Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Paleo Catalog Basics: Bulbasaurus (The Dicynodont named after a Pokemon)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 сер 2024
- 0:00 Intro
2:10 About that Name
3:32 Furry Lizards?
4:49 The Karoo Fossil Goldmine
6:41 The Real Bulbasaur
8:20 Outro
#bulbasaur #pokemon #bulbasaurus #paleontology #karoofossils #PaleoAnalysis
This week I decided to continue making Paleo catalog basics videos with an animal I’ve wanted to talk about for a while. When it was identified in 2017, the motives behind the naming of the Dicynodont Bulbasaurus. Especially when the type species was announced as B. phylloxyron, a name that literally translates to “Leaf Razor”
Despite all this seeming to point to this animal being named after a Pokemon, the scientists originally denied any connection between the real creature and the adorable grass type starter. However when the same scientists were quoted saying "similarities between this species and certain other squat, tusked quadrupeds may not be entirely coincidental. If one wished to read between the lines concerning certain similarities, I wouldn't stop them" I think it’s safe to assume that there was at least some inspiration from the biggest franchise in the world.
As a paleo nerd who also enjoys Pokemon, I figured that this would be a prefect addition to the Paleo Catalog Basics series! If you can think of any other animals from Earth’s past that we have very limited remains of, and you think it would make a good video in this series, leave a comment and let me know what you wanna see!
Click here to visit me on Twitter!:
/ paleoanalysis
Follow me on Instagram for more Paleo content!:
/ paleoanalysis
Most of my music has been provided by MehoDrums. If you enjoy any of the tunes in my background or into, check out some of his other stuff and contact him if you want to have him compose some stuff for you!
linktr.ee/Meho....
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
Id love to see you cover each fossil pokemon and the species that inspired it!
Yes this pls
I'd like to learn some more about Gorgonopaids in general. They always remind of Saber toothed cats, we'll I guess they were the fore runners so....
I really REALLY want to talk about Gorgonopsids in depth! And in addition they will definitely be getting talked about when I get to the Permian in the History of the Earth series. As far as a dedicated video I have a very specific and special plan in mind but it will probably take me more than a single week to write/record and edit such a video. Stay tuned though because it's definitely on my to do list.
@@PaleoAnalysis one week is nothing dude they will find your video in one million years
@@Coffeemancer that's pretty deep. I hope so.
If they can read this 1 million years in the future. I want to tell them just one thing from our time,
*Charmander* is the best red/blue starter Pokemon. 😁👍
This video is the best kind of nerdy content. Keep up the great work.
This kinda reminds me of the only trilobite in it's genus named after the Han people in China, which has been given species name solo(by a very Star Wars loving paleontologist). More geeky paleontology facts are always good!
I once heard dicynodonts described as 'Saber toothed turtle headed pigs'. Actually rather accurate. I would like to see you do Tully monster or isotelus rex.
Amazing video! I believe Pokemon is a good reference to paleontology with the inspiration and differences between fantasy and reality.
I almost feel like that was their reason behind naming it. Fun wink to us.
It fit the fantasy AND the reality. 😎👍
I'm a Galarian Mr.Mime... I'm an ice cold psychopath.
Thrinaxodon would be cool to go over :) Both Thrinaxodon & Lystrosaurus appear to have survived the Permian - Triassic extinction by having populations in Antarctica (southern Pangaea at the time), but unlike the dicynodonts, Thrinaxodon (or something closely related to it) would eventually give rise to us mammals :)
If there is not enough information about Thrinaxodon as an individual species, you might other cynodonts, like Cynognathus :)
i feel like the bulbasaur line actually was based on dicynodonts, cos it just... it just looks like one. Froggy body, with claws, tusks, weird beaky thing, weird horn things. so yeah
If that is the case, and GameFreak actually designed a pokemon based on a dicynodont way back in 1996, and then a actual dicynodont was named after the pokemon in 2017, that would make this all the cooler.
I love this video so much
Cause it's about Pokémon and Paleontology
I laughed out loud. Love your documentaries!
Bulbasaur is the best starter of any generation. Fight me.
Ok it has the type advantage on the 1st 3 gyms but Charmander is still cool and cute
Why would I fight you when I agree with you?
I'll fight with you.
Best is subjective. What're we talking 'bout
I love Bulbasaur and Snivy personally.
Very nice, two uploads, in a single day?
One was around 8pm yesterday CST but yes I did technically drop two videos within 24 hours 🙂
Everything about their possible fern like proto fur or even feather like structures together with the complex biome living in symbiosis in these skin structures makes every group of animal with similar features incredibly interesting. What a world!
as both a geologist that love paleo and a pokemon fan, 7:50 is so adorable, thank the algorithm for brining me here
I've always been interested in this time period, and having a critter named after a Pokémon, something I have shared with my boys since they started collecting cards and dragging me into playing the games with them way back when, is just adorable! ❤❤
Oh, how I wish I'd encountered this channel sooner! Most other channels fall into two categories, ones aimed at people with only a passing interest in the subject, often riddled with inaccuracies that even a modicum of research would have corrected, and those aimed at people who have studied the subject to some degree, and dense with technical stuff that those in the middle get lost in.
This channel, however, nicely encapsulates the middle ground- intelligent and well researched, and couched in every day but precise language. Whilst there is detail, it isn't subject specific to the point only paleontologists can understand it. There is also a good seasoning of humour, too, which always helps.
All in all, I'm loving this channel and its content, and wish more makers would give consideration to those of us who fall between the idiots and the nerds!
I think that the pokemon looks more like a cross between a frog and a green garlic bulb than a cabbage. Great videos, I am very glad I found your site, please continue.
Thank you for that amazing disclaimer! So hilarious and well said! I seriously got so angry when people began "debunking" Jurassic Park several years ago, or claimed the writers got things wrong when they were working with what information was available at that time. A film by the way that supported the connection between dinosaurs and modern day birds, a theory which was not widely accepted at that time. On that note, what would you think about covering the topic of Deinocheirus? It's a somewhat recent discovery, and there's been a lot of debate about what it's diet was.
That disclaimer has made me chuckle every time I've heard it
Such a brilliant channel , I've been binging all week and can't wait for more 🙌🏾
Furry or not Bulbasaurus is kinda cute. What's your favorite cute prehistoric animal?
Thanks for the very fun video. I'm excited to listen to these while I'm working late into the evenings.
“Don’t be an ass hat” is a great disclaimer
i love all your work! please keep uploading!!!!
Dude I love your disclaimer it is so funny
Your channel will definitely blow up w new followers
Obviously the paleontologist that found Bulbasaurus didn't want to deal with any legal issues with Pokemon so he didn't explicitly confirmed.
On my birthday paleo analysis puts out a new video now that’s cool
Happy Birthday!
@@PaleoAnalysis thanks
I just named my bulbasaur in pokemon go bulbasaurus yesterday and now i find this video coincidentally
those giant rabbits in the Mediterranean or those giant armadillos in south Africa or a great ape to early hominid is always interesting
Holy moly what happened?! I blink and you've gone from 5k to 100k?! Congrats man!!!
Nature uses Permian mass extiction, it's extremely effective
The marine biosphere lost 96% of its health!
haha i love getting jumpscared by my own art in a video! thank you for using it :D bulbasaurus is such a neat creature!
So what happened is that all the kids who like comic books, videogames and dinosaurs grew up and is now naming things they discover after things they like and think sound cool. Hence all the pokemon names in the scientific world.
"Don't be an ass hat." Words to live by Tim Tim
I PICKED BULBASAUR WHEN I PLAYED BLUE AND IT WAS MY FIRST GAME TOO!! Gang gang
love how you have Pokemon in this video
Man I can't wait till the Permian history of the earth video. Age of the SYNAPSIDS, BABY
I don't forget to leave a "like" because I put them in at the very beginning. I know I am going to like anything you bring up.
this was incredible! good work!
I would like to learn more about one of those giant sloths that ruled until they went extinct, like a megatherium
I'm Something of a paleo-nerd Myself
Really liked this vid so ima subscribe
your disclaimer takes all the fun out of trolling you!!
First of all, I want to express my regret that you have apparently been attacked by trolls about videos that are now out of date. TIM TIM, I SALUTE YOU!!!
Now, to my questions.
As a child, I remember reading in a picture book that Brachyasauruses (or Brontosauruses?) were such lumbering behemoths that they needed large bodies of water to help support their weight.
Is the term Brachyasaurus still a part of the paleontological lexicon?
When did paleontologists decide that Sauropods (correct term?) did not need water to help support their bodies?
Keep up your work, and don't let the trolls wear you down! 😄
I had to look it up to be sure but Pokémon was released in 1996 in Japan but 1998 is America, and 1999 in Europe. :)
This was so cute!
"Bulbasaur, objectively the best choice. Fight me."
Very well then. Despite the strong lead Bulbasaur then Ivysaur has over the first three gyms it's lack of coverage holds it back ESPECIALLY in the region where Psychic types are busted as fuck even in the remake. The real best choice is Squirtle because even though there are lots of decent water types available, Blastoise's defenses give it the most positive matchups and it is able to learn ice moves which give it fantastic coverage.
Ideas: Histriasaurus, Scipionyx, Mesocetus Argami
its a shame real bulbasaurs never existed, but i loved this video for bringing attention to some lesser known dinosaurs that couldve been bulbasaur! thank you :)
thats...not a dinosaur?
Awesome video. The only constructive criticism I would give is to not do the high-pitched voice over during your disclaimer, as I found it pretty grating on my ears. Other than that great job!
Yeah it's really obnoxious.
Wait, did you make the animation at the end yourself? The cute bulbasaur walking away into the forest? I love the details such as the reflection on his skin.
An accurate bulbasaurus
Could you imagine if dycynodons (not a paleontologist) weren't in fact different species but instead had similar environmental pressure expressions like grasshoppers? Because grasshoppers are locust, so is it possible, even if improbable, that species like this could be triggered in upbringing to display traits that after their discovery years later lead us to attribute them incorrectly to different species? Probably not for them specifically, but I would be surprised if no other species in the fossil record had that trait. This thought shares a room rent free with my fascination in the lack of juvenile tyrannosaurus fossils out there.
I come from the future woodwork and must correct an error. This animal was driven to extinction by the magdeburg unicorn.
I'm somewhat conflicted on the name. On the one hand it'd be really cool if bulbasaur was the real reason it got its name, but on the other the discoverer refraining from out right saying it probably means it wasn't the case (I swear if the pikachu and sonic based proteins and a species of Jamaican frogs called mountain chickens weren't enough evidence that naming nomenclature wouldn't prevent the guy from outright admitting it if it's the case, then I dunno what else could prevent them from being honest about it).
i think you could do a mini catalog "paleo pokemon"
My favorite is Sauroniops, because I'm a Lord of the Rings fan, and because if you didn't know it meant "Eye of Sauron" it sounds like a regular dinosaur name.
Somehow the way the images of Permian creatures are drawn (not just here, everywhere) makes them seem primitive and unfinished. I suspect that's just an effect of how little we know but it's surely part of the reason we see these creatures as primitive.
Bulbasaurus is the first discovered extinct animal from which we know for sure what sound he must have made.
Don't laugh at me. I've almost completed a livingdex once, so I know what I'm talking about. :P
@@Leto85 I completed a living dex once with just one generation. Aka the Gen 3 pokedex. Haha.
@@goldman77700 Well done! Was it in the RSE series or their ORAS remakes?
@@Leto85 The originals cuz you couldn't trade from the previous 2 gens. Lol
Remember, first and foremost, most scientists are nerds of one variety or another. And many nerds have cross-nerd interests. So, it really isn't too surprising that animals, both living and extinct, are being named after video games, anime, comic books, science fiction, fantasy, etc.
I love it.
Curious, I was wondering if anybody has thought about this for the nasal bosses on these and other animals. That is they could be used for tests of strength between males for mating rights ect. We tend to think of bighorn sheep slamming skulls but what if two males slowly got into each other's face and became a pushing match?
which song did you use for the intro? I love it!
Nice Pokéontology
Commenting on this video to nudge it along the yt algorithm
Very cool 👍
Pokemon was unavailable outside of Japan until 1998.
While this video is about a dinosaur that's named after a Pokémon (purposely or not), it would be cool to see videos about Pokémon who are based on real dinosaurs.
So, what other animals do we know wich lived during this time periode? I would suspect trilobites and gators off some kind, but that would be 3 animals if I am right. 🤔
tim tim's wise words !
I've finally decided that the early/mid triassic is my fav time, but the late Permian is a really close second. If we got solid evidence of furry synapsids, I'd likely change my mind.
Maybe the cabbage back part was not very well preserved as the skull. ;)
“Due to legal reasons with Nintendo I am not allowed to say that I named it after the Pokémon”
nice vibs homie
Tim Tim is best former cyanobacteria (been a while so I can't remember what he's evolved into here). You really should do a video on the Abeilasaur Thanos, and I know there's another prehistoric critter named after Japan's most famous monster.
Only just saw this one, but I am playing Pokemon Blue again on my GB emulator; Bulbasaur is totally the best starter Pokemon.
When I was 10, I thought Bulbasaur was the best because plant type Pokemon are awesome.
When I was 20, I thought Bulbasaur was the best because the first four gyms in order have rock, water, electric, and plant types. This means that you have advantage on the first three and a mutual disadvantage on the fourth. By the time you get to Fuchsia City, you should have enough other Pokemon to no longer need the starter advantage.
Now that I'm in my 30s, I think Bulbasaur is the best because plant type Pokemon are awesome.
If you ask me any animal that's walking around and eating stuff and procreating is a pretty advanced organism.
Have you heard of the mokele mbembe and all the other names they have for the beast?
Can you do gobiraptor?
In some fanfic roleplays I do with friends, I doubled down on the idea of Bulbasaur being a therapsid to the point I actually worked the idea that while its hybrid plant/animal physiology is still a mystery; fossil evidence showed that it was how and why the bulbasaur family survived not just the Permian but the entirety of the Mesozoic to the modern day. The pokedex states even in its base form, Bulbasaur can go long periods without food as it will metabolize the seeds in its bulb if necessary. That would be vital in the late Permian especially, and even during parts of the Triassic and Jurassic, not to mention the K-T extinction on top of it all. Venusaur meanwhile gets the bulk of its energy strictly via photosynthesis.
3:39 what is the name of that huge lad in the top left??
Suggestion: helveticosaurus
More synapsids please
Dunno how true this is, but its theorized that the bulbasaur line is based around the prehistoric frog known as Beelzebufo
now there needs to be a gorgonops pokemon
dunkleosteus video please !!!!
WHy that cheeky ....
Also, I believe asshat should be one word. Autocorrect disagrees with me, but I'm not a robot! I think...
Pokémon is so good nature created a dinosaur just to be named after it
Bulbasaur is my favourite :3
Nice
Heck yeah Bulbasaur Gang!
Ok, this might be a bad question, but is there any relation between diictodons and lystrosaurus?
both Diictodon and Lystrosaurus are dicynodonts
Pretty cool
It’s to bad Bulbasaurus and Aerodactylus could never have fought each other.
First video, that’s a follow from me
Bulbasaur is still the best . long live Bulbasaur
Bulbasaur and Meowth Relationship Lore nearly at least 12,000 years ago and 9,5000 year's ago takes Place at Africa - Egypt - Cyprus 🦴🧬 Cat domesticated and human fossils as well 🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍🥰👍
6:35 is that sigillaria?
Cool
When you're afraid the other nerds will bully you for liking Best Pokemon because they're still salty about picking the torch lizard xD