There is no advantage of man with man vs man with woman. If you put a baritone man singing with a tenor man, and ask them to each sing the song, they will have trouble unless the song has a pretty narrow range. The same problem occurs when you ask a baritone man to do same with alto woman (what happened with this trio). The two guys who sang Nothing Gonna Change MY Love for You were fine because they were both tenors. Put Bao in with one of them, they will have trouble.
Listening to this once again, I hate to say it, but Bao was the culprit that caused the entire song to go off the rail. There has been speculation that he actually wants to foul out now that he has the exposure, and does not want to work any harder. This performance adds to that theory. When the 3 of them started harmony, he was the one who messed everything up with his first note.
鮑大人唱英文歌絕對出色,咬字清晰動聽,非常有感覺,看他自己channel裡唱的歌就知道了,如果這首是他獨唱或與曹敏寶兩人合唱,絕對80分以上,如今3人合唱只落得66分,真可惜,希望以後這節目不要再安排合唱歌給鮑大人,如沒有鮑大人,這個節目真的沒必要看,只有鮑大人是值得一聽再聽的好聲音
個key高到上天, 都沒有難聽, .沒有失聲, 沒有拆声, Bao Boa是金嗓子啊😄
聽完古淖文的《不如不見/Desperado 》,嘩真係立分高下,不過我都支持鮑鮑。
聽咗淖文唱嘅版本,其他太💩
明知人不在Hk, 就不要搞起她復活來累街坊啦!不能一起多練習, 死梗!
幸好她無得留底
3個合唱時超難聽, 應該男主音2女和會夾d
老師問題, 呢d都唔識教
而家留在紅組嘅心情如何? 公平起見, 應該輪流轉導師
三人合唱根本就唔狹 浪費鮑大人把聲 救命
冇錯!飽大人應獨唱至啱!
呢首歌得到66分真喺『實至名歸, 冇得留低』. 相比藍綠兩組有85/78分, 輸得心服口服啦. 作為聽眾, 我聽得好辛苦, 一時『超高音』, 一時又「低8度」. 一首經典的歌就栽在你們的手上. 至於foul 咗梁小姐, 我相信評判和網民100%同意.
很不公平!別的2人一組, 你們3人一組, 又男女混合唱,確實蝕底多多, key的處理要份外小心, 導師又無料, 不懂提点成員用key是否合適度, 其中一成員更令這組攬炒, 張Sir已說明嗰位最大錯 ,幾樣碰在一起, 登他倆不值(敏宝和Boa Boa)
非常同意. 他們的老師無料. 這個老師悟人子弟. 根本不適合做指導人.
There is no advantage of man with man vs man with woman. If you put a baritone man singing with a tenor man, and ask them to each sing the song, they will have trouble unless the song has a pretty narrow range. The same problem occurs when you ask a baritone man to do same with alto woman (what happened with this trio). The two guys who sang Nothing Gonna Change MY Love for You were fine because they were both tenors. Put Bao in with one of them, they will have trouble.
唉!鮑大人比人玩完一次又一次。編曲又有問題。
❤❤❤
如只有鮑大人同曹敏寶合唱,-定會高分好多 。全被梁凱庭拖累!
十分同意,整得佢兩個應該八十幾
之前導師過咗d 咩料俾佢哋? 陰功湯咯!
一個字,無!同他們自己度的差不多
冇架,聽完試唱話 ok 冇執過,直接去比賽,紅組隊員攞分數真係靠自己本事,唔似其他組有星級補習老師指點考到高分…………
應該叫紅組導師出來唱番首歌,睇吓攞幾多分好喎
自從上次造馬俾60分,已經再冇任何興趣再睇落去,更好的節目都可以給無線毁掉了
格格不入,的感覺!就係咁
曹敏寶把聲幾好聽
唔係要棄卒保師,要做馬救包大人,姓梁嗰個淘汰咗啦,而家俾佢玩多集,賺到喇,仲想點⁉️
鮑大人唱得好先有66分, 梁小姐完全唔掂,拖低晒D分,應該被淘汰
不討好的歌
不如唱甜蜜蜜
三个长期自弹自唱,上台变左各唱各全无配合度
三个基本功未夠所以变成各唱各,拍子又不準,搞到乐隊配合不到必须正視
真實呢佢都唱得唔好, 我都唔知佢唱緊咩🙃🤔 所以佢淘汰都唔出奇。🙃
唉……失敗
個女衫師奶好吾掂
感觉各有各唱,最差组合
功底未夠,配合度不高,必出问题
唔駛識唱歌,唱得K 多都知個Key 唔啱,炒硬
唱錯歌詞無事, 唱得K多會俾人淘汰
Listening to this once again, I hate to say it, but Bao was the culprit that caused the entire song to go off the rail. There has been speculation that he actually wants to foul out now that he has the exposure, and does not want to work any harder. This performance adds to that theory. When the 3 of them started harmony, he was the one who messed everything up with his first note.
3個都難聽
其實分數好難反映實況,伍生比這首13分,好聽一些的歌15分,range很窄
建議評審比分狠一些,吳好成日話同情分,這首比十分以下好應該!
總分66也叫合格分,其實吳應該高過50分!