I am in Bangalore, these last 5 years it almost felt like the government here is for only one thing, Cash and Carry. I think BJP treated KA as the place to collect all the funds for election to be used elsewhere.
Both BJP and Congress is bad for the state of Karnataka, lot of corruption still sticks within the government works in KA, people are just fed up and have fallen for the freebies promised by Congress.
I agree we in KA don't have good leaders in BJP ....and this time the corruption was so much they acted as if they willl not get to power again just fill in bank accounts
Not just that Modis Incompetency , biased corruption charges, malicious use of CBI ED etc, besides beeing many corruption charges Modi protected his leaders from ED and CBI where as they were behind DK just becuase Modi ka Man ki baath................and the most incompetentcy of PM modi is recognised as real Pappu the south is wise to read politics
While Congress won because there local leaders took lead while central leadership took backseat. That's how election should be fought. While BJP local leaders always relying on Modi have bored the voters.
@@keerthi321 🤣🤣🤣🤣 again thats the BJP IT wing and BJPians proppaganda Modi put all his efforts ignoring the manipur riot issues to protect his corrupt leaders still failed which means people are not ready to listen to what Modi says..............and gas price was one among the many issues that reflected in the election which is complete incomptency of Modi whho is unableto control gas and fuel price at the time when Russia helpsus with low cost fuel .................this is a moment Karnataka exposed real Pappu who hides behind ED CBI and Media..............though they spend millions to promote Modi as Hero karnataka exposed the realty of fair and lovely cream like Modi
@Siddharth Sriram you'd be stupid if you think people vote for Bjp based on religion. Yogi did not repeat his term because of religion politics. Neither did we let Bjp win in Himachal. They are judged on performance. Bjp at Center level excells. But fails at state level. Congress has no Muddas. So they busy throwing freebies inspired by Kejriwal. Even in himachal what made congress win is oPS issue.
@Siddharth Sriram But BJP is central govt is far better in economic disciple, less freebie, more long term planning , sustainable projects than any govt.
I think Gandhi family taking a backseat and letting the local leaders take the lead made a lot of difference, Congress campaign was to the point and very incisive( trouble engine sarkara, paycm etc.), they talked about concerns that mattered and not raising bug bears
none of the local people cares knows much about Rahul Gandhi moreover most of the youngsters voted for congress still mocks him on social media nothing to do with any gandhi’s image
Mr Gandhi is not a leader If he is a leader he could have settled the problems in Telangana Congress After Karnataka Telangana is a bright spot for Congress But he never cares
No whip just pay before elections, throw some freebies enough, again khangress wins, as Muslims r with them Fools Hindus get divided by castes Well done khangress
Bro I Respect you and your decision but You shouldn't had done that much one sided 😅😅😅😅...... BJP supporters couldn't even show their face today.. Liberals are saying Hindutva lost Bajrang Bali lost Karnataka voters may vote congress but North people cant forget 2007 when congress said that ram was a fiction... Congratulations 🎊 for your new government
@@_kartik_chauhan I wont vote for BJP in MH because of Corruption but will vote for Modi in Centre If BJP doesnt have the values and morals of Bajrang Bali they shouldn't take his name to run their agenda
@@_kartik_chauhan Bro politics in Karnataka is very different compared to that of any other states, out of 136 congress MLA's elected only 9 members belong to minorities rest of them belong to Hindu communities and congress even without them has full majority. It''s not that only minorities support congress in Karnataka, unlike other states congress has a solid base in rural Karnataka known as a party for welfare of poor because of the amazing reform works done by former CM's like Devaraj urs and S Bangarappa. Bengaluru which was known as garden city became sillicon valley of india under then congress chief minister SM Krishna, so congress has solid base in the state and add that to the mismanagement by the state BJP government and lack of leadership at state level led to this result. BJP has no one but itself to blame for this performance, but things are different when it comes to central elections in 2019 BJP got 26 out of 28 seats even though the coalition was in power at that time.
True, when 60% of your earnings go to taxes, and the rest 40% to inflation and corruption. Who cares about Tipu Sultan, or Salman Khans Sultan. When toor dal is out of our pockets, who cares about Bajrang dal. (Many of us thought Bajrang dal was one type of dal)
"In 2023's India, Tipu Sultan doesn't matter. He may have been a good guy or an awful guy more than two century ago. Mere baap ka kya jata hai. Abusing him will not give me job or put water in my tap. Leave him to Historians. " Amazing Quote by Shekhar sir. :D
But we should be aware of what he did...his descendants are still here...and they will do the same when they come in majority and power...your water in the tap wouldnt matter that much when you are running for your life
@@krislo4788 it doesn’t matter. If someone does something illegal our forces are capable of handling it and evil people are there in every community and religion. Vote for anyone you want but stay united and behave like citizen. Then only India will win otherwise just like Britishers congress or bjp or any other political party will use History to divide and rule.
@@himanshu54365 25% people created Pakistan In 75 years from 9% to 20% Another 30-35 years and that will reach that 25% ...... We need true Indians education to rationalise their Nationalism and belongings otherwise for major of them ummah is first
This is like a Punjab 2022 repeat but with bjp in congress place; first bjp removes a popular mass leader who is from a dominating caste group, replaces him with a puppet who has absolutely no voter base of his own, doesn’t do anything remotely similar to development, listens to people like B.L. Santhosh who probably hasn’t even been to Bengaluru and refuses to either control a narrative or stop the other’s narrative.
Understanding that this downturn is something to be happy about, not stress over. Best birthday gift anyone could ever asked for. The more you learn about money, the more confident you become in building wealth. Invest make those dollars count ,stay committed to the craft . It takes the same time to make $100 as it does to make $100k.
The stock market is a crucial step to becoming fnancially free. Problem is most don’t care about anything other than football, music and sex etc. Find it normal to take credit card debt which will cost you 20% per year But it is considered risky to invest their money and make 10% or more per month
The one effective technique I'm confident nobody admits to using, is staying in touch with an Investment-Adviser. Based on firsthand encounter, I can say for certain their skillsets are topnotch, I've raised over $700k since 2021. Just bought my 3rd property for rental. Credit to my Investmnt-Adviser.
@@bsetdays6784 How can one find a verifiable financial planner? I would not mind looking up the professional that helped you. I will be retiring in two years and I might need some management on my much larger portfolio. Don't want to take any chances.
@@cloudyblaze7916 Having a coach is key to portfolio diversification, My advisor is “Eleanor Annette Eckhaus” You can easily look her up, she has years of financial market experience.
Very well explained. BJP leadership should learn from this. PM cannot win state elections, particularly when the state government is horribly under performing.
IT was clearly a vote against MOdani shah. IF you can't understand that then get a life. IF it was fight of local bjp vs local congress BJP would have won with 120+ seats easily. Congress would have won 140 even if they have put 140 donkeys or dummys up for election. Problem is people wanted to vote against Modani shah and they don't have a third alternative as JDS Was ready to be junior partner of BJp from day one. Every vote for JDS was a vote for BJP. people knew that and voted agains Modani shah.
BJP was really good back in 2006, Mr Yedurappa was a good politician. Ofcourse there is always corruption let it be any party. But now the BJP ideology is disturbing. Hope Congress looses their old mindset and seriously works for the upliftment of Karnataka.
40% V's 85% as usual. The old congess men have awaken from sleeping. They are back now from their hideout, the great Chidambaram, Yogi Yadav and the great Vadra
@@dilippatwa6574 Don't resort to propaganda. 85% is taken out of context. Rajiv Gandhi never said his government is taking 85%. What he said is only 15% is reaching last mile. This includes how much each person in the middle eats. At least he had courage to accept the situation. You can never accept arrogant BJP leaders to accept any corruption. Gone are the days were politicians were somewhat honest. Now religion based polarization is the only card BJP is playing. When people like me and you fight on the ground and die, these a$$holes will enjoy. Enough is enough. Karnataka is not UP.
@@dilippatwa6574 Last 9 years BJP top two have eaten enough. Still no answer for 20000 crores infused in Adani. BJP leaders think they are not accountable to answer. In any case, voters of Karnataka know who is best for them. At least learn to accept the mandate instead of spreading false propaganda.
@@bhatanand Lol everytime BJP won with sweeping majority its you people who keep saying its all due to EVM.. now u are not even allowing others to comment. 🤣🤣
the biggest difference was center high command of congress did not poke their nose in state congress affairs like they did in punjab before election. a big lesson for congress they need powerful state leaders to win states and respect them to gain all india level benefits.look at captain Amrinder singh, Sharad pawar, YS reddy, Mamta Banerji. they were all strong state leaders whom congress high command did not gave respect or look as threat to their crown.
@@Vizorfam No need to invoke my cast. Do not have prejudice about my political allignment because of what my last name is. I actually enjoyed your comment. However, now I am not so sure.
It's because of weak local leadership and corruption. Central command needs to be strong, they were able to give seats to new people ditching older ones because of strong high command.
In India no matter what part you are from, the one thing that works like a charm is mass leaders. There is no substitute for mass leaders. People are voting for the mass leaders. I honestly believe this is the mandate for D K Shiva Kumar rather than Congress.
@@shyambajekal8084 Siddaramaiah and kharge are doyens who hate to spend money. It is DK who made it possible. If he is made CM, he will look after the funding for Congress the next 5 years.
Yeah , especially in old mysore region and central karnataka. When D K shivakumar assumed congress presidency kpcc was at its knees and he himself was raided multiple times by IT dept and arrested and put in cell by ED dept but he rallied across karnataka and unifies the state Congress and started to expose the mismanagement of BJP government through pay CM and 40% commission government.
Yes Indians love Strong leaders. Modi, Yogi, or many others. Sometimes I believe democracy was never meant for India. People love following a strong figure. This is the same in Pakistan. I believe it's a Subcontinent thing.
Point number 8 is bang on.. seeking votes from a particular community without any ideology and leveraging that to make and change power setup is kindaa trolling democracy and system. Thank you SG sir..
But they voted for BJP last time? So they have become tolerant since last election? What is your point exactly. As if voting for left parties is only viable choice, what about hate from the Left eg Digvijaya Singh blaming 26/11 on RSS and Hindus?
@@rohanindra6401 simple brother , we do not have problem with muslims, our government priorities are development. why south indians ruling IT INDUSTRIES? why telugu students getting more admissions in to IITS ? WHY TELUGU is fast growing in USA ? why telugu people are richest community in USA? MORE SC/ ST/ BC/ MUSLIMS PEOPLES ARE EDUCATED IN SOUTH. education / career in main goal to younger people and their parents.
Lesson to BJP, have a dummy CM and face consequences, there is limit to Hindutva, Hindus are not Muslims to just blindly vote based on religion, they do care about progress, slap for BJP
So there's no substitute for economic growth and development basically. Its good that people are not voting purely on identity politics and care about performance. I hope whichever government is in power, they have the courage to make some big ticket reforms that will probably be unpopular in the short term, but in the long term will massively boost growth.
I feel you left out one of the obvious reasons of the people of Karnataka rejecting BJP is their sheer arrogance and disconnect from real issues faced by the common man.
Yep. You can't just go on stage and shout kerala story. It just showed how disconnected modi is from real issues of karnataka. This isn't UP where it might've worked
@@Vizorfam Bihar is still better than UP Gujarat. Biharis are far more educated than UP. But their education is in Hindi. Everyone has a misconception that if you don't speak English you are uneducated.
With changes in the economy leading to instability in the stock market, some individuals may face a decrease in their investments in an effort to benefit from the current market conditions, I am considering liquidating my $725k portfolio consisting of bonds and stocks. Someone else in the same situation? Please tell me in the comments!..
I have been exploring the possibility of utilizing advisors to help navigate the stock market during these uncertain times. However, I am still evaluating their potential effectiveness in providing the support I need. @Joseph Green
I was considering changing my investment strategy and planning to sell certain positions. As my retirement is coming soon,I became increasingly stressed. After thoroughly researching Christy Vallen D'souza on internet, I concluded that I had made an informed decision. Thank you for this Pointer. She seems very proficient and flexible. I booked a call session with her too. @Joseph Green
The results hardly come as a surprise. The BJP state govt in Karnataka was totally useless. The Congress is going to be equally useless, but anti incumbency under such a situation is a given ..
A hard reality check for BJP is needed. It is slowly becoming the Congress of the past with high command and weak regional leaders with a couple exceptions. Also BJP government in Karnataka was pathetic and corrupt despite helpful BJP in center. BJP deserved this loss
Biggest reason bjp lost is due to local leaders in my opinion. BJP for a while has sidelined popular state leaders and replaced them with puppets (most of whom are from minority caste) . Whenever local leader becomes more popular, he is immediately removed or sidelined. I think the difference in how Karnataka and UP voted proves this, in UP, bjp is sweeping as they have a popular face in Yogi adityanath whereas in Karnataka they are decimated as Bommai vs Siddu is like Rahul vs Modi. The first step bjp can take in Karnataka is to give full power to Yeddiyurappa and his son. Also another interesting fact is that pre 2021 (yediyurappa’s removal) bjp was actually winning bypoll after bypoll in Karnataka and some of these were in Old Mysuru which bjp this time was completely wiped out off. Unless Modi starts respecting local bjp mass leaders, bjp is more or less done for.
@@Vizorfam haha not really, in lok sabha bjp will be fine including in Karnataka due to modi. Also your congress got trashed in Punjab and gujurat last year but they won Karnataka right?
Good that BJP Lost . Modi and Shah have taken the Indian populus for granted for a very long time. Our economy is in doldrums , Oil prices are rising and Supreme leader is very silent about Chinese military intrusions on the border . The BJP cadre should take this loss seriously and start working on their main agenda on development .
Economy is not in doldrums. India is going to contribute 15% of total world economic growth next fiscal year based on IMF predictions. Our inflation is far far lower than any other major or minor economy. If at all our opposition parties are the one who have shown real potential to drag our economic growth with all the freebies they have to offer.
dude you shud say to OPEC countries why the hell they are selling CRUDE OIL at 100 dollars and even shortening their output simple business cut the supply raisè the price
How's our economy in doldrums? Kindly explain your points in support of your statement? Oil price is not rising for long time now as compared to to other nations...
Mr Modi ll eventually be the prime minister of UP and Gujarat. The brave hearts of south India shredded Modiji like the flower petals that showered on him on his roadshows in bangalore. Hate politics has no place in south India. Jai Hind.
See I don't give certificate like that but after emergency educated south voted for her.. so called Democratic.. mostly from kerela people joined isis..but I love dharma..
@@yogitashivhare2672 Most of India voted for her in 1980. Congress won 4 353 seats. How many people Joined ISIS from Kerala ? 100-200 or 1000? in a population of 4 Cr , it is a minority.
@@yogitashivhare2672 I am sure you contributed to earning of Kerala stories generously. I will suggest you to invest more in getting your information from more reliable sources like "Govt of Indian" instead of some cash grab propoganda instrument.
Shekhar! Sometimes you amaze the hell out. Hours and hours of TV debates across 100s of channels and you summarised it so well in less than 10 mins. Which brings me to my next point. Cut your Cut the Clutters to 10 mins otherwise you get very repetitive
Thank you for the kind words. I am glad you liked this episode. As for shorter CTCs, it depends on the subject or issue. Some simply demand a longer run. But I take your point, and I will try to make them crisper. Thanks for watching...best wishes, Shekhar
Brilliant as usual Shekhar. The last but one comment on the Congress is apt. The Gandhis never learn. Should have left the leadership issue to the elected MLAs who would have made their choice through secret ballot. But that would have been expecting too much. The leadership only knows how to wade into avoidable trouble and deliver a disaster.Sad.
Well said Shekhar. Karnataka elections were unique and issues at large were mostly local. The voters were at odds with the state govt over the "real issues" such as rampant corruption, inflation, employment et al rather than the fantasies propagated by BJ - Hijab, Halal, Hanuman rows. The BJP, as always, tried to bury these real issues under the carpet and underplay their own organizational troubles by the usual "winning formula" of fanning the communal flame. As you said polarization is truly a double edged sword. We criticize Congress and rest to be "family owned" or dynastic - where the diktat is issued from the kitchen, but the BJP is proving to be another version of the same centralized power - centred around the supreme leader and his words the holy verses. And, this power centre would always keep the other power centres in his party under check - the Yogis n Himantas might have to clip their wings for the time being, Shivraj Singh could explain it better. In short, the ripples of the election results might not reach the northern lands where the sangh's tried n tested formulas will work like magic for years to come.
Thanks for this one. But you still need to make another one over Karnataka 2023 election, decluttering mostly the part played or not played by NCP and other new entrants in this election!
you are living in fools paradise , modi does not tolerate any poppular state leader . he wants all state elections modi centric . he will then appoint a useless fellow . we will see how many states accept this model .
Actually .... Hello, my northern friends Tippu is not your normal northern Islamic sultan ....he's different.....he's secular and mainly betrayed down by his own prime minister Purnayya, who is a Bramhin...
Melkote village in Karnataka didn't celebrate Diwali because Around 200 years ago, by the order of Tipu Sultan, around 800 Hindus were massacred in this small village of Melkote in Karnataka.
Shekhar Sir, even i hate you regarding your hatred for Modi and Right wing, but i salute you for your perfect analysis. even many of your presentations and analysis regarding political situations are perfect and bang on. thank you .
I am happy that politics is visibly competitive again with Bengal, Punjab, Himachal, now Karnataka going to opposition parties and unlike TMC in Bengal, the others were normal peaceful elections. Perhaps BJP has become complacent with TV media being lopsided, these defeats should ring some alarms. Hope Congress continues its efforts to revive itself at grassroots, it might put up a decent fight in 2024, of course they will need a coalition.
You said true west Bengal is violence place now. But don't forget Bengal election is decided by rohingya muslim and Bangladeshi Muslim. This is so sad. Report of 2006 shows that Bangladeshi Muslim impact over 130 seat and this is 2023 think how much they influence today politics. I also don't believe west Bengal election results because more than 2 crore voters are come from Bangladesh 😂😂
@@Learner_being My friend, the population of Bangladesh is 17 crore. If 2 crore moved to West Bengal, that is almost 12% population transfer ! That kind of movement of people did not happen even during and after world war in Europe. Total number of Rohingya that moved from Myanmar was around 10 lakh, of that 8 lakh are in Bangladesh and the rest are spread all over the world including middle east, indonesia, western countries etc. There is no need for this paranoid fear of Bangladesh muslims. Their fertility is now well under replacement and they are an okay economy. The important point is that if the east of india, ie northeast states as well as Bihar and West bengal are to have thriving economies then trade and transit links with Bangladesh will be crucial. Even the Modi government understands this basic fact, that is why they have been courting them despite all the bluster.
@@joshua_ch bro ,this 2 crore record is said in Indian parliament. I am not saying this by seeing biased reporting against India nation. West Bengal already has beat Assam in terms of minorities population. But i am sure this modi govt will also hide this record when census will be done in India. There are many areas in Bengal where law didn't work. And where law work, police man came from peaceful samaaj didn't acts
Bjp didn't understand the emotions of karnataka at all, so even lingayats moved away... They always speak about making Hindi as a compulsory language which south India never accepts, Bringing Amul into Karnataka against locals protest which affected them heavily in rural areas today!! Despite all the support from lingayats they talked against limgayats especially RSS leafers like santosh and BJP national secretary C T Ravi.. Today C T Ravi defeated by Congress's Lingayat candidate!!! Almost 65 % lingayat strongholds are won by Congress's lingayat candidates.!!! They didn't respond to people's cry about 40% commission!! State leader are not bothered about anything thinking that Modi will help them to win the election but today almost all ministers are washed away in people's anger!!! Polarization doesn't work in karnataka except coastal and malnad parts rest of the state don't give damn to religion!!! If congress able to hold these many lingayats they will win 25+ loksabha seats like bjp of today... Totally congress washed away BJP with historical win after 30 years.
@@1008apocalypse1008 brother belive me BJP us the most corrupt party in karnataka so far!! Don't know what center was doing all these days! About lingayats, lingayat votes are divided not complete swing that is why BJP still holding the ground in 65 seats. In South religion card doesn't work again and again you must work and develop.. More than anything heavy corruption forced people to vote congress which is also a corrupt certainly not like BJP which was unbelievable, they looted the state in 3 years.
Sir, your way of narration is awesome. Thank you for all the effort you put into research and off course yours decades of knowledge following the politics and news in India !! Hatsoff !!!
Superb 10 points! Show something for yourself, seems the message to all parties, other than sentiments, personalities, polarizations, authoritarianism, over-confidence. Thanks!
When one religious community votes one sided, and that is happening continuously for 70+ years...that is not counted as Polarization, communal politics ?? That party is the pioneer of appeasement politics. Take your guesses friends....these journalists really do not have anything to say other than polarization, communalism, blah blah blah...the effects of secular Nasha... Jai Hind, mera Bharat Mahan...
Nice analysis. Congratulations. I hope the BJP leadership watches and listens to this. It has to mend its ways if it wants to win the 2024 Lok Sabha election. The Modi Government has done great to help the poor in India without any discrimination. But that is not enough. It has to give up its policy of divisiveness and negativity and lamenting the governments before 2014.
Yes, good analysis from Shekhar Gupta. It boggles the mind that the BJP high command wouldn't encourage the emergence of more Yogi Adityanaths and Himanta Biswa Sarma's, given the results they're producing. They seem to want weak state leaders who can be controlled from Delhi. Nah, Indian voters want their state leaders to be strong and locally-rooted. The BJP needs to recognize that strong state-level leaders not just ground its brand in strength at one more layer in the Indian federal makeup, but also create a new rung of leaders from which to find national leaders. I'm sure the BJP will turn things around though, because Modi-Shah are masters of adaptation.
Interesting analysis. Thank you. Heartening lesson that not all the Indian electorate votes on communal politics. Hopefully a lesson to the Congress that governance matters and not glorifying the Gandhis.
Thank you, Jeremy. It should, ideally, be a lesson to all parties that governance matters. Thanks for watching and for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
Brilliant analysis, SG sir, massive respect 🫡 and full paisa vasool for my subscription ❤ your analysis about the horse traders (aka Gowda clan) was spot on, the epitaph also should read exactly what you said - non-ideologue power mongers !!
@Pierre In He is a person who withdrew cases against him instead of through legal process . He cannot do that since he calls himself an Yogi. Do you think Almighty can be fooled.
Today's video is just Jabardast. Karnataka is minor setback for Hindutva but it was necessary. Modi Shah need to learn that local leaders and local issues matter. We should thank the people of Karnataka for their wisdom and wise choice. Hope this serves like a wake up call for BJP🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩
@@nirmal886 Islam spread because of politics. Politics is always mixed with religion. We are not blinded by secularism. We vote BJP because of Hindutva. Muslims don't vote BJP because of religion. They are secular because they are in minority. But progress is also necessary. Plain, simple and unapologetic.
@@abhishekjoshi4648 the day when bjp gives same importance to every religion.. Even Muslims will vote for BJP. Bjp should learn from Congress on how to be secular. Don't assume Only Hindutva votes matter or elections can be fought on basis on communal basis. Everyone will vote.. Come out communal hatred.. Work towards betterment of country.. Today people of karnataka slapped bjp in the face for spreading hatred. I hope every other state come to their senses.. You are not blinded by secularism.. You are blinded by the communal hatred.. Hope you understand..
This is the golden opportunity for Congress.. if this government does a good job, Karnataka will once again become fortress for Congress, we Kannadigas are fed up with the BJP's incompetent govt & it's one dimensional agenda to win votes..
Good on the K state to vote on performance than personalities. If everyone did this, there won’t be a need for polarized or controversial campaigns. Hope BJP learns a lesson and campaigns on their performance than religion
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
The Pain and sorrow of Shekhar ji is evident today. My heartfelt sympathies
ಮೋದಿ ಮೋದಿ ಅಂತ ಮೋಡಿ ಮಾಡುವವರು ಬೇಡ!
@@thor3932 he is doing analysis. Why are you crying 😂😂😂
@@amitsaha9436are you crying too?
@@70newlife Do i care about who wins or loses 😂😂😂
I am in Bangalore, these last 5 years it almost felt like the government here is for only one thing, Cash and Carry. I think BJP treated KA as the place to collect all the funds for election to be used elsewhere.
just wait and see how Karnataka will now be used as ATM for 2024 Lok Sabha election expenditure
@@nagbalkur1365 every state will be used in ls elections not only Karnataka
@@midorimashintaro2092 Congress does not have any strong state in terms of economics
Rajasthan and chattisgarh cannot offer much
Both BJP and Congress is bad for the state of Karnataka, lot of corruption still sticks within the government works in KA, people are just fed up and have fallen for the freebies promised by Congress.
@@xyzabc162 chattisgarh may not offer much but Rajasthan isn't that bad. But yes, KA will be used the most.
Riding piggyback on Modi isn't going to work. Time BJP realizes this. Local issues matter. And local leaders too - who have a connect with the people.
Don't worry from next year national ones will also not matter as this party will get destroyed
@@Vizorfam Don't worry, next year will butt will get beaten and you will stop spamming comment sections 🤭😂
@@Karthik-my6zf Dont vote BJPee
I agree we in KA don't have good leaders in BJP ....and this time the corruption was so much they acted as if they willl not get to power again just fill in bank accounts
@@jioboy2676 Better than Porngress 😆
The reason for BJP loss in Karnataka is an incompetent local government for last 5 years.
Not just that Modis Incompetency , biased corruption charges, malicious use of CBI ED etc, besides beeing many corruption charges Modi protected his leaders from ED and CBI where as they were behind DK just becuase Modi ka Man ki baath................and the most incompetentcy of PM modi is recognised as real Pappu the south is wise to read politics
Did u see the video.. Or just commenting.. BJP lost in state not because of Modi.. It's because weak state leaders..
While Congress won because there local leaders took lead while central leadership took backseat. That's how election should be fought. While BJP local leaders always relying on Modi have bored the voters.
@@keerthi321 🤣🤣🤣🤣 again thats the BJP IT wing and BJPians proppaganda Modi put all his efforts ignoring the manipur riot issues to protect his corrupt leaders still failed which means people are not ready to listen to what Modi says..............and gas price was one among the many issues that reflected in the election which is complete incomptency of Modi whho is unableto control gas and fuel price at the time when Russia helpsus with low cost fuel .................this is a moment Karnataka exposed real Pappu who hides behind ED CBI and Media..............though they spend millions to promote Modi as Hero karnataka exposed the realty of fair and lovely cream like Modi
@@ashishnayak6823 Very true.. Karnataka voters are smart..
Results apart. I like how my karnataka people voted maturely differentiating Lok sabha and Vidhan sabha❤
Hopefully trend is maintained in Lok sabha too,that's where the fault line of constitutional tremors lies.
@Siddharth Sriram you'd be stupid if you think people vote for Bjp based on religion. Yogi did not repeat his term because of religion politics. Neither did we let Bjp win in Himachal. They are judged on performance. Bjp at Center level excells. But fails at state level. Congress has no Muddas. So they busy throwing freebies inspired by Kejriwal. Even in himachal what made congress win is oPS issue.
In loke sabha e will vote for bjp.
@@ahmedhaqqani9469 🤣🤣🤣people are not stupid. Tell me why muslims dont vote for BJP?? BJP alone is NOT communal
@Siddharth Sriram But BJP is central govt is far better in economic disciple, less freebie, more long term planning , sustainable projects than any govt.
Voted against BJP because of rampant corruption. Same will happen to Congress if it goes back to appeasement instead of proper governance.
Congress never does appeasement it only cares about minorities
You should go back to bjp.. You deserve them.
Maybe letting Ms breathe in this country itself is 'appeasement' for you.
Suprised no it cell here
Same❤ we won
Right you are.👍
I think Gandhi family taking a backseat and letting the local leaders take the lead made a lot of difference, Congress campaign was to the point and very incisive( trouble engine sarkara, paycm etc.), they talked about concerns that mattered and not raising bug bears
TBH people only relate to local leaders here, Rahul n Priyanka s image won’t do anything
none of the local people cares knows much about Rahul Gandhi moreover most of the youngsters voted for congress still mocks him on social media nothing to do with any gandhi’s image
Mr Gandhi is not a leader
If he is a leader he could have settled the problems in Telangana Congress
After Karnataka Telangana is a bright spot for Congress
But he never cares
South people are more educated and do not fall for 'No Action, Just words words words'.
Gobar party out of south india
Congress will face the same fate if they don't perform, Kannadiga's hold the whip here.
They have, 5 years
No whip just pay before elections, throw some freebies enough, again khangress wins, as Muslims r with them
Fools Hindus get divided by castes
Well done khangress
Massive respect for people of my state Karnataka for showing maturity while voting this time❤
Bro I Respect you and your decision but
You shouldn't had done that much one sided 😅😅😅😅......
BJP supporters couldn't even show their face today..
Liberals are saying
Hindutva lost
Bajrang Bali lost
Karnataka voters may vote congress but North people cant forget 2007 when congress said that ram was a fiction...
Congratulations 🎊 for your new government
@@_kartik_chauhan cow belt will throw feku out of power
@@_kartik_chauhan I wont vote for BJP in MH because of Corruption but will vote for Modi in Centre
If BJP doesnt have the values and morals of Bajrang Bali they shouldn't take his name to run their agenda
@@ed5928 yes
@@_kartik_chauhan Bro politics in Karnataka is very different compared to that of any other states, out of 136 congress MLA's elected only 9 members belong to minorities rest of them belong to Hindu communities and congress even without them has full majority. It''s not that only minorities support congress in Karnataka, unlike other states congress has a solid base in rural Karnataka known as a party for welfare of poor because of the amazing reform works done by former CM's like Devaraj urs and S Bangarappa. Bengaluru which was known as garden city became sillicon valley of india under then congress chief minister SM Krishna, so congress has solid base in the state and add that to the mismanagement by the state BJP government and lack of leadership at state level led to this result. BJP has no one but itself to blame for this performance, but things are different when it comes to central elections in 2019 BJP got 26 out of 28 seats even though the coalition was in power at that time.
A wise man said " Beware there is Kerala is in your neighbourhood".
.
and Karnataka Replied ❤
True, when 60% of your earnings go to taxes, and the rest 40% to inflation and corruption. Who cares about Tipu Sultan, or Salman Khans Sultan. When toor dal is out of our pockets, who cares about Bajrang dal. (Many of us thought Bajrang dal was one type of dal)
I want Bajrang dal on my plate
😅
😂
Adei thambi...😂 bajrang "Daal"😅
This is Sense 💯💯
Modi should avoid low level politics and work on people’s problems.
@firegamer55588 pappu nhi pappa hai modi ka vo 😂😂😂
@@skmr5160 Mrs modi ka affair pata hai 😂....pati chodkr Gaya ...kuch to jugad karna padega na
@Fire_Gamer desh ke dalalo ko , jute maaro salo ko 24 me inko aise hi bajana h.
@Bread Pit desh ke dalalo ko , jute maaro salo ko 24 me inko aise hi bajana h.
@@pruthvirajchavan-patil380 desh ke dalalo ko , jute maaro salo ko 24 me inko aise hi bajana h.
"In 2023's India, Tipu Sultan doesn't matter. He may have been a good guy or an awful guy more than two century ago.
Mere baap ka kya jata hai. Abusing him will not give me job or put water in my tap.
Leave him to Historians. "
Amazing Quote by Shekhar sir. :D
But we should be aware of what he did...his descendants are still here...and they will do the same when they come in majority and power...your water in the tap wouldnt matter that much when you are running for your life
@@krislo4788 it doesn’t matter. If someone does something illegal our forces are capable of handling it and evil people are there in every community and religion.
Vote for anyone you want but stay united and behave like citizen. Then only India will win otherwise just like Britishers congress or bjp or any other political party will use History to divide and rule.
@@himanshu54365 salute to you bro
@@himanshu54365
25% people created Pakistan
In 75 years from 9% to 20%
Another 30-35 years and that will reach that 25%
......
We need true Indians education to rationalise their Nationalism and belongings otherwise for major of them ummah is first
@@krislo4788 what great Ashoka did with Hindus of Kalinga?
SG is an expert in Northern states,but when it comes to South India he has to go a long way.
2 reasons for congress win:
1. Anti Incumbancy
2. Strong state leadership
If had congress won in DK & Udupi, is same as returning to power in 2024.
He has good knowledge but far away from being an expert. May appear like an expert, cause there are few few NE voices
Excellent analysis. Nobody wants a state to be run from Delhi..
Then, From where should it be run 🤔
@@tbraghavendran from the state capital by the elected CM
@@tbraghavendran it’s really worrying you don’t even know the basics of federalism. Please learn something before you go out and vote.
This is like a Punjab 2022 repeat but with bjp in congress place; first bjp removes a popular mass leader who is from a dominating caste group, replaces him with a puppet who has absolutely no voter base of his own, doesn’t do anything remotely similar to development, listens to people like B.L. Santhosh who probably hasn’t even been to Bengaluru and refuses to either control a narrative or stop the other’s narrative.
Awww are you sad bhakath? Your party lost 😂😂
@@Vizorfam are you english speaking lahori
@@arjavgarg5801 Lahori chicken party today🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Burnol khale re
@@sauron2000000 moti moti gardanon wale 🤣🤣🤣
Understanding that this downturn is something to be happy about, not stress over. Best birthday gift anyone could ever asked for. The more you learn about money, the more confident you become in building wealth. Invest make those dollars count ,stay committed to the craft . It takes the same time to make $100 as it does to make $100k.
The stock market is a crucial step to becoming fnancially free. Problem is most don’t care about anything other than football, music and sex etc. Find it normal to take credit card debt which will cost you 20% per year But it is considered risky to invest their money and make 10% or more per month
The one effective technique I'm confident nobody admits to using, is staying in touch with an Investment-Adviser. Based on firsthand encounter, I can say for certain their skillsets are topnotch, I've raised over $700k since 2021. Just bought my 3rd property for rental. Credit to my Investmnt-Adviser.
@@bsetdays6784 How can one find a verifiable financial planner? I would not mind looking up the professional that helped you. I will be retiring in two years and I might need some management on my much larger portfolio. Don't want to take any chances.
@@cloudyblaze7916 Having a coach is key to portfolio diversification, My advisor is “Eleanor Annette Eckhaus” You can easily look her up, she has years of financial market experience.
@@bsetdays6784 Chinese friend, come and settle in india, you will become rich.
Very well explained. BJP leadership should learn from this. PM cannot win state elections, particularly when the state government is horribly under performing.
Don't worry this pm will not win national elections also next year
IT was clearly a vote against MOdani shah. IF you can't understand that then get a life. IF it was fight of local bjp vs local congress BJP would have won with 120+ seats easily. Congress would have won 140 even if they have put 140 donkeys or dummys up for election. Problem is people wanted to vote against Modani shah and they don't have a third alternative as JDS Was ready to be junior partner of BJp from day one. Every vote for JDS was a vote for BJP. people knew that and voted agains Modani shah.
BJP was really good back in 2006, Mr Yedurappa was a good politician. Ofcourse there is always corruption let it be any party. But now the BJP ideology is disturbing. Hope Congress looses their old mindset and seriously works for the upliftment of Karnataka.
Other than giving free and making ppl lazy they will not do anything
40% V's 85% as usual. The old congess men have awaken from sleeping. They are back now from their hideout, the great Chidambaram, Yogi Yadav and the great Vadra
@@dilippatwa6574 Don't resort to propaganda. 85% is taken out of context. Rajiv Gandhi never said his government is taking 85%. What he said is only 15% is reaching last mile. This includes how much each person in the middle eats. At least he had courage to accept the situation. You can never accept arrogant BJP leaders to accept any corruption. Gone are the days were politicians were somewhat honest. Now religion based polarization is the only card BJP is playing. When people like me and you fight on the ground and die, these a$$holes will enjoy. Enough is enough. Karnataka is not UP.
@@dilippatwa6574 Last 9 years BJP top two have eaten enough. Still no answer for 20000 crores infused in Adani. BJP leaders think they are not accountable to answer. In any case, voters of Karnataka know who is best for them. At least learn to accept the mandate instead of spreading false propaganda.
@@bhatanand Lol everytime BJP won with sweeping majority its you people who keep saying its all due to EVM.. now u are not even allowing others to comment. 🤣🤣
the biggest difference was center high command of congress did not poke their nose in state congress affairs like they did in punjab before election. a big lesson for congress they need powerful state leaders to win states and respect them to gain all india level benefits.look at captain Amrinder singh, Sharad pawar, YS reddy, Mamta Banerji. they were all strong state leaders whom congress high command did not gave respect or look as threat to their crown.
True .for all parties .even bjp .
That's always been how Congress has been at its strongest. They had excellent state level leadership all throughout India.
Very well said..
True
Entire ysrcp Congress party cadre and leaders are from Congress
Yes.
BJP needs to end the High Command culture
No actually bjp should end itself completely
@@Vizorfam....😂..😂🤣🤣
@@kunaldwivedi3197 aur dwivedi Brahmin kaisa lag raha hai aj apko?
@@Vizorfam No need to invoke my cast. Do not have prejudice about my political allignment because of what my last name is. I actually enjoyed your comment. However, now I am not so sure.
It's because of weak local leadership and corruption. Central command needs to be strong, they were able to give seats to new people ditching older ones because of strong high command.
In India no matter what part you are from, the one thing that works like a charm is mass leaders. There is no substitute for mass leaders. People are voting for the mass leaders. I honestly believe this is the mandate for D K Shiva Kumar rather than Congress.
Yes, he, Siddaramaiah and Kharge
@@shyambajekal8084 Siddaramaiah and kharge are doyens who hate to spend money. It is DK who made it possible. If he is made CM, he will look after the funding for Congress the next 5 years.
Ok. So?
Yeah , especially in old mysore region and central karnataka. When D K shivakumar assumed congress presidency kpcc was at its knees and he himself was raided multiple times by IT dept and arrested and put in cell by ED dept but he rallied across karnataka and unifies the state Congress and started to expose the mismanagement of BJP government through pay CM and 40% commission government.
Yes Indians love Strong leaders. Modi, Yogi, or many others. Sometimes I believe democracy was never meant for India. People love following a strong figure. This is the same in Pakistan. I believe it's a Subcontinent thing.
Point number 8 is bang on.. seeking votes from a particular community without any ideology and leveraging that to make and change power setup is kindaa trolling democracy and system. Thank you SG sir..
Lol Congress said they will remove HIjab ban and do everything for Muslims. Isnt that trolling democracy???
Thank you, Suneel, for watching. I'm glad you liked this episode. Thank you also for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
If it's uplift and lead to the growth of that community why not what is wrong with it people decide democracy not partisan journalist
Once again South Indian proved that they are inclusive, tolerant and intelligent 🎉
They voted for modi in 2019 and will vote for bjp again. Looks like you are a kid from school who don't know a thing about politics
Waiting for 56 Muslims countries to prove they are inclusive, tolerant and intelligent!
I am from Bengal, so by that logic since i am from the North i am intolerant and dumb ? Is that what you guys mean !!
But they voted for BJP last time? So they have become tolerant since last election? What is your point exactly. As if voting for left parties is only viable choice, what about hate from the Left eg Digvijaya Singh blaming 26/11 on RSS and Hindus?
@@rohanindra6401 simple brother , we do not have problem with muslims, our government priorities are development. why south indians ruling IT INDUSTRIES? why telugu students getting more admissions in to IITS ? WHY TELUGU is fast growing in USA ? why telugu people are richest community in USA? MORE SC/ ST/ BC/ MUSLIMS PEOPLES ARE EDUCATED IN SOUTH. education / career in main goal to younger people and their parents.
Lesson to BJP, have a dummy CM and face consequences, there is limit to Hindutva, Hindus are not Muslims to just blindly vote based on religion, they do care about progress, slap for BJP
So there's no substitute for economic growth and development basically. Its good that people are not voting purely on identity politics and care about performance. I hope whichever government is in power, they have the courage to make some big ticket reforms that will probably be unpopular in the short term, but in the long term will massively boost growth.
true
True.
Your Hinduism is nothing but a Brahmanical supremacist ideology
Muslims vote for Congress because they know they want the society to stay in harmony.... How can you expect them to vote communal hatred BJP...🤣🤣
I feel you left out one of the obvious reasons of the people of Karnataka rejecting BJP is their sheer arrogance and disconnect from real issues faced by the common man.
real issues does not matter , just face
Yep. You can't just go on stage and shout kerala story. It just showed how disconnected modi is from real issues of karnataka.
This isn't UP where it might've worked
Superb crisp and precise analysis! Thanks for putting this up on a Sunday.
A wise man said, Karnataka is not UP or Gujarat.
Bihar also
@@Vizorfam Bihar is still better than UP Gujarat. Biharis are far more educated than UP. But their education is in Hindi. Everyone has a misconception that if you don't speak English you are uneducated.
@@chatcricket1405 BJP mukt South is a thing now. They can peddle their bullshit in the Hindi belt. Lol.
😂 bastards used to give Karnataka the tag of South's up wait in 2024 lok sabha you will again use this
Wonderfully put Sir. Local government performance only matters now for state elections. Modi's charm cannot be a substitute 👍🏽👍🏽
Then make it to national now come on we have to end this hindutva mindset in this country
@@Vizorfam Then your pussy will get banged 😂
@@Vizorfam yeah make islamic india
@@abhishekagrahari8667 yes it will be soo good then
@@Vizorfam yeah live in stone age like Afghanistan
With changes in the economy leading to instability in the stock market, some individuals may face a decrease in their investments in an effort to benefit from the current market conditions, I am considering liquidating my $725k portfolio consisting of bonds and stocks. Someone else in the same situation? Please tell me in the comments!..
I have been exploring the possibility of utilizing advisors to help navigate the stock market during these uncertain times. However, I am still evaluating their potential effectiveness in providing the support I need.
@Joseph Green
I was considering changing my investment strategy and planning to sell certain positions. As my retirement is coming soon,I became increasingly stressed. After thoroughly researching Christy Vallen D'souza on internet, I concluded that I had made an informed decision. Thank you for this Pointer. She seems very proficient and flexible. I booked a call session with her too.
@Joseph Green
Today SG acquired some courage to talk about polarisation, etc.
The results hardly come as a surprise. The BJP state govt in Karnataka was totally useless. The Congress is going to be equally useless, but anti incumbency under such a situation is a given ..
😂 you are very sure about congress, they can be useless but they wont be useless as much as your papa is
@@parnamsingh1716 your reply shows your Papa's pedigree ..
@@vish3161 Yeah we got 100% of it you might've gotten 60% after deducting commission.
@@bruhmoment5145 wonder even if you understand the meaning of what you write ...
@@vish3161 40% commission party
Absolutely crisp 10 minutes! There is none second to Guptaji when it comes to Politics in India!
A hard reality check for BJP is needed. It is slowly becoming the Congress of the past with high command and weak regional leaders with a couple exceptions. Also BJP government in Karnataka was pathetic and corrupt despite helpful BJP in center. BJP deserved this loss
And the BJP even took out Yediyurappa like the congress took out Amarinder Singh from Punjab
@@santoshNarayana bjp deserves this very huge defeat by Karnataka people.
40% party couldn't get theire commission , from people
Shameless sanghi
@@Vizorfam madraschap pedoputrs
Wait and see next 5 years it will grow to 90%
They have been won over by the 85% party that hid its googly well!!😂
@Fire_Gamer 2₹ has been deposited in to your ass
Congratulations to People of Karnataka,
Today everyone look at you with respect for DEMANDING action and NOT words from politicians!
Biggest reason bjp lost is due to local leaders in my opinion. BJP for a while has sidelined popular state leaders and replaced them with puppets (most of whom are from minority caste) . Whenever local leader becomes more popular, he is immediately removed or sidelined. I think the difference in how Karnataka and UP voted proves this, in UP, bjp is sweeping as they have a popular face in Yogi adityanath whereas in Karnataka they are decimated as Bommai vs Siddu is like Rahul vs Modi. The first step bjp can take in Karnataka is to give full power to Yeddiyurappa and his son. Also another interesting fact is that pre 2021 (yediyurappa’s removal) bjp was actually winning bypoll after bypoll in Karnataka and some of these were in Old Mysuru which bjp this time was completely wiped out off. Unless Modi starts respecting local bjp mass leaders, bjp is more or less done for.
Bjp is really done their local game is pathetic and now just wait because from next year it will end of bjp along with hindutva
@@Vizorfam Says a pedoputra 😂
@@Vizorfam haha not really, in lok sabha bjp will be fine including in Karnataka due to modi. Also your congress got trashed in Punjab and gujurat last year but they won Karnataka right?
@@tomriddle4110 in your dreams next year will be the end of hindutva politics for forever minorities will be safe again
@@Vizorfam then y ur favorite party won three states in 2018 but lost all three the following year
Good that BJP Lost . Modi and Shah have taken the Indian populus for granted for a very long time. Our economy is in doldrums , Oil prices are rising and Supreme leader is very silent about Chinese military intrusions on the border . The BJP cadre should take this loss seriously and start working on their main agenda on development .
Could you elaborate on how our economy is in doldrums? I mean there's always room for improvement and efficiency but doldrums?
Here comes the ricebag who thinks he knows economics.
Economy is not in doldrums.
India is going to contribute 15% of total world economic growth next fiscal year based on IMF predictions.
Our inflation is far far lower than any other major or minor economy.
If at all our opposition parties are the one who have shown real potential to drag our economic growth with all the freebies they have to offer.
dude you shud say to OPEC countries why the hell they are selling CRUDE OIL at 100 dollars and even shortening their output simple business cut the supply raisè the price
How's our economy in doldrums? Kindly explain your points in support of your statement? Oil price is not rising for long time now as compared to to other nations...
Mr Modi ll eventually be the prime minister of UP and Gujarat.
The brave hearts of south India shredded Modiji like the flower petals that showered on him on his roadshows in bangalore. Hate politics has no place in south India. Jai Hind.
South Indians are smarter than North Indians :)
and also arrogant and racist seems like
Bjp mukta dakshin bharath
See I don't give certificate like that but after emergency educated south voted for her.. so called Democratic.. mostly from kerela people joined isis..but I love dharma..
@@yogitashivhare2672 Most of India voted for her in 1980. Congress won 4
353 seats. How many people Joined ISIS from Kerala ? 100-200 or 1000? in a population of 4 Cr , it is a minority.
@@yogitashivhare2672 I am sure you contributed to earning of Kerala stories generously. I will suggest you to invest more in getting your information from more reliable sources like "Govt of Indian" instead of some cash grab propoganda instrument.
Gupta is so happy today.
Thanks Karnataka... Definitely India will follow you!
South India don't appreciate religion politics that easily compared to North. Atleadt now BJP should speak in terms of employment and development
Their only focus is appeasement of temple going majority of this country
Religious politics does work, otherwise BJP would have lost voters. BJP retained almost all the voters. The vote shift was from JDS to INC.
Lol South too busy with caste politics😂😂😂. Thats like a stupid statement to make.
MODI WON 26 OUT OF 28 LS SEATS IN 19.
DONT READ TOO MUCH
@@chatcricket1405 when bjp next time, idk what these people will say😂
Shekhar A brilliant analysis . I hope your lessons will be absorbed by all parties.
Shekhar! Sometimes you amaze the hell out. Hours and hours of TV debates across 100s of channels and you summarised it so well in less than 10 mins.
Which brings me to my next point. Cut your Cut the Clutters to 10 mins otherwise you get very repetitive
CTC depends on the subject. If the subject is not well known to the listeners, then explaining the CONTEXT does take time.
Thank you for the kind words. I am glad you liked this episode. As for shorter CTCs, it depends on the subject or issue. Some simply demand a longer run. But I take your point, and I will try to make them crisper. Thanks for watching...best wishes, Shekhar
@@ThePrintIndia Amazing episode Gupta ji. Please keep them running, I can watch hours of this.
Brilliant as usual Shekhar. The last but one comment on the Congress is apt. The Gandhis never learn. Should have left the leadership issue to the elected MLAs who would have made their choice through secret ballot. But that would have been expecting too much. The leadership only knows how to wade into avoidable trouble and deliver a disaster.Sad.
Very good analysis it clearly prove that diverse and secular majority hindu voter give more importance to local issues and good governence.
Modi cannot fool South Indians. We Are advanced.
Well said Shekhar. Karnataka elections were unique and issues at large were mostly local. The voters were at odds with the state govt over the "real issues" such as rampant corruption, inflation, employment et al rather than the fantasies propagated by BJ - Hijab, Halal, Hanuman rows. The BJP, as always, tried to bury these real issues under the carpet and underplay their own organizational troubles by the usual "winning formula" of fanning the communal flame. As you said polarization is truly a double edged sword.
We criticize Congress and rest to be "family owned" or dynastic - where the diktat is issued from the kitchen, but the BJP is proving to be another version of the same centralized power - centred around the supreme leader and his words the holy verses. And, this power centre would always keep the other power centres in his party under check - the Yogis n Himantas might have to clip their wings for the time being, Shivraj Singh could explain it better.
In short, the ripples of the election results might not reach the northern lands where the sangh's tried n tested formulas will work like magic for years to come.
Dei. Bomb. Election yellam summa..
Vote potta makkal perchana thirumna.. Inga election yae irukathu... Ella nattu makkalum oolga yudharkhalin Adimai kal.. Poli KArona Veruz nadagam itharku seerantha ootharanam...
Brilliantly expanded .and explained .
Muslim apeasment will not Work,
Supporting Hijab will not work
Now convert all Karnataka Hindus to Isl;am and start Halaaa business!
I hate print, but This analysis was really good. It's not biased
Thanks for this one. But you still need to make another one over Karnataka 2023 election, decluttering mostly the part played or not played by NCP and other new entrants in this election!
That was awesome, Shekhar. Full of insight, yet concise.
This indeed, is your metier. Well done, Sir.
Fantastic analysis.....BJP has to groom strong stalwarts in each state now.
you are living in fools paradise , modi does not tolerate any poppular state leader .
he wants all state elections modi centric . he will then appoint a useless fellow .
we will see how many states accept this model .
Absolutely true
No hope.
The pioneers of appeasement politics are back in power...Kudos !!
He looks super happy today as his favorite party won 😂😂😂
You don't force your opinion on him.
Bjp lost because of 40% commission
Even though my alignment is center to right but, I always watch this man's analysis..... It is always on point expect for a few instances.....
As always crisp, compact and clear analysis from SG Sahab. Long live SG Sahab.
Somehow SG doesn't think Owaisi, congress, SP does not do polarization, this is reserved word only for BJP, obvious this is unbiased journalism !!
The pain of Shekar ji can be felt today
Yes Sir . Thank you for this episode of your analysis.
How happy does SG appear today!!
Thankyou for this objective and no nonsense analysis Shekhar Gupta saab...
Crisp clear analysis as always....very well presented episode
Actually .... Hello, my northern friends Tippu is not your normal northern Islamic sultan ....he's different.....he's secular and mainly betrayed down by his own prime minister Purnayya, who is a Bramhin...
True
Yeah tell those to all families he killed
Melkote village in Karnataka didn't celebrate Diwali because Around 200 years ago, by the order of Tipu Sultan, around 800 Hindus were massacred in this small village of Melkote in Karnataka.
it does not matter
This happens if you study from WhatsApp. Karnataka voted for change due to weak local leadership. Not because BJP called out Tippu's cruelty
Thanks!
Dear Kumar,
Thank you for your generous contribution to ThePrint's journalism.
Very very well summarised!!!! ❤❤❤❤
Unbiased and very well put👍..please continue the same in future
The best shortest analysis!!!!
Your take on TIPU SULTAN takes the crown
Never heard a better analysis than this one. High Regards to you, Sir
Aaj to mullo ki party hai mast. 😂😂😂😂 pappu finally Jeet gaya 😭😭😂😂😂
Analysis aside, this is the happiest I've seen him in a while 😃
Shekhar Sir, even i hate you regarding your hatred for Modi and Right wing, but i salute you for your perfect analysis. even many of your presentations and analysis regarding political situations are perfect and bang on. thank you .
I am happy that politics is visibly competitive again with Bengal, Punjab, Himachal, now Karnataka going to opposition parties and unlike TMC in Bengal, the others were normal peaceful elections. Perhaps BJP has become complacent with TV media being lopsided, these defeats should ring some alarms. Hope Congress continues its efforts to revive itself at grassroots, it might put up a decent fight in 2024, of course they will need a coalition.
As long as Mr Kharge's given the freedom to lead, this can happen. The only thing is he should stop saying "Rahul Gandhi for PM!!"
You said true west Bengal is violence place now. But don't forget Bengal election is decided by rohingya muslim and Bangladeshi Muslim. This is so sad. Report of 2006 shows that Bangladeshi Muslim impact over 130 seat and this is 2023 think how much they influence today politics.
I also don't believe west Bengal election results because more than 2 crore voters are come from Bangladesh 😂😂
@@Learner_being My friend, the population of Bangladesh is 17 crore. If 2 crore moved to West Bengal, that is almost 12% population transfer ! That kind of movement of people did not happen even during and after world war in Europe. Total number of Rohingya that moved from Myanmar was around 10 lakh, of that 8 lakh are in Bangladesh and the rest are spread all over the world including middle east, indonesia, western countries etc.
There is no need for this paranoid fear of Bangladesh muslims. Their fertility is now well under replacement and they are an okay economy. The important point is that if the east of india, ie northeast states as well as Bihar and West bengal are to have thriving economies then trade and transit links with Bangladesh will be crucial. Even the Modi government understands this basic fact, that is why they have been courting them despite all the bluster.
@@joshua_ch very sharp point. cheers
@@joshua_ch bro ,this 2 crore record is said in Indian parliament.
I am not saying this by seeing biased reporting against India nation.
West Bengal already has beat Assam in terms of minorities population.
But i am sure this modi govt will also hide this record when census will be done in India.
There are many areas in Bengal where law didn't work.
And where law work, police man came from peaceful samaaj didn't acts
One point no 1 is talking - 1.freebies, 2.freebies, 3.freebies,4.freebies, 5.freebies!!!!!
Bjp didn't understand the emotions of karnataka at all, so even lingayats moved away... They always speak about making Hindi as a compulsory language which south India never accepts, Bringing Amul into Karnataka against locals protest which affected them heavily in rural areas today!! Despite all the support from lingayats they talked against limgayats especially RSS leafers like santosh and BJP national secretary C T Ravi.. Today C T Ravi defeated by Congress's Lingayat candidate!!! Almost 65 % lingayat strongholds are won by Congress's lingayat candidates.!!! They didn't respond to people's cry about 40% commission!! State leader are not bothered about anything thinking that Modi will help them to win the election but today almost all ministers are washed away in people's anger!!! Polarization doesn't work in karnataka except coastal and malnad parts rest of the state don't give damn to religion!!! If congress able to hold these many lingayats they will win 25+ loksabha seats like bjp of today... Totally congress washed away BJP with historical win after 30 years.
What will happen if PFI shifts it's Cadre to SDPI which is a local affiliate of Congress.
Congress promises: 75% reservation, 10,000 crore for development of minority religious structures, Old Pension Scheme ... Kudos to Lingayats!
Nothing will happen
@@_kartik_chauhan nothing is visible to people except 40% commission.
@@1008apocalypse1008 brother belive me BJP us the most corrupt party in karnataka so far!! Don't know what center was doing all these days! About lingayats, lingayat votes are divided not complete swing that is why BJP still holding the ground in 65 seats. In South religion card doesn't work again and again you must work and develop.. More than anything heavy corruption forced people to vote congress which is also a corrupt certainly not like BJP which was unbelievable, they looted the state in 3 years.
Sir, your way of narration is awesome. Thank you for all the effort you put into research and off course yours decades of knowledge following the politics and news in India !! Hatsoff !!!
Insightful as always....liked the directness with which you say the mainstream and dominant media is GODI...
First stop using the word Godi.
Salute, to the people of karnataka. They are so matured .
Superb 10 points! Show something for yourself, seems the message to all parties, other than sentiments, personalities, polarizations, authoritarianism, over-confidence.
Thanks!
@@Vizorfam in ur dreams pisslamic pigshit 😆
@@Vizorfam minorities are the ones disturbing peace in india
Thank you Narendra, for watching. I'm glad you liked this episode. Thank you also for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
Inc must set an example of good governance in Karnataka.
When one religious community votes one sided, and that is happening continuously for 70+ years...that is not counted as Polarization, communal politics ?? That party is the pioneer of appeasement politics. Take your guesses friends....these journalists really do not have anything to say other than polarization, communalism, blah blah blah...the effects of secular Nasha...
Jai Hind, mera Bharat Mahan...
Thanks, Mr. SG. for your judicious analysis.
But the question is whether Congress can give a better government.
I fear it can not.
Thank you people of Karanata for upholding Democracy by rejecting hatred and bigotry !
This is the real " Karnataka story " 🙏
Vipul Saha ready with different script
Lol🤣🤣...another stupid comment
I was literally waiting for this episode today!
Well done Karnataka 🎉🎉
I would like to add one more point : PMs emotional drama was missing in Karnataka rallies. PM getting emotional in UP and Gujarat rallies helped BJP.
Nice analysis. Congratulations. I hope the BJP leadership watches and listens to this. It has to mend its ways if it wants to win the 2024 Lok Sabha election. The Modi Government has done great to help the poor in India without any discrimination. But that is not enough. It has to give up its policy of divisiveness and negativity and lamenting the governments before 2014.
Yes, good analysis from Shekhar Gupta. It boggles the mind that the BJP high command wouldn't encourage the emergence of more Yogi Adityanaths and Himanta Biswa Sarma's, given the results they're producing. They seem to want weak state leaders who can be controlled from Delhi. Nah, Indian voters want their state leaders to be strong and locally-rooted. The BJP needs to recognize that strong state-level leaders not just ground its brand in strength at one more layer in the Indian federal makeup, but also create a new rung of leaders from which to find national leaders. I'm sure the BJP will turn things around though, because Modi-Shah are masters of adaptation.
Hopefully the "Crooked timber of new India" is being repaired, treated and arrested.Crooked intellectuals too help arrest it.
Now convert all Karnataka Hindus to Isl;am and start Halaaa business!
Interesting analysis. Thank you. Heartening lesson that not all the Indian electorate votes on communal politics. Hopefully a lesson to the Congress that governance matters and not glorifying the Gandhis.
Thank you, Jeremy. It should, ideally, be a lesson to all parties that governance matters. Thanks for watching and for supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar
Brilliant analysis, SG sir, massive respect 🫡 and full paisa vasool for my subscription ❤ your analysis about the horse traders (aka Gowda clan) was spot on, the epitaph also should read exactly what you said - non-ideologue power mongers !!
Thank you for the kind words. Do keep watching and sending us feedback...best wishes, Shekhar
Perfect Analysis Sir. 👍
BJP needs more good local leaders like yogi and annamalai. Good hearted competent clever people
Encounter specialist. UP people are illiterates that is why he is on the throne.
@Pierre In He is a person who withdrew cases against him instead of through legal process . He cannot do that since he calls himself an Yogi. Do you think Almighty can be fooled.
Rural agriculture families are against Modi rule. This will show in 2024 general elections.
Its quite obvious that Gupta ji was waiting for a long time to do this type of CTC 🙂
😂😂😂 You're right 👍😊
Shekhar aaya bhari bhari analysis laaya
Modi has been trying to win *vishwas* of Peacefuls for 10 years now. How many Peaceful votes did BJP actually get ?
😂😂😂😂😂😂11
They will vote for isis if given chance....80% are completely brainwashed
Most practical truth said thank you sir not right not left but correct❤
Today's video is just Jabardast.
Karnataka is minor setback for Hindutva but it was necessary.
Modi Shah need to learn that local leaders and local issues matter.
We should thank the people of Karnataka for their wisdom and wise choice.
Hope this serves like a wake up call for BJP🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩
How is setback for Hindutva.?? Don't mix poltics with religion.. Same mistake bjp did and they got big lesson
@@nirmal886
Islam spread because of politics.
Politics is always mixed with religion.
We are not blinded by secularism.
We vote BJP because of Hindutva.
Muslims don't vote BJP because of religion. They are secular because they are in minority.
But progress is also necessary.
Plain, simple and unapologetic.
@@abhishekjoshi4648 how islam spread by politics
@@abhishekjoshi4648 the day when bjp gives same importance to every religion.. Even Muslims will vote for BJP. Bjp should learn from Congress on how to be secular. Don't assume Only Hindutva votes matter or elections can be fought on basis on communal basis. Everyone will vote.. Come out communal hatred.. Work towards betterment of country..
Today people of karnataka slapped bjp in the face for spreading hatred. I hope every other state come to their senses..
You are not blinded by secularism.. You are blinded by the communal hatred.. Hope you understand..
This is the golden opportunity for Congress.. if this government does a good job, Karnataka will once again become fortress for Congress, we Kannadigas are fed up with the BJP's incompetent govt & it's one dimensional agenda to win votes..
Good on the K state to vote on performance than personalities. If everyone did this, there won’t be a need for polarized or controversial campaigns. Hope BJP learns a lesson and campaigns on their performance than religion