When Chief Justice India gives time limit for the Protesting Doctor. He ought to have also given same time limit for the govt to provide all the safety measures that are being demanded by the Doctors.
Strange that the CJI's judgement was lopsided. How could he order the jr. doctors to go back to work while giving an observation that the doctor's demands should also be met. But there was no time limit
Sounds like the CJI's is empertice with the TMC Gov. Which allowed another tongue twisting lawyer to hide the actual culprit. So it will go easy on the evil lady n not correct what is really wrong doing going on in there.
We (doctors and engineers) in America like Indian doctors standing up for each other and for doctor murdered in RG Kar Govt Hospital. These politicians needs to understand the power of doctors (God on earth). We are with every doctors in 🇮🇳 India.
Great show again Bharka. Very proud of that Jr doctors. Please keep fighting for what you stand for. We don't want another repeat of this horrendous crime again. We stand with you all for justice. Love from New Zealand
Cji instead of ordering removal of people responsible for tampering of evidence and many discrepancies in handling the body. CJI gives a bizarre order to doctors
Why is there a delay in solving the case , sheer ineptitude of the Govt to solve the rape and brutal murder of the young doctor at the RG Kar Govt Hospital. There is so many politicking by various parties, instead of bringing the culprit to book, Why the CBI handling the case is very tardy , please see that justice is given at the earliest.
Law will take its own course. But, why none so keen n interested to account their roles who interfered with it?? Its no back seater. None of the stakeholders from administration to judiciary shown honest intention to take them to task.
The medical college under the principal created a hostile environment for the junior doctors. He, with the help of his lieutenants (which includes a few doctors), the local police authorities, officials from govt health department, presumably under the direction of the health minister made sure all the evidences are carefully destroyed. The CBI will now go round and round and make a fool of themselves. The Court will be helpless in the absence of credible conclusive proofs, the victim's life will go in vain. As for the huge corruption, extortion, and the threat culture prevailing in the medical colleges, there will be a few peripheral changes for a few months. Bengal will never ever be able to come out of the firm grip of corruption and exploitation perpetrated by the current political dispensation.
Voters don't want to jump from the frying pan to the fire, but in reality that is exactly the script that has prevailed owing to the inability of the voters to look beyond self-interests. Divide and conquer works in many forms and preceded the British in India. We're witnessing the consequences of "vote banks" in our daily lives - immovable institutions that were corrupted (just like all over the world) because voters were not interested in establishing a level playing field. All of us "pray" that remediation and corrective actions will occur sooner rather than later, but what does history tell us?
Please encourage to focus on Doctor ABHAYA'S horrific murder case. So many twists and turns from mamata and her network of people. We need justice Please 🙏 😢
Mamata never resorts to twists & turns, she's the most straightforward lady. It is the opposition who sees red whenever something takes place in Bengal!
If both parties stick to their guns, this DEADLOCK would never be RESOLVED- This matter needs an objective- minded MEDIATOR, who could seek unanimity, Barkhadidi, and get it resolved,for starters.Reconciliation NEED to start.
Demanding Resignations is NOT A VIABLE OPTION, and totally UNPRODUCTIVE. What benefits could the protesters get? Just Hollow Revenge and Empty vindictiveness,? A LARGER CONSPIRACY Theory involving police chief should be on HOLD and the MAIN FOCUS SHOULD BE to co- operate with CBI and SC to end this case.Believe it, Justice to the Bereaved and sorrowing FATHER and MOTHER would ONLY BE Delayed and denied, if status-quo CONTINUES.....the Police Commissioner services are IMPERATIVE to crack this case.
It’s an important step for the entire country. People should not be happy with half baked security at government buildings. Hopefully this protest will alter peoples expectations from the government and also set an example for other states. If Mamta doesn’t agree to their demands then Bengal will continue to get shoddy services in all departments. People should not be happy with 3rd rate service.
So the CJI got a black eye along with Mamta Banerjee by being high handed . It was a good lesson for MR Kapil Sibal at this age , telling lies in court and mis representing facts . Is money such a big factor still at this age . He is giving a bad name to the legal fraternity.
Sibal is offering FREE training to defense lawyers via media broadcasts. There is nothing wrong with Sibal's actions if CJI permits these fantastical statements without an affidavit.
So proud of our junior docs of Bengal..... truly commendable ....also not allowing the opportunist political parties to appropriate the fight for justice for their obvious agenda
justice would only be delayed and denied if status quo continues. THIS is the TRUTH. PC suspension would Only MAKE THINGS WORSE and even, IRRETRIEVABLY, lost.
What an strategy by this govt . A horrible rape happens . All the evidence is wiped out and then CM says the matter should be handed to cbi . Khatam . Jo ukadhna hain ukhad lo . Wah ... and supreme court also in hand hand
System has become so corrupt, there is no hope for an average citizen. It’s obvious there was foul play, tampering of crime scene and the way they tried to protect that Principal. It’s a shame MB still continues to be the CM.
Surprisingly Supreme court asked doctors to stop one month's protest and join duty in 1 day....how they forgot to ask the govt to meet their demands in the same one day. Why Supreme court forgot to make either police/heath administration/ District collector to be accountable if any security breach happens when doctors return back to work. Why supreme court is unable to fastrack the case Why CBI is unable to come to a conclusion in the investigation
Why is cpim sidelined even though they also ruled and know the truth.But Mamta Banerjee and Modi is boycotting them so that they don't take the lead...
CJI has always passed stern remarks against Modi government but has dared not taking any action against. But in Kolkata rape and murder case he has not taken any action against either the West Bengal Police or Hospital people involved in the crime or the Mamta government who are also part of the crime along with the other two. Hope, CJI Chandrachud comes clean in this case because he is dealing with Bengali society and the students and not spineless politicians of India and his own people from judiciary.
With all the discrepancies still No police is sacked yet. No action Talk only. Mamata should resign. The hooligans who vandalised emergency unit,so far no punishment. Hospital for breaking and clearing crime site. CJI,is condescending by their order.
The West Bengal administration seems to have forgotten that doctors are among the most highly educated and capable people in the country. Because of an inept, corrupt and incapable administration, they are having to work in what can only be called a hideous environment with apalling working conditions that completely ignore prevention of sexual harrasment norms, and that completely ignore the need for security at the workplace (for patients as well). Yet these people will work for the public enduring 36 hour shifts while the king pins of the health mafia ride their big expensive cars and live in their villas. So, how did this come to be? It came to be not because of the cpm, or the brits or the moghuls, but because of the unbridled greed of the present incumbents. They are corrupt, incapable and they are running racket after racket. They should certainly be sacked (not held up by their suspenders). The present commissioner of police is the same person who mishandled the Kamdenu case, where a young girl was raped, murdered and burnt and there was no whodunnit. Perfect match with the present case and everybody knows why. So the educated and hardworking and sincere people protesting against this are lathicharged, teargassed, water cannoned, and stopped by 9 ft barricades. To add insult to injury, the cji of india 'orders' them to stop protesting without having followed through on any of the points raised in his first suo kapil hearing. The governor will spew a few shakespearean quotes and the central home ministry has completely forgotten that there is a remedy to the ills of West Bengal. Perhaps they will remember when they realise that the TMC is a local phenomenon. West Bengal can produce other and better home grown leaders, without the help of the TMC or the BJP. Yes, it will be rough but it will be done as the people are completely disillusioned with the present administration that has brought up one after another cases of corruption and complete lack of governance.
Okay just a thought of mine, among the 3 top judges of sc including the cji, i think atleast one of the seat must belong to a woman.... It will raise the chance of justice for crimes against woman..isnt it so?
Please please make sure safety in their work area priority so that its safe for every individual feel safe while working . Why is the system so bad and slow
CJI is the only person responsible for such a situation. The Suo moto case of Nirvaya murder and rape case was started where the state government lawer failed and fumbled in so many points but the vertict was passed against the junior doctors who are fighting for justice.
Mamta Banejeeri should definitely resign from her position she is unfit for the post as a chief minister she is the main person who is involved an covering up for the culprits involved in this brutal murder of an innocent beautiful student doctors Mamta Banejeeri pls resign in a respectful manner
May Amayayas soul rest in peace 🙏 sad to say that it took her deat to to make doctors to stand hand in hand to bring things to the surfice and God gives pòwer to the just. I am not a doctor but this could happen to any one .and now is the time for justice .
1)seeing the death body being a doctors didn’t they suspect it was not a natural death? 2) without calling police and informing family and file complaints in a fast track why not ? 3) why lie to her family that she was sick and she had attempted suicide? 4)why many people were gathered and tempering the crime scene? 5) why and where are the CC videos? 6)where are those patients and their family, that night on duty doctors nurses GD staffs,guards,doctors and vice versas why not under questioning and investigation? 7) why not a proper death certificate in order to be filled up to perform the Autopsy? And if the cause of the death would have been mentioned-cause of the death to be determined after medicolegal autopsy? 8)why was not an appropriate procedures if filing the case and informing cosent taken of her family to do remains procedures? 9) why the autopsy was taken care after an appropriate timeline? 10) where are the doctors gadgets and her clothes and so called food packets as we heard she had food with her juniors Why not thoroughly investigated? 11) why West Bengal government didn’t protect RGKar while goons entered and thrash everything? 12)why West Bengal police intelligence were not aware about thousands and tones of goons? 13) why only hitting and stopping silent protest of healthcare workers? There are multiple questions and why not being answered by the government?
DEAR BARKHA, I ADMIRE YOUR TENACITY TO CONTINUOUSLY HOLDING ON REPORT OF THIS SAD INCIDENCE. AS A DOCTOR, I HAD REGULARLY ATTENDED CONFERENCES. IN ADDITION TO PRESENTATIONS BY THE SPEAKERS THERE USED TO BE MANY INFORMAL DISCUSSIONS AND AMONG OURSELVES WE DISCUSSED OUR OWN PROBLEMS. ALSO WE MADE PERMANENT CONNECTIONS WITH TERTIARY CARE DOCTORS AND OUR FELO-ATTENDEES. ALTHOUGH SUCH RELATIONS EXIST IN BJP- CHIEF MINISTERS, " THE INDI ALLIANCE CMS" SEEM TO BE "FULL OF THEMSELVES". MAMATA IS EXTREMELY ARROGANT, EXTREMELY NARROW-MINDED AND VERY RUDE - NOT ONLY WITH MODIJI BUT WITH ALL NATIONAL LEADERS! HAD SHE BEEN ATTENDING CHIEF-MINISTERS' CONFERANCES CALLED BY MODIJI, SHE WOULD HAVE HAD SOLVED THIS CRISIS LONG AGO! THANKS
We lost respect an trust in Mamta Banejeeri she is untrustable she has to resign resign resign Mamta Banejeeri you are not fit Doctors pls continue the protest until your demands are in favor 🙏🙏🙏 blessings an support to each one of your'll the protesters 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Not only West Bengal doctors ,the doctors from all over India as well as other countries are standing in support of them
When Chief Justice India gives time limit for the Protesting Doctor. He ought to have also given same time limit for the govt to provide all the safety measures that are being demanded by the Doctors.
Strange that the CJI's judgement was lopsided. How could he order the jr. doctors to go back to work while giving an observation that the doctor's demands should also be met. But there was no time limit
CJI didn't gave time to Doctors whereas CJI gave one week time to sibal for creating the missing challan subsequently 😥😥
Sounds like the CJI's is empertice with the TMC Gov. Which allowed another tongue twisting lawyer to hide the actual culprit. So it will go easy on the evil lady n not correct what is really wrong doing going on in there.
Thanks Barkha for keeping this issue alive by doing shows daily
Keep up the good work
Justice delayed is justice denied. We demand justice
No Communications ! Only Resignations ! Who is CJ to order doctors to return to work ? He should do his job first !
Why do all the culprits easily get Sibbal as their lawyer
Money power
Because Jethmalani is not available
When money speaks the truth keeps silent
We (doctors and engineers) in America like Indian doctors standing up for each other and for doctor murdered in RG Kar Govt Hospital. These politicians needs to understand the power of doctors (God on earth). We are with every doctors in 🇮🇳 India.
Thank you may God bless you and your family 🎉🎉
Mamata govt should be dismissed. Justice for doctor PG, the victim.
Great show again Bharka. Very proud of that Jr doctors. Please keep fighting for what you stand for. We don't want another repeat of this horrendous crime again. We stand with you all for justice. Love from New Zealand
Cji instead of ordering removal of people responsible for tampering of evidence and many discrepancies in handling the body. CJI gives a bizarre order to doctors
tehy took suomoto to take away the case from kolkata HC as they were doing a hood job at holding TMC accountable..
Everyone is lying. Didi is certainly lying.
Modiji lies, not Mamata !
@@dibyendupaul1572 CHUP CHOTICHATA!
Shutup TMC goon@@dibyendupaul1572
@@dibyendupaul1572bullshit
@@dibyendupaul1572 now tell me how, have something substantial to prove whatever you say!!!
We want justice for our doctor didi 😢😢
Why is there a delay in solving the case , sheer ineptitude of the Govt to solve the rape and brutal murder of the young doctor at the RG Kar Govt Hospital. There is so many politicking by various parties, instead of bringing the culprit to book, Why the CBI handling the case is very tardy , please see that justice is given at the earliest.
Law will take its own course. But, why none so keen n interested to account their roles who interfered with it?? Its no back seater. None of the stakeholders from administration to judiciary shown honest intention to take them to task.
Weeeeeeeeee wanttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt Justiceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee😡😡😡
In any case Begum has nothing to do with Durga Pujo
The medical college under the principal created a hostile environment for the junior doctors. He, with the help of his lieutenants (which includes a few doctors), the local police authorities, officials from govt health department, presumably under the direction of the health minister made sure all the evidences are carefully destroyed. The CBI will now go round and round and make a fool of themselves. The Court will be helpless in the absence of credible conclusive proofs, the victim's life will go in vain. As for the huge corruption, extortion, and the threat culture prevailing in the medical colleges, there will be a few peripheral changes for a few months. Bengal will never ever be able to come out of the firm grip of corruption and exploitation perpetrated by the current political dispensation.
ETA AR HOTE DEBO NA AMRA....WE ARE THE YOUTH POWER...
Voters don't want to jump from the frying pan to the fire, but in reality that is exactly the script that has prevailed owing to the inability of the voters to look beyond self-interests. Divide and conquer works in many forms and preceded the British in India. We're witnessing the consequences of "vote banks" in our daily lives - immovable institutions that were corrupted (just like all over the world) because voters were not interested in establishing a level playing field. All of us "pray" that remediation and corrective actions will occur sooner rather than later, but what does history tell us?
Don't go in a few numbers. Ask the government representatives come out meet them. Your safety first
The Public should take over the case.
Please encourage to focus on Doctor ABHAYA'S horrific murder case.
So many twists and turns from mamata and her network of people. We need justice Please 🙏 😢
Mamata never resorts to twists & turns, she's the most straightforward lady.
It is the opposition who sees red whenever something takes place in Bengal!
@@dibyendupaul1572 CHUP CHOTICHATA!!!
If both parties stick to their guns, this DEADLOCK would never be RESOLVED- This matter needs an objective- minded MEDIATOR, who could seek unanimity, Barkhadidi, and get it resolved,for starters.Reconciliation NEED to start.
Demanding Resignations is NOT A VIABLE OPTION, and totally UNPRODUCTIVE.
What benefits could the protesters get? Just Hollow Revenge and Empty vindictiveness,?
A LARGER CONSPIRACY Theory involving police chief should be on HOLD and the MAIN FOCUS SHOULD BE to co- operate with CBI and SC to end this case.Believe it, Justice to the Bereaved and sorrowing FATHER and MOTHER would ONLY BE Delayed and denied, if status-quo CONTINUES.....the Police Commissioner services are IMPERATIVE to crack this case.
Completely missed the main issue- doctors do not want a closed door meeting, they want it to be televised live which Mamata rejected
Kudos to you sir,we want justice
If this case is not solved, there could be another prey....
More cases... More money
Those who committed crime will go free, those who demand justice will be punished. Wah. But are they not afraid of the ultimate judge...
What about the safety of common women who are not doctors?
She said hung in ten days but now one month a ready 😅😅
honourable cm mamta or dishonorable cm nirmamta?
Support the junior doctors❤
It’s an important step for the entire country.
People should not be happy with half baked security at government buildings.
Hopefully this protest will alter peoples expectations from the government and also set an example for other states.
If Mamta doesn’t agree to their demands then Bengal will continue to get shoddy services in all departments.
People should not be happy with 3rd rate service.
Sc appeared to balm a deep wound not looking how far the abscess has gone. The agitators are canned, not a morsel to those who played with law.
TRUE SIR!
So the CJI got a black eye along with Mamta Banerjee by being high handed . It was a good lesson for MR Kapil Sibal at this age , telling lies in court and mis representing facts . Is money such a big factor still at this age . He is giving a bad name to the legal fraternity.
Exactly
Sibal is offering FREE training to defense lawyers via media broadcasts. There is nothing wrong with Sibal's actions if CJI permits these fantastical statements without an affidavit.
People who are rich are greedy money only matters for them
So proud of our junior docs of Bengal..... truly commendable ....also not allowing the opportunist political parties to appropriate the fight for justice for their obvious agenda
Thanks BArka mam
justice would only be delayed and denied if status quo continues. THIS is the TRUTH.
PC suspension would Only MAKE THINGS WORSE and even, IRRETRIEVABLY, lost.
I am sure TMC is involved
What an strategy by this govt . A horrible rape happens . All the evidence is wiped out and then CM says the matter should be handed to cbi . Khatam . Jo ukadhna hain ukhad lo . Wah ... and supreme court also in hand hand
Not only police chief will be sacked but WB CM has to step down/resign @ the same time!!!
System has become so corrupt, there is no hope for an average citizen. It’s obvious there was foul play, tampering of crime scene and the way they tried to protect that Principal. It’s a shame MB still continues to be the CM.
It's now no longer protests for justice but thanks Mamata for making it a "People vs Dictator" movement
India kadu all World jastess jastess jastess jastess jastess doctor 😢😮
Lots of respect for you barkha
Surprisingly Supreme court asked doctors to stop one month's protest and join duty in 1 day....how they forgot to ask the govt to meet their demands in the same one day.
Why Supreme court forgot to make either police/heath administration/ District collector to be accountable if any security breach happens when doctors return back to work.
Why supreme court is unable to fastrack the case
Why CBI is unable to come to a conclusion in the investigation
Why is cpim sidelined even though they also ruled and know the truth.But Mamta Banerjee and Modi is boycotting them so that they don't take the lead...
In 1 incident, the movement of self-interested women of anti-Muslim West Bengal is going on, but where are these violent groups in Muslim Rape?
We want justice.Mamta must Resign.
Only solution to this impasse - #stepdownmamata
❤❤❤❤🙏👍
CJI has always passed stern remarks against Modi government but has dared not taking any action against. But in Kolkata rape and murder case he has not taken any action against either the West Bengal Police or Hospital people involved in the crime or the Mamta government who are also part of the crime along with the other two.
Hope, CJI Chandrachud comes clean in this case because he is dealing with Bengali society and the students and not spineless politicians of India and his own people from judiciary.
With all the discrepancies still No police is sacked yet.
No action Talk only.
Mamata should resign.
The hooligans who vandalised emergency unit,so far no punishment.
Hospital for breaking and clearing crime site.
CJI,is condescending by their order.
The West Bengal administration seems to have forgotten that doctors are among the most highly educated and capable people in the country. Because of an inept, corrupt and incapable administration, they are having to work in what can only be called a hideous environment with apalling working conditions that completely ignore prevention of sexual harrasment norms, and that completely ignore the need for security at the workplace (for patients as well). Yet these people will work for the public enduring 36 hour shifts while the king pins of the health mafia ride their big expensive cars and live in their villas. So, how did this come to be? It came to be not because of the cpm, or the brits or the moghuls, but because of the unbridled greed of the present incumbents. They are corrupt, incapable and they are running racket after racket. They should certainly be sacked (not held up by their suspenders). The present commissioner of police is the same person who mishandled the Kamdenu case, where a young girl was raped, murdered and burnt and there was no whodunnit. Perfect match with the present case and everybody knows why. So the educated and hardworking and sincere people protesting against this are lathicharged, teargassed, water cannoned, and stopped by 9 ft barricades. To add insult to injury, the cji of india 'orders' them to stop protesting without having followed through on any of the points raised in his first suo kapil hearing. The governor will spew a few shakespearean quotes and the central home ministry has completely forgotten that there is a remedy to the ills of West Bengal. Perhaps they will remember when they realise that the TMC is a local phenomenon. West Bengal can produce other and better home grown leaders, without the help of the TMC or the BJP. Yes, it will be rough but it will be done as the people are completely disillusioned with the present administration that has brought up one after another cases of corruption and complete lack of governance.
The Picture of Mamata Banerjee's protest is designated here in Bengal as " Protest against Malaria by Mosquitos!"
We should stand with each other just not West Bengal all over the world 🌎
This doctor was not just raped and murdered, she was silenced. She knew too much.
👍👍👍👍👍🕉🔱🙏🇮🇳 jai Hind👍
Okay just a thought of mine, among the 3 top judges of sc including the cji, i think atleast one of the seat must belong to a woman.... It will raise the chance of justice for crimes against woman..isnt it so?
Please please make sure safety in their work area priority so that its safe for every individual feel safe while working . Why is the system so bad and slow
CJI is the only person responsible for such a situation. The Suo moto case of Nirvaya murder and rape case was started where the state government lawer failed and fumbled in so many points but the vertict was passed against the junior doctors who are fighting for justice.
Sumoto of case itself is conspiracy
Honorable CM
who ???
Mamta ??? She is the worst CM don’t call her honorable she doesn’t deserve that
Mamta Banejeeri should definitely resign from her position she is unfit for the post as a chief minister she is the main person who is involved an covering up for the culprits involved in this brutal murder of an innocent beautiful student doctors
Mamta Banejeeri pls resign in a respectful manner
May Amayayas soul rest in peace 🙏 sad to say that it took her deat to to make doctors to stand hand in hand to bring things to the surfice and God gives pòwer to the just. I am not a doctor but this could happen to any one .and now is the time for justice .
1)seeing the death body being a doctors didn’t they suspect it was not a natural death?
2) without calling police and informing family and file complaints in a fast track why not ?
3) why lie to her family that she was sick and she had attempted suicide?
4)why many people were gathered and tempering the crime scene?
5) why and where are the CC videos?
6)where are those patients and their family, that night on duty doctors nurses GD staffs,guards,doctors and vice versas why not under questioning and investigation?
7) why not a proper death certificate in order to be filled up to perform the Autopsy? And if the cause of the death would have been mentioned-cause of the death to be determined after medicolegal autopsy?
8)why was not an appropriate procedures if filing the case and informing cosent taken of her family to do remains procedures?
9) why the autopsy was taken care after an appropriate timeline?
10) where are the doctors gadgets and her clothes and so called food packets as we heard she had food with her juniors
Why not thoroughly investigated?
11) why West Bengal government didn’t protect RGKar while goons entered and thrash everything?
12)why West Bengal police intelligence were not aware about thousands and tones of goons?
13) why only hitting and stopping silent protest of healthcare workers?
There are multiple questions and why not being answered by the government?
DEAR BARKHA, I ADMIRE YOUR TENACITY TO CONTINUOUSLY HOLDING ON REPORT OF THIS SAD INCIDENCE.
AS A DOCTOR, I HAD REGULARLY ATTENDED CONFERENCES. IN ADDITION TO PRESENTATIONS BY THE SPEAKERS THERE USED TO BE MANY INFORMAL DISCUSSIONS AND AMONG OURSELVES WE DISCUSSED OUR OWN PROBLEMS. ALSO WE MADE PERMANENT CONNECTIONS WITH TERTIARY CARE DOCTORS AND OUR FELO-ATTENDEES.
ALTHOUGH SUCH RELATIONS EXIST IN BJP- CHIEF MINISTERS, " THE INDI ALLIANCE CMS" SEEM TO BE "FULL OF THEMSELVES". MAMATA IS EXTREMELY ARROGANT, EXTREMELY NARROW-MINDED AND VERY RUDE - NOT ONLY WITH MODIJI BUT WITH ALL NATIONAL LEADERS! HAD SHE BEEN ATTENDING CHIEF-MINISTERS' CONFERANCES CALLED BY MODIJI, SHE WOULD HAVE HAD SOLVED THIS CRISIS LONG AGO!
THANKS
BJP is silent in manipur case😂
Only political motive is seen in kolkata rape n murder case, BJP trying to cover up,, shame shame..
Good work
We lost respect an trust in Mamta Banejeeri she is untrustable she has to resign resign resign Mamta Banejeeri you are not fit
Doctors pls continue the protest until your demands are in favor 🙏🙏🙏 blessings an support to each one of your'll the protesters 🙏🙏🙏🙏