Test of the Apprentice: What if Ahsoka had talked with Anakin during Revenge of the Sith?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
- www.artstation...
/ caseysdigifist
Check out my second channel devoted to games, collecting and so on at: / @thorskywalkerplus
Send your art work or whatever to me at: thor_mailbag@aol.com
Enjoy my videos? Consider supporting me on Patreon and gain access to my Discord Server where we're always talking some Star Wars: / thor_skywalker
Or follow me on twitter @Tell_Kanjiklub
All my polls can also be found at the following link: / @thorskywalker
Please respond to this comment to nominate and/or vote for the “What if Scenario” we should do next.
What if I never left the order
What if Padme raised Leia and Luke
What if Qui Gon trained me
What if Fives hadn't gone to kamino with Tup?
What if Anakin and Padme didn't fall in love?
Why does everyone that truly loves Star Wars can write such a compelling scenarios yet a multimillion dollar company that literally can hire anyone of those doesn't...
I'm pretty sure creative people do apply for the job, they just don't get hired, or if they do, it's some lower end position that they have no interest in. Or, the really creative people have a massive distaste for Disney and big corporations that they prefer their ideas to stay with them. Disney will also hire only those that they can buy, bully and control too. I'm sure there are an ample of other reasons why disney lacks creative writers, but those are some that I can come up with atm.
Because the multibillion dollar company hired activists, not storytellers.
I think we can look forward to more Jon and Dave
Because Disney would rather spread a political message than making good stories and profit
@@BahamutZero09 yep, you are right. It seems like they don't even care about making $.
"Maybe Luke will become a jedi, like his father before him."
Damn, such a beautiful ending to a great 18 minute story.
And then....."somehow, palpatine returned."
@@malcolmjenkins3585 Dark science, cloning
secrets only the Sith knew
@@DarthVader-gq4ks kaminoans: you know, I am something of a sith lord myself
@@malcolmjenkins3585 ssshhhhhhhhh the sequels don't exist here. We're all safe here.
@@malcolmjenkins3585 There is no sequel trilogy in Ba Sing Se.
Dude, I actually got emotional with that! Just imagining Anakin Cradling a dying Ahsoka... I genuinely almost teared up
wdym almost? I got fully formed tears
Same! And I got chills when Ahsoka came into the room to help Anakin
It was sad idea. Wish a different idea had won.
@@GENGHISKHAN-hk3qs sad but intresting to think about. things that are sad shouldn't be not talked about
@@br0ardsw0rd97 agreed. Except in certain situations.
"Please don't flame me for killing off Ahsoka" Are you kidding me? Having her find out that Palpatine was the sith lord grooming Anakin, and exposing him to Anakin so that he could find out for himself, and then helping him take Palpatine down but at the cost of her life? That's absolutely the most badass way for her to die!
Anakin anointing her a Knight before her final breath just adds a bittersweetness that is so powerful it couldn't be any other way.
For all Anakin's recklessness, he was never willing to sacrifice everything. When he sees Luke is not only willing to die, but die for him, this touches Anakin's heart, awakens him and redeems him.
He was willing to sacrifice everything. That's one of the points of his character and his fatal flaws. He would have killed half the galaxy if it meant saving Padme. Nothing else mattered to him. Luke was the only person who could redeem him, if anyone else had done the same thing they'd get roasted by Palpatine. Half the reason was due to him being his son.
I actually think killing off ahsoka was the most accurate way of having that what if happen.
Man... I feel like Ahsoka could’ve been the only one to actually “save” him, if she discovered the real plot at hand. Their relationship was most pure. He had no romantic feelings for her, to cloud his judgment. He did not feel betrayed by her, like he did with Obi-Wan. He did not feel any obligation to keep her alive for anything she could do for him, like Palpatine. If there would’ve been ANYONE, it would’ve been her...
actually he did feel like ahsoka had abandoned him after she left the jedi.. however... to counter that is a living breathing reminder that he already once saved someone from death
@@MBoeltje41 True, but Ahsoka’s betrayal was more understood by Anakin. He had felt that Obi-Wan had gone behind his back, whereas Ahsoka had done something she felt to be right… which Anakin had admitted he understood and even greatly sympathized with.
@@MBoeltje41 He didn’t blame Ahsoka for leaving, he blamed the Jedi Council.
@@MBoeltje41 I think he blamed the Order for that more then Ahsoka
Lol no. Ahsoka wouldn't be able to save Anakin unless she offered a way to save padme which she couldn't. So he would still turned because he would do anything to save padme
Wow, dude. That ending scene with Ahsoka was perfectly orchestrated! While I would have much rather preferred a fanfic dedicated to Ahsoka confronting Anakin on Mustafar, I think you did really well with this story.
Thanks, and know that you mention it, Ahsoka finally catching up with Anakin/Vader on Mustafar could've made for a fantastic story as well. Honestly hadn't thought of that.
I think it would have been to late at that point. Who knows.
@@thorskywalker Obi-Wan and Ahsoka team up fan fic coming next?🤔
@@apologeticcanadian542 till obi-wan give up on anakin/vader
Dude that is a sad yet happy ending for a what if scenario. This is now my favorite video on your Channel
Absolutely love this "light side version" ending to ROTS. Ahsoka has always been the key, just like she is now in this alternate timeline in the mandalorian/filoniverse where Luke takes Grogu as his apprentice years before beginning to train Ben.
Yeah, so Luke would have experience training a padawan prior to training Ben which would allow him to train Ben properly, I guess that’ll lead to Filoni and Jon creating their own version of the sequel trilogy which would be fantastic
He probably wouldn’t feel as alone and isolated as he did which may help him to give into Palpatine’s offer.
Except, that isolation was part of Palpatine's plans. That's why Obiwan was sent to deal with Greivous.
I'm sure he would have found a way to keep Ashoka and Anakin apart, at least until he had a full hold on him.
@@stryletz Debatable lot of Palpatine´s plan depended on ability to see future. Ahsoka being with Anakin would definetly put a problem in his plans. Granted it would depended what exactly woul happened. Have Ahsoka for example went to Coruscant instead of Obi-Wan Dooku would probably kille her thus making Anakin´s fall to the darkside much quicker. However at the same time he could definetly be pissed on Palpatine after that enough to try to kill him. Remember he almost kill him in the office when he find out he is lord Sidious. He hold himself because he needed Palpatine for Padme, however if Palpatine would be directly responsible for Ahsoka´s death Anakin may have ignored it and given to his rage to kill him.
Ah, nostalgia. I missed him saying “and that is how this story ends”.
"He's not alone" DUDE I actually got chills at that moment, I can feel the tears forming
"Perfect answer. I am so proud of you right now. I’ve never had a UA-camr learn this quickly.”
True.
Her chance was small and she missed that window. Clone Wars and Rebels did a good job of showing how she missed her chance to save him and only Luke could save him.
she confronted him, rather than tried saving him
@@echo6501 well yeah but it didn’t work that’s the point
Holy crap. I cried for Ahsoka when Anakin made her a Jedi.
True Jedi ‘Night’
@@danachavey9063 Thats incredible.
It would have only been symbolic and matter to her (which is I suppose the point of it) as though he is on the council, he can't technically knight anyone since he isn't a Jedi Master himself. In this situation he and Ahsoka lose anyway imo, as they can't hold a candle to Sidious as swordsmen.
Ahsoka has two lightsabers. Everyone knows that's Palpatine's only weakness!
@@spinosauruskin because Maul did not have plot armour
@@rjofusetsudzin8011 palpatine also had 2 lightsabers at that fight that was why he winned
What if: Obi Wan believed Dooku on Geonosis and joined him to defeat Sidious.
That's genius.
ROTS really is a masterpiece. Its that kinda movie that gives you goosebumps when you're just sitting there and simply thinking about it.
Masterpiece? I mean it's a good movie but wouldn't call it a Masterpiece.
Order 66 doesn’t happen and Anakin lives happily ever after. Yay right guys? everything is great
The republic: is in debt, the chancellor got killed by a Jedi, there are still Palpatine loyalists the separatists are still around and the people still hate the Jedi
You..... Have a point.
And a very good one
I think that Anakin would still leave but the Jedi would decline in power and the republic would limp on. The coming decades would be one of conciliation and smaller conflicts and eventually the jedi would distance themselves from the conflicts due to the old guard jedi like Windu stepping down from the council. And a significantly smaller jedi order
The Chancellor was evil so replacing him would not be hard, if the republic investigates Palps more they should find the CIS off switch at some point, and the Jedi would have to rebuild their rep but stopping a crazy guy from killing everyone def does help in the PR department.
I personally don't think there is anything Ahsoka could have said or done to save Anakin (he was already too far gone in his fear of losing Padme), but this is literally the best and only scenario I've heard so far where I could actually see it happening. Very well thought out video.
Rey: you could have just force healed her anakin smh
Written and directed by
Jar Jar abrams
Not so easy without being a part of a Dyad you ignorant Jedi
@@splashnskillz37 so the snake was a part of the dyad as well?
@@jkay_9449 no but being part of Dyad which is "a power like life itself" makes easier for such being to be able to heal others with the force
@@splashnskillz37 anakin is literally born of the force. Not only that he is the only one who could control both the son of Mortis and the daughter. Pretty sure he was more powerful. The dyad thing was poorly explained to just justify their power boost
if she made it back to talk to anakin i honestly believe that’s exactly how it would go good job man
Surely I can't be the only who one who almost teared up a couple times watching this, right?
The logo looks badass
Agreed.
Depending on the time she had talked with Anakin, she could have stopped him from turning to the dark side, or even maybe brought him back to the light side of the force.
I disagree it isn't shown in the clone wars show very well but you underestimate how deep the connection palpatine has with anakin
Thor, why are you breaking my heart like this? Ahsoka dying a Warrior's death to save Anakin from his fall to the Dark Side (and defeating Palps in the process) is a great alt story :-)
At the risk of having some disney higher up trash call me a snowflake I will freely admit that this brought a few tears to my eyes. Of course knowing the wreckage and ruin that was prevented by Ashoka's sacrifice in your narrative was a good deal of that emotion. I don't think even Ashoka would consider this a bad ending. Your "fan service" is a far better Star Wars story than anything we've gotten between Rogue One and The Mandalorian. Thank-you.
This is literally the first fan fiction to literally ever make me cry. It’s amazing to think that these characters have been so fleshed out so well that one could make a prediction like this.
Damn. I cried when you killed Ahsoka, but it fit perfectly. Their bond would have been the one to save him and in your version it definitely did. Great job my dude! ✌🏼
During that final moment between Anakin and Obi-Wan, I was playing the "Vader's death" theme in my head. It takes on a whole new meaning in this scenario.
This story was suprisingly put together. I could totally see this happening in some alternate reality
My favorite "what if" story in SW. Simple, good hearted, and not requiring you to read all the EU and cannon novels to understand.
Geez. I was not expecting this video to make me feel as much emotion as it did!
Holy hell, just imagining that scenario play out had me in tears that would have been an amazing end!
Wow, what a beautiful story! I almost cried with you just telling it. As a full movie, that would have been even more emotional! I loved the part where Anakin knighted Ahsoka and where Obi-Wan said he would ignore Anakin keeping his lightsaber.
That was wonderful storytelling. Nicely done, Thor.
Brilliant, Thor, congratulations on crafting this excellent story ... Like many that commented and watched, tears almost came to my eyes from Ahsoka's sacrifice to Anakin leaving.... Just brilliant.
I am a MASSIVE Ahsoka fan, she is MY FAVORITE character, my BIAS if you will.
But I think people tend to give her too much credit, simply because of who her master was. Yes, she survived a duel against Darth Vader, but let's be real. If Ezra hadn't pulled her back, she would have been decapitated. She was never WINNING that fight-she was just barely holding her own. If she had stayed, she would've been UNDOUBTEDLY slaughtered along with the other Jedi. And not even counting that in the picture, but Ahsoka knew Anakin better than anyone-even maybe himself. She wouldn't be able to change his mind. Once Anakin's mind was made up, there's no convincing the Skywalker otherwise. Darth Vader that's another story though heehee.
Plus Ahsoka was a part of his past. Luke had that advantage of being a bit separate. Anakin/Vader wouldn't accept someone like Ahsoka to be able to bring him back to the light.
Also agree, Ahsoka is often overrated just because she's Anakin's padawan. Even without that I think she's often overrated. No way she would've won that duel against Vader.
If she went to mustafar, she may have been able to talk Anakin into leaving with Padme into hiding, but of course there would never be a going back for him.
@@yrsruby5396 exacto. Ahsoka cracked Vader's visage and Luke was able to break it completely. But Ahsoka on her own wouldn't be able to bring him back.
I'm also a massive Ahsoka fan and I gotta say, I agree Sith everything you just said. Lowkey, she should've died in Rebels and stayed dead. Bring her back was cheap and unnecessary, but at the end of the day I'm glad she's alive and I'm looking forward to more stories with her.
Yeah in Thor's situation with the fight, Ahsoka dies no matter what; and imo, so does Anakin, neither are anywhere near Sidious as swordsmen. Vader wasn't getting the better of her really though on Malachor, and was only going to deliver a killing blow due to her sacrificing herself to save him. Thats my take on that fight anyway.
To be honest I really enjoyed your Sunday commentary. It was different than the other Star Wars channels I listen to and it gives me a chance to listen to a rational person talk about how society effects Star Wars
I'm not done with them forever, and I'll certainly still do them when the right topic comes up (or when an idea for one comes to me)... But I really just wanted to refocus a bit and get back to what I started out doing.
@@thorskywalker can still contact anakin through the force, not like a force ghost but like Kanan though like a avatar or whatever it's called.
Ahsoka: Exists in a what if video
Thor Skywalker: "So you have chosen death"
Great video, loved it!
Man, this was really emotional. Congratulations for making me cry a bit Thor
I almost tearred up with that ending with mentioning Luke
Damn I actually felt emotion, well done Thor
I almost cried with the knighting scene. Also, that little ending with Anakin and Obi-Wan gives such a nice wrap to the story. A great what-if scenario!
Beautiful man, l was really moved by the story, feeling light side Anakin's grief and our own for Ahsoka brought down tears to my eyes, thank you !
My every hair was standing as you spoke of Anakin's confrontation with Sidious.
If only Anakin in this scenario knew Force Healing like Rey did.
This is canon, I have spoken.
I loved that end scene with Anakin and Obi-Wan parting ways as brother
Thank you so much for this wonderful story. It reminds me why we all love Star Wars so much. It was poetry.
Frick you Thor, I wasn't trying to cry today 😭
THANK YOU for coming back to this type of videos! You and SWT are the main two channels along with some online fan fictions I’ve read for many years, that inspired me to make my own channel. Please keep ‘em coming!
Last time I was this early, I was a youngling facing down Vader
Then how are you here bud?^^
I loved how you crafted that story. Ahsoka dying wouldn't be my preference but it was the logical step. Also liked that the story is open-ended, that Luke and/or Leia might become Jedi
That was really great and I could see all of that taking place if Ahsoka had spoken to Anakin. Excellent work.
I’m an emotional mess- this actually had me cry a little bit. You really brought out the relationship between Ahsoka and Anakin perfectly, and even in her last minutes I couldn’t help but painfully smirk a bit.
And I felt genuine shock when you got to the part about Anakin leaving the order, but I could totally see it happening that way now that you’ve brought it to my attention. Well done, I can’t wait to see what else you do.
That’s was a truly beautiful story, I genuinely felt sad when Ashoka died but loved the way the story went.
Makes me think, the only thing Anakin needed in the movies was an Ahsoka and the entity of the clone wars series is just teasing Anakin with what he really needed the whole time before taking her away when he finally realized he needed her
I’m not gonna lie, the knighting of Ashoka choked me up big time 😢
This is so good. Didn’t know what to expect but thank you for the great Thory
You're very welcome, thanks for watching.
Dude if you wrote a screenplay I'd watch the heck out of that movie! Really good stuff here, bro - keep up the good work, and I look forward to the next one!
As much as I love Ahsoka, I don't think she could have stopped Anakin turning to the dark side. His love had turned into possession, he *needed* to keep Padme alive, his love had blinded him, and I think he would have eventually seen Ahsoka as an enemy if she had pushed him on the point
It depends on the moment, I think. If it was post-Windu/Plaptine then probably not. Though I think if it was before that she could get him to see reason, it’s not like he wanted to kill Mace, he just was pushed to the edge.
Like I said though, after he killed Mace, only Padmé would have been able to talk him out of it. Hell she very well might have if Obi-Wan hadn’t poked his head out.
His love for Padme was indeed very selfish. He loved Ahsoka selfishly too. But up until he helped kill Mace, he had options. He could have still chosen differently before that moment. After that? No. What was there left for him? He already thought Padme was going to die, and he had just watched one of the Masters of his order act in a way totally contrary to everything he had been taught.
I think had Ahsoka caught him before he went to confront Palpatine, there’s a much better chance he doesn’t turn.
Agree. Ahsoka couldn't save Anakin unless she offered a way to save padme which she didn't have. He would still turned to the dark side.
@@melfree2545 even if she got to him before Mace was killed she wouldn't be able to save him unless she had a way to save padme which she didn't. He would still go to Palpatine because he was the only one who knew a way and he was too obsessed with padme to let her die.
Pulling all the right hearts strings. You just get Star Wars.
That would've made an amazing Star Wars Infinities comics for sure
You mentioned polls for MCU characters.
I love this idea. We’re slowly running out of Star Wars characters to do the poll, and I wanna see how Marvel characters do against Star Wars.
Also, why limit to two cinematic universes? We could do LOTR, Pirates of the Caribbean, DC, etc.
Lord of the Rings is absolutely something I'd love to do videos on from time to time. It's almost as dear to me as Star Wars is.
@@thorskywalker I'd love to see Lord of the Rings more than Marvel. Tolkien's work is a masterpiece no one has matched and I've occasionally run across references about the influence Tolkien had on Lucas.
just crying. That was such a good what if and part of me wishes it actually happened this way
Can you start a series analyzing the powers of characters in legends? I’m particularly interested in Leia since she too became a full fledged Jedi Knight in the EU.
One thing I've been meaning to do is dig much more into the Expanded Universe, so that is a possibility.
@@thorskywalker Can you please publish Mara Jade Skywalker video?
Oh I missed my favourite creators coming up with wonderful stories like this; more of this please!
Obi-Wan: "We'll be fine, as long as we stick together." 😥
Yo this was so good!! I love the idea that Anakin would leave the order after the war. This was so good and the ending with Asohka was vv touching!
I would love to watch this version of ROTS play out on a big screen. TY! May the Force be with you
That was great! So glad you are getting back to doing these, these are what initially got me listening to your channel.
Why do you ALWAYS have to do this with ashoka man!! 🥺🥺 i still cry..
Thank the maker! So happy to see what if or theory videos again!
Wow. When you mentioned that you weren’t going to covering as much real world stuff and stoping the Sunday commentary videos I was really disappointed. You are the one person who I feel actually says things for what they really are without getting your emotions and opinions involved. I actually have a playlist called ‘Facts’ where I put videos that are, as the name says, total facts. The majority of the videos in that playlist are yours and that’s why I’m subscribed to you. But this video changed my mind. At the beginning I was considering clicking off and only watching certain videos of yours from now on but something inside me just said to stay for a minute. I kept listening and got more and more drawn in to the story. This was absolutely amazing! Such a great story and I can’t wait for more!
Damn, that was emotional. Well done.
Ok, now do a video on how their life will play out after Palps is dead. We need to know the faith of the clones, republic, Jedi, obi-wan, Padma, and their kids.
You just had to make me cry, didn't you? DIDN'T YOU?!?!?!
Oh my gosh I was so into this. You had me on the edge of my seat! 😅 Seriously I loved this so much.
You really nailed the characters!
This was awesome. Good job Thor Skywalker! The new logo is rad my guy!! Thanks for a great what if story.
My goodness Thor.
Now, Ahsoka is my favourite character in Star Wars so I am a bit biased and do tend to get quite emotional anyway when she is on screen or when I hear her voice. But you just put some tears in my eyes with that story, despite it would mean Ahsoka dies and I didn't get to see any of it or hear her voice. But you told the story very well, I pictured it nicely in my head with the aid of the pictures on screen, it felt like I was there. And I almost started crying. Wow.
I don't know if I want to thank you for that :D but certainly that was a good story idea, executed very well in you telling it the way you did. I'm impressed! I mean..... Impressive, most impressive.
Been a silent viewer for years now with only rarely showing up in the comment section but this I just had to say, I'd never have thought that I get this emotional when clicking on that video. Love your channel, thanks for entertaining us fans!
that was pure gold my friend. If you could make that movie I would definitely watch
That "What if,.../Elseworlds" story was fun and well done! I actually would like to see Marvel do some Star Wars "What if,..."s like this. I look forward to your next one!
This was....ridiculously good! I started getting choked up before I realized this was a Thor Skywalker what-if video. Good job man.
It was touching, emotional and very much worth seeing. Truly an amazing what if tale of Star Wars lore. Keep up the fantastic work on your birthday videos.
Wow! That was awesome, Ashoka dying like that, the final conversation between the two, and the final ending, ingenious! Well done, much appreciated!
It's hard to describe how much I love this story. I feel like it describes something I've always felt like needed to happen in Star Wars. I know I'm alone in feeling this way, but I've always wanted Anakin to resist the dark side, as well as have Ashoka Tano come back to the Jedi.
This is one of the best what ifs I've ever heard
I like these videos, keep them up. Stupendous wave used to do these, but he got click baity, so glad to see Thor is doing them!
Great story and thank you for the effort. I do think Ashoka being there changes everything. It would make anakin pause and reevaluate the situation . Which would allow him to see that there was more than one way out and people did love and care for him . Leading him back to the light side .
This was amazing, I got very emotional and this would be an awesome episode for a what-if type of animated series. It would be awesome if Disney literally just paid a very generous royalty to you and used your plot and dialogue for the episode, it's really that good!
Loved it!!! I hate you though, you really made me cry! It was too much, too many emotions and the screencaps just added to it! Thank you!
DUUUUDE THIS ACTUALLY GOT ME REALLY EMOTIONAL
Well done sir. While listening I envisioned it as part of TCW, and it really hits hard. Great story, dialogue, everything. Spot on.
I liked your version Thor as it was more aligned with the events that were occuring
That was so good!!! The way Ahsoka acted and everything where perfect.
What a great story. I actually got emotional hearing this
Wow that was incredible. That would be a great like alternate timeline short. Good work!!