Three Carbon Fiber Violin Comparisons

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 84

  • @terria1254
    @terria1254 Рік тому +6

    Thank-you! I purchased my Glasser Carbon Composite violin (same as the one in your video) from you back in July '23. I'm VERY happy with it! I fiddle and bought it for playing outdoors, and its great for that (other players enjoy trying it too)! Its an easy to play instrument, has a very decent sound and holds its tuning well; also the geared tuners are great! Its been to outdoor woodsy moist gatherings and was played on the beach for a week-ish. And now, it will also be my winter travel-to-jams instrument. For my setup, I changed out the Larsen strings for Helicores, and I changed out its chin rest to a Wave (I have a long neck). 🎻🙂

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  Рік тому +2

      So nice to hear, a big thanks for sharing. Yes, carbon composite instruments are perfect for playing outdoors. We are so happy that you are enjoying your Glasser violin! Music to our ears 😍

  • @adi_demian
    @adi_demian 9 місяців тому +2

    Thank you so much for your comparison video. I ended up buying the Glasser AEX 5 string violin from your store yesterday. I've been using glasser braided carbon bows for many, many years, and love them. I am sure the two will sound great together! I can't wait to receive the AEX from you! ❤

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  9 місяців тому +1

      Great to hear! So happy for you! Thank you. Please keep us updated ❤️

  • @LRPhotographer
    @LRPhotographer 4 місяці тому +1

    I've read every article and watched every video I could find on various carbon fiber violins, and I kept being drawn to the Glasser. I especially like y'all's videos comparing the different brands and models, and I ultimately decided to order the Glasser from your website last night (along with a case and a bow). I look forward to playing it once it arrives. Thanks for all the videos about it. They were even more helpful than our local violin shop that also sells it.

  • @WhiteDragon689
    @WhiteDragon689 3 місяці тому +1

    So good to see you Michael doing what you love best. Thanks bud.

  • @charleskilo4383
    @charleskilo4383 Рік тому +3

    Something in the back of my mind noticed a visual difference between the first violin and the last two but I couldn't exactly tell what at first. I eventually realized that the dearer two don't have the sharp "corners" at the waist, it's more of an acoustic guitar body shape. I can't unsee it now but I think I really like that!

    • @charlottesmom
      @charlottesmom 11 місяців тому

      It's a "cleaner" look, it's interesting for sure. 👍🏻

  • @laurensitter5250
    @laurensitter5250 2 роки тому +9

    I have the exact Glasser from the video, and it has served me well my past two years learning the violin. I live off grid with degrees in the negatives through 110F depending on the season.

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  2 роки тому +3

      Happy to hear, Lauren! With those kind of temperatures it's the perfect violin to have. Happy playing!

    • @rachellane9708
      @rachellane9708 Рік тому

      Lauren, I’m looking for one to take camping. Is this a good option? My car is available to put it in, but not always climate controlled.

    • @laurensitter5250
      @laurensitter5250 9 місяців тому

      Yes, this is a great one! I’ve had it in my off grid camper in below 0 and over 100 without any issues.

  • @Discrimination_is_not_a_right
    @Discrimination_is_not_a_right Рік тому +7

    I love it. Rich, resonant tone, no dead notes anywhere in the frequency range and most importantly, consistency from one instrument to the next. You know what you're getting.

    • @ThomasTVP
      @ThomasTVP 6 місяців тому

      There is no "Rich, resonant" tone.

    • @SkepticalLlama
      @SkepticalLlama 5 днів тому

      @@ThomasTVP maybe not, but your tone sucks. 🤓

  • @patriciajrs46
    @patriciajrs46 Рік тому +4

    Great playing of Danny Boy. Thank you for all of them.
    I personally prefer the sound of the wooden ones.

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  Рік тому

      Thanks for listening!

    • @patriciajrs46
      @patriciajrs46 Рік тому

      @@Fiddlershop You're welcome.

    • @ThomasTVP
      @ThomasTVP 6 місяців тому

      Absolutely. These all sound simple and flat (to varying degrees).

  • @sbeckmesser
    @sbeckmesser Рік тому +8

    I wish these comparisons had included at least one traditional wooden violin so that one can get some idea of the tonality of the microphone's sound pickup. That way one could sort out whether the nasality I hear in all of these models comes from them or the combination of microphones and my speaker frequency responses. I know my speakers aren't flat and I bet that the mikes used aren't either.

    • @JStephs1950
      @JStephs1950 Рік тому

      Yes!

    • @charlottesmom
      @charlottesmom 11 місяців тому

      Yes, a head to head with traditional would have been great. 👍🏻🎻

  • @timcraig1161
    @timcraig1161 Рік тому +2

    but i do love the fiddle do you have any recomendations for the lowc and g strings

  • @LHoppe-sx5sh
    @LHoppe-sx5sh Рік тому +5

    With no doubt the mezzoforte sounds better and even way better than wodden instrument from the lower third of the regular price-scale (excluding really expensive violins)

    • @ThomasTVP
      @ThomasTVP 6 місяців тому

      Complete rubbish.

  • @diabloget
    @diabloget Місяць тому

    As a guitarist, I am wondering if it would be possible to create a Glasser Classical Guitar. Like respecting it's shape or maybe using the baroque shape, either way it would be nice to see. There is a few videos of Carbon Fiber classical guitars out there, but it doesn't seem like a thing you can buy and even if you find one, it will certainly not be affordable and some of them don't respect the shape of the classical anymore. D:

  • @cmw9876
    @cmw9876 Рік тому +2

    Glorious sound from carbon fibre - I have become a believer in this technology.

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  Рік тому

      Happy to hear! Thanks for watching! 🤗

    • @ThomasTVP
      @ThomasTVP 6 місяців тому +1

      Glorious sound. Are you deaf?

    • @LRPhotographer
      @LRPhotographer 4 місяці тому +1

      @@ThomasTVP Hi, Thomas. I hope you're doing well. I wanted to follow up on your posts in which you seem to prefer issuing insults rather than contributions to the discussion. Is there a purpose to your posts and, if so, what is it?

    • @ThomasTVP
      @ThomasTVP 4 місяці тому

      @@LRPhotographer I just made clear that because of the limitations imposed on carbon fibre instruments by the material (that no luthier can change) especially in terms of resonance, they're only usable for specific purposes, eg. playing outside.

  • @RupertRumble
    @RupertRumble Рік тому

    I want to be able to play mine like you one day! 😮

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  Рік тому +1

      Awww, practice, practice and practice 🤗

  • @timcraig1161
    @timcraig1161 Рік тому

    i just bought one from you through reverb the e and a strings the d finally tuned to pitc but the g string broke and c stringthe never would tune to standard low c

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  Рік тому

      Hi Tim! We don't sell via Reverb. May I ask what issues you are having, and which instrument?

  • @charlottesmom
    @charlottesmom 11 місяців тому

    I watched for the information👍🏻🎻, my dog watched tilted head for the music! 😂

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  11 місяців тому +1

      Awww, how cute! We need a picture 😃

  • @srinitaaigaura
    @srinitaaigaura Рік тому +6

    The carbon fiber gets better at higher frequencies because of its stiffness, but the lower you go the more nasal it sounds. It just doesn't have the richness of lower frequencies.

    • @StuninRub
      @StuninRub Рік тому

      Why the fuck are you playing a violin for it's lows?

    • @dont-want-no-wrench
      @dont-want-no-wrench Рік тому

      just my impression as well.

    • @ThomasTVP
      @ThomasTVP 6 місяців тому

      Because it can never have the resonance decent wooden violins have.

  • @Valentina__helen
    @Valentina__helen Рік тому +1

    which one is better??

  • @alicebish9956
    @alicebish9956 2 роки тому +2

    What about the carbon fiber violas?

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  2 роки тому +1

      Yes, that would be another great video to cover. The majority of properties still translate to viola. But let us know if you'd like to give a carbon fiber viola a try!

    • @alicebish9956
      @alicebish9956 2 роки тому +1

      @@Fiddlershop It would be great to hear if there is any difference in sound quality from a 15” or even 15.5” carbon fiber viola to a 16” carbon fiber viola. And also to hear your opinion on whether the trade off in sound quality (if any) is worth the additional difficulty of getting around a bigger viola. Yes, I “can” play a 16”, but if I have to play for 6 hours or more in one day 15” is a better choice.

    • @jameschristiansson3137
      @jameschristiansson3137 Рік тому

      @@alicebish9956 Did you get one ?

    • @alicebish9956
      @alicebish9956 Рік тому +1

      @@jameschristiansson3137 no. I did buy a carbon fiber bow though

    • @nickiemcnichols5397
      @nickiemcnichols5397 Рік тому

      I knew a lady who had a carbon fiber cello. Tonally, I couldn’t tell it from any wooden cello.

  • @JStephs1950
    @JStephs1950 Рік тому +1

    To my ear (which is aging and missing upper register overtones), the sound of the instruments is somewhat dead - an incomplete array of frequencies. So far, these instruments seem like they'd make good band instruments, especially to replace the standard electric violin, but they are not something for even semi-professional or good amateur groups. Student-level setups are pretty inexpensive (and sound it). It would be interesting to hear how a cheap carbon-fiber student level violin sounds and how much it costs in comparison.
    Another important issue is resonance. If the carbon-fiber instruments resonate too much (it doesn't sound like they do), then there will be frequency interference between notes which increases as speed increases.
    Also, what do they sound like in high registers? This demo shows instruments that would be good for Celtic, folk and C&W music, but not classical music.
    Cost is really the key indicator here, along with the need for durability (the most prominent of the secondary issues). What kind of sound do you get for your money?

    • @JMaxwell1000
      @JMaxwell1000 Рік тому +1

      Those are my feelings too, almost exactly. Very well stated.

  • @kc8hyg
    @kc8hyg 2 роки тому +1

    I need one.

  • @nekyayala1964
    @nekyayala1964 25 днів тому

    The violin carbon fiber comes with the case and bow?

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  22 дні тому

      Thanks for watching!

    • @nekyayala1964
      @nekyayala1964 22 дні тому +2

      @Fiddlershop you did not answer my question?

    • @MagSidious
      @MagSidious 8 днів тому +1

      While I am not affiliated with Fiddlershop, I can tell you that the Glasser Carbon does not (I bought one from them). The Mezzo-Forte also looks like they do not (their website).

    • @nekyayala1964
      @nekyayala1964 8 днів тому

      @@MagSidious thanks

  • @mccypr
    @mccypr 2 роки тому +1

    Great info! Can one change the bridge on the Glasser to a wooden one? Thanks! 😎

    • @nroll1181
      @nroll1181 Рік тому

      You can do whatever you want to it

  • @rolandrohde
    @rolandrohde 2 роки тому

    How would you compare these two with Luis and Clark and Carbon Klang instruments?

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  2 роки тому +3

      I know it's hard to appear objective, but in my opintion Mezzo Forte instruments are pretty close to Luis and Clark instruments. The advantage is that MF's are more easily available, L&C intruments have (last we heard) been out of stock everywhere or been on backorder for months if you order directly from them.
      Carbon Klang instruments are very nice, albeit significantly more expensive, so the very slight difference in sound quality is hard to justify for the price compared to Mezzo Forte. (-Gibbles)

  • @nirvairsingh8233
    @nirvairsingh8233 2 роки тому +1

    Can u put a wooden bridge and sound post in the glasser? Is that a video in the future, with pi strings 🤞... nice instruments!

  • @jcthejfreak
    @jcthejfreak 2 роки тому

    Is it a good idea to use a set of PI strings on the MF violin?

    • @mynameisnotlight
      @mynameisnotlight Рік тому

      It depends on how often you would use the violin, and whether you think it’s worth it or not.
      If you’re going to be using the cf violin in performances and practice on it daily as if it’s your main instrument, then i think the pi will be plently worth it.

  • @sashakindel3600
    @sashakindel3600 Рік тому

    The look of that Glasser instrument is quite beautiful.

  • @patriciajrs46
    @patriciajrs46 6 місяців тому

    Were you saying that one of the qualities of the carbon fiber models is their resistance to weather? If that's the case they might perhaps be a much better choice for students and beginners.

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  6 місяців тому

      Thanks for watching! I wouldn't say that. There are working musicians that may play more outdoor events or gigs than indoors that would benefit greatly from a carbon fiber violin for those reasons. Taking out your good violin in humid or dry conditions can have adverse effects on wood instruments, which could lead to costly repairs.

  • @dobeycalvin7571
    @dobeycalvin7571 2 роки тому +1

    ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

  • @robgrune3284
    @robgrune3284 Рік тому

    In the vocation, these are known as VSO: violin shaped object. They have none of the tonal qualities of a classic violin. I suppose you get what you pay for: $1000 for a carbon VSO that may or may not be adequate for gigs, depending upon the demands of the gig; eg. fiddler. I suppose this could be useful as a teaching/learning tool; a VSO that can be knocked about, watered, heated, etc.

    • @robgrune3284
      @robgrune3284 Рік тому

      @iiiiiiiv thank you for confirming the tonal quality is dissimilar to a fine wooden violin.

  • @timcraig1161
    @timcraig1161 Рік тому

    please help thanks tim

  • @janesmith8316
    @janesmith8316 2 роки тому +1

    I can't believe the price tag on these instruments. 😮

    • @Fiddlershop
      @Fiddlershop  2 роки тому

      Good or bad, Jane?

    • @janesmith8316
      @janesmith8316 2 роки тому

      @@Fiddlershop I don't know if it's good or bad I just had an expectation of a lower price point for them.

    • @rolandrohde
      @rolandrohde 2 роки тому +2

      @@janesmith8316
      A decent quality wooden instrument (new) starts at 30K Euro these days...so...

  • @MAGIC_JEFF
    @MAGIC_JEFF Рік тому +1

    smash

  • @lgyqchen5074
    @lgyqchen5074 Рік тому +1

    The carbon fiber violins sound like a wooden violin without sound post.

  • @ThomasTVP
    @ThomasTVP 6 місяців тому

    The problem of ALL carbon fiber violins is the lack of resonance that is inherent in the material. There is no richness to the sound, there can't be. The Mezzo-forte does sound cleaner though.