Thank you for this reaction, I was waiting for it since Part 1 )) It's a beautiful transformation indeed, and I think you're absolutely right about why HCY changed so dramatically into a great / honest / true artist.
I personally think his major talent is in 'composing' the lyrics and music to express his 'feel', which is quite accurate and resonates a lot with his generation, like 'where do i find what I believe in' in 'monkey king'
No, wait, by "his generation", you meant " his fans"... I'm in his generation, and I don't get his artistry, singing or music. Neither do my friends from the same age group.
很明顯熱門評論前幾名都沒有看到第二段我管你的講評😂 我管你是華晨宇第二張專輯（2015）的歌，他從那時就是這樣表演了，當然參加歌手時他對舞台的掌控力更好也更鬆弛 第一段的齊天是演唱會，自然會有一些為了現場演出而設計製作效果，以及這首歌本來就是戲劇化的，他的聲音可以很多變 13:20 “ I believe him now. This feel real. “
He was so young it the other one and I think he came from a broken home and he used his music to work through that and he is a lot older here and has had a lot more experience. Most of his songs have two types of singing, soft and load. At his concerts some times his fans to sing the whole song with him.
I love Hua Hua is not because his singing technique but his talent and performance in music. He has created and performed a lot of wonderful songs for us. Love it~🥰
Hua Chenyu n'a plus besoin de professeur de chant lui dictant la conduite a tenir il y a déjà bien longtemps . Il a toujours été un électron libre et le restera malgré les critiques qui n'ont en rien interférer dans sa brillante carrière. Il continue d'evoluer et d'innover encore plus haut encore plus fort n'en déplaise à certains .
His fans tried to do an Intervention, because they felt his Management were making him perform too much and it was affecting his voice. Looking at this Reaction, highlights... "where did the Rap come from with Hua Hua". He grew up listening to Muse, Radiohead, Linkin Park etc.. ROCK. He has absorbed Rap, Reggae, Pop, SynthPop, Electronic, Accoustic, Ballads, Traditional Chinese and several other genres. He's a prolific Composer, music Arranger, and multi instrumentalist who tweaks his songs all the time. The show Singer 2018, (glittery outfit), was one where he competed against Jessie J. Never heard her so good. Brilliant production on those series.
Exactly, he takes risk and he knows well about music production, and he is actually an able singer, he just doesn’t care to follow everybody footsteps, he might not be my cup of tea, but I will go to his concert, its interesting to me.
Hua Hua is the whole package in the eyes of his fans. All l can say is that has an uniqueness l have never seen in any other artist. I cannot pinpoint what it is but he seems to have the right balance as an performer/singer/artist.
I m shocked that this coach couldn’t see how talented and special he is… he is not a technician, he s an artist and he knows what he s doing, and he has beautiful vocal and nice singing skill, I can tell that he enjoys experimenting different ways, not afraid … I think he has wow factor !!
I find her comments on Qi Tian puzzling by literally saying that Hua Hua won the audience with dramatic and theatrical performances and it's not about his vocal capability. These comments are out of place because Hua was not wilder and more dramatic in the Qi-Tian performance compared to "I Don't Care" at all. I don't understand where did that comment come from and why it seems to be such a big problem in Qi-Tian and yet it's not a problem anymore in "I Don't Care". When she commented on the bad "vocal technique" in Qi Tian she didn't explain why. When she said I Don't Care is his real voice, that's also baseless. These are all Hua Hua's real voices used in different songs according to the need for different expressions The debasement of the first song and the praise in the second is too dramatic. The songs were performed just 5 months apart and Hua Hua didn't change that much in his stage performance style or singing technique. His 2017 concert performance of Qi Tian is one of the best performances that's captive to most people. He also performed it on Singers 2018 EP1 without much change in technique and won first place among professional singers. I don't think this vocal coach has a good idea of what counts as artistic expression and what's not. Her comment on "real voice" sounds arbitrary. Overall, I rate this reaction very poor because what she said doesn't make sense.
Totally agree i don't understand why people like her comment that much i don't see any respect in here. Just go to his concert to watch and hear his real voice there are many fancam with any production too
I think he s quite established as an artist and as a singer. He has his own thinking about music production , he knows his audience and most of all, he s an able singer, maybe not the style some ppl prefer, I actually will go to his live concert!
Hua Chenyu has one song that sends shiver down my spine every time I listen to it and I would love that if you try it out. The song is called Child, where he sang it in the show Singer 2018
Co do samej reakcji Hua Chenyu mój punkt widzenia jest taki: Jak każda osoba tak i profesionalny trener wokalny ma swoje preferencje. Oddzielenie reakcji od określenia niektórych technik wokalnych piosenkarza wydaje się w porządku. Gdy jest opis techniki wokalnej nie widać by trener wokalny kierował się emocjami. Tak to powinno wyglądać. Jako osoba, która nie ma pojęcia co do wokalu nie wypowiem się czy szczera jest opinia techniki wokalnej Hua Chenyu. Jednak bazując trochę na analizach i reakcjach innych trenerów głosów a szczególnie polskich, to napiszę pare wniosków. Opieram się na reakcjach i analizach innych piosenkarzy a szczególnie polskich. Niestety, ale jakoś najwięcej znam ich wizerunki medialne, nawet bardziej niż największych celebrytów z USA co są celebrytami światowymi. Zauważyłam jak dla trenera głosu jest ważna kontrola i czystość śpiewu. Praktycznie najwięksi celebryci prawdopodobnie też do tego dążą. Nie mam nic przeciwko temu, jednak patrząc na swoje preferencje nie przeszkadzało mi u Hua Chenyu brak tejże kontroli. Pani Rozette wspomina też o postawie scenicznej. Mówiąc że prawdopodobnie HCY przetrenował wokal i bycie na scenie to więcej i autentyczniej pokazuje teraz siebie. Pozwala by więcej był dla publiczności i to też nie jest złe. Jednak osobiście ja tęsknie do tego Jego świata nawet jak jest teatralny. Nawet w takiej postawie musi być gdzieś autentyczność, bo artyzm długo nie przetrwa. Może to moje osobiste oceny, ale jakoś to wolałam niż niby te Jego obecną postawę sceniczną. Im bardziej nie było w tym kontroli tym bardziej było to dla mnie autentyczne i naturalne. Choć jak zazwyczaj mam specyficzny punkt odbioru. 😉 Tak jak w pierwszej części reakcji na Hua Chenyu pisałam - jakoś lubię artyzm tego muzyka i tyle.
She s more a technician not too much an artist… I appreciate the singer mentioned here, he takes risk and he has his own thinking on music and production, his music is not my cup of tea, but I find him very talented and very interesting !
He is not only a singer, he is a actor, mostly he is a artist. He said he is only a part of the whole presentation. He voice is only an instrument not more.
He believes that human vocal is also part of music, so he would use different kinds of ways to sing to perform the emotion and atmosphere in different songs. When he was in the singing competition, he always sang other people's songs which he could not 100% present his truly attitude and emotion, but now, he sings songs he wrote himself, and we could feel 100% of his attitude.
Hua Chenyu's music growth paralleled his personal growth quite a bit. He did learn more to communicate with the audience than he used to as he came from a very sheltered, deeply introverted place. I do believe the weirdness then is as much him as his later polished performances are, he just matured as a person and performer. His journey and relateability to his audience is a huge part of why he has so many fans. His shows are an experience, weirdness, "theatricality" and all. Aversions to male artists wearing flashy costumes and being dramatic on stage is kinda eh. We dont have many Freddie Mercury, Michael Jacksons, or Princes left in Western music industry cause of the bias against men doing that kind of thing. THe jab at the production is weird though, theres a whole band and backup singers behind him, Singer is a very big, popular prime time show like American Idol.
I always liken Hua Hua to Freddie Mercury, David Bowie, Axel Rose, Steven Tyler, Prince, George Michael, Matt Bellamy and even Elton John and Bruno Mars wrapped up in one person. He can jump from genre to genre, which really only Bowie was capable of doing so well. And he is a stunning Composer and Music Arranger as well as multi instrumentalist. But really, Hua Hua's strength is his ability to push boundaries and see no boundaries.
@@Tatooa2001 oui, Je suis un grande fan de Bowie et pour mou, Hua Hua est le nouveau Bowie. Rock, Ballads, Pop, SynthPop, Electronic, mais Hua Hua chante Reggae, Rap et Chinoise Traditional aussi.
If you want to check out his vocal and why we are drawn to Hua, check out Fake Monk from Singer 2018. You may have to screen block him for copyright. Also illusion and reality which there is no live released. Martians love Hua because he is so UNIQUE from other singers. Yes he is dramatic and theatrical but with a purpose and knowing the lyrics helps to understand why he performs like he does. He chooses not to be mainstream and tends to take more artistic approach. I get why some don't get him. But I dearly respect him as one of the most dynamic and versatile artist.
You can try "Mad House", "Quasimodo's Gift", "Bullfight", "Conversation with Martian Children" (written and sung with his fans, called Martians). These are some of my favorite songs. Also try "Cancer" - he expressed how terminal cancer feels, it's a one of a kind song, his mother died of cancer. Hua Hua is also an amazing songwriter and arranger. He does not write lyrics, as far as I know, but they are very important to him and are written to express the ideas and feelings of his songs.
Hua Chenyu has never ever positioned himself as a vocalist. And he doesn't sing to show his pretty voice. He creates music with his voice and all other arrangement elements.
I would say it's a bit late that you only get to know him now. We had been following him for more than 10years. You may go back to how he started with him on stage since 2013. Let's see if you will fall in love with him like what we are.
Hua Chenyu is a singer-songwriter. While his vocal skills may not be top-tier, you have to look at him from various aspects - his songwriting, composition, and the emotions he conveys. This goes far beyond being just a singer who can flawlessly interpret songs by others. With these qualities, Hua Chenyu will go further and do better.
If we are going to do another episode of Hua Chenyu, which songs would you recommend? Please make sure there is a live version on UA-cam.
Fake Monk (without a great production), Seven personalities, Madhouse, Bullfight.
7 personnalities from New Year Eve Gala
一定要幸福（声声不息）
Why do you think that somebody is interested in her reaction?
Hua Chenyu "Must be happy " from the show Infinity and beyond.
希望老師可以多出一點關於華晨宇的reaction，我也很想透過專業的觀點去看這個歌手。
看的角度不一样的，有人喜欢声乐能力强的，有的喜欢音乐性的，乐评人都是从自己审美去看，不是统一的。给这个所谓声乐老师看曾轶可等音乐人，可能会被评价得一无是处，但是他们的音乐人格很强
這老師專門評論唱功的，這種等級的唱功就別再看了吧
自己喜欢最重要 别跟风😂
@@-qe2ic 對呀, 這位老師太主觀了, 個人覺得對華晨宇一點都不公平。對老師極度失望
@@khss7a23 這位老師如果算主觀 那你應該只能聽對於華晨宇的稱讚了 🥺
我欣賞這位老師的直率真實，看過幾部她分析幾位不同歌手影片後，這種不做作的片最好多來些
我是覺得這位老師很誠實啦😂，而且人家後面也隨著華晨宇的成長而對他有了更好的評價不是嗎？（她後面都是笑著的欸，影片裡有一段是原本要暫停，但聽到華晨宇的歌聲後又不暫停了，同樣滿滿的笑容耶）評論區的人有看完嗎？😅😅
老師到後來感覺很喜歡，快要愛上的節奏😂
其实花花本身因为早期表演风格的关系，让他成为了非常有争议性的一位歌手，不得不说很多人只要看到他的名字出现在视频的标题，一定会想打开来看。
喜欢的人，希望是好的点评，不喜欢的人，希望是坏的点评。然而只要把坏的点评安排在视频前面的段落，必定会引起很多人留言。因为事实就是恶意留言是比较容易出现在具有争议性的人或是课题上。而这些留言恰恰可以提高视频的流量。这就是流量密码。
而我相信大多数不喜欢花花的人，他们对花花的印象还是停留在他前几年（老师所谓的“放纵”式）的表演当中。所以讨厌的还是一如既往的讨厌，却感受不出他这几年来的变化。
@@maumautickedtabby 就是有很多人只看自己想要看到的東西，把其他的都無視掉🫠🫠
雖然我也不能限制那些人的思想啦，但有的時候真的很希望他們能用點腦子，畢竟腦袋長在那裡也不是純用來裝飾的對吧🤣🤣
看到你用簡字害我突然想到，現在也一堆臺灣鍵盤俠在攻擊簡字是殘體字...... 真的無語了，說是異體字還差不多，很多的簡字也是從書法字體裡變化來的啊，沒文化不可怕，可怕的是沒文化還出來秀...... 😂
@@ling-ling-ling 哈哈哈，说到没文化还秀出来就让我想起，我听过有句话也挺适合键盘侠的 “不评论还没有人知道你无知”
@@maumautickedtabby 對啊，真的是自己沒救了還跑出來讓所有人知道...... 🤣🤣
这位老师的点评确实是真实而且有实力。
老師唱歌也太好聽
只用螢幕破喇叭沒插耳機 也能聽得我雞皮疙瘩立起來
真的會笑死 這個太真實了 笑死我了
這老師好厲害 我非常喜歡
因為老師也會為自己修音
The teacher liked his progress and acknowledged his musicality and skills. Glad you liked that 👌
雖然本來就很佩服
但現在回來看 這真的是十分真實的點評
我喜歡這種評論 就是以專業的角度去分析聲音 而不是現場人數跟個人魅力來區分
虽然是专业去分析，不过也是带自己主观的意识，上面她自己也说了，她不喜欢这样的，或者那样的，比如上面唱的那种假声。她喜欢真实的声音。不过有些人会喜欢带假声的。后面那首歌没有假声，她就很喜欢。
@@dorothyjones6881 因为华晨宇的假声确实技巧用得不太好。他的真声和混声高音倒是稳一些些。
老师想批评，但已经很委婉了、很客气了。我个人的声乐老师对华晨宇根本说不出太多好话。
@@kwoo24 我也听过一些东莞跟深圳的音乐老师觉得他的假声技巧很好。机能也好。各有所爱，也各有道理
常常要團隊協助來發展？真實唱起歌上來就常走音~沒有代表作的歌者比較難以接受🤔😬🙄
原来专业老师看起来 他的技巧那么差
老师的点评说到我心里去了，我一直对华晨宇也是认为的
喜歡這位老師的視頻，簡單的製作卻令人覺得簡單易懂，老師的表情及肢體語言讓人享受，評論到一些點也不會覺得過於冒犯，而是有種，對，我也覺得（剩下會自己去想使用腦補），後面放上老師的演唱視頻真的畫龍點睛，相當喜歡❤
喜歡老師的解說，尤其是需要自己腦補的那一塊😆而老師每回結尾的演唱，是完美的句點❤
每個人有不同的角度聽取音樂, 從聲樂的角度聽.很棒的點評.老師的演唱很真誠,很打動我的心.
在今天之前我從未聽過華晨宇的歌，是聽到過不少批評他的消息，說他奇怪的舞台表演及常嘶喊無人聽懂的歌⋯⋯今天我決定聽聽他的歌曲，在YouTou我只能聽到的是他在6年前的舞台演唱，聽完後我必須說「我挺喜歡的」，在國外有許多非常有天份的藝術家在表演上都很特異，有自己的獨特風格，我看不到華晨宇近幾年的歌唱表演不知道他的轉變有多大？ 他是一位屬於舞台歌唱表演者，我認為他的表演及演唱方式很前衛，因為前衛讓保守派的音樂者無法接受他的原因吧？ 如果你有聽過美國重型搖滾樂的歌唱，就不會覺得華晨宇的特立獨行的嘶吼演唱方式是難看的！如果我有機會去華晨宇的現場演唱會，我會很樂意，我會和聲樂老師一樣喜歡看他的舞台歌唱表演。
油管有华晨宇《向阳而生》日出版，13万人一起看日出的演唱会，非常震撼！
ua-cam.com/video/qAiDhmuwT2M/v-deo.htmlsi=mu6iYBI-eTXuIlu3
Thank you for this reaction, I was waiting for it since Part 1 )) It's a beautiful transformation indeed, and I think you're absolutely right about why HCY changed so dramatically into a great / honest / true artist.
感謝老師最後的演唱，舒服，好聽，美麗的歌聲，洗耳朵跟安撫心靈。
How interesting to see a singer grow throughout his career.
I extremely recommend CZ to listen to this singer's performance in the TV show: "Singer 2018"
哇靠最後老師唱歌無修音太厲害了
我都快被老師唱哭了，
好棒的歌聲。
我覺得原唱比較好聽也
@@pureloveangelica2907 那你就覺得啊 也三小
@@pureloveangelica2907已經很好聽了，怎麼可能拿來跟Beyonce比…基本上這首歌沒有人可以唱得比原唱好，就像領悟沒有人可以唱得比辛曉琪好，這是刻在血液裡的..😂
他红是两档综艺节目一天内现场写歌，歌曲题目是网络上观众投票的，改编，有的歌没有词只有一段旋律！因为写歌火的，粉丝黏度很高！老师好厉害啊！他自己说过他的发音不是正规的发音方式，他觉得这样适合他的歌！老师听几首就听出了！
連他的歌 綜藝節目裡合作了幾年的藝人名星同事 都說不出自稱‘’神‘’ 3首歌多的是
看到他能有這麼多人喜愛，還有唱功上有成長的時候，老師是很真誠的喜悅欸，太可愛了吧😆
他從來沒有唱功差吧、只是他選擇的唱法不大衆化！華很懂音樂而且有自己想法、比很多中國新一代歌手優秀。
@@recuerdos2457 差
拿中國來說 目前天花板我個人認為是周深
張傑 毛不易也比較有實力 華晨宇 額 不行 @@takamori382
the comments should based on the whole song I believe, as what we really enjoy is his ability to convey the emotion and thoughts
一開始老師被嚇到超好笑的！想說這種聲音怎麼會有十幾萬人去聽他唱歌～～～😂
你太誠實了
說這什麼大實話
老師中間跳過太多華晨宇的成長過程了
會被嚇到是正常的
但現在華晨宇確實值得十幾萬人去聽他唱歌
說真 早期的華還有點吸引我 但他的風格漸成後 我也get不到了
@@Wenwen-j8d 瞎掰什么
I personally think his major talent is in 'composing' the lyrics and music to express his 'feel', which is quite accurate and resonates a lot with his generation, like 'where do i find what I believe in' in 'monkey king'
No, wait, by "his generation", you meant " his fans"...
I'm in his generation, and I don't get his artistry, singing or music. Neither do my friends from the same age group.
@@kwoo24 you’re right, his fans or potential fans. Just curious, what type of songs do you like
Except from Hua Hua doesn't actually write THAT many of his own lyrics. He is a great composer though!
很明顯熱門評論前幾名都沒有看到第二段我管你的講評😂
我管你是華晨宇第二張專輯（2015）的歌，他從那時就是這樣表演了，當然參加歌手時他對舞台的掌控力更好也更鬆弛
第一段的齊天是演唱會，自然會有一些為了現場演出而設計製作效果，以及這首歌本來就是戲劇化的，他的聲音可以很多變
13:20 “ I believe him now. This feel real. “
確實，歸功於歌手節目的團隊設計，我覺得對華不太公平，因為他以前就是那樣表演的
最後影片那一段，老師的唱功，已經征服我了.....
OMG, what a demonstration in the end.
听了老师的解说，真的是让我深深感觉到内行看门道，外行看热闹😅
為老師最後的歌曲讚嘆👏👏👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
這是資本的力量 你看無論超級女聲 超級男聲 越新季度的前三名都不再注重於唱功 重點是歌頌形象 噱頭 流量 有了 背後的公司就會想辦法再補技術 再營銷包裝 與過往真正歌星以歌唱技術實力為基底的藝人概念完全不同了 可以說越近代的歌手越來越依靠形象 背景音樂的搭配 而不是只靠真實的人聲與珍貴的情感 一切都商業化了
He was so young it the other one and I think he came from a broken home and he used his music to work through that and he is a lot older here and has had a lot more experience. Most of his songs have two types of singing, soft and load. At his concerts some times his fans to sing the whole song with him.
這邊是聲樂老師評論的頻道，不是一味讚美的頻道，這位老師也就他的專業講評他喜歡、不喜歡(算得體的評論)、哪裡用到什麼技巧的地方；雖然評論還是有主觀意見，但我覺得他已經盡量中立了。
只是選片上，我覺得老師既然比較在意聲音本身、唱功、如何詮釋歌曲，應該多找歌手純唱而非娛樂性質偏高的影片講評，因為兩者目的一開始就不同。
影片是隨機的，所以也許多聽幾首就會聽到想聽的。
還有粉絲多推薦。
只是我在b站與油管上面普遍看到的歌手評價，花花是才華橫溢而不是以唱功聞名，Rozette老師是專門評價聲樂唱功的，似乎不適合花花。
但是我最佩服老師的一點就是她會努力去理解每一場表演每一位歌手❤❤❤
I love Hua Hua is not because his singing technique but his talent and performance in music. He has created and performed a lot of wonderful songs for us. Love it~🥰
me too❤
Same ❤
這個老師有問題，不小心看到，希望不要再跳出來
你可能对wonderful 有点什么误解
@@zhaojingyi2973 你可能对wonderful 有点什么误解
外國人講評真的客觀到讓我很信任老師很專業
這外國老師太棒了
老師稱讚花花開始會注意台下的觀眾與互動了 結果歌是我管你哈哈哈哈哈😂 很有趣的反差ㄢ
互動確實蠻好的啊，而且老師也稱讚了他的其他層面
这个不矛盾 台下多是年轻人 在我要你管这点上 是有共鸣的
我管你是比較早期的了.........近期的演唱才是亂尖叫亂吼的，老師搞反了
@@喵咪喵咪-o3w可以知道哪首歌吗
@@喵咪喵咪-o3w近期 哪些歌是亂吼亂叫呢？
Hua Chenyu n'a plus besoin de professeur de chant lui dictant la conduite a tenir il y a déjà bien longtemps . Il a toujours été un électron libre et le restera malgré les critiques qui n'ont en rien interférer dans sa brillante carrière. Il continue d'evoluer et d'innover encore plus haut encore plus fort n'en déplaise à certains .
So funny
他在国内就快糊了。当初王杰在某节目给他提出过建议，他不但不接受而且表现非常不满，才有后来王杰采访时说不知道华晨宇是谁。谢霆锋在某节目当他的导师时，在他唱王菲的一首歌后，给他提意见，建议他不要一味彪高音，他也表现出不满。现在确实只会彪高音和说唱了。
Well-said and I agree to a high degree. 👍👍
His fans tried to do an Intervention, because they felt his Management were making him perform too much and it was affecting his voice. Looking at this Reaction, highlights... "where did the Rap come from with Hua Hua". He grew up listening to Muse, Radiohead, Linkin Park etc.. ROCK. He has absorbed Rap, Reggae, Pop, SynthPop, Electronic, Accoustic, Ballads, Traditional Chinese and several other genres. He's a prolific Composer, music Arranger, and multi instrumentalist who tweaks his songs all the time. The show Singer 2018, (glittery outfit), was one where he competed against Jessie J. Never heard her so good. Brilliant production on those series.
老師實在太厲害了，一聽就知有沒有
【我管你】我到現在才知道是他唱的ww，我還蠻喜歡那首的，還有【好想愛這個世界啊】
That lady is way too technical. Huahua isn't the norm. That is why we like him.
Exactly, he takes risk and he knows well about music production, and he is actually an able singer, he just doesn’t care to follow everybody footsteps, he might not be my cup of tea, but I will go to his concert, its interesting to me.
差點被評論帶歪，老師也有稱讚和喜歡華晨宇表演的部分，也覺得他有進步和成長，不止是造型和燈光，也沒有說他華而不實。
我覺得可以聽聽看華的其他作品吧，也有很多溫暖人心的好歌。
每個人的表達方式不同，實在無法理解為什麼要對一個人抱有這麼大的惡意，還起了什麼綽號，不喜歡不要接觸就好，何必聽了之後又來嘲諷又來罵？保持基本的禮貌很困難嗎？把快樂建築在別人的難受上很爽快嗎？
我想他會被批評是因為他批評別人也很不留情。
@@evewu1 你所謂的批評別人不過也就是看他批評毛不易的片段吧 完整版節目華也有稱讚過毛很多次 他的風評就是被那些黑營銷號帶壞的！
@@evewu1 這我必須要說營銷號真的刻意帶風向，因為我當時有追節目，被斷章取義了
@@evewu1 華晨宇當時對毛毛的批評根本是被帶風向的好嗎
華晨宇說沒有期待過的是毛毛他寫的曲，並不是說他的歌曲都不行
有看完明日之子的應該都很清楚毛不易的作曲能力的確是不太行的，反倒是作詞方面特別有天賦
但華晨宇剛好反過來，華晨宇的作曲天賦是真的牛，作詞好像就一般所以都找人代寫
當時華晨宇作為導師本來就該對下面的學員做出指點，尤其已經好幾期了但毛不易的曲依舊沒甚麼特色
我印象中華晨宇後面有說如果不行可以找人寫曲，所以我認為這部分沒什麼爭議
本來毛不易當時的歌會紅就只是因為歌詞寫到人的心坎裡去，而在他紅了以後消愁這首歌也被重新製作了出來，重新編曲後可以發現前後的質量真的差很多
@@evewu1 如果是對毛不易的話那你被帶歪了 完整的節目甚至華晨宇還保了毛不易 還有一個節目是毛雪旺 裡面毛不易自己也說了跟華晨宇是很好的兄弟
Hua Hua is the whole package in the eyes of his fans. All l can say is that has an uniqueness l have never seen in any other artist. I cannot pinpoint what it is but he seems to have the right balance as an performer/singer/artist.
I m shocked that this coach couldn’t see how talented and special he is… he is not a technician, he s an artist and he knows what he s doing, and he has beautiful vocal and nice singing skill, I can tell that he enjoys experimenting different ways, not afraid … I think he has wow factor !!
Hua Chenyu is very addictive.
应该评一期《假行僧》，有张宇的原唱，也有华晨宇的版本，还有谭维维的版本，这个老师都听过的。
I find her comments on Qi Tian puzzling by literally saying that Hua Hua won the audience with dramatic and theatrical performances and it's not about his vocal capability. These comments are out of place because Hua was not wilder and more dramatic in the Qi-Tian performance compared to "I Don't Care" at all. I don't understand where did that comment come from and why it seems to be such a big problem in Qi-Tian and yet it's not a problem anymore in "I Don't Care".
When she commented on the bad "vocal technique" in Qi Tian she didn't explain why. When she said I Don't Care is his real voice, that's also baseless. These are all Hua Hua's real voices used in different songs according to the need for different expressions
The debasement of the first song and the praise in the second is too dramatic. The songs were performed just 5 months apart and Hua Hua didn't change that much in his stage performance style or singing technique. His 2017 concert performance of Qi Tian is one of the best performances that's captive to most people. He also performed it on Singers 2018 EP1 without much change in technique and won first place among professional singers. I don't think this vocal coach has a good idea of what counts as artistic expression and what's not. Her comment on "real voice" sounds arbitrary.
Overall, I rate this reaction very poor because what she said doesn't make sense.
教練評論算是中肯，齊天這首曲子，唱的好的版本只有兩個，一個是MV，一個是2018歌手
演唱會版本要連續唱太多曲子，每一首編曲都有修改，不會是100%的演出...
agree
Totally agree i don't understand why people like her comment that much i don't see any respect in here. Just go to his concert to watch and hear his real voice there are many fancam with any production too
一開口就道破了，老師厲害。
I think he s quite established as an artist and as a singer. He has his own thinking about music production , he knows his audience and most of all, he s an able singer, maybe not the style some ppl prefer, I actually will go to his live concert!
非常喜歡後段的演唱！
老師一聽就知道有修過音，厲害😂
听得出edit的痕迹，因为那个音的边缘的jump很不自然
Hua Chenyu has one song that sends shiver down my spine every time I listen to it and I would love that if you try it out. The song is called Child, where he sang it in the show Singer 2018
Co do samej reakcji Hua Chenyu mój punkt widzenia jest taki:
Jak każda osoba tak i profesionalny trener wokalny ma swoje preferencje. Oddzielenie reakcji od określenia niektórych technik wokalnych piosenkarza wydaje się w porządku. Gdy jest opis techniki wokalnej nie widać by trener wokalny kierował się emocjami. Tak to powinno wyglądać. Jako osoba, która nie ma pojęcia co do wokalu nie wypowiem się czy szczera jest opinia techniki wokalnej Hua Chenyu. Jednak bazując trochę na analizach i reakcjach innych trenerów głosów a szczególnie polskich, to napiszę pare wniosków. Opieram się na reakcjach i analizach innych piosenkarzy a szczególnie polskich. Niestety, ale jakoś najwięcej znam ich wizerunki medialne, nawet bardziej niż największych celebrytów z USA co są celebrytami światowymi. Zauważyłam jak dla trenera głosu jest ważna kontrola i czystość śpiewu. Praktycznie najwięksi celebryci prawdopodobnie też do tego dążą. Nie mam nic przeciwko temu, jednak patrząc na swoje preferencje nie przeszkadzało mi u Hua Chenyu brak tejże kontroli. Pani Rozette wspomina też o postawie scenicznej. Mówiąc że prawdopodobnie HCY przetrenował wokal i bycie na scenie to więcej i autentyczniej pokazuje teraz siebie. Pozwala by więcej był dla publiczności i to też nie jest złe. Jednak osobiście ja tęsknie do tego Jego świata nawet jak jest teatralny. Nawet w takiej postawie musi być gdzieś autentyczność, bo artyzm długo nie przetrwa. Może to moje osobiste oceny, ale jakoś to wolałam niż niby te Jego obecną postawę sceniczną. Im bardziej nie było w tym kontroli tym bardziej było to dla mnie autentyczne i naturalne. Choć jak zazwyczaj mam specyficzny punkt odbioru. 😉 Tak jak w pierwszej części reakcji na Hua Chenyu pisałam - jakoś lubię artyzm tego muzyka i tyle.
💕
I loved your comment 🥰🥰
Art will be art. You feel it you don’t judge it. Thank you for the professionalism however
totally agree with u
Thank you for this reaction. ❤ Love Hua Hua ❤❤❤
期待能看老師出華晨宇「孩子」歌手2020版本的Reaction🥹🙏🏻🙏🏻
This is the most objective and professional review that I have ever read
😮看了好幾部解說，老師的講評是我聽過最一針見血又是最淺顯易懂的。而且在技巧、情感、舞台、觀眾、資本，各方各面都給出了最平衡的講解。比好多歌唱節目的評審都更有點評的專業。
(但私心還是認為華更多還是靠資本堆出來的。😂)
👍 agree
可圈可點的一句：
多謝龐大的制作團隊
😅😅😅😅
拿了一堆資源就這樣，看來本身也不是塊料
可能你沒感受到他的魅力，不能理解為什麼這麼多人喜歡他，這是很正常的
但不代表他的成名完全靠資本堆出來
至少對當初喜歡上他的我來說，他周圍的資本對我來說一點都不重要，吸引我的是他的音樂表現能力、現場表演的舞台魅力，就這樣熱情的甩在我面前，震撼著我
在我最低潮，每天過著行屍走肉的生活時，是他的音樂、他堅定的態度，把我從無限的黑暗穩穩的托住、把我拉出來
我一點都不覺得他需要靠什麼資本才能走紅
每個粉絲都是靠他一點一滴的努力，一首一首唱出來的
@@Wenwen-j8d 有沒有一種可能只是你的品味比較差罷了
Coach Rozette, your ‘listen’ is so great!
Very meaningful comments, Mentor Rozette. You are respectable.
In other words, her opinions match yours.
She s more a technician not too much an artist… I appreciate the singer mentioned here, he takes risk and he has his own thinking on music and production, his music is not my cup of tea, but I find him very talented and very interesting !
He is not only a singer, he is a actor, mostly he is a artist. He said he is only a part of the whole presentation. He voice is only an instrument not more.
He believes that human vocal is also part of music, so he would use different kinds of ways to sing to perform the emotion and atmosphere in different songs. When he was in the singing competition, he always sang other people's songs which he could not 100% present his truly attitude and emotion, but now, he sings songs he wrote himself, and we could feel 100% of his attitude.
That’s why he needs auto tune and other production effects on stages😅
Hua Chenyu's music growth paralleled his personal growth quite a bit. He did learn more to communicate with the audience than he used to as he came from a very sheltered, deeply introverted place. I do believe the weirdness then is as much him as his later polished performances are, he just matured as a person and performer. His journey and relateability to his audience is a huge part of why he has so many fans. His shows are an experience, weirdness, "theatricality" and all. Aversions to male artists wearing flashy costumes and being dramatic on stage is kinda eh. We dont have many Freddie Mercury, Michael Jacksons, or Princes left in Western music industry cause of the bias against men doing that kind of thing.
THe jab at the production is weird though, theres a whole band and backup singers behind him, Singer is a very big, popular prime time show like American Idol.
I always liken Hua Hua to Freddie Mercury, David Bowie, Axel Rose, Steven Tyler, Prince, George Michael, Matt Bellamy and even Elton John and Bruno Mars wrapped up in one person. He can jump from genre to genre, which really only Bowie was capable of doing so well. And he is a stunning Composer and Music Arranger as well as multi instrumentalist. But really, Hua Hua's strength is his ability to push boundaries and see no boundaries.
C'est très juste. Je suis une grande fan de Bowie, voilà pourquoi j'adore aussi Hua Chenyu.
@@Tatooa2001 oui, Je suis un grande fan de Bowie et pour mou, Hua Hua est le nouveau Bowie. Rock, Ballads, Pop, SynthPop, Electronic, mais Hua Hua chante Reggae, Rap et Chinoise Traditional aussi.
very true，and that's what i truly feel about him，as a fan，about how his work “parallel” to his life❤
哈哈哈老師好可愛說可以說有特效嗎我不想得罪他，但後製把字幕都打上去了😂😂
沒看過花花以前的，原來以前他這麼好笑喔😂
現在還是很好笑,一直都是
He is a genius musician. You like to hear yourself.
最後片尾太猛了👍
老師最後的演唱真是太動人了
老師好厲害，一聽就知他修音
华晨宇的唱功我欣赏不来，他更多是用音乐以外的因素来吸引人的注意力，可能有人喜欢，但就我而言，确实没法吸引住我。
那就去聽其他人唱歌啊，為什麼一定要發表相對惡意的發言呢，不喜歡幹嘛還要一直看一直嫌🤔他的作曲就是可以帶給我釋放 給我希望，他在舞台上的放縱表演就可以讓我覺得我也在其身與他同樂。喜歡可以大力的喜歡他，不喜歡就走啊，沒人逼你去吃你不喜歡的東西
還有妳說的不叫其他因素，歌手不是只要唱歌，就在我眼裡作為一個歌手他的唱功也就a＋這樣吧，但是喜歡一個歌手要看的也不只是唱功啊，她確實會作曲她確實很有舞台表現力而且他也確實願意去做很多國內唱功比他好的人嘗試更多元素更多風格帶給觀眾更豐富的享受，而不是只有在自己的舒適圈發瘋
@@賴以宸-v2s 他就表达了一下自己的看法，咋就变恶意了？这很中肯啊。没骂人没说什么，别代入啊。这又不是粉丝见面会，只有喜欢才能表达欣赏不来就不让说？这粉丝群体有点恶劣啊。
就是感覺不自然，不舒適
A+?
頂多b+吧
只能說製作單位的包裝太好了...
THAT culture created THAT kind of musical productions. Leave them inside.
很喜歡這位老師實話實說，雖然她已經打很多預防針但粉絲還是崩潰了...很希望老師能一直說真話，在這個音樂工廠的時代，很希望我能早日培養出能鑑定是不是修音的能力，就像平常培養媒體識讀的能力一樣，不管對修音這件事看法如何，至少能識別出來是非常非常重要的
就像我很喜歡LALA，但如果哪天老師reaction說lala舞台用了很多修音，我也不會因此而攻擊老師，反而要感謝老師能幫我拿掉粉絲濾鏡，我也懂很多時候並不是歌手能力不足而修音，只是音樂工廠的需求而被迫去開，所以花粉真的不要這麼容易被冒犯...
你哪里看到花粉‘这么容易被冒犯’了？单是评论不难发觉是很多黑粉看了片头就自嗨的多吧🙂老师评论礼貌真实，可是不影响我喜欢花花演绎的方式 ❣
@@shirleywong9051 在YT比較少，其他地方非常多，也有攻擊老師比賽經歷的
@@Sandy-kg5eo 1.我觉得这位老师的喜好有着中西文化的差异 2.老师的评语是基于技术层面，可是艺术除了技术之外，呈现方式，背景，经历等等都是引起共鸣和喜爱的因素，就像老师唱的很完美可是却完全吸引不了我，像AI无法共鸣 3.老师不是以唱歌吸引粉丝，她需要这种流量😌我也是因为她评论杨丞琳才知道她的
我要表达的是老师有着专业的唱歌技巧，却同时也因为花花是个具争议性的歌手，拥有着大量的粉丝和黑粉，所以她才会第一集就评他，她才不介意粉丝玻璃心，老师要的是流量
@@shirleywong9051 你說的這些我當然知道啊...不然我為什麼會說Lala或許不是老師會喜歡的類型
所以你到底要跟我表達什麼呢？
在专业音乐老师面前，华晨宇原型毕露，演唱更多的是演，与真正的唱功越来越远了。
听了老师最后的演唱发现，她是真正的在演绎歌曲，而不是表现自己。不知道怎么说，就是从老师演唱中有这个感受。感觉很多歌手都是在为了表现自己的声音而歌唱，而不是把歌曲透过歌声演绎出来。所以现在的“实力”歌手真的很少了。
If you want to check out his vocal and why we are drawn to Hua, check out Fake Monk from Singer 2018. You may have to screen block him for copyright. Also illusion and reality which there is no live released.
Martians love Hua because he is so UNIQUE from other singers. Yes he is dramatic and theatrical but with a purpose and knowing the lyrics helps to understand why he performs like he does. He chooses not to be mainstream and tends to take more artistic approach. I get why some don't get him. But I dearly respect him as one of the most dynamic and versatile artist.
Yes! Illusion and Reality! I think a concert version of it is on UA-cam now.
+1❤
Thank You for reaction! Hua Hua is my favorite composer-singer-performer. His songs touch deeply my soul. He is a great artist.
+1
Me too
You can try "Mad House", "Quasimodo's Gift", "Bullfight", "Conversation with Martian Children" (written and sung with his fans, called Martians). These are some of my favorite songs. Also try "Cancer" - he expressed how terminal cancer feels, it's a one of a kind song, his mother died of cancer.
Hua Hua is also an amazing songwriter and arranger. He does not write lyrics, as far as I know, but they are very important to him and are written to express the ideas and feelings of his songs.
喜歡老師的評論，真誠又專業，好好看😻，讓我們在聽音樂時多了一份鑑賞的樂趣，謝謝製作團隊跟老師。
喜歡華晨宇的表演，雖然是外行人但也聽得出他並不是以唱功出名的（如：陳奕迅、張學友），但不得不說他在音樂編排跟表演上很有才華。
Hua Chenyu has never ever positioned himself as a vocalist. And he doesn't sing to show his pretty voice. He creates music with his voice and all other arrangement elements.
@@venpin1846 沒必要人身攻擊吧
重點是他自稱永遠的神～ 😅
@@chenronan果然這是他挨駡的重點。在自己的演唱會附和歌迷的吹捧，我實在無法認同大眾因此這麽用力批評他。你該怪的是把這些惹惱你的事傳到你面前的人，畢竟華也沒想到討厭他的人會看到那些。
我對華毫無興趣，即使這樣大數據仍然推給我數十次批評華的影片，比起討厭華，我更討厭自以為可以批評他的營銷號。
不用那么低调，花花唱功不好，怎么能在2018年歌手力压汪峰、张绍涵拿下第二名的？
I would say it's a bit late that you only get to know him now. We had been following him for more than 10years. You may go back to how he started with him on stage since 2013. Let's see if you will fall in love with him like what we are.
我愛的花花❤🙂
女王陛下後面的listen 唱得好棒
老師評價中肯，所以很愛聽她說真話，中國現在就是沒有人敢說真心話，假話謊言太多，進步被拖慢了
WOW，這老師太厲害👍🏻
華晨宇就是個流量吹捧出來的名不副其實的藝人。老師雖然批評得很保守了，但是還是能聽得出來就是說他唱功不到其位，喜歡搞浮誇式的表演、飆高音，甚至都說現場修過音（大量製作），還是有一堆腦殘粉在吹捧。不過，就如同老師說的，反正有這麼多人買單，他達到目的就好。有人就喜歡吃味精，你能說什麼？
就像很多人喜歡Uncle Roger 的MSG....XDD
唱得太好了，讚！
每次看到這種留言我都不知道要說什麼，我都覺得用唱功來去評價他他絕對也不是最頂的那個，但他在華語音樂上從音樂編排到製作表現，都是跟現在市面上的東西是不是一樣的，都過了這麼久，一堆人都還是只想聽到周杰倫那種典型的華語音樂編排，真的都過多久了，審美能不能進步一下啊？
那種大家想聽到的歌，整個編曲公式化到不行，難怪整天都會被說又抄襲誰，根本不是抄不抄襲，整個編曲風格就定死在哪，不像都難，現在有人做了一些不一樣的東西出現，被說浮誇鬼叫亂吼，並不是說一定要喜歡他，是審美的彈性以及對音樂的標準就是還停留在20年前，難怪華語音樂不會進步，大家根本不想聽到新的東西
@@YJ-sl5qz 這種趨勢有一種"就算我爛我沒天份,我只要有流量就夠了"這是退步,因為沒實力的人只要包裝就能當明星,讓年輕屁孩出現一種"或許我也能跟他一樣的錯覺",讓他粉絲覺得好親民,但我真的覺得他德不配位,包裝得有夠噁心,跟當初無液煩一樣的感覺
He my favorite artist of all time. There is just something special about him to me, I'm transfixed watching and listening to him and his music.
老師的listen 指路：15:18 😍😍😍
Hua Chenyu is a singer-songwriter. While his vocal skills may not be top-tier, you have to look at him from various aspects - his songwriting, composition, and the emotions he conveys. This goes far beyond being just a singer who can flawlessly interpret songs by others. With these qualities, Hua Chenyu will go further and do better.
And Singer-songwriters are more popular, not just in China but around the world. This is why he has so many fans in China.
好厲害，直接聽出聲音修的，哈....
I wish you good luck in your career as a cover singer.
Lol ya good luck to her.
希望大家都看到最後，老師看到最後很震驚很讚美他，他成長了許多，不要再把他之前的音樂拿出來比較了
我從頭到尾都是聽他講的英文，怎麼理解不太一樣？
其實我管你才是他以前的音樂吧，我是喜歡異類時候的他，現在就......
老師的聲音❤感動，so touching
2017 2018 的呀 现在都2023年了
沒看老師的yt我第一次聽華晨語的歌，過然不是我能理解的歌，老師片尾曲，天跟地
讚給後面的listen🥰
I’m here to listen to the Listen🦻Beautiful voice and stunning performance coach Rozette 🎶
感觉大家评论冲着第一首歌曲。 要看完两首！ （老师是满意笑着看完第二首的！ ）
開頭老師又嚇到了加上最後一首連三嚇了
我的赞是给最后老师的《listen》的👍
对，赞同！ 老师的Listen好好听～～
個人認為不管是「不真實」還是「真實」
都是他個人選擇演藝呈現每首歌不同的方式，而不是進化或者改變（？）
也就是他今天覺得這首歌應該做作
他還是會做作的去表演
該真實還是真實的模式
我是覺得他自己能做到切自如的選擇
而不是一種成長
因為真的不覺得華晨宇做不到這點
只是老師可能更喜歡他用真實的模式去唱歌？
不過以上是針對對於齊天與我管你甚至是煙火裡的塵埃這個時期的他啦
He always the best for me, love him so much❤the only Chinese singer I💖 in my pass 50yrs
Interesting video. Can’t wait to see more reaction of him😊
综艺后期修音太严重了，华低音容易走音，高音紧，不够释放，假音共鸣位置不对