The level of knowledge has decreased and it is supported by the fact that the official fiba rules are poorly written open to many interpretations and usually the official interpretations are still not clear. It is no coincidence that FIBA (I don't know about the NBA) does not have the training videos of the referees open to the public. For example, the 3 seconds have been removed from being whistled almost everywhere in the FIBA and euroleage games. Of course, it is not entirely the fault of the referees as we also have the unofficial instructions to the referees.
Agree.. Training videos for referees should be open or accessible for other referees. Now I´m also hearing about total change of focus in area of responsability in 3po but it´s only been shown to refs in national youth tournaments around the world. Others have to wait.
Thank you for your sharing. I am curious to know if the video was officially released by FIBA or if it was just a fan-edited clip, as I noticed several calls made by the referee in the video were incorrect. 4:28
4:28 is correct. Gains control slightly before his left touches the ground. So left foot becomes pivot. And you can't lift your pivot before dribbling. Travel.
@@CoachFrikki Rules before 2017 While moving: ▬ To start a dribble, the pivot foot may not be lifted before the ball is released from the hand(s). Rules after 2017 A player who catches the ball while he is progressing, or upon completion of a dribble, may take two steps in coming to a stop, passing or shooting the ball: If, after receiving the ball, a player shall release the ball to start his dribble before his second step. The left foot does not control the ball in the video. 012 The steps passed without stopping.There is no pivot foot formation.
@@王阿捲 @CoachFrikki I think it's correct too. We don't know what the ref saw but maybe the 0 step was granted on the step before when his hand touch the ball (although does it count as control?). I think the spirit of the 2017 rule change is more to granted some flexibility on the feet that is already on the ground or near the ground in regards of completion of a drible or catching a pass. Using that rule to get a full 3 steps was not the intent, i believe. But who knows. And player will game the system. In the end, i have no problem that call. I think he has control of the ball and a pivot foot when his left feet is on the ground. I can then start an action a dribble or a pass (or a shot). Looks like he jump from his pivot feet and tried to pass but then change his mind. That would caugh my eye if I was the referee.
@@Talisk3r If, after receiving the ball, a player shall release the ball to start his dribble before his second step. The player did not stop so there was no pivot foot.
He catches the ball with his right foot on the floor, then does a little hop with that foot, so he made it look worse because he rushed; I think the call is ok.
@@fromtheoutside I noticed that black people often do this. They often make mini jumps or both leg movements just moments before actually starting the dribble.
I can only come up with his pivot slid before he stepped with his right foot. Other than that, he goes Left (0) -right (1) -left (2), then steps through with his right.
@@einargun Thank you for your comment. I also made a similar mistake when I was playing basketball. We did a lot of drills for that. Do you blow the whistle under NBA rules? I feel like Luka and Anthony Edwards(MINNESOTA TIMBERWOLVES) is often criticized for traveling in international tournaments.
A close call. He received the ball mid air just moments before stepping with the right foot, what would count as the first step. Then proceeds with the second step, and continues dribbling. If he received it with the right foot on the floor , or if he shot/passed after the second step, it would've been ok.
these fiba rule is bit ridiculous, especially on the one at 4:17, and this one I also have to put it on 0.25 speed to see it, basically means that u can’t pick the ball while u are running, very absurd, look at the one at 5:52, slow as Duncic also get called lol
I saw it multiples times at 0.25 in order to understand it, basically he did the gather step wrong, he picked up the ball before his left foot hit the floor which turned it into a step 1 instead of step 0.
The Trail doesn't have a very good angle, so it looks like the ball is in his hands sooner than it really was. So, I think the official having decided that, then it would make it a travel because, as @HoopsOfficial stated, he lands on the same left foot he used to jump at the first step.
It's impossible to say from this angle. We don't know if he picked the ball up with his left foot on the ground (travel) or both feet in the air (legal).
@@einargun i have to correct myself. he cought the ball midair, therefore left food is step one (pivot as you said), therefore it is a travel - good call
@@cologneconductor8591 I´m glad you look at these clips with critical eyes. Not all calls are correct in these compilations so you have to look at them from the rule book. Comment as much as you like and keep working on your ref game. Thank you.
I think FIBA should explain the footsteps. ua-cam.com/video/vXrp9y17Lkw/v-deo.html Following the video, the same footsteps is not travel in 5:33 I think the rule has not been changed.
@@einargun travel; Pivot foot rule 25.2.1., before either foot touches the ground, he shoots or passes the ball. When he lifts his pivot foot, the other foot is on the ground.
@@rogerhuang9760 How do you do a lay up then? Forget de gather/zero step. You end your dribble by putting 2 hands on the ball. The feet on the ground is your pivot foot. You jump to your other foot (which will touch the ground before after your pivot foot quit the ground and before you lay up the ball). Then you lay up the ball. I think what the ref saw was that when the player put 2 hand on the ball he has his left foot on the ground. The other foot is still in the air. The he use is left foot to perform a great pivot and then a clean step-trough. If both feet were on the gournd when it put 2 hand on the ball it would have been clean/perfect.
I agrre with you. I think what the ref saw was that when the player put 2 hand on the ball he has his left foot on the ground. The other foot is still in the air. The he use is left foot to perform a great pivot and then a clean step-trough. If both feet were on the gournd when it put 2 hand on the ball it would have been clean/perfect.
@@Talisk3r Layup 012 is a continuous action. When both feet touch the ground and the hands are holding the ball, it has nothing to do with 012. Instead, use the 25.2.1. Pivot foot rule. Both feet touch the ground, and the extra step has nothing to do with the layup.
you are doing a great job, keep doing and educate us ,thankyou
Thank you for the compliment. Glad this is useful. Enjoy :-)
Unsurprisingly, half of the travels got called on USA team
Not only that, some of the players of other nations that 'traveled' are NBA players.
@@ezekielvaldez7222 🤣
@@ezekielvaldez7222 Well, it's not "traveled", it's traveled because NBA uses the incorrect rules.
@@DataLog pardon my misuse of the quotation marks. I just want to empasize the word. :D
it makes sense, they're used to different rules
After watching a lot of NBA playoff games I needed this video to reconcile myself with real Basketball.
Yes, NBA is terrible.
Watching this just tells me that there's travelling on every single play in the NBA.
Exactly. Bad habits have gone to a huge extend because nothing is being called nowadays
Every single play, but they have their own rules ...only country that doesn't use FIBA rules.
Travels will be called! Even if they look like travelling...
thats NBA made tha USA team almost got the call😂😅😊
I had to remove a lot of USA clips because of copyrights.
Travell pivot foot
Traveling ref nice call🏀🏀
Lol, love how everyone just accepts the call like they know.
The level of knowledge has decreased and it is supported by the fact that the official fiba rules are poorly written open to many interpretations and usually the official interpretations are still not clear. It is no coincidence that FIBA (I don't know about the NBA) does not have the training videos of the referees open to the public. For example, the 3 seconds have been removed from being whistled almost everywhere in the FIBA and euroleage games. Of course, it is not entirely the fault of the referees as we also have the unofficial instructions to the referees.
Agree.. Training videos for referees should be open or accessible for other referees. Now I´m also hearing about total change of focus in area of responsability in 3po but it´s only been shown to refs in national youth tournaments around the world. Others have to wait.
This is good example
Would be great to see how many carry calls are there)
0:32 this is how jimmy butler dominated so many games
Thank you for your sharing. I am curious to know if the video was officially released by FIBA or if it was just a fan-edited clip, as I noticed several calls made by the referee in the video were incorrect. 4:28
4:28 is correct. Gains control slightly before his left touches the ground. So left foot becomes pivot. And you can't lift your pivot before dribbling. Travel.
@@CoachFrikki Rules before 2017 While moving:
▬ To start a dribble, the pivot foot may not be lifted before the ball is released
from the hand(s).
Rules after 2017 A player who catches the ball while he is progressing, or upon completion of a dribble, may take two steps in coming to a stop, passing or shooting the ball:
If, after receiving the ball, a player shall release the ball to start his dribble
before his second step.
The left foot does not control the ball in the video. 012 The steps passed without stopping.There is no pivot foot formation.
@@王阿捲 I stand corrected. Stupid rule though in my opinion though. Do they define "progressing"?
@@王阿捲 @CoachFrikki I think it's correct too. We don't know what the ref saw but maybe the 0 step was granted on the step before when his hand touch the ball (although does it count as control?). I think the spirit of the 2017 rule change is more to granted some flexibility on the feet that is already on the ground or near the ground in regards of completion of a drible or catching a pass. Using that rule to get a full 3 steps was not the intent, i believe. But who knows. And player will game the system.
In the end, i have no problem that call. I think he has control of the ball and a pivot foot when his left feet is on the ground. I can then start an action a dribble or a pass (or a shot). Looks like he jump from his pivot feet and tried to pass but then change his mind. That would caugh my eye if I was the referee.
@@Talisk3r If, after receiving the ball, a player shall release the ball to start his dribble
before his second step.
The player did not stop so there was no pivot foot.
Watching these calls is more entertaining then current day NBA basketball
Zero step my shorts! LOL
Zero step is made up
What 4:03? PIVOT foot established?
He catches the ball with his right foot on the floor, then does a little hop with that foot, so he made it look worse because he rushed; I think the call is ok.
He shook a bit with that right foot, pretty ridiculous to call on that I agree
@@fromtheoutside I noticed that black people often do this.
They often make mini jumps or both leg movements just moments before actually starting the dribble.
@@zshawn676 It's absolutely necessary to call this, I see it too often.
1:30 is clean
I can only come up with his pivot slid before he stepped with his right foot. Other than that, he goes Left (0) -right (1) -left (2), then steps through with his right.
@@fromtheoutside I see what you are saying but to me he doesn't slide the pivot foot, he only lifts it quite close to the ground looking like a slide.
Agree. This is not travel.
His left foot slipped.
It's a one-two hop step. On a hop step, both feet have to come down simultaneously. So travel
Some of those are not travel. Maybe refs call those without clearly seeing but just guessing from their experience.
5:51 Luka's Traveling
Left foot is his pivot foot. He must start the dribble before he lifts the left foot.
@@einargun Thank you for your comment.
I also made a similar mistake when I was playing basketball. We did a lot of drills for that.
Do you blow the whistle under NBA rules? I feel like Luka and Anthony Edwards(MINNESOTA TIMBERWOLVES) is often criticized for traveling in international tournaments.
Could somebody tell me why Anthony Edward got a travel call at 1:59?
I think he held the ball while taking multiple quick steps.
Although he got called again at 4:17 and it looked like he got the ball on the floor as quick as he could. Lol
A close call. He received the ball mid air just moments before stepping with the right foot, what would count as the first step. Then proceeds with the second step, and continues dribbling. If he received it with the right foot on the floor , or if he shot/passed after the second step, it would've been ok.
these fiba rule is bit ridiculous, especially on the one at 4:17, and this one I also have to put it on 0.25 speed to see it, basically means that u can’t pick the ball while u are running, very absurd, look at the one at 5:52, slow as Duncic also get called lol
I saw it multiples times at 0.25 in order to understand it, basically he did the gather step wrong, he picked up the ball before his left foot hit the floor which turned it into a step 1 instead of step 0.
0:00 Agressivity?
Not sure why she said that. Thank you for watching 🙂
Sana ganyan din tawagan sa NBA
Kaso hindi po eh. Karamihan ng mga natawagan dito sa video ay mga naglalaro pa man din sa NBA.
How about 3:47 ? any opinions ? Looks like 0-1-2 to me...
Not sure if FIBA has the 0-1-2 step rule.
Lands on the same left foot he used to jump at the first step. Travel.
The Trail doesn't have a very good angle, so it looks like the ball is in his hands sooner than it really was. So, I think the official having decided that, then it would make it a travel because, as @HoopsOfficial stated, he lands on the same left foot he used to jump at the first step.
Correct, same foot is a travel.
It's impossible to say from this angle. We don't know if he picked the ball up with his left foot on the ground (travel) or both feet in the air (legal).
first is a bad call, player ist allowed to do two step to shot or pass the ball. only way to be that a travel is him starting to dribble
I think it´s the right call. Pivot foot is left and he release without drippling or shooting
@@einargun but he passed the ball what is categorized the same way as shooting is
@@einargun i have to correct myself. he cought the ball midair, therefore left food is step one (pivot as you said), therefore it is a travel - good call
@@cologneconductor8591 I´m glad you look at these clips with critical eyes. Not all calls are correct in these compilations so you have to look at them from the rule book. Comment as much as you like and keep working on your ref game. Thank you.
4:01, can someone explain why this is travel?
oh is it because his non pivot foot (left in this case) has to land after the ball is released form his hand?
@@kostasskoulidas6549 He lifts up his pivot foot before drippling the ball. But it is very tight call.
1:30 that's not travelling
2:12 is not travel
It is traveling. Pivot foot is lifted before the dribbling starts.
r u kidding?
0:49 is legal. 2:12 is travel. The two actions are different.
@@王阿捲 I disagree. both are travel since both jumped to shoot.
@@ezekielvaldez7222 The key point is whether the player is moving before catch the ball.
The rule of travel does not care about the shooting action.
I think FIBA should explain the footsteps.
ua-cam.com/video/vXrp9y17Lkw/v-deo.html
Following the video, the same footsteps is not travel in 5:33
I think the rule has not been changed.
Jus because the ref blows the whistle does not mean its the correct call!!
correct 🙂
Give us portions of this video that you question.
@@ezekielvaldez7222ant 1:59
5:32 is clean, kept the pivot and stepped through.
@@einargun travel; Pivot foot rule 25.2.1., before either foot touches the ground, he shoots or passes the ball. When he lifts his pivot foot, the other foot is on the ground.
@@einargun Not every step through is legal.
@@rogerhuang9760 How do you do a lay up then? Forget de gather/zero step. You end your dribble by putting 2 hands on the ball. The feet on the ground is your pivot foot. You jump to your other foot (which will touch the ground before after your pivot foot quit the ground and before you lay up the ball). Then you lay up the ball.
I think what the ref saw was that when the player put 2 hand on the ball he has his left foot on the ground. The other foot is still in the air. The he use is left foot to perform a great pivot and then a clean step-trough. If both feet were on the gournd when it put 2 hand on the ball it would have been clean/perfect.
I agrre with you. I think what the ref saw was that when the player put 2 hand on the ball he has his left foot on the ground. The other foot is still in the air. The he use is left foot to perform a great pivot and then a clean step-trough. If both feet were on the gournd when it put 2 hand on the ball it would have been clean/perfect.
@@Talisk3r Layup 012 is a continuous action. When both feet touch the ground and the hands are holding the ball, it has nothing to do with 012. Instead, use the 25.2.1. Pivot foot rule.
Both feet touch the ground, and the extra step has nothing to do with the layup.