Do All Catholic Dogs Go To Heaven? | The Catholic Talk Show
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 сер 2024
- In this episode, the guys explore the relationship between the Catholic Church and man’s best friend and debate whether or not dogs actually go to Heaven.
Episode #17
______________________
-- SUPPORT THE CATHOLIC TALK SHOW --
Become a supporter of The Catholic Talk Show on Patreon and get awesome gifts like mugs, hoodies, and more: bit.ly/SupportTheCatholicTalkShow
______________________
-- SUBSCRIBE TO THE CATHOLIC TALK SHOW --
iTunes: bit.ly/CatholicTalkShow-iTunes
UA-cam: bit.ly/CatholicTalkShow-UA-cam
Castbox: bit.ly/CatholicTalkShow-Castbox
Google Play: bit.ly/CatholicTalkShow-Google...
Stitcher: bit.ly/CatholicTalkShow-Stitcher
Spotify: bit.ly/CatholicTalkShow-Spotify
______________________
-- FOLLOW THE CATHOLIC TALK SHOW --
Follow The Catholic Talk Show
/ catholictalkshow
/ catholictalkshow
/ catholictalksho
About a dozen years ago my father asked a priest if our dogs go to heaven. He simply said "how can it be heaven without your dogs"
I'm glad I read this, this made me happy
You're ignoring the fact that animals suffer, and suffering is never meaningless. Second, you have no way of knowing that animals have no rational capacity. They have performed altruistic acts. Third, being of a lower order does not preclude eternal life. So maybe they would still be on a lower order in heaven but still enjoy eternal happiness on that level!
Thanks for the podcast. My dog passed away a couple months ago. I was heartbroken. When family members have passed away, I grieved but my grief was mitigated by the knowledge they were in a better place and I would see them again. Not knowing if I would see my dog again, seemed to make the loss harder to bear. I think the podcast touched on lasting relationships and that offers hope that these relationships, and the partners in that relationship, will continue to exist. This is what I have pondered: God is love and we are products of God's love. Like God's love is everlasting, I think our love is also everlasting as long as we don't love the wrong things or love the right things in the wrong way. If this "right" love is everlasting, than the object of that love must also be everlasting. So I think the love and relationship we have for our pets, in a sense, gives immortality to them ... maybe.
The St. Bernard hospitality talk got me. My dad used to talk about the St. Bernard he had as a kid who would lay under the table, then get up and walk away... with the table on its back. Talk about service.
#StBernard
Thanks for this discussion. I once asked a priest/philosopher, by the name of Fr. Vincent Miceli, about whether or not our pets will be with us in Heaven and he replied that although the essential happiness of heaven is the Beatific Vision of God, that God will fill us to overflowing with that which gave us joy and since animals are innocent, God may very well surprise us with our beloved furry companions in some way. "Eye has not seen, nor ear heard, what God has prepared for those who love Him...." In Christ, all things are made new. "Oh death, where if your victory? Where is your sting?" If Christ conquered death for us, why not for all creation?
GOD'S LOVE makes me believe we will have our dogs cats in heaven.
I believe that all animals go to Heaven. I had a cat that was my everything that passed at 15 1/2 years old. God is good and will provide for us.
I recently lost my beloved dog at 12.5. He was part of our family since he was 8 weeks old. These companionships are no less meaningful and lasting than human companionship and I would be devastated to think I would not one day have the chance to scratch behind his ears.
We just lost our beloved German Shepherd Rusty (our 'Big Bear') over the weekend. He was such a huge part of the soundtrack that played in our daily lives. He was my sons' favorite playmate, our protector, and very best friend. There has been a great empty void in our home since he passed and my wife and I have spent a lot of time in prayer asking God to heal our hearts and keep our boy for us. I personally asked for God to let me know Rusty was okay as the pain I feel is great.
I was at a pretty low moment this morning thinking about what happened when this podcast link arrived in my email inbox. I really thank you for exploring this topic. I feel a great comfort and that God has answered my prayers of asking to know Rusty was okay. Reminded me of Matthew 7:7-8, "For everyone who asks receives, and he who seeks finds, and to him who knocks it will be opened."
Thanks for another great show. I am not a Catholic expert or a religious expert, but I have been Catholic since I was baptized a week after my birth. I work with animals every day being a veterinary assistant and I been taught by Catholic church and I believe God created everything, and every living thing God created is pleasing to him. that being said when the world ends God will create a new heaven on earth with all living things and yes dogs will be there!
And god is outside of creation and time so he very well can be in that new heaven and new earth withour pets and many other animals and whatever he wants to create. ❤❤❤
Great show!! I agree with father Rich. I have five furry babies🐶 when I die I hope I get to see them in heaven😊
I want to believe our wonderful, faithful pets will be waiting for us in Heaven. My Bichon was my true and perfect love He protected , and was always ready to go for a walk or a ride,he was my Special little love. We were together for over 15 years. I miss him so much, i ask our Lord, to watch over him i my prayers everyday.
I get that animals don't have rational souls, meaning they don't have free will, meaning they cannot sin (even if they know they're doing something that will tick us off, they can only follow their own nature), meaning they cannot *merit* heaven. I'm taking a different angle from yours, because I don't have a pony in this race. That is, I don't require reunion with my pets "on the other side of the rainbow bridge" in order to be perfectly happy. And I've got to mention that way back in the early 1970s when I was about 9 or 10, there was a nun on some weekend talk show insisting animals have souls that go to heaven. I remember looking to my dad for direction because that was a new one to me. I hadn't thought to question it before. Dad basically said the Bible doesn't tell us directly, so we'll find out when we get to heaven. Whatever the nun said was way over my head. Whatever happens to animals' souls after death doesn't affect my opinion of God one way or the other. I really like what the Catechism says, though:
2416 Animals are God's creatures. He surrounds them with his providential care. By their mere existence they bless him and give him glory.(Mt 6: 26; Dan 3: 79-81). Thus men owe them kindness. We should recall the gentleness with which saints like St. Francis of Assisi or St. Philip Neri treated animals.
2417 God entrusted animals to the stewardship of those whom he created in his own image.(Gen 2:19-20; 9:1-4). Hence it is legitimate to use animals for food and clothing. They may be domesticated to help man in his work and leisure. Medical and scientific experimentation on animals is a morally acceptable practice if it remains within reasonable limits and contributes to caring for or saving human lives.
2418 It is contrary to human dignity to cause animals to suffer or die needlessly. It is likewise unworthy to spend money on them that should as a priority go to the relief of human misery. One can love animals; one should not direct to them the affection due only to persons.
And from the Prayer of St. Basil: "May we realize that [animals] live, not for us alone, but for themselves and for Thee, and that they have the sweetness of life."
Pope St. John-Paul II and Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI, and others, have said that animals have a "mortal soul," as opposed to the immortal soul that humans have, which suggests that when animals die, their souls no longer exist. Or it may suggest that they are only aware and conscious when their bodies are alive, but this latter possibility doesn't rule out their resurrection at the end of time, when (after) the mortal bodies of humans are raised from the dead.
I kind of think that justice demands that animals who suffered because of Adam's sin, and who are aware of their suffering (they feel pain, thirst and hunger), should be raised again on the last day. There's a Jewish teaching that plants and animals are assigned suffering in sacrifice on our behalf, to atone for our sin, in payment of justice to God. They don't (because they can't) willingly choose suffering, but they accept it and continue to bless God. They can't freely offer it, but God the Father freely accepts it. He doesn't assign them merit because they're not going beyond what they were created to be, but He blesses them because they are completely innocent. Even the bitey beagle Bailey and the dachshund.
I loved this episode. I have always said when I die I want to go where my dogs are. Animals are a special gift and I’ve been blessed with some wonderful companions. Thanks for a great show.
Wonderful podcast guys! That was both informative and funny, as always.
Oh I loved this, in the past my sister had a gorgeoous miniature poodle he was a lovely intelligent dog she has had others since. I had a white West Highland terrier she was sweet but not bothered about cuddles and preffered walks with more than one human. My present dog is the opposite he is an attention seeker and is quite happy walking with just one person. While I've been watching the Catholic Talk Show he is lying on the sofa and having a few dreams. I've had him since 2020, was a rescue dog as a puppy and lived in kennels outside. Previoue owner rescued dogs but this little fellow didn't get on with the other dogs. Apart from the little girl dog next door. He was socialised with her a week after he arrived. Daisy also a rescue but much younger dog is friendly with all dogs. My little whisky is a sort of Jack Russel Terrier plus? Is deeply in love with Daisy, he stands at the back garden gate and cries for her.
Question So if dogs can have those sort of feelings why wouldn't they be allowed in Heaven?
Dogs have a soul, most are better then people. I only wish I could have one, my wife is allergic. I pray all the time for my family to have a dog. Keep the show going really like it.
I thought you meant you wish you had a soul at first.
Yorkies and labradoodles are great dogs for people who are allergic to dogs. They have hair and not fur. Grooming is a must on both but both are great dogs! Personally I would recommend the labradoodle especially if you have a family.
Good podcast guy's. My family recently lost our beloved Josie whom we rescued years ago. Over the years she had various illnesses, and other mishaps. She was the most loyal friend, companion. Our church would have the blessing of the animals. Each time if our beloved Josie was sick, and a couple of times we almost lost her. But when she was sick and vet couldn't figure things out we had her blessed and she was healed shocking the vet. Well recently she had major cancer which spread. Vet said she would live only 2 months tops. We prayed and had her blessed. Two years later she finally passed away. The last thing she wanted was holy water to drink. She knew and wouldn't touch anything else but holy water to drink. We were going to have her buried in pet cemetery. Well couple days ago the place that was going to bury her burned down. The owner called and said that everything was destroyed. I asked about our Josie. The owner said that the fire stopped 30 feet from where they had her laying. The firefighters couldn't explain why the fire just suddenly stopped. I want to believe it was God's intervention. And I know God says all of his creations will be in heaven...great show guys
I asked a Bishop if our dog's go to heaven, he simply said NO, it broke my heart, I'm glad I found your channel 💓 thank you
This was so fun!!! ...So, I am wondering if there are squirrels there too, because I know our dogs love to "make friends" with squirrels. 😁
I was 6 years old when my rabbit died and I went ballistic! Thank God my Grandparents got the rosary out with the Holy Water! We had a burial and said the rosary til I calmed down! I turned 60 and had to put my beloved Dog Marina down from lymphoma! I had my rosary. It was 3pm! I said Devine Mercy! God is great!
I was once told that we do serve others by allowing them to serve us. (I'm in a wheelchair and I struggle with often needing help by others. When I was told this it's not that it made it much easier for me but it has certainly helped). ;)
St John Bosco had a dgg called Gregio reutedly an Angel always showed up when he needed rescuing
Funny guys! Keep on the joyful discussions!
Can we talk about Fr. Rich's face at 13:27 ? 😂😂😂
Julie Douglas LOL
I have two cute dogs, one comes from the Middle East and one comes from South America, but the one that comes from the Middle East is enough to get to the middle of the trip, but the one that comes from South America he comes right away and enters my house, yes I don't know nothing, the meaning but let God give the right answer.✝️❤️🕊️🙏
"He prayeth best who loveth best
All things both great and small;
For the dear God who loveth us
hath made and loveth all."
― Samuel Taylor Coleridge, The Rime of the Ancient Mariner
I agree with Father Rich. Our Lord wants happy loving family's, so he knows how much we love our 4 legged pets. Mine was my greatest love kind protective,loveable,and always ready, to play, go for a ride, and snuggle. I miss him so much and i ask our Lord to watch over him daily.
“I Will See You In Heaven” by Friar Jack Wintz, O. F. M., is a great book. I listen to it on Audible when I go walking. Wonderfully uplifting and comforting when you’ve lost you best friend.
Until the morning my son came to the bathroom door and said, "Did Bootsie go to heaven Mom?" I would have said no. I never wanted to give any false doctrine to my children but that day I said, "Yes." Some years later when considering the reason there is death, I became convinced Jesus Christ has COMPLETE VICTORY OVER DEATH. Without sin no creature would have ever died.
I hope they do. I want my dog princess to be their so I can give her a big hug she was the best dog ever.
Awesome! ...tons of fun!! 🤣
I sincerely believe I will meet my dogs in heaven because God did promise us happiness and contentment. So, I thank you Father for clarifying the answer. We will meet again. Thanks for the podcast. My dog has given me pure love. Bailey is a Maltese.
Fr. Richard, I agree with you 100%. However, my Nana ( who you probably know or have met) has two dachshunds and they are super sweet; and i advise her not to listen to this one lol. I know you from when you come to S.J.D.R., and you are one of my favorite priests. I love you so much and i can't wait to see you again.
I don’t know but I really do hope my old Dogs will be there when I go
One question asked was “Do dogs need redemption?” I propose that they do not so there is an even greater possibility that in there complete innocence God would grant them eternal happiness. Pope Francis once told a young girl who asked him about this possibility. She was grieving about the loss of her dog and asked if she would see him again in Heaven. He responded that he could not see how God would give us these animals for companionship and happiness and take them away in our eternal home. I so look forward to reuniting with my pups. Our neighbor gave us this book and it helped me greatly after our recent loss.
The book is
“I Will See You in Heaven “by Friar Jack Wintz
What about cats?I love my Goldieboldie Boy. He about 15 yrs old. I adopted him when he was about yr old. He got rid of my mice in my house. He like a little golden tiger so very cute. I live on my own. I love him.🐈
I enjoy your podcast very much! Im subscribed on youtube as well as on iTunes. I was just a little disappointed when I saw that your podcasts have decreased in size immensely. I really wish you will return to your original length and I understand you all have your reasons. Regardless, I am still a fan and I will keep all of you in my prayers! God bless!
Fr Rich mentions C.S. Lewis and what is the name of the other guy? Peter???
My dog just died.... and my questions is in Eden, pre-fall, did dogs die? Did they suffer?
An unrelated question What is the catholic position on Ron Wyatt n his discoveries esp that of Mt.Sinai wt all the evidence shown? Could u guys talk on this topic pls? It intrigues me.
I I sure pray my fur babies are in Heaven. I'm with Father Pagano. Can we pray for the souls of pets like we pray for the souls in purgatory?
Meant to say I adopted him when he was about a year old.
Chebeagle is great it’s mix with beagle and chi Hua Hua
I am autistic when our cat died. I couldn't cope with it. I wonderd around the house.
One night Jesus saw my greeving and bleeding soul. He send me to meat Streepje in heaven.
She was lying on a big poll on a plateau en she spoke more like telepathically. Go on get of the loss of your mother in law.
Two months later in got a job as ambulance cleaner just 15 minutes from home and the Parish of Saint Peterus in Eindhoven in the Netherlands.
I think our family dog is also there protecting Jesus and God.
Doesent the bible say that the lamb and the child will play together in heaven?
One of and the only main requirement ive always respected about heaven is that youre there becuz youre guilty of being there. Id love it if our dog was there
Jon abuckle has a cat is Garfield and a dog is odie ....Mickey mouse has a dog Pluto ....
Fr. Rich
I ENJOY this podcast. Recently started watching a few months ago, and I am catching up on previous episodes, which I thoroughly enjoy. However, in this episode, I have to disagree with you. I currently have a sweet dog who does not bite. He is a dachshund named Milo. Some dogs are vicious, and some dogs are not. Just like people. Also, if dogs don't have a soul, why are they assigned St. Roch as their Patron Saint?
Also, Milo says daily prayers with me...just sayin'! Keep up the good work. You are truly a Disciple of Christ.
Where did you get the dolls?
.
They are bobble heads and they got them from a dealer that no longer makes them . : (
Father Rich seems to be really empathetic and kind in regards to animals! I love dogs! This topic has worried me for a long time as the catholic teachings on animals and dogs isn't that great for animal lovers. From what I can see dogs teach us a lot about God's and Jesus teachings. From my dog I have learned how to be forgiving and selfless, as well as receiving an unconditional love. I also believe what St Francis and St John Bosco say, that the mere existence of animals shows they give glory to God. In Genesis it says man will have dominion over animals and must care for them.
The soul issue, the free will arguments aside, I most certainly believe dogs in particular most certainly deserve to go to Heaven. Theyre better at loving us more than any human ever could. That said, I think dogs deserve heaven more than even humans.
Dogs and cats go to heaven. I think God wants us to be happy in heaven. He wouldn’t deny something that would make us happy
30:24 30:24
It might be more prudent to say that there will be every kind of animal in the New Heaven and New Earth, but maybe not these specific animals with us now.
if God created it then all things belong to him so it seems all things will return to Him
Here is what Fr. Chad Ripperger said about the topic... "You know once in a while people will ask me, 'Is my dog fluffy going to be in Heaven?' and I usually tell people, 'Yeah, he is. but he's not going to exist in Heaven'. but when you see God face to face you'll see the entire life of fluffy in it. so yeah, in a certain sense he's there because you'll get to see em anytime you want to think about em. you see him in God, it's like watching a much realer movie, it's much more real when we see it in God than it is if we actually experience the dog physically. so you won't actually have a need or a desire to have the dog physically here." ; source = 'Four Last Things: Heaven' audio clip between 26min and 26min43sec.
personally I hope to see my dogs in Heaven. but either way, everything is going to be okay ;) ; for the record... beagles are hands down my favorite dog, although I do like some others like labs etc. I like dogs in general but some definitely more than others. typically the more lovable/caring kind which is why I like beagles so much.
Look at the Leviticus 17:11 it clearly states that the life is in the blood. You can not deny that dogs of blood
Is Rich Puerto Rican?
Dogs ARE the love of God. I know the Church teaching, but I would not mind being wrong.
Dogs are still Gods creatures and God made them. Regarding if dogs go to heaven or not, that shouldn’t be the reason why we strive to go to heaven and be with God
I think father won this debate.
They aren't Datsuns :)
/t/ is the Jersey /x/
Charlie Brown has a dog name snoopy. Disney I01 dalmatians dogscheagle beagle doggyhound dog looks sad with long ears
Golden retiver hush puppiesdisney lady and the tramp
Ecclesiastes 9:4 Better a live dog than a dead lion!
Father - those "little dogs" are really the nasty ones, bred to hunt badgers and other fierce little burrowing animals. Dachshunds (dachs hounds) . It was his mother that had the dream.
I always tell my girlfriend that God made guinea pigs first because theyre just so cute, theres definitely guinea pigs in heaven haha have you ever heard them wheek? I mean thats a bit of Gods love covered with fur haha
Apparently we'll all be vegetarians in Heaven because nothing will die, hence no meat. I think that's an indication that perhaps animals do go to Heaven. :)
Do cats? hahaha
🤣 I have a dachshund and he is the sweetest dog. He wouldn't bite anyone. Dogs are a gift from God we need to know the breed. Worker dogs need a lot of exercise including dachshunds. All living creatures are Gods creation. They may not have souls but maybe they do have a place in heaven 🤔.
Dogs are the only animal (including some humans) who loves you more than he loves himself...isn't that the way we are asked to be...maybe a prefigurement of Jesus (not to be disrespectful. )
It is said the the Hound of Heaven is actually Snoopy 😆 LOL
Saint Bernard dog
Song and music who let the dog out woof woof woof woof
Guster the adorarable chebeagle puppy you tube…
This is at least two guys one being the priest that has no clue about dogs. They do not project any type of love for animals. This is a non credit talking point for these guys. Why talk on a subject you have no experience with.
Bruh im a delivery driver and i love dogs. But i gotta say. Theyre some of the omg dumbest creatures still love dogs tho 🤷
Will you see your pets again?
Mabey.. In Heaven..
Will you be going to Heaven? That is the question..
How long will you be in Purgatory?
Will you be thinking of your Dog in Purgatory? NO
Animals do not go to heaven. Can they be RE Given as gifts to us IF and WHEN we get there? Of course God gave them to you once already on this horrible side of life so he surely can fulfill your desire to be with them again.
Will you want to see your Dog again while immersed in the beatific vision praising God for all eternity with all the Angels an Saints in one unending hymn of Praise HOLY HOLY HOLY!!?? Probably not.
People use the word Heaven but I dont think it means what they think it means. To Love, desire and worship God will all your being and have NO attachments. Mothers are in heaven with sons in hell. Sons are in heaven with mothers in hell etc. They are in complete joy knowing this.. My bet is you will not desire your animals at all and God will be your ultimate desire for all eternity.
What a shallow stupid argument on the part of Ryan Scheel. Theological opinion is not doctrine. A more sensible place to start would be to recognize that animals suffer, and suffering is never meaningless. The suffering of animals can not be disconnected from the salvational mission of God.
It’s sad we live in a Society where people literally value Animals over Human life. Also, prefer to Dogs/Cats/ Etc as there babies... what an insult to parenthood & God.
Reading these Comments confirms the more about what I have said... smh
Someone s evil, real evil. Lol
Nooooo!! No animals will go to heaven
It's not right to give what is holy to dogs - the Gospels