India trends
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лют 2023
- Hours after Rani Mukherjee starrer 'Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway' trailer released, #BoycottGermany began trending on social media. The film based on the struggles of an Indian couple in Norway has now put spotlight on the fight to bring back baby Ariha from Germany. The baby of the Shah couple was taken away by German authorities in 2021 and her parents are now fighting a battle to bring her back. Netizens demanded justice for the Indian family and poured their anger against Germany on Twitter. Watch this video for more details.
#germany #india #babyariha #shah #indiancouple #childcare #authorities #taken #mrschatterjeevsnorway #film #movie #trailer #boycottgermany #trending #twitter #fight #struggle
Hindustan Times Videos bring you news, views and explainers about current issues in India and across the globe. We’re always excited to report the news as quickly as possible, use new technological tools to reach you better and tell stories with a 360 degree view to give you a better understanding of the world around you.
Sometimes life in India is so underrated...... The intervention of these western govt in the lives of their citizens is too much....
Life in India is overrated. Stay single and go to a sparsely populated country.
@@sauron2000000 definitely not! Life in India is really nice. I guess it's you who is brainwashed by western news media
Gowdre devraane nija
You can raise their kind of inhuman law in UN. But it is too early to blame Germany without hearing what Germany wants to tell. You should hear both sides first.
Out of India's 1.4billion population why Bollywood choses to present another nri story
I'm Croatian and my heart goes out to this couple. In the past I've met quite a few Indians who deeply respected Germany. Now I've noticed that Indians are starting to see Germany for what it really is.
I grew up there and have much love for the people of DE, their government's actions in the past 2-3 years have changed my mind.
Nazis will remain Nazis no matter what ! It's in their blood to target innocent since their beginning.
It's because in India , we raise our child with our own culture which might be different from them and the organization and govt. of Germany should not teach us how to raise our Child.
@@cs4u It's the people who voted for this tyrannical government.
Fuck your European heart 🖕🏻
The more I get to learn about this case, the less inclined I am to believe the parent’s version. This 7 months baby had major injuries to her private parts that needed stitches. But when doctors asked the reason, the parents had no proper answer. Suspecting their not-so proper responses, the doctors had informed police about this.
What all people need to understand is that CHILD ABUSE IS NOT NORMAL and this has got nothing to do with India/ religion/ race.
Didnt the investigation case was closed without charges?
@@viewer9451 criminal case was dismissed as the parents refused to cooperate. it is now a civil case as the child is most definitely not safe with her family. shame on them
The parents story has been inconsistent, something is very fishy. The parents have no proper explanation for how the child got the injury.
@@indiancookinguk3000 At the very least they are trying to protect someone (grandparent?) over their child. A the very worst they too are complicit in the abuse. In either case the child is not safe with them.
Is this info reliable and true? As, I have read nothing so far like this
The parents never explained how the grandmother accidentally hurt the kid. The parents also told in a video that her grandmother hurt her 2 times, not only one time. How did the same accident happen 2 times? She needed stitches in the private part due to a tear. It is not some bruises due to falls.
yeah good point
Kinda sus
Yes
That's what I was thinking
Because they don't have to because on investigation they were cleared of all the allegations then now what's the point in not returning their child.
@@sumitmishra3575 The parents said that they had not been charged with sexual abuse as there was no DNA to prove penetration. But it was also true that the child's private part was torn and needed stitches. The parents did not elaborate on how the private parts (Vagina or anus most probably as parents only saw the blood) could be torn, not cut or bruised. If they don't have anything to hide. They should come clear. German authority will not elaborate as the child is a minor.
Two types of investigation should take action
1) About the hospital who declared sexual assault
2) Investigation on the parents who are telling the truth or not, and if they are telling the truth question the grandmother.
R u idoit , even German court has dismissed the case of sexual assault accepted it as mistake, who r u to question now ?????
@786__________ another bullah with another stupid logic. Hope one day one of your family face such thing then you will get the answer. And the reason they are doing this is bcs they want to convert these kids into christianity.
@@kuldeeprathore9489 he is a mullah don't expect empathy from him.
@Death_is_beginning_not_end Some child psychologists are dumb.
@@kuldeeprathore9489 you clearly don't know anything about how they work.
If Ariha is in foster home, then who is guaranteeing that Ariha is not being SAed or assaulted at that foster home?
If Germany claims that Ariha's family SAed her, then what proofs have they presented in the court?
Narrow mindset .
I don't know why
White cruel racists mentality like British
Camera.
@Death_is_beginning_not_end Just because Other migrants never had problem,that doesn't guarantee that no migrants will ever have problems
There’s evidence that the child might have been sexually assaulted at the parents home and no evidence she’s being assaulted in the foster home. I don’t see the logic of your argument.
And if you were concerned about the child, you should be asking how she ended up with a serious injury that looks like a sexual assault.
Doesn't Germany have enough middle eastern parents sending their kids
I'm an Indian, but I'm also a gynecologist, and in no way, can I fathom, how a baby's private parts can be accidentally hurt.
Just because the parents are Indian, we should blindfoldedly accept their version of the accident, and start supporting what's trending on .
So u think they are responsible for this ...As per your knowledge about human body parts.
Sexually assault is easy to find if a victim is minor girl specially in medical term ... and if they are sure about it then there is a real chance that its true.. german govt won't gain anything for doing something like that.
You can think otherwise just because they gain enough sympathy from indians through movie trailer but i don't wanna see that little kid to get more sexually abused just cos some social influense generated by some over-emotional people who don't care about truth.
I'm not saying that which side is right but we should be strict in this regard then emotional.
I am not saying taking the child away is right, but at the same time parents negligence cannot be justified.
I hope the baby is returned to their parents soon 🙏
I've heard of instances where some Indian families (even well off and literate ones) who are deep into superstition n stuff have ended lives of their own babies believing the baby would bring them bad luck and sadly in case of a girl child they don't even need a reason to end the girl baby but in families like these if the universe some how let's the baby live their grandmothers on the other hand will become the baby's Angel from hell and you cannot begin to comprehend how cold blooded these old woman can be...
You are absolutely right. Just surprised to see ppl defending this behaviour in the name of culture BS.
Even if it wasn't the parents, there is still someone who sexually abused the girl. And that's why the youth welfare office takes the child in because the child's safety is guaranteed there. Since the parents can't be proven that it was them, they can't be prosecuted for it, but the fact is that there is someone there either with or without the supervision of the parents , the girl was abused. The youth welfare office does not take action so harshly without reason, if the youth welfare office steps in or even takes the child away, then something really bad happened.
It was never proven
correct.
@@Schopenhauer69 the child was sexually abused, it was proven to be abused...but by who? nobody knows
@schopenhauer69 It was never proven because the parents never cooperated. If they really cared for their child, they would've cooperated to find what happened, but they wanted to save their own a$$ first. Guilty much?
This is cruel. Shame on Germany
Too quick to judge?
@@megavarnan3691 not too quick.... it's already very late....I have been knowing this issue from long but still no solution.
Shame on Germany
@@megavarnan3691 Should we wait for 2 more decades or what. It has been 1.5 years and almost 50% of his life till now is not with his parents. This is truly cruel
@@megavarnan3691 chali ja khopdi ki Germany fir
@@princethakur957 i meant what he said about "cruel"
This is so wrong, children are taken away from their parents. They're doing so dirty to Indian parents and children. Indian govt. Should do something regarding this, this is really a serious issue.
@The Archangel NOOOOOO, instead of chadaoing and blindly instigating people while insinuating ignorance, you need to hear both sides of the story. Germany knows the implications and ramifications that could come about by the 'thrill and enjoyment' they would get by harassing the very 'loving' Indian family. There are hundreds of different nationalities that live and work in Germany, why would they just pick on one Indian family?????? Indians have been living and working there for years, why only now and never before????
@@TheMindspoken Get educated on the issue and then come in comments section, this problem is through out the european countries, this is not the only family that is going through this.
@@TheMindspoken German authorities have never said anything, they ignored every request & plea.
This is very common in Europe. Indians care, others don't!
Atleast they spelled boycott correct this time around
If there is a law applicable for all then why should we boycott?
I think this is not an issue for only Indians , this is a problem for all the parents living in the western society ,the government intervenes with parenting way too much. We are humans ,not some kind of robots. Parenting is not a predefined procedure by the governments , it is how the parents interact with their child.
In this case it is wrong for the government to not return the child to the parents but sometimes government and NGOs should intervene because there are a lot of cases where parents do assault their kids(very few cases sexually).so it might be helpful for those kids to get out of those situations or else those kids without any help might get into wrong tracks and ruin thei life
True.. Every child is different.. Every parent is different... Every parents go through different problems... I don't know why govts in Western countries moniter parents...Are western countries parents irresponsible? Rules are made considering social cultural and economic conditions of once country.. .
Monitoring parents in India is not all possible. .
.. Because of the high rate of population.. ..people who migrate to
other countries should be careful and respect their land's rules.. When a country allows people from other countries it also should respect other cultures . What children want Is more important. In my opinian both the children suffered due to the egoistic
Insensible govt officers of Norway...
@@dibyajyotijena212 The criminal investigation has already been closed with no charges so the sexual assault allegations are just bogus.
@@dibyajyotijena212 are you retarded or what😡 assault case was closed with no charges and you moron have the audacity to say that the kid should not be given back to parents!!!
Technocratic authoritarianism is becoming norm in the west...in the name of following unstable and unproven science, they rule the people with technocratic mandates. They use media to spread narrative and use tax payers' money to implement such diktats. Public-private intervention in every aspect of life is increasing every year, children are the prime target in that process.
Delhi High Court observed that in 2014, of the 1704 cases of rape registered in the capital, 215 cases were instances of child incestuous rape. That was in 2014. I can understand the pain of this family, but these are serious charges and need to be investigated just as seriously.
Already investigated and closed as being baseless.
@@arohisrivastava8621 That’s what happens in India.
@@serenity8145judiciary is wrong and you are right ?
@@serenity8145 if you don't know kindly do a simple google search and know that the case was within German authority's purview. Keep your biased and self loathing views if you're an Indian, to yourself. Atleast respect your username and be like that.
@@Amziiwa for them it's always like this.
*So here's what happened*
Somebody gave a tip-off to the people of Norwegian child welfare support(CWS) that the children were not treated well:-
1) Mrs Chatterjee fed one of her children with her hands so the people from (CWS) thought she was "forcefully feeding" them.
2) Mr or Mrs Chatterjee slapped their child which was also considered as child abuse.
3) One of the kids was sleeping with their parents on the same bed(idk how this offended them)
Anyways, this was just a summary of an article I read.
Thank you for reading.
(Please avoid any grammatical mistakes)
These people share the same traits as the self-righteous person who during WW2, tipped off the Nazis about the presence of Anne Frank's family's hiding place.
As usual, an anonymous person.
Corporal punishment is illegal in both Norway and Germany and Yes slapping your child is child abuse. Norway is just enforcing it’s law and there’s nothing wrong with it.
@@MarxismLeninismMaoism There is nothing wrong with separating a child from their parents? That's sick.
@@NaSaSh1087 they have literally kidnapped the child no proof against them , parents know better how to take care of thier child sick mentality.
@@MarxismLeninismMaoism we know the cultural difference Or awareness needs to be there I think
Respect for Russia increases.
Russians loves Germans more than indians...they have same racist dna
@@joexavier4070 Russian government??
Bold of you to assume russia is a saint. humanity of all races and nationalities including russians, americans indians are no different, we are heading towards our own fall and we can do nothing about it
@@dell857 who is in russian government 🙄 Russians or americana
@ISLAMOPHOBIC_BOT abee mullla, tum jaisa boht shareef ho, terrorism ka naam suna ha, ak famous community ha dunea ma ( peaceful community). Pta nhi kitna katal kr chuka ha , innocent people ka
It's very wrong to mix these 2 cases. The Norway case of the Bhattacharyas are very different that the recent Shah case in Germany. Movie is about the Norway case and there was no allegation of any actual physical abuse. Only emotional abuse due to cultural misinterpretation.
But the Shah case is about an actual suspected assault to the minor daughter's genitals by the child's grandmother. This case should be dealt with differently. There might be an actual threat to the child in the Shah case.
Exactly, the internet outrage is seeing only one side of the story, what if German authorities are true? Although it is an allegation, I think Germans are going by the books to protect the child from further abuse.
Exactly
I don't know anything about the cases. But please don't discount emotional abuse. It is extremely damaging, be it for a child or even an adult. Our society views emotional abuse lightly as it does not leave a mark like a physical abuse that others can see easily.
@@sangeetharavindran87 yeah but the evidence given was flimsy at best
Thanks for your post, because only your Text give me Orientation about these Case. Never i have hear about it till now. Greets from Germany!
The little girl in Germany who was taken away from her parents was abused (had wounds inside her private parts) . Her parents were questioned how that happened and they said she might have fallen on some toys (which is bullshit and a lie).
Exactly!!! A toy??? Cmon. These parents should be closed behind bars. An injury in the private part won’t happen randomly. I’m sure they have done something to her.
See mother of the child witnessed blood on diaper so she immediately took her to the hospital. When the doctors questioned her what happened she guessed might she had fallen. And she has got would externally. So you can't make it a case of sexual assault.
Provide a bad translator to foreigners and then kidnap their kids. An unsafe country.
Also, female genital mutilation is not done in Jain community. There's hardly any reason to believe Germany given their track record of kidnapping foreign kids and pedophilia in child services with Nazi history of similar cases.
I was in tears after watching the trailer
Well for those people who are saying why a developed country would do something like that: ever since I saw this news,I got interested in this topic and a lot of other similar cases started coming in my recommendations and I found out that yes this mostly happens in countries like Germany,Norway, Australia, Sweden and all basically all the countries that have strict laws in this matter. And what do they do is that,these child protection agencies take advantage of the loop holes in the government's laws to take away the children and then make money out of them.
@@hi.-_176 They are not developed countries they don't even have a fair judiciary.
They the same barbarian, only now they are sitting on the Gold they looted from Asia and Africa.
@@hi.-_176 These people were killing people like incests just 70years ago( 2-3 generations).
I don't know why people go to these moronic nations along with there family.
@@hi.-_176 or maybe they are actually doing something in order to protect the innocent children from heinous monsters that are running out there in the open???? India mein toh sab kuchh chalta hai tum logon ko. Bhagwaan na kare bas desh ka naam na barbaad ho, baaki chaahe yahan genocide ho jaaye.
@@anti_fascist may be they are actually protecting the child but that doesn't mean ki maine jo kaha vaisa bilkul nahi hota in deshon mein,bas jara si research kar or pata chalega ki aisa hota hai ya nahi.
When my brother was small he accidentally fell from my grandmother's hands it wasn't her intention
Now that doesn't mean the government or any one got the right to take my brother away saying we don't know how to take care
Exactly .
u r r8 but plz tell her to be careful , aise kaise baccha gira diya yaar koi bag thodi h 😅
@@atharvgitte5169 bro he was playing. And kids are like this only... His movements were too fast and to be honest it wasn't her fault and can't blame the child too. He was very active and he was trying to do something when he fall.... Well it didn't become a big issue
And then it wasn't intentional it happened in front of all of us .
She loves him so much.
Currently he is all grown up
But here the baby has not fallen, that is plausible, she has been hurt vaginally as per reports . How is that an accident ?
@@anujoshi209 Germany court dismissed the case
If the parents are innocent, this is the most horrible thing what they can do to the family. Taking a child away from their parents.
But if the parents are guilty,?
@@YouYou-sm8tf Then the shameless Indians that are bitching here will do a 180 and pretend all of this never happened.
As an Indian, I'd say respect the country you're in. You go to a country on your own, then you've to abide by their laws.
What law was broken?
Practising your own faith?
@@hobbithallows when sexually abusing own child is your fa।th
We have to stop you.
yes and you cannot abuse your child and expect the law enforcement to let the child live with you.
@@hobbithallows prolly sexually abusing your child for starters
@@brettcantrell8650 "child abuse" 🤣🤣🤣🤣 westerns are talking about child abuse
🎈🎈🎈 An indian here:
It is said that the grandmother accidently injured the child. But no specifics are provided by the media for us to honestly make an opinion. Like how did she accidentally make an injury? Why did the injury seem to appear like a sexual assault case for German authority? Was it a single injury or multiple similar injuries ?
If the German authorities are at fault for confusing an accidental injury with a sexual assault, then the child should definitely be brought back to her parents
But if the parents are really at fault, then it is better for the child to be at foster care or other responsible people.
We shouldnt form an opinion until all proofs and details are available to us. Germany - India dialogue is the way forward to deal with such complex situations. You can't immediately start clamoring for boycotting German goods and services 🎈
rightly said
VALID POINTS THERE AND ALSO IF PARENTS ARE AT FAULT THEN WHY DID GERMAN AUTHORITIES HAVENT ARRESTED THE GRANDMOTHER / PARENTS OR SUED THEM ? BUT INSTEAD ONLY TAKEN THE CHILD FROM THEM 🤔🤔
Precisely, about the only logical comment on this. I wonder if this movie needs to come with a disclaimer since in the Norwegian case the authorities mentioned that there were issues of domestic violence in the family and the mother seemed unable to cope with caring with her children. The couple never clarified on what their issues were and did get divorced. However, the authorities were OK with giving over care to the paternal uncle so sure looks like there was an issue with the parents.
@@beezlebub9 maybe the mother will be a grey charecter in the movie
We already hate Germany, we just needed a point.
This is cruel. I can also see the cultural difference here. Indian authorities must look into this issue.
*Becharay Hindu ka jeevan jhund ho gaya hai rooj 10 - 20 boycott kar kar ke.*
Jokers
@@He.Who.Remains. what do you mean
@@gargipandaonefiveseventwot4961 He's yet another wannabe German. Blood traitors.
German authorities need to look into rapes and caste and racism issues in india coz it is too much for Germans to handle in india.. india need to change for better so Germans can live in India.
If you expect foreigners to respect your customs when in your country ,you must be prepared to do the same in theirs.
This comment section is wild… and no one seems to know how the social services in Germany works.
The authorities can’t even defend their decisions publicly as there are privacy laws involved. The parents can legitimately say anything yet the German authorities involved can’t say a word because the are forced to protect those same parents rights.
I think the internet should stay out of this situation.
Either the parents abused the kid or they didn’t. We can’t know and need to trust those involved to find out.
you westerners have a sick and inhumane mentality idk why
Finally some sensible comment. Thankfully there are some people who quoted it
Trust whom? The parents, the GoI or the German bureaucracy?
Yes... As an Indian I can confirm there is no value of human life in India as we r way too many in numbers
Exactly because i also live in germany and i have seen many cases where the children have been mistreated and that was the main reason of taking the child under care
They stay in my building in mumbai. The case is very genuine, and they should get back their child.
The jain lobby must do a juloos again
@@ayushpanda8896 we can and we will
@@ayushpanda8896 dude why bring religion here panda,
@@Kathakathan11 giving you the soln veg pulao
@@ayushpanda8896 I guess you have typo mistake
This is the most inhumane allegation any one can put on parents saying they are sexually harassing their daughter.
Apni beti ko rape kiye hue kitne baap jail mein hai ek baar dekhke aaiyo.
It's true
@@He.Who.Remains. No it's not. They literally ran a case over it in Germany and they still couldn't charge the parents with sexual abuse. The case is bogus and the little girl needs to be returned to her real parents immediately.
But the allegation is true. Even the Indian government has not denied it.
@@jackricheie9683 they may not have been able to charge the parents with sexual abuse due to lack of evidences. But the girl WAS sexually abused which is why her parents have been denied the right to get her back
I think German authority did well. The fact the case is closed for parents does not necessarily mean the child will be returned without risk assessment. It could be years before child will be returned or may not be returned at all. These things are taken seriously in Western countries.
Why hasn’t the issue been raised by the Indian diplomats yet??? This matter deserves international attention.
It happens in Scandinavian Countries also. Many cases went unreported in Indian Media.
Looks like there is some kind of racial discrimination having the superflous cover of unacceptable cultural difference in those countries
It will be very useful for our Indian viewers here if you could name those countries so that Indians can be cautious.
Finland, Sweden, Norway, Germany,Netherlands etc.. The rules of these Countries are very clear. For the sake of money people are preferring these Countries.
@@soundararajanvenkataraman1445 Thank you sir, your useful information will put many on alert while they have to go there for work.
People earn to protect their families, there is no point in giving away one's family to an autocratic white supremacists racists country on the pretext that they don't recognise other cultures & regard theirs as the best is a total waste of utilising our skills for the betterment of those countries. 🙏
@@shyama6576nothing to do with race. It's their law. Indian parenting methods are not tolerated. One should think twice before moving to such countries.
@@Schopenhauer69 you are right when you said that people should think twice before moving to such countries but I cannot understand it in any other way when they are intolerant of other cultures.
The west are cold when it comes to family love ❤️
Heartless, emotionless inhuman people they're.
No
They are different from us .
You see our people are Saling their children in brothels to earn living
Yes they know family values for sure
They leave there kids to be homeless when they grew up. Now have u seen any of there government doing anything for that .
They even sue the kids instead 🤦
Always has been
Just like india
My question is how come the private part of the child got hurt?
Not trying to justify or being in favour or being against it. But just curious to know that
As a mom of two babies. Injury in the private part won’t just happen randomly. Somebody must have done something. Mostly sexual assaults are abused by close ones or relatives. Some people are very evil. I’m sure the authorities have done thorough medical examination before coming to a conclusion. I hope the baby is safe in the foster home.
@@toringl5279 first of all, I don't know what really happened? But I know many children got injuries in there private part during their childhood but that doesn't mean they were s*xually assaulted.
@@sourabstyles3118 if u think like that either something wrong with you or the parents who let the kids get injured in private part
@@sourabstyles3118 What a load of crock. Get off the drugs.
How unfortunate. We did not realise this issue until this movie trailer. Shame on us actually....
Trailer is heartbreaking and eye opening in many ways..may fight get justice and baby returns to parents. 🙏
But Germany govt wants to gives us some lectures on Human right issue
Nazis shouldn’t lecture the world. They are nazis even today.
in the 30ties they worshipped Hitler, that was not ideal,but without religion the germans lost all morals and the void in their hearts fioled with sodomie and child abuse
Fingering your daughter is not a human right.
Let them first set their house in order before they do so.😂
As someone who lives in Germany I know that the state tends to be quite careful and perhaps even to careful when it comes to taking action in cases of child abuse (in the last years we had children die because signs of abuse were ignored or childreen were given back out of care without proper reassessment). So it is quite likely that they actually have quite solid evidence that the child was at least not taken care of or even being abused by someone.
Thanks @hindustan times for the coverage 👍
This is the India i talked and dreamt ,IT STANDS FOR ITS ROOTS,AWESOME ,love to all from Assam.
Absolutely Yes
Nava Jyoti
Love from Maharashtra 🇮🇳❤️
what roots lmao ? Indian hindu civilizaton started from Aryans who came from Afghanistan and Beyond. You Monogolian eastern hindus are converted hindus.
Dhunia ❤️
The more I learn about the case the more I support what Germany's child welfare system did
Sexual assault case against parents is something which can’t be ignored .. why authorities even say something so big and also how bad was the injury which grandmother did by mistake ? Everything should be elaborated .. it is so sad that child was snatched from their parents..
By mistake made such an injury the child needed stitches?
@@anxious.subhadra that's what I am thinking
it is so sad that the child was hurt in private parts by grandmother.
@Tim Lad Did your brother ever hurt his private parts on accident. Did your brother also get hurt so much to the point of requiring stitches on his private parts🥺. Pls do answer🙂.
@Tim Lad "Accidently" hurting the vagina so much that is tears and is in need of stitches is highly unlikely. Especially for a 7 month old child. People just want to turn their head and not accept the horrible reality🙄.
Indian govt should intervene in this matter and I request our foreign minister Mr Jayshankar to look into this matter do something for this couple bring back ariha to India 🇮🇳💯
ISKCON should intervene
Their white children are safe in Mayapur, while ours suffer
What makes you think that they haven't already?
@@Asteroria And if they haven't there is a reason for it......
Even if the Indian government investigate, it’s still Child Abuse, and / Sexual Abuse….the parents are still accountable….don’t know what the punishment is in India… but we as adults in a civilized society, have to protect any Child…..‼️⁉️🇺🇸
Bwood after a long time has thrown light on a relevant and sensitive issue. Misinterpretation of culture is a serious problem and the laws around children welfare in some Western countries can too absurd for immigrants to cope with. Although the typical Asian parenting is often accused of being too harsh, nonetheless many of the recent cases have actually noted a repeated attempt on the part of the Western governments to seize custody of children from immigrant parents.
Asian parenting isn't harsh it's more disciplined approach. Look at what western society is turning into wokeism nonsense and low academic grades. Asian kids are far better adjusted to adulthood and life.
Bollywood has always made films on various social issues , you were busy licking south masala movies
Bollywood meaning druggiewood? the same people that killed a young actor? You trust those druggies and uneducated people????
now dhruv rathee wont say a word
I am not a mother but I can feel the pain May God bring her back soon 😭
Poor baby. Her Dad looks so much in love with her.
Our all Indian parents are loving and caring than any other countries, always I believe and also at the same time they teach us a limit for everything. I'm the lucky one. 😊🙏❤👍
It's all racism towards indians they are doing
@@Asiansmomsuperslippers They dont understand the cultural differences, and because they feel superior to brown Indians, they do all this.
No kid is safer in a foster home other than those being severely abused.
In India, child protection courts rarely send a kid to a shelter. They try to counsel the parents, usually adoptive, to not beat the child etc.
Because the alternative is much worse -- sending a child to strangers. It has a deep psychological impact on the kid.
@@aritrabiswas4865 Kitne countries mein parenting ke expert hai aap???? Aapki PHD kahan tangi hui hai???? Arushi Talwar ke parents kitne loving and caring hai nahi!!!!
@@newsjunkieish bcz Indian foster homes and human rights law are a joke.western countries foster homes are extremely well maintained, and childs are cared for in a much better, humane , and scientific way than Indian parents can ever dream off
And these nations called themselves as the Champion of Human Rights. Lol
They the same savage barbarians.
They don't even know what right is, they have no legislation. Jews never had legislation in Germany despite living there for centuries. You think they will give legislation to anyone on visa?
There is gap in this news or with case of this couple. I live in Germany and my experience here is people are responsible and respective of others. I think unless and until baby is being mistreated by her family the authorities won't even interfere. Germany is already short of a labor and why would they put their money and labor just to harass the parent. I think it's utter nonsense.
German Government is very careful of it's people. From my perspective if the authorities have identified something wrong with parenting they will not give the baby back as they care for the individual and until the parent proves that they are capable of taking care of the baby.
There are always 2 sides to the coin so we should not draw our conclusion just based on the news or what we hear.
Your's the most sensible comment out of all these commetry🙂.
I am agree with you
True
Personally, I think people are going into this topic with a one sided veiwpoint. "Sexual Assault" in many European countries can vary a vast number of things, sexual is just the worst reason for it to happen. These things do happen and are taken seriously in Germany and other European countries. When they say no criminal investigation is done, I see it as it could have been the grandmother accidentally injuring the child or it could have been her disciplining the child (which is illegal) and safe to say not farfetched since as an Indian my ass has been beaten countless times (illegal in many countries). So what do we take off from this issue? Respect the laws of other countries and realise that nobody is in the wrong here it's just a misunderstanding born out of who know what maybe it was an unjust police, assault or just an accident. Also take a look at our country before others, we are deep in horseshit. By having a presumption on other countries you are not just narrowing your view but also that of your child, friends, siblings and their opportunities. But with all of that still we should not stop supporting the child and her parents even after this momentary trend that just makes a buck for these large megacompanies. (No Government, Company cares for anybody but that family does hope one more soul could help them reunite)
Coming from same gujarati jain community as the parents the biggest giveaway for me is that if they had done anything wrong they would have not tried to make it huge issue coz it would bring them a lot of disrepute in their relatives and community if they are found guilty.
Unfortunately this sensibility is not common to anyone in the west. This nuance is unique to us.
We pray for ariha parents hope they will get their baby inshallah
India never raged about injustice our migrant Labour workers in the middle East and Europe face...so our hearts don't melt for the poor as much I believe
Sachme Rona aagya trailer dekhkar , maa to maa hoti hai , phir to khuch bhi bacche keliye Jung Jeet hi jati hai .
Well i can't judge pre maturely without knowing the full story . The law's in germany are strict and these type of case's are very rare . So proper investigation should be carried on both the german authorities and the parents and the child and then justice should be served and punish the one who is wrong .
Another day of thanking God to be born in india 🙏
Kyon? Indian mein law and order hai hi nahi isliye???? Nirbhaya ke rapist ko choad diya woh sahi hai, bas dusre desh mein hampe kanoon mag lagao!!!!! Badhiya hai....
@@imneeta Judiciary ko gaali do na firr ye amedkar or usske leftist stooges ka kia dhara hai. Capital punishment rapist ko milni chahiye or ladkiya Tere jaisi Jo fake rape case laga skti hai unnko bhi capital punishment milni chahiye
seriously man! Atleast our parents are free to raise us the way they want and let's be honest, we grow up in much better family bondings than these Westerners do. We have a home.
@@shelveswithstories13 exactly what i wanted to say ... In western countries they kick there child out of house at certain age ....many end up homeless...some parents sue their own kid because they refuse to leave 🤷🤦
Hopefully pollution, population and reservation gets resolved
The problem is western and eastern countries are completely different in their thought process. While Asian countries are in general emotional, family oriented, western countries are not. They are "low context" culture . Which is totally opposite to most Asian countries. And obviously the age old fact of inherent racism on the "colored third world" people ! They won't budge, so it is upto us to be careful of what we show or do while being abroad. One can question why should we change everything, but that boils down to the choice.. do you want to stay there and keep your family intact or risk everything or come back home..
This is the problem when you live in a different country than your own motherland as we cannot bear their ridiculous laws
It is a reminder to all who run away from India for opportunities. Never forget the fact the cultures of foreign countries may not be tolerant to Indian culture.
But before that, think why people are going to other countries from India?
@@abeygeorge4526 Lack of job opportunities. But it's also true that you have to face discrimination too in the land of whites.
@@abeygeorge4526 i think, even though the no. Of Indians who denounced their citizenship and applied for Foreign Citizenship has been increased in 2022, but in next five-seven years, Indians will not do it maybe, bcz Indian Universities are improving tremendously now is what Nikhil Kamat has said, so maybe that's true
@@Hindu428 improving? I don't think so....with all the biased reservation systems and stuff
@@abeygeorge4526 there are people who want to go to the west particularly because they love the western countries. In that case be prepared for such situations. If anyone go there, you are a second class citizen.
Something is fisshy ....how parents have no explaination about internal injury happened to that child....
Unfortunately sometimes the German public services truly fail their job.
I remember some years ago they accused a family of sexual assault towards their children and the children were given to foster care where they really were sexually abused, while later it was proven that the parents never had assaulted their children. The family was German, it was not about racism, more about incompetence of staff at local authorities and lack of staff to do the job properly.
This is not the norm though. It's not common practice in Germany to take away children from their families easily. There must be serious reasons to believe that the family is abusive.
i wonder how come this came to light only after a movie is being made on it
Why was the child taken in the first place? For me children’s safety is utmost important! ❤
The hospital claimed that parent sexually assaulted her (That's it). And German authorities took her, the court took away their parenting rights. The parents filed plea, never got any response. VISA eventually expired, parents had to leave Germany.
When Indian Embassy asked, German quotes what the Hospital said.
That's what Europeans nations are like, there no legislation, they can do what ever they want.
UK & USA are different there have trustable legislation which gives you a fighting chance.
@@riscnx In that case, the hospital must have had some evidence, which they must have shared with the authorities? I am sure such decisions are NOT taken simply because you’re an Indian. There are MANY Indian families in Germany.
@@pritesh0117 hospital has no evidence but the injury and the sexual assault case has been dismissed against the parents by the genman court .
They closed the case and still didn’t return her. If they had any proof they should do something about it.
@@pritesh0117 okay, but why they didn’t arest anyone, I am pretty sure one evidence is enough to file a case🤢
I have zero tolerance when it comes to abusing kids, children & domestic violence of any kind against anyone regardless of age. At the same time, domestic violence is severely under reported in India & has became a norm which I wont support. There is no such thing as little or moderate violence regardless of what form it takes place as some people might argue.
Boycott sexually assaulting parents instead.
This is not just case of Germany…US too is the same thing. There are so many cases like this if you dig deeper
Literally cried after trailer
I was born In norway, I am an Indian, I lived there for eight years in the counties of Rogaland and Ostfold (now a part of viken) I also want to go back to norway and work there for a few years after my graduation. I am fluent in norwegian, almost all my friends were norwegian there except for most family friends. Norwegians are really nice people but there are some racist elements, much less than Germany, France or nearby denmark and neighbouring sweden , but there still is a small group of racists. Norway's Barnevaern or child protective services specifically target immigrant children, 3 of my childhood friends were kidnapped by the norwegian government itself.
Child protection in these countries is a serious and debatable issue
From ndtv: The couple said Ariha's grandmother hurt her by accident in September last year. When they took the baby to a hospital, the couple said the German authorities accused them of sex assault against the child and took her away from their care.
Genuine question: how do you accidentally hurt someone in a way that makes it seem like sexual assault?
This week German Chancellor will arrive in India Nice timing of releasing the trailer
Nazz!! Mentality dint die down it seems 😢 praying the baby unites with her parents super soon. ❤
It's not only Indians, it's Universal nation this time because lot of families are suffering, child safety is something good but the system is unacceptable.
Explanation to Some idoits who r raising doubt on parents on comment section , they must know and read properly , that the sexual assault case has been dismissed against the parents by German court , parents were clearly from all changes by court and yet child has not given back to parents , that is the issue . Foster home is trying to delay the case so after completion of 12 years away from parents , parents will have no right on baby as per German law .
This is awful and absolutely unacceptable. I was once badly hurt after falling down from a bike while playing as a kid. The wound I got would have been labelled as sexual assualt had it been in Germany or Norway instead of India lol. I cant even imagine staying away from my parents at such a young age and that too, for such a baseless claim.
Thank u fr making this movie. We must get Ariha back. She belongs to india. 🙏
It is omrit kaal. Bring toddlers back to India.
But this movie is not about Germany and Ariha. This movie is about another NRI family from Norway
@@DazzlingTulips Who cares. Common Indians got new jumla.
Were they deported against their wishes to India? And how can a baby have wounds in private parts? It is the duty of the state to investigate the matter. I felt so upset when the concern of the parents was that, their child is having non veg food. Any caring person's priority would be the well-being of the child, not the religious practise.
Shame on Germany for allowing this to go on for so long. The poor child has to suffer like this.
Did half of the commentators' population even look throughout the case's details and the morphological area where the infant was hurt? That is the prime reason why the child was snatched away from her parents. Do not just boycott a country for their immediate response to a presumed case of possible infant negligence and sexual abuse whereby, the young Ariha had to get stitches on the surface of her intimate area.
Man we Indians just beleive whatever we see, never do a thorough research before speaking on internet or anywhere 😞
@@askalad You cannot generalise your statement brother. It happens that we do talk about something without knowing the two sides of the coin ... The thing is those kids need to find a proper family may it be a foster or their biological families depending on a professionally assessed case analysis and distribution of justice.
@@ashura1541 on that i can't disagree well yeah that's fact that the kids need good care
@@askalad We all just want a stable and well maintained environment for those children who deserve a good familial environment to flourish as individuals.
It's just the track record of child kidnapping services in these European states. Cannot trust them over parents.
Remember Germany are still the same people during the HitIer era. They think calling others extreme makes them appear less. During this bending over phase they’re inviting the most inhumane.
Indian 🇮🇳 government should took custody of children's of Germany 🇩🇪's Ambassador of India 🇮🇳 or their authorities. This is the only way to teach them lesson.
Tf why you guys act this cringe
Believe it or not I know Mrs. Chatterjee in person. She is a really good friend of mine.
People who are blindly boycotting Germany are the need to get out of there sensitive soft corner and think logically.
I pray before the release of the movie Ariha return to his parents
We take living in India for granted
🫡...kya bat boli hai apne.sach me
Yep
Okay, so our Indian court doesn't give right for father to visit his child during divorce case even after 3, 5, 7 years but no protests in India here. Talk about double standards of the law.
??? Thats not trie at all🤦🏽♀️
But who assaulted the baby? You can't hurt a baby accidentally and have such scars that doctor was convinced it's a sexual assault. It's not about India or Germany. The baby should be protected.
Please bring back Ariha from Germany
That's why India is the best country to live in
How much the child must have cried for her mother ,so painful I had to leave my baby to give exam and she was so inconsolable
Reminds me of the Bengali lady (having complicated pregnancy) who died in Ireland because hospital refused to abort the unborn child.
Just because Ireland has strict anti-abortion law.
We indian need a movie on lootere British
@ISLAMOPHOBIC_BOT what about full length movie on India from Ancient to Mediaeval to modern and then Contemporary history of India?
this is absolute inhuman
You know what’s inhuman? The fact that hundreds of Indian children are dying every day in poverty, because India is such a poor, dysfunctional and corrupt country. Worry about that first before blindly jumping to conclusions on this one case. For all you know the parents are evil monsters that assaulted their child. I’m sure German government is just as capable if not more than Indian government at conducting investigation to figure that out.
@@anitakay8634 where do u live? n what do u do for living?
I must say this is the power of media- entertainment industry as well as social media
The trailer made me cry ❤❤
Just think if the parents are from US or china, Germany would never have kept their daughter. What actions we took nothing just talk. The Germany chancellor is coming, why we are allowing them to come?
because we need germany's influence for growth
Power/weight of a country determines. That's the fact.
Germany need our market more than we need them
People have the power government have not any legal authorities here
@Itea8504 so stupid 😂!
We have media and international news agencies like DW,BBC,CNN,FOX doing the job😉. No need for government to intervene.
India doesn't have powerful news agencies like us, so you guys speak of our morals like- Boundaries, Jurisdiction etc etc😂
Germany thinks they are superior to India
Am so shocked at how Norway cd treat a family like that
Its old news in Germany and so sad. Here they follow the rule by letter, no human mercy.
mai bhi inhik bareme soch rehi thi inki story bhi same hai lag bhag hope yeh movie inki liye thori madadgar ho or yeh couple ko apni bachi wapas mil jaye lag bhag 1 saal ho geyi hai ink bache ko bhi esehi German government leke geyi hai ink news maime dekhi thi likin mujhe kolkata ki yeh couple ki story pata nehi thi because uss waqt Internet nehi tha or choti bhi thi hope yeh movie inn couple k liye madadgar ho or unk bachi mil jaye unhe or logo ko bhi thank you ki woh inn couple k liye awaz uthaye cheeso ko janne k baad
What if ariha grandmother actually harrased ariha in reality what would you say
Everyone is looking from emotional angle but actually Western customs don't allow corporal punishment which is normal in Indian customs
@@jaishree701 re ager kiya hai to mai to bol rehi hun na thik hai indian authority ko sope bachi unk maa baap india mai apni paksh ki rakhe fir decide ho or assure kare ki grandmother se bachi ko dur rakhegi iska matlab yeh to nehi usk maa se bachi ko dur rakho grandmother se k pas na ane dene se matlab hai grandmother se dur rakhenge wohlog
@@debalinamukherjee7197 ho hi nhi sakta mam
Indian culture mein corporal punishment common hain maine bhi face kiya hain aur commonly dekha Hain ☠️☠️ jisse german khafa hain most probably voh kuch incident ko lekar kaafi insecure hainn ladki ko lekar
Yaha full time emotions ke basis pr trend kr rahe hain log sikke kaa dusre ka pehlu nhi dekhte abusive family members actual mrin hue toh kya hoga
My Daughter works at a parent assessment home in Germany.
Many of her clients are from war torn countries, third world and imprisoned lands.
Its a cultural shock for them as regards to the tough standard to parental care.
Any type of mental or physical mistreatment to their standards must be registrable
Which in due shall be accessed.
A tribunal then decides according to the case , what the next step is.
Before any child becomes a custodian of the Govourment.
The parent/s are interviewed and when necessary, counseled on how to treat their child.
When that fails, then the child will be put into the care of a care family.
It is not written in stone that the child will remain.
Parents have later made a application to get back their children.
When approved they must agree that at first under the supervision of a care specialist.
When they achieve the parental standards.
Then they will be allowed to take their child and live a life together.
Be it on occasions spot checks will take place to make sure that the child is doing well.
Its a burocratic hurdle.
With high jumps.
The average German finds it hard going.
So no wonder it seems to those from outside, to be hard and yes even cruel.
Their country their rules
Tough standards lol. Germany is third world country itself maybe fourth world.
You see it is a kind of forcing someone from other culture to live by your standards which is nothing but acting with supremacists racists attitude. Eating by hand is normal in India & babies in India do sleep along with their parents.
Why they haven't arrested the parents & the grandmother. If they have cleared the charges holding back the child is nothing but kidnapping.
I understand that you have mentioned the procedures of Norway here but it is against human rights to against other nations culture which is not an abuse.
@@shyama6576 unka desh unka rule 😂
No surprise that here that Germany is having population decline, who would want to raise their children in Hitler rule .
parents are god for children , And no one can take care of the children better than the parents. ❤🙌
Germany has some balls to go against 4th superpower with Nuclear Triad 💀
That’s the power of cinema…but unfortunately bollywood never used it’s true potential….
As if south makes such kind of films. This is the power of Hindi Cinema but Indians are hypocrites , they will be busy south crap masala