THE KASHMIR FILES Movie Reaction Part 3 & Review | Anupam Kher | Darshan Kumaar | Vivek Agnihotri
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
- Reaction Gear: amzn.to/2QgTwk2 (affiliate link)
____________________
Intro music by DAVIS
UA-cam - bit.ly/30OK7RR
Spotify - spoti.fi/2I3vRvE
iTunes: apple.co/2KnvgYN
SoundCloud: / unofficialdavis
Facebook: / unofficialdavis
Twitter: / unofficialdavis
Instagram: / unofficialdavis
___
Jamazing Patrons of May: Krishna Venkataraman, Avijit Singh, Madhan, Bhavya Singh, Sameer, Akash Dhanasekar, Riju Mahna, Raj Malla and Snigdha Dantala!
Be a patron for Jaby and support more videos like this!
/ jabykoay
___________________________________________________
SOCIAL MEDIA:
~ACHARA KIRK~
Twitter & Instagram: @AcharaKirk
/ achara
~JABY KOAY~
UA-cam, Twitter, Instagram: @jabykoay
~VEERENDRA CHOWDARY~
Veerendra Chowdary created the opening animation.
Twitter: @NameisVeeru
~MOOSA RAZA~
Moosa Raza created additional background animation.
Instagram: @syedraza7
Twitter: @MoosaRaza27
___________________________________________________
Jaby WEST:
/ getjaby
Jaby ASIA:
/ jabytv
JABY KOAY'S SHORT FILMS PLAYLIST:
• JABY'S SHORT FILMS & F...
Click here to subscribe and know when the next video drops:
www.youtube.com...
Thanks for watching!!!
__________________________________________________
Credit of my favorite movie reviews song:
Highlight Reel Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License
creativecommons...
Intro song: Hudson Stanton (looks more like Nick Jonas than me)
UA-cam: / hudson12311
Insta: / hudsonstantonmusic - Комедії
Writer wants to say that Krishna character narrates to the People of India who is confused between who is saying right or wrong .But after watching this movie everything is clear. This movie is written so nicely and only 10% is shown of what actually had happened .Director Mr Vivek Agnihotri had taken interview of more then 600 kashmiri pandits family and did research for 4 years for this movie 🙏
Research of 4 years to produce this trash lol
He is also gonna make a documentary type webseries with those interviews
Well I think most of us could be able to see that raw pain and horrors.
Most of people thinks they are Krishna but actually they are arjun.. Just like arjun from Mahabharat ..just as confuse between 👉 or wrong.. Or what to go
yes and as jaby said that they showed very less violence/ speech wasnt bold enough from what he expected...itself contains the answer... WITH THIS MUCH ONLY LEFTISTS WERE AGITATED THAT THE MOVIE IS TAKING SIDES AND SPREADING HATRATE FOR "m community".... IN OUR COUNTRY WE CANT AFFORD TO TELL THE TRUTH WITHOUR FILTERING IT OTHERWISE IT LEADS 2 RIOTS WITHIN A FEW MOMENTS... IF THE MOVIE WOULDNT HAVE BEEN THIS MUCH SUPPORTED BY PEOPLE DEFINITELY IT WOULD HAVE BEEN "THE END" OF JUSTICE AND TRUTH
AND the thing about VFX and quality of production..let me tell u...it was made on budget of 15CR...producers couldnt afford to risk their money on such controversial topics in our country coz we have seen boycott ,failure of eye opener movies...it was courageous to put their money into this project...and it earned 150times...350 CR earning...hope this would inspire other projects to show truth ab8 other injustices
@Mean&Meaner 💀
Anupam Kher is a Kashmiri pandit himself and his father has been through all this. HENCE, he portrayed it perfectly.
I didn't know that. He is a great actor. ❤❤❤
Thanks I didn't know that. ❤
Being a neighbour of kashmiri pandit ...when they tells about these horrific incidents eyes just can't stop shedding tears ....we just can't imagine their state...May they get justice ...They left their property and wealth and living like a refugee in their own country ..
Thats a radical muslim doings not every muslims are terrorists but all terrorists are muslims.
Stop acting
Yes. They are good at acting and saying sweet words.. but in reality they have hate towards non muslims and they are happy coz their aim is fulfilled@@user-op3yc6dy4f
@@user-op3yc6dy4f hat ja yaha se jihadi
I m Kashmiri Hindu
Still living in J and K
We will never leave our land
Not afraid of jihadi muslims
Jai mata vaishno devi ji 🙏🏻
Bhai kabhi Apni jamin nHi chhodna
I live in j an k too brother!
Namaste🙏🏼
Proud of you
And start pickup guns
As a Muslim I am with u ...never ever leave ur home...
What happened to kashmiri pandit was very unfortunate...hope all of them get back to their home ...govt should help them in resettlement rather than playing politics on this issue
25:11 That villain is real. This character has been made as combination of two real life characters Bitta Karate & Yasin Malik. Everything in the movie is real. The blood soaked rice, the cutting in two pieces, kids being shot, the narrative building at universities everything was real.
Yesterday army arrested yasin
@@IM_Nothing00 he was not arrested yesterday. Yesterday the court's verdict came out which is only related to cases on him from 2016-17
@AARYAN My God.
This actor is really very talented after seeing this Role in Kashmir pandit You won't believe that he has played the role of Shivaji Maharaj in Sher Shivraj and Pawankhind the Marathi Movies
@@IM_Nothing00 not yesterday..
Im from Mauritius snd some specific community banned that movie but finally played it here. This movie is a lesson of life, who you should never trust
Right
It was banned for a reason, no one wants the truth to come out
Ofc Mauritius stops Indians to be in their country... How can they support us through movies
The real incidents are way more brutal. This movie has toned down the violence and shows just 5 percent of what happened. It was so horrific that it can't be shown on celluloid. People were cut into pieces, gangraped for days, hung alive, killed in the most brutal manner!!!
Yes ! Exactly
You forgot to mention that all this was done by followers of peaceful religion
@@tahir5864 saare patharbaaz ek jese hi hote h ek baar ko bhi bhrose laayk nhi h muslim log
@@tahir5864 but islam believe in killings others
@@tahir5864 go on, complete the statement. what after but?
Heartwrenching.....even as Indian ...this was never told to us...this movie is slap on our face. This was covered from us . It is naked truth...Krishna is not one character it's what every indian youth is....
To me, the truly disturbing part of the movie wasn't the gore, the blood-soaked rice scene or the climax. It was the very beginning. We see Shiva, Krishna's brother, playing cricket with his friends while an India vs Pakistan match is being broadcast. Shiva then starts cheering for Sachin and then gets assaulted for it. More than the horror show that was to follow, this drove the message home for me. I used to be innocent and full of praise for Sachin once. I used to play Cricket with friends too. I had many normal days like that when we played a few matches and went home when the sun set. It felt disturbingly like a scene from my own life and the people who suffered felt like people I knew and greeted everyday. This is what makes the movie work: the realization that these people could've grown up and led lives like I basically took for granted as I grew up but this was stolen from them because of the people involved.
I am a Hindu, but I couldn't find the courage to watch this movie because of the feelings it leaves you with. It's so traumatizing that the oppressor becomes the victim in the media and calls for "azaadi." Finally, Article 370 is revoked, but nothing can make up for the pain the Kashmiri Pandits have gone through.
KASHMIR HUM SHARMINDA HAI, TERE KAATIL ABHI ZINDA HAI😢
Me too and now I am crying like crazy.Only reason I voted for Modi for my first vote. I don't trust Muslims and secular Hindus.
Girija Tikoo sawed alive was our relative. Getting married into a Kashmiri family - I was horrified to know these facts each day.
My husband (was my classmate at college) and my hostel roommates - all of them Kashmiris, never ever discussed the truth and what they went through . It was too painful to revisit maybe. Now after this movie is released they did talk about it. They are on the first step to healing.
Most of the Indians including me know the truth now - a 10 percent of it-but sadly there are still many denying that this happened to the KPs.
Oh my heart 💔💔💔
Sad to hear this......... 😢😥😭........
🙏
There are Muslims defending islamic genocide in this very comment section
@@manishmishraji they can't hide.. Let them try every thing..
After Sardar Udham Singh, The Kashmir Files is ready to show the REALITY behind the exodus (NO NOT EXODUS, GENOCIDE). This movie is going to be known to set a benchmark for decades or more. A decade defining movie that is gonna make you have on tears coming from that heart's cry. The genocide which was concealed from the country by the government back then. It is definitely one of the best made movies in the WORLD in this genre. It really shows all that pain, sufferings, the whole scenario with transparency, without any social/biased filter. Here, everyone & everything got what he/she/it needed, what we call PERFECTION in words. Thanks to the director, Vivek Agnihotri, who has the dare and aptitude to show this stuff as it should be. Great work of art.
True.
And as a result more movies will be made like this. Credits to Vivek Agnihotri sir.
I cried a lot when I was watching the movie in theaters, especially in last where the women is cut into two halves vertically and the moment boy "Shiv" was shot..
@Pratham A.S Ofc yes! "We" made it successful, and "we" also includes the government of India.
It's much more bigger and deeper then sardar udam singh
Fun Fact : Anupam Kher is realy a Kashmiri Pandit, Who lost his Grandpa to Terrorists. So his Family decided to move out of Kashmir. He started his career in Acting and became a Famous Movie star later on and now he has joined Politics. He mentions how hsi mother was traumatized with events that happened in Kashmir, So having him play this Role gives us a Special Significance.
How is this a fun fact? Are you out of your mind?
When this movie ended, I knew that they hadn't showed all the atrocities and the level of brutality that had taken place. I then researched a bit and found that in reality, the mother "Sharda" was gangraped in her own house for several days and was forced to eat rice cooked with her husband's blood. And in the chainsaw scene, it was actually a teacher/lab assistant in a school in kashmir, who had later settled in jammu. She was called by her fellow coworker to come back to kashmir to collect her dues from the school. She was then kidnapped from those premises, brutally gangraped and later cut in half from the level of the abdomen with a manual saw.
This film has indeed tried to show the truth. But does not show the truth in it's entirety. And that is something you realize at the end. I hoped that they would have shown the complete truth but then realized that, this film may not have even passed by the film board, if they had done so.
These people are worshippers of satan and think they worship god. They will only get Hell for eternity for all their gruesome sins and hatred towards Hindus. Just matter of time.
I too read about them
Can u give me the link for the article
they can't add too many charachters so they try to add the major hardships into those selected few charachters so that people watching wont get confuse
@@shreyarana9145 The director has recorded testimonials from the victims and their direct relatives...Very likely he will come up with web series...
As a keralite I was not aware of what happened to kashmir. Thanks to this movie. The unfortunate truth is that kerala is becoming the next kashmir.
Malabar massacre ( moplah) before independence inspired by khilaphat movement. Pls read about that
You are still having power and don't lose it.Ram, parshuram, krishna all have wepons to destroy evils and u can end them properly by democracy, only u need to Tale actions , whenever they are in more num they will do but U r also powerful to counter them ,punch them on face by befitting reply
@@saanvi5660 muslims are not a majority lol. Only 26 percent. Majority of the population in kerala is hindu only
@@Fidah only 26%? That’s not minority.
@@pooja9321 When did I say they were a minority?
The director of this movie got z category security due many threat calls for exploring the truth of Kashmiri pandits. True untold story of Kashmiri Pandits. Tears in my eyes through out the movie. Great acting by Anupam Kher and Darshan Kumar
Also, in case if you didn't understand the Kashmir issue- Kashmir was always a predominantly Hindu state. Its the same place where Alaxander had his war with Porus and his army forced him to return back to Greece. Kashmiri Pundits were the native population- all being scholars and highly versed teachers. At the rise of Islam and its subsequent conquest, Kashmiris were slaughtered and forcefully converted. This was done over and over until the Hindu population became a minority.
When the British ruled India, they were wrongly portrayed to be controlling the whole territory of Indian subcontinent. The British controlled most part of India directly, while the several small kingdoms were governed as ally states. One of those ally states was Kashmir- which enjoyed sovereignty throughout the British Raj. After the British divided the Indian subcontinent into one territory of India and two territories of Pakistan, the ally kingdoms were left to decide their fate. It was all up to the politicians now to negotiate and bring them into their country. 58 such kingdoms agreed to drop their monarchy and join the Indian territory, 3 disagreed: Kashmir, Junagarh and Heyderabad.
A plebiscite was held in Junagarh: the public voted in favour of India.
The Nizam of Heyderabad was house arrested and coaxed to sign the treaty.
And Kashmir- giving mixed results- the king (who was Hindu) wanting sovereignty- was left alone.
Soon the Pakistani army attacked Kashmir, seizing half of the territory (which is called P.O.K.). The Maharaja soon asked India's help upon which he signed a treaty. Now Kashmir became an autonomous state- it was free to manage its internal affairs according to it's own laws.
In 1971 India won the Indo-Pak war, thus taking away half of what was Pakistan. The East-Pakistan territory which is now the free country of Bangladesh was freed by India.
Pakistan, humiliated, instigaed terrorism and brainwashing acts among the majority Muslim community of the region. Before 1970s, Kashmir used to be India's biggest tourist destination. Dal Lake was picturised in many old Hindi movies. But after 1971 things began to change in a very slow pace. By the late 80s the public had begun to be hostile towards the minorities. This led to the D-Day- 19th Jan 1991- when the now trained local youth begun harassing, killing and raping the minorities at gun point. The local sentiment had overturned. These locals used to go to POK for military training and would come back as "armed rebels"; or what propagandists and hyper liberal leftists of today call them "misguided youth" lol.
Article 370 was the article in Indian constitution that gave Kashimr the right to remain an autonomous state. The Kashmiri politicians allowed the atrocities to happen under their very nose. The Indian government was helpless at the time as India was not supposed to meddle in Kashmir's "internal affairs", thanks to this article. India could only provide shelter, and so over 5,00,000 people became refugees in their own country.
In 2018, the Modi government scrapped and dissolved the article 370. The BJP had to play real hard politics to drag Kashmir into its own loophole of demands so its powers could be snatched away. Today Kashmir is a Union Territory of India- all its internal affairs are now handled by the Indian government- The Central Government at that. No more nasty politics. No more "lle me do what I want" shenanigans. India has had enough.
thanks for all the Mehnat you put into this comment really helpful
very well written
bjp really earned some extra points and appreciation here the extremist muslims and the opposition were challenging bjp " jo karna h karlo article 370 nhi hatega " and modi amit shah reallr removed it lmao historic moment
Perfectly explained.. kudos for such a detailed post 👍
@@collegediaries1001 yes well written indeed, but the fact that indian government at that time couldn't do much is hard to digest...
That cutting with the saw incident really happened to a women called Girija Tikoo, she was only 21 Years of age. She used to work as a lab assistant in Kashmir when she left her job and fled because of the torment and threats and took refuge in Jammu. She went back to Kashmir only to get her pending salary as she was much in need of it, with the assurance that the situation was much better and safe. The real incident was much more brutal..she was r*p*d and murdered by cutting with saw. The movie is a much toned down version of what happened.
To understand why such things happened in Kashmir we need to read and understand the shocking clauses in Article 370, how it provided immunity to terrorists in the state of Kashmir such that they could do brutal things and not be touched by Indian law, even as the Indian govt paid 5 time more money (Indian tax payers money) to maintain Kashmir than to any other state.
Abrogating Article 370 was on the election manifesto of the BJP since 1980s..even when they had only 2 members in the parliament. It continued to be on every election manifesto of the BJP since then...finally Modiji came to power in 2014 and in 2019 he won the election with BJP+Allies getting 353 seats in parliament. With requisite numbers, Article 370 was finally abrogated. Only PM Modi could do it as it was said that abrogation of Article 370 was such a dangerous and impossible task.
That's one women ...but many women been raped that time and dismembered..during genocide..girijas body was found so u can hear it see it..many other kashmiri hindu women been victimised that way
They sent many women to Pakistan
APARNA TO CORRECT YOU ,SHE WAS CALLED BACK TO COLLECT HER SALARY BY NONE OTHER THAN HER "MUSLIM FRIEND" & EVIDENTLY IT WAS A TRAP.....
Thank u, Modiji. If BJP was in power instead of the Satanic Congress party which used Satans to murder the Hindu pandit in Kashmir, many Kashmiri Hindus would have been alive now. Shame on you, Congress party. U guys are murderers. Murderers of Hindus, Sikhs and the Sri Lankan Tamilzhs.
Watched it from a full packed theatre in my native kerala... Entire theatre was crying... What we just saw was our future....
The villian is combination of 2 real life people
1. Yasin Malik
2. Bitta Karate
Both are still alive mostly free so yes there is no resolution
Yes bitta is free bt Yasin malik is not free, he is in jail since 10 years n has been sentenced life imprisonment on this 25th only
Bitta karate wife is ias in kashmir
Yasin Malik is in jail and he will die a slow death no confirmation about bitta karate
No bro Yasin Malik was arrested again in 2019
Yasin just got jailed again
I when was in 8th class had a chapter in my history book 'The Mughal Empire' and only had 1 paragraph about Prithviraj Chauhan, we were never taught about our real heritage!!!
Oh i relate. We've been brainwashed.
Isiliye kabhi history ni padi Maine 7 and 8 mai .
Fail thi m 😂😂😂😂
Ise film ke baad bhuaat saare history ke student apni mehnaat dhika rahe hai duniya ko ki hum se baada history me aage koi nahi🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
That is because the Mughal Empire lasted longer than Prithviraj Chouhan's reign so naturally a history text book would give more information on the former than the latter.
@@globalnationalismyoutube His reign was surely not short that was condensed into just 1 paragraph.
@jaby_Koay : thanks for your reaction. few points. 1) this movie is based on 100% true incidents that took place early 1991 (peaked then, the brutalities were there even before and after that as well). Pandit means Scholar, they are peace-loving, vegetarian, soft spoken and well-mannered community. At the time of India's Independence, Kashmir's King decided to stay separate (not joining India or Pak), but soon as some tribal terror groups and Pak Army attacked and tried to occupy Jammu and Kashmir, the King then requested help from India and India did. Indian political leadership right from Jawaharlal Nehru even after that too did not add J&K as India's inseparable part, yet allowed to continue separately by doing some constitutional amendment that is article 370 . Until Modi came to Power Article 370 gave separate alien ruling for the Indian state of J&K. The Chief Ministers of J&K like Shaikh Abdulla, his son Farooq, later his son Omar, Mufti Md Sayyed his daughter Mehbooba et al supported militancy and always encouraged separatism though they claimed when in Delhi (India's capital) that they were Indians. Modi & team abrogated this article 370 in Aug-2017, and to an extend, cleared the main issue.
In 1991, Kashmiri Pandits in the tune of half a million flew to various parts; mainly good no of them to Delhi (they are still in Delhi as kind of refugees, doing small jobs etc, no complaints). No political parties (except the ruling BJP) paid attention to the Pandits due to appeasing the so-called minorities (they were minority post Independence in the 1950s and 60s; now they are not ) based on vote-bank politics. Now there are schemes that the current Govt is trying to them back to the valleys and rehabilitate step by step yet not successful much. even now militants in J&K with support from Pak and other militant groups are killing few of the returned families as well.
JNU (Jawaharlal Nehru University) is a globally known institution in New Delhi, which is known for its political significance and stands etc. The communists (like Prof Radhika Menon), appeasing political parties etc still create wrong propaganda.
Young Krishna is the survivor along with his Grandpa (he was playing a drama as Lord Shiva with the blue paint on face at the time of the riot) and they lived in Delhi streets' small hut in a colony with other escaped Pundits; for fear of losing him OR not to let him slip to depression Grandpa hid the dreaded truth from him, and lived in hope that one day things will change for good, and they can get back to home land. Brahma Dutt was also a Pandit, he was Chief Secretary (prestigious IAS officer) who worked his best to protect the innocents all through, but in vein. All the scenes including cutting the lady into 2 are real, in fact not even 10% of the brutal realities, as mentioned by the movie director in some interviews. The files Brahma Dutt shows Krishna are Govt classified files of original incidents and investigation report, not media report. names and pics are different for movie sake, rest all truth. Anupam Kher himself is a Kashmiri Pandit, the movie director as well. Interestingly the Prof is the movie-director's wife in real life.
The Kashmir Files was made with a budget of $2 million. No major studios wanted to invest. So, we have to keep that in mind
The US was supporting Pakistan on Kashmir issue and Russia supported India.
Also, yes, I watched the movie on theatres. And the feels this movie gave was entirely different from what I've felt. It's like everyone there were all united. So united that you would get chills.
The goddess Sharada worshipped in Sharada Peeth is a tripartite embodiment of the goddess Shakti: Sharada (goddess of learning), Saraswati (goddess of knowledge), and Vagdevi (goddess of speech, which articulates power). Kashmiri Pandits believe the shrine to be the abode of the goddess.
Yep Kashmir always belong to the followers of the Vedas since Ancient times, there is a Ancient prayer to Goddess Sharadha as follows:-
*नमस्ते शारदे देवि काश्मीरपुर-वासिनि ।
त्वामहं प्रार्थये नित्यं विद्यादानं च देहि मे ॥*
namaste śhārade devi kāśhmīra-pura-vāsini ।
tvāmaham prārthaye nityam vidyādānam cha déhi mé ॥
*Obeisance to Thee, O effulgent Sarada, worshipped in the City of Kashmir, I always beseech Thee to vouchsafe to me Pure Knowledge.*
Bruh...
YES , it is truth maa shardha is our kuldevi
@@cr7akki does that also mean she's a "Kaul" Devi?? Aye ? Aye?
@@PawanRao007 Nope Kul Means The People Who Live Their 👍... Sharda University Once Had 5000 Scholars ... The Father of Surgery And Medicine were also from Kashmir 👍 .. and the writer of yogsutra patanjali studied Here and the father or creator of bharatnatym Bharat Muni was also from Kashmir 👍
The speech she gave at the end is identical to the real one.
They toned the violence down for avoiding adult rating.
Most of the major incidents you saw were real.
yes we have such monstrous manipulating people among us
It is rated adult
@@vikrampal7582 well yes, but people still bought their toddlers to the theater
@@vikrampal7582
Yeah but many families came to the theatres with their 2 3 yr old kids.
Each and every scene in this movie is just a fragment true horrific event happened there.......
FYI, Samay Raina is a Kashmiri Pandit. He have tweeted his heartfull message about his parents experiences after watching this movie. Also, please interview the director if possible. 🙏
Plz jaby don't ever try to interview this idiot director he is spread only hatred with this movie and supported by bhakhts of one sided propaganda party
Yes please 🙏🏽🙏🏾
And he is one of those Gaddar too who join Leftist Media in Mocking Current Govt when current govt are the one who is giving them honor to go back to Kashmir again
Yes please interview the director
You have to know the other aspect to the story of Kashmir that the director has to tell
The director and the team had to be given special security after this film got released
They get death threats on a daily basis
Each Characters in this movie signifies elements in the society. 4 old aged characters signifies each pillars of the democracy - govt, journalism, judicial and people . And the hero signifies as the common Indian who never tried to learn or was brainwashed to never learn about it.
Sharada (stripped and killed, real - Girija tikoo and nandhi marg massacre) signifies Kashmir stripped of its history, culture and Kashmiriyat.
Shiva - Hindus /Hinduism were witness of that destruction of Kashmir and Hindu temples, culture. Finally killed (genocide and exodus of Hindus)
Last speech by the hero is the history of Kashmir, Exodus of Hindus - 7 times.
Islamic invasion on India is the deadliest and most horrific genocide in the history of human kind.
And the British
Both equally horrendous and monstrous as Nazis if not more..
@@devanshimishra9791 True 👍
Damnnn
Beautifully described Sir Gowda!!!
The longest war ever in the history between Islamic terrorism and Sanatana Dharma is still going on...
Nobody knows when and how will it end?? 🥺
It's a reality, the interview of Yasin Malik and bitta cratta is
on internet 🥺🥺
Yes it's on UA-cam
The top notch quality that Jaby was expecting wasnt on point due to the budget constraints.
This movie was not supported by any big giants of the industry, rather opposed by bollywood.
The way story has been put across with the proper references is commendable.
Every character in the movie is drawn from a story of a real person & stitched together to form this story.
The lady who was cut in a mechanical saw was “Girija Tikkoo” she was a school teacher, who was called by her muslim colleagues to collect her salary. She was then Gang Raped by 5men & cut into two halves.
Even if this scenes was done with really good vfx, the emotions & pain remains the same. Nobody would want to watch that.
Correction: She was gangraped and her breasts were cut by a manual saw by the bastards.
@AARYAN i hope u r lying or do not know the truth brother..coz this is really hard to digest ...too brutal to even think
She was raped before cutting...
@@abhishekanand342 it is true, even I've read this many times
@@abhishekanand342 It is true, she was raped, sodomised and cut into two while she was alive.
let me leave you with one little hope Jaby and Achara, Kashmiri Pandits are very resilient, hard working and extremely educated people as a community. No matter what part of world they are settled in today, they're all doing so well, especially the generation that was born during these events. I have grown up with them, and my best friends are Kashmiri Pandits, believe you me, they're all doing well wherever they are, because they literally focused all their energies in getting themselves out of this and since centuries Education & innovation was a big part of their culture.
They still may not be able to go back yet, but they do make you proud.
They are mostly settled in USA
Then who are those people call themselves Kashmiri pandits living in Delhi camps
11:41 That is the story of Girija Tickoo. The things which she suffered were far horrible than this.
She was a teacher in Kashmir.
10-15% is shown in this film. Think on the members of a single family, there were lakhs of families who suffered like this.
"Most people" didn't stand up for kashmiri pandits in Kashmir because "most people" were in a way supportive of those terrorists. It is as simple as that. But yeah immense respect to you to atleast trying to understand the pain of KPs . What they suffered , couldn't be described in a movie, so the movie was made just to wake India up to atleast know that this thing happened to their compatriots. They kept the violent attrocities to a minimum level so that the movie could reach at least certain sizeable population
Not supportive. Extremely idiotically ignorant. So many people just blamed everything on the Govt. and never really bothered to find out what actually happened. And to think that it's been more than 2 decades. Shameful behavior. That last scene hurt so much. I hope the victims would get justice and their souls will get peace.
@@ananyaverma9599 the point you are making ananya is very true... But this doesn't change the fact that locals there supported the terrorists, otherwise this level of travesty could have been stopped.
they are brainwashed
They supported the terrorists out of the greed of getting their properties once they leave.
@@ananyaverma9599 They supported the terrorists out of the greed of getting their properties once they leave.
It is not story it's history of kashmir.
Since you asked what parts were true. Highlighting some incidents that might come off as unbelievable but actually happened:
1) Lady made to eat blood soaked rice.
2) Lady was raped many times and then her body sawed off to dispose easier.
3) People seeking refuge at a poet / writer house who thinks he is well-regarded, but ends up being killed nevertheless.
4) Refusal to sell groceries on indian currency or outright refusal to give anything for any money.
5) People lined up and shot dead. A little kid in said line-up left behind but specifically brought to focus and casually shot dead.
6) The raliv, galiv, shaliv threatening slogans.
7) Neighbours betraying. Especially the guy pointing the rice barrel as a hide out.
8) The professor driving the college students on the convoluted revolution for freedom.
9) Local government turning a blind eye.
Many more ...
Narratively, the movie could have been made better but this is a story that needs to be told. Kudos to the filmmakers on having done this and portrayed real incidents without shying away.
The film is not made over a huge budget. Thats why visual effects were not so great. The focus was only and majorly on the story. So not much was spent on other things because yes the audience was so shook till the end, that majority didnt even notice the vfx or any other technical faults.
I think the effect of the movie is different with hindus and Indians and non Indians. Coz for us it's too close a truth. Even if we aren't kashmiri pandits we as hindus know that we can face this as well in the near future especially in Kerala, west bengal, Assam. So for us that truth of the movie is so scary we weren't bothered with the special effects. For foreigners they won't relate to it as much so they're more inclined towards how the film was made like the visual effects etc
@@JS-nj3xp ya you're absolutely right.
The Greatest movie of the world *The Kashmir files*
We miss u Girija Tickoo Sister😭😭😭
That brutal scene gave me the imotional scar for rest of my life... 😭😭
Jaby the violence that is shown in this film is just 1 percent of what actually happened.Director vivek ranjan agnihotri was not able to show that much of violence.for your information the air force officer Ravi khanna's wife had filed an fir against the director saying that his husband murder was not shown as it has happened. One more thing the scene in which krishna goes to meet the extremist bitta through the boat this whole scene is written by a muslim boy l director vivek has given a chance to write his own point of view that he purely presented in the movie as it was written by the muslim guy.
*airforce
@@nanusingh2278 ok edited thanks
Thats True , Thats our History It's True
*Director didn't even show the brutality.. this is just 20%*
*The actual brutality of Kashmiri Hindus will shake your soul.*
20% is too much. They just showed one family. 1000 of family were persecuted.
They had to cut many scenes due to the board censor laws right
In the last, the scene of Sharda Pandit cutting into two parts with a saw is real. The only difference was that at that time there was a mechanical saw which used to move slowly, imagine how much pain they must have felt at that time.😓
And in reality, she got gang raped for days before being cut into two…
All real incidents that happened over a period of time are added into a single storyline......everything is true
hahahahaha so you are a history expert now, don’t believe everything you see in a movie bro
@@kazimsheikh33 everything shown is told by the kashmiri pandits who were interviewed. Shame on you for not sympathising but laughing on their sufferings.
@@AK-kc6hd why would he be symphathetic his ancestors were also one of those brutal monsters
@@kazimsheikh33 each and every incident is authentic with proofs on the internet.
@@kazimsheikh33 I'm a kashmiri pandit from srinagar bro so shut ur trap
2:08 he was not shielded from the information it was given in the last episode when he said "tormented people don't tell they have to be listened" the boy portrayed how brainwashed people are they see one side of the story and then they take out conclusions without even trying to gather what the other felt every dialog in this movie was written with deep messages and facts
Every scene of this movie is a reality.. every scene literally pure truth. Masterpiece
In support of kashmir Files Visual effects the film was made in Just 15 Cr (2 Million USD), Because no one was Ready to produce a movie on this topic. So with the budget in Mind personally i was able to Forgive some of the bad Visuals in The movie. But yes I get what Jaby is Trying to say and i agree with him
Yes you are right.
It’s about the story to be told..atleast once..
I hope more movies will now be made..with much more budget
Thanks for watching this film, you're braver than the whole Bollywood community
Actually there was a lot to say in kashmir files while the story of sardar udham is pretty much known to everyone(at least in india) so cinematography could be played really well while in kashmir files (with such low budget and almost whole india opposing it ) it was something you wanted people to get hard hit again and again so that at least the msg is conveyed
The director Vivek Agnihotri put everything he had to make this movie because bollywood was not supporting him they outcasted him of bollywood. because of this he made this movie as an individual with whatever the money he had. So obviously he had to compromise with effects though personally I don't think more visual effects were needed. This movie was an effort to show the reality of Kashmiri Pandits to whole world which he has done successfully.
Cudos to Vivek Aghnihotri sir 🙏
I totally agree it was a low budget movie, I wasn't that emotional myself while watching the movie, but the facts that were revealed compelled me to research a bit and I came to know every incident of the movie is true, the atrocities are unthinkable, I have personally watched many interviews of kashmiri pandits and its more horrific than you think.
That guy who is confused is also shows the people of India who also kept uninformed what was happening in Kashmir
The Director has toned down the violence which happened in real life. The real life incidents were a lot more horrific than what was shown in the movie.
Actually it's not the storyline, this are the consequences of nandimarg Massacre (year 2003) ,1992 Kashmir genocide (you can assure it), and girija tikkoo 's rape and murder( in which the girl was rapped by over 17 militants in 23 days and then she was ripped off in 2parts)..
😔
please rewrite it as "brutally killed as depicted in movie" , instead of being ripped off in 2 parts, it's really unbearable to see it 😓
That incident where women was cut by saw cutter was real incident , we can imagine how much Hindus suffered in Kashmir
I am Kashmiri pandit
Hometown is Kashmir
But never visited my hometown 😔
I'm sorry we couldn't do anything to you. I'm ashamed my parents Gen didn't know or didn't do anything while your father's generation was going through it.
Don't worry whole India is with you. This time we all know what happened. You'll surely go home and get your rights.
Same bhai mein bhi nhi gya aj tak i live in Gujarat since birth
Deepu where your mom and dad lived in kashmir? Do you know kashmiri?
now its time for the kashmiri muslims to opay for their crime, each and every kashmiri muslims were dirctly involved in the genocide and now they show fake sympathy.....its time to pay back
I thought Mithun Chakraborty did a tremendous job in this movie, along with Pallavi Joshi and Darshan Kumar.
For me best was the guy who played Bitta Karate
@@Grandpapshycic I think there wasnt much complexity in the character except for being sinister. But Chinmay Mandlekar could get good "baddie" roles because of that.
Kashmir issue thanks to Pt.Nehru , congress, local political parties and our liberal leftist😢😢
Every incident in the movie was true. And to be honest, this is just 1/100th of what happened in Kashmir.
But it is very tough to put that in a single movie.
The part where mother was killed was not *unrealistic*. That was 100% real. It has happened there.
They're saying that the vfx was unrealistic, not the event.
@@ShivaMahadev108 a good vfx can make it look real but no point real story don't need vfx
Her actual name was girija tikko she was kidnapped and raped killed by terrorists
We need BJP to save india
Right ❤
Bjp hi rehvgi ib to
They are not Indian but I can say they more braver than Bollywood's people and the people who don't want talk about truth becouse of maybe their fam or something.. Lots of respect you guys Jaby and achara.. 💓
The director of Schindler's List (jews holocaust film) once said while receiving awards to ' teach this in schools, pls don't let this become a footnote in history ' , which is true even in india we read a whole chapter about how the holocaust was done, and even had a full year novel project in 10th grade on the book 'Diary of a young girl: Anne Frank'.
We learn so much about holocaust, yet are so ignorant about our own history.
it's not story . it's truth
Yes... Krishna Pandit's character resembles all those 70-80% of the youth which is born after 1989 and don't know much about the Kashmir's present situation, it's vulnerability, it's History and it's REAL TRUTH... It has been shown so nicely and identically... I'm glad they included this character...
And also... I'm so glad that they have shown a VERY important truth that included the newspaper clippings which says the truth of that time "Militants dressed as Army personnel killed them..........." Coz the separatist, misleading & hatred circulating people like female professor and also Pakistanis say that Indian army kills people there... (But it was them not the army at that time.... It was them who invited army supervision all over the area to prevent riots and another 19 January... And yes now whoever gets killed in an encounter is like that "Bitta", the terrorist, so please Pakistan, Shut the F*** up & Stop Funding & sympathizing these human killing machines just Bcoz you want our Kashmir...) It was a very good inclusion of it... Hats of to the details shown 🙌.... Yet it aches to see that it was all a true incident almost identical yet a bit muted enough so that people could really watch it.
What a film 💯🤍😔🤞🏻
And for the part yess.... The name "ANU" has been taken from the JNU University (very well known and big University) and the center of student politics.... & answering your question, Yes the student politics here is very serious and a big event.... The character of the professor is also true and real
The worst part what is happening today, there are group of people in India, they deny that anything of such genocide has ever happened in Kashmir....where we all know the truth, from a long long time.and yet justice to Pandits has not been served for political gains.
This is a real story 😭😭😭😭
A real history of innocent people dying just because they have different beliefs. I know this is not the right time but, I'd recommend you an anime called devilman crybaby. It shows the true nature of humans and how brutal they can get. Not saying that it has any relation to the topic at hand but it portrays humans in their true forms (especially the last 3 eps).
One suggestion. Whenever you're watching these kinds of Indian movies, it's better to keep someone with you at that time so he/she can provide you the actual facts related to that which is only known to and felt by Indians. Your review with those info inputs will be much appreciated by the audience. In this movie, there was too much to show in one movie that the storytelling had to be like this. Each incident that has been shown here has happened with different vital characters, but showing so many characters in one movie would have been more confusing, so they had to show everything in one family. The reporter, the minister each have a significant role in this story and are still in the current Indian politics. It's too hard to show all of these. Also, Sardar Udham and Milkha Singh were not about the internal conflict and were based on the impact of British colonization. So you can get a budget for that. But this topic is still so taboo that no one was interested in funding this movie. The director himself spent around 6-8 years taking real people testimonials and doing the movie himself. That's why the visuals are kind of cheap. Hope you see this comment and consider my suggestion. Thank you for spending your time and doing this watch along.
Not only that but in sardar udham there was 1 main event, which is easy to work around in a long movie. For bhaag milka bhaag, it’s a story of an athlete and there r many movies for directorial inspiration. In this move, events r very unique and characters had to be reduced/combined and a lot of creativity was required.
The last scene was actually related to what happened to Girija Tikoo, she was brutally raped, but the director kept it mellowed to keep dignity of victim's family. Her family didn't speak about the incident until this movie was made and now they are actually started their healing process. She is yet to get justice.
felt by indians? woke hindus were crying after learning about the success of this movie.
same woke indians are complaining about the saffron depiction in RRR
If indian movies will not show hindu culture, who will show it? Pakistan?
anupam khair is also a kashmiri pandit and he also left his house from J & K at that jenoside
Hi Achara and Jaby.
Your tears show the sincerity of the movie. The events were surprising even for an Indian like me.
Story needs to be told this way. Not a single Kashmiri pundit got a closure.
Hope such events never happens ever 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽
A lot of violence in this movie has been edited or cut due to censorship. Director's cut or the original one has a lot more of the real stuff. This outcome itself gives us an idea of what could be the things or scenes that weren't shown in the end.
That last scene in which sharda was cut in two pieces is real
Also watch "The Tashkent File" Which is also made by Vivek Agnihotri
The people who have gone through this are still very traumatised, and motive of the movie was to bring the reality in front of world but if they would have gone very real with the torture and rape scene and the gun shot scene it would have just for the other audience it would have disturbed the suffered audience in a unexplainable way... That's why the movie was more focused on just conveying the story instead of realistic effects...
I am a Kashmiri pandit too, but i have been living in Gurgaon. My parents had to move away from there. I have only visited there once. This story made my father cry
The director wanted it to be a theatrical release & tried to keep it suitable enough for older generations who aren't used to seeing violence & gore.....that's why he intentionally held back on depiction of violence & abuse
He felt that the story is heavy enough & he didn't need to make it seem heavier even though it would be closer to reality
He tried to keep it mild so that the families aren't too uncomfortable watching it together....that's why depictions of sexual violence were also skipped
Limited budget was also a reason as showing good violence requires good money, & the film was made at about 1.9 million USD, most of which went for the sets & location
Sardar Uddham had double of that budget
Most of the things that are negative about this project are bcoz of lack of budget & lack of support
This is more like an indie film instead of being a big film from the Hindi movie industry which Sardar Uddham was
Invite the director of movie Vivek Agnihotri for the interview. I'm sure he would easily accept your invite. He can surely answer all the questions you are asking here. That way you can have better understanding of the context and nuances.
The every single scenes is based on real story
This is not just a story, this was the reality of Kashmir since it was invaded by Islamist invaders - and now the land is free of Hindus/Sikhs, there is no one left except their stories and the smell of their blood... And on the other hand the one more reality is that no government indeed wants to resettle them again in Kashmir, coz Kashmir not a heaven anymore - it's the living hell on the earth like Syria... In India it's very straight thing that being a poor and Hindu (non-Islamic) , a millions have to suffer a lot especially in getting justice, coz India is the land /home of Socialists...
The main satisfaction which could be derived from this movie is that this is the first time ever when the real stories of the Kashmiri pandora has ever been told and accepted by the people all around the country. This is a start and I hope that it gives the people something to think about just like Krishna pandit
1989-1990 were nightmarish years for Kashmiri Pandits.. there are hell lot of things which were missed due to the sensitivity on that movie and due to the cuts on the movie from censor board !! It's a documentary and there is more than what has been showed !!
For all of your questions you should do an interview with the director of this movie Dr. Vivek Agnihotri.He will tell you everything from Kashmir's past to its present and in-between.He did his research very well for 4 years and then he started to work on the movie.
You can agree or deny but that's the real face of islam
The worst part is that it all happened and none of them got justice yet. Although these events happened to different people, unlike how it has been shown to just 1 person/family.
The horror is the fact that the director held back in depicting the brutality to make it palatable in a film!
Jaby its always such a fun watching you both review such good movies. Love from India .
The last lady who were cut into two halfs was a School lab assistant And her name were "Girija Tikku" She were Tortured, Gangrap.d and Cut into 2 halfs.
thats the true story of our KASHMIR.. sad but truth
They toned it down a 10000. So the blind can see..or else would close their eyes. The real stories are available online and we are all reading them after the movie. The reality is ghastly.
this is true story every single thing is true and real and sad
THE KASHMIR FILES is not just a movie , it's an emotion 🔥🔥🙏🙏🥺🥺🚩🚩
Right
It's a reality
The director understated the level of violence becoz he wanted the kids and youths of India to watch it .
This narration really just scratched the surface of how a community suffered from the hands of another but please remember it was not for the time this happened. The time of partition I believe was the first open tragedy when the communities suffered and numerous untold stories are buried in the depth of history. I have heard some of the narrations and they can't be narrated out in open just like that, they are so horrifying but we know that happened so all those people that are still skeptical if The Kashmiri Files was a true narrative or not, because they can't believe how such an atrocious act can occur so they are in denial or whatever, I just... NO WORDS REALLY
Sardaar Udham Singh's budget was several times more than this movie.
Making Sardaar Udham Singh had zero political risks, the makers of this movie had to take risks with their lives and careers.
This is not a movie, it's reality
As a kashmiri hindu and proud sanatani i have only one motto in my life
"ASPIRE RECLAIM CONQUER"
i have the same moto.... i dont want, to see it repeating in all the part of India.
It's absolutely true, all the small incidents of violence and discrimination are based on personal anecdotes and experiences. All of it is documented, yet unfortunately some people chose to overlook it.
Shri Anupam Kher is himself a victim of the scenario.. he and his family, themselves experienced this stuff in his pre-bollywood life.. the emotions which he portrayed here were just not the acting and channelising something fake.. it was all his real experiences which he channelised.
RESPECT.
And his father's name is Pushkar Nath (name of his character)
@@sriramiyer4612 but wasn't his father a victim?
no he wasn't a victim his family was migrated before independence he has brought up and lived in shimla
@@rishabmoza3326 yes.. I understand your point.. but I stated that.. "he and his family..." Bcz.. his family suffered and to protect themselves n their future lives.. they "migrated to Shimla" where, bittu was born (Anupam Kher)..
What my point is.. they didn't have to "migrate" to any place if they wouldn't have recognised the threats..
There is this one interview of Anupam Kher too.. where he shared all of his pain.. which he gathered by the experiences shared by his family to him.. he also mentioned about his initial home in the place which his family missed a lot.. n said he wanted it to be his family's home again.. would be more than happy if he could ever be able to make that happen for his family again... The interview which I've mentioned is not any recent one to promote the movie.. it occurred may be 4-6 years back.. I saw it with my family on TV..
@@sriramiyer4612 nope.. kindly confirm your sources please😊