Flutter vs React Native vs. Swift/Kotlin In 5 Minutes

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 149

  • @KaroKaro290
    @KaroKaro290 Рік тому +187

    1. If you learn native you will switch into crossplatform in a second.
    2. As a native dev you have opportunity to work in a big companies and your financial/code skill ceiling is much higher.
    3. At some stage of crossplatform dev you will need native knowledge anyway.

    • @bullymaguire2335
      @bullymaguire2335 4 місяці тому +2

      you will or can ?

    • @Coding-t4h
      @Coding-t4h 2 місяці тому +2

      @@bullymaguire2335 I think he meant can

    • @justinasbei
      @justinasbei 7 днів тому

      " If you learn native you will switch into crossplatform in a second." What this supposed to mean?

  • @jamesdyale
    @jamesdyale Рік тому +181

    Yeah apps aren't doing any crazy rendering where performance becomes a top priority so you're super spot on there. I have been building using react native for some time now and I have never really noticed any issues. Great video btw!!

    • @YourAverageTechBro
      @YourAverageTechBro  Рік тому +25

      Yep people over emphasize theoretical performance when really it takes a lot to push an app to really struggle with performance haha

    • @i.am.oarabile
      @i.am.oarabile Рік тому

      ​@@YourAverageTechBro same I use an android framework Droidscript that uses a bridge like react and I use js, no performance problems

    • @giuliopimenoff
      @giuliopimenoff Рік тому

      yo accept my beta application please xD

  • @maran.ath4
    @maran.ath4 Рік тому +45

    Now that's a Developer who did his research before making a video, ugh, you're a breath of fresh air, have my subscription

  • @Dwika34
    @Dwika34 Рік тому +39

    So far from what I noticed, what's really hard on working with multiplatform is if you're making an IOT app, that needs to exchange command in the form of bytes that is sent to the device. Granted sometimes the manufacturer of the device you are working with offers a multiplatform SDK, but most of the time they don't, so eventually you have to dig deep into native code implementing the command sets yourself in which at that point it's just better to go native all the way.

    • @dewaldesterhuysen712
      @dewaldesterhuysen712 11 місяців тому +5

      For IoT let the backend handle that. For the front end it should be like with a 'normal' app

  • @ajaykotiyal427
    @ajaykotiyal427 Рік тому +41

    I think Flutter is now became much more popular. Flutter is best option of discussed, because it also provides single code base for different platforms, without loosing performance. If App is more dependant on hardware usage (like Games), then Natives (Swift / Kotlin) are best option. Mostly Flutter can be used.

    • @wezter96
      @wezter96 Рік тому +8

      Except if you want to build web and mobile with same codebase.
      Flutter kinda sucks for web whereas using RN for web and mobile using things like Solito and Tamagui is pretty good.

    • @JEsterCW
      @JEsterCW Рік тому

      @@wezter96 The problem with react native is the limited ui in the concept of look, flutter can provide unlimited modern look towards our ui elements, you can make any ui element without any hestitation, and in react native most of times is barely possible without frustration or boilerplate an example is circular progressbar in react native you need reanimated + skia that has many lines of code and in flutter its 4 lines of code including curly brackets, so ye i pref productivity than the whole shithole altho youre right in terms of sharing the code between web and mobile especially if you already have a web app and wanna extend your product to mobile react native is the only goal as long as its react based web app otherwise flutter is the only way to go.

    • @MrRe-sj2iv
      @MrRe-sj2iv 9 місяців тому +1

      Are you sure?

  • @seanknowles9985
    @seanknowles9985 Рік тому +19

    You missed out Kotlin KMP and Jetpack Compose Multiplatform

  • @EddiKh
    @EddiKh 9 місяців тому +6

    One of the main reasons I started on Flutter dev is because of the reliable Type strict language

  • @Aviamoyal
    @Aviamoyal 11 місяців тому +6

    Bro you should make playlists that are categorized in different areas, love your vids 💯

  • @gavinbryan123
    @gavinbryan123 Рік тому +17

    Great video, totally balanced and agree with you. Have programmed natively with Swift and Kotlin for many years which I love but mainly use React Native now as the performance difference for 99% of the apps I’m working on is not enough to warrant writing twice in native and end user would be none the wiser. If I had a use case to do so I would but so far React Native working really well for me and also the fact that it is quick to get general React developers up and running on React Native too and share same React idioms across web and mobile app development especially nice using TypeScript. But appreciate also very much depends on project / team / background skill sets etc.. Also interesting Xamarin is not mentioned anymore (I was certified developer in 2015) which I can understand and now replaced with MAUI I believe which is Xamarin Forms from what I can make out ?

  • @hyungtaecf
    @hyungtaecf Рік тому +25

    For most of the general cases Flutter is the best in my opinion. The cases where the cost-benefit ratio won't apply are very specific, like yours. You wanted to use something that probably Firebase would do the job, but you wanted to use something else.

  • @WeeklyFire
    @WeeklyFire Місяць тому +2

    TBH JetBrains made writing cross-platform code in Kotlin (called Kotlin Multiplatform) much easier via Jetbook Compose basically like Flutter if JetBrains owed it. In theory, you don't need to learn swift (Objective-C) for Apple OS applications with this new framework it surpasses the traditional Kotlin/Swift codepath. React Native and Flutter (Dart Programming) are still options though.

    • @doke6057
      @doke6057 Місяць тому

      So its now better to go thé kotlin road, right ?

  • @sanandresprograma
    @sanandresprograma 3 місяці тому +3

    en mi caso me quiero especializar en iOS, pero como estoy apenas iniciando en el desarrollo móvil, decidí irme primero por flutter ya que me permite hacer con un solo código apps para iOS, Android, web y PC, por lo que me permitiría trabajar de manera freelance.
    Gracias por el video desde Colombia

  • @andrewdddo
    @andrewdddo Рік тому +9

    Super useful video man! Honestly most times, just choosing a framework is the hardest part haha

  • @martypickens1257
    @martypickens1257 Рік тому +4

    This video came at a good time! Great video as always dawg

  • @monarchgam3r
    @monarchgam3r Рік тому +11

    React native no longer needs bridge

  • @-mohammadalakedy5417
    @-mohammadalakedy5417 6 місяців тому +1

    React native now is amazing ❤

  • @Manish-zl9jh
    @Manish-zl9jh 3 дні тому

    Please make an updated video making apps using react native since react native does not have that compilation bridge in new update.

  • @shankar7435
    @shankar7435 3 місяці тому

    Super concise video. Thanks.❤❤❤

  • @jso2332
    @jso2332 Рік тому +5

    Would you stay at a company that hired you to do native, but 1 year later forces you to go cross platform?

  • @Shaheer-xs5os
    @Shaheer-xs5os 10 місяців тому +6

    I think Kotlin is my all-time favourite, but I also wanna try Flutter in future...

    • @jameshamze
      @jameshamze 10 місяців тому +1

      How bro tell me a road map to become mobile app development with Kotlin

  • @presidentresident
    @presidentresident 11 місяців тому +4

    Any ideas as to why Fiverr is predominantly filled with Flutter developers? Is that indicative of a softer barrier to entry?

    • @pyros4333
      @pyros4333 7 місяців тому

      Easier entry. Framework already includes scaffolding.

  • @giuliopimenoff
    @giuliopimenoff Рік тому +9

    you forgot to include kotlin multiplatform too :)

    • @Masda.X
      @Masda.X Рік тому +1

      Is kotlin cross platform now ?

    • @giuliopimenoff
      @giuliopimenoff Рік тому +1

      @@Masda.X yes it can compile to obj C which is usable by swift

    • @Masda.X
      @Masda.X Рік тому

      @@giuliopimenoff thanks

  • @karlsour500
    @karlsour500 Рік тому +2

    Always native will be in our hearts!
    Cross- platform go by

  • @paudisart4001
    @paudisart4001 3 місяці тому +1

    A minute into the video, I realise your glasses are off-centre. Can't unsee D:

  • @techwithabox9574
    @techwithabox9574 9 місяців тому +3

    Lol meta wrote their whole app in native (kotlin,swift) , they also used jetpack compose for their new threads application

  • @sophiechavigny9725
    @sophiechavigny9725 Рік тому

    So helpful. Thank you very much!!

  • @ayberkmogol
    @ayberkmogol Рік тому +13

    Native is best ❤

  • @chrisorr5223
    @chrisorr5223 2 місяці тому +1

    Would performance matter for a TikTok clone app? Basically I want to have an app that is similar to TikTok where you watch vertical videos that you can scroll through. I followed a react native tutorial which used AWS S3 and the video is a bit laggy, sometimes the video takes a while to load and it's nowhere near as slick as TikTok. Is it possible to do this sort of thing in react native? Can it reach a comparable level to TikTok performance if I were to spend time trying to optimise the react native code?

    • @AIBusiness-vq2gu
      @AIBusiness-vq2gu Місяць тому

      My guess. Definitely do that native. Why? You don't want any stuttering whatsoever.

    • @chrisorr5223
      @chrisorr5223 Місяць тому +1

      @@AIBusiness-vq2gu building in native will be a lot more work. Realistically, its just an app that plays videos and even if its not the most efficient code, I think most phones should be able to handle that without stuttering. I did manage to make my app a lot faster by compressing the videos before uploading them. I think by doing this and a few other tricks like loading videos in the background I should be able to improve the performance a lot.
      I’m still open to building in native if it is really required, but I’d need to see some really compelling arguments as react native will be much faster (and cheaper) to make the app

    • @AIBusiness-vq2gu
      @AIBusiness-vq2gu Місяць тому

      Good point! Now that I think of it based on what you said, I would definitely go the RN route. You can always decide to move to native later on if necessary. But for starting out RN will probably save you a lot of time and maintenance.

  • @khethelogp
    @khethelogp Рік тому

    Beautifully said

  • @EmiliaKaida
    @EmiliaKaida 8 місяців тому +1

    What about Kotlin Multiplatform? It seems to be in a super early stage (at least for exporting to iOS) though.

  • @stonebat
    @stonebat 8 місяців тому

    There may be another one replacing flutter or react native. But Swift & Kotlin are here and stay

  • @ashleymorris9091
    @ashleymorris9091 Рік тому +1

    In the case of post hog can you mix flutter and native development easily? E.g. could I make calls to a facade that I create in Kotlin/Swift native that I call out to from flutter?

  • @nathanielreeves_dev
    @nathanielreeves_dev 5 місяців тому

    React natives secret weapon is expo. The fact that it allows me to build for android and iOS without needing Mac hardware is huge

  • @D3S1N3R
    @D3S1N3R Рік тому +11

    Im worried if I start developing in Flutter Google will EOL it in a year. Is that a real concern for anyone?

    • @OpyJoe
      @OpyJoe Рік тому +1

      Me too

    • @rahul123715
      @rahul123715 Рік тому +1

      HI @jasonthedesigner honestly if someone was starting a career I would still say native is the approach to go. Have been in the cross platform space for 10-11 years and have seen lots of cross platforms come and go like Cordova,Ionic, NativeScript, Xamarin, Native is always the most stable option. I have a feeling React Native will outlive Flutter not because it is better but just that it allows people from web background to move whereas Dart is honestly a learning curve in organizations when you could have a React dev. Although it is niche it is also limiting in terms of opportunities. Flutter has been for more than 5-6 years and honestly I have not seen google promoting it as intensively and its adoption as compared to what it should be

    • @codegambit2507
      @codegambit2507 Рік тому

      @@OpyJoe People have been saying this same thing for like 5 years now and the Flutter and Dart team keep releasing great updates that improves the technology. It ain't going anywhere anytime soon

    • @MyshKatze
      @MyshKatze 7 місяців тому

      That's impossible tbh

  • @AharonBabel
    @AharonBabel 2 місяці тому +2

    Should learn Objective-C for Apple first ,then Java for Android, then Swift again for Apple ,then Kotlin for Android again and so on ...Never ending story ...😅

    • @caege7091
      @caege7091 Місяць тому

      Why do we need to learn Java, pls explain. I'm learning kotlin and I'm not new to programming, I know python and JavaScript. Learning any programming language is just familiarising myself with their idiosyncrasies. Suffice to say I think we don't need to learn Java to learn Kotlin.

  • @ulrich-tonmoy
    @ulrich-tonmoy Рік тому +4

    Is there any place for .NET MAUI in app development

    • @YourAverageTechBro
      @YourAverageTechBro  Рік тому +1

      I'll be honest I have never heard of .net maui 😬

    • @maritomesquita6719
      @maritomesquita6719 Рік тому +5

      .net maui ui libraries are still very poor, it's just a mess. not ready yet

    • @FrankyDeMeyer
      @FrankyDeMeyer Рік тому

      I wouldn’t trust it. MS bought Xamarin and they have a habit of dripping support. I’ve used Xamarin Mac for a big project. A few months ago, MS released a brand new editor for Mac and a few months later announced that Xamarin Mac will be discontinued next year!
      I think MAUI has no future, tbh

  • @mehmetedex
    @mehmetedex Рік тому +2

    Skia is not dedicated copied from chrome.
    Dedicated Impeller rendering engine is released a few months ago and its superior to skia and its the default for a few months now but..
    This is the forth video I encontered that doesn't even mention it. 🤨I feel really salty at this.

  • @sman6320
    @sman6320 Рік тому +9

    How about .NET MAUI?

  • @asitabhpaul
    @asitabhpaul 8 місяців тому +1

    Je wala sahi jai😅

  • @bullymaguire2335
    @bullymaguire2335 4 місяці тому

    Since Facebook is not involved with react native anymore does it mean its community support will diminish ?

  • @theunluckymaker
    @theunluckymaker 9 місяців тому

    any update on if posthog and flutter have gotten a better support lately?

  • @f0rtyxo
    @f0rtyxo 5 місяців тому

    if I want to build an application that i want both on iOS and Andriod that communicates with IoT Devices such as fans or lights, what's the best way? should i go react native? any help or input would be nice. I have programming knowledge so adapting to any is okay by me but i really wanna know whats the best and easiest way to go about it since i will be the only one developing it

  • @omanshsharma6796
    @omanshsharma6796 Рік тому +1

    thanks a lot for such a great breakdown!!

  • @rezamohammadi1210
    @rezamohammadi1210 Рік тому +3

    Hey thanks for nice video,
    Can you please give credit for who has this video in UA-cam or website?
    At 1:07 flutter moving background slider ?

  • @emenikedaniel
    @emenikedaniel Рік тому +4

    I honestly thought we can now develop cross platform applications using kotlin. I saw that in a recent update on their website.

    • @YourAverageTechBro
      @YourAverageTechBro  Рік тому

      maybe! I've never tried it out myself

    • @s1nistr433
      @s1nistr433 Рік тому +1

      Yes, but it's really new and there's not much support for it. It has a lot of potential though

  • @belmo_
    @belmo_ Рік тому +1

    Well, it is going to change with compose multiplatform

  • @rush_and_crush
    @rush_and_crush Рік тому +3

    i thought kotlin is also cross platform, am i wrong?

  • @CashMoneyMoore
    @CashMoneyMoore Рік тому

    Thanks for the info

  • @chiyanchin120
    @chiyanchin120 4 місяці тому

    i do think discord run very slow in android. Every update making it noticeably slower and my android is quite high end.

  • @Happymaninyellow
    @Happymaninyellow 7 місяців тому

    Average bro, do you think flutter is overhyped. Will you prefer KMP now?

  • @atulkulve2981
    @atulkulve2981 7 місяців тому +1

    Came here for clarity and you confused me more..😂

  • @AlekseyKovshov-n5h
    @AlekseyKovshov-n5h 11 місяців тому +1

    kmm for kotlin is joke?

  • @DediAnanto
    @DediAnanto Рік тому

    Mantap sekali ini folio, kayaknya next project akan make ini aja deh 😍

  • @kidusman7923
    @kidusman7923 Рік тому +1

    what about app size

  • @harshdeep7015
    @harshdeep7015 Місяць тому

    The main reason I switched to flutter because it has photo editor packages 😅

  • @josbexerra8115
    @josbexerra8115 8 місяців тому

    NO mencionastes a Framework Maui Net..... ;(

  • @harshdeep7015
    @harshdeep7015 Місяць тому

    You app is not working android 😢

  • @rehanshah4262
    @rehanshah4262 Рік тому +2

    in perfromance you should also , mention problem of skyia enginee with ios' enginee

    • @YourAverageTechBro
      @YourAverageTechBro  Рік тому

      haha yeah woops should've mentioned it. I may have accidentally edited it out

  • @manolisbach2380
    @manolisbach2380 6 місяців тому

    What abou xamarin and maui 😅

  • @willowsayswhat9642
    @willowsayswhat9642 8 місяців тому

    right now I'm struggling with Flutter Local Notifications and I just can't implement them in my app. I look at swift and it looks so easy... sigh.

  • @Rahmat_Kakar
    @Rahmat_Kakar Рік тому

    I'm planning to become a cross platform mobile app developer please give me advise which framework i should learn

    • @ak_fashion_worlds
      @ak_fashion_worlds Рік тому +2

      Dart and flutter

    • @rahul123715
      @rahul123715 Рік тому +7

      Have been in the cross platform mobile space for close to 10 years. I honestly would still vouch for native as a major and cross platform like React Native or Flutter as a secondary thing. I feel native helps you master a single platform more deeply and platforms like React Native open your potential to web if you want to move down the full stack path. Although crossplatform is a quick way to build for both it makes you more niche and specific and I have seen a lot of platforms evolving and changing from Cordova to Ionic to React Native , Flutter, NativeScript, Xamarin. I would follow the native path as in the long run it is stable, it pays you well and follow crossplatform as a minor

  • @balloney2175
    @balloney2175 4 місяці тому

    What if Flutter has strengths that React Native doesn't have?

    • @ak-loz
      @ak-loz 4 місяці тому

      Like what?

    • @balloney2175
      @balloney2175 3 місяці тому

      @@ak-loz Networking?

  • @christianm4906
    @christianm4906 5 місяців тому

    At this point, everything seems better than react.

  • @olekollo7875
    @olekollo7875 8 місяців тому

    Elexir

  • @erenizci4197
    @erenizci4197 10 місяців тому

    1 question is enough do you have macbook yes watch this video no go learn kotlin

  • @ThomazMartinez
    @ThomazMartinez Рік тому

    Not Skia but Impelar

  • @xeakpress
    @xeakpress 4 місяці тому +1

    Named all those apps that use React and all I can remember about them is they're all trash

  • @dodada-6050
    @dodada-6050 Рік тому +1

    You forgot to include kivy & kivyMD for python

  • @elvispalace
    @elvispalace 10 місяців тому

    web react developers can learn expo RN in 1 day

  • @faruhsayfullayev8329
    @faruhsayfullayev8329 Рік тому +1

    Flutter created for developers, RN created for ppl

  • @p0igi0vc
    @p0igi0vc Рік тому +2

    How much has Facebook paid you to advertise for react native

  • @sudheer-suri
    @sudheer-suri Рік тому +1

    Two words: function components

  • @TomBerghuis
    @TomBerghuis 3 місяці тому

    i thought todewy was created by engineer girlfriend 🤔

    • @YourAverageTechBro
      @YourAverageTechBro  3 місяці тому +1

      I helped build out the initial version with her but then stepped away after a few months. It's 100% her app now though - I was just there in the beginning haha

  • @emmanuelmichael1713
    @emmanuelmichael1713 Рік тому

    thought kotlin has cross-platform feature

  • @quickmaths4762
    @quickmaths4762 Рік тому +1

    This one says react native has better performance than flutter: ua-cam.com/video/tTGWfXPKxf4/v-deo.html

  • @khanra17
    @khanra17 9 місяців тому

    Over done audio

  • @Alexander-mg4pr
    @Alexander-mg4pr 9 місяців тому +1

    I'm never, EVER going back to React Native!! 🤮

    • @ComputationalArt
      @ComputationalArt 8 місяців тому

      Why?

    • @z77876
      @z77876 8 місяців тому

      Same. I regret not learning flutter first

  • @engelshentenawy
    @engelshentenawy 6 місяців тому

    video is full of misinformation.

  • @krudos
    @krudos Рік тому

    fix the flutter library and make a PR

  • @JosepCrespoSantacreu
    @JosepCrespoSantacreu 6 місяців тому +1

    Yeah, nowadays comparing performance between frameworks is just a matter of milliseconds to compile, open de app first time, so it becomes totally IRRELEVANT. “Oh look at my app is 100% native” OK, nobody cares but you…

  • @danielhyatt8063
    @danielhyatt8063 Рік тому +3

    Terrible view IMO. Said Flutter uses Skia when now the default is Impeller for iOS and soon to be for other platforms as well. Within performance, Flutter may consistently reach 60fps but that doesn't mean the end product "feels native." I 100% prefer Flutter to RN but RN wins in terms of performance. Numbers can only get you so far. When you get both in your hand, you'll be able to tell that one feels native and one feels like Flutter. Not to mention performance and community support are two random metrics you chose to use to pick which one is best. If you're actually talking about developer experience, you'd mention that Flutter has many, many more first-party widgets than RN has components. Also Flutter not having OTA updates (Shroebird coming soon though) while RN does. Why not mention how React Native is three years older than Flutter? This video was spoken like someone who has never actually used these technologies.

    • @TheTdg97
      @TheTdg97 8 місяців тому

      someone got triggered because he didnt fanboy over flutter and said its the best ever and that everyone should drop RN and native for flutter :b
      He basically said, use whatever you want, just analyze your exact needs before starting development

  • @victortimi
    @victortimi Рік тому +2

    First to comment 🎉

  • @rainbowinthedark2835
    @rainbowinthedark2835 16 днів тому

    React Native really sucks

  • @DelightBessie
    @DelightBessie Місяць тому

    are you wearing a wig..no offense?