Bottom Line with Pravin Sawhney: Lessons from the Kargil Conflict and Modern Warfare Dynamics
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 чер 2024
- Join Pravin Sawhney in this episode of Bottom Line as he examines the lessons learned from the 25th anniversary of the Kargil Conflict and their implications for modern warfare strategies.
Pravin discusses doctrinal lessons and operational challenges faced during the conflict. He delves into the significance of jointness among different military branches and the necessity of theater commands in modern warfare scenarios.
From analysing military strategies employed by both Pakistan and India to discussing the importance of conventional deterrence and long-range precision fire, Pravin provides valuable insights into India's military requirements and the challenges it faces in building credible capabilities.
Don't miss this insightful discussion on the Kargil Conflict's legacy and its relevance to contemporary military strategies. Tune in to Bottom Line with Pravin Sawhney, exclusively on Force Magazine's UA-cam channel.
![ПОЛНАЯ ИСТОРИЯ ЭКЗОРЦИЗМА [Топ Сикрет]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qBySr6Bt0B8/mqdefault.jpg)
Excellent program as usual. The best strategy for the region would be for China, India and Pakistan is to live in peace and avoid war at all costs. Dont let out of the region countries or powers to divide and rule us. I truly hope that sense will prevail.
It will be boring 😞😞😞😞
Impossible for Indian military to take on the PLA in any area. Doing so will be suicidal.
@@Gman979India has never invaded or started a war .if at all war happens it will be started by China . & to deter them International backing will be required . Or a military alliance with USA / western nations.
India doesnt send terrorist and suicide bombers to pak..
Both India and Pakistan need domestic stability and rule of law before anything else.
印度問題：宗教，民粹，種姓，資源不平衡，外部投資環境，槍枝，毒品，貪污，人民素質！🧐
Free Kashmir, occupied like Palestine and there may be peace
@@saliksayyar9793 Indian side is peaceful, progressing and happy. What's going on in POK? Why Pakistan wants others land? If Pakistan leaves POK then it will progress like Bangladesh. Corrupt Pak generals creates the problem for both India and Pak
@@Cannoli_JJ 他们过着幸福快乐的生活……我在中国工厂看到了中国人的生活
@@nirmalbhel3231 然後呢？中國人的工廠怎麼了？🧐你考慮過有工作和沒工作是什麼區別麼？
Thanks, Mr Sawhny, for educating the unaware, especially the military commanders, and the top leadership of all the regional players confronting mutual destruction for the interests of the extra regional powers.
Hope they learn and carve out and way forward for the regional peace with mutual benefits.
Salute to you from Pakistan for your strategic vision and advise for the top leadership.
Pravin misleads. War or conflict? How does it matter? Kargil was one of dozens of misadventures of Pakistan. It was a foiled attack on Indian soil. Anyway, Pak is paying economic price now.
You are an asset for your country! Salute from Pakistan
Brilliant analyas always
Great👍
Well said sir. Anybody in the govt. hearing?
Brilliant as always always Sir❤
Mr. Sawhney, you have very valid point on having Indian military forces organized in most effective manner. However, I do think before additional forces put into places, it is necessary to have theater command first so that army can be directed by navy commanders or vise versa. With this critical step, they will be only taking orders from commanders in same forces and high barriers with others even in time of war. I also think the upper echelons got their interests in the game. Your voice will never be heard.
Sir kargil top peak point 5353 still Pakistani control
LOC runs on this peaks, technically it is no mans land. As of now, no one is there. Pak's post is below this peak, which is in Pak's control. Kargil was Pak generals biggest bunder after 65
@@nirmalbhel3231 it was not a blunder it was a good plan but it lacked the one supportive thing which is the Airforce. India won only on the basis of its Airforce, if Pakistan had used its Airforce then India would have never been able to reoccupy it.
@@MirzaShahidmughal1 Don't know how much you know about this. Air Force Navy were not told of this plan. Mussaraf approached Qureshi, he told he is not prepared F16s needs ammunitions from US. Only 36 F16s were operational. 0
Indian side was fully prepared Mig Miraj, Jaguar were ready to bomb deep inside. Indian Navy also came out. Many of your expert says it was a BIG BLUNDER. World termed Pak a rogue nation and started supporting India
@@MirzaShahidmughal1
But i thank Pakistani army claim when they initially claim those were the terrorists which occupied the peak.
@@MirzaShahidmughal1 Perhaps u don't know why ur shaheen Airforce didn't come in rescue.
Pakistan was lacking BVR missiles both on F16 and Mirages.
On the other hand Indian Mig 29 had R27 and R60 BVRAAM and Mirage 2000 had super matra.
It would have been suicidal. PAF got cold feet like 1971.
Viewing from Pakistan❤
You aren't alone. Most of his viewers are ISPR and CCP zombies. On a side note, congratulations. Looks like you have both electricity *and* internet access!
PLA is not your threat. The threat of India is the Indian delusional belief and foreign policies.
Well said well said. But the major portion of the population are so desperate for something to be proud of they will exaggerate everything albeit fakes or untruth .
A very nicely explained narrative. I am from Pakistan, but I have great regards for such professional analysis. Both India and Pakistan need to understand that war is not a good option. Why can't we co-exist peacefully
Pakistani are dalit muslims.😊
Beautiful
Great analysis. Thank u.
Excellent information and narration...
Sir, our leadership is confused and only involved in perception management
Excellent analysis sir.......India is blessed to have you, and hope will not be doomed by not listening to your thoughts
Excellent brief, present General to take lessons.
Good analysis 👍 viewer from Pk
As usual he speaks about the unpleasant truths
Great analysis sir,
Salute to your Wisdom Sir. 🫡
Love from Pakistan
It would be nice to have a video on the topic of the Russian president's visit to China.
India never had any interest in changing the border with Pak. It always taught a lesson to Pak in 1965, 71 & 99. Pak Army can't match Indian Army thus, doing cheap proxy war designed by Zia. Modi had very well in managing Pak, previous Cong govt like UPA failed
1. Chinese realizing the need of theatre commands in 2014 is military genius. India realizing the same in 2002 is a blunder.
Kaha se laate ho aisa gyan
2. Jointness is much needed when their is scarcity of resources. Please read basics of optimization techniques.
3. When and Which PM of India ordered the armed forces to obliterate the boundary line?
4. Because of whom India lacks defence manufacturing capacity, Modi came in power 10 yrs back with his plate full of economic woes.
5. Think twice before blaming a man like Atal Bihari.
Mr. Shawney seems to be a master of theories - could his theories disprove all the victories India won in the past? Didn't the capability, credibility etc work in India's favour, in previous conflicts? And, in Atmanirbhar issue ( Swedish Defence Journal report ) Mr. Shawney cleverly hides a mouse behind an elephant - Aircraft purchases or the likes which consumed vast chunk of the total outlay, are included in total arms imports.
Excellent discourse. However, both countries need to resolve all issues amicably and justly and rather be good neighbour to the benefit of their people.
India and Pak both wants but not Pak generals.
All Pakistani love him he was in Pakistan i have seen him on Pakistan now channel.....i think he is paid by isi and PLA
😊
If India cannot fight a all out hot war against Pakistan and win why on earth would India want to pick on a big superpower like china? Perhaps they thought by aligning themselves with the west they could scare the Chinese off. Knowing the troubles their western friends are having domestically and how they would respond when it gets too big by absconding why would they think that china would be intimidated by their alignment with the west is another enigma . Sign of desperation perhaps ?
India is not looking to pick a fight with China. China wants Arunachal Pardesh which Chinese call South Tibet and Ladakh. Chinese have already bullied and taken over part of Ladakh in the past few years in pieces. India is not even trying to get those pieces of Ladakh back. It is just a matter of time before China come and attack India and take over both Arunachal Pardesh and entire Ladakh. India has the right to try to prevent the above. All Indian Prime Ministers from the first Jawaharlal Nehru to present Narendra Modi have been always trying to please China so that China does not attack India. But unfortunately that has never worked and India has always been repeatedly attacked by China since it’s occupation of Tibet. Any alignment with Western countries, Australia or Japan is more for economic reasons and access to sell in those markets. India will never attack China on the behest of USA or any other country. War with China is inevitable as China will attack to get Arunachal Pardesh and Ladakh. Next China will also try to remove Kashmir from India with Pakistan help from the West. China has too much investment at stake in POK Pakistan occupied Kashmir. China needs access to entire Indus (Sindhu) river infrastructure and part of that lies in India at the moment.
China is not a superpower as it can't project power like US, it will become. India is not a superpower but it can do limited power projection as it did in Red Sea. Chinese vessels were also there but they were unable to help anyone. India is not a war mongering country, it wants to stop Chinese aggression. China will definitely attack on some day. India is preparing to defend itself. Same with Pakistan, they want to capture Delhi. It's very unfortunate that India has neighbor like Pak & China
Your Foreign Minister, a week back talked about difficult times (next 4-5 years) for the world. He, being among the top FMs of world has a solid ground to talk like that or say know the future game plan of US and its allies. Ukraine and Israelis massacre are part of that prediction, as most western thinkers are talking about WW-III. The new strategic alliance between Australia, UK and US (AUKUS) to counter China in Indo-Pacific region has purpose, a serious preparation for a big war. India may not be officially declared to be a part of this alliance, but by giving its (India) support facilities/logistic support to these countries is like becoming a part the alliance. In case of a war between AUKUS and China, the alliance will drag India into the war not only through logistics but forcing Indian forces to engage China from its south. This will be a disaster to Indian economy even if India remain neutral, which is difficult because of its huge exports to Europe and US, which will be exploited. The dollar is losing ground, BRICS dissolving western dominance are enough for the dark future ahead of these global players. America will keep creating wars to offset threats to its national security and this threat is much bigger and stronger than ever before in its history.
Very realistic analysis of present political situation imho.
Excellent analysis Mr. Sawhney. Credibility, you have pinpointed rightfully; it comes from the top. A self-centred man who has no regard for ethnic and religious minorities and occupies the PM's post has made tons of blunders. Galwan, Balakot, arresting opposition like Mr. Kagriwal, and destroying every institution, even the military leadership promotions, can not be any Capacity, Capability and Credibility. Please get rid of that man and put some politicians in the help of the affairs department in Delhi.
Pakistan has the greatest leadership in the world.
@@anuradharaghavan872 That is incorrect, but they don't claim to be thumping 56" chests, either.
@@zaffazad4040 And a former Pakistani Prime Minister said Pakistan would have nuclear bombs even if their people have to eat grass - and it has come true!!!
@@anuradharaghavan872 He was an intelligent man, he foresaw that there will be a moron in India, Mr. Modi. Pakistani nukes may help him maintain his sanity.
was sacked from defense services and teamed with a Kashmiri Separatist Gazala Wahab. I can understand why Pak wants PM like Modi
Modi has never said that India has achieved atma-nirbhar in defense sector... this is another lie by this loyal Indian
Modi said a lot of things too many most of the time .
@@wh4uf he is playing politics
@@nirmalbhel3231 yup.
He is a China-Paki Agent
@@nirmalbhel3231 he's not playing politics but telling the sober truth . He's hope is that common sense can prevail in the right circles. But after 10 years of modi it has just gotten from bad to worse . Deny for all you want and it's good for others. Slumber on while the bed is warm.
Sir you forget to mention one more thing. The huge disadvantage Pakistan had in conventional capabilities. Pakistan only launched operation with light infantry and light artillery. PAF was not brought into war theater bcz it did not have capabilities. PAF calls 90s the lost decade due to some reason. On the other hand IAF had complete immunity to operate as PAF was unable to match IAF capabilities.
😂Paf f16s had already been inducted and flying.. Pak mılıtıarg restraint was actually ımposed by clınton
Assuming what you said that Pakistan did not involve the other sector of their military in the Kagil conflict is true which I know you're wrong. Even with such lack on the Pakistani side India was unable to win this war . You just added insult to India's injuries.
Be realistic don't live in fools world.😂 we are watching you😂
@@wh4ufplease enlighten me when did Pakistan used its airforce in Kargil.
@@snd9826 That's what I said the Pakistan did not use their air force or the result would had been more disastrous for the indian .
ब्लॉगर्स को अपने ऐतिहासिक अध्ययन को मजबूत करना चाहिए और भारत के इतिहास और क्षेत्र को समझना चाहिए ताकि दर्शकों को गुमराह न किया जा सके।
Pravin sawhney is a very intelligent person when sir could not get proper importance in India he started working for Pakistan seating in America with his Pakistani partner
Pravin is an idiot who misleads. War or conflict? How does it matter? Kargil was one of dozens of misadventures of Pakistan. It was a foiled attack on Indian soil. Anyway, Pak is paying economic price now.
please talk about ancient alien war capabilities of modi sena
true advice
India thinks it won every war. You lost Kargil and in 1962 China kicked India's behind!!🤣🤣🤣
Joke of the century 😂😂😂😂
@@santhugowda7179 Ask Geneerla Bakshi calling Indian's "darpok qom". Exposing how historically Indian people have been ruled by outsiders for centuries🤣🤣🤣🤣ua-cam.com/video/3DgGY9WrIYU/v-deo.html India is the biggest joke ever!
Yes India lost Kargil and Pakistan got jammu and Kashmir.. U know why
Islam in brain jumps out😅
kargill bhai ap chutiye paida huye the baad m jakar hue ho
While the jawans on the front lines are willing to sacrifice lives for their mother land, the indian army leadership is pathetic and dont have a clear strategy against china and Pakistan
Pakistan was defeated since it is politically established force without any political leaders in command to guide and plan any solid strategies with full scale of army airforce in joint operation.
Pakistani after losing they will come up with lame reasons for losing war against India.
~~~HIGH COMPLIMENT~~~ 'India/Pakistan matched' -
Being that India has a 1-10 disparity in its favor.
Actually they are not, Indian had never surrendered while the Pakistani had done that a couple of times moreover Pakistan had lost more than 9000 km to India in western theater since 1947.
I can understand the purpose here, Pravin was sacked from defense services and teamed with a Kashmiri Separatist Gazala Wahab
Pravin loves India and wants it strong. You talk like a paki who wants a weak India
Great
You have a fundamental misunderstanding of rules of engagement when it comes to contested territory and uncontested territory. Particularly when the line between the two countries is LAC and not a border. Thus, your argument that Chinese are not deterred by Indian nukes is based on false assumptions.
Second, calling Pakistanis "pakis" shows the mindset and frustration. Not professional nor it suits a respectable analyst to use a derogatory slur.
You do make some good points so thank you for that.
For god sake please upload comedy videos for entertainment.😂😂😂😂😂
S Jaishankar said that situation at LAC is very abnormal, please make a video on this.
GREAT MIND😊
Well, I agree what you have said but I don't agree with your stupid definition of war. Secondly how can you question the then decision of Hon. Gen. Malik?? Do you think you are more competent than Gen. Malik??Now with the benifit of hind sight you can go bla...bla....bla.
Pravin misleads. War or conflict? How does it matter. Kargil was one of dozens of misadventures of Pakistan. It was a foiled attack on Indian soil. Anyway, Pak is paying economic price now.
Ghazva-e-Hind...
Keep dreaming that and dont work. Pak will go down India will go up and keep dreaming of Gazwa... Muslims of India have started converting back, it is long way but it will happen. Welcome to Ghar Wapasi
Basically,
India is, ____ mein dum nahi, hum kisi se kam nahi 😂
Be it Hindutva Right Wing or Casteist Centrists at the helm.
Such a shame 👎🏻
China and India have an agreement not to use arms and ammunition on their LAC . The Chinese beat the hell out of the Indian army with fists and clubs and pushed them into the freezing river. Both were fighting On Ladakh, a land that belongs to neither country
Praweny you are an intelligent man, war causes destruction and great suffering. Campaign for peace, not war. India and China should leave Kashmir and let the people be free. Peace may follow
Pakistan should leave Kashmir too. In the name of Kashmir the Pakistanis have ruined Pakistan too.
Listening to this guy made me want to throw up!
Poor Modi has his work out out for him with this kind naive and antinational thinking!
There are so many loopholes in his theory that you pass an aircraft carrier through them.
He has raised so much nonsense that it would a whole day to rebut his nonsense!