People always says that Shuhua should get more line but lets clear this up once and for all. Firstly, Suhua says that she is happy with few lines because it meant not being tortured by Soyeon when recording, secondly, she is a sub vocalists, sub vocalists tends to have the fewest line distribution in any groups, thirdly, the reason why she doesn't have much lines is because she was not very fluent in Korean during their rookie era which is not the case anymore.
She gets more lines when there are more rap verses, I noticed. Like on Wife she had pretty equal lines with Minnie, and the other three were also almost the same as each other.
Tortured? If anything, Shuhua should be grateful that Soyeon spends the time and effort to get her to sound acceptable. Had this been SM, Shuhua would have been given 1-2 words because no producer would waste his time with her.
@avut2001 don’t compare them, wtf if u don’t like them go away, it’s not that hard. Plus some people don’t like being in the recording studio and doing that stuff. don’t say stuff like that bc it’s not true.
@@Delilah16121It's definitely true and It's telling how you don't complain about OP bashing Soyeon, but as soon as it is the fandom darling then it's unacceptable. How about calling out the part of the fandom always causing trouble, i.e. Miyeon/Shuhua solo stans and OT4
Так всегда распределение одинаково во всех песнях Айдл всё что изменилось это у соён не самые большие партии и вокалистам дали партий побольше так как песня такая, а у вас сразу складывается впечатление что партии справедливы
@@Ylikxsya Я и не отрицала, что у айдл обычно распределение справедливое😉 Просто существует много песен, в которых у участников с самой короткой партией и самой длинной партией разница большая, бывает даже, что в пол минуты, а здесь довольно небольшая, вот и всё😉
@@karina_sv_ о том что она хочет мало партий она когда сказала? Года 3 назад или даже больше? А позиция вижуала нечего не говорит. В группе еще вроде миен вижуал ну или я что то путаю.
It's crazy how the best performer is the most hated in the fandom while the untalented visual is praised for simply existing. Soyeon is the main rapper and center and has as much "right" to get lines as the main vocalists.
Because if she didn't take the backseat, she'd get hated by OT4/Shuhua stans/Miyeon stans. I hope she gets a new solo soon, because it's crazy that the best performer should not be promoted as such
@@carolynhoo5756 ? Minnie has the most lines overall, with Soyeon second and Miyeon just behind, so all main vocal roles are in the top. It's not Soyeon's fault that haters hyper-focus on her to the point that they do not realize that she doesn't even have the most lines.
I always think soyeon is gonna have the most lines cus she usually does when she writes the song, idk if she wrote this one. Usually she has the most Minnie is second.
And when it's a Minnie or Yuqi song they give themselves the main parts, but where is the criticism for that? Apparently it's only an issue if Soyeon has the most. Soyeon did write this one, fyi
actually it's: 1) Miyeon 30.9s 2) Yuqi 26.9s 3) Minnie 26.3s 4) Soyeon 23.8s 5) Shuhua 19.8s If you don't believe me and need a link: ua-cam.com/video/tYjm-uL6NEs/v-deo.html
No, Shuhua herself asked to give her fewer games, because she is afraid of stuttering or... It’s not right to say something, she doesn’t speak Korean well!
So, Neverlands bully Soyeon until the best performer in Gidle is reduce to 4th place and yet you still complain and pretend that she's egoistic. She doesn't even have the most lines overall, it's Minnie with quite a big lead, but the criticism is always about Soyeon
Personally, I think this is pretty fair
Mmhm
Ofc.
its not rlly fair imo.
it is fair compared to their other songs but still, 20s to 25s was kinda crazy.
@@LEE-KNOW_SUNGHOON_YUH how ? ita a 5 sec difference
@@LEE-KNOW_SUNGHOON_YUHHow? Shuhua is not as good as the others in singing so she got a pretty good line distribution
MINNIE AND MIYEON OWNED THIS ERA
MIYEON OWNED KLAXON
Yea
ofc
I think Minnie/miyeon
Miyeon always stands out in more summer-like concepts
finally minnie is getting to shine with her beautiful voice ❤
I thought Miyeon has the most lines omg. But this has to be their fairest perhaps
its always fair bc it doesnt mean everybody gets same amount but their parts suits their liking and abilities
It was always fair, the members chose their own lines.
I think amitkpop posted a vid already
Miyeon does this line distribution is a bit wrong
@@sky_crumbles No they don't
I thought Miyeon had the most lines, she stood out so much!
I THOUGHT MINNIE HAD THE LEAST PART😭😭
I thought so too, but now I’m glad that one of my biases has the most parts)
SAMEE 😭
Same dude. I love her too much
Same dude happy for my bias 😭
SAME
People always says that Shuhua should get more line but lets clear this up once and for all. Firstly, Suhua says that she is happy with few lines because it meant not being tortured by Soyeon when recording, secondly, she is a sub vocalists, sub vocalists tends to have the fewest line distribution in any groups, thirdly, the reason why she doesn't have much lines is because she was not very fluent in Korean during their rookie era which is not the case anymore.
plus Soyeon lets them chose their own lines! If she wanted more she could probably ask for them too!
She gets more lines when there are more rap verses, I noticed. Like on Wife she had pretty equal lines with Minnie, and the other three were also almost the same as each other.
Tortured? If anything, Shuhua should be grateful that Soyeon spends the time and effort to get her to sound acceptable. Had this been SM, Shuhua would have been given 1-2 words because no producer would waste his time with her.
@avut2001
don’t compare them, wtf if u don’t like them go away, it’s not that hard. Plus some people don’t like being in the recording studio and doing that stuff. don’t say stuff like that bc it’s not true.
@@Delilah16121It's definitely true and It's telling how you don't complain about OP bashing Soyeon, but as soon as it is the fandom darling then it's unacceptable. How about calling out the part of the fandom always causing trouble, i.e. Miyeon/Shuhua solo stans and OT4
Shuhua OWNED this era her vocals in Bloom are just 😫🤌🤌 shes the best in this era!!
YESSS❤❤❤
@@HELLO_KITTY3333 IKRR?? ❤️❤️
Какое справедливое распределение, у всех почти одинаковое количество партий!
Так всегда распределение одинаково во всех песнях Айдл всё что изменилось это у соён не самые большие партии и вокалистам дали партий побольше так как песня такая, а у вас сразу складывается впечатление что партии справедливы
@@Ylikxsya Я и не отрицала, что у айдл обычно распределение справедливое😉 Просто существует много песен, в которых у участников с самой короткой партией и самой длинной партией разница большая, бывает даже, что в пол минуты, а здесь довольно небольшая, вот и всё😉
Справедливое? Почти одинаковое? У них разница в 12 секунд,а для группы в которой 5 человек это достаточно плохо.
@@Dima-vg4bn А то, что у Шухуа основная позиция - вижуал и что она сама не хочет много партий вам ни о чём не говорит?
@@karina_sv_ о том что она хочет мало партий она когда сказала? Года 3 назад или даже больше? А позиция вижуала нечего не говорит. В группе еще вроде миен вижуал ну или я что то путаю.
This era is for Miyeon and Minnie. I also looooove the bsides ❤❤
i personally think this was minnie’s and shuhuas era!!
THEY SLAYED THIS COMEBACK, BUT I REALLY WANT SHUHUA TO HAVE AT LEAST 30 SECS IN THE FUTURE 😭😭
Her honks carried the song
In HEAT Flip It she has 30 sec line distribution
I think she herself does not want to get a lot of lines
but shuhua is not the main vocalist
Nah we don’t want that. If they can’t sing well and have too many lines that could lead to career downfall . Look at Le sserafim
Finally Minnie has a lot of lines
shuhua getting enough lines is a miracle
I am waiting for the day shuhua has the most lines
Flip It HEAT she has the most lines
Edit: Apparently she also has the most lines in DOLL 2 but I’m not sure because I didn’t hear her voice a lot
@@MelodyOdyssesyty! now op doesn't have to wait anymore 😍
@@hivisonnogueira848yw!
ok what about "HEAT" go check it out!
She doesn’t want many lines
Finally a fair line distribution ❤
STREAM THE SONG IT NEEDS SOTY AND 100M VIEWS
Yeah but its 600k now 😢😢😢
@@ArmyV-zexal now 1 million) +400 thousand views for a 9 minutes
за первые 24 часа песня набрала 7 млн просмотров)
finally shuhua getting lines im happy
Shuhua slay, even though her part it's just "hon hon hon" but yeah still slay , Ilove her outfit in this mv
I saw in many distribution lines, that Miyeon or Minnie came first and another came second
I will never recover from Minnie's curly hair ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
If soyeon had the most lines these comments section will have been hate
SOYEON ERA THO ❤❤
It's crazy how the best performer is the most hated in the fandom while the untalented visual is praised for simply existing. Soyeon is the main rapper and center and has as much "right" to get lines as the main vocalists.
The fact that Soyeon wrote the song and she got second to the least words.
Because if she didn't take the backseat, she'd get hated by OT4/Shuhua stans/Miyeon stans. I hope she gets a new solo soon, because it's crazy that the best performer should not be promoted as such
Minnie love you❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
SHUHUA SURELY DIDNT GET THAT MANY LINES
It’s the honks😅
Why?
@@RRRica_aThey are saying they can’t believe it, not that she didn’t deserve it
@@MelodyOdyssesy oh thanks! Now I can understand
Well, she surely doesn't make them justice live, so it's already a shame that she gets this much
Klaxon❤❤❤
miyeon voice stands out so much and she own the era
При первом прослушивании я подумал, что у Соен больше всех сек, но к моему удивлению, оказалось, что нет
My opinión
1Yiqi,shuhua,soyeon,minnie,miyeon
2
3
4
5
Era Minnie ❤
Yuqi❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😅divaa
#justiceforshuhua
Miyeon es la q más canta en Klaxon, d hecho, ella tiene 30.9 segundos
I would love to see dolphinkpop make a line distribution of klaxon 👀
Yuqi owns this era ❤❤❤❤
我覺得舒華進步很多，雖然他歌詞是最少的但已經有了5分之1啊❤
Ok, the first time seeing Minnie first in a song that has MV (i’m crying)
I don't know why but when I hear it first time i feel like it's sounds like yuqi solo song
Miyeon😮
Yuqi❤
Minnie😅
Soyeon😂
Shuhua🎉
Minnieeeeeee
MIYEON OWNED THIS
Nah33 ❤
Song Yuqi❤
Soyeon owned this era imo & Miyeon 2
Minnie was glowing
But all of em owned it
agree
Compared to other groups, this is amazing
I think miyeon should have more line bc she's main vocal too, but miyeon owned this era!
Just a 12 sec different from lowest to highest is pretty fair for me tho....
наконец-то шухуа дали больше партий😭🫶🏼
i really like how shuhua really push herself to learn rap😊 i really wish they do songs with more shuhua rap and vocal in future
Shuhua dreserves more😢
THIS SONG 🔛🔝
GUYS SHUHUA ASKED FOR LESS LINES😅
It seems pretty even
Kpop fans so obsessed with this stuff. Good music isn’t made with “fair” line distribution.
Exactly! It's also hypocritical how they complain about the lack of talent in Kpop, while they hate on Gidle's best performer in favor of its worst.
finally shuhua got more 18sec
pretty fair. if you want unfair, look at SM groups
its fair minnie having most lines after super lady
소연은 0초라도 이미 승자. ㅋ
직접 프로듀싱했고 작사도 혼자 했고.
작곡과 편곡에도 참여했으니 다른 네 멤버보다 이미 더 벌었음. ㅋㅋ
I thought the line distrubion was like
Soyeon😅
Minnie😅
Yuqi😅
Miyeon😅
Shuhua😅
Yk a common kind of line Distribution in (G) I-DLE
@@carolynhoo5756 ? Minnie has the most lines overall, with Soyeon second and Miyeon just behind, so all main vocal roles are in the top. It's not Soyeon's fault that haters hyper-focus on her to the point that they do not realize that she doesn't even have the most lines.
PRQASC_O1 version
1.Cheasea 41.2s 41.1%
2.Shui 40.1s 40.0%
3.Dahyena 39.0s 38.9%
4.Yeojian 38.2s 38.1%
I always think soyeon is gonna have the most lines cus she usually does when she writes the song, idk if she wrote this one. Usually she has the most Minnie is second.
And when it's a Minnie or Yuqi song they give themselves the main parts, but where is the criticism for that? Apparently it's only an issue if Soyeon has the most. Soyeon did write this one, fyi
(G)I-DLE NEVER DISSAPPOINTED US FROM SUMMER CONCEPTS
What are u girl the second anyone drip u make vid within hour or something!!!!
U R WORKER APPRECIATED 💛💛💛
Definitely song of the summer
Soyeon owned this
Shuhua getting shine day by day and she owned this era i said what i said
Miyeon is most line shes first 😊😊😊😊😊😊
its pretty fair now, FINALLY SHUHUA GOT MANY LINES🫶🏻(SoyeongiveShuhuamorelines)
Why should the better performers give up their lines for someone that cannot even sing them live?
they all served this era! miyeons chorus gagged me lol i really liked this comeback
Guys this is not the actual line distribution, miyeon had the most with 30 seconds and shuhua with 19s. The order way shuhua soyeon yuqi minnie miyeon
20,2
32,4
12,2
это норм
miyeon has the most lines, followed by yuqi, soyeon, minnie, shuhua in that order
Minnie era
So Fair 💗💗💗
Ура, ни у кого нету распределений меньше 20 секунд!!
Minnie’s era fr
Minnie complained to soyeon about her lack of lines in super lady so soyeon gave her the most lines this comeback 😭😭😭
actually it's:
1) Miyeon 30.9s
2) Yuqi 26.9s
3) Minnie 26.3s
4) Soyeon 23.8s
5) Shuhua 19.8s
If you don't believe me and need a link: ua-cam.com/video/tYjm-uL6NEs/v-deo.html
Miyeon’s era so idc
NO SHUHUA 1
Miyeon had most lines...can you check in main line distribution
20 second are good amounts of line tho 🤧
Shu got 20 seconds but its mostly honks. She deserved more 😢
this is actually pretty fair, hwaa was way worse
No, Shuhua herself asked to give her fewer games, because she is afraid of stuttering or... It’s not right to say something, she doesn’t speak Korean well!
Why does Minnies line sound similar to Kataeye's debut.
Miyeon had the most lines no Minnie check random_j line distribution for klaxon
Here i was kinda upset that Minnie might have gotten the least line 😭
Please give shuhua moree lines...
shuhua got robbed
No, she has way too many parts already considering how poor a performer she is
Miyeon had most lines, no Minnie
THIS LINE DISTRIBUTION IS NOT TRUE! Miyeon is first with 31s, Minnie and Yuqi have 26s and the others are the same
Why Shuhua always had the last line
No Miyeon first
И кто теперь скажет, что Соен на себя много берет?
Ну Минни по сумме партий по всем альбомам давно в лидерах
Who owned klaxon?
👇Reply down below!
Nope it is
Miyeon
Yuqi
Minnie
Soyeon
Shuhua
Miyeon is first not minnie
miyeon is 2nd
Miyeon has the most lines?
SOYEON!? IN FOURTH PLACE!? AM I SEEING THINGS
So, Neverlands bully Soyeon until the best performer in Gidle is reduce to 4th place and yet you still complain and pretend that she's egoistic. She doesn't even have the most lines overall, it's Minnie with quite a big lead, but the criticism is always about Soyeon