Fact is, in whatever other group, Winter would easily be the Main vocal, Only on Nmixx and aespa, who are the best vocal group, Winter such a mother🙌❤️
It's kinda sad seeing people focusing only on how she sounds nasal instead of paying attention to her gorgeous vocals. I mean, the sustained A4-B4-C5 sounded very good (even if, indeed, it was throaty), and even most of her C5s here were pretty good (Her D5s, E5s and the G5 too obvsly)
@@Minavis_Penguin yeah frr, people like to say that her notes above B4/C5 are tense as hell but she isn't that tensed. It's just that she's very throaty and has a very light voice so it sounds like she strains while it's her tone
she's not competing to anyone, she's still young and give her the time to reach notes according to your preferences, but FOR NOW LET US ALL ENJOY LISTENING TO HER
okay, i may not be knowledgeable about vocals, but i feel like that C5 at 0:30 doesn't sound bad at all. Can someone please confirm this cuz i don't want to sound embarrassing loooool
@@hanatake2353stop saying that. Ningning has been the Aespa member with the most solo promotion this year. Even more than Karina's. So instead of trying to desperately keep this narratif, go support Ningning solo work. And maybe then SM will also remember to give Giselle's some.
@@tnlkb6115 not an akgay, but nn really deserved that after being mistreated by sm and discriminated by knetz since debut for being chinese. But im not saying other members dont deserve those promotion, for now the unluckiest member is only gs since shes the only member who doesnt have any luxury brand schedule (individual) not gonna talk about korean shows tho😶
@@hanatake2353 Nin2 is really the one who has attended the most brand events, the one who has never been is Giselle while Winter is the only one, Ning2 is really the one who has attended the most events this year while Giselle is only one
@@Portugall_ actually she is also main vocalist with NingNing because Koreans preffer Winter's vocal and Both are C+ tier vocalists so recently they gave Winter the main vocalist position because her voice is more loved in Korea
@@albiatenea but she's still a bit weaker than Ningning, and she's logically a lead Vocalist, which is hard for me to say since I'm a Winter ult-biased but I have to admit that she's a lead, not a main (yet, cause she's there to be considered as a second main)
@@Portugall_ she is a second main, she was before lead because she was known for her dancing but now she is second main or that i heard because her voice is more loved in Korea she could becaome the only main.
i did not enjoy this performance tbh😭 she needs to work on lightening her mix in the 5th octave bc the tenseness in the notes is CRAZY it’s like she tries way too hard to sound strong so high in her mix but like without the needed support that’s just damaging. and she doesn’t rly let go of that tenseness when moving down to her comfortable register :/
This was her third song and also talked nonstop. Singing such while sitting stay still, hence what do u expected? Her facial expression didn't even try much tho
It could also be conforyable to her. Human body really works different from people to people. It might be damaging as you think but it might feel comfortable to her
@@vuthavanken7009excuses excuses… nobody is attacking winter or saying she’s a totally incapable vocalist. But just don’t being up “she sang a lot before this, she talked” etc. every time you see a simple reasonable criticism cause it’s just meaningless. Actually being able still sing well on your last song as well as your first song is also a criteria vocalists are judged on. So saying but “she’s tried” doesn’t mean much.
![[리무진 서비스 클립] Confetti | 에스파 윈터 | aespa WINTER](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/tNU4n-vGTgo/mqdefault.jpg)
Fact is, in whatever other group, Winter would easily be the Main vocal, Only on Nmixx and aespa, who are the best vocal group, Winter such a mother🙌❤️
Also she can't be main vocalist in Weeekly, Pink Fantasy
Maybe billlie too, but i think she’d be main vocal along with haram
Winter proving she is the lead vocalist of the 4th gen
Main vocalist from 4 gen is Lily from Nmixx
@@albiateneareading is fundamental, they clearly said LEAD vocalist, not main
@@azariah3797 yes i know but i was saying that if Lily doesnt exist Winter would be main vocalist with NingNing
@@albiateneawdym? Even before Nmixx's debut Winter was known as a lead vocalist and Ningning as a Main vocalist tho?
@@Portugall_ but they Both are C+ tier and Winter should be main vocalist with NingNing.
Theres a reason why shes one of the best vocalist in 4th gen
It's kinda sad seeing people focusing only on how she sounds nasal instead of paying attention to her gorgeous vocals. I mean, the sustained A4-B4-C5 sounded very good (even if, indeed, it was throaty), and even most of her C5s here were pretty good (Her D5s, E5s and the G5 too obvsly)
I agree, her notes above C5 don't have much tension + sustained.
@@Minavis_Penguin yeah frr, people like to say that her notes above B4/C5 are tense as hell but she isn't that tensed. It's just that she's very throaty and has a very light voice so it sounds like she strains while it's her tone
If Winter will continue to practice & train her voice, I can see her as the new Taeyeon...
she's not competing to anyone, she's still young and give her the time to reach notes according to your preferences, but FOR NOW LET US ALL ENJOY LISTENING TO HER
She is young and her tier is C+ I cant imagine her tier when she got older i think It Will be A like Taeyeon
yup she doesn't seems to sound too piercing on C5 now
So easy the G5. And her C5 is getting so good.
I liked the sustained A4 it wasn't bad at all
she sounds so pretty although she’s tense throughout
okay, i may not be knowledgeable about vocals, but i feel like that C5 at 0:30 doesn't sound bad at all. Can someone please confirm this cuz i don't want to sound embarrassing loooool
it's not bad for winter but it's throaty af
Its pretty throaty and tight
not supported
@@victorcaua7094por que ela não suporta um c5 se ela já suportou várias outra vezes?
Much less vibrato than I expected
could you pls make a vocal showcase with wendy on lee mujin service?
oh she’s EATING….
now send ningning sm ent!!!
no
Sm favor korean members so maybe next cb? Idk
@@hanatake2353stop saying that. Ningning has been the Aespa member with the most solo promotion this year. Even more than Karina's. So instead of trying to desperately keep this narratif, go support Ningning solo work. And maybe then SM will also remember to give Giselle's some.
@@tnlkb6115 not an akgay, but nn really deserved that after being mistreated by sm and discriminated by knetz since debut for being chinese. But im not saying other members dont deserve those promotion, for now the unluckiest member is only gs since shes the only member who doesnt have any luxury brand schedule (individual) not gonna talk about korean shows tho😶
@@hanatake2353 Nin2 is really the one who has attended the most brand events, the one who has never been is Giselle while Winter is the only one, Ning2 is really the one who has attended the most events this year while Giselle is only one
0:03 I guess this is F5 and also in 0:34 the last note.. idk either because it's just that high
They’re both E5… might sound a bit higher since E5 is out of her comfort zone
Can you do something similar for NMIXX’s It’s Live performance of Party O’Clock please?
I posted it on tiktok kind of haha
Super!! Shall we be friends?
Winter should be main vocalist with Ningning
I agree
@@Portugall_ actually she is also main vocalist with NingNing because Koreans preffer Winter's vocal and Both are C+ tier vocalists so recently they gave Winter the main vocalist position because her voice is more loved in Korea
@@albiatenea but she's still a bit weaker than Ningning, and she's logically a lead Vocalist, which is hard for me to say since I'm a Winter ult-biased but I have to admit that she's a lead, not a main (yet, cause she's there to be considered as a second main)
@@albiatenea but I absolutely understand why people call her main vocalist, she can show better and fuller moments than Ningning in the G#4 - B4 range
@@Portugall_ she is a second main, she was before lead because she was known for her dancing but now she is second main or that i heard because her voice is more loved in Korea she could becaome the only main.
Can you do Ningning something like that analysis?
maybe next time when ningning got a chance to have an opportunity like this
@@cutiieeepatootieee2002 actually she had opportunity when she was singing something like that on "It's live" show
Can you do Sullyoon on lee mujin?
(bad eng. Abmskxkkamb)
was busy but forgot about it haha
that G5 was falsetto right?
yes
@@slaypaisn't head voice? :0
@@nri4950 it's very airy, so nope
What's his tier?
She's Mid-High Average // C
Same tier with jihyo twice
@@Rexille_Creative yep
@@Rexille_Creative but she is better than Jihyo
@@rimkim21true
i did not enjoy this performance tbh😭 she needs to work on lightening her mix in the 5th octave bc the tenseness in the notes is CRAZY it’s like she tries way too hard to sound strong so high in her mix but like without the needed support that’s just damaging. and she doesn’t rly let go of that tenseness when moving down to her comfortable register :/
Sempre tem um pra achar erros onde não tem, impressionante
This was her third song and also talked nonstop. Singing such while sitting stay still, hence what do u expected? Her facial expression didn't even try much tho
It could also be conforyable to her. Human body really works different from people to people. It might be damaging as you think but it might feel comfortable to her
@@vuthavanken7009excuses excuses… nobody is attacking winter or saying she’s a totally incapable vocalist. But just don’t being up “she sang a lot before this, she talked” etc. every time you see a simple reasonable criticism cause it’s just meaningless. Actually being able still sing well on your last song as well as your first song is also a criteria vocalists are judged on. So saying but “she’s tried” doesn’t mean much.
Who are you? Let me see your singing then