Arc they were annoying, Post Genesis Arc they're just alright
SMG1 (SuperMegaGangsta1) - Good antagonist for the S.M.G Club episode, I remember liking the twist of finding out that the SMG1 abbreviation stands for SuperMegaGangsta
Enter X - For being the first non-Bowser related antagonist in the series, X does a solid job. His gimmick is quite interesting.
Bob - This is yet another controversial take, But I thought Bob was absolutely terrible up until late-2017, His "noticed me" joke was the only thing that defined him early on and it got annoying real fast, It wasn't until The Rapper Bob Arc where he started to become more than tolerable.
Belle - She had the potential to be a recurring rival for Tari, But they've done absolutely nothing of note with her since The UA-cam Arc ended.
Sonic The Hedgehog - The most underrated character in the series, I loved his role in Sonic The Derphog and I feel like he still has a ton of potential.
Dr. Pootis - One of the only post-2013 comic reliefs that I liked, Even though his whole character is based on using Heavy sound clips.
Heavy - Him and Dr. Pootis have the same gimmick, But they're both really entertaining.
Stu and Pid - Probably some of my favorite one-time characters in SMG4, It's a crime that they didn't get brought back while Pete The Skeleton did, Their humor was so much funnier in comparison.
Susan Wojcicki - About as unlikable as the actual UA-cam CEO, I understand that is supposed to be the point of her character, But it doesn't make her any less insufferable.
Teletubbies - On the lesser scale of classic comic reliefs, But they're still relatively solid.
Toast Guy - I don't find his jokes quite as bad as some of the other one-trick-ponies, But he's still never been all that funny.
Villager - Not as great as Enzo, But still a solid minor antagonist.
Weegee - I never understood the appeal of him, His jokes got old quickly for me. No idea why SMG4 decided that he was funny enough to have multiple episodes center around his existence.
Weegee Doll - He's a decent antagonist in the Luigi Labyrinth and Luigi Uprising episodes, But is forgettable outside of that.
Whimpu - While I understand that the point of his character is to be a pathetic loser, I still don't find him enjoyable in the slightest.
X - Like I said for FM, X during the 2011 - 2013 episodes is a really good character, But he's progressively gotten more and more flanderized as time has gone on. Without watching those videos you would have forgotten that he was more than just the WOTFI host, He went from being a straightman type that had a knack for hunting zombies to a less interesting version of SMG4. He also has decent appearances from time to time, But he's still nowhere near what he used to be.
Chica - While I can understand people liking other one-trick-pony characters like Chain Chomp and Toast Guy, I have no clue what the appeal is for Chica, The "pizza" line is the most played out gag in the entire series, It wasn't funny the first time, And it became completely unbearable after the first one hundred. Out of all the terrible characters I put in this lineup, Chica is by far the worst.
Sans - He was fine in the Undertale episode, But is mostly unfunny outside of that.
Ztar - Bad stars is a solid duology, And that's about it.
2/2
Niles?
Axol was really good even After the Anime arc but i didnt like how it turned out After His melony relationship
@Nostalgia Egg
I 100% agree with you on Sonics case. He's one of the only modern characters (despite him being introduced to the series in 2011), that has barely any appearances, if at all. He did have a major role in the Sonic Movie recreations. I bet we'll see another one in 2024.
Why you gotta do Karen like that man she's a great character and her relationship with JubJub is adorable
Truly a masterful piece of art
One character Knuckles forgot in this video: Niles, the guy who possessed SMG0 and did all the bad things to the universes.
He's Ateoses
@@MothyTD excuse me? Who is scoliosis?
I'm pretty sure Niles would be multiple times illegal
@@EXPeepik I had one hand available I was trying to type atrocious
He would be so illegal no number could quantify it
Question: Is this based off your opinion on the characters, or is it based on their morality?
Opinion
Y.y. yo....
You dont like the i like toast shy guy
@@NostalgiaEgg called it
@@NostalgiaEgg I was kinda sad that u hated chain chomp but its u not me
@@NostalgiaEgg I just realized: this is the only video Waluigi doesn't get rejected in.
*sees SMG3 getting approved*
My mission is accomplished , I can die peacefully
Agreed.
Backstory: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Awesomeness: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Power: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Development into a friend overtime: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Jokes: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
The lighting is so good on the characters
this legend had the courage to say axol wasn't all that good but was approved anyways. I salute your bravery
Nah axol is an excellent meme I disapprove
Yeah, how dare he???
Lemme try to be knuckles real quick. Excellent MEME. Approved
realy happy to see some obscure character such as Enzo
Who let the chomp out was the 1st SMG4 video I’d ever watched, so it’s sad to see it like this :(
I never cared for Who Let The Chomp Out?, I don't dislike it as much as I used to but it still doesn't do anything for me.
@@NostalgiaEgg HEY THIS MF DONT LIKE CLASSIC SMG4 VIDEOS
@@JasonSmith-dg1xf My favorite SMG4 episode of all time is My Best Friend Slenderman from 2012, I absolutely adore classic SMG4. But I don't consider Who Let The Chomp Out? apart of the classic era, It's from the randomness era.
@@NostalgiaEgg you still have to give who let the chomp out? A lot of credit as it drew a lot of people in
@@TheColdfrontCommander Despite that videos' high view count I think Freddy's spaghettria was the more influential of the two since that one was literally everywhere, But both of them did play a part in making SMG4 what it is today, Though in fairness I think Who Let The Chomp Out? is a much better video than Freddy's spaghettria.
Melony in WOTFI 2021: Literally a goddess and has a freaking sword
Melony After WOTFI 2021: i slep
And after revelations
I like how the cops came after Jacob Ware.
Interesting
Oh really?
stahp.right.there
Damn knuckles got good taste
OOoOoOoOoooOoooOoOoOoOoO
He does for some of the characthers, but liking meggy, tari and saiko? Damn.
@@David_28050
Meggy: Inkling version is one of the best and most influential SMG4 characters, Human version has had some fantastic moments, But is very inconsistent.
Tari: Her debut in the Waluigi Arc was really good, Everything after that has been consistently decent.
Saiko: She was pretty bad at first, But started improving after The Rapper Bob Arc
@@NostalgiaEgg you made chain chomp illegal but why, it’s the reason for smg4 most viewed video!!!!!
Knuckles has great taste in characters, I approve of this
Knuckles when SMG4 Peach: N O M E M E
4:43 Oh god I bet most people won't even know who that is. Such an ancient character in SMG4 history.
Bob was always a good character and whenever he’s on screen I just am happy to see what he does
Watching this I'm just like "Who are some of these characters!?"
same
YOU GO WATCH SMG4
Chill out my guy there's like a thousand episodes
0:01 SMG4
0:11 mario
0:22 luigi
0:30 princess peach
0:45 yoshi
0:58 toad
1:11 toadsworth
1:20 toadette
1:34 wario
1:45 waluigi
1:57 steve
2:08 bowser
2:18 bowser. Jr
2:34 SMG3
2:44 inkling meggy spletzer
2:55 human meggy spletzer
3:05 tari
3:12 saiko bichitaru
3:20 melony
3:31 desti
3:39 ben
3:52 axol
4:00 chain chomp
4:13 chris
4:25 swagmaster
4:36 EpicYoshifan
4:43 crazy toilet dude
4:54 princess daisy
5:05 donkey kong
5:13 dr. Eggman/robotnik
5:24 enzo
5:36 starman3
5:42 starman3 IRL
5:49 police officer
5:57 FM [fightermario]
6:04 fishy boopkins
6:12 francis
6:26 frankie
6:34 freddy fazbear
6:49 ganondorf
7:03 admiral greg
7:11 hal monitor
7:21 isabelle
7:29 jeeves
7:35 jub jub boopkins
7:46 kaizo
7:55 karen
8:03 king pipe
8:16 kirby
8:24 lakitu
8:40 mariomario54321
8:46 sergeant mark
8:53 MCGustavo
9:00 silver mario
9:07 santa claus
9:15 notch
9:22 E. Gadd
9:30 rob the scarecrow
9:41 the rock wizard
9:52 princess rosalina
10:01 ruffman8890
10:07 shrek
10:21 shroomy
10:29 slenderman
10:41 SLG4
10:50 SMG0
10:57 SMG1 & SMG2
11:04 SMG1
11:13 enter X
11:20 bob bobowski
11:27 belle fontiere
11:34 sonic the hedgehog
11:43 dr. Pootis
11:52 heavy weapons guy
11:59 stu & pid
12:07 susan
12:21 teletubbies
12:29 toast guy
12:44 villager
12:52 weegee
13:07 weegee doll
13:13 whimpu
13:28 X [Xboxfan]
13:36 withered chica
13:50 sans the skeleton
14:04 Ztar
The one after SMG1 and SMG2 is the original SMG1 (SuperMegaGangster1) from the S.M.G Club episode
11:05 SMG1 original, club SMG
@@NostalgiaEgg thxi fixed it
12:07 susan: that’s it! I’m banning this UA-camr from UA-cam for life!
4:10 bro how could you! The chain chomp is a Classic!
This man knows everyone from the smg4 universe
And that’s because he been a fan since 2012
-Swag are u see this?
-OMG CHRIS WE ARE MEMES WE CAN LEAVE A SPAGHETTI FACTORY FINALLY!!!!
11:36 if only he approved himself he would’ve gone mad with power
That’s sonic tho,how do you not know that
Of course he needs to get approved he is the reason for even him to be horned 💀
Good ending
Dont worry guys hes still CEO of memes and UA-cam
He just went to a vacation
Wundervoll That Eggman/Robotnik was approved by…
…himself…
Oh well Cant blame him he’s a good character!
This is what the internet was made for
Finally, someone who acknowledges the old character!
5:42 - Jacob Ware should share a cell with Shawn Mays in prison
Yeah the dude tricked me into believing that he’s changed….. and I believed it for over a year. Plus he literally blamed my mother over my personal problems what a piece of shit.
Maybe Jacob Ware would be good friends with Cosmodore.
@@turbobist2889 true because both of them used to be liked in the Community but now became hated due to there horrible actions.
@@Vinsalazar19 And said horrible actions are pedophilia.
@@turbobist2889 yes exactly
5:43 hey you said it not me
Bowser must be so depressed that he was approved but his son wasn't.
By the way, if you're still reading these comments, how would you rate Mr. Puzzles and Leggy?
@@Zman0523 Mr. Puzzles: Approved / Leggy: No
@@NostalgiaEgg Yeah true.
Ah, rock wizard, a classic
I like how at 10:21 you rated Shroomy the Mushroom this…
…He was my favorite character just like SMG4 and Mario and even Luigi too and others.
I counted 6 characters getting earraped. How did they mess up that badly?
i genuinely love rob, he is my favorite smg4 character and idek why so
1:21 I've never watched a SMG4 episode with Toadette in it so that kinda stung lol
She's just a slightly less annoying version of Peach
@@NostalgiaEgg ah I see, that sucks :(
She always annoying Toad
Shes forces toad to love her
Finally a classic fan who no bashing Meggy, Melony, Saiko, Tari or another modern characters...
Fuck you for Liking Meggy Tari Saiko Melony & another Modren Characters maikonrobertotitton2070
I Think SMG3 Axol SMG0 And Niles Are My 4th Favorite Character.
I haven't watched SMG4 for a couple of years now so I may be out of the loop, but during the time I was an active viewer I can guarantee you 90% of arguments in the comments of a video were related to 2:48 somehow. You could've sworn Meggy was a political figure with how radically divided opinions on her were.
he actually used EVERY character from smg4 lore like even a character that was used only once (example:bug/virus mario)
11:13 FINALLY SOMEONE REMEMBERS X!!!
Now we’re curious, what would Knuckles think of every GS Character?
Meggy is so good, she's been approved as a squid and a human.
Literally the Knuckle Ending video gives me Guesbombs and keep getting me jumpscared
exactly this part here: 10:16
Imagine we get a Bowser Jr arc lmao
The koopalings and bowser would definitely fight with jr and bowser jr is able to get luigi and melony to join them by staging a coup de etat in both weegeepie and melonyvideotime :D
8:08 everyone hates pipe monarch
3:23 I like Melony personally. Her outfit is awkward sometimes
That guy was king pipe and i like him but for melony its a soso because of her oppressive fanbase
I like her cuz sleep
@@Tailsbot98761 I just like how adorable and powerful melony is
I liked some of the jokes surrounding melony but looking back I didn’t like the direction of 2021’s arc took her in as it felt like anime. I don’t really like anime and I don’t think that’s a direction the channel should head.
Melon goddess.
Chris and Swagmaster getting approved.
I agree, best underated characters, i honestly think they are better thannthe core cast old and new.
(Just opinion, they are all good)
Personally, I started watching smg4 towards the end of 2014, and there are characters I don't really miss...
Apart from Bowser, who had a pleasant personality and was pretty funny, other characters ended up being forgettable over time, always having the same running gags
Peach is just a character who's angry all the time about anything, just that it's fun to see her get bashed
And Toad... he's just a terrible person... all his faults are scattered throughout the smg4 gang (no bravery being Tari, egoism being Bob, laziness being Melony and addiction to a food is Mario) but unlike those characters, he has no qualities and is not lovable by the other characters.
On the other hand, I hope to see an evolution in Tari's character, who hasn't had much importance since Waluigi arc, and more scenes with Melony, as she hasn't been around much since Revelations, especially as I like her a lot... cause my favorite smg4 videos are often when almost all the smg4 gang interact with each other and have fun or adventures/dramas, it's not the best video of 2023 I think but I loved for example the episode "The very safe & legal smg4 show"
As for Axol, he was one of my favorite characters because he may not have been the funniest or the most remarkable, but he's the nicest guy for me and greatly influenced the other characters (especially Melony and Meggy). I find modern characters more enjoyable after WOTFI 2021
Well I love Toad but I respect your opinion on him
Ngl i expected Heavy to be a no hesitation rank
11:40 obviously it's SONIC afterall
3:23
I don't really like melony. All she did until the SMG0 arc was act cute and sleep
Kevin focused so much on making a watermelon frickable that he forgot to make her actually something decent
tbh your spittin facts melony was really just a funny little side character but when they made her like a "main character" her funny really just disappeared which really just made her character feel you know empty
Very yes
Your channel name being "Nostalgia Egg" is right, I forgot about some of these characters lol
Bruh the cameraman deserves a slight approval
He's been standing watching knuckles the whole time
2:44 I pretty Much Agree with you
I love how Meggy was approved twice
Yeah XD
@@Laennie5 Cringe
@@deliotorres1815 how
@@Dripkenthefirst XD sometimes means cringe for me
@@deliotorres1815 lol you make yourself cringe cuz you x lol
Good job 👍
Knuckles approves knuckles approving memes: exelent meme!
Yo the characters look so rtx (what I mean is that the smg4 photos look High Graphics)
Swag be like: you're mom you're mom you're mom you're mom you're mom you're mom you're mom you're mom you're mom
2:08 LETS GO :D
Balls of steel making toad not approved, classic smg4 fans be screaming
Funny thing is that's the exact reason why he didn't get improved, Because he was only great during the classic era 2011 - 2013 and has been a hit or miss character since.
that old toilette Guy is back !! (4:47)
Im glad you made peach illegal 109373937303937393963 times
He better approve melony she's so damn cute and innocent. Also im pretty sure saiko threatened knuckles to approve her
Melony being "cute and innocent" isn't enough to say that she's a good character, I don't necessarily think those sorts of characters work with SMG4. But that's just me, She got better later on which is why I didn't outright disprove her.
@@NostalgiaEgg in my eyes being those things make a character good you know?
My only question is why did knuckles approve dr eggman isn’t he a bad guy
Where tf do some of these hd renders cone from
The SMG4 wiki
@@NostalgiaEgg wait, that exists?
The reason why knuckles made sans illegal is because of how the undertale community used to be (or it could just be that sans doesn’t have much of a role in the series)
7:37 bro I saw him put away the paper and had a heart attack
6:45
FREDDY NO!!!
Time for a random comment
SML VS SMG4
Still good contact: smg4
Many controversies: SML
Favorite characters: Tie
Worst characters of all time: SML
Toxic Fandom: tie
Best characters of all time: tie
Serious stories: smg4 (because it has many serious storylines)
Amazing old videos: smg4 (and still like old Sml as well)
Really funny Contant: Smg4
The creator: smg4
Annoying characters: sml
Free points: Sml
Who got sued by Nintendo in reality: sml
Most tragic downfall: sml
Still makes Mario videos: smg4
Villains: Smg4 (kinda)
Likable characters: smg4 (not the most likable characters but kinda likable then Mario, JR and Joseph except Brooklyn guy)
Who won: SMG4
EDIT April 16: I think I should remake this comment
I'd say that SML's fandom during its peak was ten times worse than what the SMG4 fanbase became, The SML fandom has mostly died following Logan's switch to using the puppets. But prior to that it was infuriatingly terrible.
@@NostalgiaEgg I’m a SML fan as well, I like both of these channels the most problems are SML I don’t even see Sml for some reason I don’t know why but I think both of there fandom are toxic the smg4 Community is really split other side is who people who still like smg4, still love meggy, and love every video on the other side is that people don’t like smg4, thinks that Meggy or Kevin ruined SMG4,
Despise human Meggy so much, don’t like new videos that has new characters, and people think that smg4 is greedy even though there kinda no proof of that and SML…nah I think u already know other side people love Jeffy and attack people that don’t like jeffy and the other side people hate jeffy don’t like the new videos and slowly not liking SML…and dubdude Literally yelled at people saying the word “SML” and make Livestreams 24/7. Both of the fandom are toxic.
THAT A FACT!
@@Vinsalazar19 I'm not disagreeing that both of the fanbases are toxic, I'm just saying that the SML fandom during 2017 - 2019 was on another level of terrible.
Back in those days there was major drama and serious allegations every other week, It got so terrible to the point where it completely collapsed on itself and decayed in relevance due to how unstable it was.
Admittedly I've only been in the SMG4 fandom since 2019, But nothing I've seen comes close to the Dean VS GCD, FlameyCat, Davidplex, and especially the Shawn Mays drama. Everyone involved is still feeling the effects of that mess to this day. It was that crazy.
I feel like sml was enjoyable when I was little. I feel like id cringe looking at him now.
Smg4 rn is just mid and nothing more. I watched this man cause I want to laugh and not cry. Like as soon as they started pulling this Persona 4 shit with Meggy they instantly lost me. Like I look back at his retarded series (don't hate me thats what they were called back in the day. People didn't take offence to the word retarded. Grow up people!) they had some actually funny stuff. I go back to those videos and said to myself "Man I miss the good ole UA-cam days."
Those days we're the best. The days where everyone wasn't offended about every little thing. I genuinely feel the change in writing direction is due to how the way modern society is. Or at least American Society. Nowadays you can't say retarded and not get hate.
My opinion:
Still good content: SML.
Many controversies: SML.
Favorite characters: Tied.
Worst characters 9f all time: SMG4.
Toxic fandom: SMG4.
Best characters of all time: SMG4.
Serious stories: SML because it's not stupid unlike SMG4.
Amazing old videos: vkth.
Really funny content: SML.
The creator: SMG4.
Annoying characters: SMG4.
Free points: SML.
Who got sued: SML.
Most tragic downfall: SMG4.
Still makes Mario videos: This is unfair.
Villains: Ifk.
Likable characters: Idk.
Who won: SML.
Seeing Enter X made me so happy
1:46 Wah!
Onestly you couldn't be more accurate
You had the guts to put Starman in
Smg5 approved my friend
But u put Meggy twice yet still uv earned a sub
OMG YES ENZO I LOVE YOU
POLICEMAN YES THIS IS WHY UR CALLED NOSTALGIC EGG
Frankie wow..... yippee
Nintendo getting called "smg4" for the eighty billionth time:
Bob shouldve been ranked perfect
Bob nowadays isn’t funny
@@Chill-Noob1 whaddya mean.
Hes just perfect
I agree with you Bob is a legend
I’ve seen a lot of SMG4 but there are even characters I haven’t seen. When did you start watching him?
I started watching SMG4 in 2012, And I've seen every single episode at least once.
Can’t believe this Sonic Boom scene became a meme
You should do a top 10 best smg4 videos
I will be doing that soon.
@@NostalgiaEgg nice
I love how he flat out hates lakitu and wants him long gone
Is the yoshi one suppose to represent how many crimes he committed 😂
Knuckles approves sonic. Approved
That only because they friends don’t you lied kunckles we are watch you😂
If knuckles was in a gaming government:
Quality Meme Ranks (best to worst):
Platinum
Diamond
Gold
Silver
Bronze
Marble
Stone
Whatever paperclips are made from
Wood
Fabric
Plastic
Paper
Trash
Human waste
Urinium (not Uranium)
What about Niles?
I forgot to include him. My thoughts on his character are very similar to my thoughts on SMG0.
Niles is a nice boi
Hmm niles is kind of a bad character I don't really like him especially what he did to melony in the smg4 episode apsulte betrayal
Magic rock wizard is a smg4 classic
Absolutely. He more better than I expected
honorable mentions/other characters (My opinion, I am starting to rewatch the old episodes)
Also I find all the mario recolors to be very funny and awesome but starman3 has drama
Old man pokemon sprite: Probably wasn't all that good but it was approved
Old mario (smg4 mario from before 2014 or before the modern videos) Approved excellent multiple times
John ham (too offensive today to say the part before ham): Approved
Bots: Very simple characters but still approved (the part where the whole battlefield attacks them is hilarious)
more coming soon
Starman 3 was 𝓵𝓾𝓬𝓴𝔂 to even be there
I know right
Knuckles for President
Wario: ha ha ha ha Im a number one 1:34
man some of my childhood chareter are here
Why not shy guy