I dont like how you guys know VERY little about islam and the quran and yet speak with such conviction. Islam is very different to christianity, we dont believe in blind faith. Our religion is very rational and clear, you come to believe in one God with absolute certainty. Pls continue to react to islamic content and you will both be extremely suprised. Good to have greater understanding about the faith of 2 billion humans and the fastest growing religion in the world. God bless :)
There is an infinite amount of information out there, which means you will never be able to fully understand everything. Just because we know very little about Islam does not mean we don't have an experience of it, even if just a small one. We present are current understand and experience as it comes. It the best anyone can do. We force nobody to watch our content. I'm pretty sure there will be more content in the future. ✌
Jst seemed like you guys were talking about your experiences with christianity a lot and then conflating the two. But i guess youre right, your views will only change with more knowledge and experience with the faith. Dont be put off :)
In lslam God has created three creations 1.angel (Gabriel) made up of light 2.jinn(luccifer or chief of devil) made up of fire and have choosing free will 3.human(adam or eve) made up of clay and have choosing free will
I'd like to comment on your remark @ 19:24. It would be useless to keep on arguing if you tell a religious person to stop referring to their Holy Scriptures. Because while you don't believe in any holy scripture, they do. So the first step before asking any questions that is related to their faith, the two of you have to establish a common ground...either you debunk their faith and prove to them that their Holy Scriptures are wrong, or they prove to you that their faith is true and their Holy Scriptures are true and from God. Then you two can argue about the minor details that are attached to that faith. Otherwise, they will keep referring to their Holy Scriptures and you keep asking how do you know it's true? And why do you have believe such Scripture! (Basically keep running in an endless fruitless circle).
I appreciate the comment, and although I find it very deterministically black and white, there is no arguing from our side. As a matter fact is was completely one sided. We were just responding to a request to react on this particular video. Just because I don't believe in their scriptures does not mean we can't communicate. Many times changes comes through long periods of time, getting to know each other, and finding the things we do agree on. You build trust, and before you know it you find yourselves in place where you and other have become more tolerant and understanding of each other, and probably a bit of you has rubbed off you onto them, and vice versa.✌🙏
@@stayspiritual you are right of course. And I apologize if I sounded offending in any way. Maybe the word argument wasn't the correct word to use. I'm merely saying that it's useless to discuss something of you don't have a common ground you start with or at least a reference that everyone agrees upon. Just the example you have provided in the video when Dr Zakir said that Angels are created to be completely obedient to God's commands. if the person who asked doesn't believe in the existence of Angel in the first place, then it's useless (in my opinion) to tell him that Angels can't go against God's will and compare them to humans. He doesn't believe in Angels in the first place so what the use of discussing whether the Angels are created completely submissive to God's will or not or how they differ from humans. If for example that one who was asking simply wanted to learn about Islam's POV regarding free will or the purpose of Life or the reason behind the way we were created then it's ok to ask but the man in the video was trying to debate the Islamic perspective when he doesn't believe in God in first place.
If we are doing our research on something for PHD purpose, can all the data needed or information needed obtained solely by thinking? Or will you need to have a reference? regardless through the interview session or referring to BOOK or Scripture perhaps?
Let me ask both of you a questions respectfully, if you sleep but when woke up suddenly found yourself somewhere unknown place what would you do, would you find the way to live your life or make excuses why are we here and give up your lives. It’s kind of irrelevant example but in some way it is relevant so you are here in this world as human being with free will .This is the fact why are you saying is free will better or not leave this guys The thing is you are here with free will as humans under the test being going on. 2 options either do good deeds believe in GOD and all the messengers and follow the commandments or worship your desires have alcohol or any evil deeds which are forbidden it up to you you can choose either if you choose right path very very easy to have good result otherwise bad performance lead to repercussions we don’t like free will free will choice is yours
not a reaction video, even far from the title stay spiritual🤣, more like debating a video of zakir rising, instead the two of them argued, which without realizing it had a lot of sound without any content.
As a Muslim, I really appreciate the efforts you put into making this video, and I hope you will dedicate some time to learn more about the concept of Islam. In my humble opinion, I think this video needs a bit more advanced knowledge about Islam for some of your remarks. It's like trying to solve algebra without mastering the order of operation. Having said that, it's very interesting to me observing your genuine reaction which is based on your current perspective . I'm very sorry if I sound disrespectful. The Quran invites anyone to challenge and question it and provides rational answers. I wish you the blessings of God in your journey.
Don't be sorry, actually you are probably one of the more respectful people we have had comment on our video, so thx and appreciated. We are continuing to learn, and will be releasing some more Muslim content soon.
@@stayspiritual Its okay. I like you guys for questioning about quran because I strongly believe you guys will get clear answers always. Because I always found clear answers. One day we also had all the questions. I think you should watch about many popular questions. Such as, 1) Who created god. 2) What is the fault of a child who born in a non muslim family. And I recommend you to watch how Al Quran gave so many scientific theories that we found recently so many years ago although Quran came to Guide people to right path, not to teach science.
These two dudes are so frustrated why religious ppl are so Dogmatic about their books..but these two dude doesn't realise that they are themselves are so Dogmatic with their belief that all religion are all the same.. never bother to question their belief and ask the question to themselves "what if amongst these religions with their books there 1 religion that are actually true religion..just what IF?"..
Seeing this video, I can imagine, is it possible for Christian priests or other religious priests to have the courage to have an open debate with their audience like this? and would they like to give priority to giving the opportunity to ask followers of other religions
Hello, thank you for this reaction, it is nice to see you guys respecting and learning other religions. As for a few questions as to why he didn't answer him fast and get over it. It is because as well as answering to the guy he is also trying to provide an answer to many others with similar questions, so rather than just spit the answer, he is taking the time to make them understand the answer better as well by giving simple examples. Also you mentioned that any person according to their belief system can stand up and hold their book saying this is the true book. But it is different in Dr. Naik's case because he is not just blindly giving that statement in front of such a huge audience. If you have researched about him, he is a scholar of comparative religions meaning he has already studied all the major religions (e.g. all the versions of bibles) and knows them by heart in memory. So when he is giving such a statement it is not that he is trying to be egoistic or biased like any other person would be. Rather he is saying it based on his level of knowledge and trying to make others aware and encourage others to research and learn. Lastly, the "validity" of the book Quran which was asked in the video is already done by him. Please listen to his other talks which specifically answer why that the Quran is "proven to be magical" as you said. Which are miracles proven by science now. Additionally during his debates he actually encourages his audience to do what you guys mention about coming to a "common ground to agree on somethings...". Best of luck, thanks :))
33:00 True, he’s not the only guy standing on stage holding up a book, rather the opposite is true, there are many people claiming that their religion is the truth, but only one can be true. They can’t all be false because that would mean that everything is false and reality doesn’t exist. And They can’t all be right because they contradict each other. Therefore, we’re left with one option, and it’s that one has to be by necessity the “Truth”. Islam is that truth.
I love your deductive reasoning. Why does there only have to be one right way? Why does it have to be Islam? If anything, given the probability of reality being infinite, we as humans don't know anything, we just pretend like we do for psychological grounding. 🤔
@@stayspiritual Why Islam? Well, we must utilize our faculty of reason and intellect. We have been endowed with an exquisite mind for good reason. First and foremost, we must analyze our surroundings, and upon doing so, we cannot but arrive at the conclusion that this intricate design must have an ingenious source which is more brilliant than the design itself. According to the first law of thermodynamics, something cannot arise from nothing.For instance, if I were to install solar panels on my roof, I would harness energy in the form of electricity, indicating that the source of sunlight is an extremely powerful and energetic force. Secondly, we must ask ourselves why this supremely intelligent entity, whose brilliance is beyond our imagination, would create such a creation without purpose. That would contradict “wisdom” which is an integral component of intelligence. Thirdly, this creator must be singular due to the ‘infinite regress’ argument which posits that there cannot be an infinite series of preceding events or causes, so the origin must be one and uncaused out of necessity. Fourthly, if everything was created with a purpose by a single intelligent creator, then that creator must inform us of that purpose. Finally, why Islam? Because there is no other viable option. It is either believing in pagan idols which clearly cannot be the intelligent uncaused entity or believing in an illogical, edited and altered book which speaks of the creator having offspring. It is not befitting of an infinite creator to be limited by having children or incarnating as a created being. Islam is the only logical conclusion because “Islam” means submission to God, and submission to the omnipotent source of creation is the only rational conclusion.
@@stayspiritual Quran: We will show them Our signs in the horizons and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that it is the truth. But is it not sufficient concerning your Lord that He is, over all things, a Witness? 41:53 And it is He who spread the earth and placed therein firmly set mountains and rivers; and from all of the fruits He made therein two mates; He causes the night to cover the day. Indeed in that are signs for a people who give thought. 13:3 [We sent them] with clear proofs and written ordinances. And We revealed to you the message that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them and that they might give thought. 16:44 Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you might use reason. 2:242
Truth can be one but wise speak of it in different ways. Just because your way does not match with other it does not mean they are false. In the end reality cannot be put into words. Words ≠ reality
@@SanatanSurya12 Words are a description of reality, just like code in programming is the language of electronics, and DNA is the language of organisms.
You guys mentioned why doctor naik is replaying slowly, well as you noticed that guy did not understand even giving an answer so the doctor has to repeat again, and it's not one on one debate a lot of other people have questions so won't be justice, however, please react more to doctor naik videos love to see your reactions.
My dear brothers this world 🌎 didn't create itself out of nothing! And there is injustice everywhere and Evil is roaming free, and powerful criminals and corrupt leaders and elites don't get punishment in this world, hence the judgment Day. This life is a test that is why we live and die and will be resurrected and judged upon our deeds and believes at judgement day! Hereafter is eternal life we live in good shape or bad depends upon our deeds and believes!
We will always continue our searching with open minds. Thank you for the comment, but I feel you have a lot of absolute stated conclusions, that I personally require deeper investigation for. 🙏🙏🙏✌
I really appreciate your indepth analysis of the video...... thank you Things to take in consoderation 1. The questioner watched Dr Naiks DVD.... and his question was based on the statements made in the DVD 2. What is meant by " the better creation" if i am an enigeer and i created a robot that is programmed to do what i command .... then there is an Engineer that created a robot that can make his own decisions for its self (free will)..... which Engineer would you be impressed with the most? .... for example can any engineer create something as great or as simple as a fly (that can reproduce, fly, and can sustain its self for energy) as small as it is? Would not such an engineer be great? Or the greatest and worthy of being whorshipped? So many arguments for God to recogized as in comparable and worthy..... the questioner how ever is not amazed by God as a Creator, yes its easy for God but for no one else .... that is what makes God Great and the Greatest!
Free will is better because you two had a free will to choose your belief over being religious. In your previous video (the purpose of life part 1) if i remember one of you said that it is good to think independently and so on ( that is a free will).
33:29 when we say our book is the ultimate truth and words of God because we have Prove of how we have preserved it in its complete original form. One piece of evidence is that Muslims every year fast one month during the month of Ramadan in this month there’s a night prayer in which a chapter of the Quran is recited by heart and if the person reciting makes mistakes or forgets someone behind helps him. This has been happening from the time of the prophet. We have 6 year olds memorising the whole Quran and every Muslim knows 50-100 verses at least by heart
12:59 in Islam, life is a test. Also, we need to understand that the person Dr Zakir is dealing with is an atheist/agnostic, addressing his questions from a human point of view would be best suited for him to understand what Dr Zakir is talking about
I'm a Muslim, and I appreciate your honesty. Your genuine reactions are something I value. I like that you both challenge Islam, as it encourages thoughtful discussion. Thank you, guys! 👍
Hey y’all! So I watched few of your reactions and I actually learned about my own faith.. I really do appreciate the fact that I learned to sit through some of your comments because this platform form is actually insightful on how how someone can be so turned off by faith. I honestly found this particular video a bit disturbing because if the idea is to question and learn about different perspectives then it’s important to listen then comment. The video did come off a bit condescending but that’s only my opinion on it. Dr Zakir is a scholar and no everyone agrees with him which is why we all have different views or beliefs, he’s very clear on where he stands and only explaining his beliefs and experiences. Take what you will is his position (free will).. I watch and listen to understand what your position are and what other might be asking about my faith because I might have similar questions on their beliefs. I hope I didn’t offend anyone. All love 🤍
This right guy is so stupid, and actually, I didn't see these videos on their channel because it shows how foolish these people are. I wouldn't watch their videos only if I had watched this video before. I was actually thinking that they were not reacting to the right videos because they were reacting to videos of the army of Satan types, but I was completely wrong about them.
That's why he said, Quran has been tested and the only holy scriptures on earth that passed the test. You should search knowledge about the test. First you may start from his video related to the holy scripture testing.
1. Angels don't have freewill,jinns do.( Bad jinns are called devil/shaytan) 2. Ofcourse he is gonna use the scripture, beacuse he believes in it. We believe in Qur'an beacuse it has scientific miracles mentioned 1400 years ago which science is discovering now.( I suggest to hear scientific miracles in Qur'an by Dr zakir naik) Qur'an also has prophecies which came true and has numerical and mathematical and historical miracles. It presents complete way of life as well. Also Qur'an challenged 1400 years ago to make one chapter like it and smallest chapter is of 1 line. But in 1400 years not a single human being could come up with a single line like the Qur'an. Qur'an also says that had it been from other than god, there would have been contradiction. But there is no single contradiction and the so called ones have been refuted by Muslims. 3. Btw keep emotions aside while reacting. "There is no space for emotions in ground of knowledge" 4. Btw the life of this world is a test. Also this guy is just not a debater he is very knowledgeable and has good memory. Millions of people watch him and for a reason. Not beacuse of emotions. 5. He doesn't only speaks with emotions that this book is most logical. He has proofs unlike those Christians Preachers. 6. Highest level of paradise is jannatul firdous, if we wanna go there we gotta work hard. 7. Why the one on right has so much hatred against scripture? Unlike others Qur'an has all sort of miracles and no contradictions and no mistakes. Btw we Muslims don't trust the scripture because of no reason. 8. He said non intelligent people can go to jannah if u r truthful.(u should have paid attention) 9. Not all smart people go to jannah either if they don't accept the truth, Allah knows best. 10. U wanna know book is valid? Then watch the video where he proved it with scientific miracles. 11. He is not only defending, but spreading the truth with authentic references and proofs and is not shouting with emotions"jesus(pbuh) loves you!!!" Like those Christians preachers. 12. Also listen to 38 scientific mistakes in bible by Dr zakir naik. -btw if u have any question especially regarding Islam then feel free to ask.
im just normal muslim still learning using his logic imagine your teacher saying "youre failed in this university" before even you take study and take test for you thats why god give human free choice either you want to be in paradise or hellfire along with his teaching way of life
@@stayspiritual oh well but in the video i see you guys don't even know basics of Islam from your comments and rampaging on it because it doesn't go with your world view. i have doubt that where is your stands on religion, can you please clearly state that because when someone is saying another thing is wrong then they must know the truth. if they don't know the truth they can only say i don't know but not wrong
39:53 it's not that we are fools and that's that -- Allah (swt) guides us to the right path many many times but the disbelievers choose to ignore it again and again. For instance, this conversation with Dr Zakir would've been one of the guidances for the speaker but if he chooses to ignore this guidance, the previous guidances and future ones, then he is the fool and has done this to himself.
Hello my brothers ima Canadian who’s been looking into the Quran n Islamic theology for a while and notice you were incorrect about some key points, if you would like I’d be more the happy to have a chat with you guys maybe help you understand some things, there’s no such thing as a dumb question if your seeking an answer:) have a good day everyone :)❤️
Hi guys, Just wanted to add on a misconception about the religion in short. The meaning of Islam in Arabic is the submission of the will to God only,the god of Abraham, Adam , Jesus , Moses, Noah etc. all the prophets that were sent with same teachings to worship god alone without partners. However, the message was changed through out the time and people got misguided that’s why prophet Mohamed was revealed with the Quran to preach the same message that have been always the same.
And since prophet Mohamed is the last massinger the Quran had to be preserved in a different way memorization so no one can change it . And that is the miracle of Quran.
I love you guys perspective and the way of deduction of values rather than things that are just written , you guys are open and that's what important , . Love from india 🇮🇳🇮🇳
your Question at 18:56 is valid why is Dr zakir referring to Quran , The answer is very very simple that is to analyze whether the Scripture is really a word of God or not if it is then we accept whatever it says.. And Quran can be easily proved to be a word of God it is 100% preserved,by looking at the prophecies which came true, scietific and Historical facts mentioned in it which were proved recently, the elequence of Arabic used, it challenges the all the humans together to come up even 3 or 10 verses.. No other scripture even comes close to the Quran. we have the clear cut prophecies of Prophet Muhammad which came and are coming true. It is not like to escape from the questions we refer to the it is because we have first proved that Quran is the word of God and Prophet Muhammad is his messanger. And Dr zakir wa giving the example the test similar to the life of this world and when he said you can't refer to the textbook during the exam he was equating the textbook to the past when Allah said to us whether you want to appear in this test(in this world )
36:25 we don't have the idea of "the elect" in Islam.What he means is that not everyone can enter the highest level of Heaven becase you need to earn it in this life, by getting "the highest grade in this life test" to put it simply, and this is through folowing the 5 pillars of Islam and maintaining a good approach to life.
22:41 it's not that one didn't make the cut biut it is that you yourself have acted on your own desires and forgotten to follow the path of Allah. And that's why Dr. Zakir says that no one will object to the justice of Allah - Allah (swt) is the most merciful, the most forgiving and he wants us all to go to Jannah (Heaven). If you end up in hell, it is because you have repeatedly sinned and did not repent, and so you would be justly sent to hell.
Around 16-17 minutes in to the video Justin said something very profound.....he said he had to become atheist to 'get out of the scripture'....that's what we Muslims start with too...we declare their to be no god i.e. atheist...except Allah...it therefore naturally follows you become Muslim once you rid yourself of all other religious bias. The little flavour you keep getting of similarity to this religion and that religion is because all religions came from that original one true religion (Al-Islam) from the dawn of mankind.....the differences in our view are just the corruptions people put on it through time. Keep researching, keep learning guys and keep reacting!
Hey bro’s . I like your honest reaction. But one suggestion to you both that one should let other finish his talk and then you can ask or comment on it. Well even i used to think exactly same like you both 20 years back. But then i go through all scriptures with open mind. And finally after a long research and giving a lot of time in understanding scientifically and logically i landed up being a Muslim (Alhumdolillah) by choice.
Thank you for your kind words. Its hard with reaction videos to know when to stop or keep going. This is an older one, we are continually getting better I think 🤔. In terms of spirituality, we are always growing and learning. 🖖
Its a very limiting human concept to take Allah as a person who has an ego.. Allah is not a person who is egotistical and demanding and narcissistic. These are adjectives for subjects. Imagine you cook a very healthy meal.. You first pick the fresh ripe ones from your garden (even tho you planted the same seeds, they dont grow or come out the same), cut them, slice them, mix them, cook them on fire, and turn them into a nourishing delicious meal, knowing all along that you are going to eat it, chew it, swallow it, your stomach will break them further into pieces and all that.. So are you in this case an evil, punishing, egotistical person? Or is the food useless because u decided its fate? No. It keeps you alive. Its tranformed, not destroyed in essence. Just as a perspective on how we fall into the trap of projecting our humanity on Allah and evaluate him as that. Sending love from Istanbul guys 😇
@32:00 you missed the answer for the first part of the question. The answer was broken down like this as a metaphor. There is a child taking a test with q teacher. Teacher = god Child = us Test = life Whilst the test (life) is ongoing, we wont be able to checj the answers to see if it is true or not 100%. Only after can we see if what the teacher (god) told us is legit or there is no god like athiests claim.
40:00 ok this is annoying don't expect every topic to be about the validity of the quran or any other religious text for that matter. Some topics requires you the listeners to follow the narratives as a hypothetic, I'm sure you can engage in a thought experiment even if you don't believe its literally true. Its simple logic Dr zakir have done his studies to help his come to the conclusion that the Quran is from God and its contents are true . Instead of unfairly lumping all religions together do your homework ,no one will do the research for you. I would recommend going onto the Efdawah channels live streams interfaith discussions where a couple of Muslims guys answer and take questions. Sorry for the rant 😁
NO no no its good, get the rant out and feel through all those emotions. That'a where all the real gold is... if you hear what I'm saying. Why get any way... sad / happy / frustrated etc... I think those emotions might be telling you something about yourself not fully realized.
Don't make things difficult, to understand talk to a practicing Muslim, and read The Holy Quran with the intention to understand but,not make a mokkery of. There is no force for you to accept.
Thanks for interesting discussion and courage to bring such topics that so many others doesn't bring it. Dr. Zakir is always saying "I am student of religions /science and if anyone can show me more logical religion than Islam, I am willing to accept it today" so my advice if you found better scripters from your point of view, then go for it and if you cant find better, so keep learning more because Idk if you agree with that this complex creature "human" cant be left without catalog (purpose , life system as a guidance and afterlife knowledge)
Hey guys, awesome reaction! Thanks for posting your content!! This is not a comment on you guys just on society- How come so called religious people aren't afraid of studying science to high levels, in depth, even if according to atheists it may debunk their beliefs but atheists/non believing scientists seem unwilling to do the same with religions? It appears from the outside like the religious people are more genuinely seeking the truth. Science and religion are not at odds though, Islam explicitly urges believers to study the world around them. A muslim even invented the scientific method. Great reaction video, your criticism of Islam is welcomed and any questions for clarification I'm sure will be happily answered by muslims watching, if wanted in future.
Thanks for the kind words Taufeeq. I think science gives time mostly to things it can observe. Can a scientist observe heaven and hell, or can a scientist talk audibly with Allah like you and me can? Can you measure sincerity and faith? What is the exact amount of belief needed to appease Allah and can I definitively calculate for certain that I'm in his good graces. Just a few questions a skeptical scientist might ask.
@stayspiritual Heaven and hell is another dimension so science cant act on it, just as consciousness is. Also, the amount of belief you need is actually just sincerity. That's all. Just like you sincerely have the intention to marry your wife and commit to her for life. Things might change later, but mostly, people have that sincere intention ( maybe clouded with love😂) to commit for life. About all religions being able to just hold up a book and just claim things, Islam actually encourages you to research everything with an open mind but with sincerity to accept the truth when found. If there are different opinions on something where only one can actually be true, all you need is to analyze them deeply and sincerely to find the truth or at least eliminate the false claims. Islam primarily just tells you to realise there is a creator that created you (even though we can't phantom how he looks like) and then worship him sincerely. Check out the religion of Ibrahim in Islam. He looked at things people were worshipping at that time and realized they were limited (just as Jesus is), and just decided to worship the creator of everything. I really think you need an actual discussion with a muslim so you can have a proper back and forth. I recommend you join either of these UA-cam channels in their regular livestreams ' Hamzas den' or 'Muslim Lantern '
Great viewpoint , i don't know but I feel many people here are just trying to impose , blame and convert .always love your reaction guys . Always remain who you are , just try and you will get to know about truth , about the reality and nature of the physical and spiritual realm .
29:15 in Islam all questions are welcome and Muslims as the most questions so you will hear an answer for literally everything. It tells you how to wash your private parts and when to cut your nails when to pray how pray when to fast how to fast when to break your fast how to break your fast thousands of questions just from one question questions is how many question do you have to ask until you agree that the Quran is from god and Mohammad is a prophet just like Jesus Moses Joseph Abraham Noah Adam and lots more in between them
Guys, watch Bobby’s Perspective. He was on phycadellic (i dont know how to write those). I think you should try to react on videos about the basic of Islam first then move on to a more complicated matter. I just feel that this subject is more than you can chew at the moment
24:03 About that, what the best the one who has free will and the one who hasn't free will, I will ask you as an example, is true love the same will fake feelings? No of course you know that this one loves you but is love the only thing he feels about you so it's not equal to the one who loves you truly.
All religious teachings are true for me, but I want to say that you respect each other about religion because we have our own rights about choosing a religion, so I mean don't ever be insulted Other people's religions if you don't want your religion to be insulted too. Do you think if someone insults your religion, can you accept it? So are other people's religions
I think your words are a little mixed up, but yes, it's not good to insult others. Sometimes, simply having a different opinion can be seen as insulting. People get easily offended. ✌️
It's mixed up, how about we just use logic here, the point is, if you don't want to be insulted by other people, then learn to respect that, accept it or not, take the risk yourself
I might try to talk to Bob in an interview, but from what I've seen, he is all over the place, and I have caught him miss representing other people on his channel. But we all make mistakes, that's not a deal breaker for me.
@@stayspiritual to learn about Islam you can talk to mufti uthman invite him to your live stream... because when you react on Islam n give reviews you should have basic knowledge about the religion
For clarification, our souls were ready to risk it all for heaven, once we saw heaven we were ready to "gamble" for it, since its that amazing its something a human mind cannot comprehend.
Both guys holding the book on the other sides are from the same truth, and they mean the same thing. But the obvious boring question is which one is pure and intact. Islam teaches that Adam is a God worshipper, but his children derail through time, and God sends prophets with miracles to guide the nations to not forget the creator of Adam and master of everything created.
24:02 a person with free will is better than a person without freewill, in the context of this video, because you would be ACTIVELY worshipping Allah and doing good deeds, rather than doing so because you are made to do so, like the Angels who obey every command Allah. That means our reward, a humans with free will who believe in Allah (swt). is a lot more and a lot better
To answer your question at time stamp 9:10 .. you should worship god because he gave you life .. your eyes , nose , mouth , heart , lungs etc .. your alive because of God . And that is why you should worship him my friend ..
A Being with No free will is just like angel. Do the command . No reward. No desire. No feeling. Plain. But Free will, you are human.you have feeling, you can feel happy, you have emotion and most importantly ; Because there will be the best reward : you will meet and see Allah ( the best reward). For muslim it is very special if we can see Allah the Creator. The Al Mighty that we cant see in this world. and another reward you can enter paradise ( jannah) . Those rewards , you cant even describe it how amazing they are. It is beyond .
Life is a TEST in Islam 😂 this is islamic conviction. Allah of course is the all knowing and with his infinite knowledge he knows how every oraganism will act, BUT he doesn't obliges you to do wrong, you do wrongful things when you follow your Nafs/ego or Satan. Hence you're accountable for your actions, and you will be rewarded accordingly in the Afterlife. He created you in the best form, gave you mind and will, sent you messangers, books and prophets to guide you, but you choose your own distiny. Really you need to read the Quran, read Surat Al Baqraa/ The Cow and you will understand alot.
33:07 yes we Muslims are saying this is the book this is the correct one just like many others are saying that their book is the correct one. Finding out whether we Muslims are speaking the truth or the others are speaking the truth is YOUR responsibility, we have no obligation to spoon feed you a thing, our job is to deliver the message only, whether you accept or not, that weight will be on your shoulder on the day of Judgement, not ours. So don’t humour yourself thinking otherwise. Go ahead use your free will and find the truth for yourself and remember one thing, you becoming Muslim does not benefit Allah in any way. Allah doesn’t need you it is you who need Allah
The way you wrote the comment sounded like some of the manipulations tactics used to scare me into following Christianity back in the day. I won't be scared into following anything.
@@stayspiritual ohhoho you are not only scared, you are terrified. That's why you take your face away from the truth and try to keep thoughts of your inevitable demise away from your mind. Enjoy this limbo while you can for it will soon end.
Advice for friends in the west, get into the habit of studying something until it is completely finished, then give your comments. The habit of western people is to always judge and cut things off
Honestly watching your reactions makes me feel and want to be closer to Allah. I in the most respectful way would not ever want to think the way you guys do. May Allah guide us all! Ameen🤲🏾❤️
Blessed is He in whose hand is dominion, and He is over all things competent - [He] who created death and life to test you [as to] which of you is best in deed - and He is the Exalted in Might, the Forgiving - . Quran (Al-Mulk) The Sovereignty 67:1-2
I'm a muslim. If i had the chance to answer that man from the video. I would say : this is god we are dealings with. Not your client or your friend. God own all the knowledge. We humans dont And to answer you about why free will better then been a robot. Choosing to help or love is better then you be forced to do. What ever god tells you to do is better for you. God doesnt need your prayers. You need the worshipping. To ascend to heaven Or choose to f**** around and you fall to hell. This is based on my knowledge. I know nothing. God knows everything
How can anyone not believe that free will is much better than not having free will? If you don't have free will, then you will do everything you are asked to do. If humans had to do everything their real parents asked, even if it meant killing innocent people, would that be good? Having free will as a human has been taken for granted, even when considering that the punishment given by law is just taking away one's free will and imprisoning them even for heinous crime.
Because you did not listen to the complete answer and the difference in what you believe in, you have created a lack of acceptance, so I advise you to listen until the end and then respond or comment for safe transmission and understanding.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR REACTION I understand your points. and I agree with you that Dr. Zakir, wasn't convincing in his answer. because if I'm an Atheist, why should we refer to a book I don't believe in. For a Muslim, what Dr. Nazik is convincing because he believe on the same book. I'm a Muslim and I believe on Quran and Islam is the Truth. but your video make me understand how others understand things. thank you
I like your videos and how you guys are very open minded. But please try watching at least more than 30 seconds before reacting. Let it process and understand what the DR is trying to say.
It is nice reaction from you brothers it is true reaction from you. it is good to question faith to know the truth not go after blind faith continue please
A human being has a free will, and it's the only creature with the free will, and they will enjoy this free will in paradise, where there would be no check and balance upon anything, and a human would be capable of doing anything without anyone's interruption. That's why a person with free will is good than a person with no free will
The reason for the similarity of religions is that God’s message is one from Adam to the last of the messengers, Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, but some distortion occurred in the previous messages, so God sent the last of the prophets, Muhammad, with the same message (Google translation)
Why is free will better than no free will? Rational answer: because noone wants to lose independent control of themselves. Logical: because emotionally we are humans and if we lose our ability to make decisions for ourselves and are forced to do things, especially against our likes and dislikes then we would ne effectively be tortured emotionally. Further, it wear you down mentally.
*The problem with these guys is that they confront scholars explanations of written facts with sarcasm. I can understand that to some ppl some things are hard to comprehend. It´s like Albert Einstein trying to explain how to splt an atom to a 6 year old* *I mean, even if you´re 40 and not into chemistry, you´ll never get it.* Only way to get grip of something is to start at the beginning. I recommend you guys to watch : Imam Ali describes God الله [ALL EPISODES] I´m a muslim and I was blown away by this information When I watched it recently. Every missing piece fell into the right place, and suddenly everything started to make sense. I´t a aprox 24 min video and I really wish you guys can watch it, or react on it.
You guys actually need to react to zakir naik explanation on ‘is there god’…. Then you need to listen to his video on ‘is quran the word of god’ Then you guys need to react to his video on ‘does heaven and hell exist’… you guys need to go in order to understand this video… you guys need basic understanding…the guy asking the question has already watched zakir naiks video so he had some confusion… now the guys asking question has converted to islam… he is a muslim now… if you want i will provide you the links… its on youtube
for ur question about free will, its better to have free will because as ur friend said, you get a choice, u have control, if u have a slave thats being forced or no choice but to obey, and then u have another worker or employee who is doing it out of his own choice, thats better. i answered without theatricals bcuz thats what u wanted but in all honesty when you asked that question it sounds like you are just asking for the sake of asking XD when u lowkey know the answer even the look on your friends face was weird cuz he tried to agree with you but he was confused. either ways i like yall reactions keep at it guys! the more you learn the more you know AND all the answers you couldnt find in christianity i dont blame you, but if you give islam a chance im sure it will answer 100% of your questions, give it a chance
Wallah the first question came to my mind just hours ago and I knew the answer but was not sure so I thought I'll search it and then I forgot but now Alhamdulillah I'm gonna get the answer. Ofcouse it was simple question not the objection.
I dont like how you guys know VERY little about islam and the quran and yet speak with such conviction. Islam is very different to christianity, we dont believe in blind faith. Our religion is very rational and clear, you come to believe in one God with absolute certainty. Pls continue to react to islamic content and you will both be extremely suprised. Good to have greater understanding about the faith of 2 billion humans and the fastest growing religion in the world. God bless :)
There is an infinite amount of information out there, which means you will never be able to fully understand everything. Just because we know very little about Islam does not mean we don't have an experience of it, even if just a small one. We present are current understand and experience as it comes. It the best anyone can do. We force nobody to watch our content. I'm pretty sure there will be more content in the future. ✌
Jst seemed like you guys were talking about your experiences with christianity a lot and then conflating the two. But i guess youre right, your views will only change with more knowledge and experience with the faith. Dont be put off :)
That's what I was thinking of. It's not fair to speak about something you don't have any knowledge about
@@stayspiritual brother infinite is a concept and doesn't exist on realm. there is many information but finite.
@@stayspiritual No, the information is the Quran. And you need to make sure you understand the meaning.
They dont believe in angels but they believe nothingness made them..very logical😂
In lslam God has created three creations 1.angel (Gabriel) made up of light
2.jinn(luccifer or chief of devil) made up of fire and have choosing free will
3.human(adam or eve) made up of clay and have choosing free will
Ok thanks for the low down 👍
I'd like to comment on your remark @ 19:24. It would be useless to keep on arguing if you tell a religious person to stop referring to their Holy Scriptures. Because while you don't believe in any holy scripture, they do. So the first step before asking any questions that is related to their faith, the two of you have to establish a common ground...either you debunk their faith and prove to them that their Holy Scriptures are wrong, or they prove to you that their faith is true and their Holy Scriptures are true and from God. Then you two can argue about the minor details that are attached to that faith. Otherwise, they will keep referring to their Holy Scriptures and you keep asking how do you know it's true? And why do you have believe such Scripture! (Basically keep running in an endless fruitless circle).
I appreciate the comment, and although I find it very deterministically black and white, there is no arguing from our side. As a matter fact is was completely one sided. We were just responding to a request to react on this particular video. Just because I don't believe in their scriptures does not mean we can't communicate. Many times changes comes through long periods of time, getting to know each other, and finding the things we do agree on. You build trust, and before you know it you find yourselves in place where you and other have become more tolerant and understanding of each other, and probably a bit of you has rubbed off you onto them, and vice versa.✌🙏
@@stayspiritual you are right of course.
And I apologize if I sounded offending in any way. Maybe the word argument wasn't the correct word to use.
I'm merely saying that it's useless to discuss something of you don't have a common ground you start with or at least a reference that everyone agrees upon.
Just the example you have provided in the video when Dr Zakir said that Angels are created to be completely obedient to God's commands. if the person who asked doesn't believe in the existence of Angel in the first place, then it's useless (in my opinion) to tell him that Angels can't go against God's will and compare them to humans. He doesn't believe in Angels in the first place so what the use of discussing whether the Angels are created completely submissive to God's will or not or how they differ from humans.
If for example that one who was asking simply wanted to learn about Islam's POV regarding free will or the purpose of Life or the reason behind the way we were created then it's ok to ask but the man in the video was trying to debate the Islamic perspective when he doesn't believe in God in first place.
If we are doing our research on something for PHD purpose, can all the data needed or information needed obtained solely by thinking? Or will you need to have a reference? regardless through the interview session or referring to BOOK or Scripture perhaps?
May Allah guide you both ...
Let me ask both of you a questions respectfully, if you sleep but when woke up suddenly found yourself somewhere unknown place what would you do, would you find the way to live your life or make excuses why are we here and give up your lives. It’s kind of irrelevant example but in some way it is relevant so you are here in this world as human being with free will .This is the fact why are you saying is free will better or not leave this guys The thing is you are here with free will as humans under the test being going on. 2 options either do good deeds believe in GOD and all the messengers and follow the commandments or worship your desires have alcohol or any evil deeds which are forbidden it up to you you can choose either if you choose right path very very easy to have good result otherwise bad performance lead to repercussions we don’t like free will free will choice is yours
For surely it is not the eyes that are blind but the hearts. - Quran 22:46
☝🏽😎
Sounds like an important metaphor. Blind to what?
@@stayspiritual Spirituality is about seeking a meaningful connection with something bigger than yourself
not a reaction video, even far from the title stay spiritual🤣, more like debating a video of zakir rising, instead the two of them argued, which without realizing it had a lot of sound without any content.
@@stayspiritual blind to accept the truth
@@MohammedNizlan-2328
The truth don't make friends with disbelievers
As a Muslim, I really appreciate the efforts you put into making this video, and I hope you will dedicate some time to learn more about the concept of Islam. In my humble opinion, I think this video needs a bit more advanced knowledge about Islam for some of your remarks. It's like trying to solve algebra without mastering the order of operation. Having said that, it's very interesting to me observing your genuine reaction which is based on your current perspective . I'm very sorry if I sound disrespectful.
The Quran invites anyone to challenge and question it and provides rational answers. I wish you the blessings of God in your journey.
Don't be sorry, actually you are probably one of the more respectful people we have had comment on our video, so thx and appreciated. We are continuing to learn, and will be releasing some more Muslim content soon.
@@stayspiritual Thank you very much 🙏
@@stayspiritual Its okay. I like you guys for questioning about quran because I strongly believe you guys will get clear answers always. Because I always found clear answers. One day we also had all the questions.
I think you should watch about many popular questions. Such as,
1) Who created god.
2) What is the fault of a child who born in a non muslim family.
And I recommend you to watch how Al Quran gave so many scientific theories that we found recently so many years ago although Quran came to Guide people to right path, not to teach science.
If the questioner was not given free will, he would have been stood here asking why was I not given a free will?.
These two dudes are so frustrated why religious ppl are so Dogmatic about their books..but these two dude doesn't realise that they are themselves are so Dogmatic with their belief that all religion are all the same.. never bother to question their belief and ask the question to themselves "what if amongst these religions with their books there 1 religion that are actually true religion..just what IF?"..
Seeing this video, I can imagine, is it possible for Christian priests or other religious priests to have the courage to have an open debate with their audience like this? and would they like to give priority to giving the opportunity to ask followers of other religions
Religious leaders from all faiths take question, and in many formats, at least from what I've seen.
Hello, thank you for this reaction, it is nice to see you guys respecting and learning other religions. As for a few questions as to why he didn't answer him fast and get over it. It is because as well as answering to the guy he is also trying to provide an answer to many others with similar questions, so rather than just spit the answer, he is taking the time to make them understand the answer better as well by giving simple examples.
Also you mentioned that any person according to their belief system can stand up and hold their book saying this is the true book. But it is different in Dr. Naik's case because he is not just blindly giving that statement in front of such a huge audience. If you have researched about him, he is a scholar of comparative religions meaning he has already studied all the major religions (e.g. all the versions of bibles) and knows them by heart in memory. So when he is giving such a statement it is not that he is trying to be egoistic or biased like any other person would be. Rather he is saying it based on his level of knowledge and trying to make others aware and encourage others to research and learn.
Lastly, the "validity" of the book Quran which was asked in the video is already done by him. Please listen to his other talks which specifically answer why that the Quran is "proven to be magical" as you said. Which are miracles proven by science now. Additionally during his debates he actually encourages his audience to do what you guys mention about coming to a "common ground to agree on somethings...". Best of luck, thanks :))
Thanks for all the info Giti.
33:00 True, he’s not the only guy standing on stage holding up a book, rather the opposite is true, there are many people claiming that their religion is the truth, but only one can be true. They can’t all be false because that would mean that everything is false and reality doesn’t exist. And They can’t all be right because they contradict each other. Therefore, we’re left with one option, and it’s that one has to be by necessity the “Truth”. Islam is that truth.
I love your deductive reasoning. Why does there only have to be one right way? Why does it have to be Islam? If anything, given the probability of reality being infinite, we as humans don't know anything, we just pretend like we do for psychological grounding. 🤔
@@stayspiritual Why Islam? Well, we must utilize our faculty of reason and intellect. We have been endowed with an exquisite mind for good reason. First and foremost, we must analyze our surroundings, and upon doing so, we cannot but arrive at the conclusion that this intricate design must have an ingenious source which is more brilliant than the design itself. According to the first law of thermodynamics, something cannot arise from nothing.For instance, if I were to install solar panels on my roof, I would harness energy in the form of electricity, indicating that the source of sunlight is an extremely powerful and energetic force.
Secondly, we must ask ourselves why this supremely intelligent entity, whose brilliance is beyond our imagination, would create such a creation without purpose. That would contradict “wisdom” which is an integral component of intelligence.
Thirdly, this creator must be singular due to the ‘infinite regress’ argument which posits that there cannot be an infinite series of preceding events or causes, so the origin must be one and uncaused out of necessity.
Fourthly, if everything was created with a purpose by a single intelligent creator, then that creator must inform us of that purpose.
Finally, why Islam? Because there is no other viable option. It is either believing in pagan idols which clearly cannot be the intelligent uncaused entity or believing in an illogical, edited and altered book which speaks of the creator having offspring. It is not befitting of an infinite creator to be limited by having children or incarnating as a created being. Islam is the only logical conclusion because “Islam” means submission to God, and submission to the omnipotent source of creation is the only rational conclusion.
@@stayspiritual Quran:
We will show them Our signs in the horizons and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that it is the truth. But is it not sufficient concerning your Lord that He is, over all things, a Witness? 41:53
And it is He who spread the earth and placed therein firmly set mountains and rivers; and from all of the fruits He made therein two mates; He causes the night to cover the day. Indeed in that are signs for a people who give thought. 13:3
[We sent them] with clear proofs and written ordinances. And We revealed to you the message that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them and that they might give thought. 16:44
Thus does Allah make clear to you His verses that you might use reason. 2:242
Truth can be one but wise speak of it in different ways. Just because your way does not match with other it does not mean they are false. In the end reality cannot be put into words. Words ≠ reality
@@SanatanSurya12 Words are a description of reality, just like code in programming is the language of electronics, and DNA is the language of organisms.
You guys mentioned why doctor naik is replaying slowly, well as you noticed that guy did not understand even giving an answer so the doctor has to repeat again, and it's not one on one debate a lot of other people have questions so won't be justice, however, please react more to doctor naik videos love to see your reactions.
We will see, we have a tone of requests right now to get to, but thanks for watching 🙏
My dear brothers this world 🌎 didn't create itself out of nothing! And there is injustice everywhere and Evil is roaming free, and powerful criminals and corrupt leaders and elites don't get punishment in this world, hence the judgment Day. This life is a test that is why we live and die and will be resurrected and judged upon our deeds and believes at judgement day! Hereafter is eternal life we live in good shape or bad depends upon our deeds and believes!
We will always continue our searching with open minds. Thank you for the comment, but I feel you have a lot of absolute stated conclusions, that I personally require deeper investigation for. 🙏🙏🙏✌
36:10 No he's talking about levels of paradise and you have to work harder for each level. 😊
I really appreciate your indepth analysis of the video...... thank you
Things to take in consoderation
1. The questioner watched Dr Naiks DVD.... and his question was based on the statements made in the DVD
2. What is meant by " the better creation" if i am an enigeer and i created a robot that is programmed to do what i command .... then there is an Engineer that created a robot that can make his own decisions for its self (free will)..... which Engineer would you be impressed with the most? .... for example can any engineer create something as great or as simple as a fly (that can reproduce, fly, and can sustain its self for energy) as small as it is? Would not such an engineer be great? Or the greatest and worthy of being whorshipped? So many arguments for God to recogized as in comparable and worthy..... the questioner how ever is not amazed by God as a Creator, yes its easy for God but for no one else .... that is what makes God Great and the Greatest!
Thanks for the great comment. It's good to see people mulling over such deep and complex ideas, deconstructing to see how things work. 👍👍👍
Free will is better because you two had a free will to choose your belief over being religious. In your previous video (the purpose of life part 1) if i remember one of you said that it is good to think independently and so on ( that is a free will).
He say "If you intelligence you will understand "... The answers he told from the first time is "Life is test"
33:29 when we say our book is the ultimate truth and words of God because we have Prove of how we have preserved it in its complete original form. One piece of evidence is that Muslims every year fast one month during the month of Ramadan in this month there’s a night prayer in which a chapter of the Quran is recited by heart and if the person reciting makes mistakes or forgets someone behind helps him. This has been happening from the time of the prophet. We have 6 year olds memorising the whole Quran and every Muslim knows 50-100 verses at least by heart
12:59 in Islam, life is a test. Also, we need to understand that the person Dr Zakir is dealing with is an atheist/agnostic, addressing his questions from a human point of view would be best suited for him to understand what Dr Zakir is talking about
Literally if you would read Qur'an it WILL BLOW YOUR MIND
I'm a Muslim, and I appreciate your honesty. Your genuine reactions are something I value. I like that you both challenge Islam, as it encourages thoughtful discussion. Thank you, guys! 👍
Hey y’all! So I watched few of your reactions and I actually learned about my own faith.. I really do appreciate the fact that I learned to sit through some of your comments because this platform form is actually insightful on how how someone can be so turned off by faith. I honestly found this particular video a bit disturbing because if the idea is to question and learn about different perspectives then it’s important to listen then comment. The video did come off a bit condescending but that’s only my opinion on it. Dr Zakir is a scholar and no everyone agrees with him which is why we all have different views or beliefs, he’s very clear on where he stands and only explaining his beliefs and experiences. Take what you will is his position (free will).. I watch and listen to understand what your position are and what other might be asking about my faith because I might have similar questions on their beliefs. I hope I didn’t offend anyone. All love 🤍
It's all good 👍
This so funny. The guy asking why is it better to have free will than no free will whilst he is disagreeing with everything he hears..how ironic😂
This right guy is so stupid, and actually, I didn't see these videos on their channel because it shows how foolish these people are. I wouldn't watch their videos only if I had watched this video before. I was actually thinking that they were not reacting to the right videos because they were reacting to videos of the army of Satan types, but I was completely wrong about them.
I just subscribed to your channel because I love your back and forth banter and your rational approach in listening.
He is explaining from the perspective of Islam.
That's why he said, Quran has been tested and the only holy scriptures on earth that passed the test. You should search knowledge about the test. First you may start from his video related to the holy scripture testing.
Absolutely love that
It is not the eyes that are blind , but the hearts . ( Al Quran)
Allah always in the Quran mentions that we have to think, investigate and reason the signs
I mean it’s not blind faith
1. Angels don't have freewill,jinns do.( Bad jinns are called devil/shaytan)
2. Ofcourse he is gonna use the scripture, beacuse he believes in it. We believe in Qur'an beacuse it has scientific miracles mentioned 1400 years ago which science is discovering now.( I suggest to hear scientific miracles in Qur'an by Dr zakir naik)
Qur'an also has prophecies which came true and has numerical and mathematical and historical miracles. It presents complete way of life as well. Also Qur'an challenged 1400 years ago to make one chapter like it and smallest chapter is of 1 line. But in 1400 years not a single human being could come up with a single line like the Qur'an. Qur'an also says that had it been from other than god, there would have been contradiction. But there is no single contradiction and the so called ones have been refuted by Muslims.
3. Btw keep emotions aside while reacting. "There is no space for emotions in ground of knowledge"
4. Btw the life of this world is a test.
Also this guy is just not a debater he is very knowledgeable and has good memory. Millions of people watch him and for a reason. Not beacuse of emotions.
5. He doesn't only speaks with emotions that this book is most logical. He has proofs unlike those Christians Preachers.
6. Highest level of paradise is jannatul firdous, if we wanna go there we gotta work hard.
7. Why the one on right has so much hatred against scripture? Unlike others Qur'an has all sort of miracles and no contradictions and no mistakes.
Btw we Muslims don't trust the scripture because of no reason.
8. He said non intelligent people can go to jannah if u r truthful.(u should have paid attention)
9. Not all smart people go to jannah either if they don't accept the truth, Allah knows best.
10. U wanna know book is valid? Then watch the video where he proved it with scientific miracles.
11. He is not only defending, but spreading the truth with authentic references and proofs and is not shouting with emotions"jesus(pbuh) loves you!!!" Like those Christians preachers.
12. Also listen to 38 scientific mistakes in bible by Dr zakir naik.
-btw if u have any question especially regarding Islam then feel free to ask.
im just normal muslim still learning
using his logic
imagine your teacher saying "youre failed in this university" before even you take study and take test for you
thats why god give human free choice either you want to be in paradise or hellfire
along with his teaching way of life
Please at least listen, the right guy is getting emotional. Please don't pause so much at least listen for 10 minutes or 5 then give your opinion.
🤔
36:00 he was talking about the most high level of paradise
Great Man zakir naik love ❤ from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
I see a lot of love out there for this man.
*he is an idiot*
There r so many cases against him, and he is thrown out from india
If you read the quran you mind will blow and your life will change its amazing it's guidance for human
I have listened to the whole audio book before. 🙏🙏🙏👍
I've read it, it made me not like Muslims. Actually loved u guys prior to
It’s gross bro twisted insanity from the mind of a demon..
@@stayspiritual oh well but in the video i see you guys don't even know basics of Islam from your comments and rampaging on it because it doesn't go with your world view. i have doubt that where is your stands on religion, can you please clearly state that because when someone is saying another thing is wrong then they must know the truth. if they don't know the truth they can only say i don't know but not wrong
39:53 it's not that we are fools and that's that -- Allah (swt) guides us to the right path many many times but the disbelievers choose to ignore it again and again. For instance, this conversation with Dr Zakir would've been one of the guidances for the speaker but if he chooses to ignore this guidance, the previous guidances and future ones, then he is the fool and has done this to himself.
Hello my brothers ima Canadian who’s been looking into the Quran n Islamic theology for a while and notice you were incorrect about some key points, if you would like I’d be more the happy to have a chat with you guys maybe help you understand some things, there’s no such thing as a dumb question if your seeking an answer:) have a good day everyone :)❤️
You will understand insha'Allah
Hi guys,
Just wanted to add on a misconception about the religion in short.
The meaning of Islam in Arabic is the submission of the will to God only,the god of Abraham, Adam , Jesus , Moses, Noah etc. all the prophets that were sent with same teachings to worship god alone without partners. However, the message was changed through out the time and people got misguided that’s why prophet Mohamed was revealed with the Quran to preach the same message that have been always the same.
And since prophet Mohamed is the last massinger the Quran had to be preserved in a different way memorization so no one can change it . And that is the miracle of Quran.
@@ahmedmansoor4081 absolutely. Its enough proof for openminded people to accept quran is the word of Allah
Can I validate that Allah laterally revealed the Quran to him, in my direct experience?
I love you guys perspective and the way of deduction of values rather than things that are just written , you guys are open and that's what important , .
Love from india 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Thank you, not everyone see things the same, but that's OK!
Love from Canada 🙌✌
True bro
your Question at 18:56 is valid why is Dr zakir referring to Quran , The answer is very very simple that is to analyze whether the Scripture is really a word of God or not if it is then we accept whatever it says.. And Quran can be easily proved to be a word of God it is 100% preserved,by looking at the prophecies which came true, scietific and Historical facts mentioned in it which were proved recently, the elequence of Arabic used, it challenges the all the humans together to come up even 3 or 10 verses.. No other scripture even comes close to the Quran. we have the clear cut prophecies of Prophet Muhammad which came and are coming true.
It is not like to escape from the questions we refer to the it is because we have first proved that Quran is the word of God and Prophet Muhammad is his messanger.
And Dr zakir wa giving the example the test similar to the life of this world and when he said you can't refer to the textbook during the exam he was equating the textbook to the past when Allah said to us whether you want to appear in this test(in this world )
36:25 we don't have the idea of "the elect" in Islam.What he means is that not everyone can enter the highest level of Heaven becase you need to earn it in this life, by getting "the highest grade in this life test" to put it simply, and this is through folowing the 5 pillars of Islam and maintaining a good approach to life.
22:41 it's not that one didn't make the cut biut it is that you yourself have acted on your own desires and forgotten to follow the path of Allah. And that's why Dr. Zakir says that no one will object to the justice of Allah - Allah (swt) is the most merciful, the most forgiving and he wants us all to go to Jannah (Heaven). If you end up in hell, it is because you have repeatedly sinned and did not repent, and so you would be justly sent to hell.
There is no such thing as a fallen angel in Islam
So we have learned thx
Around 16-17 minutes in to the video Justin said something very profound.....he said he had to become atheist to 'get out of the scripture'....that's what we Muslims start with too...we declare their to be no god i.e. atheist...except Allah...it therefore naturally follows you become Muslim once you rid yourself of all other religious bias. The little flavour you keep getting of similarity to this religion and that religion is because all religions came from that original one true religion (Al-Islam) from the dawn of mankind.....the differences in our view are just the corruptions people put on it through time. Keep researching, keep learning guys and keep reacting!
Hey bro’s . I like your honest reaction. But one suggestion to you both that one should let other finish his talk and then you can ask or comment on it.
Well even i used to think exactly same like you both 20 years back. But then i go through all scriptures with open mind. And finally after a long research and giving a lot of time in understanding scientifically and logically i landed up being a Muslim (Alhumdolillah) by choice.
Thank you for your kind words. Its hard with reaction videos to know when to stop or keep going. This is an older one, we are continually getting better I think 🤔. In terms of spirituality, we are always growing and learning. 🖖
Its a very limiting human concept to take Allah as a person who has an ego.. Allah is not a person who is egotistical and demanding and narcissistic. These are adjectives for subjects. Imagine you cook a very healthy meal.. You first pick the fresh ripe ones from your garden (even tho you planted the same seeds, they dont grow or come out the same), cut them, slice them, mix them, cook them on fire, and turn them into a nourishing delicious meal, knowing all along that you are going to eat it, chew it, swallow it, your stomach will break them further into pieces and all that.. So are you in this case an evil, punishing, egotistical person? Or is the food useless because u decided its fate? No. It keeps you alive. Its tranformed, not destroyed in essence. Just as a perspective on how we fall into the trap of projecting our humanity on Allah and evaluate him as that. Sending love from Istanbul guys 😇
@32:00 you missed the answer for the first part of the question. The answer was broken down like this as a metaphor. There is a child taking a test with q teacher.
Teacher = god
Child = us
Test = life
Whilst the test (life) is ongoing, we wont be able to checj the answers to see if it is true or not 100%. Only after can we see if what the teacher (god) told us is legit or there is no god like athiests claim.
He is banned in UK, Bangladesh and India also...😮
😅😅bangladesh haw bro. I am from Bangladesh i Don't no😅
I'm also from Bangladesh...there is no restriction for him...
40:00 ok this is annoying don't expect every topic to be about the validity of the quran or any other religious text for that matter. Some topics requires you the listeners to follow the narratives as a hypothetic, I'm sure you can engage in a thought experiment even if you don't believe its literally true. Its simple logic Dr zakir have done his studies to help his come to the conclusion that the Quran is from God and its contents are true . Instead of unfairly lumping all religions together do your homework ,no one will do the research for you. I would recommend going onto the Efdawah channels live streams interfaith discussions where a couple of Muslims guys answer and take questions. Sorry for the rant 😁
NO no no its good, get the rant out and feel through all those emotions. That'a where all the real gold is... if you hear what I'm saying. Why get any way... sad / happy / frustrated etc... I think those emotions might be telling you something about yourself not fully realized.
Don't make things difficult, to understand talk to a practicing Muslim, and read The Holy Quran with the intention to understand but,not make a mokkery of. There is no force for you to accept.
Hi guys please react the meaning life muslim spoken word
No promises, but I will put in the request bin. 🤙
Thanks for interesting discussion and courage to bring such topics that so many others doesn't bring it.
Dr. Zakir is always saying "I am student of religions /science and if anyone can show me more logical religion than Islam, I am willing to accept it today" so my advice if you found better scripters from your point of view, then go for it and if you cant find better, so keep learning more because Idk if you agree with that this complex creature "human" cant be left without catalog (purpose , life system as a guidance and afterlife knowledge)
Hey guys, awesome reaction! Thanks for posting your content!! This is not a comment on you guys just on society- How come so called religious people aren't afraid of studying science to high levels, in depth, even if according to atheists it may debunk their beliefs but atheists/non believing scientists seem unwilling to do the same with religions? It appears from the outside like the religious people are more genuinely seeking the truth. Science and religion are not at odds though, Islam explicitly urges believers to study the world around them. A muslim even invented the scientific method. Great reaction video, your criticism of Islam is welcomed and any questions for clarification I'm sure will be happily answered by muslims watching, if wanted in future.
Thanks for the kind words Taufeeq. I think science gives time mostly to things it can observe. Can a scientist observe heaven and hell, or can a scientist talk audibly with Allah like you and me can? Can you measure sincerity and faith? What is the exact amount of belief needed to appease Allah and can I definitively calculate for certain that I'm in his good graces. Just a few questions a skeptical scientist might ask.
@stayspiritual
Heaven and hell is another dimension so science cant act on it, just as consciousness is.
Also, the amount of belief you need is actually just sincerity. That's all. Just like you sincerely have the intention to marry your wife and commit to her for life. Things might change later, but mostly, people have that sincere intention ( maybe clouded with love😂) to commit for life.
About all religions being able to just hold up a book and just claim things, Islam actually encourages you to research everything with an open mind but with sincerity to accept the truth when found.
If there are different opinions on something where only one can actually be true, all you need is to analyze them deeply and sincerely to find the truth or at least eliminate the false claims.
Islam primarily just tells you to realise there is a creator that created you (even though we can't phantom how he looks like) and then worship him sincerely. Check out the religion of Ibrahim in Islam. He looked at things people were worshipping at that time and realized they were limited (just as Jesus is), and just decided to worship the creator of everything.
I really think you need an actual discussion with a muslim so you can have a proper back and forth.
I recommend you join either of these UA-cam channels in their regular livestreams ' Hamzas den' or 'Muslim Lantern '
Great viewpoint , i don't know but I feel many people here are just trying to impose , blame and convert .always love your reaction guys . Always remain who you are , just try and you will get to know about truth , about the reality and nature of the physical and spiritual realm .
Lets get unified 🙏🙏🙏
29:15 in Islam all questions are welcome and Muslims as the most questions so you will hear an answer for literally everything. It tells you how to wash your private parts and when to cut your nails when to pray how pray when to fast how to fast when to break your fast how to break your fast thousands of questions just from one question questions is how many question do you have to ask until you agree that the Quran is from god and Mohammad is a prophet just like Jesus Moses Joseph Abraham Noah Adam and lots more in between them
Guys, watch Bobby’s Perspective. He was on phycadellic (i dont know how to write those). I think you should try to react on videos about the basic of Islam first then move on to a more complicated matter.
I just feel that this subject is more than you can chew at the moment
Possibly and Noted
24:03 About that, what the best the one who has free will and the one who hasn't free will, I will ask you as an example, is true love the same will fake feelings? No of course you know that this one loves you but is love the only thing he feels about you so it's not equal to the one who loves you truly.
I try to follow Islam as much as I can.
From this brother question, we have got a logical answer.
All religious teachings are true for me, but I want to say that you respect each other about religion because we have our own rights about choosing a religion, so I mean don't ever be insulted Other people's religions if you don't want your religion to be insulted too. Do you think if someone insults your religion, can you accept it? So are other people's religions
I think your words are a little mixed up, but yes, it's not good to insult others. Sometimes, simply having a different opinion can be seen as insulting. People get easily offended.
✌️
It's mixed up, how about we just use logic here, the point is, if you don't want to be insulted by other people, then learn to respect that, accept it or not, take the risk yourself
@@anonymous5986 I hear you
What about my words is this fair or not
“Blind idiot” - jesus christ
If you see Bobby's perspective you will find your answers
I might try to talk to Bob in an interview, but from what I've seen, he is all over the place, and I have caught him miss representing other people on his channel. But we all make mistakes, that's not a deal breaker for me.
@@stayspiritual to learn about Islam you can talk to mufti uthman invite him to your live stream... because when you react on Islam n give reviews you should have basic knowledge about the religion
I have a basic knowledge of Islam?
@@stayspiritual Seikh Uthman?
For clarification, our souls were ready to risk it all for heaven, once we saw heaven we were ready to "gamble" for it, since its that amazing its something a human mind cannot comprehend.
simple solution from begining until now just “READ ALQUR’AN” 😊
The one eye logos vary from phrased "stay spiritual", then the phrased "Satan's worshippers" is more appropriate.
Both guys holding the book on the other sides are from the same truth, and they mean the same thing. But the obvious boring question is which one is pure and intact. Islam teaches that Adam is a God worshipper, but his children derail through time, and God sends prophets with miracles to guide the nations to not forget the creator of Adam and master of everything created.
I see 👀
Too many comments and no knowledge even before Dr. Zakir answered the question. Comments after the answer would be better
May Allah guide you guys Insha Allah ❤❤
May God bless them with Islam ❤
May god bless them with peace and truth
I can see how the truth touch it you and its clear when you start frustrating, you mission is to go and seek for the truth in every book
24:02 a person with free will is better than a person without freewill, in the context of this video, because you would be ACTIVELY worshipping Allah and doing good deeds, rather than doing so because you are made to do so, like the Angels who obey every command Allah. That means our reward, a humans with free will who believe in Allah (swt). is a lot more and a lot better
To answer your question at time stamp 9:10 .. you should worship god because he gave you life .. your eyes , nose , mouth , heart , lungs etc .. your alive because of God . And that is why you should worship him my friend ..
A Being with No free will is just like angel. Do the command . No reward. No desire. No feeling. Plain.
But Free will, you are human.you have feeling, you can feel happy, you have emotion and most importantly ;
Because there will be the best reward : you will meet and see Allah ( the best reward). For muslim it is very special if we can see Allah the Creator. The Al Mighty that we cant see in this world. and another reward you can enter paradise ( jannah) . Those rewards , you cant even describe it how amazing they are.
It is beyond .
Could’ve just googled him😅. Dr Zakir Naik has (besides obv. being a doctor) studied comparative religion and is working as a public orater.
A little knowledge of science make u an atheist and full knowledge of science make u believe in god
Dr. Naik is a student of comparative religion. He knows by memory the Koran, the Bible, and the Hindu scriptures. He is also a medical doctor.
Life is a TEST in Islam 😂 this is islamic conviction. Allah of course is the all knowing and with his infinite knowledge he knows how every oraganism will act, BUT he doesn't obliges you to do wrong, you do wrongful things when you follow your Nafs/ego or Satan. Hence you're accountable for your actions, and you will be rewarded accordingly in the Afterlife. He created you in the best form, gave you mind and will, sent you messangers, books and prophets to guide you, but you choose your own distiny. Really you need to read the Quran, read Surat Al Baqraa/ The Cow and you will understand alot.
33:07 yes we Muslims are saying this is the book this is the correct one just like many others are saying that their book is the correct one. Finding out whether we Muslims are speaking the truth or the others are speaking the truth is YOUR responsibility, we have no obligation to spoon feed you a thing, our job is to deliver the message only, whether you accept or not, that weight will be on your shoulder on the day of Judgement, not ours. So don’t humour yourself thinking otherwise. Go ahead use your free will and find the truth for yourself and remember one thing, you becoming Muslim does not benefit Allah in any way. Allah doesn’t need you it is you who need Allah
The way you wrote the comment sounded like some of the manipulations tactics used to scare me into following Christianity back in the day. I won't be scared into following anything.
@@stayspiritual ohhoho you are not only scared, you are terrified. That's why you take your face away from the truth and try to keep thoughts of your inevitable demise away from your mind. Enjoy this limbo while you can for it will soon end.
Advice for friends in the west, get into the habit of studying something until it is completely finished, then give your comments. The habit of western people is to always judge and cut things off
Honestly watching your reactions makes me feel and want to be closer to Allah. I in the most respectful way would not ever want to think the way you guys do. May Allah guide us all! Ameen🤲🏾❤️
It's because of free will, we know technology tday...
Blessed is He in whose hand is dominion, and He is over all things competent -
[He] who created death and life to test you [as to] which of you is best in deed - and He is the Exalted in Might, the Forgiving - . Quran (Al-Mulk) The Sovereignty 67:1-2
I'm a muslim.
If i had the chance to answer that man from the video. I would say : this is god we are dealings with. Not your client or your friend.
God own all the knowledge. We humans dont
And to answer you about why free will better then been a robot.
Choosing to help or love is better then you be forced to do.
What ever god tells you to do is better for you. God doesnt need your prayers. You need the worshipping. To ascend to heaven
Or choose to f**** around and you fall to hell.
This is based on my knowledge. I know nothing.
God knows everything
hey bros, i highly recommend getting in touch with the muslim lantern channel, that dude can clarify all things about islam...
Please hook us up.
Don't dont need you , its the human that need God
Zakir nayk is a student of the south African big schooler debater " Ahmad Didat" , and he is so funny too
How can anyone not believe that free will is much better than not having free will? If you don't have free will, then you will do everything you are asked to do. If humans had to do everything their real parents asked, even if it meant killing innocent people, would that be good? Having free will as a human has been taken for granted, even when considering that the punishment given by law is just taking away one's free will and imprisoning them even for heinous crime.
Because you did not listen to the complete answer and the difference in what you believe in, you have created a lack of acceptance, so I advise you to listen until the end and then respond or comment for safe transmission and understanding.
THANK YOU FOR YOUR REACTION
I understand your points. and I agree with you that Dr. Zakir, wasn't convincing in his answer. because if I'm an Atheist, why should we refer to a book I don't believe in.
For a Muslim, what Dr. Nazik is convincing because he believe on the same book.
I'm a Muslim and I believe on Quran and Islam is the Truth. but your video make me understand how others understand things.
thank you
I like your videos and how you guys are very open minded. But please try watching at least more than 30 seconds before reacting. Let it process and understand what the DR is trying to say.
It is nice reaction from you brothers it is true reaction from you. it is good to question faith to know the truth not go after blind faith continue please
May God guide you to the truth
Hey thanks, and you as well 🙏
A human being has a free will, and it's the only creature with the free will, and they will enjoy this free will in paradise, where there would be no check and balance upon anything, and a human would be capable of doing anything without anyone's interruption. That's why a person with free will is good than a person with no free will
The reason for the similarity of religions is that God’s message is one from Adam to the last of the messengers, Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, but some distortion occurred in the previous messages, so God sent the last of the prophets, Muhammad, with the same message (Google translation)
Why is free will better than no free will?
Rational answer: because noone wants to lose independent control of themselves.
Logical: because emotionally we are humans and if we lose our ability to make decisions for ourselves and are forced to do things, especially against our likes and dislikes then we would ne effectively be tortured emotionally. Further, it wear you down mentally.
Keep searching for 'the' answer guys., do not satisfy easily., I pray for U..❤
Great analysis
Feeling the Love 🙏🙏🙏👍 Thanks
Great videos as a Muslim I'm paying for you my brother so you continue in this beautiful journey 🙏💕
*The problem with these guys is that they confront scholars explanations of written facts with sarcasm. I can understand that to some ppl some things are hard to comprehend. It´s like Albert Einstein trying to explain how to splt an atom to a 6 year old*
*I mean, even if you´re 40 and not into chemistry, you´ll never get it.*
Only way to get grip of something is to start at the beginning.
I recommend you guys to watch : Imam Ali describes God الله [ALL EPISODES]
I´m a muslim and I was blown away by this information When I watched it recently. Every missing piece fell into the right place, and suddenly everything started to make sense.
I´t a aprox 24 min video and I really wish you guys can watch it, or react on it.
You guys actually need to react to zakir naik explanation on ‘is there god’…. Then you need to listen to his video on ‘is quran the word of god’ Then you guys need to react to his video on ‘does heaven and hell exist’… you guys need to go in order to understand this video… you guys need basic understanding…the guy asking the question has already watched zakir naiks video so he had some confusion… now the guys asking question has converted to islam… he is a muslim now… if you want i will provide you the links… its on youtube
We believe you....all request possible and noted
for ur question about free will, its better to have free will because as ur friend said, you get a choice, u have control, if u have a slave thats being forced or no choice but to obey, and then u have another worker or employee who is doing it out of his own choice, thats better.
i answered without theatricals bcuz thats what u wanted but in all honesty when you asked that question it sounds like you are just asking for the sake of asking XD when u lowkey know the answer even the look on your friends face was weird cuz he tried to agree with you but he was confused. either ways i like yall reactions keep at it guys! the more you learn the more you know AND all the answers you couldnt find in christianity i dont blame you, but if you give islam a chance im sure it will answer 100% of your questions, give it a chance
Wallah the first question came to my mind just hours ago and I knew the answer but was not sure so I thought I'll search it and then I forgot but now Alhamdulillah I'm gonna get the answer.
Ofcouse it was simple question not the objection.