I don't understand all this hater on giselle not dancing so well, forgetting that giselle is the main rapper? she dances well, not the best in the group, but she still knows how to dance. I must also say that aespa's choreography is not the best in the world. Let's just compare with illusion and black mamba which are the best choreographies in aespa and we see giselle dancing well. it's ok to make mistakes, it just shows that she's human I will continue to support and show my love for giselle
의상빨 조명빨때매 연습때보다 더 실력이 그럴듯해 보일테고, 첫 주는 라이브도 안해서 퍼포먼스 발휘하기 딱 좋은데 너ㅓㅓㅓㅓㅓㅓㄴ무 움직임 둔해서 할말이 없음.. 나는 지젤이 더욱 더 열심히 했으면 좋겠음 … 회사에선 에스파는 완전 글로벌로 자리잡으라고 밀어주던데 충분히 다른 매력이 돋보이는 멤버라는건 아는데 결국은 그룹이 오래가기 위해선 기량이 제일 중요한거 아닌가 .. 춤은 하는 만큼 느는거라 생각하는데 저건 연습 부족임
Guys Ive seen her past fancams and she was a lot more energetic. For example in Black mamba she danced pretty well and had a lot of energy. Right now she might be going through something or all of these harsh comments could have affected her. Im not biased but I don’t think we should judge someone so harshly without knowing their situation. I still have faith that she can do better. I feel like she’s not letting her self loose she might be nervous cuz people seem to literally hate her whole being.
exactly this comment. I felt that black mamba was her most confident era but over time even now, all the hating just made her lost her confidence. Up till recently i also saw knetizens bodyshaming her. With all this hate, i would have also lost confidence eventually being on stage. I did see the fanmeeting my synk giselle fancams and infront of the fans, she had so much charisma. i hope she can let loose of herself too
As an aespa fan starting form their debut, I HAD faith that she'd do better. But with their cb stage being a disaster - as if she only spent half the time as other members learning the choreo, plus the Zoo performance which was really disappointing (btw, not only talking about the "earpiece problem" but also the choreo), I'm starting to lose faith in her. Even Ningning who's a foreigner is making a huge effort to make progress, which is noticeable, then why is Giselle not improving (relatively)?
@@user-si1ks2ni4b okay, suppose she is a foreigner, still makes no difference. Both Ningning and Giselle are foreigners, why am I seeing huge improvement from NN but not her?
glad i was with her since debut and now seeing her improvement especially during armaggedon era and now getting more lines and screentime in whiplash oh aeri uchinaga you have come a long way ! so glad you took those criticisms and slapped back at haters with so much improvement i hope the haters who commented here are seeing her latest faancams as well and noticing her growth
Constructive criticism goes a looong way. But it's also possible she might have some sort of issue, because if you look at every other choreography, she had no issues unlike this one.
That time is a dark time with Giselle, so i didn't mention or look back much. But after a random dicussion with my friend, i suddenly recognized that this fancam seems to be not the same with the group fancam which made Giselle get bashing so much. I don't know why M2 didn't use this fancam for group fancam. We can see that she did not look lazy here.
Giselle is insanely charismatic here, her growth as a performer from debut to here is just amazing! Her red hair is *awesome* ,she's absolutely lookin like goddess!!
I'm a My and I would not deny that Giselle needs to work more on her dancing. Yes, she's improving in her own level but she's with a group of good dancers so she would most likely stand out if she wouldn't catch up with their power and energy in the dance. She trained only for a short time so I'm pretty sure she's well aware that she has a lot of catching up to do. She's not a trainee anymore so the pressure to do better is much heavier than what it used to be. I just hope that with all the criticisms she get, she would stand up stronger and prove that she can do better than whatever is thrown at her. Hang in there Giselle ♡
Giselle really knows how to use her eyes.. The way she moves her eyes while performing she look confident I think this is her strength point.. As well as she's good at hands moves Really love her expressions on her parts... Also she's really good at body waves if you know what I mean 00:34 (idk if it's right to say this lol).. Proud of you gigi ✨✨
I agree with what you said about her eyes and her body waves. I noticed in Life's Too Short MV, she's the best at executing the body waves for the chorus. I think the reason why her dance skills is overlooked is because aside from she had the shortest training period and has a weaker core compared to the other members, most of aespa's choreos don't fit her dance style. She suits more fluid choreos like Life's Too Short and Dreams Come True. But aespa's choreos are more on sharpness, corners, and isolation. And that's why Karina and Winter are the best at executing them because aside from they're the main dancer and the lead dancer, Karina and Winter's strength are isolation and popping. But Giselle is not a bad dancer. I believe she's gonna keep getting better over time. Love seeing growth among artists.
@@AyemJen yup she just needs to get used to it and practice more she can keep with the group she just need to build her special aura which will make her unique as a dancer I already love that she's having her own style.. I also agree.. Choreos like illusion fit her way better she shined when she was on the center and her charisma showed up...
Looking at the famcam, I don't see any mistake and I actually find her pretty smooth and great! I dont know why people ate complaining... She's got a lot on her plate.. Dancing, singing, the camera movement, the audience, facial expression, even her members and the outfits
But it was her profession, she should be enthusiastic about the stage, but I didn't see her like that. And the comparison between her and her teammates would have been even more devastating, and would she have been so ashamed to stay?
I think this performance of personal fancam is different from the group fancam , so people are criticizing her judging from the group fancam. Both fancam can be recorded from different take so yeah.
giselle is so gorgeous her rap was full of swag she is on fire when her part comes every detailed of choreography she ate it aeri uchinaga the main rapper of aespa
giselle my love is improving in dance, look at her confidence. if SM can bring Taeyong from the worst dancer and train him untiil he’s so strong dancer, I believe in the potential that Giselle has.
Yaah that's true, i almost forget that taeyong can't dance in the beginning😩 now see him as a really good dancer and many idols stan him like role model of other idol. I'm so proud
Actually people are just so hard on her. Cmon, little mistake on 1 or 2 stages doesn't mean anything and not to the extend that she didn't deserve to debut or to be with the group. People are just obsessed looking for a even a small hole to drag her down. And I just want to say this. Clearly people are being weird and double standard. There are literally idols out there who is out of tune, got mixed up with the choreo, missing the beat/timing, voice cracked but all I see are "Oh she/he must be having a bad day" "poor him/her, it must be tiring" "It's okay, mistakes do happen" But when Giselle was lagging even for not more than 2-3 seconds, we got some "pros behind the phone screen" saying she should leave the group and she shouldn't have debuted? So, other idols are allowed to do it wrong, but when it comes to Giselle, she have to be punished and received all sort of name callings and being bullied. The real definition of fcked up and fcking evil kpop stans.
Gigi, if youre reading this, I want to say that dont listen to those jobless haters. I remember you used to smile so much during black mamba era but now it saddens me you lost that beautiful smile. We mys will defend you so keep doing your best. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH MY GISELLE
I cannot understand the hype of this group... It really pays to be from SM. She's not even giving 60% and this song is average by most standards, yet it breaks records and people gas her up like her skills are iconic. People really just stan looks from SM. It's no hate to her as a person but all this shielding fans do from genuine criticism will only come back to her ten fold down the road
As a Giselle stan, I'm really proud of her to see improve every comeback. I'm really shocked how she can get along with the girls every movement. I've been stanning her since debut. HOWEVER (ps: this is based on my observation and never mean any harm towards giselle) but I see her lack of push of every choreography unlike karina, winter and ningning, GISELLE is really good at vocal and rap I have no comment for those. But in terms of dancing as I've said she's lack of pushing and I believe she will improve more. Also such extra sassy movements, like movements of shoulder, head and feet. I see nothing but STIFF. I don't know if it's because of clothes but I see her every fan cam, there is definitely improvement but I see more STIFF. I need to see the energetic giselle in choreo. But I can't wait giselle will improve.
I don't understand what step makes her look so lazy because she looks completely fine in her dancing. True, her old energy was more than now but she did really good in this perfoemance 💖💖 I hope the haters realize how really good she is in dancing!! Keep up the good work Giselle and you also look really pretty ❤❤ Stan AESPA
@@taru1566 뚝딱이로 데뷔했으면 차라리 성장캐로 자리잡아 가는게 젤 좋지ㅜㅜ 한순간에 잘 추길 바라는건 힘듦 계속 제자리 걸음이면 몰라도 지젤 블맘때보다 훨씬 나아지고 계속 나아질 것 같은데 매 컴백마다 성장해나갈 수 있는걸 오히려 악효과 볼 수도 있음ㅜ 물론 자기가 매번 노력해야하는 거긴 하지만
For people who say bad things about Giselle, are you perfect? When you are body shaming her, have you looked in the mirror with your own body? Your fingers are so mean for typing too much hate on her🙄
![[MPD직캠] 에스파 지젤 직캠 4K 'Supernova' (aespa GISELLE FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2024.5.23](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/AazfOarDjjE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MPD직캠] 에스파 지젤 직캠 4K 'Supernova' (aespa GISELLE FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2024.5.23](/img/tr.png)
![[안방1열 직캠4K] 에스파 지젤 'Savage' (aespa GISELLE FanCam)│@SBS Inkigayo_2021.10.24.](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/idG-laMFQkQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MPD직캠] 에스파 직캠 8K 'Girls' (aespa FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2022.7.14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4kAxgCm1BPM/mqdefault.jpg)
We passed this era along with giselle, now she showcasing more strong and better better version of herself, love you aeri🖤
최근 보면 백배는 더 늘었다 진짜 ㅠㅠ
자랑스러운 애리 … 지젤력 핫걸 행복하자
I don't understand all this hater on giselle not dancing so well, forgetting that giselle is the main rapper? she dances well, not the best in the group, but she still knows how to dance. I must also say that aespa's choreography is not the best in the world. Let's just compare with illusion and black mamba which are the best choreographies in aespa and we see giselle dancing well.
it's ok to make mistakes, it just shows that she's human
I will continue to support and show my love for giselle
의상빨 조명빨때매 연습때보다 더 실력이 그럴듯해 보일테고, 첫 주는 라이브도 안해서 퍼포먼스 발휘하기 딱 좋은데 너ㅓㅓㅓㅓㅓㅓㄴ무 움직임 둔해서 할말이 없음.. 나는 지젤이 더욱 더 열심히 했으면 좋겠음 … 회사에선 에스파는 완전 글로벌로 자리잡으라고 밀어주던데
충분히 다른 매력이 돋보이는 멤버라는건 아는데
결국은 그룹이 오래가기 위해선 기량이 제일 중요한거 아닌가 .. 춤은 하는 만큼 느는거라 생각하는데 저건 연습 부족임
진짜 방구석 악플러들 말은 보지 말고 힘내서 본인과의 싸움으로 춤 개선 했으면..
연습부족 맞는듯 솔직히 춤실력이 리아정도도 아니고 연습하면 더 잘할수있을것같은데… 왜 그렇게 힘빼고 느슨하게 추는지 모르겠음
지젤진짜 너무 귀여운데 섹시. .... 신이냐고;;
미친 지구젤리 앞머리 내리니까 진심 존예잖아.... 뭐야 핫걸...???
びじゅあるよすぎ！！かわいい！！
Guys Ive seen her past fancams and she was a lot more energetic. For example in Black mamba she danced pretty well and had a lot of energy. Right now she might be going through something or all of these harsh comments could have affected her. Im not biased but I don’t think we should judge someone so harshly without knowing their situation. I still have faith that she can do better. I feel like she’s not letting her self loose she might be nervous cuz people seem to literally hate her whole being.
exactly this comment. I felt that black mamba was her most confident era but over time even now, all the hating just made her lost her confidence. Up till recently i also saw knetizens bodyshaming her. With all this hate, i would have also lost confidence eventually being on stage. I did see the fanmeeting my synk giselle fancams and infront of the fans, she had so much charisma. i hope she can let loose of herself too
Ofc she is a human being at the end of the day. She is still doing really good tho. People really need to give her some rest
As an aespa fan starting form their debut, I HAD faith that she'd do better. But with their cb stage being a disaster - as if she only spent half the time as other members learning the choreo, plus the Zoo performance which was really disappointing (btw, not only talking about the "earpiece problem" but also the choreo), I'm starting to lose faith in her. Even Ningning who's a foreigner is making a huge effort to make progress, which is noticeable, then why is Giselle not improving (relatively)?
@@user-cn9pj3iw3s Gisele is also a foreigner
@@user-si1ks2ni4b okay, suppose she is a foreigner, still makes no difference. Both Ningning and Giselle are foreigners, why am I seeing huge improvement from NN but not her?
우왕~~♡ 자신있는 지젤 넘 좋아♡
빨머 완전 찰떡이야 ㅠㅠ 랩 포지션인줄만알았는데 보컬도 잘해 ㅠ 우리 애리 앞으로도 홧팅!
지젤은 앞머리가 레전드❤️
glad i was with her since debut and now seeing her improvement especially during armaggedon era and now getting more lines and screentime in whiplash oh aeri uchinaga you have come a long way ! so glad you took those criticisms and slapped back at haters with so much improvement i hope the haters who commented here are seeing her latest faancams as well and noticing her growth
エリちゃんの赤髪今までの髪型の中で1番大好き…
girlsの活動ファイティン🫶🫶🫶
뚝딱뚝딱 🥢뚝🪨딱 뚝딱 뚝딱🪵🔨뚝딱
카리스마는 미쳤다… 너무 예쁘다… 바로 지젤 핫걸입니다 ❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥 애리야 잘하고 사랑해요 🖤
나름 잘 하는거 같은데 댓글 왜들 그러지… 했는데… 3:30 여기부터 뭔가 잘못됨을 직감함
진짜 이정도면 거의 방송사고급
ジゼルちゃんの笑顔みるとなぜかホッとする
춤 늘었다고 칭찬댓글 너무 웃기다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
スタイルイイよね✨この衣装似合う🎵
ジゼちゃんの前半のラップかっこよすぎて何回も聴いちゃう😍かっこいいのに最後の笑顔がかわいすぎて何事⁉
ほんとにじぜるちゃんがだいすき！！！💞💞💞
Giselle BEST PERFORMANCE 💓💓💓💓💓
지젤 사랑해! 댓츠핫! 앞머리 진짜 잘어울려
지젤 개이뻐진심
빨강머리 찰떡ㅠ 앤공주와 인어공주같은느낌ㅠㅠ 왜자꾸 이뻐지는거야.... 댓츠핫... 지구젤리는 사랑입니다
3:32 여기서부터 진짜 깜짝 놀람…
연생 기간도 오래하고 그만큼 쟁쟁한 멤버들 사이에서 오히려 본인은 짧은 연생기간과 멤버들보다 뒤처진다는 생각에 부담감도 어마어마 할 거 같은데,, 젤리야 진짜 너무너무 예쁘고 특히 젤리 랩파트 너무 멋있어 🤍 남은 활동도 기대할게❤️🔥❤️🔥
뭐가 멋있다는거지 랩도 못하고 그냥 원터 카리나가 멱살잡고 끌고가는데
@@우기우기-x2e 원터? 뭘 원하세요
ㅈㅅ
@@우기우기-x2e 이게맞음
김애리 누가 그렇게 이쁘래...누가 그렇게 노래 잘부르래...흡혈귀같다..언니 내 피 다가져가...항상 응원해 김애리!💗💗
춤이나 잘춰라ㅋㅋㅋ
립싱크인데 노래 잘부르내 ㅇㅈㄹ
??얘넨 또 뭐람 춤 많이 늘었는데 도깨비불 보면 춤실력 많이 늘은게 보이는데 왜 또 난리일까? 립싱크든 아니든 결국 저 음원도 지젤이 부른거잖음;; GMA 썸머 콘서트에서 라이브 잘한다는거 인증까지 했는데 적당히좀 까 이제;; 할짓이 그렇게 없나;;
天才 かわいい かっこいい 美しい 全て持ってる神ジゼル🌙
1:26 when she heard the screaming for her and started smiling aah that was so cute
애리언니 고생하셨어요 짱멋있어..
I just notice that Giselle was more confident during GIRLS era and her Brunette hair make her visual stand out more!! 🥺
you guys can tell giselle about her mistakes and give her advice but you can't bully her. just be respectful
Constructive criticism goes a looong way. But it's also possible she might have some sort of issue, because if you look at every other choreography, she had no issues unlike this one.
Gisele, don't lose.
We will always support you no matter what you are.
mid
えりちゃんが世界で一番最高だよ〜愛してる今回のカムバもずっとカッコいい
好きだ
存在してくれてありがとう
She looks so healthy and beautiful. My gir Gigi!
attitude while dancing is rare, aeri showing us improvement can happen if you want to
ほんとーーーーにだいすき
わたしのなかのNO.1 ᵕ ᵕ̩̩💓💓💓💓💓
That time is a dark time with Giselle, so i didn't mention or look back much. But after a random dicussion with my friend, i suddenly recognized that this fancam seems to be not the same with the group fancam which made Giselle get bashing so much. I don't know why M2 didn't use this fancam for group fancam. We can see that she did not look lazy here.
Giselle is insanely charismatic here, her growth as a performer from debut to here is just amazing! Her red hair is *awesome* ,she's absolutely lookin like goddess!!
아니요
@@minhokittens2404 tru
@@minhokittens2404 true
@@minhokittens2404 wrong
yes, she is ♥
지젤언니 정말 귀여워요..ㅜㅜ
사랑해요!!!!
ジゼルちゃん本当に可愛いㅜㅜ
愛してます!!!!
I'm a My and I would not deny that Giselle needs to work more on her dancing. Yes, she's improving in her own level but she's with a group of good dancers so she would most likely stand out if she wouldn't catch up with their power and energy in the dance.
She trained only for a short time so I'm pretty sure she's well aware that she has a lot of catching up to do. She's not a trainee anymore so the pressure to do better is much heavier than what it used to be.
I just hope that with all the criticisms she get, she would stand up stronger and prove that she can do better than whatever is thrown at her.
Hang in there Giselle ♡
希望Giselle能被更多人喜欢
앞머리 진짜 그리웠다고..ㅜ 이쁘다💓
첫 무대부터 헤메코 너무 완벽하자나🥹🫶 오늘 고생많아써 앞으로 남은 무대들도 마이랑 함께 힘내보쟈~🖤
Giselle really knows how to use her eyes.. The way she moves her eyes while performing she look confident I think this is her strength point.. As well as she's good at hands moves Really love her expressions on her parts... Also she's really good at body waves if you know what I mean 00:34 (idk if it's right to say this lol).. Proud of you gigi ✨✨
I agree with what you said about her eyes and her body waves. I noticed in Life's Too Short MV, she's the best at executing the body waves for the chorus. I think the reason why her dance skills is overlooked is because aside from she had the shortest training period and has a weaker core compared to the other members, most of aespa's choreos don't fit her dance style. She suits more fluid choreos like Life's Too Short and Dreams Come True. But aespa's choreos are more on sharpness, corners, and isolation. And that's why Karina and Winter are the best at executing them because aside from they're the main dancer and the lead dancer, Karina and Winter's strength are isolation and popping. But Giselle is not a bad dancer. I believe she's gonna keep getting better over time. Love seeing growth among artists.
am i the only one who thinks giselle is a good dancer.
@@wintoreos she is good dancer but I just personally think that they all needs to make their move but more Powerful
@@wintoreos I agree
@@AyemJen yup she just needs to get used to it and practice more she can keep with the group she just need to build her special aura which will make her unique as a dancer I already love that she's having her own style.. I also agree.. Choreos like illusion fit her way better she shined when she was on the center and her charisma showed up...
Looking at the famcam, I don't see any mistake and I actually find her pretty smooth and great! I dont know why people ate complaining... She's got a lot on her plate.. Dancing, singing, the camera movement, the audience, facial expression, even her members and the outfits
But it was her profession, she should be enthusiastic about the stage, but I didn't see her like that. And the comparison between her and her teammates would have been even more devastating, and would she have been so ashamed to stay?
I think this performance of personal fancam is different from the group fancam , so people are criticizing her judging from the group fancam. Both fancam can be recorded from different take so yeah.
What I can see is she didn't even move😄is this called dance??
@@bwahaha7964 then what do u see huh? She's playing around?
@@bwahaha7964 "ela nem se mexeu" a jura oque ela tava fazendo então? se consegue criticar consegue fazer, então faz melhor
giselle is so pretty and stunning i can’t get over her truly she’s the LEGEND
지젤님 너무 예뻐요🥰♬
우리 지구젤리 .. 🌙
지젤 너무 예쁨 ㅠㅠㅠ
giselle is so gorgeous her rap was full of swag she is on fire when her part comes every detailed of choreography she ate it aeri uchinaga the main rapper of aespa
swag lol
@@kenziekaylynn ?
@@kunpunko swags just a funny word 💀
Swaggy Giselle Aeri Uchinaga
えりちゃんがきれいな言葉だけを見て、おいしいものいっぱい食べて、しあわせに生きれますように🤍🤍🤍
あなたはほんとに最高のアーティストです！！！！！！
지젤 너무 잘한다 잘해! 항상 응원해! 잘하고 있어!
SHES SO PRETTY
그녀는 2일 동안 춤을 훈련했어야 한다
Dia juga manusia bukan robot
She looks amazing with red hair
giselle my love is improving in dance, look at her confidence. if SM can bring Taeyong from the worst dancer and train him untiil he’s so strong dancer, I believe in the potential that Giselle has.
Yaah that's true, i almost forget that taeyong can't dance in the beginning😩 now see him as a really good dancer and many idols stan him like role model of other idol. I'm so proud
지젤 이쁘다
이번에 지젤 개이쁘다..🔥💖 앞머리랑 머리색 찰떡이고 갈수록 점점 더 이뻐지는듯..
이번 무대에서 유독 지젤이 예뻤음..❤갈수록 미모도 빛나고 춤노래 실력도 더 늘고있는듯 애리 짱 사랑해🖤🌙
진짜??
@@Vanban9295 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 현질 많이해야겠는데
1:27 랩 좋다. 지젤 매력 잘 살렸음
지젤👏👏👏👏👏항상응원 합니당^^♡
Actually people are just so hard on her. Cmon, little mistake on 1 or 2 stages doesn't mean anything and not to the extend that she didn't deserve to debut or to be with the group. People are just obsessed looking for a even a small hole to drag her down. And I just want to say this. Clearly people are being weird and double standard. There are literally idols out there who is out of tune, got mixed up with the choreo, missing the beat/timing, voice cracked but all I see are "Oh she/he must be having a bad day" "poor him/her, it must be tiring" "It's okay, mistakes do happen"
But when Giselle was lagging even for not more than 2-3 seconds, we got some "pros behind the phone screen" saying she should leave the group and she shouldn't have debuted? So, other idols are allowed to do it wrong, but when it comes to Giselle, she have to be punished and received all sort of name callings and being bullied. The real definition of fcked up and fcking evil kpop stans.
역시 핫좌는 앞머리 내리면 너무 이쁨요,,
지젤 화이팅 !!
지젤 이쁘다💖💖💖🫶🫶
Gigi, if youre reading this, I want to say that dont listen to those jobless haters. I remember you used to smile so much during black mamba era but now it saddens me you lost that beautiful smile. We mys will defend you so keep doing your best. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH MY GISELLE
giselle during her 2nd verse rap just screams confidence
우리 지젤이 잘하고있다 ! 긴장하지말고 자신감가지고 활동 화이팅! 뒤에 마이들있다!
매력이 넘침~ 매력녀 지젤~~
하앙 우리지구젤리 오늘도 다리길이 이메다네ㅠㅠ❤️ 넘이뻐 최고😭❤️🔥❤️🔥❤️🔥🫶
I cannot understand the hype of this group... It really pays to be from SM. She's not even giving 60% and this song is average by most standards, yet it breaks records and people gas her up like her skills are iconic.
People really just stan looks from SM. It's no hate to her as a person but all this shielding fans do from genuine criticism will only come back to her ten fold down the road
maybe she wasn’t feeling well. however she’s an amazing rapper and a great vocalist, she just needs to get better at dancing.
I have to agree, some groups are famous because of the members looks and the agency's impact and aespa its an good example of this in my pov
見る度に良くなってるし、努力してるのが伝わってくるから応援したくなる。
ジゼルちゃん可愛い💕
えり大好きだほんとにきらきらしてる、可愛すぎる…
지젤 너무 이쁘다 노래도 잘한다💗💗
giselle so pretty
As a Giselle stan, I'm really proud of her to see improve every comeback. I'm really shocked how she can get along with the girls every movement. I've been stanning her since debut. HOWEVER (ps: this is based on my observation and never mean any harm towards giselle) but I see her lack of push of every choreography unlike karina, winter and ningning, GISELLE is really good at vocal and rap I have no comment for those. But in terms of dancing as I've said she's lack of pushing and I believe she will improve more. Also such extra sassy movements, like movements of shoulder, head and feet. I see nothing but STIFF. I don't know if it's because of clothes but I see her every fan cam, there is definitely improvement but I see more STIFF. I need to see the energetic giselle in choreo. But I can't wait giselle will improve.
omg gisele look so good 🤩 with red hair
Giselle dance keeps getting better. Keep the hard work girl will rooting for you 💪
I don't understand what step makes her look so lazy because she looks completely fine in her dancing. True, her old energy was more than now but she did really good in this perfoemance 💖💖 I hope the haters realize how really good she is in dancing!! Keep up the good work Giselle and you also look really pretty ❤❤ Stan AESPA
역시 지젤깅💕💕
この時のジゼルめちゃかわなんだが！？
3:04 전체샷에서도 티났는데,,,단독샷은 완전 뚝딱이임;; 제발 안무연습좀 해라
연습은 당연히 하고 있을거고... 이번에 걸스 준비하면서 퍼포도 그렇고 전보다 확실히 더 늘었던데 첫 대면 음방이기도 하고 예쁘게 봐주셈ㅜ 님네 애기들한텐 사랑한다 소리 잘 만하면서 이번에 많이 늘었구만 타 아이돌한테 왤케 빡빡함
엥 에스파 완전 호감이여서 계속 보고있는데 진심 지젤 민폐임 ㅠ 빡빡한게 아니라 저 춤실력에 비해 욕 덜먹고 있을때 ㄹㅇ 정신차려야함
@@taru1566 뚝딱이로 데뷔했으면 차라리 성장캐로 자리잡아 가는게 젤 좋지ㅜㅜ 한순간에 잘 추길 바라는건 힘듦 계속 제자리 걸음이면 몰라도 지젤 블맘때보다 훨씬 나아지고 계속 나아질 것 같은데 매 컴백마다 성장해나갈 수 있는걸 오히려 악효과 볼 수도 있음ㅜ 물론 자기가 매번 노력해야하는 거긴 하지만
@@suzetteeee 아니 차라리 블맘이 더 나아요.... 이번 걸스 안무는 하나도 소화 못하고 있는 걸로 보이는데 ㅠㅠㅠ 솔직히 매번 아쉬움
@@suzetteeee 2년차인데 아직도 저러면 문제있는거라고 봐야지 지금 한두명도아니고 다수가 심각하다고 지적하는데
gigi is so gorgeous!
Giselle so pretty🥰
Giselles rap skills are from another world💕💕💕
赤髪似合ってる〜♥️前髪ありジゼルちゃん大好き😽
ああああぁ、可愛いイィ🥺🥺愛してる
非常にきれい
Giselle is GORGEOUS
Giselle is the ace. She's amazingly talented and she's slaying this stage! Good job Gigi!
지구 젤리 화이팅💛💛💛
For people who say bad things about Giselle, are you perfect? When you are body shaming her, have you looked in the mirror with your own body? Your fingers are so mean for typing too much hate on her🙄
ずっとかわいいな〜
Giselle cantik bangettt😭😭😭
Giselle looks like an anime character
Our Aeri always come back stronger