Fans of Daniel, don’t be angry at Dimash, if not for him singing this song I never would’ve found Daniel. I looked into his life and cried about his tragic and untimely death. He is alive for me, a new fan and I’ve listened to his beautiful voice so many times since. If not for Dimash, I would not have found this gift.
Balavoine ❤️ toutes ces chansons sont formidables, et comme quelqu’un a dit, un grand ami de Michel Berger. Mais pour moi, le seul qui ait vraiment pu rendre justice à cette chanson, c’est Grégory Lemarchal. Ne l’oubliez pas, lui et sa voix d’ange qui est mort si jeune. Daniel Balavoine et Gregory Lemarchal avaient des voix aux nuances magnifiques. J’habite en Angleterre, je ne connais pas Dimash mais je sais que cette chanson est très dure à chanter mais ça ne veut pas dire que quelqu’un dont la voix ne monte pas aussi haut ou ne descend pas aussi bas ne peut pas bien la chanter. Ce qu’il fait pour la chanter, c’est du cœur, pas la chanter pour just fame or money.
@@irened.Gregorio a participar a un concurso.il a chanter tres bien. Así comme il etait malade ,il est mort peu apres les gens ont aimer surtout por son probleme de santé.Il falta ecouter la versión de Dimash,car c est un grand homenaje a cette chanson❤❤❤❤
@ghislaine3016 Peut-être aussi remercier Luc Plamondon puisque c'est lui qui a écrit les paroles. Michel Berger a composé la musique et non les paroles.
For the record, the music for the song "SOS d'un terrien en détresse" was composed by Michel Berger (a very great French composer) especially to exploit the vocal qualities of Daniel Balavoine who, for his part, add soul to it as he did to all his interpretations. This video that you have just watched is truly unique because it is the only time (in 1985) we can see him sang this song live on French TV before his tragic death on January 14, 1986. Because of the great Ethiopian famines, Daniel was committed to Africa through the Paris-Dakar Rally. And it was during the transport of water pumps for the cultivation of rice that he died, along with 4 others, in a helicopter accident while flying over the Malian desert. This man was just great in everything.
FROMfriend toLOVE (cest in English, SORRY 4 any inconveniences) 8 hours ago hello, if interested, have a glimpse, 1. What dreams may come - (film) - (LOVE, sacrifice in public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/ 2 The Poseidon Adventure (1972), - (movie) - (LOVE, sacrifice + public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/ Steve Jobs' Life Advice Will Leave You SPEECHLESS, Steve Jobs' Speech Will Leave You SPEECHLESS | One of The Most Eye Opening Motivational Videos Ever.
FROMfriend toLOVE (cest in English, SORRY 4 any inconveniences) 8 hours ago hello, if interested, have a glimpse, 1. What dreams may come - (film) - (LOVE, sacrifice in public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/ 2 The Poseidon Adventure (1972), - (movie) - (LOVE, sacrifice + public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/ Steve Jobs' Life Advice Will Leave You SPEECHLESS, Steve Jobs' Speech Will Leave You SPEECHLESS | One of The Most Eye Opening Motivational Videos Ever.
Yes you are right the lyrics were written by Luc Plamondon, When A great composer works with the master of lyrics it gives this absolutely masterpiece !! @@JChriz27
Спасибо вам за эту историю. Мне очень нравится песня и её исполнители. Трагические судьбы заставляют сжиматься сердце. Я желаю добра и счастья всем. А Димашу крепкого здоровья и творческих успехов!!!( Он мой соотечественник). Всех обнимаю, всем добра и счастья
Dimash can't express the same emotions as Daniel or Gregory because he doesn't understand what he sings and his version is so deformed he turned this amazing song into some operette ...
Me too. Funny how they criticize about emotions etc. I was moved by the way Dimash delivered each and every note and his version is so… moving. I don’t have to understand what he’s saying but emotions stirred up, just like when I listen to Lana Fabian sing Caruso at Albert hall with Hausser playing the cello.
Sans froisser les interprètes très talentueux des nouvelles versions, la voix de Balavoine transmet une émotion, une sensibilité, une vulnérabilité inégalables.
Honnêtement, personne ne peut transmettre les mêmes émotions que Balavoine, sa voix, son timbre, peut importe le nombre de fois que j'écoute cette chanson (et je le fais régulièrement) je suis toujours aussi bouleversée.
Une tristesse tellement profonde se fait partager par sa voix, son visage, sa gestuelle. C’est fou comme Daniel avait ce don de l’émotion. Que ce soit là colère, la mélancolie, le bonheur. J’ai des périodes où j’ai ce besoin d’écouter ses chansons. Il manque quand même.
I love that version, the original one interpretation.... Because that's what it is, the 70s, that atmosphere of that music... It's "falsetto" in the style of Gilliam, Byron and others ❤❤
@@ElisabethDarwiche-kn8xxThey both interpret it with their own feelings. It’s different but that’s it. In classical music you can have one single piece that gets interpreted in many different ways by various musicians. All of these interpretations are not wrong. Same here. Just like musicians have different interpretations we like certain interpretations more or less. I prefer Dimash, but my parents but prefer Daniel^^
Both are amazing musicians, no comparison needed. Daniel created and delivered a masterpiece of story and emotion, incredible song that's rightly a classic. Dimash paid homage to it by taking it to levels even Daniel would have approved of. The song and the listeners win in both cases.
@@holpcs2 Daniel would laugh his ass off--and he laughed like a loon. He would find this new version extraordinarily funny. (Don't worry, it's a French thing. And an old thing. Water under the bridge.)
@Marie C Jones I have only recently heard the Dimash version a few times now. Hearing Mr. Daniel sing it brings a more heartbroken feeling to the surface. It's beautiful! 😭❤️
@@lightendarkly27 also to me you can enjoy it over and over whereas the other ability is impressive but you'd get tired upon if you had to hear it on repeat.
Thanks to Dimash I came across this song for the first time - "sos d'un terrien en detresse". And what a song , a masterpieace all the way through.I can honestly say its the most beautiful and most sad song I have ever heard, and its with me now where ever I go. Thank you to all, Luc, Michel Berger, Balavoine and Dimash for everything.
Это ангельская песня, и каждый исполнитель, который ее исполняет, передает Душу, поэтому нельзя говорить что какой-то вариант лучше или хуже. Современные исполнители поют с более улучшенной техникой, а также изучают новые техники вокала. Через десять лет появятся еще более глубокие, безупречные и чувственные варианты песни. Также и прежние исполнители были на высоте своего времени и передавали Печаль Души.
Very often perfect technique takes away the soul in music. The human side, whether it's about joy or like in this song despair and hopelessness. Btw, nowadays Dimash sadly is a threatened species, that actually CAN sing, he sings live, and isn't using any kind of digital equipment to adjust his voice. What you hear is HIM singing. That's becoming more rare each year, I'm afraid. OF COURSE there are MANY good singers that can sing, very good too. But for some, to me STUPID, reason, some ANYWAY have their voices auto tuned, or manipulated in other ways on recordings, sometimes even on live performances (not playback, the signal from the microphone goes through a digital process, like auto tune, before it reaches the speakers.) This is what skilled people with the right programs can reveal, and you have a bunch of them on YT. (You can only imagine what the fans write in the comments, when their hero/heroine is exposed 😣. To be honest, when an older recording is reissued, it is usually processed, sometimes without permission from the artists, if they have sold the rights. In my opinion that's not ethnically defendable. Actually, it's about the same thing as unauthorized using someone's voice for AI. In my mind.
Daniel sang it first without knowing any other previous version. He didn 't study lyric and music at university level as Dimash did. He performed it live analogique and non digital without computers and digital effects. A man with a great deal of humanity and good haert who died standing for what He beleieved in. He did a lot for many. Artisticly I was truly surprised by the range of his voice through out this speachless and moving performance. I didn 't know he was hable of that many tones. RIP
French is my Language, so sorry for my weird English, Michel Berger has written the music of this song of "Starmania" specifically for Daniel Balavoine and Daniel carries so perfectly the rights emotions at the rights moments that I never have seen anybody else that did better than him, even dinash with his amazing, mind blowing voice, I cut the song before the end.
¿Y de donde sacas que Dimash usa efecto por computadoras? me parece que estas muy equivocado y no para decir que admiras a alguien le tenes que echar tierra a otra persona más a un buen ser humano como es Dimash , en cuanto a cantar con emoción y sentimiento el no tiene nada que envidiarle a nadie mira si tendrá sentimiento que es el único cantante que me hace llorar de emoción al escucharlo
Died standing for what he believed in? He died in a helicopter crash, when he was flying to assist a football match organised during Paris-Dakar. So what did he believe in, according to you: helicopters? football? Paris-Dakar?
Las dos versiones son hermosas. Personalmente me gusta más la de Dimash, no usa computadoras ni efectos digitales, como vos decís. Genéticamente está dotado de cuerdas vocales maravillosas, pero tuvo que trabajar duro para poder encausar tanta energía y capacidad. No demerezcamos a ninguno de los dos, por favor.
I also came here due to Dimash but more because I also wanted to hear the story and original emotions behind this song. And I must say I am deeply impressed by this interpretation. Thanks for uploading it.
I think sometimes people forget that you can love and/or appreciate two versions of the same thing without putting either version down. Dimash has incredible vocal technique and range and he showed it off brilliantly while singing his cover. Daniel has that raw emotion that hits you in the back of your throat and he's still hitting very difficult notes in a range that most people can't sing. Both versions are absolutely beautiful for a multitude of different reasons and each deserve to be celebrated and put on repeat.
¡Hermoso! No se puede comparar a Daniel Valavoine y Dimash... Ambos son excelentes.. Si no hubiera escuchado esta canción en Dimash, jamás hubiera llegado a escuchar esta bella canción, 🤗
Je viens juste de decouvrir cette chanson par le petit Soan (The Voice Kids France 2019), et je me vois obliger de trouver Balavoine... Comment ne pas pleurer en ecoutant une telle chanson? Merci Balavoine.- Merci Luc Plamondon
Normand Groulx, Alexis Carlier, Antoine Wend, Bruno Pelletier, Piet Arion, Dimash Qudaibergen et de nombreux autres interprètes de cette merveilleuse chanson méritent une grande reconnaissance. Daniel Balavoine était le premier.
I don't understand any of the debates in here tbh. Daniel Balavoine was interpreting the character from Starmania, with his words, his feelings, his past. Dimash is proposing a vocal performance and I guess he had to learn everything phonetically, he is very impressive indeed. But the two performances don't have the same goal at all, the aim of Dimash is an impressive vocal performance and the aim of Daniel was to interpret a character. (with an impressive vocal performance, as a result haha)
onsoir , j'espère que je ne vous pose pas de soucis moi c'est pamiene. Juste pour savoir si vous faite partie des grands amateur de la musique francaise et aussi mieux faire votre connaissance . Essayer de me joindre à cette adresse ci dessous :pamienelabelge405@gmail.com .Exellente journée à vous Merci .
I agree. And I prefer Gregory's version over Daniel. Dimash is my favorite singer, but for this song, he is behind Gregory and Daniel because he just hit the notes, but not really feel the song. I don't care about his pronounciation, but he totally skip and miss some important parts of the song (to just do the more impressive one). But he's still my favorite singer, because I know he can sing with a lot of emotion and passion, he did it a lot. But of course, it was a vocal show at The Singer
Technically Dimash is probably the most gifted singer I've heard but in this version the emotion for me is more evident. Even though I do not understand French I feel this song needs a certain vulnerability. French is such a beautiful language on the ear.
The way he sings it suits the lyrics so much. Someone "normal" would try to sing pretty, but he's not someone "normal". He's someone who sticks out, who doesn't see the world like other people, and he sings in a way that's not usual at all.
Came here because Dimash. I am a big fan of Dimash. The vocal range of Dimash is inhuman but, Gregory Lemarch and Daniel have their own way to touch souls and minds too. So happy to discover such beautiful voices 😍
@@КайратЕлибаев-щ5ы А это твоя любимая певица? Не иначе .Если ты ее всем советуешь послушать !.Как раз достойный твоего вкуса и ума выбор . Приятного тебе прослушивания Ольги Бузовой !
It's nice to hear the original. I got curious about the vocal arrangement and had know how what this sounded like. Just look at his eyes and you will see all the emotion.
Как здорово, что остались все эти записи.. вот она.. история музыки ❤❤❤
3 роки тому+34
Very pleasant to hear. I love this old song vibe and, in fact, it's a good old song and his voice sings it amazingly! Of course, like many here, I got to know this song through Dimash, who really did an incredible job giving it his own colors. But it's clear: no matter what your favorite version is, both are beautiful, and Dimash chose to sing SOS because this version exists and he appreciates it in Daniel's voice. Neither invalidates the other, and everyone is different from each other.
Such a beautiful and heartfelt rendition. This song was, I believe, written for him and his unusual vocal range, for the musical Starmania in the '70s. This man is singing a story...I would love to see the musical if it is available. I love Dimash too, just very different contexts. Beautiful, moving song, no matter the singer. RIP Daniel Balavoine.
Yes, it was wriiten for him. Michel Berger, the composer, knew exactly Daniel and his vocal capacities. they were friends. There is an english version of "Starmania": "Tycoon". I don´t know now, but before corona, "Starmania" still was played in Paris, but the 2nd version and setup, not the original version and setup of 1979. The one after Daniel, who had the vocal capacity to sing that song, was Renaud Hantson, in 1989-1990. Have a great day!
Dimash is an incredible singer, but he’s very much a _performer_ too. He’s singing is so bombastic and flashy that he doesn’t (I believe) capture the heart of the song, which is more somber and introspective. His version is still very good, but like you said, they’re very different contexts. Which you prefer will ultimately come down to personal preferences.
This is unbelievably beautiful 😥😥 there's something so sincere in his voice and this song just makes me cry. It takes a certain soul to sing a song like this ❤❤❤ it's freaking stunning! Also, the pain in @0:48 😥😥 I just cant even cope 💔
Well if you wanna feel Balavoine this was his speciallity famous for his emotions if you hear nay of his sounds they are most of them that way.... You can go listen to "LA vie ne m'apprend rien" From him all his sounds are that way
Nice to hear the original artist sing this song. I had never heard of this song until Dimash sang it, and while Dimash hits the high notes much more effortlessly than Daniel does, I do like this version almost as much. A very touching song.
In fairness I think Dimash covers Gregory Lemarchal's interpretation (on Star Academy). For example the end of the song, he ends it like Gregory does, not Balavoine. But either way, it is a beautiful song that has been beautifully interpreted by all three singers.
Bravo, je te découvre par hasard, à travers un talent show italien, qui a nommé Dimash et puis je suis arrivé à toi et viceversa. Les mots et ton interprétation me touchent énormément, vie ta vie, n'importe où tu es, tu es libre.
@@nathalieboisvert6676 Nathalie, c'était par rapport à la chanson, qui parle d'un homme en détresse, perdu... Donc j'ai dit: maintenant tu es libre de vivre ta vie, un peu philosophique
Ciertamente sin DIMASH no habría llegado a esta interpretación, extraordinaria, un cantante también adelantado a su época. Cada quien tiene lo suyo. Extraordinarios ambos.
@@gustavomachado7317 me too cause he is french and the original artist of the song so unlike Dimash i understand his prononciation and he sings the right lyrics at the right time.
Gracias por esta bella canción a su escritor Michel Berger y a Daniel por su primera y dulce interpretación sin ellos no hubiera sido posible escuchar hoy a nuestro amado 💖💖Dimash💖 interpretandola.
Bravo Daniel il a interprèter magnifiquement cette chanson. Des années après gregory à presque égale Daniel. Tout 2 sont partis trop jeune gregory 23 et Daniel 35 avant d'accueillir son 2 eme enfant après jeremy 2 ans johanna née après son décès rip a 2 grandes voix
Le français plus-que-parfait. .ça sent tellement vécu . l'original, et maintenant le SOS de Dimesh. .qu'en penser. .Voilà Dimesh c'est Belavoine 2020 en plein Tempête covid19. Je suis certain que Belavoine d'en haut applaudi Dimesh, digne de continuité : éternelle Question existentialiste.
You don't have to hate on one version of this song in order to appreciate and enjoy the other! Just love both versions for what they are and don't force your preferences on others! BE KIND!
По мне несколько дерганый звук, вызывает раздражение, при всем уважении к оригиналу. Всегда была большой фанаткой Пельтье и любила эту песню в его исполнении, но как прослушала в исполнении Нормана Гру, так она стала вообще моей любимой, такой лёгкий и в то же время щемяще - проникновенный вокал..
Fans of Daniel, don’t be angry at Dimash, if not for him singing this song I never would’ve found Daniel. I looked into his life and cried about his tragic and untimely death. He is alive for me, a new fan and I’ve listened to his beautiful voice so many times since. If not for Dimash, I would not have found this gift.
@Bentlee Damon No, just stop that, you wouldn't like it if somebody hacked into your account, don't do it to others anyone reading this.
@Bentlee Damon We give 0 shits about u
Thank you for sharing that sentiment.
Well said, I just learned about 3 amazing artists in one night! RIP❤️🙏🏼
I’m here because of Dimash, another great artist we need to remember!
Balavoine ❤️ toutes ces chansons sont formidables, et comme quelqu’un a dit, un grand ami de Michel Berger.
Mais pour moi, le seul qui ait vraiment pu rendre justice à cette chanson, c’est Grégory Lemarchal. Ne l’oubliez pas, lui et sa voix d’ange qui est mort si jeune.
Daniel Balavoine et Gregory Lemarchal avaient des voix aux nuances magnifiques.
J’habite en Angleterre, je ne connais pas Dimash mais je sais que cette chanson est très dure à chanter mais ça ne veut pas dire que quelqu’un dont la voix ne monte pas aussi haut ou ne descend pas aussi bas ne peut pas bien la chanter. Ce qu’il fait pour la chanter, c’est du cœur, pas la chanter pour just fame or money.
Escuchaste la versión de Dimash?
Gregory qui?? C'est un Britannique? Ou c'etait? J'habite aux USA, j'en ai jamais entendu parler.
Si tu ecoute Dimash,tu va aimer.❤❤❤
@@irened.Gregorio a participar a un concurso.il a chanter tres bien. Así comme il etait malade ,il est mort peu apres les gens ont aimer surtout por son probleme de santé.Il falta ecouter la versión de Dimash,car c est un grand homenaje a cette chanson❤❤❤❤
Je l'aime Balavoine depuis toujours j'ai 58 . Et je la chante tout aussi ému que a mon adolescence.. merci aussi Michel Berger
@ghislaine3016
Peut-être aussi remercier Luc Plamondon puisque c'est lui qui a écrit les paroles. Michel Berger a composé la musique et non les paroles.
For the record, the music for the song "SOS d'un terrien en détresse" was composed by Michel Berger (a very great French composer) especially to exploit the vocal qualities of Daniel Balavoine who, for his part, add soul to it as he did to all his interpretations. This video that you have just watched is truly unique because it is the only time (in 1985) we can see him sang this song live on French TV before his tragic death on January 14, 1986.
Because of the great Ethiopian famines, Daniel was committed to Africa through the Paris-Dakar Rally. And it was during the transport of water pumps for the cultivation of rice that he died, along with 4 others, in a helicopter accident while flying over the Malian desert. This man was just great in everything.
Yes but the auteur of this song was a french-canadian, Luc Plamondon! Dont forget it...
FROMfriend toLOVE
(cest in English, SORRY 4 any inconveniences)
8 hours ago
hello,
if interested,
have a glimpse,
1. What dreams may come
- (film)
- (LOVE, sacrifice in public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/
2 The Poseidon Adventure (1972),
- (movie)
- (LOVE, sacrifice + public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/
Steve Jobs' Life Advice Will Leave You SPEECHLESS,
Steve Jobs' Speech Will Leave You SPEECHLESS | One of The Most Eye Opening Motivational Videos Ever.
FROMfriend toLOVE
(cest in English, SORRY 4 any inconveniences)
8 hours ago
hello,
if interested,
have a glimpse,
1. What dreams may come
- (film)
- (LOVE, sacrifice in public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/
2 The Poseidon Adventure (1972),
- (movie)
- (LOVE, sacrifice + public-spirited professionism like patroit in reality)/
Steve Jobs' Life Advice Will Leave You SPEECHLESS,
Steve Jobs' Speech Will Leave You SPEECHLESS | One of The Most Eye Opening Motivational Videos Ever.
Yes you are right the lyrics were written by Luc Plamondon,
When A great composer works with the master of lyrics it gives this absolutely masterpiece !! @@JChriz27
Спасибо вам за эту историю. Мне очень нравится песня и её исполнители. Трагические судьбы заставляют сжиматься сердце. Я желаю добра и счастья всем. А Димашу крепкого здоровья и творческих успехов!!!( Он мой соотечественник). Всех обнимаю, всем добра и счастья
Dimash brought me here and I now have a lot of respect for Daniel.
Same
Dimash can't express the same emotions as Daniel or Gregory because he doesn't understand what he sings and his version is so deformed he turned this amazing song into some operette ...
See although I adore Dimash’s voice. He over-sings the song and that affects the emotional outcomes … I love Daniel’s version way way more …
Me too.
Funny how they criticize about emotions etc.
I was moved by the way Dimash delivered each and every note and his version is so… moving. I don’t have to understand what he’s saying but emotions stirred up, just like when I listen to Lana Fabian sing Caruso at Albert hall with Hausser playing the cello.
@@divinel1249dimash's version is a million times better than this lol.
Sans froisser les interprètes très talentueux des nouvelles versions, la voix de Balavoine transmet une émotion, une sensibilité, une vulnérabilité inégalables.
1000% d'accord... sublime de sensibilité.
Honnêtement, personne ne peut transmettre les mêmes émotions que Balavoine, sa voix, son timbre, peut importe le nombre de fois que j'écoute cette chanson (et je le fais régulièrement) je suis toujours aussi bouleversée.
De acordo...uma voz única. O melhor intérprete.
Génio. Génio. Génio. Que talento ...que afinação. Nem parece possível.
Unique
Une tristesse tellement profonde se fait partager par sa voix, son visage, sa gestuelle. C’est fou comme Daniel avait ce don de l’émotion. Que ce soit là colère, la mélancolie, le bonheur. J’ai des périodes où j’ai ce besoin d’écouter ses chansons. Il manque quand même.
Верю, он воскреснет . В день всеобщего воскресения и будет с Богом,он имел веру и любящее сердце ♥️
I love that version, the original one interpretation....
Because that's what it is, the 70s, that atmosphere of that music... It's "falsetto" in the style of Gilliam, Byron and others ❤❤
As a huge Dimash fan, I just gotta say this version is absolutely breathtaking. What passion and connection to the music...
This is *the* version.
I'm sorry, but dimash is singing it mor pure.
@@ElisabethDarwiche-kn8xxThey both interpret it with their own feelings. It’s different but that’s it. In classical music you can have one single piece that gets interpreted in many different ways by various musicians. All of these interpretations are not wrong. Same here. Just like musicians have different interpretations we like certain interpretations more or less. I prefer Dimash, but my parents but prefer Daniel^^
The original song not that weird dimash interprétation
@@ElisabethDarwiche-kn8xx😂😂😂😂😂 nope
Both are amazing musicians, no comparison needed. Daniel created and delivered a masterpiece of story and emotion, incredible song that's rightly a classic. Dimash paid homage to it by taking it to levels even Daniel would have approved of. The song and the listeners win in both cases.
Daniel would say: "where is the humility?"
@@alyagab8553 That's what YOU would say.
@@holpcs2 Daniel would laugh his ass off--and he laughed like a loon. He would find this new version extraordinarily funny. (Don't worry, it's a French thing. And an old thing. Water under the bridge.)
@Marie C Jones I have only recently heard the Dimash version a few times now. Hearing Mr. Daniel sing it brings a more heartbroken feeling to the surface. It's beautiful! 😭❤️
@@lightendarkly27 also to me you can enjoy it over and over whereas the other ability is impressive but you'd get tired upon if you had to hear it on repeat.
Let’s not forget the original artist, Daniel Balavoine, without him this song wouldn’t exist, RIP🙏🏼❤️
Je ne le lasserai jamais de t écouter
Daniel and dimash are great singer. Just different era
i agree
Yeah, one is from era where talent and depth were here, the other is from a narcissistic era with no depth.
Лемаршаль вообще ангел по сравнению с ними ...песня была написана для него !
Thanks to Dimash I came across this song for the first time - "sos d'un terrien en detresse". And what a song , a masterpieace all the way through.I can honestly say its the most beautiful and most sad song I have ever heard, and its with me now where ever I go. Thank you to all, Luc, Michel Berger, Balavoine and Dimash for everything.
Это ангельская песня, и каждый исполнитель, который ее исполняет, передает Душу, поэтому нельзя говорить что какой-то вариант лучше или хуже. Современные исполнители поют с более улучшенной техникой, а также изучают новые техники вокала. Через десять лет появятся еще более глубокие, безупречные и чувственные варианты песни. Также и прежние исполнители были на высоте своего времени и передавали Печаль Души.
Very often perfect technique takes away the soul in music. The human side, whether it's about joy or like in this song despair and hopelessness.
Btw, nowadays Dimash sadly is a threatened species, that actually CAN sing, he sings live, and isn't using any kind of digital equipment to adjust his voice. What you hear is HIM singing.
That's becoming more rare each year, I'm afraid.
OF COURSE there are MANY good singers that can sing, very good too. But for some, to me STUPID, reason, some ANYWAY have their voices auto tuned, or manipulated in other ways on recordings, sometimes even on live performances (not playback, the signal from the microphone goes through a digital process, like auto tune, before it reaches the speakers.)
This is what skilled people with the right programs can reveal, and you have a bunch of them on YT. (You can only imagine what the fans write in the comments, when their hero/heroine is exposed 😣.
To be honest, when an older recording is reissued, it is usually processed, sometimes without permission from the artists, if they have sold the rights. In my opinion that's not ethnically defendable.
Actually, it's about the same thing as unauthorized using someone's voice for AI. In my mind.
We can say what we want about other singers if we want to ...we are in free countries 😂😂😂😂
Je ne me lasse pas. Je ne m'en lasse pas. Merci Balavoine. Félicités éternelles !
Io amo questa canzone. ❤ E ho sentito tante versioni. Mi piace sempre e mi fa. Volare. Grazie😊
Tellement belle cette chanson... surtout lorsque c'est lui-même qui la chante
Daniel sang it first without knowing any other previous version. He didn 't study lyric and music at university level as Dimash did. He performed it live analogique and non digital without computers and digital effects. A man with a great deal of humanity and good haert who died standing for what He beleieved in. He did a lot for many. Artisticly I was truly surprised by the range of his voice through out this speachless and moving performance. I didn 't know he was hable of that many tones. RIP
French is my Language, so sorry for my weird English, Michel Berger has written the music of this song of "Starmania" specifically for Daniel Balavoine and Daniel carries so perfectly the rights emotions at the rights moments that I never have seen anybody else that did better than him, even dinash with his amazing, mind blowing voice, I cut the song before the end.
¿Y de donde sacas que Dimash usa efecto por computadoras? me parece que estas muy equivocado y no para decir que admiras a alguien le tenes que echar tierra a otra persona más a un buen ser humano como es Dimash , en cuanto a cantar con emoción y sentimiento el no tiene nada que envidiarle a nadie mira si tendrá sentimiento que es el único cantante que me hace llorar de emoción al escucharlo
Beautiful. He sang is great! Good points 👍😇🎶🎵.
Died standing for what he believed in? He died in a helicopter crash, when he was flying to assist a football match organised during Paris-Dakar. So what did he believe in, according to you: helicopters? football? Paris-Dakar?
Las dos versiones son hermosas. Personalmente me gusta más la de Dimash, no usa computadoras ni efectos digitales, como vos decís. Genéticamente está dotado de cuerdas vocales maravillosas, pero tuvo que trabajar duro para poder encausar tanta energía y capacidad. No demerezcamos a ninguno de los dos, por favor.
I also came here due to Dimash but more because I also wanted to hear the story and original emotions behind this song.
And I must say I am deeply impressed by this interpretation. Thanks for uploading it.
Tres cher Daniel:tu nous a quitté beaucoup trop tot;et cette chanson m'emeu au+profond de moi.Repose en Paix
Incroyable Daniel ! Repose en paix
I think sometimes people forget that you can love and/or appreciate two versions of the same thing without putting either version down. Dimash has incredible vocal technique and range and he showed it off brilliantly while singing his cover. Daniel has that raw emotion that hits you in the back of your throat and he's still hitting very difficult notes in a range that most people can't sing. Both versions are absolutely beautiful for a multitude of different reasons and each deserve to be celebrated and put on repeat.
Exactly
Согласна с Вами,полностью.
I agree with you completely
I don't know who Daniel is. But because of Dimash I got to hear SOS. I am thankful to hear such a Beautiful song. Much respect for Daniel.
Daniel wrote that song
@@restervivant3210 This song was written by Berger and Luke Plamondon for the rock opera Starmania, and Daniel was the lead actor.
@@restervivant3210 This song was written by Michel Berger for Daniel
¡Hermoso! No se puede comparar a Daniel Valavoine y Dimash... Ambos son excelentes.. Si no hubiera escuchado esta canción en Dimash, jamás hubiera llegado a escuchar esta bella canción, 🤗
Gracias Daniel por haber existido... Todo empezó contigo... Nos dejaste un tema que además inspiró a muchos cantantes prodigios...
Je viens juste de decouvrir cette chanson par le petit Soan (The Voice Kids France 2019), et je me vois obliger de trouver Balavoine... Comment ne pas pleurer en ecoutant une telle chanson?
Merci Balavoine.-
Merci Luc Plamondon
Quelle magnifique interprétation !
Quelle voix!
J'ai des frissons.
Normand Groulx,
Alexis Carlier, Antoine Wend,
Bruno Pelletier,
Piet Arion,
Dimash Qudaibergen et de nombreux autres interprètes de cette merveilleuse chanson méritent une grande reconnaissance.
Daniel Balavoine était le premier.
and i bet Daniel and Gregory are enjoying Dimash`s version from above.
Unlike those qc natzis.
This man just made me cry and I don't even understand French. That's some powerful delivery
I don't understand any of the debates in here tbh. Daniel Balavoine was interpreting the character from Starmania, with his words, his feelings, his past. Dimash is proposing a vocal performance and I guess he had to learn everything phonetically, he is very impressive indeed. But the two performances don't have the same goal at all, the aim of Dimash is an impressive vocal performance and the aim of Daniel was to interpret a character. (with an impressive vocal performance, as a result haha)
onsoir , j'espère que je ne vous pose pas de soucis moi c'est pamiene. Juste pour savoir si vous faite partie des grands amateur de la musique francaise et aussi mieux faire votre connaissance . Essayer de me joindre à cette adresse ci dessous :pamienelabelge405@gmail.com
.Exellente journée à vous Merci .
I get you.
Exsactley
@@pamienelabelge2578 elle parle anglais pas français
I agree. And I prefer Gregory's version over Daniel. Dimash is my favorite singer, but for this song, he is behind Gregory and Daniel because he just hit the notes, but not really feel the song. I don't care about his pronounciation, but he totally skip and miss some important parts of the song (to just do the more impressive one). But he's still my favorite singer, because I know he can sing with a lot of emotion and passion, he did it a lot. But of course, it was a vocal show at The Singer
Technically Dimash is probably the most gifted singer I've heard but in this version the emotion for me is more evident. Even though I do not understand French I feel this song needs a certain vulnerability. French is such a beautiful language on the ear.
listen to grégory lemarchal's version, it's probably my favorite
You are right, the whole song is about vulnerability and distress so the voice and your body langage should show it.
Agree with this, Dimash is technically perfect but I teared up as soon as Daniel Balavoine started singing 😭😢💔
@@sarah9572 I just listened to it and read about him. His tragic story led to his performance being a complete one off. Devastating.
@@costascosta273 ngl your right
He has a tragic story and he wanted a good life like disney princesses
The way he sings it suits the lyrics so much.
Someone "normal" would try to sing pretty, but he's not someone "normal". He's someone who sticks out, who doesn't see the world like other people, and he sings in a way that's not usual at all.
A beautiful song beautifully sung
Came here because Dimash. I am a big fan of Dimash. The vocal range of Dimash is inhuman but, Gregory Lemarch and Daniel have their own way to touch souls and minds too. So happy to discover such beautiful voices 😍
Adesso c'è anche Antonio. Al minuto 1:41 inizia. ua-cam.com/video/plLVUidO0gY/v-deo.html
Иметь больший вокальный диапазон голоса ,ещё далеко не всегда означает " лучше петь ".
@@ИринаВегера-щ3х ну .тогда слушай бузову.саиый раз
@@КайратЕлибаев-щ5ы А это твоя любимая певица? Не иначе .Если ты ее всем советуешь послушать !.Как раз достойный твоего вкуса и ума выбор . Приятного тебе прослушивания Ольги Бузовой !
@@ИринаВегера-щ3х нет это твая любимая певица. Уитни тоже кричит но все ее обожают.так что кричать тож надо умеючи
Une des plus belles chançons qui soient ....
Excellent Balavoine! Et sublime interprétation de Dimash. Le talent de l'un n'enlève pas le talent de l'autre. ❤❤
It's nice to hear the original. I got curious about the vocal arrangement and had know how what this sounded like. Just look at his eyes and you will see all the emotion.
Как здорово, что остались все эти записи.. вот она.. история музыки ❤❤❤
Very pleasant to hear. I love this old song vibe and, in fact, it's a good old song and his voice sings it amazingly! Of course, like many here, I got to know this song through Dimash, who really did an incredible job giving it his own colors. But it's clear: no matter what your favorite version is, both are beautiful, and Dimash chose to sing SOS because this version exists and he appreciates it in Daniel's voice. Neither invalidates the other, and everyone is different from each other.
Such a beautiful and heartfelt rendition. This song was, I believe, written for him and his unusual vocal range, for the musical Starmania in the '70s. This man is singing a story...I would love to see the musical if it is available. I love Dimash too, just very different contexts. Beautiful, moving song, no matter the singer. RIP Daniel Balavoine.
Yes, it was wriiten for him. Michel Berger, the composer, knew exactly Daniel and his vocal capacities. they were friends. There is an english version of "Starmania": "Tycoon". I don´t know now, but before corona, "Starmania" still was played in Paris, but the 2nd version and setup, not the original version and setup of 1979. The one after Daniel, who had the vocal capacity to sing that song, was Renaud Hantson, in 1989-1990. Have a great day!
You can find the 1988 version with Norman Groulx on daily motion.
It's easy if you wanna hear starmania you can do it most of the songs are on youtube just write starmania soundtrack it will get out for you
Dimash is an incredible singer, but he’s very much a _performer_ too. He’s singing is so bombastic and flashy that he doesn’t (I believe) capture the heart of the song, which is more somber and introspective. His version is still very good, but like you said, they’re very different contexts. Which you prefer will ultimately come down to personal preferences.
Tengo entendido que para 2024, planean poner la obra de teatro en marcha ❤️👍
Но, само душевно, трагично спел эту песню Грегори Лемаршаль. Ему через столько всего пришлось пройти.( Светлая ему память!!!)))
I love Dimash version, but also love this. I'm so grateful that Daniel wrote such a beautiful song. Daniel would be proud to hear Dimash perform this.
This song was Written by Michel Berger and Luc Plamendon for Balavoine
Que c bo et léger . J'adore . Je pleure chaque fois que je réécoute. Merci pour ton message mondial.
Best version ever, pour moi aucune reprise ne peut égaler celle-ci.
Oui, d'accord!
No, but it's still a good performance.
Oui...
and dimash?
@@rominavillalobos me gusta Dimash
This is unbelievably beautiful 😥😥 there's something so sincere in his voice and this song just makes me cry. It takes a certain soul to sing a song like this ❤❤❤ it's freaking stunning!
Also, the pain in @0:48 😥😥 I just cant even cope 💔
Well if you wanna feel Balavoine this was his speciallity famous for his emotions if you hear nay of his sounds they are most of them that way.... You can go listen to "LA vie ne m'apprend rien" From him all his sounds are that way
and without all the technological corrections and enhancements we use at live shows in the 2000s!
My favorite interpretation. This is definitely the right way to sing it. Respect!
Balavoine. Incomparable. Quelle voie. Quel homme. Je t'aime toujours autant. Merci.
Nice to hear the original artist sing this song. I had never heard of this song until Dimash sang it, and while Dimash hits the high notes much more effortlessly than Daniel does, I do like this version almost as much. A very touching song.
chaque interprétation m'envoûte. La chanson est d'une autre planète...
Both are good! I came here by Dimash.
Same
Me too
👊👊👊👊
Daniel Balavoine: one of Dimash's inspiration ☺️ Both are great singers
je m'appelle josh mark je t'apporte une bonne nouvelle
In fairness I think Dimash covers Gregory Lemarchal's interpretation (on Star Academy). For example the end of the song, he ends it like Gregory does, not Balavoine. But either way, it is a beautiful song that has been beautifully interpreted by all three singers.
Un talent fou et doté d’une forte personnalité singulière ! ❤️🙏
Incroyablement beau, sublime,,,
Благодаря Димашу узнал о Даниэль и его трагическую историю. Очень эмоциональное выступление.
Благодаря Димашу узнали еще и про трагичного Грегори Лемаршаль
Darf ich nachfragen, was passiert ist? Ich bin durch Zufall auf diese Urversion hier gestoßen.
Tu chante trop bien
Bravo, je te découvre par hasard, à travers un talent show italien, qui a nommé Dimash et puis je suis arrivé à toi et viceversa. Les mots et ton interprétation me touchent énormément, vie ta vie, n'importe où tu es, tu es libre.
Vis ta vie, je m'excuse
@@gennaroamoroso1353 il est décédé
@@nathalieboisvert6676 oui, je le savais, je voulais dire vis ta vie, n'importe où tu es, où tu te trouves
@@nathalieboisvert6676 Nathalie, c'était par rapport à la chanson, qui parle d'un homme en détresse, perdu... Donc j'ai dit: maintenant tu es libre de vivre ta vie, un peu philosophique
Wow! Beautiful and pleasing to my ears! I'm happy I was lead to the original. Bravo!
this one is deeper, made me shed tears without realizing it
same
každý z nich zobral pieseň famóznym spôsobom. Každý si zaslúži potlesk a našu vďaku za možnosť počuť túto pieseň vždy inak,
Je ne pe lasse pas de Daniel ...
Самое проникновенное и неповторимое исполнение! Браво!!!
Daniel is beautiful, he sings with so many emotions...and that bass is insane
Ciertamente sin DIMASH no habría llegado a esta interpretación, extraordinaria, un cantante también adelantado a su época. Cada quien tiene lo suyo. Extraordinarios ambos.
La voix de Balavoine est si touchante , elle dit bien le ressenti de la chanson
Меня всегда пробирает дрожь от этой песни, но когда я прочитала перевод, поняла почему. Эта песня - достояние всего мира
Gregory Lemarchal, también fué todo un referente interpretando esta bella canción entre su repertorio. Descansen en paz El y Daniel 🌟🌟🌠🌠
Это он автор своей песни,из рок-оперы "стармания" душевно поёт, 1978 г.спец эфыектов не было таких как сейчас.Песня сложная в исполнении.Браво!!👏💜
you can't compare dinash and daniel. Not the same decade, not the same country. the one is from a musical the second a live voice show...
I agree
@jay cee Please show some respect
Agree. Particularly I prefer this interpretation.
@@gustavomachado7317 me too cause he is french and the original artist of the song so unlike Dimash i understand his prononciation and he sings the right lyrics at the right time.
Of course you can. You just need to try. You'll get there, I promise.
L ho ascoltata in tutte le versioni. È stupenda ogni volta. Adoro tutti gli interpreti. Io volo ogni volta. Graxie
I started crying even tho I didn’t understand the lyrics that shows how good he is at bringing out the right emotions in the song
J'écoute toujours cette bel chansson
EMOTION on its pure state... voice, interpretation, feeling, the base playing...it's harmonious and beauuuutiful as it is.
Olala.... L émotion a l état pure. On s'envole, on décolle, quel TALENT
I love the artistry where @1:36 you cannot distinguish between the bass and his voice, perfection!
Gracias por esta bella canción a su escritor Michel Berger y a Daniel por su primera y dulce interpretación sin ellos no hubiera sido posible escuchar hoy a nuestro amado 💖💖Dimash💖 interpretandola.
Souvenirs de Paris... Daniel Balavoine, le meilleur.
Fabuleux!
So beautiful. My favorite version.
magnifique ❤❤❤❤❤
Как это прекрасно! Как трогает душу и сердце! Униканый певец!!!❤
Such a beautiful falsetto.
Очень красивая песня и прекрасное исполнение!!!!
Meilleure interprétation ❤
Ojalá Daniel Balavoine hubiera vivido hasta el día de hoy sólo para escuchar el cover que hizo Dimash... Me encantaría escucharlos cantar juntos :(
Magnifique ❤️
I only wish Daniel could hear how much we love him. Dimash brought his songs to ears like mine that might never have heard him.
You will never arrive at Balavoine’s beauty! Doesn’t matter who tries. He is one of a kind.
Toujours aussi vibrant cette musique avec l'authenticité de l'orchestre 🔥
Tres belle musique. Ihab je suis Algerian
Браво! Взволновала исполнение)) Очень интересно, послушать оригинал.
que d'émotions à travers ta voix incroyable
que serais-tu devenu dans ce monde pourri par les pandémies, guerres et autres " joyeusetés" ?
I love Dimash but this version is totally my favourite. RIP Daniel Balavoine ❤️
Bravo Daniel il a interprèter magnifiquement cette chanson. Des années après gregory à presque égale Daniel. Tout 2 sont partis trop jeune gregory 23 et Daniel 35 avant d'accueillir son 2 eme enfant après jeremy 2 ans johanna née après son décès rip a 2 grandes voix
Le français plus-que-parfait. .ça sent tellement vécu . l'original, et maintenant le SOS de Dimesh. .qu'en penser. .Voilà Dimesh c'est Belavoine 2020 en plein Tempête covid19. Je suis certain que Belavoine d'en haut applaudi Dimesh, digne de continuité : éternelle Question existentialiste.
Very nice. Daniel died way to young. What a lost. RIP
Thank you Dimash for introducing this beautiful song to me. This version is amazing as well⚘
Un artiste,un VRAI….Parti beaucoup trop tôt…
You don't have to hate on one version of this song in order to appreciate and enjoy the other! Just love both versions for what they are and don't force your preferences on others! BE KIND!
Я искала этот комментарий ♥️благодарю
Have you heard the English version?
Как можно его исполнением не проникнуться ? Merci,Daniel Balavoine!
Не проникся. Тускло, вери мач
Сергей Волков ,не согласна,что тускло. Но у Вас своё мнение,а у меня-своё).
По мне несколько дерганый звук, вызывает раздражение, при всем уважении к оригиналу. Всегда была большой фанаткой Пельтье и любила эту песню в его исполнении, но как прослушала в исполнении Нормана Гру, так она стала вообще моей любимой, такой лёгкий и в то же время щемяще - проникновенный вокал..