RX 580 vs GTX 1060 - Which GPU Aged Better, Tested in 2024?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 чер 2024
  • RX 580 vs GTX 1060 - Which GPU Aged Better, Tested in 2024?
    Timestamps
    00:00 - intro
    00:19 - Horizon Forbidden West
    01:19 - Skull & Bones
    02:45 - Cyberpunk 2077
    03:58 - Palworld (Game Pass)
    04:43 - Enshrouded
    05:34 - Alan Wake 2
    06:25 - Counter Strike 2
    07:14 - Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II
    08:17 - Starfield (Game Pass)
    09:09 - Apex Legends
    09:58 - Remnant 2: The Awakened King
    10:49 - Baldur's Gate 3
    11:38 - Hogwarts Legacy
    PC Specifications:
    Amazon Affiliate Link - amzn.to/45GcOkK
    ► CPU : intel Core i7-9700F
    ► Motherboard : Gigabyte Z390 Aorus Pro WiFi
    ► RAM : 16GB (2*8GB) DDR4 3200MHz C16-16-16-50
    ► CPU Cooler : COOLER MASTER HYPER 212 EVO
    ► PSU : CORSAIR TX650M - 650 Watt 80+ Gold PSU
    ► GPU : ASUS RX 580 8GB DUAL OC, GIGABYTE GTX 1060 6GB Windforce OC
    ► Drivers : Nvidia 551.86 / AMD Andrenalin 24.3.1 Drivers
    ► OS : Windows 11 Pro (x64) Build 23H2
    ► GAMING SSD : WD BLUE SN570 2TB
    ► Recorder : Corsair Elgato HD60 X Game Capture
    ✘ Also Watch ✘
    ► AMD GPU's Playlist-
    RX 7000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/42ddc7J
    RX 6000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/38sLdYN
    RX 5000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3v73qES
    RX 500 Series benchmarks - bit.ly/3NINRPg
    RX 400 Series benchmarks - bit.ly/3vgwKsw
    ► Nvidia GPU's Playlist-
    Nvidia RTX 40 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3MVVst9
    Nvidia RTX 30 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3qwOwUR
    Nvidia RTX 20 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/46iFe5e
    Nvidia GTX 16 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3XjZ3F6
    Nvidia GTX 10 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3rDGfjl
    Nvidia GTX 9 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3X-lTrKh
    ► intel CPU's Playlist-
    intel 13th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/45Hh4ky
    intel 12th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/33Bcngr
    intel 11th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3oRBGBi
    intel 10th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3eqaiqX
    intel 9th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/2OHj4Gi
    intel 8th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3CH8Ifi
    intel 7th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3qCEbGW
    intel 6th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3es9v9d
    intel 4th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/2PWnUQR
    intel 3th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3vaFZdU
    intel 2th Generation CPU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3eqWIDV
    ► AMD CPU's and APU's Playlist-
    Ryzen 7000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/43q6Kv7
    Ryzen 5000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3v73qES
    Ryzen 3000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3fMRMYW
    Ryzen 2000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3oOcpbv
    Ryzen 1000 Series Benchmarks - bit.ly/3fnFFTo
    Ryzen APU's Benchmarks - bit.ly/3ukPPbz
    if You Requested any Benchmarks or Comparison before... Please Check Requested Benchmarks Playlist - goo.gl/4idZne
    ♛ Hope you like the NJ Tech uploads and be sure to Subscribe to stay up to date with my latest daily Benchmarks uploads! ♛
    🔔 Don't forget to turn that notification bell on Computer and Phone! 🔔
    #njtechbenchmarks #njtech
    #PCGamePassPartner #SkullAndBones
    #9700F #rx580 #gtx1060
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 85

  • @aaronsorspomar96
    @aaronsorspomar96 27 днів тому +4

    Really paired, and considering the RX 580 was launched to beat the GTX 1060, cause is an enhaced RX 480, the original GTX 1060 rival, not bad at all. Also lower power consumption for the nvidia card. In favor or the 580, the 2 extra GB

  • @grand6master
    @grand6master 2 місяці тому +2

    when in same settings they are almost the same, the 8gb allows to crank up textures

  • @kivervivas1274
    @kivervivas1274 Місяць тому +4

    esa es la gtx 1060 6gb mini la zotac , sera que vale la pena comprarla este año ? tengo un procesador 6500 y 16gb de ram

    • @kenethgarcia390
      @kenethgarcia390 Місяць тому +1

      Para empezar y si no tiene plata, hágale sin miedo, modelos tope de gamma como el Rog Strix y MSI valen como 400 usados, para que se haga una idea

  • @masiosareanivdelarev562
    @masiosareanivdelarev562 2 місяці тому +2

    Good video

  • @martingolding4951
    @martingolding4951 Місяць тому +2

    Am using a geforce 1060 6gb here plays all the latest games smoothly. My sim driving is ATS, and ETS2 forza games play good as well

    • @crazyyt327
      @crazyyt327 Місяць тому

      which gpu u got i have the same gpu with i5 4590 should upgrade it to i7 4790 ?

  • @Junior_POA
    @Junior_POA 2 місяці тому +2

    CS: 1060 and COD: 580 surprised me

  • @noppol8583
    @noppol8583 9 днів тому

    I'm hesitating about which product to buy. 1060 6Gb rx580 8gb Cpu that I use i5 8500

  • @rodmedia3643
    @rodmedia3643 2 місяці тому +3

    wtf , we are in 2024

  • @donaldnemesis393
    @donaldnemesis393 16 днів тому +1

    but what if both gpu are overclocked

  • @Atom22835
    @Atom22835 2 місяці тому +3

    Why is there such a difference in CS2?

    • @NJTechBenchmark
      @NJTechBenchmark  2 місяці тому +3

      because of MSAA.

    • @zakur0978
      @zakur0978 2 місяці тому

      ​​@@NJTechBenchmark is it because 580 has 32 ROPs and 1060 48?
      can you test without anti-aliasing to see if there is a difference
      CS2 without anti-aliasing, 580 vs 1060

  • @northwind4362
    @northwind4362 Місяць тому +2

    GTX 1060 overclocking 202 MHz

  • @segopadang666
    @segopadang666 2 місяці тому +2

    nice

  • @akapeach915
    @akapeach915 2 місяці тому +5

    Is the 580 undervolted?

    • @BeastAsNoob
      @BeastAsNoob 2 місяці тому

      yh i think so , bcz mine avg is like 118-145w

    • @jazzone903
      @jazzone903 Місяць тому +2

      Is there any fix, it should be 185 watts isn't it?. I heard u have to turn off the radeon chill​@@BeastAsNoob

    • @BeastAsNoob
      @BeastAsNoob Місяць тому

      @@jazzone903 i believe if u increase power limit it can go upto 210watt

    • @BeastAsNoob
      @BeastAsNoob Місяць тому

      @@jazzone903 the one i use is asus dual which mostly goes 148-143w but i undervolt it to fixed 123w bcz im using 6pin to 8pin currently going to change psu to avoid hardware damage and yes i use Radeon chill too for fos games and single player games

    • @brawss
      @brawss Місяць тому

      if we talking about power consumption...the asus rx 580 dual oc has a power limit of 145w, apex legends pushes it to the max, reaching 140w. the 185w tdp is just part of the standard specs announced by amd, brands use different power limits for their cards.

  • @Akivili234
    @Akivili234 12 днів тому

    Dude, gtx 1060 has 1911MHz, why it so high💀

  • @paramedic48
    @paramedic48 2 місяці тому +2

    👍👍

  • @Ciberdyn
    @Ciberdyn 17 днів тому +1

    Did you overclock the GTX 1060???

  • @zakur0978
    @zakur0978 2 місяці тому +11

    RX 580 draws 210+W
    GTX 1060 draws 135W
    so in power efficiency 1060 is better
    efficiency = less heat = less noise
    RX 580 supports DX12_0
    GTX 1060 supports DX12_1
    on directx support 1060 is better, so in theory it's more future proof.
    RX 580 has better raw power and +2gb vram, however many games can't take advantage of that raw power
    and on the driver side: even tho amd updates the drivers, they are just fix.
    not a single support title(game)
    so far gtx 1060 6gb wins when it comes to future proof
    btw this doesn't prove anything when it comes to brand.
    GTX700 series and R 200 on those amd had the upper hand DX12_0 vs DX11 of gtx 700
    but the possibility that the gtx 1060 will be better in the future cause it has dx12_1 is there

    • @lewzealand4717
      @lewzealand4717 2 місяці тому +2

      Did you even watch the video? Where do you see the RX580 drawing 200W? Ignored the rest of your fanboy post after that.

    • @zakur0978
      @zakur0978 2 місяці тому +2

      @@lewzealand4717 software power reading is not total gpu power draw, not on old gpus anyway

    • @tristanwahahaha5082
      @tristanwahahaha5082 2 місяці тому

      nah just use fsr 3 fg mod and ur good to go

    • @ysnyldrm73
      @ysnyldrm73 2 місяці тому +1

      The only problem is performance wise dx12 is much better supported by rx 580 while dx11 is much better supported by gtx 1060. Dx12.1 does not any any meaningful things to pascal gpus or exclude polaris to run any game. 12.2 is the real upgrade that both does not support. Rx 580 with 8gb vram and driver finewine was much more future proof.
      Do you really think that there is a game support for pascal gpus nowadays? Im a 7 years old pascal user here, for the last 2 years the "supported" games runs very poorly, a freaking gtx 1650 is much performant than gtx 1060 in ds remake... They fixed uncharted 4's pc problems for pascal (hw gpu sch.) one month later, than they broke it with the next driver.. What a supported gpu...

    • @zakur0978
      @zakur0978 2 місяці тому +2

      ​​​​​​@@ysnyldrm73 Forspoken(DX12_1) doesn't run on rx580.
      Alan Wake II runs poorly on rx580, and my guess is because it support less futures of DX than gtx1060 5:50
      or maybe because there was no driver optimize for alan wake ii
      doesn't matter the case, it shows that gtx 1060 is more likely to be in better position in the future.
      ofc the ideal gpu right now is dx12_2, but we are talking about rx580vs1060
      as for rx580 dx12 performance, it should be better if it isn't hold back from dx 12_1 or 12_2 futures or driver support.
      However recently we see for example Starfield 8:43, remnant ii 10:21, skull&bones 2:03 that the new games don't optimize enough for the advantage to show
      and Tekken 8 doesn't run better on rx580 etc
      i don't know if the dev doesn't optimize for rx580, or if the problem is amd driver optimization since it had 0 supported/optimized titles on their last 2 drivers.
      seems like the rx580 by force runs those games

  • @JoseAvila-fr3xs
    @JoseAvila-fr3xs 2 місяці тому +9

    "The RX 580 will perform like a 1080 over time, in fact it already performs like a 1070 or more"
    - Typical comment from an AMD fanboy.
    The worst of all is that there were many who believed these things.

    • @lewzealand4717
      @lewzealand4717 2 місяці тому +4

      And you posted it so you're the fanboy.

    • @zakur0978
      @zakur0978 2 місяці тому +3

      the only way to think that would be with spec only
      for example
      GTX1070
      Shading Units 1920
      TMUs 120
      ROPs 64
      SM Count 15(compute units)
      Vs
      RX580
      Shading Units 2304
      TMUs 144
      ROPs 32
      Compute Units 36
      the problem is that the count of cores is not useful if the cores are weaker
      the other problem is more cores usually need more memory bandwidth, rx580 is memory starved
      i think that was the reason, amd used HBM memory on Vega gpus
      im just guessing

    • @JoseAvila-fr3xs
      @JoseAvila-fr3xs 2 місяці тому

      @@zakur0978 There was also a clear difference in frequencies.
      And well, at the level of architecture and drivers, much of the same. Same reason why VEGA 64 was at a similar level to a GTX 1080, having higher specifications than the 1080 Ti.

    • @willian4872
      @willian4872 2 місяці тому +3

      Em 2028 a RX 580 alcançará a RTX 4090.

    • @lewzealand4717
      @lewzealand4717 2 місяці тому +2

      @@zakur0978 Core clock as well, the GTX 10 series regularly boosts to 1900 MHz while Polaris runs at barely 2/3 that speed, that's a huge difference.

  • @withcarename
    @withcarename 2 місяці тому +20

    Gtx1060 wins, cause driver support for rx580 has been stopped.

    • @MimiFattah
      @MimiFattah 2 місяці тому +17

      Driver rx580 Has beeng stopped..?😂

    • @Alejandro-pk5is
      @Alejandro-pk5is 2 місяці тому +1

      no one won

    • @tanmay5570
      @tanmay5570 2 місяці тому +9

      Lookup at amd's website before spreading bs!

    • @lewzealand4717
      @lewzealand4717 2 місяці тому +7

      Wins what? What matters is FPS and they're about equal in these games. And AMD is still releasing drivers for Polaris though not as often as for the RDNAs.

    • @Sam-cq9bj
      @Sam-cq9bj 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@MimiFattahYes. Go and search AMD discontinued polaris, Vega completely

  • @MisterKyle93
    @MisterKyle93 Місяць тому +5

    Fake video

    • @Ian1557
      @Ian1557 Місяць тому +1

      Да. Попались на Alan Wake 2

    • @NJTechBenchmark
      @NJTechBenchmark  Місяць тому +1

      Fake How?

    • @Ian1557
      @Ian1557 Місяць тому +1

      @@NJTechBenchmark ALAN WAKE 2 RX580 real 1-2 FPS.

    • @NJTechBenchmark
      @NJTechBenchmark  Місяць тому +1

      Update the alan wake 2 bro.

    • @northwind4362
      @northwind4362 Місяць тому +1

      @@Ian1557 6 -11 FPS .

  • @thetidy7969
    @thetidy7969 2 місяці тому +4

    Both aged like milk