this is one of their best performances ngl... live, they sang the chorus(!!!), everyone is out of breath but still performing their hearts out. i love red velvet
how is it that the deeper into the song, the more stable wendy’s vocals get 😦 like after and even DURING jumping around like that, she hits all the notes flawlessly 😭 i mean all if them are great singers but man, wendy just hits different 😭
Years had passed yet we still have to get a perform as remarkable and perfect as this. They really showcased their insane vocal skills and how stable and committed they are to sing live. I respect them a lot especially after seeing how they sing the choruses, the ad-libs, the high notes, etc...when they don't have to. Really really impressive, as expected from Red Velvet.
i love EVERYTHING about this performace. seulgi, wendy, and joys stability and their bright tones,,, irene and yeris rapping,,, irenes deep voice and yeris cute voice,,,, AHHHHHHHH
This is so goddamn impressive, like they were fully doing their choreography (not their easiest either, by a long shot), a fairly vocally challenging song with a fast tempo, sang all verses, harmonized, and sang the choruses all while sounding THAT good???? I know I stan the right group ong
@@Maddie-rv6sp yeri and irene were singing perfectly fine and theyre not even the main vocal line. and they’ve improved a lot since this performance too. all the girls are talented
@Mitzee0972z their company doesn't give then as much work. Since aespa has came in they have been put under the rug more. They are probably more out of practice. They are turning to more solo work now. Wendy, in her recent comeback, sounds pretty similar to here though. So she's still doing good.
@@vanhminglianitochhawng3209 she isn't the strongest but she is probably one of the most stables, just check out other (reliables) mr removeds, she always sing very clearly unlike here (which idk why).
![레드벨벳 - 음파음파 (Umpah Umpah)[유희열의 스케치북/Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook ]20190823](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Vg1MOij3k_A/mqdefault.jpg)
![레드벨벳 - 음파음파 (Umpah Umpah)[유희열의 스케치북/Yu Huiyeol's Sketchbook ]20190823](/img/tr.png)
this is one of their best performances ngl... live, they sang the chorus(!!!), everyone is out of breath but still performing their hearts out. i love red velvet
Yes
Wendy rly understood the assignment here (2:28)
woow she slay
2:31 irene hit the tune PERFECTLY (wendy is salying as always)
아니 노래 2개부르면서 고음부분을 다 부른다고?? 진짜 한번 쉴법도한데 와..레드벨벳은 전설이다
how is it that the deeper into the song, the more stable wendy’s vocals get 😦 like after and even DURING jumping around like that, she hits all the notes flawlessly 😭 i mean all if them are great singers but man, wendy just hits different 😭
Nerves probably went away at the end.
두곡연속 춤추면서 라이브
대단하다는 말밖에..
they are completely MONSTERS OF SINGING LIVE, this is forever INSANE
진짜 잘하네요. 유스케 나올 수 있는 몇 안되는 걸그룹 중 하나.
wendy is crazy talented
Years had passed yet we still have to get a perform as remarkable and perfect as this. They really showcased their insane vocal skills and how stable and committed they are to sing live. I respect them a lot especially after seeing how they sing the choruses, the ad-libs, the high notes, etc...when they don't have to. Really really impressive, as expected from Red Velvet.
i love EVERYTHING about this performace. seulgi, wendy, and joys stability and their bright tones,,, irene and yeris rapping,,, irenes deep voice and yeris cute voice,,,, AHHHHHHHH
joy and wendy so stable???
코러스 라인도 라이브 하는게 대박
This is so goddamn impressive, like they were fully doing their choreography (not their easiest either, by a long shot), a fairly vocally challenging song with a fast tempo, sang all verses, harmonized, and sang the choruses all while sounding THAT good???? I know I stan the right group ong
Wow Joy, Wendy and Seulgi singing perfectly 🙀
The vocal line
facts LOL! the other two were....realyl questionable ....
@@Maddie-rv6sp ur underestimating them
@@Maddie-rv6sp yeri and irene were singing perfectly fine and theyre not even the main vocal line. and they’ve improved a lot since this performance too. all the girls are talented
@@Maddie-rv6sp maybe because theyre rappers LOL??? whyr u dragging them
Btw, irene raw vocals are fire!!!
i love it when they sing live they do it so amazingly
Wow they even sang the chorus
They always do :)
@@fanz7054Why their voice isn't stable now?
@@Mitzee0972zwatch their concert video. they do
@Mitzee0972z their company doesn't give then as much work. Since aespa has came in they have been put under the rug more.
They are probably more out of practice. They are turning to more solo work now.
Wendy, in her recent comeback, sounds pretty similar to here though. So she's still doing good.
조이랑 웬디가 진짜 안정적이네..
춤추면서 어떻게 음정이 안 흔들리고... 대단하당
Wow the mr have harmonies😭😭😭😱
I love gg and redvelvet because they are in harmonies and not making the song dry😭
JOY STABLE QUEEN
2:28
That's like the most impressive part of a MR removed I've ever watched. Wendy's a queen!
Slaaayyyyy why cant newer idols do this instead of lip syncing im sad coz they can do this as well
1:33 omfg slay
Wendy eat her part on the CD
wendy's amazing !!!! her ending...was beautiful........
Yeri's microfone is so LOW, damn we can barely hear her, and we can see that she is trying her bestt
She always sings like that...the problem isn't her mice
Its because the backtrack was so loud,she could barely hear herself and she isn't the strongest vocalist
@@vanhminglianitochhawng3209 she isn't the strongest but she is probably one of the most stables, just check out other (reliables) mr removeds, she always sing very clearly unlike here (which idk why).
i think cause her voice is soft like that
It’s not the mic lmao she always sing like that so it’s hard to be stable
WENDYS DEEP VOICE OMG.
Really proud of my girls achievements 💖
5:27 She's singing with all the desire in the world. She always delivers everything on stage, i love her!!! 💖💖😭😭
슬기 되게 잘한다... 웬디는 원래 알고 있었는데 슬기 고음 화음 다 참여하네
원래 슬기에쎔에도 보컬로 뽑했죠. 물론 춤도 넘 잘추는 올라운더지만
웬디는 그냥 안정적이란 말로 부족. 라이브가 음원보다 좋음
exactly why i stan them ♥︎ luvsss
how even wendy did that
Seulgi is insane!
조이 음색 미,...쳐ㅅ..따
joy's so stable
존나 잘하네
I realized that SM artists are taught to control their breathing not to make sound when performing.
1:33!! wow!!
They are so stable!!
QUEENS
Yeri's line is so low so that's why she is struggling :))
Joy here impressed me so much, omggg, so stable!!!!!🤩🤩
Yeri vocal so Low, its so deep💜
I have to search red velvet mr removed after hearing something shitty today
열린음악회, 유스케 이 두 곳이 개빡센듯ㅋㅋㅋ
Dios mío los vocales de las chicas.
EARGASM
SLAYYY MY QUEENNNNNNNN!!!! 👑🤩4:45
Red Velvet
Heaven 🫶🏻
where do you download sketchbook performances
근데 요즘은 유스케 후속인 뭐 더 시즌즈? 그것도 후보정하더라... 아쉽
와뭐야 왜캐 잘불러.. 춤 격렬한데.. 음정 안불안해 특히 조이 음색쩐다... 근데 예리는 음 잘모르겠음
슬기 웬디 조이 빼고 다 나가라 라고 말하고싶지만
틀와이스나 다른 그륩보다 우수하기에 계속 영원해라
막귀 인가?!!! ㅎ 레드벨벳 모든 멤들 각자의 음역과 역할을 제대로 해내는 라이브 실력 탄탄한 걸그룹으로 손꼽히는데 무슨 억까 좀 그만!!!
ㅋㅋㅋ 당신이 뭔데요..;;
@@yun14013 내가 느그애미다
대부분 호흡이 되게 많이 떠있네 춤 때문인가
당연한거 아닌가..
이 곡 부르기 전에 2곡 불렀습니다
im a luvie but lol they sound like robots 💀💀💀
sketchbook ❤️ autotune
honestly the strength varies per performance, this is probably mid strength
where
@@jenseulnade9147 if you have an ear for pitched vocals vs raw natural vocals it's easy to tell, but 2:19 is a tad more obvious at the end of her line
@@a35nct30 not here
THEY RLLY GOOD
JOY STABLE QUEEN
5:55