Cultivated Australian Accent Compared to RP

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 121

  • @ProfChaos10
    @ProfChaos10 4 роки тому +77

    That beard is cultivated.

  • @bassic6959
    @bassic6959 Рік тому +18

    His australian accents were really good. Ironically the only thing that gave it away for me was the way he would say "Australian" it still had an american ring to it. It still sounded a bit like Austrelian. but overall this is super impressive

  • @elcapitan6126
    @elcapitan6126 2 роки тому +15

    that's an impressive ability to subtly shift accents with all their nuances well done and very informative thankyou 👍

  • @Signorscrittore
    @Signorscrittore Рік тому +6

    How fascinating, thank you! This was really instructive.
    I recently learned that I have a cultivated accent, which is a description that makes me feel like a class traitor, haha.
    My mother speaks with a general Australian accent unless she's doing public speaking, when she instinctively slips into cultivated, and my father has an incredible broad accent - people who've called him on the phone just after lunch sometimes apologise for waking him up!

  • @E.R.Hewitt
    @E.R.Hewitt 4 роки тому +45

    That's an incredibly good grasp on the Aussie accents

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +12

      Thanks! It was a really challenging accent for me for years, and I still wrestle with my confidence with it.

    • @jazlynr8316
      @jazlynr8316 3 роки тому +3

      @@AccentHelp Can confirm that your accent sounds fantastic- honestly, you could have fooled me into thinking you were Aussie!

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  3 роки тому +9

      @@jazlynr8316 Oh, stop!
      ...not really... keep going... Thanks!

    • @frankibianchi6188
      @frankibianchi6188 3 роки тому

      Cultivated Australian accents do not flatten Australia.

  • @RollingInTheClouds
    @RollingInTheClouds 2 місяці тому +2

    When I moved to Australia, I was introduced to the broad accent in the western suburbs of Sydney. My thought was it sounded like speakers were chewing their vowels and they sounded very rounded

  • @mikemewz6209
    @mikemewz6209 2 роки тому +15

    Hands down the best cultivated Australian accent I've heard, uncanny how easily you can switch too!

  • @KenjiStrazdins
    @KenjiStrazdins 4 роки тому +32

    Wow, as a "Cultivated" Australian English speaker, you've got the diphthongs bang on. Also, with the intonation - Cultivated Australian English does tend to go to the RP side. I also have the weak vowel merger in non-morpheme final positions, which distinguishes my English from RP and Estuary (abbot and rabbit are perfect rhymes in my speech). Also, yep, I tend to pronounce my t's strongly rather than flap them but can glottalise them before consonants, which distinguishes me from General Australian and Estuary.

  • @champagneandflamingoes5435
    @champagneandflamingoes5435 3 роки тому +8

    I have a cultivated Australian accent myself and you're the closest match I've seen of any UA-camr! The one thing I'd add is that the pronounciation of "Australia" is more like "A-stralia" or "Uh-stralia" in my accent- we don't really pronounce the "Aus" part :) I watched your cockney/australian video too and that was fascinating. Also as someone said below- the clear pronounciation of the letter "t" in the cultivated Australian accent is similar to RP. In 'broad' or 'general' Aussie you would pronounce the letter "t" as a "d" most of the time, in the middle of words, and soften it at the end. In cultivated, we tend to pronounce the "t" a little more thoroughly.

    • @ByeByeBelly
      @ByeByeBelly Рік тому

      We don't say straya like he did either... Most common accent pronounces it uhstraleeun, definitely not that more bogan astraya

  • @scotuslaurentius2763
    @scotuslaurentius2763 4 роки тому +16

    I grew up mad bogan but when I went to Uni I switched to a posh Aussie accent so as not to be so noticeable - I was just pondering the relation between posh Aussie and RP - I'm having a small identity crisis.

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +5

      The last thing I want to do this year is contribute to another freakin' crisis... Please forgive me!

    • @abilea4081
      @abilea4081 4 роки тому +4

      Same thing with me, I grew up with a more "bogan" accent then went to catholic school and uni and began to switch for a more cultivated accent to blend in more

    • @scotuslaurentius2763
      @scotuslaurentius2763 4 роки тому +1

      @@AccentHelp ah I've had the identity crisis for awhile - I've forgotten what my true or actual accent is ... depending upon my social company I can switch my accent but which one is more true to who I am?

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +11

      @@scotuslaurentius2763 I don't think there's such a thing as your True accent. We're all chameleons, to some degree, so adapting your accent is just another sign that you're alive and still changing! It's likely it will continue to shift. No worries.

    • @noway325
      @noway325 4 роки тому +4

      @@scotuslaurentius2763 dont worry almost everyone in my extended family does that. I don't think it is unusual for people in Australia. Sometimes when my mum talks to her mum her accent gets so broad she sounds like another person.

  • @susanhall9871
    @susanhall9871 4 роки тому +33

    The main difference is in the 'ahh' sound, for example in 'car' or 'large'. Australians use a much broader sound, similar to the one used in Irish or northern English accents and also in rural East Anglian accents - but never in RP or Cockney. That is the way you can instantly tell if someone is either from Australia or the south east of England and this strong 'ahh' is usually present in all Australian accents.

    • @carlossanchezn.2459
      @carlossanchezn.2459 3 роки тому

      What is the position to create the cultivated Australian versión of the long /a:/ vowel?

    • @ByeByeBelly
      @ByeByeBelly Рік тому +1

      Do ppl confuse Australian with cockney..?

    • @susanhall9871
      @susanhall9871 Рік тому +4

      @@ByeByeBelly British people and Australians wouldn't normally confuse the two because of the different 'ahh' sound. Also cockneys use glottal stops more instead of a 't' sound in the middle of words whereas Australians often use a soft 't' that sounds quite similar to a 'd', just like Americans do.
      A lot of vowel sounds in broad Australian and cockney are almost identical though.
      I've heard that Americans can get them confused and even that they've assumed strong Yorkshire accents are Australian accents because they are so unfamiliar with them.

    • @edwardamosbrandwein3583
      @edwardamosbrandwein3583 Рік тому +1

      @@ByeByeBelly These two are generally confused

    • @richieseager6130
      @richieseager6130 2 місяці тому

      @@susanhall9871 I’m a Londoner and Melbourne I noticed seems to have alot of cockney terms and influence they are miles different but Americans wouldn’t probably have a clue

  • @utha2665
    @utha2665 2 роки тому +4

    I was looking for the accent that Australian journalists used to use in the 70's and earlier and came across this. Fascinating, to say the least, listening to you traverse the accents was quite surreal and quite subtle. I did a double take the first time I heard it, really cool how you do that.

    • @utha2665
      @utha2665 2 роки тому

      @MACABRE L.A. To a point yes, but the lower socio-economic regions still had a stronger Australian accent. RP English seems to have been a thing with higher society and journalism back then. Of course this isn't a total generalisation as I'm sure we could find lower and higher socio-economic regions that would buck this trend.

    • @utha2665
      @utha2665 2 роки тому

      @MACABRE L.A. Me too, I was just making an observation of older news reels and early TV. I wasn't around either, I'm only a year older than you.

    • @utha2665
      @utha2665 2 роки тому

      @MACABRE L.A. Yeah, it is fascinating and sometimes a bit cringeworthy, particularly around the white Australia policy. Looking back that was an embarrassing time.

    • @richieseager6130
      @richieseager6130 2 місяці тому

      ⁠@NoirL.A.which era did they sound more “British”

  • @tahnae99
    @tahnae99 4 роки тому +11

    One difference is pronunciation so things like privacy and vitamin in RP are quite different even to a cultivated Australian accent where it’s like pry-vacy compared to the RP priv-acy. One thing that really differentiates cultivated from more general and broad Australian accents is the pronunciation of the letter t. Broader accents dull the t to almost more of a d sound while it’s usually still a t in cultivated accents which is something which stands out and does make it sound more posh.

    • @AidanMclaren
      @AidanMclaren 2 роки тому

      Are you talking about "t" in the middle of words like "butter", or just "t" in general?

  • @brendanhoffmann8402
    @brendanhoffmann8402 2 роки тому +10

    My accent (cultivated Australian) is often mistaken for a British accent... I was often teased in school for enunciating the i in nine, as in shine... The lower class kids definitely singled me out in that way but I was poor myself. My accent had been passed on when my parents entered a lower social class...

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  2 роки тому +3

      Would you be willing to do a dialect recording for me? I'd love to have an example of your accent to share with actors. No worries if you'd rather not, Brendan!

    • @Stratahoovius
      @Stratahoovius 2 роки тому +2

      I'm from Adelaide, and I've always had people from abroad think I'm British. It's funny because I'm definitely not posh, and my parents were total working class people.

    • @jzen1455
      @jzen1455 Рік тому +1

      I had a processor from Adelaide who sounded British to me. I think he was from the upper class, as he acted very "civilized" and "proper".

    • @amyfeldman5301
      @amyfeldman5301 Рік тому +2

      I’m from Adelaide too. I get asked if I’m British even by people from Adelaide. Even though I was born and grew up here

    • @Stratahoovius
      @Stratahoovius Рік тому +1

      @@jzen1455 Likely, there is an Old Boy's network in Adelaide, descendants of the first free settlers who founded the city.

  • @laracroftvideos
    @laracroftvideos 4 роки тому +5

    Glad you're adding more amazing content to this channel! 😊

  • @virtualcircuit
    @virtualcircuit 9 місяців тому +3

    I've got a cultivated Australian accent and get the absolute piss taken out of me working in the UK and seeing its relations to RP make me realise why now, especially when working in the regions! My father was an Australian radio announcer in the 60s so it makes sense now.

    • @richieseager6130
      @richieseager6130 2 місяці тому

      Why did they take the piss where was you in UK

  • @matheuspavan2336
    @matheuspavan2336 4 роки тому +1

    I have to say that your content is the only one of it's kind in the whole youtube. Keep up the superb work

  • @FrostySkull
    @FrostySkull 4 роки тому +1

    Every time I see your uploads I get an urge to purchase another one of your accent guides. Learning is just so damn fun, but I'm saving up and need to start being responsible hahaha.
    If ever you go Apple iBook format though, I'll be going on a shopping spree...

  • @brettritchie5
    @brettritchie5 4 роки тому +6

    I play D&D with my friends your accent break downs help me invent my own for my world! If you haven’t seen “The Expanse” I recommend it there is an invented accent they invented for the belters you might find interesting.

  • @Ali-qy5ic
    @Ali-qy5ic 3 роки тому +8

    Great video. As an Australian it really pains me that our accent is always portrayed as that super-broad, Crocodile Dundee/Steve Irwin style in Hollywood movies, although I suppose Hollywood loves the cliche that we all live in the outback surrounded by Kangaroos. To be fair our accent is incredibly difficult to replicate properly - I find people who try always sound like a mix of broad Aussie/Kiwi/South African/Cockney.

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  3 роки тому +5

      Did your kangaroo type this? C'mon, we know they've taken over...
      I've been working on my Aussie accent for years, and I still find it a big challenge! Indeed, the drift towards the other accents is incredibly common... Would you mind simplifying your accent for us Americans, so we don't suck at it so badly?

    • @Ali-qy5ic
      @Ali-qy5ic 3 роки тому +3

      @@AccentHelp Okay, okay yes, a kangaroo forced me to type that & a koala made me wear an Akubra hat! As for tips the key is in the vowels - this is where accent attempts end up sounding slightly kiwi. Australian's would say 'hat' whereas the vowel sound with a Kiwi accent would be 'het' . We say 'cat' they say 'ket'. :) You do a great job though! Kate Winslet did a good job in the movie Holy Smokes too.

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  3 роки тому +2

      @@Ali-qy5ic I appreciate your kind words, kanga. Please tell Ali thanks as well, and wish him luck with his chimps on the Barbie doll house, or whatever that saying is.

    • @Ali-qy5ic
      @Ali-qy5ic 3 роки тому

      @@AccentHelp No worries, mate!

    • @Ali-qy5ic
      @Ali-qy5ic Рік тому

      @@liam3284I’ve never said it in my life and have never heard anyone say it either. No one in Australia says ‘shrimp’ 😂

  • @i-anhsieh98
    @i-anhsieh98 4 роки тому +4

    Very clear explanation, thank you Jim!!!

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому

      Glad I could help! I was afraid it was still too muddy, but I hoped, if nothing else, that if I talked around it enough, I might share the info that's most useful to you.

  • @noway325
    @noway325 4 роки тому +1

    You did a really great job with this thanks I'm fascinated by accents and thankyou for pointing out that there are more than three Australian accents

  • @frankie3213
    @frankie3213 Рік тому

    Your demonstration of the Australian accents was spot on.

  • @sophia-logos5348
    @sophia-logos5348 20 днів тому

    Excellent video and very useful (and explicable) to this Aussie with a cultivated accent (level of education is the other divider, alongside wealth/socio economic status). Thank you! I was born in Oxford (UK) to Aussie parents, and left when I was 4yr. Until I was about 14yr, whenever I read out-loud I would automatically switch to an RP/UK accent. It was very odd because I hadn't learnt to read when I left the UK. I had to teach myself to maintain my usual accent...Don't know if you've heard of that kind of phenomenon...

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  16 днів тому

      I haven't heard of that specifically before. Humans are interesting creatures...

  • @leonk9837
    @leonk9837 Рік тому

    I enjoyed learning about the differences between Standard British (and Estuary) and the Cultivated Australian accent!

  • @user-bf8ud9vt5b
    @user-bf8ud9vt5b 2 роки тому +3

    The goal of Cultivated Australian was/is to sound as much like RP as possible. It makes sense they're so similar.

  • @user-ob9ho1rq7t
    @user-ob9ho1rq7t Рік тому +2

    i've recently found out i have a posh aussie accent. ive had alot of people mistaken me for english and brought this up with a friend and my boss the other day. i thought it was so amusing and weird but both told me i have a slight english accent. one of them said i sound like a 'rich, private school girl'. i feel fancy as f haha

  • @illogicmath
    @illogicmath 2 роки тому

    You didn't explain how ockers say the A in same for example

  • @virginiarundle4005
    @virginiarundle4005 2 роки тому +2

    Fascinating show, so correct with those Aussie diphthongs. RP was taught in private schools in Australia - AusTRAYLIA being the acceptable common pronounciation (with my emphasis). However comically the broad accent comes out more like Straya. HM The Queen, back in the 1960's was taught by Sir Robert Menzies to pronounce Australia properly, after she was caught out calling it ORStralia. The giant mixing bowl of Australia's population and accents now often sees newsreaders pronouncing it as AusTRAALia.

  • @albertlouisher
    @albertlouisher 4 роки тому +1

    Maybe you can also compare RP to what is called the "transatlantic accent"?

  • @abolishwelfare
    @abolishwelfare 2 роки тому +1

    I’m a Yank who recently discovered the old Australian tv series “Kath & Kim”. I’m trying to get a handle on the accents and dialect of “Trude” and “ Prue”. I cannot understand a damned thing they say 😂

  • @wagnerjunior6524
    @wagnerjunior6524 4 роки тому +1

    Where can I study more about the diacritics?

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +2

      I'll be finishing up my IPA materials this fall, so I'll be diving into clarifying some that I find incredibly helpful in examining speech for accents for actors, but that's a little ways off... Any specific ones you'd like clarification on? I could do a post...

    • @wagnerjunior6524
      @wagnerjunior6524 4 роки тому

      @@AccentHelp I'd like to learn at least the most important/frequent ones to describe the main American accents.

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +1

      @@wagnerjunior6524 I think it's actually going to be more about what diacritics are most helpful for describing accents in general. I'll work on that and make another video.

    • @wagnerjunior6524
      @wagnerjunior6524 4 роки тому

      @@AccentHelp Thanks a lot! I appreciate it!

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +1

      @@wagnerjunior6524 In planning it, I'm realizing I'll need to cover them in a few videos. I'll get the first one done this week and follow up with the others.

  • @Katy38316
    @Katy38316 Рік тому

    Would you be able to do New Zealand accent? 😃

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  Рік тому

      I can. I have. And I have to be very much tuned in to pull it off, making the distinctions that keep it from slipping toward Aussie!

  • @robbdgaf1768
    @robbdgaf1768 Рік тому +1

    Can you do one on the "Pilbara Accent" North West of Australia, It is influenced by the Indigenous people ie even white, malaysion aussie etc have this same Pilbara Accent when living there or raised there.. I personal have this accent and alot ofnew zealanders will ask if Im from new zealand and alot of latinos will ask if im latino, dont even have a passport, never been to their countrys... so would be quite interesting

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  Рік тому

      I don't know of this accent... Would you be willing to do a recording for me to hear it? Thanks for bringing it up!

  • @ByeByeBelly
    @ByeByeBelly Рік тому

    You did ok but the way you say "Australian" isn't the general way we say it. My husband and I are working class and we say Osstrayleeun, not Ostrayan (that's the thick broad "bogan" accent). We pronounce Australian fully

  • @hoanglinhlynguyen3388
    @hoanglinhlynguyen3388 3 роки тому +1

    I tried to speak with British accent (RP) and it turned out to be Aussie accent :(

  • @maldon4084
    @maldon4084 Рік тому +1

    Funny how so many Australians in the comments declare themselves to have a cultivated accent.

  • @Seneillion
    @Seneillion 3 роки тому +1

    I have no idea what these concepts ("estuary", "RP") refer to, but I noticed the subtle difference between the three. TBH 'cultivated' and the next in line are still similar enough to me to be splitting hairs (Aus-born & 30 years young), but 'broad' hit a nerve.
    You missed one thing though, and that's the humorous, hard to dissect dialect we call "Strine". To be truly proficient in Aus accents you need to be at least able to imitate it, but you'll asphyxiate before you get it done.
    I don't know whether there was a point to this comment but I'm posting it anyway.

  • @TheGilbalfas
    @TheGilbalfas 4 роки тому +9

    not bad you're closer than most american actors

    • @noway325
      @noway325 4 роки тому +1

      I think he is doing a good job 😊

  • @ScribblebytesWorldwide
    @ScribblebytesWorldwide 3 роки тому

    What accent do I have?

  • @finnicol-taylor2976
    @finnicol-taylor2976 6 місяців тому

    Probably the best Australian accent I've ever heard from an American.

  • @latenightlogic
    @latenightlogic 3 роки тому

    That’s a pretty mean beard. With a grasp of the Aussie accent I can see Ned Kelly here.

  • @michaelorourke3674
    @michaelorourke3674 Рік тому

    I am a 71-year-old student with a postgraduate education. I agree with all of this.

  • @mrbrisvegas2
    @mrbrisvegas2 Місяць тому

    Cate Blanchett and Geoffrey Rush are typical examples of a modern Cultivated Australian Accent. There was also 'old' Cultivated Accent very similar to historical RP. It is almost extinct and not spoken by anybody under 70.

  • @Moonlightcastle127
    @Moonlightcastle127 Рік тому

    There are more than three accents in Au. Three Accent : Cultivated Australian, General Australian, broad Australian( in outback). The biggest difference: DipHthong. Intonation: RP=More fluctuating, Au: More bends. Diphongs: 1. Price /aɪ/: RP-no round. AU= round. ; 2. /oʊ/ & /əʊ/ no big distinction; 3. /aʊ/ -->/æʊ/, 4. /ei/ & /oi/ no big difference in CA. Summary: C.A has more common with RP. There's no big difference between RP and CA with sounds, but Intonation and placement.

  • @vpcproduction7070
    @vpcproduction7070 Рік тому

    why do Australians use all 5 vowels to say the word "no"?

  • @jordantoulson4376
    @jordantoulson4376 3 роки тому

    Very clever. Solid grasp on Australian accents, especially not an Australian yourself

  • @mrebear9758
    @mrebear9758 Рік тому +2

    I feel the Cultivated Australian is a fake, put on accent now - similar to the transatlantic accent. You only hear university professors or thespians using it now, and most certainly didn't grow up with it. No one under 40 spoke like that, even at the most elite private schools.

  • @elchewbacco
    @elchewbacco 4 роки тому

    broad pronounced in broad would sound more like br-awwd like in awning

  • @johndaviscosmo1594
    @johndaviscosmo1594 4 роки тому +1

    Interesting, and very true. And without searching your profile I've no idea of your true country of origin. Maybe american ? . Not sure

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +1

      Yup. Originally from a small farming town in Iowa, then affected by 10 years in Chicago, 20 in Houston, and many years of voice, speech, and acting...

  • @sks6763
    @sks6763 3 роки тому +2

    As someone with a "cultivated" Australian accent and family members with RP due to English heritage. I'm impressed with how detailed this short video was.
    My general observation would be Australian accents in general, are lazy compared to RP.
    This would make sense as my grandmother can't stand people with "bogan" or broad accents as she believes the individuals were not brought up "properly".

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  3 роки тому +4

      I don't buy into the "lazy" default explanation. (I prefer the word "efficient" at least - why work harder than you need to in communicating to the people you talk to, unless there's a problem and you're unclear. --the wider the circle of people you talk to, the more likely to have to alter your speech to be understood by a wider range of folks.)

    • @sks6763
      @sks6763 3 роки тому

      @@AccentHelp many Australians are hard to understand.
      Especially bogans.

    • @richieseager6130
      @richieseager6130 2 місяці тому

      That’s called snobbery

  • @Goodday639
    @Goodday639 3 роки тому

    very interesting

  • @pequenaudtekno2909
    @pequenaudtekno2909 3 роки тому +3

    Also there's the Adelaide accent, which is different again. Basically the major cities have different accents, while the rest share a working class accent

  • @pacoclooney6859
    @pacoclooney6859 2 роки тому

    Genius 🤯

  • @banafeel1238
    @banafeel1238 4 роки тому +3

    Nice beard.

    • @AccentHelp
      @AccentHelp  4 роки тому +5

      I've only been growing it until I got a compliment. Now I can finally shave.

  • @Furmily
    @Furmily 2 роки тому

    More like, "up themself", "normal" and "bogan"

  • @justynjonn
    @justynjonn 3 роки тому

    Estuary is awful.

    • @compulsiverambler1352
      @compulsiverambler1352 3 роки тому +2

      Thanks for that most edifying insight, Professor Higgins. It's a tough job, but somebody has to shake a fist at clouds, or they'll never stop changing.

  • @NEBUKEDNEZZA
    @NEBUKEDNEZZA 4 роки тому

    Fail video because he is trying to say too much (in the nine minutes) he drops into other accents while speaking which only he is "aware" of, because viewers don't know the differences or they would not be watching "to discover" what the different sounds are.
    Make videos for three minutes only.

  • @southpawlibranine3511
    @southpawlibranine3511 Рік тому +1

    Why do aussie actors in hollywood lose their accents quicker to some degree than british who never seem to lose theirs

  • @brettritchie5
    @brettritchie5 4 роки тому +2

    I play D&D with my friends your accent break downs help me invent my own for my world! If you haven’t seen “The Expanse” I recommend it there is an invented accent they invented for the belters you might find interesting.