PRO PERFORMER'S first REACTION to JOHNNY HALLYDAY & LARA FABIAN "Requiem pour un fou"

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 98

  • @sebcemoua
    @sebcemoua 3 роки тому +47

    This performance took place in a stadium with 90,000 spectators. So yes it was necessary to do much more than on a televised service. Thank you for this reaction.

  • @TheGewurtz
    @TheGewurtz 3 роки тому +10

    Too monsters Singer's for a monster performance

  • @dawnstone610
    @dawnstone610 2 роки тому +8

    Listen to Johnny. He is a French icon. Everyone loves him in my country.

  • @marie-annenogues8667
    @marie-annenogues8667 3 роки тому +10

    Johnny Haliday said to her, ' you are me as a broad' What a compliment!!!! I love this woman!

  • @bartonbagnes4605
    @bartonbagnes4605 3 роки тому +15

    They definitely were telling a story, but then theater acting is designed for the movements to be discerned from the last row as well as the first. Great vocals though.

  • @nimocash3535
    @nimocash3535 2 роки тому +3

    I can understand the too much side. But 1) it was on the stadium, so you must show big (and the rain omg this tonight).
    2) the lyrics are just insane, you are two people who are crazy, crazy of love and they killed their lover !!! the police are there to arrest him/her

  • @sandrinecozic7214
    @sandrinecozic7214 3 роки тому +6

    Johnny was born in France, his mother was french,his Father from belgium

  • @nedthumberland
    @nedthumberland 3 роки тому +6

    My goodness.....I am shaken by this performance.

  • @C.R1987
    @C.R1987 24 дні тому +1

    Lara's microphone sound was at maximum (it resonated..) and Johnny's was lower.. It was Johnny who asked for it to be done like that. Lara was his guest at the Stade de France and he wanted her to demonstrate her vocal power and shine. Lara herself confirmed it. Johnny in all his generosity... Know that Johnny was a vocal power too but on this last interpretation he did not want because it was done on purpose, Johnny was very intelligent in doing that to make the song more dramatic and show their acting on this magnificent song that belongs to him. The desired goal was the dramatic side of the singing all in power but less than Lara (Johnny) with at the same time next to him a more striking singing power (Lara) and the passionate play between the two. Everything was imagined by Johnny himself to end the last interpretation in style. A masterpiece, perhaps the most beautiful duet in the world.💣🎉💥

  • @QueenPcontrolstheuniverse
    @QueenPcontrolstheuniverse 3 роки тому +6

    there is nothing not genuine. Johnny was that way and Lara too (at the time). it's considered his best duo in his 60 years of carreer and she considers it the best moment of her career, what a legendary moment! I got child even 20 years later!

    • @dannytheswedishmusixian1513
      @dannytheswedishmusixian1513  3 роки тому

      To me it looked way overplayed and acted.

    • @QueenPcontrolstheuniverse
      @QueenPcontrolstheuniverse 3 роки тому +2

      @@dannytheswedishmusixian1513 And for them it's not. It's 100 % natural, that's how they always performed. Lara suffered because of it, the "press" mocked her. She doesn't perform that way anymore as a result. Also a lot of people saw a competition between them even a fight but she says it was the opposite. One needs to know who Johnny is and what he represents to us french to understand this was typical of him and also who lara is. With that being said, if you compare to most artist yeah you could think it's acted and over played.

  • @manofiske3318
    @manofiske3318 2 роки тому +3

    It( performance perceived overwrought) may _or_ _may_ *not* eventually, grow on you. Time will tell. Revisit it, sometime down the road.
    It may seem like an odd adjective to associate to such a seemingly "in-your-face" offering, but like almost all of Fabian's best work , the word sublime applies here as well; it's this quality that could initially be lost on the uninitiated.

  • @maxencesavary6596
    @maxencesavary6596 2 роки тому +3

    Requiem for a madmen..😉Johnny the biggest french rockstar RIP

  • @aurorabagnato3199
    @aurorabagnato3199 Місяць тому +1

    Qluesto persona che reagisce a lara e j onny Holliday non mi piace non sa niente di jonny non sa di chi ha davanti .... Anche per noi italiani era un mito un grande cantante e bellissimo uomo!!!!🇮🇹✌️❤

  • @crhu319
    @crhu319 3 роки тому +4

    Given the lyrics and the fact that the audience had to sit in the rain...it's not too much.

  • @mjcole12
    @mjcole12 3 роки тому +8

    It's just entertainment at the end of the day. We're looking at a stadium filled with 80k+ people...300 piece orchestra and choir, it's raining and these two people are singing, excuse me..., performing their hearts out on stage! Some commenters say it's too much, but for me I have a comparison. The band 'Meatloaf' has a live performance of " Paradise by the Dashboard Light " which is considered "Rock Opera!" Here's the link so you can see for yourself- ua-cam.com/video/C11MzbEcHlw/v-deo.html.
    What kind of Opera can Lara and Johnny's song be called?...Rock/Pop Opera? I don't know...The intensity between the two ( singers and performances)is the same! Both can seem over dramatic but I believe it was meant to be so that we, the viewer, can feel the passion that this kind of song requires...The roughness of Holiday's voice, I wasn't a fan of at first, but after multiple listening, I've grown to really enjoy this performance....Lara dominated this performance for sure...she was the Alpha here in my opinion

    • @dannytheswedishmusixian1513
      @dannytheswedishmusixian1513  3 роки тому +2

      Yeah I like both voices. The “drama” was just too much for me.

    • @mjcole12
      @mjcole12 3 роки тому

      @@dannytheswedishmusixian1513 I respect that. I feel bad for Johnny's left ear as Lara was singing right next to it with that powerful voice of hers lol! Did you check out that Meatloaf vid? Awesome song...Awesome performance!

    • @minkstapedes
      @minkstapedes 7 місяців тому +2

      I am primarily a liturgical and ensemble singer and this performance blows me away. As a soloist I have had to fight with the emotions summoned by the music to give a good performance. These artists were firing on all cylinders: emotion, power and technique. I don't use "awesome" often, but I am awed by this performance and kicking myself for not seeing Johnny at the Beacon in NYC in 20012.

  • @LetsChillPage
    @LetsChillPage 3 роки тому +20

    Hello, you talk about what is called "La nouvelle vague" and of Godard's Movie "Pierrot le Fou with Anouk Grinberg and Jean-Paul Belmondo.
    Johnny Hallyday is dead in 2017 and was a kind of French Elvis/Jagger/Sinatra or even Springsteen star equal in France.
    His funeral brought together nearly a million people on the Champs Élysée. His career began in France in the 60s and therefore ended in 2017. We can say that it was he who made Lara's career take off by inviting her to do this duet 3 nights in a row during his concert at the Stade de France. Let's say it was a bit like the dubbing of the French King of Rock. In France, Johnny Halliday is called "Le patron" (The boss).
    Lara Fabian still speaks of this duo at the Stade de France as the turning point in hes career.
    I perfectly understand what you feel about this performance so "Dramatic". But it's for a spectacular show in a Stade. And Unfortunately, if you see well, in fact we just see a little part of the stage. We even not see the crown, all spotlights, etc. I think this is which creates this discrepancy and gives this impression of overbidding, of ostentation. It had to be a lot better from the spectators' point of view.
    Thanks for this reaction.

  • @DoggieFosters
    @DoggieFosters 3 роки тому +11

    On repeated viewings, I grew to really appreciate and even love this performance. This was the piece that he was most known for. He broke it into two voices for a young Fabian to perform it with him, if I'm not mistaken. I believe she is the only female vocalist he ever sang it with.
    I think they captured the madness of the title well. Requiem for a Madman.
    She's a powerhouse that gets to the heart of any song she takes on.
    If you'd like some different looks at her vocal craft: Adagio (English, she wrote, From Lara With With Love concert.)
    You're Not From Here, also from that concert, she also wrote. Insane vocal control. It's insanely difficult but she keeps it sounding gentle and easy as pie.
    Her covers of the Italian songs Caruso (with only piano) and Pedere L'Amore from From Lara With Love.
    🤘

    • @dannytheswedishmusixian1513
      @dannytheswedishmusixian1513  3 роки тому

      Thanks!

    • @THEREALZENFORCE
      @THEREALZENFORCE 3 роки тому +4

      "This was the piece Johnny Hallyday was most known for" nonsense.
      Johnny Hallyday one million persons concert at the Eiffel Tower.
      Millions of persons in the streets at his funeral in France.
      A Legend since the 60s. Also brought Jimi Hendrix to Europe (France)
      Johnny was the idol Lara Fabian looked up to not the other way around :-)
      110 million records sold in the World.
      Johnny already sang Rock in the 50s when Ozzy Osbourne still did not know what it was.

    • @DoggieFosters
      @DoggieFosters 3 роки тому

      @@THEREALZENFORCE Your reading comprehension is severely lacking. Try again. Or don't.

    • @THEREALZENFORCE
      @THEREALZENFORCE 3 роки тому

      @@DoggieFosters you : " I believe she is the only female vocalist he ever sang it with." Yes true for that song.
      you "This was the piece that he was most known for"
      He sold 110 million albums world wide.
      Most sold singles songs :
      Marie
      Que je t'aime
      J'ai un problème (duo with Sylvie Vartan)
      There are six single songs ranked above Requiem pour un Fou (and that is his solo version of the 1970s)

    • @THEREALZENFORCE
      @THEREALZENFORCE 3 роки тому

      @@DoggieFosters So instead of insulting people online and spreading misinformation, you better do some research before making up claims.
      And for comprehension, sorry English is only my fourth language.

  • @dianabunaciu9645
    @dianabunaciu9645 3 роки тому +5

    Perdere l'amore ( Lara Fabian) and Ti amo cosi ( that's a trio: Lara Fabian, Dimash and Aida Garifulina), please! Regards from Romania!

  • @dawnstone610
    @dawnstone610 2 роки тому +2

    Johnny was a big time French actor, motorcyle guy.

  • @C.R1987
    @C.R1987 Рік тому +6

    It's a song by Johnny Hallyday from the magnificent album "Derrière l'amour" from 1976. When Johnny sings this song alone in concert he puts on more intensity. Here on this duet less because he would have asked that we lower his microphone to make Lara shine. Johnny in all his generosity...

  • @aysun9354
    @aysun9354 2 роки тому +1

    Malheureusement, elle en fait trop avec sa gestuelle et ses grimaces. C'est ce qui m'a toujours gênée chez elle.

  • @ProfEmerita
    @ProfEmerita Рік тому

    Respectfully disagree. The orchestra, choir, lyrics are powerful, dramatic and the singers embody, portray the feelings perfectly. These two great singers put everything into their performances.

  • @C.R1987
    @C.R1987 8 місяців тому +1

    I would like to point out that during rehearsals Johnny Hallyday would have asked Lara Fabian to sing with all her power, he wanted her to shine because she was his guest.
    Confirmation from Lara Fabian herself this morning January 25, 2024 on the French channel “TF1” in the show “Bonjour la matinale”
    This is why Johnny Hallyday is below vocally.
    It was intentional on his part.
    Johnny Hallyday was very generous.
    Also note those who do not know or know very little about this singer Johnny Hallyday, he could easily rise very high too. Very big vocal power too.
    I wanted to provide a clarification that I had already known for a long time but now with proof for those who belittle or who do not know this great performer.
    I'll let you judge for yourself by listening to a few albums in their entirety:
    "Rivière Ouvre ton lit" from 69, "Flagrant délit" from 71, "Insolitudes" from 73,
    “Derrière l'amour” from 76
    “Hallyday 84 Nashville en direct”
    "Rock'n'roll attitude" from 85, "Gang" from 86, "Cadillac" from 89,
    "Ça ne chanhe pas un homme" from 91,
    “Ce que je sais” from 98, “Sang pour sang” from 99,
    “A la vie à la mort” from 2002, “Ma vérité” from 2005, “L'attente” from 2012,
    “Rester vivant” from 2014, his last posthumous album “Mon pays c'est l'amour” from 2018.
    And so many other magnificent albums.. etccccc
    Je tiens à préciser que lors des répétitions Johnny Hallyday aurait demandé à Lara Fabian de chanter avec toute sa puissance, il souhaitait qu'elle brille car elle était son invitée.
    Confirmation de Lara Fabian elle-même ce matin 25 janvier 2024 sur la chaîne française "TF1" dans l'émission "Bonjour la matinale"
    C'est pour cela que Johnny Hallyday est en dessous vocalement.
    C'était volontaire de sa part.
    Johnny Hallyday s'est montré très généreux..
    Sachez également ceux qui ne connaissent pas ou très peu ce chanteur Johnny Hallyday, il pouvait facilement monter très haut lui aussi. Très grosse puissance vocale également.
    Je voulais apporter une précision que je connaissais déjà depuis longtemps mais maintenant avec preuve pour ceux qui rabaissent ou qui ne connaissent pas ce grand interprète.
    Je vous laisse en juger par vous-même en écoutant quelques albums en intégralité: "Rivière Ouvre ton lit" de 69, "Flagrant délit" du 71, "Insolitudes" de 73,
    "Derrière l'amour" de 76
    "Hallyday 84 Nashville en direct"
    "Rock'n'roll attitude" de 85, "Gang" de 86, "Cadillac" de 89, "Ça ne chanhe pas un homme" de 91,
    "Ce que je sais" de 98, "Sang pour sang" de 99,
    "A la vie à la mort" de 2002, "Ma vérité" de 2005, "L'attente" de 2012,
    "Rester vivant" de 2014, son dernier album posthume "Mon pays c'est l'amour" de 2018.
    Et tant d'autres albums magnifiques.. etccccc

  • @linajosephsson8773
    @linajosephsson8773 5 місяців тому

    They are not from north. What is for swedish too much,for french is enough and opposite. Not always can put a line between north and south, as taste is different, but its egzist differenses betwean feelings expresion betwean north and south people.

  • @phenix749
    @phenix749 3 роки тому +3

    fantatic realy

  • @lisaargyrou1488
    @lisaargyrou1488 Рік тому +1

    Wow 🎉 RIP to a french legend ❤️

  • @kriswalter8273
    @kriswalter8273 2 роки тому +1

    hello, Johny Hallyday is dead now, and was a show master in France, rocky voice well known, and you add to him Lara Fabian with NO AUTOTUNES , just real singing, real singing, the magic of a real voice, a great singer with singing techniques mastered to perfection
    I have few things to say about this video.
    Some people can think the gestures are exaggerated. You have to put in context. This is a live concert in a stadium with 90 000 peoples, in a rainy day. You have to do this, so anyone can get the message.

  • @koshm4r754
    @koshm4r754 3 роки тому +2

    c'est du johnny mon pote

  • @bricemazz
    @bricemazz 3 роки тому +2

    It is the best , what amazing singers they are

  • @fr33z00
    @fr33z00 3 роки тому +5

    She was only a guest for one song in this Johnny Halliday live show. This guy has been the french super star of the super stars from 17 y.o to his death at seventy something. I absolutely agree that she over exagerated her playing, but when you sing with such a monster, in front of such an audience, and only once, then, you may not be fully yourself :-)

  • @benoitlandry9193
    @benoitlandry9193 3 роки тому +3

    Bonsoir monsieur Daniel, greetings from Quebec City... Banzai! Banzai! Banzai! for reaching ten thousand subscribers in such a short time!

  • @claudiafreitasfreitas7288
    @claudiafreitasfreitas7288 3 роки тому +2

    Absolutely brillant! Amazing!💖💞

  • @karimaliege1051
    @karimaliege1051 3 роки тому +2

    welcome in fabulous lara's world!!!!!!!!!!! my favourite singer since 20 years!!! this duo is amazing, and you'll discover crazy songs from her, you must try "broken vow" and "adagio" and "caruso" shes amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @mauriziodiantonio6080
    @mauriziodiantonio6080 7 місяців тому

    Go and sing in the pub downstairs

  • @bevohw
    @bevohw 3 роки тому +1

    I have found it My fault Greetings

  • @catherineliu5899
    @catherineliu5899 3 роки тому +2

    Please react to Lara’s “Broken Vow” & “Je T’aime(live concert). It’s really really amazing and tearing. She’s Frence singing Queen. 🙏🙏🙏

  • @aurorabagnato3199
    @aurorabagnato3199 Місяць тому

    As

  • @kriswalter8273
    @kriswalter8273 2 роки тому

    Hello you spoke from the gestures but you did not really sspeak from the vocal performances (a bit from hers but.................

  • @elodiemaelelo3867
    @elodiemaelelo3867 3 роки тому +1

    Johnny

  • @nicolecostes4043
    @nicolecostes4043 2 роки тому +1

    Jésus malade🤣🤣🤣🇫🇷

  • @thierryroberfroid9400
    @thierryroberfroid9400 2 роки тому

    the original from johnny (1976) : ua-cam.com/video/1sEu0d0hEAQ/v-deo.html

  • @catkucing282
    @catkucing282 3 роки тому +1

    Please react to ISYANA SARASVATI- IL SOGNO 🇮🇩

  • @paulinecorre5368
    @paulinecorre5368 3 роки тому +1

    huge fan of youuuuuuu and eskobar

  • @JulienNK
    @JulienNK 3 роки тому

    too much for sure, as both singers....

  • @victorbradshaw7359
    @victorbradshaw7359 3 роки тому +1

    Congrats on 10k

  • @infopolit4015
    @infopolit4015 3 роки тому +1

    Tu veux parler de Pierrot le fou ?

  • @heartsource417
    @heartsource417 3 роки тому +1

    I have never seen anyone mauled while singing. before. Don't get me wrong I am not saying it is wrong. Ha.This was intense. Very intense. They may be the first singers to get an Oscar! Ha. I also prefer it a bit less dramatic. But that's okay. Thank you for your reaction. I have to say I agree with you. Take care!

  • @MartinWeng
    @MartinWeng 2 роки тому

    Love Lara ❤
    Love from Denmark ❤

  • @mrrrka
    @mrrrka 3 роки тому +2

    johnny ruined this song - his voice is awfully subpar to Lara

    • @dannytheswedishmusixian1513
      @dannytheswedishmusixian1513  3 роки тому +1

      Well, it’s definitely a different style to hers.

    • @Rosannasfriend
      @Rosannasfriend 3 роки тому +4

      He has a good voice. It’s a very distinct sound nothing wrong with that. Sounds dramatic. He didn’t ruin his own song. Just say you prefer her voice and that’s it.

    • @Rosannasfriend
      @Rosannasfriend 3 роки тому +2

      Her overacting ruined it

    • @mrrrka
      @mrrrka 3 роки тому

      @@Rosannasfriend sure. i'm entitled to your opinion

    • @joseexposito5769
      @joseexposito5769 3 роки тому +4

      No i m sorry but johnny hallyday sings very well this song with lara.... it s a different style. I m spanish and in spain johnny is loved.