p&s defender a pretender when it comes to durability?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 150

  • @DETAILSofficial
    @DETAILSofficial Рік тому +8

    Great video and breakdown 👌. I'm noticing on our maintenance vehicles with ph neutral soaps this stuff is holding up extremely well after a month so far. On heavily soiled vehicles that need a pre wash solution that's a bit stronger the hydrophobic properties begin to breakdown. But like you said, it's a solid sealant at an affordable price. 👌

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +4

      You were my muse for this video! I appreciate you being the pioneer and it is a solid sealant just if it had film , grime etc it will diminish over time

  • @ulyssesluevano257
    @ulyssesluevano257 Рік тому +6

    I think this would be a good topper and not a stand alone sealant. Eddie is always bringing the unbiased reviews! Thanks bro!

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +2

      It’s good just not super chemical resistant

    • @ulyssesluevano257
      @ulyssesluevano257 Рік тому +2

      @@Ecdetails it’s a little better than beadmaker then. Still a decent option for some people.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@ulyssesluevano257 for sure

  • @taip9040
    @taip9040 Рік тому +3

    Always appreciate your unbiased opinions. Another great one.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Appreciate you! Thank you for the support

  • @millerdetailing4176
    @millerdetailing4176 Рік тому +2

    Great and honest review Eddie . Thanks for the content and congrats on the 1000 mark almost there.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Hey 👋 thank you , and I am excited to hit the good ole 1000 appreciate your support

  • @TheHairyHouseWife
    @TheHairyHouseWife Рік тому +2

    Broo been watching your videos for last few hours .... Love it ❤

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +2

      Bro you are amazing man thank you for the support

    • @TheHairyHouseWife
      @TheHairyHouseWife Рік тому

      @@Ecdetails Keep it up man great content honestly

  • @barrycook8116
    @barrycook8116 Рік тому +1

    Quick beads protection was gone after I week of application and spraying a megs degreaser on there. I did the same thing to defender and he held up. These tests I take with grain of salt.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Oh for sure my experience is mine and like is aid it’s still good but if you live in areas where salt and chloride exist for winter it’s not lasting

    • @barrycook8116
      @barrycook8116 Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails most stand alone spray sealants will not unless their is a coating on their first. I have seen many spray sealants in Florida that are all hype up not last but maybe 2 washes with the heat and rain.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@barrycook8116 I have a few that hold up , I think I have enough for you to test if you want me to send it. Nv jet ,nv lustre and op creamic detailer

    • @barrycook8116
      @barrycook8116 Рік тому +2

      @@Ecdetails i have all of those. I love NV products. Personally for me I like real world testing. I text our products on my neighbors car because it sits outside in the sun and rain. Usually if a protection fails I just take 10 seconds to reapply it to that area. I don’t think P&S is hype like most people. There are just so many factors when it comes to testing and products fail. People freak out over one test. That’s just me.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@barrycook8116 💯 percent agree , and as I mentioned it’s a sealant it’s not meant to be more then that. And I reapplied after the test I like the gloss and slickness nothing more nothing less

  • @atdautospa
    @atdautospa Рік тому +1

    Great video and appreciate the effort to make the content. Without being too negative this is exactly the reason at our shop that I market “5 year coatings” as 2-3 years, and 9 year coatings (Crystal Serum Ultra ) as a 5 year. I would much rather under promise and over deliver whenever possible. Ceramic Pro sport which is actually developed by a different company (Kubebond Diamond Plus) is the only sprayable coating I’ve seen last 12 months or even 6 to be honest. C2V3 doesn’t last a month or two at least not here in Illinois.
    Thank you for your honest review there was quite a bit of hype on this one.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Appreciate you taking the time to reply, and I as well try to gate my customer’s expectations there has been so much hype around everything lately. I’m jus trying to weed through it. Defender as a sealant in climates not Idaho or places with salt , winter etc just won’t last but it’s a good protection for the price. Anyway thank you again!

  • @robpeluso2852
    @robpeluso2852 Рік тому +1

    Another great video, Eddie! Thanks for the durability test review!

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Hey rob as always thank you so much for thr support means a lot to me

  • @orthodox1717
    @orthodox1717 Рік тому +2

    What’s interesting, on the fender after the first hit of Nv Snow, it noticeably degraded. The door stood up stronger with harsher chemicals initially. 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Ya I was confused I felt like Joel wondering what’s happening. Maybe it was a weird batch but I expected more to be honest

  • @JK-rh1rv
    @JK-rh1rv Рік тому +1

    Thank you for sharing and being real 👍!
    Another great video.

  • @cebasmb8250
    @cebasmb8250 Рік тому +1

    Great video Eddie, yes sometimes i tell people don't buy into hype wait it out now I'm glad to see that it can't keep up from harsh chemicals...... i never buy into hype you did a great job on this one..... you just own yourself a new subscriber boom 💥

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Thank you very much for the support and the sun I appreciate it.

  • @NipkowDisk
    @NipkowDisk Рік тому +2

    My intention for P&S Defender is using it as a topper coat for my two coats of Jescar Ultra Lock Plus. After that, I'll probably top the whole shebang with some Optimum Spray Wax as essentially a quasi-sacrificial coat, especially in the winter months.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      How was your experience

    • @NipkowDisk
      @NipkowDisk Рік тому +2

      @@Ecdetails It's pending... I'll let you know once I get it applied. I just got my gallon bottle yesterday ;)

    • @NipkowDisk
      @NipkowDisk Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails I gave it a try this afternoon. Incredibly easy to apply and wipe off. Very slick and shiny results! Even if it didn't last more than two or three months, I'd be happy with it. Tried it on my wheels with equally great results. I think P&S has hit another one out of the park!

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@NipkowDisk awesome ya for thr price like I said it’s awesome

  • @ethanblan435
    @ethanblan435 Рік тому +1

    I know nothing about how the chemistry of defender works. But I’m thinking that maybe it’s like Yvan said in that one podcast that some chemicals sort of scar coatings and they lose the hydrophobics until they heat up and cool off again. It’s only a sealant so it’s probably not chemically resistant to something like forst, but it should be able to tank all the incredible suds you can throw at it. I could be 100% wrong and that’s probably likely, maybe a good question for the p&s team during beadmaker and coffee on Monday though

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      I’ll ask if for sure :) thanks for watching !!

  • @jakegillman4549
    @jakegillman4549 Рік тому +2

    How did you find the hydrophobic performance of defender? Did you find it beads and sheets aswell as most other products in this category?

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Had great beads - just drove it to Montana and the lowers didn’t survive mud water etc

    • @jakegillman4549
      @jakegillman4549 Рік тому +1

      Thanks for the reply. Yeah I can see the durability isn't the best compared to some other products. But in the gallon size it's rather good value. Perhaps could work well as a quick detail spray after every wash at that price point. Almost as a replacement for there Beadmaker product. Especially if the hydrophobics are better then that. Then the durability isn't as big of an issue.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@jakegillman4549 great buy actually for the gallon just gotta taper our expectations

    • @jakegillman4549
      @jakegillman4549 Рік тому +1

      Indeed. Does it have a fragrance like Beadmaker does or no real smell to it?

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@jakegillman4549 I can check in the morning it sure I have 16 oz left

  • @christianmarrero3413
    @christianmarrero3413 Рік тому +2

    What product should I used that last 6 months?

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Depends where you live but here’s what I would use
      Diy ceramic glosss
      Op Detailer
      Armour detail supply ceramic sealant
      Drive auto reup
      Griots 3 in 1
      Nv jet

  • @Lg1969
    @Lg1969 Рік тому +2

    Hey Eddie where can I order the Water nozzle from, have a LINK ??

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Hey my friend Graeme love on Facebook makes them

  • @nomad509
    @nomad509 Рік тому +1

    Eddie's coming in hot with this video ladies and gentlemen! This is a valuable test for those who are considering using some soaps and degreasers. Before winter hit I applied some Griot's Ceramic spray to test out which is basically it's a spray sealant. I've applied Forst on it twice to break down the road grime and it appears to retain some beading but I feel its definitely taking a hit until I use their spray on wax on the panel where it immediately beads up as if its rejecting it. I'm considering using a strip wash so I can use up all my old Griots gallons and move onto the good stuff. Anyways this is probably why I'd use Defender as a topper on a true coated car but I'd definitely choose it as a protectant in a pinch and knowing its limitations you mentioned in the video.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      I need to try griots cause I’m hearing some amazing things, defender does goo for gloss but it breaks down to fast

  • @functionaldoc5054
    @functionaldoc5054 Рік тому +1

    Well Defender is a light topper that is above Beadmaker in their line but made for California where they are located. All chemicals should have ratings for northern climates with salt and chloride exposure and a durability rating for southern climates. Company's also should have a rating scale for all their products in their line for chemical resistance , gloss , beading etc.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Doc, and not all sealants are created equal but I’ve used and tested sealants that take more of a beating then this. For the price and what it does inguess it might be worth it if you lived south more vs where snow ❄️ ice salt etc exists

  • @thomasdeluca754
    @thomasdeluca754 Рік тому +2

    I certainly like the look it gives for sure.

  • @pauloguerra5710
    @pauloguerra5710 Рік тому +1

    This the same car you sprayed water on before the suggested cure time?

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Sealants have a cure time? I ask that cause 2 hours is longer then more high grade coatings but to rebuttal I demonstrate on panels that weren’t touched with water as well to demonstrate that with higher ph it will diminish the sealant especially in areas that have snow salt etc

  • @thesamsquatch5224
    @thesamsquatch5224 Рік тому +1

    Excellent video! I wonder how often youd have to reapply. Or it may be best to have a coating as a base layer

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Not sure , as a stand-alone it will last longer in none northern situations

  • @stevenv9224
    @stevenv9224 Рік тому +2

    How does it compare to ceramic gloss? Which is more durable? Great video and demo on it Eddie! 👍👍

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Hey Steven I’m not sure I’ll have to test it to verify how it does I do know the following nv lustre ,owners pride ceramic detailer , nv jet can take more of a hit. I’ll need to test ceramic gloss

    • @stevenv9224
      @stevenv9224 Рік тому

      @@Ecdetails yeah little bro! Love to see that happen. Looking forward to see that comparison

  • @bekiro28
    @bekiro28 Рік тому +1

    Eddie i don't know about the defender but that car and it's color is sick bro wow i love that thing

  • @MikeGDetailing
    @MikeGDetailing Рік тому +2

    Great video. Thanks for sharing your experience. You have just upset the balance of the P&S and TRC fans 😅. Doesn’t look very durable.
    Waiting on Jamie to come in and say you used it wrong and that you need an $80 brush to apply it lol.
    Vonixx Sinergy seems pretty durable so far here in Southern California but I don’t live in harsh conditions. Might be something to add to your list later on.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      👀 haha 😂 I applied it like a sealant anymore complicated we need to call it f11 or a ceramic coating. It is a good topper but don’t expect miracles

    • @JamieTheCleaner
      @JamieTheCleaner Рік тому +1

      The $80 brush makes everything work better no brush means #TWG4life

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      😂

  • @05xrunner
    @05xrunner Рік тому +1

    this lines up with another video i saw. They applied it to a truck and then did a 1month follow up and it was basically 80% dead. Now you are showing that it breaks down pretty quick even after gentle soaps. Saved me $26 I will stick with my DIY ceramic gloss and quick beads. I am starting to feel like P&S stuff is a bit just hype. I didnt find Absolute very impressive and beadmaker is good for slickness but sucks at actual beads and doesnt last at all. I like brake buster only because of the corrosion resistance i spray my rotors good while washing the wheels to cut down on the surface rust after a wash. P&S Xpress I used and scrubbed pretty good with and thought it was all clean. I followed up with a quick wipe with DIY interior clean and protect and it removed so much more dirt even after scrubbing with Xpress before hand.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Man that’s rough , I expected it to last a bit longer maybe 3-5 washes right so the question now is what gap does this fill? I like the cleanmaker mix and clean buster for maintenance washes. Owners pride ceramic detailer is a beast and so is ceramic gloss

  • @mattmccauley5561
    @mattmccauley5561 Рік тому +1

    Well ithink ill just stick with beadaker as i have great results with it where i live. I just finish it off with dreammaker cause we have a shit load of pollen here. I like diy detail quick beads followed with dreammaker as well. Love your channel eddie.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      I really do enjoy the cleanmaker mix and dream maker the gloss is nuts. Thank you so much for your support!!!

  • @Dee--Jay
    @Dee--Jay Рік тому +1

    18:40 If you woulda came back and washed the panel with the wash mitt after rinsing off bucket naked wash, that then woulda weakened or killed it like it did on the other 1st panel

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Your right , just didn’t think it would bring value as we saw what it did to the other panel

  • @davidkasparian3813
    @davidkasparian3813 Рік тому +3

    Let’s gooooo tuning into this during breakfast haha #30moresubs #roadto1000 #B&S

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Appreciate your support!! Means a lot to me

  • @Dee--Jay
    @Dee--Jay Рік тому +2

    Somebody else did a 1 month later video on this product and it was basicially dead at 1 month mark. It saved me 60+ bucks

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Don’t get me wrong it’s a good topper just not chemical resistant

    • @Dee--Jay
      @Dee--Jay Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails true but based on a few videos ive seen. There are equivalent or better products out there like 3D Bead it up. Better performance at half the price

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@Dee--Jay I need to get some other ones to test I’ll probably do that and do a head to head

  • @superado2k
    @superado2k Рік тому +1

    Love your content, EC!
    BUT...in all fairness to Defender, didn't your test simulate a much longer timeframe by foaming AND contact washing the same panel multiple times...with a higher pH product each time? Rinse/Foam/Rinse/Foam/Contact wash/Rinse X 3... pH neutral/pH8. 5/pH12ish... before calling it dead?

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Ya that’s why I went to other panels to demonstrate it

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Umm and to be answer your questions a ph 8.5 with incredible suds should not do a dang thing to it. But I did do bucket naked to the other panels and let it sit. To show that over time it’s bro lasting 5 washes with higher ph soaps

    • @superado2k
      @superado2k Рік тому +1

      @@EcdetailsMaybe it needs to be contact washed with a $30 soft bristle Curveball brush! 🤣😉

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@superado2k 🤣 nah it’s good sealant just don’t expect it to be more then what it is

  • @Buckyvw
    @Buckyvw Рік тому +1

    Love that soothing voice

  • @DetailingMadeSimple
    @DetailingMadeSimple Рік тому +1

    Wow it was that easy?! Sheesh. Didn’t even make it down the line of the soaps you had lined up! 🤣. Great point with Brian. This wouldn’t passed the 10 Wash test before the actual chemical test.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Ya I was taken back at how it died so quick but like I said 20 bucks as a topper maybe 🤔

    • @DetailingMadeSimple
      @DetailingMadeSimple Рік тому

      @@Ecdetails if you use it every wash you’ll be good. But you’ll end up spending a lot more. I agree with nv lust. That’s a tank!

  • @Franko.Details
    @Franko.Details Рік тому +1

    (honestly asking) where does it say defender last 6 months or how long it’s supposed to last period as a stand alone sealant. of course everyone has their opinions, not knocking that but this poopooing of p&s just don’t sit right. i could be wrong absolutely but point me in the direction where p&s says how long it’s supposed to last and how it holds up to those test-icles

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      They said it on there trcma video and online.

  • @dannyv970
    @dannyv970 Рік тому +1

    Awesome vid Eddie! Have you tried Griots garage 3in1 ceramic wax? Stuff lasts a good bit

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Hey I have never used griots anything but there soap 1 time, are you saying it will last after a wash 😂

    • @dannyv970
      @dannyv970 Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails yea I have had great luck with it here in PA with all the salt they throw all winter

    • @kirkwilson5900
      @kirkwilson5900 Рік тому +2

      ​@@Ecdetails put that one to the test next bossman!

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@kirkwilson5900 imma have to buy it

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@dannyv970 I’ll have to give it a shot

  • @edornelas7248
    @edornelas7248 Рік тому +2

    Noice. Which sealants u likey Eddie!??

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Owners pride ceramic detailer
      Diy detail ceramic gloss
      drive auto appearance rejuvenator
      Nv lustre
      Nv jet
      Nv boost

    • @edornelas7248
      @edornelas7248 Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails gotta try that rejuvenator. U have a discount code for drive?

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@edornelas7248 ecdetail20 it’s non affiliated one time use

    • @edornelas7248
      @edornelas7248 Рік тому

      @@Ecdetails gotcha TY!

  • @davidkasparian3813
    @davidkasparian3813 Рік тому +1

    EDDIE LETS GO BRO I BE CHECKING 😂😂6 more ‼️

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Hahah my guy

    • @davidkasparian3813
      @davidkasparian3813 Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails two subscribers 😳you going live for the 1000😂😂

    • @davidkasparian3813
      @davidkasparian3813 Рік тому +1

      Subscriber countdown party ‼️

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@davidkasparian3813 ya but then like 8 unsubscribed like yesterday haha 😂

    • @davidkasparian3813
      @davidkasparian3813 Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails I made some new accounts yesterday and then they all got banned 💀💀💀

  • @ThisOldDetailingDude
    @ThisOldDetailingDude Рік тому +1

    Great video!

  • @armourdetailsupply
    @armourdetailsupply Рік тому +1

    Disappointing! Was hoping for something great to come from P&S with defender! Would love for you to test our Ceramic Spray Sealant in comparison.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      I’ll have to buy some and test

  • @jbalinski
    @jbalinski Рік тому +5

    Eddie "Destroyer of SI02" Colon

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      Lord , cold plunges and how to be a man in 2023 😂😂😂

  • @bikerider5296
    @bikerider5296 5 місяців тому +1

    Defender doesn't seem like it's any better than P&S Beadmaker. My vehicle is not garaged and Beadmaker only lasts a couple weeks. It looks great and beads up, but I can feel it has degraded after a couple weeks and washes. Looks like Defender is about the same.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  5 місяців тому

      To be fair - I hit this with chemicals before leaving on a door panel the rest died that sucked but I’m going to try again

    • @bikerider5296
      @bikerider5296 4 місяці тому

      @@Ecdetails I just picked up a 16oz bottle of Tech582. I'm curious to see if it is as good as everyone claims. Also, I'm using these products as toppers for Rupes Uno Advanced that I put on with a DA polisher last May.

  • @deakemarschall2992
    @deakemarschall2992 Рік тому +1

    Road to 1,000...... next exit. Gettin' real close.

  • @Youknowitbby
    @Youknowitbby Рік тому +9

    Everybody and they momma bought into that P&S HYPE 😂😂😂

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      👀👀👀👀👀 haha 😂 it works but the durability in winter areas you ain’t getting 6 months

    • @thesamsquatch5224
      @thesamsquatch5224 Рік тому +2

      Swift couldn't catch his drift and now defender may just be a pretender

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      @@thesamsquatch5224 👀👀👀hahaha

    • @davidboyce6427
      @davidboyce6427 Рік тому +1

      Hey Eddie give Turtle Wax Seal and Shine using this same test. It’s a Gladiator: Are you not entertained?👍

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@davidboyce6427 imma grab one just what do undo after intest it haha 😂

  • @JamieTheCleaner
    @JamieTheCleaner Рік тому +1

    Bucket Naked gonna Bucket Naked 💪🧼

  • @joemartell09
    @joemartell09 Рік тому +1

    Ok, who gonna be the first to mix it in with some bead maker

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      Jamie did it already haha 😂

    • @joemartell09
      @joemartell09 Рік тому +1

      @@Ecdetails of course he did

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      @@joemartell09 😂😂😂😂

  • @havingtoomuchfun4806
    @havingtoomuchfun4806 Рік тому +2

    When are going to stop wasting your time with P&S garbage. I think of them as a high end Chemical Guys.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому +1

      😂😂😂😂 your so funny! Just had to make sure we test and we discuss

  • @elevatedshine
    @elevatedshine Рік тому +1

    Oop.

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      👀👀👀👀👀👀👀

  • @4214979
    @4214979 Рік тому +1

    I’ve never been impressed by anything P&S.

  • @1stfrompuertorico568
    @1stfrompuertorico568 Рік тому +1

    First!!

    • @Ecdetails
      @Ecdetails  Рік тому

      ❤️

    • @1stfrompuertorico568
      @1stfrompuertorico568 Рік тому

      ​@@Ecdetails I think that with just the soap of 12 would have been flat so it would have not been needed the other soaps and obviously it doesn't necessarily last for 6 months, I would say it would do like 2 months at best