The Ladykillers (1955) -- What Makes This Movie Great? (Episode 18)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 67

  • @grahamboffey457
    @grahamboffey457 6 місяців тому +4

    I was convinced for years that Alec Guinness’ character was Alistair Sym, such was his majesty of the role. Great film.

  • @aktolman
    @aktolman Рік тому +7

    This film is an absolute master piece - the acting and script really is something else.

  • @routemaster19
    @routemaster19 3 роки тому +18

    Katie Johnson was so determined to get the part of Mrs Wilberforce she offered to pay for her own insurance on the production (in case she passed away during filming!) She had only really done bit parts before on film but she knew this was her role. She won the Best Actress BAFTA for it. She passed on 2 years later leaving this as her legacy.
    It was one of the last films made at Ealing Studios themselves, before it was sold to the BBC. Ealing as a production company made a few more films in Elstree but the golden years were behind them. The actual Ealing studios are still very much in use and are the oldest purpose built film studios in the UK.

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому +1

      excellent comments, thank you.

    • @5610winston
      @5610winston 7 місяців тому +2

      She was a wonderful actress, and it seemed as if the role was written for her.
      [STRAIGHTENS HAT] "...and who is Mrs. Lopsided?"

    • @5610winston
      @5610winston 7 місяців тому

      As I recall, Herbert Lom who played Peter Sellers's boss in the _Pink Panther_ films played secons viola i _Ladykillers_

  • @featherstone5838
    @featherstone5838 5 місяців тому +2

    I was never terribly fond of movies, until I saw the Ladykillers in the mid 70s. It convinced me that movies can be works of art.

  • @2011littlejohn1
    @2011littlejohn1 3 роки тому +8

    One of the gems of my early teens. Alec Guiness's talented versatility is so impressive it irritates the hell out of me that younger people can only remember that cowboys in outer space thing he did.

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому

      Hey, that's cowboys and ROBOTS in outer space. Do not forget the robots!

    • @2011littlejohn1
      @2011littlejohn1 3 роки тому

      @@LearningaboutMovies :) I liked them the best but Data's the man. (pun intended).

  • @SuperCosmicMutantSquid
    @SuperCosmicMutantSquid 6 місяців тому +3

    I joke but it's amazing that Alec somehow looked YOUNGER when he played Obi Wan than in this. He looks like a ghoul but has the mannerisms of a kind gentleman and the heart of a right bastard.

  • @franl155
    @franl155 4 роки тому +12

    I've read that Alec Guinness was doing a take of Alastair Sim from London Belongs To Me - in fact, Sim commented that he's had praise for a film that he never appeared in

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  4 роки тому

      very interesting.

    • @5610winston
      @5610winston 7 місяців тому

      @@LearningaboutMovies Alastair Sim as the madam of a British girls' public (what we Americans would call _private_ ) school and her twin brother, a crooked turf accountant.
      Miss Fritten: "They may close Saint Trinians!"
      Teacher Rose: "Thank heavens, someone's seen the light."
      Miss Fritten: "May I remind you, Rose, that if they close Saint Trinians it will be at least five years before YOU see the light?"

  • @fredericfournier5662
    @fredericfournier5662 Рік тому +1

    A few years ago, Bertrand Tavernier released in France a DVD box in which we could find 8 Ealing films and a documentary about the history of Ealing Studios.
    -The Ladykillers
    -It always rains on sunday
    -Whent the day well ?
    -The man in the white suit
    -The lavender hill mob
    -Kind Hearts and coronets
    -Whisky galore
    -Champagne Charlie
    It's a pleasure to watch these films from a different time and some of the characters and situations are still going on, like the social story behind "The man in the white suit" one of my favorites, full of poetry however.
    Greetings from France 🎥
    I suscribe !

  • @mango4ttwo635
    @mango4ttwo635 Рік тому +1

    my favourite Ealing comedy by far. I'd also recommend Kind Hearts and Coronets, and Passport to Pimlico. Perhaps old, but some gems and this one top of the lot. And yes, Mrs Lopsided takes the biscuit

  • @chris221195
    @chris221195 4 роки тому +6

    You are absoluty right! One of my favorite old movies of all time! My parents love this movie and we watched it often together! I am now 24 and I still enjoy it! Very nice review, I will keep my eyes on your channel for more reviews like that! Thank you

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  4 роки тому

      thank you.

    • @antoniosilvestro2494
      @antoniosilvestro2494 3 роки тому +1

      I love films full stop of varying cultures. English films I love the most. This is one of my favourites and I love the silent films and Laurel and Hardy & Chaplin movies & WIZARD OF OZ 1939 classic. When I was a kid growing up we had great comedy in the 70's. BLESS THIS HOUSE & PORRIDGE & RISING DAMP & TWO RONNIES & KEN DODD & DICK EMERY & FRANKIE HOWERD & BENNY HILL & SID JAMES & GEORGE & MILDRED & LIVER BIRDS et al

  • @jkhalsa
    @jkhalsa 4 роки тому +5

    Just saw it for the first time tonight. Recommendation of a friend. We thought it was great too. Thanks for your review. Your smiling eyes make it a pleasure to listen to..

  • @skiddmark7153
    @skiddmark7153 3 роки тому +6

    Absolute British classic when the remake came out with tom Hanks I could only watch ten minutes before i ejected the CD and promptly chucked it in the trash.

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому +3

      yes. that's the only Coens Brothers movie I refuse to watch.

    • @leifvejby8023
      @leifvejby8023 8 місяців тому +1

      I endured about ten minutes too.

  • @Dallas-Nyberg
    @Dallas-Nyberg 2 роки тому +2

    I have lost count of how many times I have watched this classic movie.. it is a gem.
    I have also watched the Cohen brothers version. It is OK, up to a point, but it is nowhere as good as the original.

  • @williamburnham3659
    @williamburnham3659 3 роки тому +8

    May I recommend two Alistair Sim films
    Green for Danger and Scrooge ( 1951) He was an absolute genius

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому

      yes, excellent!

    • @5610winston
      @5610winston 7 місяців тому +1

      As I recall, Sim also appeared in the Peter O'Toole film _The Ruling Class._

  • @LauraSeabrook
    @LauraSeabrook 4 роки тому +7

    Many of the older British comedies hold up to repeated viewing. In addition to this film, I love ANCHORS AWAY (aka BARNACLE BILL) and THE SMALLEST SHOW ON EARTH.

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  4 роки тому

      thank you.

    • @5610winston
      @5610winston 7 місяців тому

      I loved the _Carry On_ films. Not as genteel, but Sid James was a crossover actor between Ealing and the Carry Ons.

  • @DenkyManner
    @DenkyManner 6 місяців тому +1

    Everyone in it is superb, including Katie Johnson. Alec Guinness was never better IMO, though he's excellent in many films. Hard to believe it is two years before Bridge on The River Kwai. What other actor could play both roles so flawlessly?

  • @markdettra1794
    @markdettra1794 2 роки тому +2

    There's no comparison between the 1955's and Tom Hank's. The original has a quality level which is compelling , like Hitchcock's 'Vertigo' , only with bittersweet humor and irony. The acting is absolutely superb , like observing a real event.

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  2 роки тому +1

      I think it's one of the few moments where the Coens slipped.

    • @roberthill799
      @roberthill799 7 місяців тому +1

      Agreed. It was uninspired and unnecessary. And I consider Tom Hanks to be very overrated. He's not bad. Just not as great as he is hyped up to be.

  • @ericgander1272
    @ericgander1272 3 роки тому

    One of the greats! They just released a 65 anniversary 4k box set you can get on amazon U.K. I just bought it! The 4k restoration looks amazing!

  • @ying2217
    @ying2217 3 роки тому +3

    Watched it last night, it is a shame my flatmate hates this film because she thinks it doesn't make sense when most of the robbers are pretty stupid (and I think some old British humor doesn't click with her
    But I think she really missed the point
    This film definitely has its faults but the plot is interesting and I love the house and the backyard right above train tracks, creating some memorable scenes and atmosphere
    I won't say it is my favorite but there are a lot of elements in the film which I find enjoyable and inspiring

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому +1

      hate?? robbers are stupid, most of them. these guys aren't that bad. glad you liked it!

    • @ying2217
      @ying2217 3 роки тому +1

      @@LearningaboutMovies I guess she just expects criminals have to be intelligent and as a group they should be more united, instead of arguing all the time
      That's why I say she really missed the point, which is quite a shame

    • @mrowley7300
      @mrowley7300 3 роки тому +1

      @@ying2217 there is the saying no honour among thieves

  • @johnhughes3796
    @johnhughes3796 2 роки тому

    Great movie of course. Many get confused between Guinness and Alastair Sim, another Ealing actor, in this as Guinness looks unlike his usual self.

  • @dylanclements2485
    @dylanclements2485 2 роки тому +1

    It's a masterpiece in every way 💕

  • @Steven_Rowe
    @Steven_Rowe 3 роки тому +1

    Google Katie Johnson and she is almost an unknown, your absolutely correct about her,it is as if this was her in real life.
    I love Danny Green aka one round the thick eared muscle man who in reality has a huge heart.
    The house was a mock up at the end of Frederica street and it was next to the portal of the southern end of Copenhagen tunnel.
    At the other end of Frederica street is Caledonian road where the famous Pentonville Prison is.
    It is famous for the hangings of Timothy Evans and Reg Christie from 10 Rillington place.
    I just find it ironic that these 5 miscreants would pull a robbery so close to the prison, a place they would surely have gone to if they had been caught.

  • @banddirector23
    @banddirector23 3 роки тому +2

    You're right, the old English lady plays a great old English lady.

  • @minskie
    @minskie 3 роки тому +2

    And the remake with Tom Hanks is abhorrently sacrilegious.

  • @minskie
    @minskie 3 роки тому

    Nice review! how old are you?

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому

      thank you. 41.

    • @minskie
      @minskie 3 роки тому

      @@LearningaboutMovies you have excellent taste in film for a youngin'. ;)

  • @matthewbolitho-jones
    @matthewbolitho-jones 4 місяці тому

    I like The Ladykillers

  • @AlonsoRules
    @AlonsoRules 3 роки тому +4

    Ladykillers is a great film - superbly written, backed up by great acting and music. One of the finest British films ever.
    The remake on the other hand is a disgrace to cinema. The Coens have made great films like Fargo and No Country for Old Men, but Ladykillers is certainly not their finest work.

  • @5610winston
    @5610winston 3 роки тому

    The 2004 "remake'" of this wonderful film isn't fit to be mentioned in the same breath.
    Likewise the "remake" of "Last Holiday".
    At least "The Lavender Hill Mob" has been spared this indignity.
    And they could never remake "Kind Hearts and Coronets" or "The Belles of Saint Trinians" or any of the "Carry On...."series.

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому

      yes, none of these could be remade, plus "Man in the White Suit" and "Captain Paradise".

    • @5610winston
      @5610winston 3 роки тому

      @@LearningaboutMovies Captain's Paradise! Yvonne de Carlo was HOT!

    • @roberthill799
      @roberthill799 7 місяців тому

      Thanks for reminding me of "Kind Hearts..."! I haven't seen that since I was ten--over fifty years ago!

  • @superninja493
    @superninja493 3 роки тому

    I decided to watch this film last night, I had the idea of doing it since watching the YTP: The Trainkillers: ua-cam.com/video/KcxiMoVOa10/v-deo.html and The Ladykillers is a very good movie, I think I might stay away from the 2004 one though

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  3 роки тому

      yes, watch the original for sure.

    • @superninja493
      @superninja493 3 роки тому

      @@LearningaboutMovies I showed the film to my mum yesterday, we both give it a 9/10, the original of course

  • @sidv192
    @sidv192 2 роки тому

    How is this better than the Coen Brothers? I tried to watch two minutes and was bored out of my skull

    • @LearningaboutMovies
      @LearningaboutMovies  2 роки тому +2

      This website is free, and with commenters like this, you get what you paid for.

    • @roberthill799
      @roberthill799 7 місяців тому +2

      If you have that short of an attention span, I suggest you stick to reruns of The Brady Bunch and Baywatch.