Amusing to see Mr Kanwal pushing RRR for answers. RRR is not the one who needs to answer why the economy is in its current state and what needs to be done to put it in the right path. Push people in the Fin Ministry, Niti Ayog and PMO, but that you wont do. Need a spine for that.
After I returned from middle East, I see the country has produced several delivery boys and drivers. My suggestion would be, 1. Govt need to spend more on R&D in every sector, create value added products, create world class products (we are yet to produce a decent mobile phone from design to assembly) 2. Need a friendly policy to restrict brains (from IITs) moving to US and work for them. I mean offering them equal to US. 3. Focus on organic development and not religions. 4. Reducing taxes to a sweet spot where economic activity and margins do not affected. 5. Politicians and officials should think about our country's growth.
Well i am not an economist, but i am IIT Bombay grad with degree in core engineering, i feel uncertainty about future growth in my job, forget about starting new business, existing mncs are struggling to match the growth. Such poor economics of country discourage innovation and risk taking ability of smart people it seems to me hard times ahead govt should stop free bees and encourage people to actively join workforce and improve on ease of doing business so the productivity goes up and boost economy. We need to think ahead of ambanis and adanis, religion, caste, and so on
With all due respect to your Engineering degree and your business knowledge just dont pass comments on Welfare schemes as Freebies. Actually the term freebies is coined by the party who is boasting the things you mentioned caste, religion, etc. I agree with ur whole point except the wrong narrative of Welfare schemes in the name of Freebies especially sitting in a country which thrives on Consumer Economy.
Rahul Kanwal trying very hard to please his TOP master, unfortunately Mr. Rajan is not one of his scripted guests // well done Mr. Rajan, for taking this s guy on with FACTS
This man is always so sceptical. Earlier he used to say we should not be manufacturing mobiles in India, then he moved on to, mobiles are only being assembled, now as one by one compnent manufacturers are coming and govtbis launching PLI for components, his arguments fell flat ..now he says we should not invest in chip ecosystem …:-)
@@Suhas. Umm a person with an opinion? Calling someone names doesn't add validity to your arguments, rather dilutes it. Please learn how to conduct a civil argument.
Rajan is a socialist economist. He has a point of view. Not necessarily correct. Another point of view is emerging from what milei is doing in Argentina. You should listen to his speech in World Economic Forum this week. He has brought Argentina out of hyper inflation in one year. Very capitalist. Rajan talks about income redistribution. A socialist concept. Is that really how we want to run our society? Tax and redistribute, rather than tax minimal and use that for development. Create a society of innovation that will award the innovators and the hard working ..
It's bjp's failure and corruption that is exposed .... Let Nirmala Sitaraman and Modi apologize to all Indians and working class citizens for unfair TAX on middle class people, Unemployment , uncontrollable poverty ratio, unrest communal politics
Chadarmodi ne Desh ki vaat laga di 😂😅 Dr Manmohan Singh said : Without discussing the merits of Narendra Modi I sincerely believe that it would be disastrous for India to have him as Prime Minister :: And everybody is experiencing its now 😅
He is good...One reason for Dual Citizenship for people like him ...NRIs ...could make them come back to India without their family needing to suffer or can have only one Citizenship !!!
Rajan sir, I again request a clarification. RBI data shows 46 crore MUDRA self-employment borrowers and 13 crore agricultural loan borrowers. If two persons are engaged in each loan account, how many people are self-employed in these 2 sectors?
The problem is we are too many. Too many people means we can be exploited for work for lower wages, which in turns also impact consumption. Also instead of focusing on high quality job and High technical jobs, we tend to focus on just providing any average job.
Govt must reduce tax for lower, middle class people to improve consumption, stop freebies, control on private companies on price inflations and they must create jobs, encourage NRIs to invest in india 🇮🇳
The large part of discussion is on private investment huge corporate is on market capitalisation trends in bubbling the economy.Even in BJP Potential people like Vishnav, jaishankar, urjit patel ..are capable to handle the country, RSS , should be independent to lead the country. Indian in abroad are potential to invest not venture into India because for decimal number of courts and judges, none application of information technology in proceedings is real concern in protection of the investment,-Faith starts from Redressal mechanism.Mr Rajan himself raised concern about ROYALTIES, would have suggested market capitalisation earnings on RESEARCH .
Dr Raghuram Rajan, when the guy asking cuts you when speaking on talent missed due to limited institution and he leads you to FM Nirmala S suggesting comment on tax and reforms there what does that indicate and how hard it must be to pull over and over when these are adamant driving their agenda?
Reporter unnecessarily excited and always raises voices everytine.....mocking liike he is aaking intelligent questions.... when the water is low it makes more noise....
इस रघुराम राजन को इंडिया की strength का अंदाज़ा ही नहीं है. कितने साल से कह रहा है कि इंडिया फेल हो जाएगा. और, इंडिया rise हो रहा है यानि कि इस की बात, लगातार ग़लत सिद्ध हो रही है
How is a person to be taken seriously who takes Rahul Gandhi so seriously. These economists have the liberty to say and interpret things acoording to their whims and fancies.. cause economics is unlike science.
China is example of infra spending . It built an infra that no country comes closer to China, the currency is stable wrt $, wry little depreciation, cost (other than house) is half the cost of India and one fifth cost of EU and USA , loan interest is one fourth of India and its sovereign rating is “investable grade” unlike India which stands at between stable and u stable investable grade. China is self sufficient in every respect unlike USA and EU, except energy where it has Russia to bail out a reason why China is with Russia unlike India who does not know where it wants to go
Whole Enviornment in India is vitiated because of religion politics and undermining Institutions.With deglobalisation in the wind across the world,Die hard business people in India will move with great caution no matter how much FM screams.Rule out any sizeable increase in private CAPEX in near future.Depend only on Govt spending which will also be restricted as there is a limit of how much more you can borrow.Settle for a 5% -6% growth now.Balance are all political slogans.Prepare for an OUTSIZE population of young UNEMPLOYED.
This guy is Congress agent for spreading negativity about India. His sole objective is to make Rahul a PM, hence his commentary is negativity towards Modi
@Karptml ..but that's the few of the core business/tech theme where world is moving ..if not amabani them whom It takes billion to set up AI industries/GPUs and small players don't have that capability nor appetite for large scale tech set up..Amabani's have to develop..or india will be behind
Dr. Rajan pls have a better choice of the channel and host..this guy Rahul Kanwal, elephant food taster at Ambani wedding, this guy can only rabble rouse and do you really think he has any business knowledge for you to engage with him...🎉😂
Because of the clean-up his initiated coupled with better functioning under the current regime, PSBs not forced by politicians to give loans to their friends for loss making projects
It's because all the loss making banks merged to profit making banks. Their cumulative balance is in profit. But, still the bad debts of those loss making banks still exist.
China economy big market world and next new business market policy 2025 and America make new policy world media understand but next khalistan zindabad nice media answer waiting??bawaG +baba G world news pakistan pajab city faisal abad gnn 🎉🎉
He did well there ..he forced tha banks to recognise the issues such that it is understood, calibrated and a solution is put in place. Earlier Banks were evergreening the loans, hence it looked like low NPA.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
We need someone like him as fm, not the arrogant and i know everything type
FULLY AGREED. We need educated heads to lead the country..
Agreed. I want R R sir next fm or PM.
I would like to see as a next FM of India Mr.R R
He did a terrible job when he was RBI governor, no risk taking, only conservative approach, I. His time inflation was high
He has to wait till RaGs Khan is PM.
You need to know more about economics… he is a failed economist..
@@ishankanwar8411
True
Amusing to see Mr Kanwal pushing RRR for answers. RRR is not the one who needs to answer why the economy is in its current state and what needs to be done to put it in the right path. Push people in the Fin Ministry, Niti Ayog and PMO, but that you wont do. Need a spine for that.
Rahul does not have the guts to question the ruling party.
Rahul dosent have the cricket balls to do that 😂
👍👍👍 for Dr.Rajan and 👎👎👎👎👎👎👎👎 for the channel and specially to his guy Rahul Kanwal
He should be made a Rajya Sabha MP and let him head the finance ministry
After I returned from middle East, I see the country has produced several delivery boys and drivers. My suggestion would be,
1. Govt need to spend more on R&D in every sector, create value added products, create world class products (we are yet to produce a decent mobile phone from design to assembly)
2. Need a friendly policy to restrict brains (from IITs) moving to US and work for them. I mean offering them equal to US.
3. Focus on organic development and not religions.
4. Reducing taxes to a sweet spot where economic activity and margins do not affected.
5. Politicians and officials should think about our country's growth.
How more jobs will be created when some person wants 90 hour work that means 2 persons work from 1 employee but want to pay the same minimal wage?
Well i am not an economist, but i am IIT Bombay grad with degree in core engineering, i feel uncertainty about future growth in my job, forget about starting new business, existing mncs are struggling to match the growth. Such poor economics of country discourage innovation and risk taking ability of smart people it seems to me hard times ahead govt should stop free bees and encourage people to actively join workforce and improve on ease of doing business so the productivity goes up and boost economy. We need to think ahead of ambanis and adanis, religion, caste, and so on
With all due respect to your Engineering degree and your business knowledge just dont pass comments on Welfare schemes as Freebies. Actually the term freebies is coined by the party who is boasting the things you mentioned caste, religion, etc.
I agree with ur whole point except the wrong narrative of Welfare schemes in the name of Freebies especially sitting in a country which thrives on Consumer Economy.
Rahul Kanwal trying very hard to please his TOP master, unfortunately Mr. Rajan is not one of his scripted guests // well done Mr. Rajan, for taking this s guy on with FACTS
This man is always so sceptical. Earlier he used to say we should not be manufacturing mobiles in India, then he moved on to, mobiles are only being assembled, now as one by one compnent manufacturers are coming and govtbis launching PLI for components, his arguments fell flat ..now he says we should not invest in chip ecosystem …:-)
With the falling growth rate, how are you going to stay optimistic about the Indian economy?
Your comment is same as Spitting on the Sun ☀️and getting back to your face 😂
He is world renowned economist. Who the F are you?
@@Suhas. Umm a person with an opinion? Calling someone names doesn't add validity to your arguments, rather dilutes it. Please learn how to conduct a civil argument.
Rajan is a socialist economist. He has a point of view. Not necessarily correct. Another point of view is emerging from what milei is doing in Argentina. You should listen to his speech in World Economic Forum this week. He has brought Argentina out of hyper inflation in one year. Very capitalist. Rajan talks about income redistribution. A socialist concept. Is that really how we want to run our society? Tax and redistribute, rather than tax minimal and use that for development. Create a society of innovation that will award the innovators and the hard working ..
I would see Bharat on the right track when there is a reverse migration...people going from cities to the villages for a better life
Beautiful conversation
A salaried person's hard earned money is going into the pocket of Babus, IAS, Corrupt politicians and rich people through loan waiver.
It's bjp's failure and corruption that is exposed .... Let Nirmala Sitaraman and Modi apologize to all Indians and working class citizens for unfair TAX on middle class people, Unemployment , uncontrollable poverty ratio, unrest communal politics
Very currect but BJP peoples are not understand it
Chadarmodi ne Desh ki vaat laga di 😂😅 Dr Manmohan Singh said :
Without discussing the merits of Narendra Modi I sincerely believe that it would be disastrous for India to have him as Prime Minister ::
And everybody is experiencing its now 😅
@muksman1 Dr.Manmohan Singh give certificate to Mr.Modi ?
Serious lack of confidence of the investors about the future of the Indian economy. There are no takers for the Vikshit India story.
He is good...One reason for Dual Citizenship for people like him ...NRIs ...could make them come back to India without their family needing to suffer or can have only one Citizenship !!!
Rajan sir, I again request a clarification. RBI data shows 46 crore MUDRA self-employment borrowers and 13 crore agricultural loan borrowers. If two persons are engaged in each loan account, how many people are self-employed in these 2 sectors?
I am waiting for RR to say India's growth would be low. Last time he said this we achieved a robust growth rate.
The problem is we are too many. Too many people means we can be exploited for work for lower wages, which in turns also impact consumption. Also instead of focusing on high quality job and High technical jobs, we tend to focus on just providing any average job.
MR RAJAN SHOULD TAKE CARE OF HIMSELF . THE NEW BHARAT KNOWS ITS WAY .
Govt must reduce tax for lower, middle class people to improve consumption, stop freebies, control on private companies on price inflations and they must create jobs, encourage NRIs to invest in india 🇮🇳
The large part of discussion is on private investment huge corporate is on market capitalisation trends in bubbling the economy.Even in BJP Potential people like Vishnav, jaishankar, urjit patel ..are capable to handle the country, RSS , should be independent to lead the country.
Indian in abroad are potential to invest not venture into India because for decimal number of courts and judges, none application of information technology in proceedings is real concern in protection of the investment,-Faith starts from Redressal mechanism.Mr Rajan himself raised concern about ROYALTIES, would have suggested market capitalisation earnings on RESEARCH .
Agree with him now, but RRR was worse as an RBI governer. All he is good at is constructive criticism, but not as a leaders himself.
Dr Raghuram Rajan, when the guy asking cuts you when speaking on talent missed due to limited institution and he leads you to FM Nirmala S suggesting comment on tax and reforms there what does that indicate and how hard it must be to pull over and over when these are adamant driving their agenda?
Reporter unnecessarily excited and always raises voices everytine.....mocking liike he is aaking intelligent questions.... when the water is low it makes more noise....
the problem is with the government on which businesses do not have any confidence.
where is Mr Panaghariya when i want to know his opinion on falling gdp
Arent developing countries already putting 20-40% import taxes on US made products ?
DAVOS is the seat of the Biblical "Beast" with 10 horns.
इस रघुराम राजन को इंडिया की strength का अंदाज़ा ही नहीं है.
कितने साल से कह रहा है कि इंडिया फेल हो जाएगा.
और, इंडिया rise हो रहा है यानि कि इस की बात, लगातार ग़लत सिद्ध हो रही है
ये इंसान हर बार ग़लत हो कर फिर एक नया झूट बोलता है । जब ये RBI मैं था तब ये ख़ुद एक फेलियर था ।
Right
Raghu for Fm Please
Rajn may thinking in terms of economics instead in terms of security right?
👍👍👍
How is a person to be taken seriously who takes Rahul Gandhi so seriously. These economists have the liberty to say and interpret things acoording to their whims and fancies.. cause economics is unlike science.
the interviewer is searching for answers desperately .... he doesn't believe Indian analysts in India .... is he fully long on India for 2047 story??
Disruption from notebandi..lockdown...gst all broken backbone of common people
China is example of infra spending . It built an infra that no country comes closer to China, the currency is stable wrt $, wry little depreciation, cost (other than house) is half the cost of India and one fifth cost of EU and USA , loan interest is one fourth of India and its sovereign rating is “investable grade” unlike India which stands at between stable and u stable investable grade. China is self sufficient in every respect unlike USA and EU, except energy where it has Russia to bail out a reason why China is with Russia unlike India who does not know where it wants to go
He never speak good about India 🇮🇳
Open Ur brain and listen to him first
Raghu doesn't sugar coat, unlike some of our politicians "Amrit Kaal" 😂😂😂
Whole Enviornment in India is vitiated because of religion politics and undermining Institutions.With deglobalisation in the wind across the world,Die hard business people in India will move with great caution no matter how much FM screams.Rule out any sizeable increase in private CAPEX in near future.Depend only on Govt spending which will also be restricted as there is a limit of how much more you can borrow.Settle for a 5% -6% growth now.Balance are all political slogans.Prepare for an OUTSIZE population of young UNEMPLOYED.
This guy is Congress agent for spreading negativity about India. His sole objective is to make Rahul a PM, hence his commentary is negativity towards Modi
Deep state
Rahul was a moron in pushing for the ideal rupee dollar rxchange rate ! 😂😅
1990 to 2010 rupee wasn't depreciate look in chart
How Modi bhakt is talking about geo Economic matters.
He has some predictions on every thing....but his predictions never come true. I think he has some hidden agenda
Absolutely, he makes no sense
This is the only bottomline.
If there is a slightest hint of congis coming back to power anywhere in the horizon, economy will plummet. period.
India is done
SHAMELESS RAJAN..WHEN MODI IS NOT RESPECTING HIM WHY HE SHAMELESSLY SPEAKS ON INDIA . SHAMELESSLY DOING CHAMCHAGIRI
Not sure why ambani is not making chip company
They don't understand in chip market
@Karptml ..but that's the few of the core business/tech theme where world is moving ..if not amabani them whom
It takes billion to set up AI industries/GPUs and small players don't have that capability nor appetite for large scale tech set up..Amabani's have to develop..or india will be behind
He is planning to start POTATO CHIPS.
@@santanodcosta3360 😄😄😄🤣
Dr. Rajan pls have a better choice of the channel and host..this guy Rahul Kanwal, elephant food taster at Ambani wedding, this guy can only rabble rouse and do you really think he has any business knowledge for you to engage with him...🎉😂
Just few weeks back he said Indian economy is good
How?
RRR must be asked why, after his departure, as RBI G Indian public sectore banks are in profit.
Because of the clean-up his initiated coupled with better functioning under the current regime, PSBs not forced by politicians to give loans to their friends for loss making projects
It's because all the loss making banks merged to profit making banks. Their cumulative balance is in profit. But, still the bad debts of those loss making banks still exist.
Just by removing bad debts from their balance sheet makes them profitable. All accounting gimmicks.
😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
Wokes tries to brings weight in wokes. Good drama.
Tax terror economic paralysis
Competent governance lacking....propaganda Bhashan advt cheer leading going on
At @26:38 - bro he's just an economist not God to know all the answers 😅
worst interviewer ever
Is anyone listening to the warnings ?
A corrupt country like India will never succeed in anything big.
😂😂😂😂😂😂...
Tell it to pappu.
NPA Rajaaaaaa
China economy big market world and next new business market policy 2025 and America make new policy world media understand but next khalistan zindabad nice media answer waiting??bawaG +baba G world news pakistan pajab city faisal abad gnn 🎉🎉
Badly edit. Lot of repeated content
Is this sounding like a blind leading a blind ?
In his tenure NPA skyrocketed
He did well there ..he forced tha banks to recognise the issues such that it is understood, calibrated and a solution is put in place. Earlier Banks were evergreening the loans, hence it looked like low NPA.
Sab changaa seee😂😂😂😂😂